8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

1/10

rftar

si

Draw

PointConstruction

mprovement

slng

SixSigma

[,1u6yid

asan

asd, akhmat

ulyanh

Pengcmbangan

engukuran

aya aing

engan

lfefodo/o

i

World conomic

orun

(IVEFJ

ntuk

ingkat ropinsi

awa arat:

asil

engukuran

dan

dentifikasi

aktor

Kunci

Dwi

arso

Model

truktural

engaruh

tribut roduk

erhadap

epuasan

an oyalitas

Pelanggan:

tudi asus

elanggan

elkomsel

i Jabodetabek

lstiSurjanda.i,eny amdani

Pond's rand

Community

otentiatr

mongHigh

School

emale

tudents

n

Bandung

leza

shad asulion,

aninia

adiahi

)enga-ruh.

Nilai.Nilai

ersonal,

aya epemimpinan

anBudaya

rganisasi

rerhadap

epuasan

erja

aryawan

\udkGuslomo.

nita

SiManita

renggunaan

Soft

Systen

Methodoloy

an

Grounded

heory

alam

Membangun

eorl

rada

enelitian

roses trateglStntegy

rocxs

Researchi

/idjajani.

una

lahja Djaiadiningral,

ariLubis,Gatot

udoko

rnalisis

ebijakan

engembangan

ndustri

reatif

i Kota

Bandung

)gar

\4. lmalupang,

atot udoko,

uanlb

andayati,gung

asc€suseno,

'ishna

Pemadi,

anda

istiani

J u r n a l

M a n a J e m e i

T e k n o r o { l

Volum€8Number12009

Draw

oint

onstruction

mprovemen

Using

Six

Sigma

t{ursyld

Hasan

a3rl

Ope€tons

nd

Pedomance

anagement

roilp

school l

gtlsiness

nd

Managemenl

TB

muGyid@sbm.ilb

c

d

Ralhnat

Mulyanto

Depafunent

f

Unde€ound

onsbrlclion

PT. reeportndonssia

€khmal-mulyanto@ftni

om

Abstract

Dtaw

pdnt

s a toadhg

pointberosll,

I slope,

u61i'jng

av

y

to

'ove down

bulk

maleial

n

tJndeenundMlno

,ock

Ca,,;,ng

f PT

Fr,glr,tl

ndonesia'

4dnw

poinl

s a sloo/

61

't

is ot€ded

nd

pourei

n

ptace

wllh

6,nmte.

Tltt|B a'E

sub

prccsssgs

t

d|rw

poinl

consfuc0onl

'ito

rEparadon'

'leancot'l/Jr,le,anboddedrail,uncnlef,(r,t'anvillop'linletfit'lotning&rneshirq'wallEtcfi

conl)r)le,

@plng

genetal

ean4p.

Eased

n data

anatsb

pedtd

2008'

'eta

s 8

gap

1 03

uhll

dnw

Nint

ol

yea;y

wgot

ttiltt

avaElgo

l @ntpblion

ine

ot a

daw

Nnl

@n*udjon

46

44 shitls

€nd

"Ona"rU

a*irtion

O.gS

t'

ns. ftis

stowet

W

g

7y"ot

a4st

t2

stfits

lho

hrgh radad

deiatin

aN

slor{gf rccess

,rdic€fo

lo

s is a

ptffist

quary

pto

r/n n

dnw

Fint

@ndnrtioNt

l

nakes

dnw

poinl

anstrudion

n.f,nf,iance

o achieve

ls nonkly

ot

yesv

larget'

Fo nplovingho

prccess

uav

Six

Signa

ap'(,ach

wth

DMAIC

ethdolqy

will

bo usod

o dentilv

incaoabre

mcoss

nd s

causes.

