+ All Categories
Home > Documents > A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample...

A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample...

Date post: 30-Jun-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
53
A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in Public Plant Breeding Yunbi Xu Susanne Dreisigacker, and Jonathan H. Crouch Applied Biotechnology Center International Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT) Mexico
Transcript
Page 1: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in Public Plant Breeding

Yunbi XuSusanne Dreisigacker, and Jonathan H. Crouch

Applied Biotechnology CenterInternational Maize and Wheat Improvement Center (CIMMYT)

Mexico

Page 2: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Introduction

Seed DNA-based MAS

Selective Genotyping and Pooled DNA

Analysis

Large-Scale Association Mapping in Wheat

Using Multi-Environment Trial Data

Genetics and Genomics of Drought Tolerance

in Maize

Marker-Assisted Selection in Wheat

Future Prospects

Page 3: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Goff and Salmeron 2004 Scientific American 291(2) 42-49

Maize

CHALLENGES

Page 4: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Yield gap to be filled by modern plant breeding

ExperimentalStationyield

PotentialFarmyield

Theoreticalpotential

ActualFarmyield

Yield gap 0

Yield gap I

Yield gap II

For scientists to conceiveand breed potential varieties

Nontransferable technologyEnvironmental differences

{Biological• Variety• Weeds• Pests• Problem soils• Water• Soil fertilitySocioeconomic• Costs• Credit• Tradition• Knowledge• Input• Instructions

17.1

5

G A P

t/ha

(modified from Chaudhary 2000)

Page 5: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Xu. 2009. Molecular Plant Breeding, CABI Publisher

Biotechnology product development process with projected time: 7-12 years

Discovery Market Introduction

Definition of the trait• Choice of genes• Source of genes

Decision and actions here can have a long-term and late consequences

• Stringent agronomic performance and eff icacy criteria

• Greater than 90* of all events are eliminated

• Based in part on methods used to evaluate conventioanl varieties through traditional breeding

Detailed risk assessment for regulatory review

• Food

• Feed

• Fuel

• Environmental

• Product performance

• Investigate complaints

• Support of academic research into applications

Appropriate product stewardship

Selections of line(s) with appropriate characteristics

ProductConceptProductConcept

GeneDiscovery

GeneDiscovery

Line Selection ProductionProduction MarketMarket Post

MarketPost

MarketTransformation

or MASTransformation

or MASGH & fieldEvaluationGH & fieldEvaluation

VarietyDevelopment

VarietyDevelopment

Avai

labl

e te

chno

logy

and

fu

rthe

r im

prov

emen

t

Steps involved in crop biotechnology product developmenet using transformation or marker -assisted selection (MAS). The whole process from discovery to market introduction takes about 7 to 12 years

Page 6: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Road from Basic Genomics Research to Impacts

Bumpy

Long

Windy

Wrong turns Unexpected blockades

Page 7: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Long

Cost-Effective and High Throughput Genotyping Systems

Wrong turns

Genotype by Environment Interaction

Unexpected blockades

Powerful Bioinformatics and Decision Support Tools

Windy

Genetic Architecture of Complex Traits

Bumpy

Molecular Marker Development and Validation

Bottlenecks in Marker-Assisted Selection

Page 8: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Reducing Costs & Increasing Scale and Efficiency of MAS

• Single-Seed Based DNA Genotyping and MAS System

• Precision and High Throughput Global Phenotyping

• Utilization of Genetic and Breeding Materials

• Selective Genotyping and Phenotyping from Large Base Populations

• Integrated Genetic Diversity Analysis, Genetic Mapping and MAS

• Developing Breeding Strategies for Simultaneous Improvement of Multiple Traits

Xu and Crouch 2008 Crop Science 48:391-407

Page 9: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Seed DNA-based Genotyping

