+ All Categories
Home > Documents > A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia...

A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia...

Date post: 26-Oct-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 3 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
32
HAL Id: inria-00070781 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070781 Submitted on 19 May 2006 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- entific research documents, whether they are pub- lished or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers. L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires publics ou privés. A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, Tatiana Kozubskaya To cite this version: Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, Tatiana Kozubskaya. A tetrahedral- based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics. [Research Report] RR-5212, INRIA. 2004, pp.28. inria-00070781
Transcript
Page 1: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

HAL Id: inria-00070781https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070781

Submitted on 19 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme foraeroacoustics

Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, TatianaKozubskaya

To cite this version:Nicolas Gourvitch, Gilbert Rogé, Ilia Abalakin, Alain Dervieux, Tatiana Kozubskaya. A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics. [Research Report] RR-5212, INRIA. 2004, pp.28.�inria-00070781�

Page 2: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ISR

N IN

RIA

/RR

--52

12--

FR

+E

NG

ap por t de r ech er ch e

Thème NUM

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme foraeroacoustics

N. Gourvitch, G. Rogé, I. Abalakin, A. Dervieux, T. Kozubskaya

N° 5212

May 26, 2004

Page 3: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone
Page 4: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Téléphone : +33 4 92 38 77 77 — Télécopie : +33 4 92 38 77 65

� ������������� ��������������������������������������� ��!���"�� #$�&%'����������������(�")*���

+-,/.1032"465�798;:'<"=?>@.A,"BC03DFE?G'>"H',JI K"LFMNLPOQ7SRJT'>JIU,"V WX465�7SWX2QYJZ[>J\1,@]03^_2"K"`aOPL?b3L3c

dfehg6ikj�lnmporqts?uwvyxzg6ikjav�{?|hik}a~����X|hjav�J~z�[�yj*xns?i��_v�e

� �[�h�F��~�x �wj�~zja��ehja~z��ehj�{3�J���h����qto1�;u���h�������[��q��[��������j�v

����a 6¡'¢h£� �¤ ¥ j �wjavz�*~z�§¦Fj�¨{X|�i�ja~����6��©�vz��ehj6ikj�ª9�_~e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«���6v�¬�j6©«©��_�h�[�hx�ja�Uxz��¦F�[xze­�[ja~���®�huX{P�[ik�«�av��[{P�U��j6~z�_�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�av6¯Cdfe�j°v���ehjaikj��«v±�j6~�x�j6²U�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��(�Q³´x����h�h©«�§j�v�¬��§x�eAv�ja�*�_{��U��~��wj6~�_�6�6|h~z�_�*uUx��U|h{�v�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja�­x�j6x�~��[ehj��w~��«µa�[x��«��{�v��[{P�Aj*²?xzj6{��hv�xz�¶eh�§�_ehj6~k�_~z�wja~ ·S|h�¸x��¶v��§²?x�eP¹��_{���*j6~�xz���§{¶xyu?�FjC��ªn�6�[~�x�j�v����[{¶ikjav�ehj�v6¯-swj6±�ja~z��©@¦��_v����C��j6~z�_���6��|�v�x�����{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©/j6²w�Pja~��«ikj6{Xxzv��[~zj��~�j�v�ja{_xzja�(¯º1»X¼3½z¾¿ ¡'À���¤ÂÁ ja~��X���*�_|�v�x����6va�_{?|hikj6~z���6�[©(vz��ehj6ikj�v6�?e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«�«�Ãik�w�wj6©�v6�w©«�«{hja��~���v�j��CÄJ|�©§ja~�ja�X|��'®xz�§�_{�va�w|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j�� i�j�v�e�jav