]hen

altemalive

ott

.,ts

ae

UorDsed

o

6' iI and@ntol

theke'l

pfg.gss

ar'ables

susitg

ie deftcls'

Key

words: onfletionline,

P0c€ssQualty

Stx

Srgma,

MAIC

1. nkoduction

Draw

point

s a

loadlng

point

beneaf

a slope'

utitilng

gravity o move

dom

blllk

matenal

n

Undeeround

ine

Block aving

l

PTFreepod

ndonesia

h€dt8w

dnt

constuclion

locess

consisb

ofgsubprccess€sthatisstar|edlromsitepreparationandfinishedbysbippingandgene

The

oiclures

fdraw

oinl

ub

process le

p€senledn Figures

-8

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

2/10

Underground

ine son€

fPT

Freeportndonesia

lning

ivision,

ive

esponsibility

o

undsrground

construction

epartmenl

hat onstructsraw

oint

aybydayasamount

hats

planned

n Rr\AB.

CunenllyJG

onstruction

as 8 mployees

ordrawpointconstruclion

hatwo

n24houls(oneday

consistof3shifts:

ay,

wingnd

ightshift)grouped

n4 rews

hatollowoster

-2, -2, -3.

Based

nanalysis

ala raw

oint

onstructio

n

period

008,heres

a

gap4.03

nitdrawpointrom

yeatly

arget

145.97

nils f

150units

eay

target) ith

ve.agefcompletion

ime fdraw

oint

conslruction46.44

hitts nd

landardoviation

_95hjfts.t s

lower.7%

l arget2 hjfts.he

igh

standard

eviation

ndslower

rocess

ndicated

heres

a

process

uality roblem

n draw

oint

construclion.

t

willhave

irecllympact

n he ncomplianco

fdraw

oint

onstruction

oRKAB

arget.

To mprove

his

pfocess

uality

roblem,

[,4A|C

rameworkDeline-Measure-Analyze-lmp.ove-

Conlol) ill

eused

Pfzdet,

003a).

MAICsa vatuable

ool hat

elps

eopt€

inds

emanent

solutions

o ong-standing

rtricky

usiness

roblems

ocus n

uslomerrequirement.

ome

oolshal

ar€ sedn

his tudy

re eferedoPyzdek

2003b).

FbuG . 6 D Coicr.t I Emb.dodatl

L i

r r

a ,

N

e ' l a

j e f t . 4 r

r e k . t

I

F{uc 7 w'll I R@l Fmii9 aid Cs@E

FsuE0 StDriA t @ftlO.r'

uo

2.Define

The

irst iepo

get

heSix igma

tarled,

roposedroject

hader

hal esc.ibes

e cudenl

ituation

f

dnw

poinl

onslruction

rocess,

he bjec0ve

ndhe cop€tlhis

mprovement.

igure

pres€nls

e

pojectharterf his rcjectormprovingraw ointonsttuctionocess.hemain bjectives

get

significant

mprovement

n

process

peed

y ncreasing

roductivity,

ecreasing

adation

ncrew nd

eliminatingon dded

alueo educe

ompletionme9.77.

aster ndo

reduce

an

hiff

obe

136

manshifts

erunil.

CdrpladdrTltnc

It

Adrlavqnrnt Der Cilw

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

3/10

Afier

he

prdecl

harlorlroadypproved,hengxt teps

preparo

hoas-is

rccess

appingfdraw

polnl

onslrucllons hown:

Elgr

e

10. he rossunctlonal

rocess

appingoscdbesllofactivity

in

d|aw

oint

onstucton

rcc€sg.

ffgr r€atod

rocess

ap,hsnwill b9 donlifiedho re he

suppliersnd ustomers

f draw

oint

onstruc,lion

rccess.

IPOCiagram

n Figurc i

presents

supplier

S),

nput

rocess

l),

rocess

P),

ulput

ocessO)

nd ustomer

C).

