A sideways look into the proton
Transverse momentum and transverse spin in QCD
Alessandro Bacchetta
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
2/60
Outline
• Introduction• Transverse spin• Transverse momentum• Transverse spin and transverse
momentum• Factorization and hadron collisions• Conclusions
Introduction
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
4/60
Deep Inelastic Scattering - DIS
target proton
electron
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
5/60
Inclusive DIS
proton
lepton l
'l
tran
sver
se
longitudinal
( ) ( ) ( ) l p P l X
2 2 virtuality ( ' of pho o) t n l l Q2
2 ( ')
Q
xP l l
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
6/60
Semi-inclusive DIS (SIDIS)
proton
pion
transverse momentum of pionhP
hP lepton l
'l
( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) hl p P l h P X
2 2 virtuality ( ' of pho o) t n l l Q2
2 ( ')
Q
xP l l
( ')
hP P
zP l l
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
7/60
Vectors and angles involved
DIS
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
8/60
Vectors and angles involved
SIDIS
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
9/60
Transverse momentum effects
hP
SIDIS
Tq
Drell-Yan
TK
e-e+ to pions
TR
3-Dp-p to pions
Whenever we measure transverse-momentum effects, we need kT-factorization and we need transverse momentum dependent (or unintegrated) parton distributions
Collins, Soper, NPB 193 (81)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
10/60
Feynman diagrams & Factorization
proton
lepton lepton
pion
SIDIS
Partonic scattering amplitude
Fragmentation amplitude
Distribution amplitude
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
11/60
Feynman diagrams & Factorization
Partonic scattering amplitude
Fragmentation amplitude
Distribution amplitude
proton
lepton lepton
pion
SIDIS
electron
positron
pion
pion
e–e+ to pions
proton
proton lepton
antilepton
Drell-Yan
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
12/60
Feynman diagrams & Factorization
proton
lepton lepton
pion
SIDIS
proton
proton lepton
antilepton
Drell-Yan
proton
proton
pion
pion
p-p to pions
electron
positron
pion
pion
e–e+ to pions
??
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
13/60
Nonperturbative elements
2
,
0
[0 ]( ; ) , (0) ( ) ,2
i x Pij j i
dx S e P S P SU
,P S
k
=
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
14/60
Decomposition of the correlation function
1 1 5 1 5( ) ( )1
)2
(( ); Lq
Tq qf x g x h xx S S S
1
1
1
( )
(
(
)
( ) (
)
) )
(
(
)
q
q
qT
q x
q x
q x
f x
g x
q xh x
Unpolarized distr. func.
Helicity distr. func.
Transversity distr. func.
0(1 ), leading twistO Q
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
15/60
Longitudinal vs transverse momentum
target
parton
Tk
P
partonk
longk xP
photon
Long. view
long. spinphoton
Trans. view Photon moves into the screen/ proton moves out of the screen
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
16/60
Longitudinal vs transverse momentum
Tkpartonk
longk xP
photon
Long. view
trans. spinphoton
Trans. view Photon moves into the screen/ proton moves out of the screen
target
partonP
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
17/60
Probabilistic interpretation
( ) ( )qTh x q x 1
_
( ) ( )qf x q x 1
( ) ( )qg x q x 1_
Photon moves into the screen/ proton moves out of the screen
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
18/60
Decomposition of the correlation function UNintegrated over kT
12
1
21
2 ( , )1
( , ( , ))2
..( , ) .
qT T
qT
qT
T T TT
T
f x kS k
x kM
ki
Mh
k
k
f x
x
Boer-Mulders
Sivers
Sivers, PRD 43 (91)
Boer, Mulders, PRD 57 (98)
Mulders, Tangerman, NPB 461 (96)Goeke, Metz, Schlegel, PLB 618 (05)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
19/60
Probabilistic interpretation
-Sivers
-Boer-Mulders
Photon moves into the screen/ proton moves out of the screen
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
20/60
Unpolarized distribution functions q(x)
ZEUS Coll, EPJ C42 (05)
7 groups are working on the extraction of these PDFs (see www-spires.dur.ac.uk/hepdata/pdf.html)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
21/60
Helicity distribution function q(x)
AAC, Hirai et al. PRD69 (04)
6 groups are working on the extraction of these PDFs (see www-spires.dur.ac.uk/hepdata/pdf.html)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
22/60
• What about the transverse spin distribution h1(x) ?
• What about the transverse momentum dependence, e.g. f1(x,kT
2)?