Æ�ÇFÈ�ÉFÊ�Ë'ÌzÍSÎ�ÏyÐ*ÑyÒaÓ;Ñ/Ô�Õ;É�Ï�ÖØ×�Ï�Ù�Ë�ÎÅÎzÚ*ÛÅÛ�Ê3Ü'Ï�Ý�Þ;ÖSÍßÖNÓ;à9Í9á�Ï�àSÒ;ÑÅË;â'àØÏ�Ò;×yÑãJä Ï�ÖNÖNÏ�Ó;Ù åØÍ�æ?Ð�çèÏzåØçêéÅÒXË�Î�ë�ì�Ó;Ï�ç?á�Ï�àS×�ÑyÙ ä Ï�ÖØÖ´Ï�Ó;Ù å�Ë'íÅîÅî�ïyÚnðaÏ�çêÒ6åSÍSÊ3ÙêéÅÓ;ñXË�â'àNÏ�Ò;×yÑò"ó á�á�Ë'áôçêÓ;ÖØõ�Ï�ö6Ï�ÖN÷[ÕêË;Ú*Ï�Ë'áôéÅÖØ×yé�øùï�îÅÛÅú�Ú6ÎaË�ûüÓ;ÖNÖØçèÏý ó È�û ó æ�Ë[îÅúÅú�Ú�ûüéÅÓ�åØÑ@ñ;ÑyÖ�þ?Ó�×�çêéÅÙêÑyÖ�Ë'Ô(ÉwÕ[íÅÿ�Ë'úÅÌÅíÅúÅî ðaéÅÞ�Ü;çèÏzÍßæ�Ò*åØçêÞ�éÅÙêçêÖ�Ë;â'àØÏ�Ò;×yÑ� ó á�á�Ë'áôçêÓ;ÖØõ�Ï�ö6Ï�ÖN÷[ÕêË;Ú*Ï�Ë'áôéÅÖØ×yé�øùï�îÅÛÅú�Ú6ÎaË�ûüÓ;ÖNÖØçèÏ

Page 5: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ���J��� #$� � �������������������� ����������������������� ��!�-���������������������C�ü��)����

�� �� �� � ¤ � j ~��[�h�F��~�xk�h}a�*~z�§xk|�{¸vz��eh}6i��U{?|hik}6~z�«�X|hj ¦h�«j6{ �����[�wxz}��U©�� ��}6~z�?�huX{P�[ik�«�X|hj j*x�A©�� �[}a~��X���*�_|�v�x����_|�j�¯ � j-v���eh}ai��ùjav�x�*ja{Xx�~z}�v��_iki�j6xCj*x�h~�}��*��vC��| v�j��*��{P� �_~z�h~�j¨v�|h~�hjav�xzj*®xz~z��}a�w~z��v��[x��«��{�v�{���{w® vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�}ajav�j6xp��� |h{��_~z�h~�j���©§|�vÃ}6©«j6±_}C·ê�y|Pv��X|�� �Cv�� ²�¹nv�|h~p|h{��6j6~�xz���§{1xyu?�Fj��wjxz}*xz~z��}a�w~z�«vz�'xz�§�_{�6��~�xz}av��§ja{h{hj_¯��Ã|hja©«�X|hj�v�j*²w�P}a~�ja{��*j�v"{?|hik}6~z�«�X|hj�v��hj�¦���v�j�ja{��[}6~z�_�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�X|hj�v��_{Xx��~�}�v�ja{_xz}6j�v6¯� ¿  �� ½ £�� � ��¤ Á }6~z�_�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�X|hj_��v���e�}6i���vJ{?|hik}a~����X|hjava�_ik�w�wga©§j�v/e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«���_|�java�_ÄJ|h©«j6~�©«�§{h}��[~z�«v�}��i����§©«©«����j�v�{���{w® vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�}�v

Page 6: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� '

