+ All Categories
Home > Health & Medicine > A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

Date post: 21-May-2015
Category:
Upload: john-wilbanks
View: 620 times
Download: 2 times
Share this document with a friend
Description:
Seminar series, Office of Responsible Research Training and Postdoctoral Affairs Conducting Research, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia.
Popular Tags:
99
1. enclosures and openings
Transcript
Page 1: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

1.

enclosures and openings

Page 2: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 3: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 4: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 5: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

http://genomemedicine.com/content/5/3/27

Page 6: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

as much as 84% of the genes in the human genome

http://genomemedicine.com/content/5/3/27

Page 7: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 8: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 9: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 10: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 11: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 12: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 13: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 14: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

and very little changes, very slowly.

Page 15: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

(but if an iPhone bends, we are ON IT)

Page 16: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 17: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 18: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

2. !

a new methodology for research

Page 19: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

not just solo labs, but communities.

Page 20: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

TCGA Pan-Cancer Consortium

Page 21: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

TCGA Pan-Cancer Consortium

Page 22: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

TCGA Pan-Cancer Consortium

Page 23: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

TCGA Pan-Cancer Consortium

Page 24: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 25: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

TCGA Pan-Cancer Consortium

Page 26: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 27: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

doi:10.7303/syn1710680.4

TCGA Pan-Cancer Consortium

Page 28: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

18NPG papers

68core projects248

researchers

28institutions

1070datasets1723

results

TCGA Pan-Cancer Consortium

Page 29: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

29

Page 30: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

30

A

B

C

D

E

F

1

2

3

4

5

6

groups datasets subtypes

Page 31: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

31

A

B

C

D

E

F

1

2

3

4

5

6

G ...

Page 32: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

not just solo labs, but challenges.

Page 33: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 34: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

code sharing a prerequisite.

http://synapse.org

Page 35: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

accuracy of model jumped three orders of magnitude in nine days.

Page 36: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

36

76% accurate.

Page 37: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

generated an entire suite of available math models attacking

the problem.

Page 38: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

21 february 2013

17 april 2013

ongoing...

Page 39: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 40: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

SHOW ME THE CODE!

Page 41: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

...

Page 42: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

(all code is free as in beer and as in freedom)

!

http://synapse.org

https://github.com/Sage-Bionetworks/Synapse-Repository-

Services

Page 43: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 44: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

not just solo labs, but the general public.

Page 45: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 46: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 47: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 48: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 49: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 50: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

how do we scale engagement when our systems weren’t

built for it?

Page 51: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

https://www.scienceexchange.com/

Page 52: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

3. !

informed consent as vector for scaling engagement

Page 53: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

written by a doctor edited by a lawyer re-edited by a committee

presented to a participant for zero-sum game

Page 54: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

written by a doctor edited by a lawyer re-edited by a committee

presented to a participant for zero-sum game

Page 55: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

comprehension language time format

regulatory issues liability fears

Page 56: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 57: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

57

Page 58: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

58

Page 59: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

59

Page 60: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

key insights: !

make the interface visual !

bring the experience into the consent process itself

Page 61: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

1. initial metaphor

Page 62: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

62

2. initial design

Page 63: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

63

3. second revision

Page 64: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

implementation in 2 Sage Bionetworks clinical studies (parkinsons,

post-chemo cognition)

Page 65: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

user interface to consent

informed consent document

IRB

map between form and interface

reviews for ethical and scientific propriety

reviews for effectiveness in informing

mobile clinical study protocoluse standard, vetted interface

and open source software code for consent

write locally appropriate consent forms

Page 66: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

66

4. PD mobile study (IRB approved)

Page 67: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

67

Page 68: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

68

Page 69: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

69

Page 70: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

70

Page 71: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

71

Page 72: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

72

Page 73: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

73

Page 74: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

74

Page 75: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

75

Page 76: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

76

Page 77: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

77

Page 78: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

78

Page 79: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

79

Page 80: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

4. !

the participant-centered consent toolkit

Page 81: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

81

Page 82: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

82

PCC Visual Language PCC consent workflows Sample clinical documents Implementation support

Page 83: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

83

everything needed to create visual consent interfaces…

Page 84: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

84

only requirement is attribution.

Page 85: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

Release Strategy !

• article in E-GEMS methods journal

• website with open source tools (attribution licenses) !

• apps implementing

• pre-committed beta testers

• public presentations through autumn

• social media promotion !

• liase with PRIM&R and others to smooth review of protocols using toolkit

Page 86: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

86

technical architecture for open science

Page 87: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

87

(the price is freedom)

Page 88: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 89: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

this is not an abstract thing, this open science.

Page 90: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

“our competitors' reliance on public databases with high VUS and error

rates will further restrict patient access to this life-saving medicine.”

Page 91: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

open systems allow for evolution, for experimentation,

for adaptation.

Page 92: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 93: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 94: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

94

Page 95: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 96: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data
Page 97: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

no company could have built it.

Page 98: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

don’t we deserve that kind of freedom to

“make” in health care?

Page 99: A New Model for Informed Consent: The Impact of Open Science on the Responsible Use of Research Data

thank you. !

@wilbanks [email protected]


Recommended