 

E

i'il

E

a

t

; :

;rs

9 l

 

; l

l*

E',s

E-EEEE, ,rEtrriy=l

Frgr

l[ A&b Mlpore

Fhr

Ccr .ion Pro6.

cu.tomfi i.(rllr.i|..t

Bett r

ve.t2,5 unlts DP

per

month 9

)elNar 150 unltr DP na

\car 9

ED 3

ED lette hando\€r rocess

3

cc

I

EO

rlme comole ion 42

shllrtoe. unit DP 9

-esstnan

5

5611s/ dit DP

er

month 9

ED

.essthan 136 manshifts/unlt 0P

per

1

cc

' '5F

9

' 3

1

Entlru.dnt O€partment

Co$tControl Departlrlent

HIgh6t

J u r n a l l , , l

a f a l e r n e n

T e k n o t o l J

L

Fgucn SPOC

D6*

poml

sdruclM

OLrlputf

draw

oinl

onstruction

hen

willbe

aligned

ith uslomer

quiremenl

oice f @stomer

(VOC)

an

b€ a tool

to identry

what

s the critical

output

o costomer'

Based

on

inteNiew

wilh

Engineering

epartment,

roduclion

epartment

ndCost

Contot

oepa'bnent,

ecan

get

hevoice

f

cuslomerNOC)asshown

nTable

.

WPOINT CONSTRUCTION

PROCESS

OUTSUT

CUSTOMER

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

4/10

3.Moalurc

Measu.

s

a

phasg

o

measuro

he ur€nt

rccess

€rfomance.

t

sno€dod

o

noasurc

he urent

process

omplian@

lth

ustomor

equkement.

efore

easudng

he

urent

rocess

ompjiance,

l

rs

need€d

o conduc.t

te

measuBment

ystem

nalysisMSA)

odarify

o

capability

f measurement

tools.

or

raw

oinl

ocess,

uronty

UG

Construction

ave

ield lppod

ersonnel

ach

hiff hat

appraisss

hin

rogruss

n

€nd

f treshifr

hat

will C

eporled

o senior

anagemenl.

o

@nduct

ne

MSA{t

will

ea est

ohem

using

ome

ictu.e

f ask

obe

appfaised

he

rogress

l hem

wice.

I

ne

resull

fthe

estsdescdb€d

nTable

.

Ed€

2 llSA

b.*

pdnlpt

dlf

Based

n

data

bov6,

slng

Minitab

oflwaro,

t s

analzod

auge

oprcducibitity

nd

Repeatability.

llo

analyrb

"lult

6

sho{,nn

Flgu.s

2, he

mo"t

%conhbullon

l vada

n

comercm

arl-to.psd

93.87%

lle6.'l3%

ontdbuflon

l he

Gauge &Rbelow

0%).

h6

umbor

tdistinct

ateqories

s5

(more

han ).

So

basod

nh9

Automobile

ndustry

clion

oup AIAG)

tandad,

hemea-surement

systemisacceplable(Hendradi

006).

o.C.

Rtn

lnldt

-

A'IOVA

.OEd

tloc ...

.tri.t1.n

I

.r..u.ry

?OO9

P.po.r.d

by:

-Ir.-$rr

Axon^

t br.Wtiffi6

I . s r

r

l r p r r i . . r

ra

5a6 .0

2r

t31 .0

55 r r? ro .o

r a . 6 r t

^ P p r . 1 ' . r ' r ' k

1 1 . 9 0 2

255.212

l 0 r . a 9 a

FrouE2

Gr{.

nrR

snd,drr

[*rbb

J

u r

n

a I

M

a

n a

j e

m

e n

T e

k n

o l o

q

I

O .

RIR

(AfgA)

flr

or6Flt

t .

Drn ot rv: r ).ud ll 9

--------- :==-

-t-------ilr=--

&r .H I

L| lI-::::

|

.l t*-{

/- \ I

'- l+----+J

J-"-'-J

\l

a.F.rdh':

ilrdrrr.'a

ffi;

r''r*.'..rl.l.a

r:l\,^lH

Fa@13G.u9€lR Ct n

Attercheckinghg

capability f he measurcment

hidr s ac4eptable. |en

l will be condnued y

measudng

he draw

oint

omplianc€o

voice l dstomer Table shows

hathe

qlfienl

prccess

as

hlgh efectmte. he

result

ives

swaming yslem

hal he

process

anb€

ncapable.

trbr. 3 0.i..101in. curir P'ug

r.lh

tal

,.r 12.5 .ll| 0P

0..

monlh

EO f t l i v . r 150unr 3 P

n.