( ) �������� �C�/��)*���

dfe��«vÃ���[�Fj6~px���*�j�v �h©����6j��«{Xx�� �C~zjav�ja��~z��e �h~z���_~z��i�ikj���§ik�«{h��[xp��~��_�P�Xv��«{h�°{?|hikj6~z���6�[©"vz��ehj6ikjavja{h��|���e ���h���wx�j��°xz��¦F�[xze1���*�_|�v�x����Ãik�w�wja©«v���{�� �*��ik�Fj6~�v�v��«¦h©§j,+�|h��� ik�?�hj6©�v6¯³´x��«v�§{­�6��{h{�ja�Åxz�§�_{Ux����¨v�j6~z�«jav���ªf¬���~*wvôª9�w�*|�v��«{h�1��{¶xzehjC{?|hikj6~z���6�[©�v��«i|h©��'xz�§�_{ù�[ªfx�|�~�¦h|�©§ja{_x+P�'¬ v�¬��§x�e�v�ja�6��{��?®´��~��wja~�vz��ehj6ikj�vJ�[�h�h©«u?�§{��Ã�_{�|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja��ikjav�ehj�v6�[j��X|h�§���Pj���¬��§x�ek�p±�ja~�u�©«�'¬�h�«vzv��«���[x��«±�jÃx�j6~zi ��v�j6j.- �_�0/´�1-ê�[��/´�2- �h��/´¯dfe�j{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©"v��«i|�©«�[x��«��{¨��ª@x�ehj��h~z�������_�[x��«��{ �[ª��_�*�_|�vyxz�«�¬��;±_jav�¬��§x�e43�~�vyx�®N�_~z�wja~n����~�xz�«��©��h� ªß®ª9ja~�ja{Xx����[©3ja�X|��[x��«��{�v��[ª�e?uX�Fj6~z¦F��©«�«�Ãxyu?�Pjôe��_v��[{ �§ik�F��~�xz��{_xf�«i��P���Åx��_{ ���§~��*~��'ªßx��wjav��«��{ü�5-«�76�/´�h�[{P��«{?±��_©§±_javp� �h�98°�*|�© x���h�h~z�;²?�«i��'xz�§�_{¨�h~z��¦h©«j6i ¯�� �'xzehj6~�v��«i���©§j�v�ja�*�_{��?®´��~��wj6~ô���a�*|h~��'xzj�ikj6x�eh�w�hveP�;±�j�¦Fj6j6{-i|���e1|Pv�j��¨�[{����[�h�h~zja�6�«�[x�j��Cª9�_~Ãja©§©«�«�wx������h~z��¦�©§jaikva¯ ³ {��6��{Xx�~���v�xa��ª9��~:3�~zv�x�®´��~��wja~ e?u_®�Fj6~z¦F��©«�«�av6�@{��[xk��{h©«u¶x�ehj1�wja~��«±'�'xz�§�_{A�[ªp��j6{?|h�«{hja©§uùv�ja�*�_{��A�_~z�hj6~�i�j6x�eh�w�hv�e��_vk�*�_v�x�j��­�-©§��x���ªj�;F�_~�x�v6��¦h|wxp��©«v����§xÃv�jaj6i�v�xze��'xÃi��Xvyx ��ª@v�j��*��{P�?®N�_~z�hj6~�ikj*xzeh�w�hv·Ø�[{�� ja±�j6{ ik�_v�xn��ª�xzeh�«~z�?®´��~��wja~�_{hjav�¹��[~zj�x��?���w�«vzv��§���[x��«±�j�x�����©§©«�'¬Aj�8°�6�§ja{_x@ja{h��|���ek���6�6|h~��'x�jf�*�_ik�h|wxz�[x��«��{�v"��ª3�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�av�ª9��~J~zja�[©©«�§ª9j��h~��_¦h©«j6i�v6¯swj6±�ja~z��©w���?�w��eh�§�_e���~��wj6~@vz��ehjai�j�v@�[~zj�{h�'¬ �;±'�[�«©«��¦h©§jfª9�_~@~zj6��|�©«��~Ji�j�v�e�jav ·Øv�jaj��_ª9��~@j6²w��ik�h©§j_�<-«��/9¹Å¯dfe�j6u°�[~zjô�wj6~z�§±_ja�°ª9~��_i v���ehjaikjav�¬�� xze ©§�'¬ �h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ü�w�'x�©«ja�_vyx�ª9��|h~�x�eh®N�_~z�wja~��_�6�6|h~z�[x�j_�X�_~�¬��§x�e�k�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{{��[x�©«��~��_j6~�x�eP�[{ x�ehj��h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ �[�h�h©«�«ja��§{ ª9��|�~�xzew®N�_~z�hj6~����a�*|h~��'xzjpvz��ehj6ikj�v6¯dfe�jô�a��v�jn��ª�~zj6��|�©«��~�ikjav�ehj�v���v���~�ja©«�[x��«±�j6©«ukja�_v��«j6~f��{�j�¯ ¥ j��a�[{C|�{��wj6~�v�xz�[{P�°xzeh�«vf�§ª�¬�jô�*��{Pv����wj6~xzehjfv��«ik�h©§�13�j����a��v�j/�[ªF���w±_ja�Åxz�§�_{�¬��§x�e��6��{�v�xz��{Xx�±�ja©§�w�6� xyu_¯Q³ {�xze��'x@�a��v�j��03�{��w�«{h�ô�n�_�?�?����w±_ja�Åxz�§�_{vz��ehjai�jf��vJjavzv�j6{Xx����[©«©§u=3P{��w�«{h���[{��§{Xxzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{kv���ehjaikj�¯�³ {�xzehj �6�_v�jf��ªF� � ��|�~z��{_x"{?|hi¦Fj6~Jj��X|��[©xz�?>A@«��v���ikj�v���ehjaikjav �a�[{ j6±_j6{ ¦Pj�j6²h���Åx�¯CBh|�~�xzehj6~��h~zj6��|�©«��~�ikj�v�ehj�v �[~zjô���[~�x����*|�©«��~�©«u�ªS�;±��_|h~��[¦h©«jxz�kx�ehj��wj6~z�§±'�[x��«��{ �[ªJeh�«��ew®´��~��wja~ ���6�6|h~��'x�j�vz��ehj6ikj�vfx�e��[xÃ�*�Xvyxn�k~��'xzehj6~Ãv�i��[©«©ü{?