A Product of Wealth Securities, Inc.
Index Value Change % Chg
PSEi 5,031.78 19.21 0.3803 All Shares 3,376.91 11.58 0.3417 Financials 1,269.71 4.46 0.3525 Industrial 7,581.04 66.56 0.8703 Holding Firms 4,143.24 36.80 0.8962 Property 1,843.16 33.61 1.7908 Services 1,735.08 17.72 1.011 Mining & Oil 24,960.23 470.61 1.8505
US stocks gain on strong jobs and manufacturing data
US stocks gained yesterday (Mar 15) as strong jobs and manufacturing data spurred
buying. All three major indices posted sizeable gains with the Dow rising 0.44%; the S&P,
0.60%; and the Nasdaq, 0.51%. The S&P closed above the 1,400 level for the first time
since June 2008. The labor department reported yesterday that new claims for
unemployment benefits unexpectedly declined last week, supporting claims of a
strengthening economy. Manufacturing data in New York and the mid-Atlantic region also
strengthened, adding more to the positive sentiments. Semiconductors were among
yesterday’s best performers with AMD gaining 6.3%. Apple meanwhile pulled back 0.7%
after reaching new highs recently.
Foreign portfolio investments post net outflow in February
The Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas reported that foreign portfolio investments or hot money
yielded net outflows of US$305M in February 2012. This is a reverse from a net inflow of
US$589M the previous month and US$534M a year ago. In gross terms, inflows increased
2% to US$1.494B in February compared to last year, while outflows increased 92% to
US$1.799B. The BSP said that the surge in net outflows was a result of profit taking in the
Philippine Stock Exchange.
Smart Communications Inc. secures P5.5B loan from lenders
Smart Communications, Inc. announced that it had secured a P5.5B five-year fixed rate
loan facility from 18 lenders. Proceeds from the said note facility will be used to refinance
old debts. First Metro Investments Corp. was appointed as lead arranger and sole book
runner for the transaction. Smart said that strong demand for the notes led to a 1.3 times
oversubscription. Issue date is on March 19.
15 Mar 2012: 5,031.78 - 19.21 Value T/O, net Php 5,251 million 52-week High 5,070.20 Low 3,705.18 Foreign Buying: Php 3,574 million Foreign Selling: Php 3,039 million
Mar 14
Feb ’12 CB Accounts statistics
Mar 15
Jan’12 Remittance press release and statistics
Mar 15
Feb’12 SPEI
Mar 20
TA ASM
Index Movers Points
PLDT -21.29
Ayala Land Inc. -11.89 Alliance Global Inc. +9.81
SM Investments Corp. -8.86 Metro Pacific Investments Corp. +8.00
Index Out-performers Up
Belle Corp. 8.26% Metro Pacific Investments Corp. 7.89%
Alliance Global Inc. 6.77% ICTSI 4.21% DMCI Holdings 3.95%
Index Under-performers Down
Meralco 3.56% Ayala Land Inc. 3.49% Megaworld 3.28% PLDT 2.74% Ayala Corp. 2.41%
Dow Jones 13,252.80 +58.66
FTSE 100 5,940.72 -4.71
NIKKEI 225 10,123.30 +72.76
OF remittances jump 5.4% in Janury
The Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas said that remittances from overseas Filipinos rose at
an annual rate of 5.4% in January 2012 to US$1.6B. Remittances from both sea-based
and land-based workers grew 19.8% and 1.6% respectively. The BSP said that strong
demand for professional and skilled Filipino workers abroad continued to sustain the
steady inflow of remittances in the country. Data from the POEA sowed that total
processed job orders for the first two months of the year alone reached 22,688. For
2012 however, the BSP expects only a 5% growth in remittances due to
enhancements of recruitment systems of host countries.
