©1999 Sigma-AldrichCo.
SUPELCOCapillary GC Troubleshooting:
a Practical Approach
Gas Separations R&D
Katherine Stenerson
Supelco, Supelco Park, Bellefonte, PA 16823
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Outline
✔ Basic Troubleshooting Strategy
✔ Preventing Problems
✔ Identifying Common Problems
✔ Recommended Reading
✔ Discussion
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Troubleshooting Strategy
✔ Have appropriate equipment and supplieson hand.
✔ Establish a systematic approach.
✔ Know what to look for first.
✔ Record what you did to correct the problem.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Suggested Equipment to Have on Handfor Troubleshooting:
✔ Electronic Leak Detector
✔ Flow Meter
✔ “Test” Column
✔ Replacement Accessories (Syringes,Ferrules, Septa)
✔ Replacement Purifiers
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Five Major Sources of ChromatographicProblems:
❶ Operator Error
❷ The Sample
❸ The Column
❹ The GC Electrical System
❺ The Gas Flow System (both internal andexternal to the GC)
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Approaching the Problem
✔ Check first to see if a “fix” for the problemis already known.
✔ Check the Supelco Capillary GCTroubleshooting Guide (Bulletin 853.)
✔ Check back in the instrument maintenancerecord.
✔ Talk to others in your lab.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Check operating parametersRun Ref. Std.
OK Not OK
OKNot OK
Problem was sample related
Install Test
Column
OK Not OK
Problem was
Column related
Cap off Detector
OK
Not OK Problem is in the Detector
Problem is in the Inlet or with the carrier gas
Isolate the Source of the Problem
Correct the parameter
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
When reviewing operating methodparameters consider the following:
? Is my starting temp. low enough to allowsufficient sample focusing?
? For splitless injections, is my splitter opening atthe appropriate time?
? Is my column flow set to give me maximumefficiency at the most critical point?
? Are heated zones (injectors, detectors, interfaces)set appropriately?
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
The Best Way to Solve Problems is toPrevent Them!
✔ Install and maintain proper purification forall gases in the GC system.
✔ Maintain the injector by periodicallyinspecting and changing the liner, septa,and seal (H/P™.)
✔ Use the proper injection technique-thisincludes using the right liner for the job.
✔ When necessary, use a guard column toprotect the analytical column.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Gas Purification
✔ Carrier Gas– At minimum, remove hydrocarbons, water, and oxygen.
✔ Hydrogen (FID)– At minimum, remove hydrocarbons.
✔ Air (FID)– At minimum, remove water and hydrocarbons.
✔ Nitrogen make-up (FID, ECD)– At minimum, remove hydrocarbons.
✔ P-5 make-up (ECD)– At minimum remove hydrocarbons (especially halogen-
containing), oxygen.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Acceptable Purity Levels forChromatography Grade Gases
Impurity / Maximum Concentration
Gas O2 H2O CO2 COTotal
Hydrocarbons
Helium <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppmNitrogen <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppmAir 20-22% <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppmHydrogen <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppmArgon/ Methane <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm <1.0 ppm
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Suggested purifiers
Hydrocarbons Water Oxygen
Carrier Supelcarb HCSupelpure HC
Mole Sieve 5A OMI -2
H2
Air Mole Sieve 5A
N2 makeup
P-5 OMI -2 OMI -2
P-5
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
What are some signs that my purifiersneed to be changed?
Hydrocarbon TrapsNoise in the baseline (FID)
Increase in background peakson tune (MSD)
Higher than normal baselinereading on FID
Extra peaks visible in run
Molecular Sieve 5AIncrease in column bleed
Water visible in MSbackground
Poor peak shapes for gaseousVOCs (purge and trap)
Extra peaks visible in run
OMI™-2 color change
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Injector Maintenance
✔ Change (as needed):
1. Liner and O-ring*
2. Seal and washer **H/P™ GCs
✔ Inspect the inlet periodically
-Look for contamination in the liner
-Look for residue on the seal
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Using the right liner and injectiontechnique can also prevent problems:✔ Split Injection
– used for concentrated samples– high flow of carrier gas through liner during
injection– should use liner designed for split injection
✔ Splitless Injection– used for trace analysis– low flow of carrier gas through liner during
injection– inertness and internal volume of liner used are
critical
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Some liners used for split injection
Cup (unpacked)
Cup (wool packed)
Split/splitless- wool packed
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Some liners used for splitless injection
2 mm ID, straight
Dual-tapered
Single-tapered
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
If you must clean a liner….