Page 10: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Seed

Seed

Molecular biologyGenetic analysis PCRMolecular markersMicroarray… …

DNA

Seedling

Leaf tissue

Planting

Leaf- and seed-DNA approaches

Page 11: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

① Soaking ② Sampling ③ Grinding

⑥ Tracking backand planting

④ DNA extraction⑤ PCR and genotyping

Seed DNA-based Genotyping in Maize

Gao et al 2008. Molecular Breeding 22:477–494

Page 12: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 2415

Seed DNA-based genotyping in maizeusing 24 randomly selected SSR markers

From left to right for each markerSarcosyl, sarcosyl+CTAB, CTAB, Leaf DNA

Gao et al 2008. Molecular Breeding 22:477–494

Page 13: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Greenhouse tests: The sampled seed germinated quickly with slightly weak seedlings

CutCut and treatedwith fungicide Control

7 days

14 days

Page 14: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

LS SS Control

a

SSControl LSSS

b

LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample sizeControl: no sampling

Seedling establishment for seeds with endosperm sampled for DNA extraction

compared with controls

Gao et al 2008. Molecular Breeding 22:477–494

Page 15: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Conclusion from maize trials

No labeling or tracking is needed

Almost all DNA extraction protocols work well

DNA quality is functionally comparable to leaf DNA

DNA extraction can be high-throughput

30mg endosperm can yield 3-10ug DNA 200-400 agarose-gel PCR-based markersSeveral million chip-based SNP markers

Page 16: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Selective Genotyping and Pooled DAN Analysis

Page 17: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Xu 2009 Molecular Plant Breeding. CABI Publisher

Selective Genotyping and Pooled DNA Analysis

Qualitative traits

Linked

Linked

Unlinked

R plants S plants

A

Quantitative traits

0.0

0.5

1.0

0.0

0.5

1.0

Population distribution

Selection

DNA Pools

GenotypingLinked

Unlinked

High tail

Lowtail

0.0

0.5

1.0 Linked

B

Alle

le fr

eque

ncy

Page 18: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Why Selective Genotyping and Pooled DNA Analysis

Unlimited number of markers available Two high-dimensionvariables

Large numbers of plants to be genotyped

Cost is still too high

Example: Select two contrasting extremes each with 30 plants from a population with 1000 plants

For selective genotyping 60/1000 = 6%, compared to the entire population genotyping

For Pooled DNA analysis2/1000 = 0.2%, compared to the entire population genotyping2/60 = 3.3% compared to the selective genotyping

Page 19: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 1500

2

4

6

8

10

12

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0 15 30 45 60 75 90 105 120 135 1500.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

Pow

er (%

)Po

wer

(%)

LOD=3.0

LOD=6.0

LODPower LO

DLO

DcM

A

B

LODPower

QTL effect= 10%Population size =200, Tail size=15Marker density=15 cM

LOD=3.94Power =67%

QTL effect= 10%Population size =500, Tail size=30Marker density=1 cM

LOD=10.37Power =98%

Two Typical Selective Genotyping Strategies

Sun et al (2009) Molecular Breeding

Page 20: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

20% 15% 10% 5% 3% 1%153050100

20% 15% 10% 5% 3% 1%153050100

20% 15% 10% 5% 3% 1%153050100

20% 15% 10% 5% 3% 1%153050100

010

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

010

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

010

2030

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

010

20

30

4050

60

70

80

90

100

QTL effect

Tail

size

Pow

er (%

)

QTL effect

Tail

size

Pow

er (%

)

QTL effect

Tail

size

Pow

er (%

)

QTL effect

Tail

size

Pow

er (%

)

N = 200 N = 500

N = 1000 N = 3000

Selective Genotyping: QTL Effects and Population/Tail Sizes

Xu 2009 Molecular Plant Breeding, CABI Publisher

Page 21: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

0

10

20

30M

ean

LOD

sco

re

A. Two interacting QTL with a1=a2=aa= 0.2236

ICIM

SIM

SGM0

20

40

60

80

100

pow

er (%

)

