1
A debate:A debate:Distance LearningDistance Learning
in Education in Education and Trainingand Training
Baek-Kyoo Joo, Merry Rendahl, Jaci Seeman, Yelena Yan.
HRD/AdEd 5001
June 28, 2003
2
Team Introduction
4D4D
3
Content
I. Distance Learning Overview
II. Debate Questions
III. DL in Education
IV. DL in Training (Corporate E-Learning)
V. Conclusion & Recommendation
VI. Class Discussion
4
I. Distance Learning Overview
“In a time of drastic change,
it is the learners who inherit the future.
The learned find themselves equipped
to live in a world that no longer exists.”
- Eric Hoffer, in Vanguard Management, 1989
5
Definition of Distance Learning
“Distance education is planned learning that normally occurs in a different place from teaching and as a result requires special techniques of course design, special instructional techniques, special methods of communication by electronic and other technology, as well as special organizational and administrative arrangements”.
(Source: Moore, M., Director, The American Center for the Study of Distance Education, Penn State)
6
Subset of Distance Learning
Source: W. R. Hambrecht and Co. 2000. Corporate e-learning: Exploring a new frontier.Retrieved from http://www.wrhambrecht.com
7
Distance Education: US Perspective
Distance education has grown to a great extent o
ver the past 30 years.
Past
– Correspondence
– Videotapes by Mail
– Satellite
8
Distance Education: US Perspective
Some studies show that there is no significant diff
erence between distance education and tradition
al education.
Present
– Videoconferencing
– Web-based learning
– Completely on-line educational experiences
9
Distance Education: Int’l Perspective
“A U.S. perspective alone does
not represent the entire field.”
McLean & McLean, 2001
10
Distance Education: Int’l Perspective
Terms similar; Practice varies widely Majority World countries face considerable
education and training challenges.(Hawkridge, 1996; Patru & Khvilon, 2002; McLean & McLean, 2001)
Distance Education seen as promising solution(Patru & Khvilon, 2002)
Key differences between NA and MW– Level of technology– Centralized vs. Localized Educational Systems
(Patru & Khvilon, 2002)
11
II. The Debate
12
The Debate
“no significant difference”
Significant differences
Janette McDonald (2002)
13
Comparisons Between Traditional and e-Learning Approaches
Source: PrimeLearning, Inc. (2001). E-learning: A strategy for maximizing human capital in the knowledge economy.
14
The Real Question?
Question should center around usefulness of any/all methods in helping individuals learn. (McIsaac, 1999)
Andragogical principles still apply and new methods and theories are evolving.(McDonald, 2002)
15
?
?
??
The Debate Still Rages
Traditional
Something New
E-Learning
Blended
Learning
16
Our Conclusion:
Things are Changing in Education and Business
17
III. Distance Learning in Education
“Education is about to change. … Almost everything
we know about education is up for grabs: the way it is
funded, designed, managed, and even delivered.”
Source: The New Education Economy, 1999 , as cited in W. R. Hambrecht and Co. 2000. Corporate e-learning: Exploring a new frontier. Retrieved from http://www.wrhambrecht.com
18
DL in Education
In 1998, only 58% of colleges in the United States reported offering distance learning courses.
By 2002 it was about 84%.
U.S. Department of Education
19
DL in Education
Schools and colleges try to embrace the
new technology-mediated environment.
– Technology-enhanced learning in a regular
classroom
– Technology-mediated learning environment
Instructor vs. student performance
20
DL in Educational Setting
What factors influence adoption of innovative DE practices?
DLDL
BehavioralBehavioral
EnvironmentalEnvironmental CognitiveCognitive
21
DL in Educational Setting
Environmental factors (campus culture)– Administration support– System of financial and social incentives,
benefits, and rewards– Wide network of support resources– Peer pressure – Availability of workshops, trainings, and
consulting– Availability of hardware/software
22
DL in Educational Setting
Cognitive factors– Cyber-anxiety– Self-efficacy– Need to re-evaluate one’s own teaching
philosophy– Unfamiliarity and lack of experience with
the specifics of new learning environments and instructional practices to be used
23
DL in Educational Setting
Behavioral– Time commitment– Lack of compelling reasons to try new
teaching/learning technologies– Personal risk
24
Possible solutions
Creating a supportive campus culture
Establishing a system of rewards and incentives
Resources to develop self-efficacy through computer training and workshops, coaching, mentoring
Assessment (does it work?)
Communication with emphasis on inclusion
25
IV. Distance Learning in Training - Corporate E-Learning
26
What is E-Learning?
E-learning can be defined as instructional content or learning experiences delivered or enabled by electronic technology.
Functionally, E-learning can include a wide variety of learning strategies and technologies.
CD-ROMs Computer-based instruction
Videoconferencing
Satellite-delivered learning
Virtual educational networks (Source: ASTD, 2001)
27
DemandDemand• Rapid Obsolescence of knowledge
• Need for just-in-time training delivery
• Cost-effective ways to meet learning needs
• Demand for flexible access to lifelong learning
DemandDemand• Rapid Obsolescence of knowledge
• Need for just-in-time training delivery
• Cost-effective ways to meet learning needs
• Demand for flexible access to lifelong learning
SupplySupply• Internet access becoming standard at work and home
• Advances in digital techno- logies enable creation of interactive, media-rich content
• Increasing bandwidth and better delivery platforms make e-learning more attractive
SupplySupply• Internet access becoming standard at work and home
• Advances in digital techno- logies enable creation of interactive, media-rich content
• Increasing bandwidth and better delivery platforms make e-learning more attractive
E-commerce/ E-businessE-commerce/ E-business
e-learning
(Sources: SRI Consulting and WR Hambrecht + Co, 2000)
Why Companies Choose E-Learning?
28
E-Learning Market Gaining Market Share
29
A Statistical Portrait of E-Learning
The percentage of organizations using the Internet for training purposes grew from 3 percent in 1996 to 38 percent in 1999. For intranets, the rate of growth was even higher, from 3.5 percent to nearly 40 percent. (Source: ASTD)
Web-based training, according to the survey, is expected to surge by more than 900 percent between 1999 and 2003. (Source: International Data Corporation)
A key reason is that “online training is far cheaper than bringing in a live instructor, let alone sending employees to an offsite training location. And productivity doesn’t suffer as much when employees get their how-tos at their own computers.” (Source: Business Week)
30
Advantages of E-Learning
E-learning is learner-focused.
E-learning allows employees to learn at their own pace.
There is no lag time between hiring and training.
E- learning offers cost and time savings.
31
Disadvantages of E-learning
E-learning has no personal touch. E-learning does not promote problem-
solving. E-learning does not allow students
to build network. E-learning is expensive to develop.
32
Future of Distance Learning
“Online learning is not the next big thing;
it is the now big thing.”
- Donna J. Abernathy,
Editor of Training and Development, 1999
33
Future Trends
UNESCO is expecting the following trends toshape Distance Learning in North America
– Blended Learning Solutions
– Continued simultaneous cooperation and competition among traditional colleges and universities and new online only entities
(Patru & Khvilon, 2002)
34
Blended Learning
Blended LearningBlended Learning
35
VI. Class Discussion
36
Questions
What experiences have you had with distance learning, both as learners and as instructors?
How do the principles of andragogy play out differently in Distance Learning?
How do you imagine Distance Learning will affect your career?