A Study on the Flower Sellers of Choolaimedu -Aruna v N

8/8/2019 A Study on the Flower Sellers of Choolaimedu -Aruna v N

1/30

A STUDY ON THE

FLOWER SELLERS OFCHOOLAIMEDU

AN EXPLORATORY NARRATIVE REPORT

Aruna V N

PGPBA

IGTC CHENNAI

A BRIEF STUDY ON THE FINANCIAL AND BUSINESS ASPECTS OF FLOWER SELLERS

AND TO UNDERSTAND HOW MICRO FINANCE CAN PLAY A ROLE IN THEIR LIVES


2/30


3/30

A study on the flower sellers of Choolaimedu Aruna V N, IGTC Chennai

7.3 Matt Duncan: ..................................................................................................................21

8. Money matters: .....................................................................................................................22

8.1.1 A simple income statement of the flower sellers: .......................................................22

8.1.2 Money lenders Vs MFI ............................................................................................... 23

9. Observations: ........................................................................................................................24

9.1 Demographic aspects: .................................................................................................... 24

9.2 Business aspect: ..............................................................................................................25

9.3 Financial aspect: .............................................................................................................26

10. Scope for further study .......................................................................................................27

Appendix 1: ..............................................................................................................................28

Appendix 2: ..............................................................................................................................29

Page 3 of30

1st November, 2010


4/30


Abstract

This report aims at understanding how flower sellers manage their business and the modes

and terms of credit preferred by them to sustain their business and the livelihood.

For this study, the area covered was the entire stretch of Shanmuganar Salai and the

Choolaimedu High road over a period of 2 days (21st and 22nd of October 2010). 20 flower

sellers were interviewed mainly about their background and their business. Focus was on

how they manage their finances.

Also included in this report are insights from 3 others who are a part of the world of micro

finance Mr Matt Duncan of the Grameen foundation, Ms Rebecca, centre leader of Equitas

in Choolaimedu and Mr Viswanathan, a local money lender.

The report is an exploratory narrative research and is qualitative in nature.

Page 4 of30

1st November, 2010


5/30


1. Introduction:The two things that an average Indian buys on an everyday basis are vegetables and flowers.

Not bouquets or fancy bunches of flowers but long strings of fragrant flowers. Flowers are

an integral part of our daily lives, especially to Hindus who consider them as a superior form

of offering to God.

It was an anathema for the Tamilians, even 40 years ago, if the unmarried and married

women did not wear flowers in their hair. Now, even if they dont adorn their hair with

flowers, the Indians make sure that they adorn the pictures of their Gods with flowers.

Flowers here not only symbolises love, but also worship and respect.

Every household interacts with a flower seller on a daily basis and this proximity is the key

inspiration to conduct an exploratory study on the way of life of these people. In a city that

boasts of dozens of flower sellers in every major street, their sheer number and their nature of

their business is apt for an exploratory study on micro finance.

How do these flower sellers run their shop? What made them get into this business? How do

they manage their finances? What kind of a role can MFIs play in the lives of these women?

These are some of the questions for which this study seeks an answer.

2. Objective:To conduct an exploratory narrative research on the flower sellers of Choolaimedu to

understand about

Their demographic background

Nature of business

Financial aspects of their life and business

The sampling method used for this study is snowball sampling.

3. The flower sellers of Choolaimedu:Of the 20 flower sellers that the researcher had interacted with, 19 of them are illiterate with

only one woman who has studied till 8th standard. The flower sellers buy flowers in bulk from

either the Koyambedu flower market or the Parrys market. (17 of the 20 buy from

Koyambedu and the rest from Parrys). They buy flowers every day, early in the morning.

Typically, the sell flowers for 4 hours in the morning and 4 hours in the evening.

Apart from buying flowers, the other expenses that they incur for the business include travel

fare, which ranges anywhere between Rs 30 to Rs 40 per day, depending on whether they

Page 5 of30

1st November, 2010


6/30


take the share auto, deluxe bus or the regular low fare bus. At Rs 10 per bundle, the flower

sellers spend Rs 20 per day for the thread in which they tie the flowers.

Another important aspect of the business is the concept of delivering flowers to the houses of

some regular customers. 12 of the 20 flower sellers do flower delivery to houses and they

collect money from the customers at the end of the month. On an average, this amounts to Rs

1000 to Rs 2000, which varies depending upon the quantity purchased. Collecting the money

on the monthly basis helps them to meet the beginning of the month expenses such as rent,

milk, grocery expenses etc.

There seems to be no association or any informal body which brings together the flower

sellers of Choolaimedu. Each seller operates independently and new comers dont find it very

difficult to set shop as there is no collective opposition from the existing flower sellers.

Making a profit in this business is a gamble, as they deal with perishable goods, which is of

no use at the end of the day. The flowers that are not sold are usually given to a nearby

temple or go to the dustbin.

4. Limitations of the study:

In this study, only the flower sellers in the Shanmuganar Salai and Choolaimedu high

road were interviewed

The figures quoted for capital investment and profits made are the ballpark sum that

were told by the flower sellers and the researcher had no way of verifying it

The same goes for the amount of money that they borrowed from the money lender.

The flower sellers have the habit of constantly taking a new loan as soon as an old one

is paid off and there is no way to know the total amount that they have borrowed

The flower sellers, being illiterate, were able to throw little light in the name of the

self help group of which they were/are a member. They joined the SHG based on peer

recommendation and in many cases, the group leader being known to them

personally.