B. Two interacting QTL with a1=a2=aa= 0.2236

ICIM SIM SGM

012345

Mea

n LO

D s

core

C. Two interacting QTL with a1=a2=0,aa= 0.3873

SIM

SGM

ICI

M

0

5

10

pow

er (%

)

D. Two interacting QTL with a1=a2=0,aa= 0.3873

0

10

20

30

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

110

120

130

140 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

110

120

130

140

150

Mea

n LO

D s

core

position

E. Two interacting QTL with a1=aa= 0.2739, a2=0

ICIM

SIM

SGM0

20

4060

80100

0 10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

110

120

130

140 0 10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

10

0 11

0 12

0 13

0 14

0 15

0

pow

er (%

)

position

F. Two interacting QTL with a1=aa= 0.2739, a2=0

Sun et al. 2009 Mol Breed

Page 22: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Why Can Pooled DNA Analysis Be Used for Genetic Mapping with Illumina GoldenGate Assay ?

POOL 1 POOL 2

5:5 5:5

4:66:4

10:0 0:10

No linkage

Partiallinkage

Completelinkage

Scored asHeterozygotes

Scored asHomozygotes

Inaccuratescoring

Page 23: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Replacement of entire population genotyping

Yes, if the total and tail population sizes are large enough andmarker-density is high.Selective genotyping can be used for effective genetic mapping of QTL with relatively small effects, QTL with epistasis, and linked QTL. Selective genotyping can be used for fine mapping to narrow downthe target region to less than 1cM or even few candidate genes.

Recommendation

Large QTL (15% or higher): Population size = 200+; tail size =20+

Medium QTL (3-10%): Population size =500-1000; tail size=50+

Small QTL (0.2-3%): Population size =3000-5000; tail size=100+

Innovative Uses of Selective Genotyping and Pooled DNA Analysis

Page 24: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

“All-in-one plate” - Genetic Mapping of All Target Traits in One Step

Availability of trait-specific genetic and breeding materials:Inbreds/cultivars with extreme phenotypesEternal/fixed segregating populations (e.g., recombinant inbred lines), doubled haploids, near isogenic lines, introgression linesGenetic stocks (e.g. single segment substitution lines) and mutant libraries

Availability of phenotypic data: Multiple environmental trials (MET) Availability of pooled DNA genotyping system

=>>>One 384-well plate could be designed to cover 192 traits/populations=>>>Almost all major gene/QTL controlled agronomic traits for a crop species

Innovative Uses of Selective Genotyping and Pooled DNA Analysis

Page 25: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Materials collected so far

1. 8 RIL populations, each with 60 to 150 lines2. 5 BIL populations3. 3 F2 populations4. 800 Inbreds selected from over 2000 of various sources

What traits are covered:

1. Drought tolerance (multiple sources)2. Disease resistance (5)3. Insect resistance (4)4. Nitrogen response5. Grain quality and nutrition (10)6. Lodging resistance7. Physiological traits (5)8. Agronomical traits (5+)

Representing 2200 extreme entries or over 6000 entries of entire populations

“All-In-One Plate” Project in CIMMYT

Page 26: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Large-Scale Association Mapping In Wheat Using Multi-Environment Trial Data And

Ex-situ Germplasm Collections

Page 27: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

The International Wheat Improvement NetworkCIMMYT's improved germplasm is dispatched through nurseries targeted to specific agro-ecological environments to a network of researchers

Data from these trials are returned to CIMMYT, catalogued, analyzed

ESWYT: Elite spring wheat yield trial

30-50 lines distributed each year from 1979 to present to partners in over 40 National Agricultural Research Systems

Full pedigrees and selection histories are known and phenotypic data cover yield, agronomic, pathological and quality data

Page 28: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Wheat Phenome Atlas

ESWYT Phenome Atlas:25 cycles from 1979/1980 to 2004/2005685 lines1445 trials across 400 locationsPhenotypic data for 21 traits:8 agronomic traits (including yield)3 rusts (leaf, stripe, and stem rust)10 other foliar diseasesGenotypic data: 1447 DArT

