A Teaching Practice that helps students achieve Academic and Cultural Excellence!
Culturally Relevant Teaching:
Focusing on Teaching Minority and Economically DisadvantagedStudents
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
3
DRUGGED BY MY PARENTS...
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
4
Why Are we Here? We are here because we have a
strong personality and passion for working to improve education.
We believe in Educating ALL: students, parents, teachers, the community, and school leaders.
We continue to worked to bridge the gap among and between parents and the schools.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
5
Why are we here? We are committed to a quality
and equitable education for all.
We are here because students’ needs come first. “We are not here to make ourselves look good. We know we have work to do and many students to reach.
“It is not about you, it is not about me, it is all about the students!”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
6
Today’s PurposeTo help teachers and others to
successfully work with All students in a manner that is fair, equitable, respectful and rewarding
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
7
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
8
Econ. Dis.
4-5Classroom
Regular Ed 6-95041
EC 3-4
ESL
1-2AIG 2
Close the Gap!
Typical Heterogeneous Classroom
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
9
What is shared here today is important to ALL students learning, but essential for working with minority and economically disadvantaged students!
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
10
“Education, like electricity, needs a conduit, a teacher, through which to transmit its power….”
Rev. Jesse Jackson
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
11
Group Activity Each participant should have 5 small
cards with numbers 1-5. As a question is asked each
participant will choose a card to identify where they fit on the knowledge line.
After identifying where they fall ask participants to stand for each number called out.
All participants are asked to look around the room and reflect on the results.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
12
DestructivenessCauses intentional harmIncapacityCauses unintentional harmEvasiveness (denial)“I don’t see differences”Pre-competenceSeeks to learn about self and othersCompetenceActions consistently reflect stated valuesProficiencyAdvocates for change
Cultural Competence Continuum
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
13
Cultural Competence
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
14
What does it mean to be white? Race identity is like oxygen: It’s
taken for granted when plentiful and frighteningly apparent when deprived.
White people are taught that our lives are morally neutral, average, and ideal (D.W. Sue 2004)
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
15
Racial Identity ModelsIdentity models explain the stages we
are at in terms with our connectedness with our race. When we discuss, for example, the Black, Latino, or Asian identity models, we look at assimilation and acculturation within and around the White Euro-American culture. When we look at the White Identity Model, we look at how Whites deal with being the majority and acknowledgment of their privilege vs. others’ disadvantage.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
16
White Identity Model Naiveté phase: It lasts the first 3
years of life. Social meanings are absent. The child is innocent, open, and spontaneous regarding differences.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
17
Conformity phase: The white person’s attitudes and beliefs are very ethnocentric as there is minimal awareness of the self as a racial being. There is a strong belief in the universality of values and norms governing behavior. They know very little about other ethnic groups and rely on stereotypes as the main source of information.
White Identity Model
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
18
Dissonance phase: “Movement into the dissonance stage occurs when the White person is forced to deal with the inconsistencies that have been compartmentalized or encounters information/experiences at odds with denial. In most cases, a person is forced to acknowledge Whiteness at some level, to examine their own cultural values, and to see the conflict between upholding humanistic nonracist values and their contradictory behavior.” “Dissonance may result in feelings of guilt, shame, anger, and depression.”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
19
Resistance and Immersion phase: “The white person who progresses to this stage will begin to question and challenge his or her own racism. For the first time, the person begins to realize what racism is all about, and his or her eyes are suddenly open. Racism is seen everywhere (advertising, television, educational materials, interpersonal interactions, etc.). This phase of development is marked by a major questioning of one’s own racism and that of others in society. ” “Realities of oppression are realized as well as “the advantages being white grants”.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
20
Integrative awareness phase: “Characterized by 1) understanding the self as a racial/cultural being, 2) being aware of sociopolitical influences regarding racism, 3) appreciating racial/cultural diversity, and 4) becoming more committed toward eradicating oppression.The person values multiculturalism, is comfortable around members of culturally different groups, and feels a strong connectedness with members of many groups.”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
21
Commitment to antiracist action phase: “This phase is most characterized by social action. There is likely to be a consequent change in behavior and an increased commitment toward eradicating oppression. Seeing ‘wrong’ and actively working to ‘right’ it requires moral fortitude and direct action.” “Objecting to racist jokes, trying to educate family, friends, neighbors, and coworkers… are examples of individuals who achieve this status.”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
22
“When someone pushes racism into my awareness, I feel guilty (that I could be doing so much more); angry (I don’t like to feel like I’m wrong); defensive (I already have two black friends… I worry more about racism than most whites do – isn’t that enough); turned off (I have other priorities in my life with guilt about that thought); helpless (the problem is so big – what can I do?). I HATE TO FEEL THIS WAY. That is why I minimize race issues and let them fade from my awareness whenever possible.”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
23
If anything can help ease the conscience of an unintentional suppressor, it is that all races, including White, are victims of racism. We have all been programmed by society to be racist
.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
24
Not only is everyone a victim of racism, everyone is RACISTRACISTOnly when we accept it can we do something about it
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
25
What can we do? Realize that all cultures are valid
and valuable. Begin appreciating other cultures. Ask others about their cultures. Take field trips to cultural centers. Point out the elephant in the room
“We are not from the same culture, do you feel comfortable discussing this with me?”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
26
Multiculturalism “Refers to the process of recognizing, understanding and appreciating cultures other than one’s own. It stresses an appreciation of the impact of differences…”
Cultures are more than racial, they include class, age, physical, sexual/affectional orientation, and religions.