|hi�¦Pja~n�[ª"���Fj6~��'®xz�§�_{�v�ª9��~fxzehj6�«~n�_v�v�j6i�¦h©§u_¯dfe�jô�a��v�jô�[ª"|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��Cikj�v�ehj�v�~zj6�h~zjav�j6{Xxzv�xzehj�i��'²w�§i���©ü�w�98°�6|h© xyu_¯$B��§~�vyx��hikjav�e�«~z~�ja��|h©��[~z� xyu��ik�h©§�13�j�vp�h�«v��Pja~zv��«��{���ehj6{h�_ikj6{���¯�s?j��*��{P�w©§u_�üi��[{?u1|�v�j*ª9|h©J{?|hikja~����6��©�ikj6x�eh�w�hv��w� {h��xôj6²?x�j6{P�j���v��§©«u ·ßxz~z�_�w� xz�§�_{��[©��6��ik�����*xkvz��ehjai�j�v6�/ª9��~kj*²h��i���©§j;¹�xz��xzehj�Dy|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja��E �6�_v�j_¯­dQ�w�h�;uùj�vy®v�j6{Xxz�«��©§©«uCxy¬��°ªS��ik�§©«�§j�vn��ª�vz��ehj6ikjavnj6{'�y�'u eh�«��eh®N�_~z�wja~ �[ª����6�6|h~����*u_�P�6��{�v�j6~z±'�'x��«��{1��~��_�Pja~�xz�§j�vn�[{P��h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{A�_{hjava�Jx�e�j �_�h�[�wx��'xz�§�_{A�[ªÃÄ/lGFn®NxyuX�Fj v���ehjaikjavx��U|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��Aikjav�ehj�v ·H- ��/ß¹*�/�[{P�xzehjJIÃ�«vz�*�_{Xx��«{X|���|�v�®LKô��©§ja~�*?�«{-ikj6x�eh�w� ·H- ' /9¹Å¯NM�|wx�x�ehj�v�j°xy¬�� ªS��i��«©«�§j�v��[ª vz��ehj6ikj�v��[~zj°���a�*|h~��'xzjja{h��|���e ��{h©«uC�§ªJx�e�j6u �[~zj��[ª"ª9��|h~�x�e �_~z�wja~a¯�³ { x�eP�'xn©���v�xn�6�_v�j_�hx�e�j6u �*��{Pv�|hikj���©��[~z��j��6��ik�h|wxz�§{h�j�;F�_~�x�ª9��~�ja�_��e°|h{O*?{h�'¬�{ü�w��{���xzehj6u��[~zjnj�8°�*�«j6{Xx��_{h©«u�¬�e�j6{Cja{h��|���e°{h�w�wj�vf�[~zjn|�v�ja�°��{��C�±�ja~�uv�i��[©«©(j6~z~��_~f�«v��wjai��[{��wj��(¯B�~��_i x�ehj�v�jp~�jai��[~*?v�¬�jÃ�6��{�wja~��«±�jnx�ehjpª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{��~zja�*�_ikik��{��h�[x��«��{�v@ª9��~�|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��°ikjav�ehj�v�P®n·S��¹�¦�|h�§©��1v�ja�*�_{��?®´��~��wj6~fvz��ehj6ikjav�xze��'x �«{?±���©«±�jô��v�ª9ja¬ �h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ ��v��w�keh�«��ew®´��~��wja~fvz��ehjai�j�v6�®�·9�«��¹@ja�X|h�«�kx�ehjnv�ja�6��{��w®N�_~z�wja~Jv���ehjaikj��[ªüv�|��Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6j��h~z���Fj6~�x��«jav@��{��6��~�xzjav��«��{�ikj�v�ehj�v@�[{P�|Pv�j���vf��ªßx�ja{ �_vf�P�Xv�v��«¦h©§j��a�[~�x�jav����[{Cikj�v�eh�«{h�k�[ªJv�|h¦h~zj6���«��{Pv���ªQxzehj��*�_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���©ü�w��i��[�«{ü¯M�u�v�|h�Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6j��h~z���Fj6~�x��«jav�¬�jpikja�[{°x�e��[x�xzehjôv���ehjaikjÃ�[���h©§�«jav�xz���[~z¦h�§x�~��[~zu�|�{�vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j��ikj�v�ehj�v�¦h|wx �«{~zj6�_�§�_{C¬�ehja~�jÃx�ehjôikjav�e �«v��a�[~�x�jav����[{ü�Xx�e�jÃxz~�|�{��6�[x��«��{Cja~�~z��~���v�v�i��[©«©«j6~f¦?uCv�ja±�ja~z��©�_~z�hj6~�v��[ª i�����{h�§x�|��hj�¯ Á v�ªS�[~���v ·9�ß¹���vk�*��{P�*j6~z{hj��(�"¬�jj6ik�he��_v��«µ6jCx�e��[xx�e�jCx���v�*U��v��*��ik�h©«j*²(¯³ {P�wj6j��(�ü�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{-v�eh�_|h©��¨��;3j6~ô� �*��ik�Fj6{�vz�'xz�§�_{1x�� �w��v��Fj6~�v��§�_{¨�§{-x�e�j�v�j6{�v�j�xze��'x�j6²w�6javzv��«±�ja©§u�h�«v��Pja~zv�ja�Ceh�«��e°ª9~zja�X|hja{��*�«javfv�eh��|�©«�C¦Pj��h��i��Fja��«{�_~z�wja~/xz���;±��������Xv��6�§©«©«�[x��«��{�v��[{P�°©��[~z��jnja~�~z��~�va¯dfe�jp¦P�[©��[{��6jÃ��v���j6{�j6~��[©«©§u��_¦wxz���§{hj��°¦?uC��eh�?�Xv��«{h�e��§�_ew®N�_~z�hj6~f���6�6|h~����*u_¯RQn�'¬�ja±�ja~a�X�§{x�e�jô�hj6~z�§±'�'®

