9/9/2014

Appealing: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Comments: Has Olde Towne feel.Looks great, but probably too large to fit in with Olde Towne.

Appealing: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 3 - NO

Comments: Too big.Like modern look. Too crowded.Feels very plain and industrial.

Appealing: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Comments: Too big.Too "old" style.Could be made to work with Olde Towne's character.

Appealing: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 3 - NO

Comments: Too ornate. Great trees.Too undefined. Too blank and hard.Character fits Olde Towne, need to be careful of scale.

Entrances: 1Entrances: 2

Entrances: 3Entrances: 4

Entrances

Appealing: 3 - YES 6 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Comments: Feel good casual.Too temporary.Vinyl weathers too quickly. Looks cheap.Feels very temporary.

Appealing: 8 - YES 0 - NO

Appropriate: 7 - YES 2 - NO

Comments: OK.Works well w/ grading of property. Great trees. Looks like what is in this space now.Looks good!

Appealing: 3 - YES 6 - NO

Appropriate: 1 - YES 8 - NO

Comments: Too big.Too big for space; doesn't invite in.Looks fake and out-of-scale for Olde Towne.

Entrances: 5 Entrances: 6

Entrances: 7

Appealing: 6 - YES 2 - NO

Appropriate: 6 - YES 2 - NO

Comments: Great trees.Too many for small space.Good mix of shade/sun but still open, solid. Lighter color for tables would be cooler.Too dense and industrial.

Appealing: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Appropriate: 2 - YES 4 - NO

Comments:Too modern for Olde Towne.Too urban.Looks like a classroom; too straight.Like modern design but for 1 person only?Metal.I like modern look, and it could be designed to work with Olde Towne's character.

Appealing: 2 - YES 7 - NO

Appropriate: 2 - YES 7 - NO

Comments:Like - can move around and adjust for group size. Dislike mess.Furniture doesn't look sturdy enough. Prefer less mobile, less scattered.Chairs look uncomfortable.Scale is correct for Olde Towne, not sure how moveable furniture will do.

Appealing: 8 - YES 1 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 2 - NO

Comments: May not be appropriate.Like motion and shape.Appealing design but not sure goal of seating.Too long; blocks walkers.

Tables & Seating: 1

Tables & Seating: 2

Furnishings: 3 Tables & Seating : 4

Tables & Seating

Appealing: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 3 - NO

Comments:Chairs out of place.Would be good for amphitheater - not good for gathering.Furniture random and not enough for large groups. Dog walk area concerns?Quaint, comfortable chairs.Very nice space.

Appealing: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 3 - YES 5 - NO

Comments:OK.Use bamboo or other sustainable. Material inappropriate.Looks neat and modern.Looks great when new - need to consider how wood ages and upkeep requirements.

Appealing: 4 - YES 5 - NO

Appropriate: 3 - YES 6 - NO

Comments:Too close together. Wood tables get carved and marked. Too many tables in space.A bit too cafeteria style; lacks small group space. Too crowded, but fewer tables would be OK. Ground surface?Appealing look, takes up too much space with fixed use.

Tables & Seating : 5Tables & Seating : 6

Tables & Seating : 7

Appealing: 4 - YES 5 - NO

Appropriate: 2 - YES 5 - NO

Comments:Interesting but not functional. Would prefer bike rack. Not great for either use.Would be nice to have a bike repair station nearby.Big bench, only good for one or two people when bikes are parked.

Appealing: 7 - YES 2 - NO

Appropriate: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Comments:In the right place a good idea. Great idea to draw hipsters. Good idea.Limited usefulness.

Appealing: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 8 - YES 1 - NO

Comments:Change the style to more modern. Like idea but not specific fountain. Good idea.Olde-time/modern clash.Some other versions would be useful.Fits with Olde Towne.

Appealing: 8 - YES 1 - NO

Appropriate: 8 - YES 1 - NO

Comments:Iconic feature for a train station. Clock OK.Fits with Olde Towne.

Accessories: 1 Accessories: 2

Accessories: 3 Accessories: 4

Accessories

Appealing: 9 - YES 0 - NO

Appropriate: 7 - YES 2 - NO

Comments:Lifeguard required by MoCo.Appropriate in that it uses the bricks. Appealing but don't want.Fun and a draw.Other than lifeguard issues.Something new and different/fresh would be nice.This sort of fountain would be very successful.

Appealing: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Comments:Functional but artistic.Bile racks needed but not as abstract.Not sure what these are but they look cool.

Appealing: 5 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 4 - YES 5 - NO

Comments:No space but need things for children. Cool!Takes up too much space with a fixed use. Possibly would work as part of the train museum outdoor space.

Appealing: 8 - YES 1 - NO

Appropriate: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Comments:

I like water.Lideguard.

Accessories: 5 Accessories: 6

Accessories: 7 Accessories: 8

Appealing: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Comments:Maybe not exactly set up like this but good activity.Good idea - not sure how much use chess would get in Olde Towne.

Appealing: 4 - YES 5 - NO

Appropriate: 1 - YES 7 - NO

Comments:

Really?Not appropriate for Olde Towne.

Appealing: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 1 - YES 7 - NO

Comments:Takes too much space.How to not lose balls and paddles for something like this?Equipment storage would need to be addressed. Too much space for only 2 people.I don't know much about ping pong and the amount of use these would have.Great for larger parks - not sure how you keep track of equipment.

Activities

Activities: 1

Activities: 2

Activities: 3

Appealing: 7 - YES 2 - NO

Appropriate: 7 - YES 2 - NO

Comments: Has potential. Maybe. Perhaps larger.Maybe nice tie-in with Book Festival.Similar to statues near concert pavillion.

Activities: 6

Appealing: 8 - YES 1 - NO

Appropriate: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Comments: Unobtrusive but... Maybe.Love this!

Appealing: 8 - YES 1 - NO

Appropriate: 3 - YES 4 - NO

Comments:Too large area in park. Maybe.Needs space.Interesting - could be an issue in Olde Towne with pieces walking away.

Activities: 4

Activities: 5

Lighting

Appealing: 6 - YES 2 - NO

Appropriate: 7 - YES 1 - NO

Comments:What we have already?Fine.Traditional would be best fit.

Lighting: 5

Appealing: 7 - YES 2 - NO

Appropriate: 6 - YES 3 - NO

Comments:Uplighting is great.Like in conjunction with downlighting. Anti Dark-Sky.Bland - not particularly special.Soft, indirect light is much more appealing than direct down lights.

Lighting: 4

Appealing: 5 - YES 4 - NO

Appropriate: 4 - YES 4 - NO

Comments:Creates many shadows but cool. Makes it hard to see away from lights. To modern.Soft, indirect light is preferred.

Appealing: 5 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 7 - YES 2 - NO

Comments:Just there.Been there. Done that.Fits the location well.

Appealing: 4 - YES 3 - NO

Appropriate: 1 - YES 6 - NO 2 - Maybe

Comments:OK for big plaza but not here.Maybe; not sure on space.Not sure. Could be fun.Prefer modern that is fanciful to modern that is stark. Appealing yet too modern.This is cool!Very nice - too modern for Olde Towne. Fits well in Chicago!

Lighting: 1Lighting: 2

Lighting: 3