PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
765
A STUDY OF OPEN COAST TIDAL FLAT SEDIMENTOLOGY BASED ON
OUTCROP DATA IN NGRAYONG FORMATION, KADIWONO AREA, CENTRAL
JAVA
Rifqi Zakaria1*, Rian Cahya Romana2, Rivandi Taufik1, Tara Shinta Dewi2, Putri Ramadhina3 1Dept. of Geology, UPN “Veteran” Yogyakarta
2GeoPangea Research Group (GPRG) 3Sedimentology Lab, UPN “Veteran” Yogyakarta
*Email : [email protected]
SARI
This study employs sedimentological analysis and basic principles of sequence stratigraphy to correlate
sedimentary log and try to reveal the sedimentology of open coast tidal flat outcrop in Middle Miocene
Ngrayong Formation, Kadiwono Area, Blora Regency, Central Java. Open coast tidal flat is unique
system in its wave and tide dominated physical setting.Ngrayong Formation deposited in North East
Java Basin and one of the giant reservoir in Indonesia. In the study area, Middle Miocene Ngrayong
Formation with the thickness >400 meter which is dominated by sandstone, siltstone, and claystone.
Based on the physical aspects, such as lithology, texture and sedimentary structure in the field, there
are 12lithofacies. These lithofacies is spread in the 4 facies association, there are mud flat, mixed flat,
sand flat and subtidal flat. Mud flat is dominated by fine grain (mud) which is showed the low energy
that affect to the depositional of mud flat. Mixed flat are composed by mud and sand, that is happened
because of medium tide level, therefore that founded a contact between sandstones and mudstone, which
is interpreted as flooding surface. Sand flat is dominated by sand, but there is a few layer of mud. Lateral
accretion is often occurring in sand flat, the evidence is the domination of planar and trough cross
stratification. In the subtidal flat, lateral accretion is also occurring, and hummocky cross stratification
is constructed because of the influence of sea waves. Moreover, there are limestone which is interpreted
as a sequence boundary type 2 the product of transgressive surface deposits.
Keywords: Ngrayong Formation, Tidal Flat, Sedimentology, Stratigraphy.
I. INTRODUCTION
Ngrayong Formation is part of North East
Java Basin in the Rembang Zone. This
formation is commonly deposited with
progradingfluvio-deltaic lowstand system
and shallow-marine systems (Johnstone et.
al., 2006) and composed by interbedded of
quartz sandstone with claystone, siltstone,
lignite, and bioclastic limestone
(Pringgoprawiro and Sukido, 1992).
Furthermore, Ngrayong Formation is one of
the potential oil reservoir in Northe East Java
Basin, this can be seen from Ngrayong quartz
sandstone that has a good porosity and
permeability.
The purpose of this research is to employs
sedimentological analysis and basic
principles of sequence stratigraphy to
correlate sedimentary log and try to reveal the
sedimentology of open coast tidal flat outcrop
by integrating of all data fields that have been
investigated by researcher.
II. REGIONAL GEOLOGICAL
SETTING
North East Java Basin stretches from West to
East from Semarang to Surabaya 250 km
(width of 60-70 km). Tectonic phase in North
East Java Basin are divided into 4 phase. The
first phase happened during Tertiary to Early
Oligocene, where Ngimbang Formation and
Kujung Formation are deposited. In this
phase the work force is predominantly
extensional force and this force formed fore
arc basin. The second stage happened during
Middle Oligocene to Late Miocene. In this
phase, Hindia plate subducted to Java Island.
This oblique subduction forming folds and
faults that trend to Northeast-Southwest
(Meratus pattern). Fore arc basin has entered
a phase of sagging-inverse and at this time,
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
766
Prupuh Formation, Tawun Formation,
Ngrayong Formation, Bulu Formation,
Wonocolo Formation and Ledok Formation
are deposited. Top notch sea level at this
stage is relatively regression and
progradational occurs. This caused changes
in facies
Laterally towards the ground to the north.
This matter evidenced by the changes in
facies of limestone (Prupuh Formation) to
sandstone, mudstone mineral-rich glauconite
(Ngrayong Formation and Ledok Formation).
Sandstone is likely deposited in delta. The
third phase occured in the Late Miocene to
Early Pleistocene. In this phase, transgression
occured which caused the sea level rise
relatively which Mundu Formation, Paciran
Formation, Selorejo Formation and Lidah
Formation deposited. In the fourth phase
occured during Late Pleistocene to Holocene.