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 7: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

xz�§�_{A�[ª�xzehj In��v��Fj6~�v��§�_{­��j6©��'xz�§�_{A�J~zjav�j6~z±X�«{h�­·�IÃ�n�/¹�v���ehjaikj��@d��[i �[{��­�*�[®´¬���~*�j6~�vp�h~zj*ª9j6~�x���_�wx��«ik�§µajpx�ehj�vz��ehj6ikjpª9��~�©«�'¬ ��e���v�jôj6~z~��_~�¦Fj*x�x�ja~�x�e���{ *_j6ja�h�§{��k�_�6�6|h~z�_�*u¨·H-§��/ß¹*¯

³ {�-«����/N�'��ªS��ik�§©«uÃ��ªh±�ja~�xzj*²?®´�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��n|��X¬��«{�����j6~z�_�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�"vz��ehj6ikjavQ�[�h�h©«u?�§{���x��nx�j*xz~z��ehja�h~��«µa�[®xz�§�_{�v��[{P���~�j�v�ja{_xz�§{��kv�|h�Fj6~��*�_{X±_j6~z��ja{��*jÃ�h~��_�Pja~�xz�§j�vf¬��_vf�§{Xxz~��w�w|��6ja�(¯@dfe��«v vz��ehjai�jô��v �[©�v���|Pv�j���«{1v�ja±�ja~z��©P¬���~*wvp·H-§����/�-§���7/�-§�a��/ -«����/ß¹fdfehj���~�j�v�ja{_xf~zj6�F��~�xf��~��_�P�Xv�j�v�� ' I�j*²?x�ja{�v��§�_{��ª��§xa¯