Foreign Buying-Selling : 12-month period
Source: PSE
US, Dollar 42.7340
Japan, Yen 0.5105
UK, Pound 66.9727 Hong Kong, Dollar 5.5053
EU, Euro 55.6781
Bahrain, Dinar 113.3620 Saudi Arabia, Rial 11.3948
China, Yuan 6.7486
As of 3/15/2012
NYMEX Crude Futures
105.11 -0.30%
NY Gold Spot ($/t oz.) 1,661.10 +1.53%
Silver Comex ($/t oz.) 32.42 +0.68%
London Copper Spot 8,582.75 +1.29%
As of 3/15/2012
03
Pure retail play. We view Puregold as the best proxy in the retail space which is highly reflective of the robust consumption in the country. Key factors that should sustain the company’s earnings growth in the short to medium term include improving consumer confidence, rising workforce particularly in the BPO scene, and resilient inflow of OFW remittances.
Reaping economies of scale. The strong interest in Puregold is not surprising given its robust growth rates in 2011 – total revenues of P38.9 billion (+33.9% YoY) and net income of P1.5 billion (+203% YoY). Worth noting are improvements in gross profit margins of 207 bps to 14.20% and net profit margin increase of 221 bps to 3.96%, due to continuous improvements in lowering cost of sales through stronger support from suppliers in terms of discount and rebates as well as successful implementation of the rollout of new stores. Operating expenses stayed flat at 11% of sales in the past four years while store count grew from 30 to 100.
WE
ALT
H S
EC
UR
ITIE
S
Puregold Price Club. (PGOLD) Initiating Coverage with a Buy
Company Snapshot
Price (P) 20.30 Price Target (P) 24.00 Shares O/S (million) 2,000 Market Cap (P million) 40,600 52-week High (P) 23.60 Low (P) 17.78 12-mo Avg. Value T/O (P'm) 101.58 Shareholders
Majority 65.5% Free float 34.5%
Price Performance
1m 6m 12m PGOLD -5.36% +62.40% N/A PSEi +5.43% +17.25% +28.40%
Pure Retail Play
Nikki Yu T: 689.8000 local 8150 E: [email protected] Bernard C. Aviñante T: 634.5038 local 8164 E: [email protected]
Financial and Valuation Highlights in P'million 2009A 2010A 2011A 2012E 2013E Net Sales 24,112 29,108 38,988 52,426 64,580 EBITDA 755 1,264 2,673 3,761 4,765 Net Income 131 510 1,545 2,178 2,601 EPS (P) 0.11 0.40 0.97 1.09 1.30 EPS Growth 0.0% 263.6% 142.5% 12.3% 19.4% Gross Margin 9.2% 12.1% 14.2% 14.0% 14.0% EBITDA Margin 3.13% 4.34% 6.86% 7.17% 7.07% Net Margin 0.54% 1.75% 3.96% 4.15% 4.03% P/E (x) 184.55 50.75 20.93 18.62 15.61 P/S (x) 1.68 1.39 1.04 0.77 0.63
Source: Wealth Securities estimate, company data A = Actual calendar/fiscal year results; C = Bloomberg consensus; I = Annualized interim results; E = Wealth Securities estimates
04
Expansion pipeline internally financed. Management has already secured all sites for their planned expansion of 25 store openings by yearend, the majority of which will be rolled out in the latter half of this year. Capex stands at P3 billion for FY2012 funded by internally generated funds in addition to the balance from the IPO proceeds. Balance sheet is very healthy as the company has zero debt.
Medium-term expansion towards Vis-Min region. Puregold is one of the fastest growing retail chains in the Philippines. With 61 hypermarkets, 28 supermarkets, and 11 discounters in 2011 entirely represented in the denser and more affluent Luzon area (53 in Metro Manila, 16 in North Luzon, 31 in South Luzon), the company is ready to expand its geographic coverage towards Visayas and Mindanao by 2013 with a goal of 200 stores by 2015. This represents a roll-out of 25 stores annually over the next four years. Puregold Price Club plans to reach out to consumers by providing more product choices at lower prices, especially in communities that had only local retail monopolies prior to the chain’s arrival.
Beneficiary of robust consumption. OFW remittances reached a
record $20.1 billion in 2011. This represents a 9.5% CAGR from 2006-2011. The steady influx of remittance money augurs well for an economy underpinned by domestic consumption. Retailers are direct beneficiaries of a consumption boom. The Puregold invasion is, in fact, a product of the economy’s vibrant consumption-led growth. We expect this trend to sustain and for Puregold to continue riding the growth momentum.