✔ Handle liners with gloves or forceps.
✔ Use clean compressed gas and/or a finebrush to remove particles.
✔ Rinse liner in an appropriate solvent anddry with clean compressed gas.
✔ Use mineral acid and/or detergent only ifabsolutely necessary.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Using a Guard Column
✔ Choose a guard column which has beendeactivated.
✔ Usually, the ID of the guard matches theanalytical column.
✔ A 5-10 meter length is normally used.
✔ Connect with either a GlasSeal™ or buttconnector.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Common Problems
1 Poor Peak Shapes (either tailing, fronting,or just generally ugly.)
2 Nonlinearity
3 Baseline Noise and /or Drift
4 Ghost Peaks
5 Missing Peaks / Poor Response
6 Insufficient Resolution
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
1. Poor Peak Shapes
✔ Fronting can indicatecolumn overload.
✔ Tailing can indicateactivity in the system orimproper columninstallation.
||
||
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
1. Poor Peak Shapes (cont.)
✔ Generally ugly peaks,such as a,a-dimethylphenethylamine,can be caused by avariety of problems.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
➨ Column overload
➨ Detector overload
➨ Standards preparation
➨ Poor peak shape resulting in improperintegration
2. Nonlinearity
The most common causes are:
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
An Example of Overload:
Peaks have broad bases,fronting on last few visible inrun.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Preventing column overload for splitlessinjections:
✔ Inject a smaller amount / use a 1 ul syringe.
✔ Use a thicker film column.
✔ Use a column with a wider ID.
✔ Decrease upper limit of calibration range.
✔ Use a column of slightly different polarity.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
An example of poor peak shape affectinglinearity:
✔ Benzoic acid istypically of poorshape when doingsplitless injections.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
3. Common causes of baseline noise /drift.
✔ Column bleed
✔ Dirty detector
✔ Contaminants in carrier gas / carrier gaspurity
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
10
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
5000
5500
6000
6500
7000
7500
8000
8500
9000
9500
10000
10500
11000
11500
12000
Effect of carrier gas purity on baselinenoise:
H2 carrier from tank
H2 carrier from a generator
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Column bleed results from the normaldegradation of the stationary phase.
✔ All columns bleed to some extent.
✔ Bleed increases with temperature.
✔ The amount of bleed will increase in thepresence of oxygen.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
A Typical Bleed Profile:
4
Bleed measured as thedifference between 1 and 2.
1
2
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Column Bleed on an MSD
✔ Visible as baseline rise in the TIC.✔ Check spectra for key bleed ions:
– PTE™-5: 207, 281– SPB™-1: 73, 207, 281– SPB™-624: 207, 269
✔ Make sure interface temp. is < columnmax. temp.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Ion 207 corresponds to a fragment known as D3:
O Si
SiO
Si
O
CH 3 CH 3
CH 3
CH 3
CH 3
+
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO40 60 80 100120140160180200220240260280300320340360380400
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
5000
5500
6000
m/z-->
Abundance
Scan 2895 (27.487 min): 1118015.D207
2817313396
191
253
50
327223162 355115 415
MS spectra of bleed from a PTE™-5 Column
207
281
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
40 60 80 1001201401601802002202402602803003203403603804004200
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
5000
5500
6000
6500
7000
7500
8000
8500
9000
9500
10000
10500
11000
11500
m/z-->
Abundance
Scan 1941 (28.793 min): 0122002.D73
44
207
147
281341
96 119 179 253 429401313
MS spectra of bleed from an SPB™-1 Column
73
207
281
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
MS spectra of bleed from an SPB™-624 Column
40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320 3400
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
20000
22000
24000
m/z-->
Abundance
Scan 8581 (33.704 min): 1022006.D207
269
44253
19113373 96177147
283119 322 343239163 22359298
207
269
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
40 60 80 1001201401601802002202402602803003203403603804004200
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
20000
22000
24000
26000
28000
30000
32000
34000
36000
38000
40000
42000
44000
m/z-->
Abundance
Scan 604 (7.460 min): 1201001.D73
147
281
32745
207415399
131 191 343 383251 29795 223163115
MS Spectra of Septa Bleed
73
147
281
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Prevent column bleed!