A case by case description of the flower sellers are given below.

5. Case studies

5.1. Vasantha:

Vasantha The flower seller, who doesnt know how to tie

the flowers, was the first flower seller the researcher

encountered. Born and brought up in Chennai, she was into

a host of other jobs a house maid, distributing milk packets

etc before settling into the business of flower selling. Whenasked about what made her get into the business, she simply

Page 6 of30

1st November, 2010


7/30


stated that it was old age. 10 years ago, she started selling flowers as her health started failing

and hence, could no longer do hard physical labour. Getting into this business was a little

easy as her aunt and her nieces are already into this business, which provided her with a

decent exposure to the business of flower selling. With her savings as the capital, she started

this shop.

With 2 handicapped sons, this uneducated lady does her best to support the family to make

the ends meet. One son has a fruit shop nearby and another is an auto driver. With the help of

her sons, who sometimes go and buy flowers from the market and her daughters in law who

distributes flowers to the door steps of the customers, she manages this shop which she has

been running for 10 years.

On a small table that is buckling under the weight of flowers worth Rs 500-1000, she runs the

shop. And as she doesnt know how to tie the flowers, she outsources it to another lady to

whom she pays Rs 100 per day. Each day, she makes a profit at the range of Rs 100 to Rs

200. This amount notwithstanding, she regularly borrows money from the local money lender

to meet her household expenses. To the money lender, she pays an amount of Rs 50 or 100

per day, depending upon how much money she has borrowed.

When asked about her awareness about MFI, she proudly told the story of how she managed

to get a loan of Rs 10,000 from Mahasemam recently inspite of her being 58 years old. I

gave them a photo of mine that was taken 8 years ago. In that I look 50 years old and thus

managed to get a loan. If I told them that I am 58, they wont give me a loan. She giggles.

Her daughter in law has also got a loan of Rs 10,000 from Mahasemam. For this loan, she has

to make a fortnightly payment of Rs 250 for one year. She came to know about Mahasemamthrough her friends. However, she feels that SHGs are not for her as the procedures involved

are not transparent enough for her to understand.

Content with the shop, she has no further plans for expansion or generating more income. All

that worries her now is her 6 year old grandson who has undergone an eye surgery.

5.2 Kannama.S:

Soft spoken uneducated Kannama was

watching curiously when I was speaking

with Vasantha. Kannama and Vasanthahave their shops right next to each other

and they whispered slyly as how the other

persons business was affecting them. Her

voice is barely audible and her daughter

Kalpana came to my rescue by amplifying

what her mother spoke. The former Vellore

born vegetable vendor had come to

Chennai 40 years back and shifted to

flower selling business 5 years back as she

could no longer lift heavy basket of

Page 7 of30

1st November, 2010


8/30


vegetables. The 60 year old Kannama has 4 sons and a daughter. She buys flowers everyday

for Rs 1000 and makes a profit of Rs 100 to Rs 150 per day. Kannama is lucky to have the

support of her daughter in tying flowers and distributing it to customers houses. Also, her 4

sons and her husband pitch in to help her buying flowers from the market. Inspite of the help

from her daughter, she outsources flower tying to a third party as she doesnt know how to tieflowers.

Totally unaware of MFIs and SHGs, Kannama prefers borrowing money from the money

lender. She gets the loan to meet her other expenses and has no intention of expanding the

shop further to generate more income. Taking care of a shop of this size by itself keeps me

busy. If I expand, I will only end up making a loss says Kannama.

It was interesting to note that Kannama is unaware of MFI when her next shop neighbour has

gone to the extent of circumventing Mahasemams policy of not lending out money to people

above the age of 50 years.

5.3 Sivabaghyam:

Glib and oozing with confidence,

Sivabaghyam is a woman of substance.

When asked about her education her

answer set the tone for the rest of the

talk so what if I didn't have

education? I have talent and thats all

that counts came the reply.

This 47 year old Chennai born mother

of two is a born business woman. With

her smooth talks and a knack for

identifying opportunities, she is least handicapped by her illiteracy. Her shop is set opposite

to a small temple in the Shanmuganar Salai. Apart from selling flowers, she also sells other

items that are required for pooja on small scale coconut, banana, lemon and betel leaves.

She runs the shop at a capital of Rs 500 per day. This may go upto Rs 3000 during festival

times and manages to make profit of Rs 100 Rs 150 per day. She says that she can manage

the shop with the money she earns by it. And she also proudly points out to beautiful fresh

Bangalore roses which she always keeps stock.

Flower selling comes to her naturally as she has been on and off in this business since she

was 10 years old. This is also the family business of her in laws. Supported by her mother in

law and her husband who ties the flowers, she has a successful business and has managed to

educate her son, who is a BSc computer science graduate. Her daughter studied till 10 th

standard and is now married.

She borrows only for family expenses weddings, deaths and other occasions. Her experience

with self help group was not all rosy. The 10,000 rupees that she had borrowed from SHG

required her to pay Rs 275 every 15 days and she quit the group once she finished the loan.1 year is too long a period for repayment and the meetings that one has to attend is a pain in

Page 8 of30

1st November, 2010


9/30


the neck she says. She is comfortable borrowing money from the local money lenders as she

can finish of the loan within 3 months and avail another soon after.