If you struggle with how to proceed, ask yourself: What does it feel like to be older, a woman, of a different religion? (We can feel the other side when we look at differences in this light)
Multiculturalism
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
27
Research and Resource
Culturally Diverse Counseling
D.W. Sue, 2004
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
28
Latino/Hispanic
Native America
African American
Asian
EuropeanAmerican
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
29
European American
Latino/Hispanic
American Native
African American
Asian
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
30
So what…..?
I must know;
Myself in order to understand others
My values, my beliefs, my opinions and how they impact my decisions and others.
The impact of my power to influence.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
31
Topics of Discussion Why Culturally focus teaching? Being conscious of what you do
unconsciously. Building Relationships with All
students. Build relationships with parents and
the community Shift in Thinking How we work with
students Culturally Relevant Teaching what
does it look like?
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
32
What do we know?
Minority students continue to lag behind their counterparts on all standard measures of achievement.
Minority students are three times more likely to drop out and twice as likely to suspended from school.
These same statistics correlate to minority students coming from harsh social and economical realities.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
33
What do we know? Most minority students are already
segregated in “community schools” usually in the inner city area.
African Americans and other minorities who attend private or independent schools consistently show higher levels of achievement than those who attend public schools.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
34
What do we know?“Although the 1960s produced a large body
of literature on teaching the disadvantaged and the 1970s produced a body of literature about effective schools none of it was aimed at specifically preparing teachers to meet the needs of minority and disadvantaged students. Even today some of the more popular educational innovations, such as cooperative learning and whole language approaches to literacy, were developed and refined to improve achievement among disadvantaged students. Unfortunately the relationship of these practices to minority learners is rarely made clear.”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
35
What do we know? Society fails to recognize African
Americans as a distinct cultural group. Society tends to relate minority low
performance and achievement to environmental and social factors (poverty and lack of opportunity).
One in three Latino children live in poverty.
Poor children are much more likely than non-poor children to suffer developmental delay and damage to drop out of high school, and give birth during the teen years.
Children from poverty are more likely to be raised by a single parent.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
36
What do we know? Poor youth living in the inner
city are more likely to be victims of child abuse or neglect than are other children.
Poverty is caused by parental employment status, earnings, family structure, and a parental education.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
37
HMMMMMMMM???
“It is not that we don’t want to change; it’s that we often don’t
realize there’s a need for change or how to go about making the
change.”
Megan Milani
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
38
Think of a time when someone’s
message, tone, body language or actions affected your feelings or your thinking.
1. Describe what the person did?
2. How did this action make you feel?
3. Were you able to determine if it was intentional or a perception created by yourself?
4. How do you know?
Group Activity
Stop, Think and Discuss it!
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
39
Be Conscious of what you do unconsciously!
“If we were to look closely at even the simple things we subconsciously do each day, we would probably be stunned by the implications and the impact on our students.”
Sometimes what we do unintentionally: our actions, tone, words, and body language may imply a wrong perception to others.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
40
Scenarios/Role Play Scenarios/Role Play Act out or read the scene. Discuss what the issue is. Explain how you would handle
this. What could have been done
differently? Are there any hidden innuendos? What other factors might we
need to consider?
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
41
Be Conscious of what you do unconsciously!The teachers who communicate to
children through words and actions what they believed to be their true potential, empower students to begin to believe in themselves.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
42
Shift in Thinking
We have to believe that every student in our classroom can reach their full potential and will learn.
We must observe students through a new lens, and refrain from making judgments that put limits on kids.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
43
Shift in Thinking
Change your thinking from “there is something wrong with this kid, to perhaps there is something wrong with the way we are teaching or approaching this child.
Hmmmmmm?
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
44
Shift in ThinkingBring your assumptions
down to where you can challenge them.
“Assumptions have a truth status that are uncertain.”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
45
Shift in ThinkingThink of different way to
approach the child.
Every day is a new day, forget what happen previously and rethink your approach.
Find a mentor to work with your students.