Expansion to the entire set of SAWYT

Connect phenotype and genotype “data islands” in time and space usingnew biometrical tools, to better understand interactions among genes that influence complex traits

Page 29: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Patterns of genetic variationDetermination of population structure based on phenotypic, pedigree and marker dataEnvironments and GEIEnvironmental classificationLD analyses LD in different subsetsChanges in allele frequencies over time and locationsUnderstanding of linkage blocks and selectionHaplotypes at known genese.g translocations, introgressionsMarker-trait associationsAssociations using diverse modelsFamily-based associationsGenotyping a set of parents

Crossa et al., 2007 Genetics 177:1889-1913Dreisigacker et al., 2009 in preparation

Wheat Phenome Atlas

Page 30: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Many significantly associated markers per trait

● Stem rust resistance: 63 DArT (colocalized with many reported including 1B.1R with major effect)

● Leaf rust resistance: 87 DArT (colocalized with > 50 reported)

● Yellow rust resistance: 122 DArT (colocalized with many reported genes with minor effect)

● Powdery mildew resistance: 61 DArT, no direct selection for resistance to PM has been done at CIMMYT. Several were associated to genes transferring resistance to PM

● Grain yield: 213 DArT (corresponding to 7 QTL already published, QTL correlated with regions observed to be under continuous selection)

Page 31: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Next step: Marker validation and conversion for MAS – e.g. new stem rust QTL

wPt9690c 0.00wPt2573c 1.20wPt0357c 4.50wPt5931c 5.20wPt8833c 5.20wPt7599c 7.20wPt0959c 14.60

P34/M483-77 29.80wPt2991 34.50wPt7662 36.80

P33/M59-148 37.20wPt1089 39.00DuPw217 39.20wPt9532 39.40wPt1922 39.60wPt3130 39.60wPt4283 39.60wPt7150 39.60wPt9990 39.60wPt6994 39.70wPt4520 39.80wPt8239 40.20wPt4720 40.50wPt1547 40.60wPt6282 41.40wPt3116 41.40wPt3304 41.40wPt5188 41.40wPt1852 41.90wPt7777 41.90wPt6988 42.90wPt8015 44.00wPt4706 46.50wPt7954 47.60wPt0259 58.10

P34/M48-158 59.20wPt3376 60.00wPt5256 61.90wPt1241 62.60wPt8814 63.10wPt3605 63.50wPt2786 64.30wPt2175 65.00wPt7745 65.50wPt4858 66.10stm5212 66.10

P46/M48-423 66.90gwm132 69.70wPt3309 70.60wPt5333 70.60wPt2218 74.40wPt9594 75.00

P46/M62-107 75.60P45/M60-265 80.20

wPt1700 84.00P34/M48-84 86.40

wPt3733 87.50P34/M48-331 88.40

gwm518.2 88.50

YR(3), SR, YR

GY(3), GYAA(1), SR

GY

GY(2), SR

GY(2), SR

PM(9), GY

GY(5), GYAA(3), SR

GY(5), GYAA(3), SR

GY(3), SRGY(5), GYAA(1), SR

PM(12), GY

GY(2), SRGY(3), SR

GY(3), GYAA(4), GY

6BS ESWYT20_24

potential QTL for stem rust resistance

1. QTL validation

....GATGCACATGAAACGGGAGCGCCGGGTGGCCGCCGTGAACAAGTTCAGAGAGAAGAGAAAAGAGAGCAGGAAGAGGCAGTTCGTGGGCAGCCGCCACCGCCGGCTGCCGTTGAGAGATAACCTCCCGCCACACACCTAGctatacctagtacctactatttagac....