5.4 Lakshmi:

55 year old uneducated widow with a 25 year

old widowed daughter to support is Lakshmi for

you. Her shop is very small when compared to

the previous 3. A small wooden plank set up at a

street corner is her shop, which she runs at a

capital of Rs 300 per day. For this she earns a

profit of Rs 50 and sometimes, this may go upto

Rs 100 when her capital increases to Rs 500.

Lakshmi was formerly running a small Tiffin

shop nearby but she quit the business when herknee started troubling her. 1 year ago, she started the flower business with the money that she

had saved and is helped by her daughter who ties the flowers. Lakshmi also outsources flower

tying and pays around Rs 30 per day for the labour.

She manages the shop from the money she earns from it and is supported by her son now and

then. Her daughter gives beauty treatment to women at their home. Lakshmi is wary of

SHGs. She was associated with one and had successfully repaid the Rs 5000 loan that she had

taken. But she decided to opt out when they offered only Rs 7,000 for a Rs 10,000 loan. The

SHG leader is not trustworthy...they are trying to cheat us is what she feels.

Half way through the conversation, her daughter Amudha joins us along with her daughter.

She explains that now they have got a loan from Equitas for an amount of 15,000. Lakshmis

face beams with pride when she explains that she had used the loan amount to get a cycle for

her granddaughter. Lakshmi is now very strict about not taking any more loans from the local

money lenders as she feels that she can make the ends meet through her business. You get

used to the money and then you start borrowing more and more. When I was young, I could

cope with the repayment, but now it is no longer wise. After repaying the Rs 15,000, I am

planning to sustain without any further loans and support my daughter in whatever way I

can says this devoted mother and grandmother.

5.5 K.Rani:

70 year old Rani doesnt look a day older than 50 and has a

grit in her that enables her to carry on with her life. Deserted

by her 2 sons and a daughter, she now lives all alone and

sleeps in the verandah of a kind hearted house owner.

My husband died with a loan of Rs 1 lakh 7 years

back...when I managed to finish that, I spent another lakh for

Page 9 of30

1st November, 2010


10/30


my sons wedding for which am still repaying. Inspite of that, they left me all alone now she

laments.

A native of Dhindivanam, she came to Chennai 29 years back and has been into the flower

business for 12 years. When asked about what made her get into this business, she said that

when people came to buy fruits from her husbands shop, they would also ask if he had any

flowers. Recognising this customer need, Rani started the flower business despite her

husbands protests. Before getting into flower business, she was working as a maid.

Her age does not allow her to invest more than Rs 100 or Rs 200 per day for the shop and she

gets a profit of Rs 25 to Rs 50 per day. Very rarely she invests Rs 500 as capital. She is now

afraid of taking any further loans, even from the local money lenders as she feels that at this

age, it will not be easy for her to repay. I can sustain the shop with what I earn. My needs

are also less and I dont have to support any one anymore. So what is the need for borrowing

money? she smiles.

Though she is aware of SHG (which she associates with misappropriation of funds) and

MFIs, she feels that they are not needed for her.

5.6 Uma:

30 year old Uma is a class apart from other flower sellers as she does this business to use her

time productively, while for others, it is a means of livelihood. Her husband, in association

with his father, runs a successful garland business. This paved the way for Uma to start

selling flowers 5 years ago at her own doorstep. Flowers worth Rs 150 to Rs 350 is brought

from Koyambedu from her husband and her 2 children a son and daughter who are studying

in 6th and 1st standard respectively helps her in delivering the flowers to the homes of her

customers. Though she is uneducated, she is determined to provide a good education for her

children.

With a profit of around Rs 100 per day and sufficient income earned by her husband, she

finds no need to borrow money from outsiders. However, she has borrowed Rs 3000 and Rs

2000 from her close friends who have started money lending business. I got the money as

they have started this business very recently. I have borrowed money just to support them

she says.

When asked about SHG, she says that it is not for her as attending to their meetings always

throws a wrench in her schedule. With no plans of expanding the business, she says MFI is

not her cup of tea.

Page 10 of30

1st November, 2010


11/30


5.7 Sakkarai:

Into the flower business for the past 20 years,Sakkarai is a proud mother of 2 sons, one of

whom has studied polytechnic and another is

into the flower business. 45 year old Sakkarai is

a Dindukal native and flower business is their

family business. Her late husband was also in

this business.

She started her business with a capital of Rs

100, which she had borrowed from the money

lender and now she invests anywhere between

Rs 250 to Rs 500 per day for her business, out

of which she makes a profit of Rs 100 to Rs 150

per day.

She is unaware of the concept of micro finance and regularly borrows money from the money

lender and this sum ranges from Rs 1000 to Rs 3000, depending upon the needs. She utilises

this money to meet her household expenses and for paying her sons education loan. For the

past 7 months, she is a part of a self help group and is raring to get done with it as she finds it

difficult to make the monthly payments and attend to the meetings.

She says that she is comfortably running her business with the money that it generates. Her

sons are her pillars of support and she is keenly looking forward for retirement from the

business.

5.8 Veeramma.M

True to her name, Veeramma had

courageously battled it out with other

nearby flower sellers to set up her own

small flower shop in the Choolaimedu

high road. The uneducated 30 year old

Dindukal native came to the city of

Chennai 3 years back and started the

flower selling business 6 months ago.

