+ All Categories
Home > Documents > A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney...

A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney...

Date post: 01-Jul-2018
Category:
Upload: phamdan
View: 214 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
26
THE CONTINUITY CONUNDRUM A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products Fatmir Menkulasi, PhD, PE La-Tech University JP Binard, PE Bayshore Concrete Products
Transcript
Page 1: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

THE CONTINUITY CONUNDRUM A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE

Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products Fatmir Menkulasi, PhD, PE La-Tech University JP Binard, PE Bayshore Concrete Products

Page 2: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

HISTORY

Page 3: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

CURRENT CODE PROVISION

• AASHTO LRFD SPECIFICATIONS:

Page 4: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

CLAUSE:

• 50% Live Load

• Temperature Gradient

• Superimposed Comp DL

• Creep

• Shrinkage

• Settlement, not considered

COMPRESSIVE?

Page 5: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

DESIGN

Page 6: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

PROBLEM?

Page 7: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

PARAMETERS:

• PCBT 45, 69, & 95

• Solar Radiation, Zone 3

• 2 Span, 3-Span, 4-Span

Page 8: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

THERMAL

Page 9: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

2-SPAN: THERMAL + LL , + SDL

Page 10: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

3-SPAN: THERMAL + LL , + SDL

Page 11: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

4-SPAN: THERMAL + LL , + SDL

Page 12: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

SIMPLIFIED CLAUSE:

• 50% Live Load

• Temperature Gradient

• Superimposed Comp DL

• Creep

• Shrinkage

• Settlement, not considered

COMPRESSIVE, TYPICAL

INVESTIGATE

Page 13: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

CREEP & SHRINKAGE

• AASHTO LRFD SPECIFICATIONS

Page 14: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

V/S RATIO

AASHTO LRFD, SIMPLIFIED

NCHRP 496 EQUATION

Page 15: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

CREEP COEFFICIENT

Page 16: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

SHRINKAGE STRAIN

COMMENTARY EQUATION RESULTS ARE CONSISTENT WITH THIS STATEMENT

Page 17: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

EXAMPLES:

Page 18: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

EXAMPLES:

Page 19: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

EXAMPLES:

Page 20: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

EXAMPLES:

Page 21: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

MEASUREMENTS:

Page 22: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

EXAMPLES:

Page 23: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

MEASUREMENTS:

Page 24: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

CURE TO MATURITY:

REDUCE COEFFICIENT TO < 1.0 • Increase t and f’ci

Page 25: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

CONCLUSION:

• The 90 Day Clause of AASHTO LRFD may be relaxed for common PCBT span to depth ratios in solar radiation zone 3.

• Thermal + 50% LL + SDL for standard cases is already compressive and may be excluded in the determination of compression at the bottom flange/diaphragm interface

• Creep and Shrinkage using modern day concretes and the appropriate formulas allow continuity to be established at a younger age.

• If continuity needs to be established at a young age, increase release strength and cure time.

Page 26: A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE · A PRECAST SUPPLIER PERSPECTIVE . Al Patel, PE Clark-Nexsen Rodney Davis, PhD, PE Bayshore Concrete Products ... NCHRP 496 EQUATION . CREEP COEFFICIENT

QUESTIONS:


Recommended