2. PCR-based marker development from DArT sequences

3. Verification of nearby SSR markers

significant DART

Page 32: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Step 1: sampling global genetic resources to create a core sample based on passport information

Various collections

Data collection

Composite Set (10%, up to 3000)

Step 3. Association mapping approaches genes/alleles tagged for marker-assisted breeding

Anonymous markers

Phenotyping Genotyping

Functional markers

Exploitation of germplasm collections for allele mining

Step 2: genotying the complosite set to select a reference sample for integrated characterisation and evaluation efforts

Genotyping, Sampling

Reference sampleor mini core

Slide reference: J.C. Glazman

Drought phenotyping of three wheat reference samples

Page 33: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Genetics and Genomics of Drought Tolerance in Maize

Page 34: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Multidisciplinary approach to improve drought tolerance in tropical maize

Phenotype GenotypeField evaluation

(segregating populations)

Drought consensus map(QTL, gene, Expression data)

Morphological and physiological data(Heritability)

(Phenotypic correlations)(Genotypic correlations)

Linkage maps

Candidate genesESTs

QTL data

Profiling experiment(RT-PCR/Northern/microarry)

Drought genes(ESTs)

Sample harvest for(RNA extraction)(DNA extraction)

MAS

New elite germplasm

DNA microarraySelected SNPs

Allele sequencingat selected genes

(Association genetics)

Preselection tool to predictdrought tolerance in new germplasm

MARS

Page 35: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Summary of the QTL analysis

● Four crosses / six segregating populations● F2/3, F3/4 and RIL families / hybrids● Tlaltizapan, Zimbabwe, Kenya

-P1xP2, (F3 families) 2 stress and 2 well-watered trails- P1xCM247 (F3 families) 3 stress and 1 ww trials- H16xK6 (F4 families) 8 stress and 1 ww trials- CM444xSCMalwi (F3 families) 10 stress and 3 ww trials- P1xP2 (RILs from C1) 7 stress and 3 ww trials- CM444xSCMalwi 6 (RIls, from C4) 8 stress and 3 ww trialsTotal: 43 water-stressed and 13 well-watered trials

● About 1000 QTL identified through individual analysis● About 600 QTL identified from combined analysis

Jean-Marcel Ribaut et al

Page 36: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

From plant phenotype to gene expression

GY ENO0.77 0.42 0. 82

EW0D SW0D

3 QTL 2QTL 3QTL

Droughttolerance

Geneexpression

Sucrose(carbohydrates)

ABA

Proline(Stress response)

-0.64

-0.57

Functional genomics to go

to the genes

Yieldcomponents

Secondarytraits

Physiologicalparameters

-0.51

A very large number of the QTL for carbohydrate regulation map in the QTL-rich regions identified on the consensus map

Page 37: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Metabolites assayed:- ABA and metabolites: ABA-glucose ester, phaseic acid- proline- carbohydrates: glucose, sucrose, starch

Tissues sampled:- leaf at 2 and 4 weeks after irrigation stopped- ear tip and silk at 0 and 7 d after anthesis

5000 tissue samples each year (2005-2006); assayed in duplicate1200 samples in 2007-2008; assayed in duplicate

Page 38: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Significant SNP associations for metabolite traits in 384 tropical inbreds tested under drought (flowering stage)

in 2005-2006 at Mexico TL. Specific for ABA in ear and silk

Specific for CHO in silk

Page 39: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Marker-Assisted Selection in Wheat

Page 40: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Breeding Objectives: e.g. Rust Resistance

Globally effective resistance to rusts:Leaf rust:Occurs worldwide wherever wheat is grown. It is most important where dews are frequent during the jointing through flowering stages and temperatures are mild, 15-25 C.Hotspots in DW: Morocco, Chile, Ethiopia, MexicoStem rust:Wide spread. Race Ug99 is currently spreading across Africa, Asia and most recently into Middle East and is causing major concern and an increase of food riots and civil unrest, notably in West and Central Africa among the worst-hit countries.