Errant husband who no longer contributes

to the family income made her take up

this job. Tying flowers since the age of 10

and her husband being in the flower

business made choose the business of flower selling to boost her income.

Page 11 of30

1st November, 2010


12/30


She started out as a house maid and with a generous help from her employer, she started this

business with a capital of Rs 100. Now she invests around Rs 200 per day and manages to

make a profit of Rs 90. Her daughter, who is now studying 3 rd standard is what keeps her

going on. Having lost four sons earlier in childbirth, her daughter is the centre around which

her life revolves.

She supplements the income from flower shop by working as a maid. Back at her native

place, she was a member of a SHG but was not happy with it as she felt that she was being

cheated. The experience now has her shunning away from joining any SHG as she says that

she cannot afford the monthly payments, nor can she go for the meetings.

Borrowing money from the local money lender works fine for me as the repayment

instalments is as small as Rs 20 per day for the Rs 2000 loan that I have taken. Also, I can

close the loan in a short duration as against the 1 year period it takes in SHG. She says. The

amount that she borrows mainly goes for meeting her household expenses. She is not aware

about MFIs.

Her little daughter helps her in the business by delivering flowers to homes. Veeramma

expressed that all she is looking forward is to give her daughter a decent education and that is

all that matters to her right now.

5.9 Indira:

A widowed woman with a child to support and supported by her sisters is Indira for you.

Come from a family that has been in the flower selling business for more than 3 generations,

she, along with her 2 sisters, mother and nieces and nephews runs this flower shop at

Choolaimedu high road.

Answers for my queries flew left right and centre from the 3 sisters and a niece. Between the

3, they run a flower shop, a tender coconut shop, sells vegetables. This big joint family have

their shop in the same premises for the past 40 years.

They invest an amount of Rs 1000 per day for their flower shop and earn a profit of Rs 200

per day. Uneducated native Chennaiites, Indira and her sisters regularly borrow money in the

range of Rs 5000 to 10,000 from the local money lender to meet their household expenses.

They sustain the shops from the income that it generates. Recently they have become a

member of Mahasemam and have obtained a loan of Rs 10,000 a few weeks back.

The closely knit family system and the comradeship between the sisters ease the financial

burden on the family.

Page 12 of30

1st November, 2010


13/30


5.10 Anjalai:

55 year old Anjalai started selling lowers since she was 15years of age and has been running the flower shop in the

same premises for the past 40 years. Mother of 4 sons and 2

daughters, none of her children has completed schooling and

her sons are working as contract labours.

Anjalai, who is uneducated, is a native of Chennai. Her small

flower shop runs at a capital of Rs 200 to Rs 250. She makes

a profit of Rs 50 per day. Her husband helps her financially in

the business and she resorts for borrowing money from the

money lenders to meet her household expenses.

Anjalai like many others is not keen about SHG as she feels

that she cannot gel well with other women. The regular meetings that one has to attend if they

are a member of SHG also keep her away from such programs.

Ignorant about the concept of MFI, she showed les enthusiasm to it even when explained as

she felt that group dynamics with her peers in the area is not her cup of tea. Getting money

from the money lenders is easy to keep track of and is less of strain on the purse she says.

Anjalai has plans of selling bananas and coconuts in her shop in the future and is working onhow to generate the capital required for it.

5.11 Gowri:

Gowri is a 52 year old diabetic patient who laments that most of her income goes for her

medication. Her late husband was a rich man who had acres of land in Vizhupuram, but the

family came to poverty as the husband became an alcoholic and squandered away the wealth.

The mother of 5 daughters and a son, Gowri never did any work previously and lived in her

sons support. 10 years ago, she took up the business of selling flowers with the help of her

daughters who are flower sellers. She started the business with an investment of Rs 50, whichhas now increased to Rs 200 per day. She makes a profit of Rs 50 to Rs 100 and gives this

money to support her sons business and her grandsons education. She delivers flowers to

the home of her customers. Her son helps her in the business by buying flowers for her from

Koyambedu and apart from that, she has no one else to help her in the business. Every 3

months, as and when she repays a loan, she borrows another amount from the money lender

to meet her household expenses and for supporting her sons business.

She was a member of Mahasemam and opted out of it as she felt that there was a

misappropriation of funds. So now, she depends solely on the money lenders.

Page 13 of30

1st November, 2010


14/30


5.12 Aarumugam Ammal:

When asked for her name, her husband rushed

forward and said Aarumugam Ammal with a

heavy stress on Ammal. The husband and

wife duo hail from a family of flower sellers

from Kariampatti a small village near

Dindukal. She was also the only flower seller I

had encountered to have had some education.

She has studied till 8th class. 34 year old

Aarumugam Ammal is striving to make ends

meet and also support the education of her son,

who is now in 11th standard and daughter who is

in 9th.

We started this business because we fell into

bad times and badly needed additional income.

Says Murugan, her husband, who sometimes

helps her in running the shop. He works in a

flower shop in Parrys and they buy the flowers

for the shop from Parrys. Into this business for the past 10 years, Aarumugam Ammal sets

shop for a capital of Rs 500 and makes a profit of Rs 100 to 15 per day. Once, she was a

member of SHG but unfortunately, the group has dissolved and now, she is looking forward

to join another SHG, mainly for saving money rather than availing loan. We borrow money

from the money lender only during festival times to infuse more capital to the shop.