In this phase, subductionHindia Plate formed
structures that trend East-West. This
subduction caused partial melting, and
occured volcanism in south Rembang Zone
(Figure 1).
Ngrayong Formation is composed by
interbedded of quartz sandstone with
claystone, siltstone, lignite, and bioclastic
limestone. This formation deposited on
shallow marine and progradely the
depositional environment change into
lagoonal to Outer Sublitoral. The thickness of
Ngrayong Formation up to 900 meters, and
this formation is one of the potential oil
reservoir.
III. DATA & METHODS
Methods in this research are divided into
three stage.
The first stage is observation stage. Primary
data acquired from observation including
field orientation, rock description along with
rock sampling, and measuring section.
The second stage is analysis. Various analysis
has been done with petrographic analysis,
microfossil analysis, and measuring section
analysis.
The last stage is interpretation for all data that
has been analyzed. The researcher employs
sedimentological analysis and basic
principles of sequence stratigraphy to
correlate sedimentary log and interprete the
sedimentology of open coast tidal flat
outcrop.
IV. DEPOSITIONAL
ENVIRONTMENT ANALYSIS
a. Lithofacies
Lithofacies defined as subdivisions of a
sedimentary sequence based on lithology,
grain size, physical and biogenic sedimentary
structures, and stratification that bear a direct
relationship to the depositional processes that
produced them. Lithofacies and lithofacies
associations (groups of related lithofacies)
are the basic units for the interpretation of
depositional environments.
As the identifying of depositional
environment analysis, there are 12 lithofacies
of object study of Ngrayong Formation that
was observed ;
1. Parallel lamination claystone (Clm)
This consist of grey to brownish claystone
with 10 – 20 cm of thickness. In several
place of outcrops, this unit consists of
siderite noduls. Parallel lamination was
observed as sedimentary structures. This
unit associates with lenticular bedding
claystone and flasher bedding
sandstone.This unit was deposited by
effect of lower energy current or with lack
of mud concentration while depositional
process by suspension current.
2. Lenticular Bedding Claystone (Cln)
Grey to brownish claystone and lens of
fine grain sandstone with 40 cm of
thickness dominated this unit. Lenticular
bedding was observed as sedimentary
structures. This unit associates with
lenticular bedding siltstone.The
comprising of claystone and fine grain
sandstone in this unit indicated that this
unit was deposited by decreasing energy
current which affect of tidal process.
Therefore, fine grain sandstone stuck
inside of claystone which called as
lenticular bedding sedimentary structure.
This sedimentary structure is produced in
the environment which depositional
condition and preservation of mud was
more than sand.
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
767
3. Parallel lamination Siltstone (Llm)
This consist of brownish siltstone with
parallel lamination of sedimentary
structure and 20- 40 cm of thickness. This
unit associates with lencicular bedding
siltstone. This unit was deposited by effect
of lower energy current or with lack of
mud concentration while depositional
process by suspension current.
4. Lenticular bedding siltstone (Lln)
Brownish siltstone and lens of fine grain
sandtone with 40 – 100 of thickness
dominated this unit. Lenticular bedding
was observed as sedimentary structures.
This unit associates with parallel
lamination siltstone.The comprising of
siltstone and fine grain sandstone in this
unit indicated that this unit was deposited
by decreasing energy current which affect
of tidal process. Therefore, fine grain
sandstone stuck inside of siltstone which
called as lenticular bedding sedimentary
structure. This sedimentary structure is
produced in the environment which
depositional condition and preservation of
mud was more than sand.
5. Flasher Bedding Sandstone (Sfl)
This consist of very fine grain to fine grain
brownish sandstone that were dominate
composed by quartz and k-feldspar.
Sediment structure was identified as
flasher bedding with dominated by
sandstone and lens of siltstone to
claystone. This unit has 50 – 100 cm of
thickness and associates with wavy
lamination sandstone and planar cross-
bedding sandstone.This unit can be
formed by lower energy of suspension and
traction mechanism with fluctuative
hydraulic condition.
6. Hummocky Cross-Stratification
Sandstone (Shc)
This consist of medium grain brownish
sandstone. The characteristic of this
sandstone are subrounded – rounded of
grain, well sorted, composed by quartz
and k-feldspar minerals, hummocky
cross-stractification of sedimentary
structure. This unit has 100 cm of
thickness and associates with planar cross-
bedding sandstone.This unit is formed by
wave and storm activities which can be
made by combination of unidirectional
current that linked of storm activity.