CAP-Caring Adult Program
Contact outside agency
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
46
Milani’s Research from “The 3 Habits of Highly Successful Reading Teachers”
Students have a good sense of what we think of them, if we believe in them, and what we expect of them.
Teachers indicate true feelings all the time. Expressions on our faces may be fleeting, but they are there and others are easily able to pick them up and ascertain what they mean.
It is vital to know how much you can affect the students you teach, and how well they do.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
47
“Students don’t think like adults think, but they feel like adults feel.”
Lee Jenkins
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
48
Building Relationships with Students Think about the message you send to
students, by your tone, your words, your body language
Convey positive messages to All students
In your classroom, remind students everyday that you know they are smart, and that sometimes learning is hard work but that you’re there for them.
Try something new
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
49
Building Relationships with Students Observe your students to see
how they learn best Make sure the classroom
environment is one where students feel comfortable, appreciated, and safe.
Look at your students in a new way
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
50
Building Relationships with Students Don’t assume you already know what to do
for a child look for the truth. It is imperative that you tell each child that
she or he is capable and is making progress. Celebrate every step toward the goal.
Culturally Relevant TeachingCulturally Relevant
Knowledge is continuously recreated, recycling and shared by teachers and students. It is not static or unchanging.
Knowledge is viewed critically
Teacher is passionate about content
Teacher helps students develop necessary skills
Teacher sees excellence as a complex standard that may involve some postulates but takes student diversity and individual differences into account
Assimilations Knowledge is static and is
passed in one direction, from teacher to student.
Knowledge is viewed as infallible
Teacher is detached, neutral about content
Teacher expects students to demonstrate prerequisite skills.
Teachers sees excellence as a postulate that exists independently from student diversity or individual differences.
Research from Successfully Teaching African-American Students, Gloria Ladson-Billings, pg. 81
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
52
Create the Optimal
Environment by
intentionally
Purposefully make students feel comfortable
Making students feel appreciated
Making students feel safeListen, listen,
listen
Purposefully, help students feel valued
Connecting reading and learning to culture and environment
Looking at students in new ways
Giving students opportunities
Holding students accountable
Intentionally building rapport with parents
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
53
Purposefully include opportunities for learning about different cultures.
Go to community events where your students are.
Invite Parents to your classroom to view student presentation.
Determine with the class what will be your symbol for respect of diversity.
Connect reading and learning to culture.
Do community service in surrounding neighborhoods and in your classroom.
Host Parent nights specifically showcasing student work/project.
Cultural Relevant Focus
Don’t assume you can relate to other cultures.
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
54
What factors influence brain development and academic achievement?
Genes
Love
Positive reinforce-ment and FeedbackExercise
Nutrition
Challenge and the Arts
Social
Emotional
Psychological
Physical
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
55
Resources
•Billings-Ladson, Gloria, Successful Teachers of African-American Children.•Clark, Ron, The Essential 55.•Covey, Stephen, R. The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People and The 7 Habits of Highly Effective Teens.•Garner, Betty, Getting to Got it!•Pavik, Robert and Ramsey, Richard, Reading and Writing Sourcebook.•Jensen, Eric, Teaching with the brain in mind.•Peters, Stephen, Do You Know Enough About Me to Teach Me?•Teaching Tolerance (magazine subscription)•Educational Leadership (magazine subscription)
Educate yourself and be in the know!
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
56
“It is well-known that when we are in an environment where we feel comfortable, appreciated, and safe, we thrive. If we know that our opinions matter, that we are listened to and valued, it’s a place where we want to be. When we know what the expectations are and that much is expected of us, and we are given the tools, time, and guidance to reach our goals, we surpass what we think we’re capable of.”
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
57
1. Be conscious of what we do unconsciously?
2. Shift in our thinking about how we approach and work with minority learners.
3. Intentionally, genuinely build relationships with students.
4. Intentionally, genuinely embed opportunities for cultural learning into instruction.
5. Intentionally, build relationships with parents and be involved in the community.
What did we learn? What will we do?
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
58
The world is a rainbow
With Many Kinds of People
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
59
It takes all kinds of people,
To make the world go round!
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
60
“Kids only have one chance for an education---and we need to have the courage to stand up for them.”
Anne Duncan
“Gods little flowers, that’s what I call them. Every one a little different but every one so sweet. And just like a garden, the classroom has got to be a place that nurtures them. They don’t all need the same thing. One might need a little pruning and some might need to roam free. They’re just so precious and it breaks my heart to see the hurtful way they are treated. Some teachers think they are hard because they live tough lives but they are just as fragile as hothouse orchids.”
Elizabeth Harris
God’s little flowers….
Created by Marlene Bryan Smith and Robin Ambrosini
62
Contact Information
Marlene Bryan Smith
(704)-253-3188
Robin Ambrosini
(704)-528-5137