Otherwise, with the money that we earn between us, we can manage our expenses beams

Aarumugam Ammal. The couple feel that it is best to avoid borrowing as it becomes an

unnecessary strain on their pockets. It is best to limit our expenses in accordance with the

income says Murugan.

Incidentally, it was Murugan who changed her wifes name to Aarumugam Ammal from

Aarumugam. Its a mans name... I wonder how her father gave her such a name he

grumbles good naturedly, while Aarumugam Ammal smiles shyly.

Page 14 of30

1st November, 2010


15/30


5.13 Vasantha:

45 year old Vasantha has her shop right next to the

Choolaimedu bus stop and has been doing business in the

same area for almost 30 years. A native of Bunroti,

Vasantha inherited this shop from her neighbour from

Bunroti, who was moving to another area. Ever since, she

has been running this shop and currently invests Rs 300 to

Rs 400 per day as a capital, making a profit of Rs 100 per

day.

Vasantha had to repay a loan that was taken by an

acquaintance in her name from a finance company nearby

Amma Finance in the Choolaimedu high road. Theyabsconded with the money...I had to pay back for the Rs

10,000 loan she laments.

Vasanthas livelihood and business revolves around the money she continually borrows from

the local money lenders. It is no strain. I have to make a daily payment of Rs 10 to Rs 50,

depending upon the amount I borrowed. And once I finish of the loan in 3 months, I avail

another she grins.

When asked about SHG and MFI, she was able to say that she was a part of both but was not

able to explain the details of it. When pressed further, she took me to the centre leader of

Equitas, from whom she has borrowed Rs 10,000.

I dont believe in these SHG and MFI. I end up paying more. Never again am going to

borrow money from these people. Money lenders are the best choice she says with

conviction and nothing could shake her conviction, even the calculations that I made for her.

With only one son, who is uneducated like his mother, Vasantha avails his help and her

mothers for the business. I am planning to build a home at my native. Once that is done, I

will retire...Have had enough of this business says Vasantha.

5.14 Kuppamma:A huge red bindhi, lips that are stained maroon with constant

chewing of betel leaves and an attitude that is aimed at milking

sympathy this is Kuppamma in a nutshell. This 65 year old lady

supplements her income by working as a night watch woman in

one of the flats nearby, though which she earns Rs 2000 per month.

15 years ago, she got into the business of flower selling, before

which she worked as a maid. Old age made her quit the previous

profession and turn to the less labour intensive job of selling

flowers. Skirting around the topic of her family, this Chennai native

Page 15 of30

1st November, 2010


16/30


talks about the days when she started the business with a 50 rupee capital. Now she invests

anywhere between Rs 1000 to Rs 2000 per day for her shop. From this, she makes a profit of

Rs 250 to Rs 300. Kuppamma has availed a loan of Rs 10,000 from Amma Finance in

Choolaimedu and is looking forward to finish off the loan in the next 3 months. not a big fan

of money lenders or SHG, she says that borrowing money from neighbours and other knownpersons is the smart way to supplement the income as she can repay the borrowed amount

without interest within a couple of days.

5.15 Shanthi:

Fiercely independent and self sufficient,

Shanthi literally snarled out when I asked

who helps her in running the shop. I

dont need anybodys help for this.

Neither will I ever go and ask somebodyto lend me a hand says Shanthi. 48 year

old Shanthi has been running this

business for 28 years. Mother of 2 sons

and a daughter, this uneducated woman

has given her children the basic

schooling. The capital for her shop comes

mainly through the money that she borrows from the money lenders. Shanthi is also a part of

a SHG, where she has successfully completed the repayment of a loan of Rs 10,000 and has

now taken a loan of Rs 15,000 from them. She repays this loan through monthly instalmentswhile for the money lenders, it is through daily instalments. She, however, is not aware of

MFIs.

She sets up the shop with a capital of Rs 500 to Rs 1000 and outsources a part of the flower

tying at a payment of Rs 20 per day for labour. The shop gives her a profit of Rs 100 and she

is quite content with what she has now, with no further plans of expansion.

5.16 Lakshmi:

75 year old Lakshmi is a very intriguing

character. Estranged from her sons and herhusband, she has been living alone for the

past 35 years. Coming from a family of

flower sellers, she buys flowers from her

husbands shop at Koyambedu. It is

purely business. I pay him promptly...I

dont expect or want his help says

Lakshmi. She has been into this business

for the past 40 years. She invests Rs 700

per day for the shop and makes a profit of

Rs 50 to Rs 100 per day which though which she sustains her life. A member of a SHG at

Page 16 of30

1st November, 2010


17/30


Aminjikarai, Lakshmi is not eligible for taking loans, but she uses the SHG to save Rs 110

per month.

I stay alone and there is no one to look after me. So the only option available for meet my

financial needs are the local money lenders. I regularly borrow Rs 10,000 from them and

repay it at the rate of Rs 100 per day and finish of the loan in 3 months, after which I again go

for a loan. It is through this money that I sustain my business and my livelihood says this

lonely grandmother.

5.17 Leelavathy:

With her hair tightly bound into a bun and

stern specs perching on her nose, Leelavathy

looks like your regular government school

miss. But this 45 year old 3rd generation

flower seller proudly announces that she will be the last in her family to sell flowers.

Leelavathy has been running the shop for the

past 30 years and is proud of the fact that her

only son has studied B.Com. He got a merit

seat at the Pachaiyappas College and we

didn't have to get even single paise as loan

for his studies she beams with pride. The

son now works with TTK Pharma.