The pie is large enough. SM’s more dominant chain of retail stores
poses a significant threat to Puregold. While this may be true, we believe that the pie is large enough for all the players. According to Planet Retail, the Philippine industry’s retail sales and grocery sales are expected to grow by 11.3% and 11% respectively from 2010-2012. In 2010, Puregold’s grocery sales represented only 1.03% share in the total industry’s grocery sales estimates ($661 million vs. $64.2 billion), thus showing greater potential for expansion without cannibalization.
WEALTH SECURITIES. INC
15 March 2012 Consumer
Puregold Price Club
29 34 44 61
79 93 109
125
1 7
16
28
32 40
46 52
- -
2
11
14
17
20
23
-
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
08 09 10 11 12E 13E 14E 15EDiscounters Supermarkets Hypermarkets
Source: Company data, Wealth estimates
Puregold Store Count
- 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
-
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
P/$ $'mn Remittances (lhs)
FX rate (rhs)
Source: Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas
05
Key Developments: S&R Acquisition. Puregold management is reviewing the potential acquisition of the S&R Price Club shopping business. S&R Price Club is a high-end, membership-based hypermarket wholly owned by the Co family, the same controlling shareholder of Puregold. It is comprised of six stores, mostly situated in highly urbanized areas within Mega Manila.
S&R Shopping Club Operating Stores’ Locations
1. Bonifacio Global City, Taguig City 2. Alabang, Muntinlupa 3. San Fernando, Pampanga 4. Congressional Ave., Quezon City 5. Aseana, Baclaran 6. Mandaue City, Cebu Value of S&R acquisition - Trump Card. We think that the S&R acquisition would be value enhancing to PGOLD. Assuming annual spending of P200,000 per member or an average net ticket price of P675/day (on 10k members), we believe our forecasted net income can increase from P2.2 billion to P2.7 billion assuming a 4% net profit margin on P12 billion incremental sales from S&R. The P0.24 EPS accretion increases our valuation by P4.80 after assigning a multiple of 20x P/E considering the steady growth of the company’s stores until 2015. We believe ascribing 20x P/E is justified considering peer valuations. We believe P200,000 is a conservative estimate as most of the S&R shoppers belong to the A&B segments who, theoretically, have higher disposable incomes than the average Filipino consumer. Further, PGOLD’s average net ticket price for its hypermarkets is just lower by 5% compared to our assumed spending for S&R.
Growth at a Reasonable Price. We performed a discounted FCF model
and a P/E based multiple in arriving at our target price for PGOLD. We believe these two methods capture the company’s fair value as they factor in market value, downside risks, growth rates, and cash flows. Based on the said valuation parameters, we arrive at a P24.00 price target for PGOLD, translating into a forward P/E of 22X. In our FCF model, we assumed 11% cost of equity and 5% terminal growth rate. We believe assigning a 22x P/E target is warranted, as this factors in a 10% discount to average forward P/Es of regional peers such as Thailand’s Siam Makro and Big C Supermart. Both companies possess similar high revenue growth trajectories and mirror-image net margins. We initiate coverage with a Buy.
Regional Comparable Peers
Name
Rev Growth
(1 Yr) Fwd P/E
Net Margin
Puregold 33.94% 18.62 3.96% Siam Makro 12.38% 24.08 2.63% Big C Supercenter 47.92% 25.89 4.78% China Resources Enterprise 35.24% 28.91 2.95% Zhongbai Holdings 16.79% 17.5 1.75% Wumart Stores 19.60% 28.57 4.71% Average 27.65% 23.93 3.46%
WEALTH SECURITIES. INC
15 March 2012 Consumer
Puregold Price Club
Source: Bloomberg
• Over the next six to twelve months, Wealth Securities expect the share price to increase by 12% or more
BUY
• Over the next six to twelve months, Wealth Securities expect the share price move within a range of +/-12%
HOLD
• Over the next six to twelve months, Wealth Securities expect the share price to decline by 12% or more
SELL