³´x ¬��«©§©Qe��;±�jÃx�ehjôª9�_©§©«�'¬��«{h�k�h~��_�Pja~�xz�§j�v�P·S��¹�xzehj�vz��ehj6ikjô�«vn�*��{Pv�ja~�±'�'xz�§±_j��·S�§�ß¹�x�e�j��w�«vzv��§���[x��«��{ü�w¬�e�j6{ |�v�ja�(�w��v �wja~��«±�j��°ª9~z��i v��§²Xxzew®´��~��wj6~��wja~��«±'�'x��«±�j�v6�·S�§�«�ß¹fx�e�j�vz��ehj6ikj���v 3�ªßx�ew®´��~��wj6~n¬�� xze��w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{¨��{��¨v�� ²?xzew®N�_~z�hj6~ ���a�*|h~��'xzj�¬��§x�eh�_|wxp�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{¬�e�j6{ � xn��v��[���h©§�«ja�Cx��°������~�xz�«�6|h©��[~��6��~�xzjav��«��{Cikjav�eü¯

� � ��� � )6�Q��)*� �ô��)*�������C�����/��)6�� ���"�� #$����� (��mn�?¬��§{�� vz��ehj6ikj�vk�[ª Kp�?�h|h{h�'±Axyu?�Fj1j6{'�y�'u �¶©§��x°�[ªô�§{Xx�ja~�j�vyxz�§{��¶�X|���©§�§x��«jav��h|hj x��¶xzehj¨�Fj6~�ª9ja�Åx�_�wja�X|��[x��«��{ �[ª"x�e�j�|h�?¬��§{��h�§{h�Ci�j���e��[{��«v�i xzehj6u�§{?±��_©§±_jô¬�� xze1|h{�v�x�ja�_�wuC¬f�;±�j�v6¯�m {wª9�_~�xz|h{��'xzj6©«u��xzehj°�[ik�_|h{Xx��[ª��w�«vzv��§���[x��«��{-x�ehjau-�6��{Xxz���§{¶v�jaj6i�v�i�|���e¶©«��~��_j6~px�e���{¶{hja�6javzv���~�u ª9�_~�[{¶���a�*|h~��'xzj{���{w®´�_vz�*�«©§©��'xz��~zu {X|�i�ja~����6��©@�[{�v�¬�j6~�¯ Á v�� �*�_{�v�ja�X|hj6{P�*j��Qx�ehj°�h��ik�§{P�[{Xx�x�ja~�i �[ª�x�ehj�{?|hikj6~z���6�[©ja~�~z��~���v �6��~�~z�§j��°¦?u�xzehj��w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{Q¯

¥ jv�|h���_jav�x�x���ª9��~z��j6x��[¦F��|wx�vyxz~����Åx�i��_{h�[xz��{?u¶�[{��Uxz����j6x�«{�v����§~zja�ù¦?u In�«~zja�Åx�s?�«i|h©��'xz�§�_{xzja��eh{��«�X|hj�v �«{1¬�eh�«��e1{���{w® �w��v�v��§�P�'x��«±�j�e��§�_e1��~��wj6~n���h�h~z�;²w�§i��'xz�§�_{�v��[~zj�v�xz�[¦��§©«�«v�ja� �«{1���?�w�1���a�*|w®~����6up�6��{��h� xz�§�_{�vüxze��[{<*?v�xz� 3�©§x�ja~zv�¬�eh����e�~zj6©«u���{�±_j6~zu_®´eh�«��e�ja±�j6{��~��wj6~��wj6~z�§±'�[x��«±�java¯ ¥ jfv�e���©§© 3�~�vyxv�eh�'¬ e��'¬ x�e��«v �a�[{ ¦Pj��h��{hj�¬��§x�e1����{hj6®´�h�§ikj6{Pv��«��{���©3eh�§�_ew®´��~��wj6~ o1mps � � ikj*x�e��?� ik�w�w�13�ja� �«{v�|���e �ki��[{h{hja~fx�e��[x�x�ehj��h��ik�§{P�[{Xxn�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{x�ja~�i!�«v���v��§²Xxzew®´��~��wj6~��wja~��«±'�'x��«±�j_¯J³ { x�ehj�©«�§{�ja�[~�a��v�j��?xzeh�«vf��v�j6²w�_�Åxz©§u�xzehj��*�_{�v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{C�[ª - ��/��[©�v���|Pv�j��C�«{ - ��/N¯