Leelavathy who is a member of a SHG iswaiting to get out of it as she feels that the

group leader misinformed her about the terms of the loan. She saves Rs 110 per month in the

SHG and is waiting for the 3 year period to get over so that she can come out of it. Once, she

got a loan worth Rs 3500 from the SHG and she says enough is enough. I have repaid the

loan and once my 3 year locking period for my savings gets over, I will get out of SHG. She

sets her shop with a daily investment of Rs 400 and earns a profit of Rs 100 per day. To meet

her day to day expenses and to supplement the capital for her shop, she prefers the local

money lender from whom she regularly borrows Rs 5000 and repays it in 3 months through a

50 rupee daily instalment.

5.18 Tamizhchelvi:

32 year old Tamizhchelvi started selling flowers 3 years ago

when her husband deserted her. With a son and a daughter,

uneducated Tamizhchelvi says that all that she wants now is

to see to the fact that her children get good education. She

started the business with a capital of Rs 200, which she

invested out of her savings. And now, the shop has expanded

and she invests Rs 500 to Rs 900 per day, making a tidy profit

of Rs 150 to Rs 200. Incidentally, the business that providesher with livelihood is the family business of her in laws.

Page 17 of30

1st November, 2010


18/30


I never borrow money. What I earn from the shop is sufficient to meet my needs she says.

When I looked at her in astonishments, she smiles and says that her mother and her brothers

support her by giving provisions and some money for urgent needs. It was them (her mother

and brothers) who married me to the man who deserted me. So it is their responsibility to take

care of me says this Madurai native.

With this support, she says that there is no need for her to borrow money. Tamizhchelvi si a

member in a SHG in which she saves Rs 110 per month. I got a loan from the SHG and

transferred it to someone else she grins. With her son and daughter supporting her in the

business by delivering flowers to the houses of customers, Tamizhchelvi is happy with the

way her business is flourishing. I am planning to expand my business soon by getting more

varieties of flowers she signs of confidently.

5.19 Panjaksharam:

You ask her about her age, it comes with a disclaimer. Am only 56 years old, but my hairhas gone white prematurely says

Panjaksharam, who has been selling flowers

since she was 10 years old. She fondly

recollects the days when she sold flowers with

her father at the bus stop in Parrys. Selling

flowers is the only thing I know. It is in my

blood she says.

This woman of grit has been through the death

of 2 sons and her husband. After my husbanddied 2 years ago, I stopped taking loans from

the money lender. It is better to get money

from the neighbours and repay within a few

days free of interest says Panjaksharam. With

this flower business, she contributes to the

running of the family of her two remaining

sons and is helped in her business by her sons

and sharp 10 year old grandson who ended up asking me more questions than I asked to his

boisterous grandmother.

Her shop is one of the oldest in Choolaimedu, which she set up way back in 1968. Her

regular customers include the Amma Hospital, Aruna Diabetic centre and a couple of other

clinics nearby. She invests Rs 500 to Rs 900 per day and earns a profit ranging between Rs

100 to 150. Panjaksharam, who is not a big fan of SHG or MFI, says that she is content with

what she has and is keenly exploring various avenues of savings.

5.20 Kannatha:

Kannatha was the last flower seller I interacted with and her shop was also the smallest that I

encountered. 60 year old Kannatha is a resigned woman who has no one to support or look

Page 18 of30

1st November, 2010


19/30


20/30


6. Business model of flower sellers:Given below is the graphical representation of the business model of the flower sellers.

Fig 1: Business model generation canvas

7. Other insights and inputs:

7.1 Vishwanathan:

Every day, Vishwanathan, the money collector makes rounds on his scooty to collect money

from those who have borrowed from the money lender. His customers have a wide flexibility

on the loan amount, which ranges anywhere between Rs 100 to Rs 10,000 and also on

repayment terms. Borrowers can repay the money on a weekly or daily basis. However, the

repayment period never exceeds 3 months.

Vishwanathan has 15 colleagues who go around distributing and collecting money every day.

He says that over the years the business has been steadily increasing and laughs out when

Page 20 of30

1st November, 2010


21/30


questioned whether MFIs are their competitors. They can never be our competitors. Can

they lend a sum as small as Rs 100? he asks.

Vishwanathan has been in this business for the past 20 years and he says that his customers

always promptly repay the money.

When questioned further on turnover and other details, Vishwanathan refused to divulge any

information and sped away in his scooty.

7.2 Rebecca:

Rebecca is a dynamic entrepreneur who is into detergent sales. She is the centre leader of a

group of 25 women of Equitas Microfinance and the group leader of the self help group,

Swarnammal Arakattalai promoted by M.K.Stalin.

Her group has opted for the joint liability model for the MFI loan. They are in the last leg of

repayment of the Rs 10,000 per person loan from Equitas and will soon be eligible for a loanof Rs 15,000. When asked about the enthusiasm shown by the members for the MFI, Rebecca

was sceptical. After this, maybe just 10 to 12 of the group members will be willing to take

up the next loan she said. When asked for the reason, she said they find it difficult to repay

the money on a fortnightly basis as the sum gets accumulated as against what they pay to the

money lenders on a daily basis. Being a joint liability model, even if one defaults, the others

have to share the burden, which is quite difficult for us.