Y . . r

EO

ED

8.nr

h.ndove.

ord.33

cc

EO

I i n . . o m o l . l i m 1 2 . h i f t

D . r

n i l Op 9

cc

Ie r s h .n

5

56 ,115 /un i t P

et

mo^ lh

EO

rl5 nanrhrllt /un't DP oe, honlh

TSsa

a0

cc

I

EnB iEe . ingD€p. r thenr

co3rconkol Dep..rne.r

To heckhe pability f

he

rocess

hentwill e onducted€pabilitynalysis

or e axrent

rccess.

The ata

nouttoMinitabs

comoletion

ime achask fdBw

Doinlorocess.

ltere re155 ata

iom

different

ocation.

he alanput

s

shown

nTable.Figure

.3

escdbese c€pabilitynalysisfD€w

poinl

Construction

roc€ss,

igures4

and

5 orwall

E

roofmeshinglormings ie

lowest

igma

lev€loldraw

ointsuborocassos.

hesummarizedoralldrawDointsub

rocesses

s hown

nTable

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

5/10

T.fls

1.

hb

InM

fo.C$obfig/vE

b

TabL

.

Sonnaiz€d

nc..s

Capodny

a.n

Tast

,tE

6Fl|It'

o?Or.w

t

tra

Flguru

4.

P@ss

Cap€blry

ot D.aw

poht

C.nsrddion

r r . r a r M i a a , , : m e r r e ,

t€{ C.Fllll'

., Srll I

l6t ta.|l4 a

tditha

Fiqu|s5.

mcossap€bililyl

wall Rool eshin{

Fo{irlng

Easedn

ub

rcc€sses

pability

esult bove,

all cotmeshing

oming

s01eowest

gma

evel'

Next tep,hissubprocess illbe udher nalfzedogethe rcot€use ol process uality oblem..

4,Analf:€

Byusing xperi€nce

ndoperalional

mnon

ensen

group iscussionnd

nleMew

lth ome

pgrson

nchargondraw

oint

onsbuction

iable

), t s oundome

otenlial

aus€s

l$e

ncapable

proc€ss

orwall& rof

meshing foming.

llhe

potential

€uses

illb€desc{ib€d

n Fault

ree

Analysisut nly

ignificanlperationally

nd latjslic€llyauses

ill eexplained

n

his

pap€r

Eblo 6. PeM in Ch.q.

in

o.fl

Finl

cnstucljo.

Figure

6

hows

heaullteo nalysis

fWall Roof

MeshingForming.he

ilst nalFis

s

conduded

on hs tabililyl

wall

&

oofmeshing

oming

rocess.

singe conbol

had s hown

n gure

, t

found

1

points

hatshe ndicalionl out l

cDntol

ro{ess.

t

shorn

nhult ee analysis,

e out f

conlrol

roc€ss

6

aused

y aclo6. hey re

umber

l

elea eadyiver lealiacaess

haring3nd

accesslockgd.asedn he pocialc€uses

nalysis,eover

rcakfnose umperM

draw

dnl

area rc

hemosl ommonausesf outot control

ocess.

t needso bestabilizedeforc

udle

impmvementsing

roblem

olving

rocess.

r.k. 4lCo.rihdirY

lo..n.- an*

pot.r. t

V.l. orl..d.oordin.tion

rnh ltlin.an.,

irshall

td.o.. Or.w

poid

C

i h i l r

d . m . n

D a s

P o i ^ r c 6 n u r i 6

V.k.dr.r

Poi^r

a

3dr.t t 'aaa

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

6/10

Figwe

16.Fauti

T6e

An.tsis

ot WaI &

RootMeshing

Fomins

Figu/e

17. Controt

Chan

ot Wa[

& Root Meshing

& Foming

"

H0 No

Din66n@

ttrdlcne ,m

&d

.

H,

o|fltrs€

pndu.rvry

6;ono

cr;

I-MR

Chart

of Wall

&

Roof

eshlng

& Forning

?

t

c

F,gue 9 Ana

s

s ol

Mean clNilyy C,ew

After nalyzing

heoutof contrcl

actors,

hen n control

aclor

s

elaboraled

he llsl analysrs

s

conductedo check

hecrclr

adance.ased

n wo

wayANOVA

esull

s

shown

n lglre

18which

analyzehe

mean teach rew

clivity

ershift

nd

rcgrcss

ershiftweot nfomalionhal here

sn

sufficienl

videncet 950/0

evel l signillc€nce

oshow

hat ifferenc€

roducllvity

mong 'ew

Ho)

becauseofp-value

orehan .05.