✔ Sufficiently purge column with carrier beforeramping it up in temperature.
✔ Make sure carrier gas is filtered for water andoxygen.
✔ Check integrity of all fittings leading to thecolumn.
✔ Do not heat the column above its maximum temp.
✔ Precondition the column prior to use.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
4. Ghost Peaks
✔ Residue in the inlet liner and at the head ofthe column
✔ Contaminated syringe / and or washsolutions on an autosampler.
✔ Sample carryover
✔ Contaminated carrier gas
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
1200000
1400000
1600000
1800000
2000000
2200000
Response test mix, before
If pieces of septa get into an inlet liner...
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
0
500000
1000000
1500000
2000000
2500000
3000000
3500000
Time-->
…even a simple analysis can be ruined.
Response test mix, after
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
5. Missing Peaks / Poor Response
✔ Sample decomposition– Activity in the inlet or column– Injection port temperature too high– Sample not stable enough for GC– Standards not stable
✔ Coelution✔ Insufficient run time / final temperature✔ Sample not volatile enough for GC✔ Improper column installation
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
0
50000
100000
150000
200000
250000
300000
350000
400000
450000
2,4-
din
itro
phen
ol
4-n
itro
phen
ol
2-m
ethy
l-3,
5-di
nitr
ophe
nol
pent
ach
loro
phe
nol
Nasty samples can damage a columnby creating active sites:
Before Sample Injection
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
0
100000
200000
300000
400000
500000
600000
700000
800000
900000
Time-->
Abundance
2,4-
DN
P &
4-N
P s
hou
ld b
e he
re
2-m
ethy
l-3,
5-di
nitr
ophe
nol
Pen
tach
loro
phen
ol s
houl
d b
e he
re
After sample injection
Here, the responses of some acidswere affected:
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Response can also be affected by theposition of the column in the inlet:
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
1200000
1400000
1600000
1800000
2000000
2200000
2400000
2600000
2800000
8 mm above top of ferrule
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
1200000
1400000
1600000
1800000
2000000
2200000
Here, the column was not inserted farenough:
5 mm above top of ferrule
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Here, the column was inserted too far:
0
200000
400000
600000
800000
1000000
1200000
1400000
1600000
1800000
20 mm above top of ferrule
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
6. Insufficient Resolution
✔ Wrong column– Longer columns increase resolution.
– Smaller ID columns increase resolution.
– A different phase altogether may be needed.
✔ Wrong Conditions– Carrier gas flow too fast or slow .
– Oven ramp rate too fast.
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Recommended ReadingSupelco Bulletins
1. 741: The Supelco Guide to Leak-Free Connections2. 783: Cleaning Flame Ionization Detectors3. 853: Capillary Troubleshooting Guide4. 875: Supelco Capillary GC Selection Guide5. 895: Installation and Maintenance Instructions for .25
mm and .32 mm ID Fused Silica Capillary Columns6. 897: Installation and Maintenance Instructions for .53
mm ID Fused Silica Capillary Columns7. 898: Gas Management Systems for GC8. 899: Capillary GC Inlet Sleeve Selection Guide9. 916: Purge and Trap System Guide10. 918: Selecting Purifiers for Gas Chromatography
©1999 Sigma-Aldrich Co. SUPELCO
Help is just a phone call or mouseclick away!
✔✔ Supelco Technical ServiceSupelco Technical Servicephone: 1-800-359-3041email: [email protected]✔✔ Supelco Customer ServiceSupelco Customer Servicephone: 1-800-247-6628email: [email protected]✔✔ Sigma-Sigma-Aldrich WebsiteAldrich Websitewww.sigma-aldrich.com