However, she was much more enthusiastic about the SHG and said that it has been a huge

success and the members are looking forward to avail the next loan.

When asked about how the group members utilize the money obtained as loan, Rebecca was

non committal and said that it may be used for both business as well as personal expenses.

7.3 Matt Duncan:

Matt Duncan is associated with the Grameen Foundation and is based in Seattle, USA. The

researcher chanced upon meeting Mr Duncan at the Coffee Day Square in Bangalore while he

was discussing technical aspects of micro finance with an associate.

Duncan has come to India to conduct a seminar on technology for microfinance which is to

be held in Delhi. The researcher discussed about some aspects of micro finance with Duncanand he patiently shared his expertise. Given below are his insights and observations.

There are only 10 major micro finance companies catering to the entire world! he started.

MFIs need to focus on moving out and reaching out to more people rather than moving up

and making more money. The need of the hour is that MFIs must go back to the basics and

remember that they were started with a social objective in mind and must adhere to it, instead

of letting the focus drift more towards profit making.

When asked about the impact of micro finance in the lives of people, Duncan had many

success stories to share. However, when asked specifically about the role of MFI in the lives

Page 21 of30

1st November, 2010


22/30


of urban population, he stressed again on the stand adopted by some MFIs who restrict

themselves to urban areas and how it may not really make a difference.

Duncan, along with his associates, has developed a new cloud technology which can be used

by MFIs at lower costs to enhance their performance and efficiency and at the same time, cut

down their cost. If an MFI can reach the rural population at the same cost that it can reach

the urban population, then what is there to stop them from extending their hands to the

needy? says Duncan.

8. Money matters:While the business cycle and the money management of the 20 flower sellers have already

been discussed in the report, given below is an overview of the operating monetary metrics

for everyday business day for these flower sellers. Also, a small comparison has been made

between the interest levied by the money lenders and the MFIs and respective loan terms. The

perceived merits and demerits of the credit sources by the flower sellers are also touched

upon. The figures as presented in this section have been arrived at by averaging the outcomes

of the survey.

8.1.1 A simple income statement of the flower sellers:

Parameter Percentage

Sales turnover per day 100%

Cost of setting shop per day as a % of sales 73.45%

Profit earned per day as a % of sales 26.55%

Loan repayment expense as a % of profit 51.22%

Other daily expenses as a % of profit 48.78%

Page 22 of30

1st November, 2010


23/30


Given below is an example*

Parameter Percentage Example

Sales turnover per day 100 500

Cost of setting shop per day

as a % of sales 73.45 367

Profit earned per day as a %

of sales 26.55 132

Loan repayment expense as a

% of profit 51.22 68

Other daily expenses as a %

of profit 48.78 64

* The figures presented have been arrived at based on the results of the survey pertaining to

the investment, daily turnover, and loan repayment, up to the date of the survey.

8.1.2 Money lenders Vs MFI

Given below is a comparison of the loan terms from the different sources. Comparison of

simple interest has been adopted for reasons of convenience.

Parameters MFI Money lender

Payout to customer as a % of

total loan amount 100% 85%

Amount withheld as a % of

total loan amount 0% 15%

Simple interest on the loan 16.34% 64.41%

Loan period 2 years 100 days

Frequency of repayment Once in 15 days Daily/weekly repayment

Page 23 of30

1st November, 2010


24/30


Customers perception of borrowing from money lenders:

1. Daily repayment is perceived as an advantageous option since the business thrives on daily

cashflows, and the burden of repayment is viewed as minimal.

2. Short duration of loan facilitates frequent borrowing, which is seen as apt for the business.

3. Transactions (lending and repayment) happen at borrower's doorstep, which is seen as a

convenience.

4. The flower sellers feel that the interest rates charged by MFI are higher inspite of proving

to them through simple calculations that it is the other way round. This is mainly because,

when borrowing from the money lender, the repayment is made in small amounts, which

makes them believe so. Lack of knowledge and ease of procurement of loan are also viewed

as distinguishing factors.

Customers perception of borrowing from MFI

There a lack of awareness about MFI among the flower sellers who were interviewed. Those

who have borrowed money from the MFI have the following to say

1. Difficulty in attending to group meetings

2. Making bulk payment (ie around 250-300 rupees) every fortnight is difficult as the money

needs to be mobilised before hand

3. Long loan duration makes it difficult to borrow more frequently. The florwer sellers prefer

a lesser turnover period.

9. Observations:By studying this small sample of 20 flower sellers in Choolaimedu, some of the thoughts and

questions that come into the mind are discussed below.

9.1 Demographic aspects:

1. The average age of the women who are into this business is 50 years, with the

youngest being 30 years of age and the oldest 75 years

2. 50% of the women come from a family of flower sellers and hence, taking up this

trade has been a natural step for them

3. Of the remaining 50%, the business of flower selling was an option that they took

because it was less labour intensive and hence, could easily be managed inspite of

their advanced age.

4. 60% of the flower sellers are Chennai natives and the rest have settled in this city formore than 10 years

Page 24 of30

1st November, 2010


25/30


5. 19 of the 20 flower sellers are uneducated.

6. Their children are also not highly educated. Most of them are school dropouts with

exception of 2 cases where the children have finished under graduation

7. 45% of the flower sellers are widowed and for the remaining, the husbands are intoeither flower business or work as labourers.