Figu@ 3 TwoWay NOVA

clivrtynd

og@$

WR

p€r

Crew 0.y ol@t*

Then

twill eanalyzedhe

roduclivityotcrewin

all&rcolmeshlng

oming

rocess

ased0ntabie

7, he urent

roductivity

ershift

sstilllowerlhanustomer

equirement.umberf

activitieshat

s

conductedach

rew ower y

8% and

progrcss

er

shift

pef

area

draw

point

ower 1% o

gel

requirement

2.5 raw

oinl

er

month. ased n

Figures

9

and

0 allcre$'

ave

erlormanceower

than aluecquired.

Table ConplianceoiCur€nl

/all& oor

Meshing

Foniig P.ocess

N O

T a r a e t

1

N o o f a c t i v i t i e s

p e r

r h i f t

l 94

1 . 8 0

a'/.

2

P r o

r e

5 s

p e

s h r f t

p e r

a r € a

0

0 7 0 0 6

l 1 %

OreWdV

mo.tul A,NOnid A.llvlly

lA/R

5

shlfl

aE =0(6

i ,."

rrc.w:yAtovA:^d|vllywnp.

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

7/10

cElv€y

l\loiEl iAS4 fa

pr.gr-

${

pd

Ea ft

Df,

DP

^Fb

-0 6

Figu€

20.Aialtsis ol MeanPograss

p€r

Activilyby cl#

'

Ho No

Corda .nLnjry&Avrlbb$ry

lrh oOos

'

He

Co@hnon liliy Avalhbiilyth Pms'B

ForanalFing

quipmentconlribution

nthencapable

rocess

fwall&cofmeshing

forming,twillbe

anallz€d

o(elallon

etweonhgutility f boomruck

nd he chi€vomenl

fdraw

olnt

sshownn

Figurc

1,The osults

Thorosn't ufilclentvldence

t 95% evelof

lgnllicanceo

showhat ny

conelalionlllity

availabilityilh

achievemenl

Ho),

able

gives

ther

ntormationhat he

boom

truck tilitylill ow ompare

ilhhe vailability

f his quipment_

codr.tronr:

urlhy, Av.arrbtuiy,YR cht.wm..ri

acntmm.d

Figuf€

l. Tle Corelalion

1alysis lilhys

Achlov€ment

Tabl6 B@m

ruc{Data

Equlprnent

Eq No

Availabllity

l%)

utillty

l%)

Eoom

Tr ck

730031

93%

24%

710044

96%

20%

730045

93v.

37%

J u r n a l f u l

a n a t . m e r

r s k

r o i r i . r

Sased nanalYsisabove,

lcan e oncluded

halthe

ut f

mnlrol

rccess

auses

aveosolve

irsl

o

makeprocessstable

ndthen

ollowed

yinqeasing

e

productivityoachieve

25 un(5draw

olntper

monlhasrequrred.

Figurc 2.

The RoolCaus€

l n€Fble

wall 6 Roor

MeshnsE Foming

P.bess

5.lmDrcve

Wall oofmeshing

orming

she

ongestub

rocess

fdraw

oint

onsfuction

t

l

can

e cduced

the

mean f

durationlwall

&

roolmeshing

onning,

e€n

gel

dmw

point

onstuclion

omplele

faster. ased nanalvsisesult,lheverbreak

t

nose umperand

raw

oint

rea

make

all&

oot

meshing

onning

ut lconkol.

orming

s

on;

ol he

mainasks lwallE

oofwhichan

tabilize

nd

rcducehe

uralionf

wall oof

meshing

oming

For

he urthoranalysis,

twillbe

sed

Pughmatrixo

selecl e best

olution

or each

loblem

s

decision

riteria.

ewilluserileria

s hovin

n able9.

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

8/10

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

9/10

Iabro 10.