7. Parallel Lamination Sandstone (Slm)
This consist of brownish very fine grain
sandstone that were dominate composed
by quartz and k-feldspar. Sediment
structure was identified as parallel
lamination. This unit has 40 cm of
thickness and associates with lencticular
bedding siltstone and wavy lamination
sandstone. This unit is formed by high
energy depositional current as upper
plane-bed phase lamination and by low
energy depositional current as lower
plane-bed phase lamination.
8. Planar Cross-Bedding Sandstone (Spc)
This consist of fine to coarse grain
sandstone. The characteristics of this unit
are brownish of colour, subrounded to
rounded of grain, well sorted,composed
by quartz and k-feldspar minerals, planar
cross-bedding of sedimentary structure.
This unit has 30-100 cm of thickness and
associates with planar stratified sandstone,
hummocky cross-stratification sandstone,
trough cross-bedding sandstone, and
flasher bedding sandstone.
Cross-bedding is formed by the
downstream migration of bedforms such
as ripples or dunes in a flowing fluid. The
fluid flow causes sand grains to saltate up
the upstream ("stoss") side of the bedform
and collect at the peak until the angle of
repose is reached. At this point, the crest
of granular material has grown too large
and will be overcome by the force of the
depositing fluid, falling down the
downstream ("lee") side of the dune.
Repeated avalanches will eventually form
the sedimentary structure known as cross-
bedding, with the structure dipping in the
direction of the paleocurrent.
9. Planar Stratified Sandstone (Ss)
This consist of fine to coarse grain
sandstone. The characteristics of this unit
are brownish of colour, composed by
quartz and k-feldspar minerals,and
parallel lamination of sedimentary
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
768
structure. This unit has 30-100 cm of
thickness and associates with planar
stratified packstone and planar cross-
bedding sandstone.This unit is formed by
high energy depositional current as upper
plane-bed phase lamination and by low
energy depositional current as lower
plane-bed phase lamination.The
association with planar cross-bedding
sandstone identified that there was
increasing of current velocity which
planar stratified sandstone facies eroded
planar cross-bedding sandstone facies that
early formed.
10. Trough Cross-Bedding Sandstone (Stc)
This consist of coarse grain sandstone.
The characteristics of this unit are
brownish of colour, subrounded to
rounded of grain, well sorted, composed
by quartz and k-feldspar minerals, trough
cross-bedding of sedimentary structure.
This unit has 60 cm of thickness and
associates with planar stratified sandstone.
11. Wavy Lamination Sandstone (Sw)
This consist of fine to coarse grain
sandstone. The characteristics of this unit
are brownish of colour, composed by
quartz and k-feldspar minerals,and wavy
lamination of sedimentary structure. This
unit has 40 cm of thickness and associates
with flasher bedding sandstone and
parallel lamination sandstone.
This unit is formed by the process in quiet
water current. Fine grain sediment is
deposited by traction transported while
depositional process of ripple is formed
which alternately change to quiet period
for mud deposit.
12. Planar Stratified Packstone (Ps)
This consist of calcarenite which has
characteristic white colour, poor sorted,
dominated by skeletal, and planar
stratified of sedimentary structure. This
unit has 30 cm of thickness and associates
with planar stratified sandstone.This unit
can be formed by high energy depositional
current as upper plane (flat) bed. Existing
of skeletal of this unit identified that the
depositional procces formed by high
energy current which formed planar
stratified of sedimentary structure. This
unit occur as sequence boundary (sb)
b. Facies Association
Facies Association is a combination of two or
more lithofacies that forms the body of rock
in a variety of scales and combinations that
are genetically interconnected in the
depositional environment. Facies association
reflects the depositional environment or
fasies process whereby fasies were formed
(Mutti Ricci Luchi, 1972). In the
determination of facies association and
depositional facies of the Ngrayong
formation, the author refers to the tidal flat
depositional facies models that have been
created by the Boggs (1995), Dalrymple
(1992) and the model of the open coast tidal
flats by Kim et al (1999); The et al (2006b),
in Fan Daidu (2012). (Figure 4)
From the results of the analysis on the
Ngrayong sandstone unitsfasies, the
faciessssociationNgrayong Formation in the
study area is divided into four facies
associations, namely:
1. Mudflat
The suspension occurs frequently, thus
producing facies association Clm and Llm.
The influence of tidal (wave fluctuations)
with a constant low energy formed lenticular
bedding of sedimentary structure which is the
facies Association of Cln and Lln.