!�"$# %'&)(+*�,-(/.�#103254�%)687:9<;>=@?BA).$(+*C,$;>D� j*x�|�v 3P~zv�x �*��{Pv����wj6~fxzehjôx�e�j���{hj6®´�w�«ikj6{�v��«��{���©3�6��{?±�j��Åxz�§�_{Cja�X|��[x��«��{

EGFIHKJLELM8NPO ·y��¹

dfe�j,3P{h� xzj*®´±��_©§|hikjpikj*x�e��?���vf|�v�j��°ª9�_~�x�ehj�v����'xz�«��©3���h�h~z�;²w�§i��'xz�§�_{ü¯+QCR��5>TS�UVSXW �hj6{h��x�jpx�ehj�h�«vz�*~zj*xz�§µ��'x��«��{ �F���«{_x�v��[ª�x�e�j�ikjav�eü¯ B���~�ja�_��e1�w�«vz�*~zj*xz�§µ��'xz�§�_{�F���«{Xxa�h¬�j�vyx��'xzj&P E RZY E+[ Q R�\ �[{P�¬�j��wj�3P{hjôx�ehj��6��{Xx�~z��©3±_��©«|hikjT]^R���v�xzehj��§{Xxzj6~z±;��©>_ Q Ra`cbd�e Q R<fgbdih ¬�ehj6~zjIQ R<fIbd N

QCR H QCR<fkjl ¯

� j*xnm Npo�E R�q x�ehjk|h{<*X{��'¬�{-±_ja�Åxz��~p¬�eh�_v�jk�*��ik�F��{hja{Xxzvô�[~zj����h�h~z�;²w�§i��'xz�§{���x�ehj�ª9|h{P�Åx��«��{E+[ Q \ �«{°j�����e�{h�w�wj�U��[ª(x�e�jnikjav�eü¯ ¥ jn¦h|h�«©���x�e�jn±�j��Åxz��~'r [ m \ �_�6�6��~��w�§{���x���v����[x����[©F�[�h�h~z�;²w�§i��[®xz�§�_{��ª [ts+[uE \$\ M �h¬�eh����e �6�[{ ¦Fj�¬�~��§x�xzj6{1��v=P

rcR [ m \ N >v Q [xw R<f bdzy w Ra` bd \�{ w R<f bd N|wg[uE R<f bdi} e E R<f bd�~ \ ·Ø��¹

ó È�û ó æ

Page 8: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �

sh��ehj6ikjav � � ��� ��� � ¡;À » ¡� � ��� ' � � '� � ��� ' ®n��'� � �' � ��� ' � ®n��'� �� � ��� ' ®n���w�a� ®n��?��� �� � ��� ' ®n���w�a� ®n��?��� �

d��[¦h©«jk�AP Á �a�*|h~����6u��[ªJ�w�9;3j6~zj6{Xx�±�ja~zv��«��{�v��[ª�x�ehj�{�j6¬ v���ehjaikjp�«{¶�7I��a��v�j

¬�ehja~�j E R� bd�� �hj6{h��x�jôx�e�j�±;��©§|�jav���ª E �[x ¦P�_|h{��h��~��«javf��ª"�6��{Xx�~z��©(±_��©«|hikjT]^R�¬��§x�e wg[uE e� \ N�� _ [ > y ��������� [ J \$\ EKH [ > y ��������� [ J \ \ >h ¯Á �a�*��~��w�«{h�ôx��x�ehjôo1mÃs � � ikj*xzeh�w�w��©«���_u· - ��/9¹Å�_x�e�jn©«j*ªßx��[{��k~z�§�_eXx��*�_{_xz~��_©h±��_©§|�i�jn¦P�_|h{��h��~�uv�xz�[x�j�v E R� bd � ��v�¦h|��§©§x |�v��§{h�k©«�§{�ja�[~��«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{Cª9�_~�i�|h©«�_vGP