Points to ponder:

Many of the flower sellers, despite their age, continue to support their family by generating

income through this business. These women exhibit extraordinary grit when it comes to

seeing the welfare of their children and grandchildren.

More than a means of livelihood, this business is also a means through which they support

the livelihood of their grown up sons and their sons.

9.2 Business aspect:

1. The average capital employed by the flower sellers is around Rs 500 per day and on

an average, they make a profit of Rs 100 per day

2. The flower sellers do not have a fixed supplier from whom they buy flowers every

day

3. The common flowers that they sell are jasmine, jaadhi or mullai depending upon the

season, saamandhi, kadhambam (which is a mix of jasmine, kanakambaram,

marikozhundu). Hybrid rose is also sold.

4. Neither do they have a predetermined product mix. They vary the quantity of flowers

depending upon the price of each variety.

5. The flower sellers do not seem to have a large number of regular customers.

6. They sell flowers primarily from the same location. Once they set up a shop, they do

not move that particular place.

7. Home delivery of flowers is done to select customers from whom they collect money

from a monthly basis.

Points to ponder:

Considering the nature of this business which requires infusion of capital on a day to day

basis, how can MFIs or SHG help these flower sellers with the lump sum that they give out as

loans? Can there be any way through which women such as these can be reached out and

helped by the MFI?

The local money lenders seem to be the perfect alley for these women as they lend amount as

small as Rs 100 which will help the women to set up the shop. They find frequent borrowingmore suited for their style of business and these money lenders cater exactly to this need.

Page 25 of30

1st November, 2010


26/30


9.3 Financial aspect:

1. 17 of the 20 women go to the money lender for their requirements and find it

convenient to repay to the lender on a daily or a weekly basis

2. Short repayment period, flexibility over instalment amount, minimum loan amount,

individual liability and frequency of repayment period make the option of borrowing

money from the money lender attractive

3. Another added advantage with the money lender is that the money is lent and

collected at their doorstep.

4. As the repayment period is short, the flower sellers are able to avail new loans once

every 3 months, which is not the case with SHG or MFI, where the repayment period

is as long as 1 year.

5. Trustworthiness of SHG is a major concern among the flower sellers as those whohave been a member have had bad experience and feel cheated by the group leader.

6. They also find attending to the meetings and liaising with peers of SHG as

inconvenience

7. Only 3 out of the 20 women are aware of MFI.

8. The flower sellers feel that the procedures involved in availing loan from SHG or MFI

complicated. This is another factor which makes them go for the money lender

9. The flower sellers feel that repaying money on a daily or weekly basis is easy on their pocket and does not put much strain on their resources. However, when an

accumulated amount is paid fortnightly or on a monthly basis, they feel the pinch.

10. The purpose of borrowing in majority of the cases is for meeting personal expenses

rather than for business needs.

Points to ponder:

The question that arises is that, if these women, who borrow primarily to meet their personal

expenses, continue to do the same without a thought of generating more revenue, than how

can MFI or SHG help in improving their standard of living? Will they really make a

difference in the lives of these urban flower sellers who already run an established business?

Is there a way to help these women out of the vicious cycle of borrowing and repaying and

borrowing again?

Also, it is glaringly visible that these money lenders make the lives of the flower sellers

easier. They give them capital for setting up the shop everyday and what they collect at the

end of the day is a small percentage of the profit that these women earn by selling flowers.

Looking at the money lenders in this perspective, we see that they are nothing but very small

scale venture capitalists. Contrary to the popular belief, these money lenders cannot be

Page 26 of30

1st November, 2010


27/30


deemed as villains or ruffians in a broad sweep, but they can be looked up as street venture

capitalists.

10. Scope for further studyThis report is a small step towards understanding the needs of urban women, who are

engaged in a business that requires daily infusion of capital.

The study can be further developed by covering different industries like the vegetable sellers,

fruit sellers, fish sellers etc, for whom the credit needs are different from women who enter

into a business that does not require daily capital infusion like handicrafts sellers, farmers

etc.

Also, the further studies can be made in the direction of finding out the relation between

various aspects of the business like profits earned per day, loan taken, sales etc statistically.

By doing so, a path can be paved for meeting the credit requirements of these women, who

still largely depend on the money lenders.

Page 27 of30

1st November, 2010


28/30


29/30


Appendix 2:Questions:

The questions that were asked are

1. Demographic

a. Name

b. Age

c. Educational qualification

d. Native place

e. Number of members in the family and their educational qualification

f. Family business

2. Business

a. Number of years for which they are into this business

b. Support received for the business from family and through outsourcing

c. Various aspects of the business

d. Time for which they sell the flowers

e. Sourcing of raw materials

f. The inspiration behind starting the business

g. Future plans of the business

3. Financials

a. Capital employed per day for the business

b. Profit earned per day

c. Source from which they borrow the money

d. Interest rates of the money borrowed

e. Frequency of money borrowed and the purpose of borrowing

f. Repayment details

4. Awareness level

Page 29 of30

1st November, 2010


30/30


a. Awareness about self help groups (SHG) and micro finance institutions (MFI)

b. Details regarding their own participation in SHG and MFI

c. Their views about SHG and MFI

d. Preferences regarding sources of borrowing and the reason for the chosen

source

Date post:	10-Apr-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	aruna2248
View:	227 times
Download:	0 times

A Study on the Flower Sellers of Choolaimedu -Aruna v N

Documents