Transverse spin
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
24/60
Transversity in SIDIS
12
12(... sin( ) ( , ) ., .) .T h S TTh x pd S H z k
see e.g. A.B., Diehl, Goeke, Metz, Mulders, Schlegel, JHEP 0702,093
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
25/60
Data from Hermes and Compass
HERMES, hep-ex/0507013
HERMES, PRL 94 (05)
COMPASS, NPB 765 (07)
COMPASS, PRL 94 (05)
PROTON DEUTERON
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
26/60
Data from BELLE
BELLE, PRL 96 (06)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
27/60
First extraction of transversity
Anselmino et al., PRD 75, 054032 (07)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
28/60
Comparison with some models
[1] Soffer et al. PRD 65 (02)
[2] Korotkov et al. EPJC 18 (01)
[3] Schweitzer et al., PRD 64 (01)
[4] Wakamatsu, PLB 509 (01)
[5] Pasquini et al., PRD 72 (05)
[6] Anselmino et al., PRD 75 (07)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
29/60
Tensor charge from Lattice QCD
1 1
1 1
( ) 0.84, ( ) 0.64,
( ) 0.23, ( ) 0.35
u u
d d
u h x dx u g x dx
d h x dx d g x dx
S. Aoki et al., PRD 56 (1997)M. Göckeler et al. [QCDSF/UKQCD], PLB (05)
Compared to axial charge
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
30/60
Comparison of tensor charges
Barone, Drago, Ratcliffe, PR 359 (2002)
lattice
quark soliton 1
spectator
bag
quark soliton 2
quark
non-relativistic
2.4 GeV2
0.3 GeV2
Wakamatsu, 0705.2917[hep-ph]
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
31/60
Evolution equations
Barone, Drago, Ratcliffe, PR 359 (2002)
Hayashigaki, Kanazawa, Koike, PRD56 (97)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
32/60
Other observables
12
12(... sin( ) ( , ) ., .) .T h S TTh x pd S H z k
Efremov, Mankiewicz, Tornquist, PLB 284 (92)Collins, Heppelmann, Ladinsky, NPB 420 (94)Jaffe, Jin, Tang, PRL 80 (98)
12
1(... sin( ) ( , , ) .) ..T h R h xd S H z M
Dihadron fragmentation
11 1 212 ( )... ( ) ...T Td S h xS h x
Doubly polarized Drell-YanRalston, Soper, NPB 152 (79)
Transverse momentum
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
34/60
Semi-inclusive DIS
proton
pion
l p l X 2 2 virtuality of p( ') hotonl l Q
transverse momentum of pionhP
hP lepton l
'l
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
35/60
Example of model calculation
diquarkproton
quark
(GeV)xk
yk
21 ( , )q
Tf x k
0.5x
(GeV)xk
yk
21 ( , )q
Tf x k
0.01x
2 20.13 GeVTk 2 20.48 GeVTk
Jakob, Mulders, Rodrigues, NPA 626 (1997)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
36/60
Example of a measurement
H1 Coll, NPB485(97)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
37/60
Transverse momentum distribution
q
q
h
intrinsic
pQCD
Koike, Nagashima, Vogelsang, NPB744 (06)
fragmentation
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
38/60
Differences between flavors?
(GeV)xk (GeV)xk
yk yk
21 ( )u
Tf k 21 ( ) 2d
Tf k x
ud diquarkproton
u
uu diquarkproton
d
Assuming ud uuM M
Up and down quark can have different
transverse momentum distributions
Transverse momentum and transverse spin
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
40/60
right
left
lepton l
'l
Semi-inclusive Deep Inelastic Scattering
proton
pion
l p l X
R L
R L
N N
N N
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
41/60
Measured asymmetries in DIS
HERMES Coll, hep-ex/0507013
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
42/60
Parton distribution functions with transverse spin
-Sivers
-Boer-Mulders
-Transversity
Photon moves into the screen/ proton moves out of the screen
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
43/60
right
left
Chromodynamic lensing
proton
quarks
Long. view Trans. view
Burkardt, PRD 66 (02)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
44/60
right
left
Chromodynamic lensing
photon
Long. view Trans. view
NOTE: QCD tells us that the FSI has to be attractive, since quark and remnants form a color antisymmetric state
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
45/60
right
left
Chromodynamic lensing
photon
Long. view Trans. view
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
46/60
right
left
Distortions in transverse space
proton
quarks
Long. view Trans. view
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
47/60
right
left
Distortions in transverse space
proton
quarks
Long. view Trans. view
A distortion in the distribution of quarks in transverse space can give rise to a nonzero Sivers function
The presence of spin can distort the distribution of quarks in transverse space (orbital angular momentum of quarks is required)
Spin-orbit correlations
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
48/60
Results from Lattice QCD
QCDSF/UKQCD Collab. (see e.g. hep-ph/05110032)
Sivers function expected to be:
•NEGATIVE for up quarks
•POSITIVE for down quarks
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
49/60
Data from Hermes and Compass
HERMES, hep-ex/0507013
HERMES, PRL 94 (05)COMPASS, PRL 94 (05)
PROTON
DEUTERON
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
50/60
Different fits
Anselmino et al., hep-ph/0511017
[20] Anselmino et al., PRD72 (05)
[21] Vogelsang, Yuan, PRD72 (05)
[23] Collins et al., hep-ph/0510342
Factorization and hadron-hadron
collisions
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
52/60
Feynman diagrams & Factorization
proton
lepton lepton
pion
SIDIS
proton
proton lepton
antilepton
Drell-Yan
proton
proton
pion
pion
p-p to pions
electron
positron
pion
pion
e–e+ to pions
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
53/60
right
left
Sivers effect in SIDIS
proton
quarks
Long. view Trans. view
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
54/60
right
left
Sivers effect in Drell-Yan
proton
Long. view Trans. view
photon
antiquark
The Sivers effect gets an extra minus sign due to the difference between initial and final state interactions. Impossible to predict
it in parton model.
Clear-cut prediction of QCD Collins, PLB 536 (02)
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
55/60
Final/initial state interactions
SIDIS
q
q
q
q
pp to hadrons
A.B., Bomhof, Mulders, Pijlman, hep-ph/0505268
Drell-Yan
q
q
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
56/60
kT -factorization is broken
My personal opinion: what is shown by Collins and Qiu is not sufficient to make such a statement. Maybe new concepts (i.e. “advanced” factorization and “generalized” universality) can work. Bomhof, Mulders, Pijlman, PLB596
A.B., Bomhof, Mulders, Pijlman, PRD72
Is kT -factorization broken ?
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
57/60
An example
jet atRHICp p X
A.B., D’Alesio, Bomhof, Mulders, Murgia, hep-ph/0703153
“Standard” factorization & universality
“Generalized” factorization & universality
Broken factorization?
Alessandro Bacchetta A sideways look at the proton
58/60
Conclusions
• Transverse spin and transverse momentum observables uncover a new dimension of the structure of the nucleon
• Intense progress is taking place both from the theoretical and experimental point of view
• Impact also on hadron colliders and unpolarized physics