2. Mixed Flat
Faices association of Sfl, Sw, Lln, Llm and
Slm are on this zone. Current activity eroded
the ripple crest sediment which formed first,
that causing the rippled sand recently buried
and preserved layers of ripple with mud
which formed flasher bedding. When the
current activity increases will form Sw (wavy
lamination) facies which still preserve a layer
of mud between SW facies. While on the
conditions of deposition and preservation of
mud is larger than sand, it will make the sand
stuck between silt (lens of sandstone) and will
form Llnfacies.
3. Sand Flat
SPC Facies is formed by migration of ripple
and dune which effect by a current that is
formed during lower flow regime conditions
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
769
(lower flow regime). In other conditions, it
can also be formed during the process of
erosional and scour which will form trough
cross-bedding of sedimentary structure
(Stcfasies).
4. Subtidal Flat
This zone formed Spcfacies which associate
with Ssfacies. It occurs because Ssfacies
formed when the speed of the current
increases, and forms the upper plane (flat)
bed) which eroding Spc (Sand dune waves)
facies which earlier formed. Because of this
zone is affected by ocean waves, it will form
deposits of storm (Shcfacies). PC facies is the
last facies which is formed when the speed of
the current is increasing that bringing with
many of skeletal sediment that preserve into
the layers.
c. Architectural-Element
Architectural element is a large of facies
association which group of facies association
in the system of depositional environment
(Allen, 1983 in walker, 1992). In the
development of the relation of facies
association, the definition of architectural
elements is a morphology from the specific
depositional system characterized by
grouping of facies,facies geometry, and the
process of deposition.
As we know that, facies association in study
area of Ngrayong formation are divided into
4 groups namely mudflat, mixed flat, sand
flat in intertidal and subtidal flat.
Mud flat is a part of the intertidal at tidal flats.
In the intertidal, mud flat is a part that has
high rate of tidal wave. Facies that contains in
the mudflat is Clm, Cln, LlmdanLln. The
thickness of the mud flat association on the
study area was
RCR-1: > 3.14 m
RCR-2: > 2.48 m,
RCR-3: > 3.66 m
RCR-4: > 1.71 m
Changes of the sediment mud flat to mixed
flat was characterized by a relatively
coarsening upward sequence. This occurs
because the sea level relatively increase (HST
phase) and produce a retrograding mud to
mixed flat.
Mixed flat is a part of intertidal at tidal flats
which has a medium tide level. This can be
explained by the presence of granules 2
mixing mud (clay-silt) and sand which is
evidenced by the presence of faciesLln, Llm,
Slm, Sfl and Sw. The thickness of the mixed
flat association on the study area was
RCR-1: 3.14 m,
RCR-2: 2.83 m,
RCR-3: 3 m
RCR-4: 2.92 m
Changes of the sediment mixed to flat sand
flats, characterized by a relatively coarsening
upward sequence. This occurs because the
sea level relatively increase (phase HST) and
formed retrograding Sand flats. In this zone
there was contact between the sandstones
with claystone, which is interpreted as
flooding surface (FS), which was used as one
of the datum in the facies correlation of tidal
deposit in the study area.
Sand flats is a part of intertidal at tidal flats
which has a medium – low tide level. Sand is
dominating of the granules in this part
although there is little inserts a layer of mud
(Sflfcies). On the sand flats of this activity the
suspension have been very rare, whereas
lateral accretion of a lot going on. Evidence
of the presence of lateral accretion is Spc and
Stcfacies. The thickness of the sand flat
association on the study area was
RCR-1: 3.29 m,
RCR-2: 3.21 m,
RCR-3: 3.52 m,
RCR-4: 3.78 m.
Changes of the sediment mixed to flat sand
flats was also characterized by a relatively
coarsening upward sequence. This occurs
because the sea level relatively increase
(phase HST) and there was a lateral accretion
which caused of forming retrograding
Subtidal flat.
Subtidal flat is a part of tidal flat which has a
low tide level. In this zone the process was
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
770
strongly influenced sedimentation of sea
waves,which were no longer influenced by
the tides (tidal). There were occur many of
lateral accretion. Because of greatly
influenced the waves of sea water,it formed
Shcfasies which were formed because of the
existence of a combination of direct current
or the existence of the storm. The other of
facies association are Ss, Spc and Pc facies.
Pc facies occurs as a contact of sequence
boundary type 2 and as a result of
transgressive surface deposits. This sequence
boundary type 2 is characterized by a
minimum of erosion on the contact between
the Pc and Ssfacies which in this phase of the
environmental change because the sea level is
relatively increase (TS) which can be formed
the limestone (Pc fasies) that covering sand
facies below.