Page 41: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Breeding Objectives: e.g. Rust Resistance

Globally effective resistance to rusts:Leaf rust:

Use of major genes effective in hot spotsPyramiding on top of these, molecularly marked major genes (Lr19, Lr47…)Use of minor gene-based resistance, some molecularly marked (Lr34, Lr46)

Stem rust:Use identified sources of resistance Pyramid effective major genes, transfer from BW to DW (Sr25, Sr22, Sr26)Use of minor gene-based resistance, some molecularly marked (Sr2)

MAS

MAS

MAS

MAS

Page 42: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Sampling of leave tissue

MAS Outline

Field selection based on MAS

Fragment analyses

Bo1

Lr34

DNA extraction

PCR

Rusts: Lr19/Sr25, Lr34, Lr35/Sr39, Lr37/Yr17/Sr38, Lr47, Sr2, Sr22, Sr24, Sr26, Sr36, Lr14a, Lr46additional Fungi: Fhb1, Fhb2, 5A-QTL, H, StbViruses: Bdv2 Soil borne diseases: Cre1, Cre3, Cre5, Rlnn, 2.49 Quality: Pina,b, 1B/1R, 1A/R translocation, Gpc-B1, GBSS, Glu-D1, Glu-1Bx, pre-harvest sprouting, PsyPrecocity: Ppd-D1, Ppd-B1, Vrn-A1, Vrn-B1, Vrn-D1, Rht1, Rht2 Other: Bo1, Ph1

MAS for wheatRoutine application of approx. 30 markers: Major genes or major QTL of quantitative traits:

Page 43: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

CIMMYT Wheat - MAS: Throughput vs. costs Increasing deployment of MAS in CIMMYT wheat breeding programsMAS for major genes needs now to be combined with whole genome selectionMajor drawback in wheat is the lack of high throughput genotyping platforms

0

5000

10000

15000

20000

25000

30000

35000

40000

07/1 07/2 08/1 08/2 09/1

Breeding cycle

Num

ber

of d

atap

oint

s

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

07/1 07/2 08/1 08/2 09/1

Breeding cycle

Cos

t

Page 44: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Marker-Assisted Breeding Platform in Maize

I. Major gene introgression (target genes only)2 -10 markers for each trait

Single trait introgressionMultiple trait introgression

A few markers for hundreds of plantsTaqman genotyping system

II. Marker-assisted backcrossing (target genes plus background)2 -10 markers for each trait 100-200 markers for background selectionA few hundreds of markers for hundreds of plantsIllumina genotyping system

III. Whole genome or genomewide assay500 to several thousands or millions of markers for hundreds or thousands of plants/linesIllumina genotyping system

Page 45: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Information CollectionInformation Integration

Data standardizationDevelopment of generic databasesUse of controlled vocabularies/ontologiesInteroperable query systemRedundant data condensingDatabase integrationTool-based information integration

Information retrieval and miningInformation management systems

Breeding Informatics

Page 46: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Germplasm management, evaluation, and enhancementBreeding population management and improvement

Building up heterotic patternsPrediction of hybrid performance Marker-assisted inbred and synthetic creation

Genetic map constructionMarker-trait association identification and validationMarker-assisted selection methodologies and implementationGenotype by environment interaction analysisIntellectual property right and plant variety protectionBreeding design through simulation and modeling

Decision Support Tools

Page 47: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

GenotypeSequencesMarkersMapsGenealogy

PhenotypeYieldQualityAgronomyStress response

EnvironmentWater FertilizerSoilTemperaturePrecipitationGISDay length

Data Tools Output

Gene functional analysis

Genetic diversity

Germplasm evaluation

Germpalsm classification

Variety identification

Genetic mapping

Marker-trait association

Marker-assisted selection

GXE interaction

Environmental classification

Variety stability/adaptability

LIMS and Analytical Tools for Genetic Improvement

BLASTN/X…MapmakerMultiQTLGeneFlowQTL CartographerSAS/JAMPStructureGeneMapperPowerMarkerArlequinBiPlotCMTV……..