Compadsn

Modular s TEditional

24

l7

18

59

TaUo

1. ro3.Coft

v&&6skHandllng

tsmatfua

olultons

Pughratrlr

By slng

gclslon

dtedas hownn able

.I hent

can e omparcd

hre6 ltemaliveolutions

o

got

Mlchsolullon

illmako

lnonl

oc€ss

€ttor

stng

ugh

Matdx

ceoEe,2005).

y alcutating

he

weightod

um

f

poslllves

nd

egativesor

acholution,tc€n

€ el€cted

he hird olution

s he

bestolulion.

he ugh alix

an e eenlnTable5.4.

TaUe12.

ugh rmhx

ot 3 Aitmadv

SotubB for Fomin

A@s

K.y

CriLtl.

I

t

1i

:Ev m.. f .nill. r

w hl { ar d to

Gduce t im. ol re

:abriete

ne n.ral

tomin Re.loc€ u.h

rod br N..d

ru.e ..piLl tor

hbrlol.

lhe new neta

irviry

t ineo..pplrctt lon

rEhha

on

worl

urhSm.r.

,.rv how, n€€d

tp..i.

trdllnt,or

{t

ty.onc.rn

Inh|na on

hll.lr modul.l

i.tluc. unll 6ri

bl Ned hd. opil. l tor

p rch8in3

hodul.l

iturnlrlmoon.ppllorlo.

u . n a

\ , 1

a . i :

r i , r , r

( ,

6,Conlrol

To

ontrolthe

mplementation

l hssolutjon

nd o

get

@ntinuous

mpovement

he€ arcsome

ontol

methodshatcan

beus€d:

A. Full-sc€lemplonentation

esuits

o oata

hads ndother

elorc/aner

oclmentation

howing al he

realized

ains

arg

n inewilhhs

Prciect

harter

o

ProcessonbolPlan

Documonlationnd

measures

repared

orsuslainability

Essentialocumentation

f$e

impmved

rocess,

nduding ey

prccedures

nd

orccess

maos

Prcc€durcs o

be used 1o

monilor

pmaessp€rformance

nd

contnued

efreclivenessf hesolution

Contol

harts. apability

nalysis,nd

othef ata

displayshowing

nenl

pedoflnsncsnd efifying

ains

Evidencelbuy-in,

hadngnd eleb|ating

Tsslimonialsrdocumentaton

howing

hat:

I Theapprcpriate

eopl€

avo valuated

ndsigned fl

on tl€daog€s

i Ths

prccess

owner has

laken over esponsibility

of

managing

conlinuing

Peralions

 

Ile

proieclwotk

asbeen ha.ed

ih he wod area

and ompany

l

large

using

pro,ecil

atabas€.

ulletinoads,

tc.)

Summary

f essons

eamedhroughoule

ploiect

List of

issues/oooortlnalieshal

werc not addressed

n flis

pojecl (t0

be

considered

sc€ndidales

or uture

rojecls)

ldentjfication

f oppodunilies

o use he

mehods rom his

proiecl

n

oher

pqeqs

Plansforcelebratingthehadwo

ndsuccessfulefiorts

o

c.

o

T.Concluslons

SixSigma

s oday'seadingechnique

omaximize

roduclion

fficiencl

nd

mainlainontrolover

adl

stgp

n he manaoerial

rocsss

o achieve

etter, sler, and

cheaper

mptpvemenl.MAIC

methodologysappliedouncoveand olve

oblem

ndraw

oinl

onsflction.

t sdefined€t

the

problem

s

a

gap

t

yeaC,y

argel

ompletjonime.

ollowing

h€

edlnhue.col aus€ t

he

6blem

s

idsntlfisd.

ialistic.l

nalysls 63 onducledo

validaloadt slep. tbs end

f ho study,sveral

allemativeolutons

ere

ensraled

nd hen e

b€st

olulion

schoseo.

lhough

ix

igma

oject

n

thls

tudy

as ot ompleted

et,

t

sshown

at sixsigmas a

promising

edniqueosolve usiness

challengas.

8/18/2019 86-138-1-PB

10/10