The thickness of the subtidal flat association
on the study area was
RCR-1: 4.19 m,
RCR-2: 6.6 m,
RCR-3: 6.6 m,
RCR-4: 6.42 m.
V. CONCLUSIONS
There are 12 lithofacies at study area,
namely Parallel lamination claystone
(Clm), Lenticular Bedding Claystone
(Cln), Parallel lamination Siltstone
(Llm), Lenticular bedding siltstone (Lln),
Flasher Bedding Sandstone (Sfl),
Hummocky Cross-Stratification
Sandstone (Shc), Parallel Lamination
Sandstone (Slm), Planar Cross-Bedding
Sandstone (Spc), Planar Stratified
Sandstone (Ss), Trough Cross-Bedding
Sandstone (Stc), Wavy Lamination
Sandstone (Sw) and Planar Stratified
Packstone (Ps).
12 lithofacies that interpreted at study
area divided into 4 facies association,
namely Mud Flat (Clm, Cln, Llm and
Lmnfacies), Mixed Flat (Clm, Lmn,
SflSlm, and Swfacies), Sand Flat (Sfl,
Spc, and Stcfacies) and Subtidal Flat
(Shc, Spc, Ss, and Ps facies).
Mud flat is dominated by fine grain
(mud) which is showed the low energy
that affect to the depositional of mud flat.
Mixed flat are composed by mud and
sand, that is happened because of
medium tide level, therefore that founded
a contact between sandstones and
mudstone, which is interpreted as
flooding surface (FS). Sand flat is
dominated by sand, but there is a few
layer of mud. Lateral accretion is often
occurring in sand flat, the evidence is the
domination of planar and trough cross
bedding sedimentary structures. In the
subtidal flat, lateral accretion is also
occurring, and hummocky cross
stratification structure is constructed
because of the influence of sea waves.
VI. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
We would to thank all Seminar
NasionalKebumian UGM committee for
publishing this paper, and Ir. Sugeng Widada,
M.Sc, and Ir. BambangTriwibowo, M.T, and
also all of GPRG Indonesia member for
valuable discussion.
REFERENCES
Ardhana, W. 1993, A Depositional Model For The Early Middle Miocene Ngrayong Formation And
Implications For Exploration In The East Java Basin,Proceedings Indonesian Petroleum
Association.
Boggs, S.,1987, Principles of Sedimentary and Stratigraphy, Merril Publishing Company, a Bdl and
Howel Company, Columbus, Ohio.
Daidu, Fan. 2012. Classifications, sedimentary features and facies associations of tidal flats. Journal of
Palaeogeography. Volume 2, Issue 1, January 2013, Pages 66–80.
Davis, Jr, Richard A and Dalrymple, Robert W, 2012, Principles of Tidal Sedimentology, Springer
Dordrecht Heidelberg London New York.
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
771
Mutti, E., and F. Ricci Lucchi, 1972, Turbidites of the northern Apennines: Introduction to facies
analysis (English translation by T.H. Nilson, 1978): International Geology Review, v. 20, p.
125-166.
Selley, R.C.,1970, Ancient Sedimentary Environment and their sub-surface diagnosis, Cornell
University Press, Ithaca, New York.
Sribudiyani, Muchsin N, Ryacudu R, Kunto T, Astono P, Prasetya I, Benyamin S, Asikin S,
HarsolumaksoAgus H, Yulianto I, 2003, The Collision Of The EastJava Microplate And Its
Implication For Hydrocarbon Occurrences In TheEast Java Basin, Proceedings Indonesian
Petroleum Association.
Walker,R.G.,James,N.P.,1992, Facies Models Response to Sea Level Change,Geological Association
of Canada.
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
772
FIGURES
Figure 1. The correlation between tectonic and stratigraphy at North East Java Basin (Sribudiyani et
al, 2003)
Figure 2. Work flow of study area
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
773
Figure 3. Several outcrops of lithofacies in the study area
Figures 4. Profile of Ngrayong sands groups in Sendangharjo with the depositional facies models
(without scale)
PROCEEDING, SEMINAR NASIONAL KEBUMIAN KE-9 PERAN PENELITIAN ILMU KEBUMIAN DALAM PEMBERDAYAAN MASYARAKAT
6 - 7 OKTOBER 2016; GRHA SABHA PRAMANA
774
Figure 5. Interpretation of facies model in the study area based on tidal flat model (Darlrymple, 1992
with modified)
Figure 6. Depositional facies correlation and architectural elements of tidal flat deposit at study area