Integrated IMS for molecular breeding

ICIS

Page 48: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

FUTURE PROSPECTS

RFLP maps with markers every 10cM

PCR-based markers every 1 cM

Whole genome sequence for one or two genotypes

Array-based genotyping using 100K SNPsAll candidate genes + all germplasm collections

SQUENCING THEM ALL (???)

1980s

1990s

2000s

2010s

2020s

Page 49: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Long

Cost-Effective and High Throughput Genotyping Systems

Wrong turns

Genotype by Environment Interaction

Unexpected blockades

Powerful Bioinformatics and Decision Support Tools

Windy

Genetic Architecture of Complex Traits

Bumpy

Molecular Marker Development and Validation

Bottlenecks in Marker-Assisted Selection

Page 50: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Now … … Gene Networks + G-P-E Model

Home

Networks

TrafficWeatherCarDriver

Performance of a Geneat a road network is determined by …

Gene EnhancersDGProgram DirectorPeople around

OfficeLabStreet

Regulators

Page 51: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Acknowledgements

FundingRockefeller FoundationBill and Melinda Gates FoundationEuropean CommunityGeneration Challenge ProgramUnited States Agency for International DevelopmentNational Nature Science Foundation of ChinaState Scholarship Fund of China

SNP markers, genotyping etcMolecular and Functional Diversity in the Maize Genome Ed. Buckler, Mike McMullen, Jim HollandCornell Life Sciences Core Laboratories Center: Peter Schweitzer

Lab and field supportEva Huerta MirandaCarlos Martinez FloresMartha Hernandez Rodríguez Alberto Vergara AlvaMaria Asunción Moreno OrtegaJose Simon Pastrana Marias

Maize Molecular Breeding Groupand colleagues at CIMMYTShibin Gao Stephen MugoZhuanfang Hao Dan MakumbiYanli Lu Jianbing Yan Raman Babu Suketoshi TabaJiankang WangCosmos Magorokosho Bindiganavile S. Vivek

Page 52: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

Main Contents· Molecular Plant Breeding Tools: Markers and Maps· Molecular Plant Breeding Tools: Omics and Arrays· Populations in Genetics and Breeding · Plant Genetic Resources: Management, Evaluation and Enhancement · Molecular Dissection of Complex Traits: Theory · Molecular Dissection of Complex Traits: Practice · Marker Assisted Selection: Theory · Marker Assisted Selection: Practice · Genotype by Environment Interaction · Isolation and Functional Analysis of Genes · Gene Transfer and Genetically Modified Plants · Intellectual Property Rights and Plant Variety Protection · Breeding Informatics · Decision Support Tools 

HardbackPub Date: November 2009 ISBN: 9781845933920640 pages

Main DescriptionRecent advances in plant genomics and molecular biology have revolutionized our understanding of plant genetics, providing new opportunities for more efficient and controllable plant breeding. Successful techniques require a solid understanding of the underlying molecular biology as well as experience in applied plant breeding. Bridging the gap between developments in biotechnology and its applications in plant improvement, Molecular Plant Breeding provides an integrative overview of issues from basic theories to their applications to crop improvement including molecular marker technology, gene mapping, genetic transformation, quantitative genetics, and breeding methodology. 

ReadershipResearchers and students involved in plant breeding and plant biology 

Page 53: A Roadmap from the Genomics Revolution to a New Era in ... · Control LSSSSS b LS- large sample size; SS- Small sample size Control: no sampling Seedling establishment for seeds with

18 August 2009 16:00 - 17:00Social Sciences Seminar Room (G210) UWA (Hackett Entrance No. 1, Car Park 3 and 4)

Associate Prof Sven-Erik JacobsenDepartment of Agriculture and EcologyUniversity of Copenhagen, Denmark

Enquiries: (08) 6488 4717 Email: [email protected] Website: ioa.uwa.edu.au

Climate proof cropping systems and the potential for under-utilised species in the Mediterranean environment


Recommended