E R<f bd } N E R H j� v E R<f bd } { E R<f bd ~ N E R<f j y

j� v E R<f bd ~E Ra` bdi} N E Ra` j H j

� v E Ra` bd�} { E Ra` bd�~ N E R yj� v E Ra` bd�~

· ' ¹

¬�ehj6~zj v E R�zbd � �[~zjôv�©«���Fjava�w�د j�¯@���h�h~z�;²?�«i��'xz�§�_{�v/��ª��wja~��«±'�'xz�§±_jÃxzj6~zi�� E� Q¯

v E R<fzbd } N [ > y � \ [ E R<fkj y E R \ H � [ E R y E Ra`1j \ ·9�X¹v E R<f bd�~ N [ > y � \ [ E R<fkj y E R�\ H � [ E R<f � y E R<f j�\

·Ø��¹¬�e�j6~zj��@� �«v/|h�?¬��§{��h�§{h����[~��[ikj*xzj6~Jxze��'xf�*�_{_xz~��_©«vJx�ehjn�6��i�¦h�§{P�'x��«��{���ª3ª9|h©§©«uk|h�?¬��§{P���[{��°�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��v�©«���Fjava¯ B���~�� N >����xzehj�v���e�j6ikjô�«v�xzehj�vyx��[{����[~��°xzeh�§~����~��wj6~����a�*|h~��'xzj�v���ehjaikj�¯³ {­x�ehj �h~zjav�j6{Xxk±�ja~�xzj*²?®´�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��ù�*�_{_xzj*²?xa�/eh�§�_e­�_~z�wja~��_�6�6|h~z�_�*u¶��v�{��[xk��¦wx��[�«{hja�­¦XuA�-eh�«��ehja~�®�_~z�hj6~��§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{­¦h|hx°¦Xu �[{¸�§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{Axze��'x°�*�_ik�Pja{�v��[x�j�vxzehj1j6~z~z��~k�*��ik�«{h�-ª9~��_i x�ehj3P{��[©ü�6j6{Xx�~��[©ü�w�1;3j6~zj6{��6�§{h�k�«{ù·Ø��¹*¯@dfeh��vf¬�~��§x�j�v���v�ª9��©«©«�'¬ v�P

v E R<f bd } N [ > y � \ [uE R<f j y E R \ H � [uE R y E Ra` j \H � � [ y E Ra`1j H � E R y � E R<f j H E R<f � \ ·S�_¹H � � [ y E Ra` � H � E Ra` j y � E R H E R<f jk\v E R<f bd�~ N [ > y � \ [uE R<f j y E R\ H � [uE R<f � y E R<fkj\H � � [ y E Ra`1j H � E R y � E R<f j H E R<f � \ · �[¹H � � [ y E R H � E R<f j y � E R<f � H E R<f � \

¬�ehja~�j!�@�"�����{��#���U��~�j¨|��X¬��«{��w�«{h� ���[~��[ikj*xzj6~�v�xze��'x �*��{Xxz~��_© x�e�j-�*�_i¦h�«{��[x��«��{ �[ª�ª9|�©§©«u|��X¬��«{�� �[{P��6j6{Xx�ja~�j��v�©§�_�Pj�v6¯

¥ j���¦�v�j6~z±�jÃx�eP�'xnvz��ehj6ikjavf�wj�v��6~��«¦Fja� �§{¶·Ø�_¹f�[~zjô�§{ ��ja{hj6~��[©(v�ja�*�_{��?®´��~��wj6~f���a�*|h~��'xzjô¦h|wx�x�e�j6u¦Fja�6��ikj eh�«��eh®N�_~z�wja~@���a�*|h~��'xzjfª9��~�v���ikj�±'�[©«|hj�v@�[ª3xzehjn����~z��ikj*x�ja~zv$�/�%�?��� � �[{��&� � ¯ ¥ jn{h��x�j�xze��'xª9�_~'��� N O e � � N y >�(¬�jki��'²w�«ik�«v�j�x�ehj°�wja��~zj6jk�[ªf|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h��¯ Á ©«v���� 3hªßx�e¶��~��wja~����6�6|h~����*u

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 9: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

� ��� ��� ]�������� M�� ' � � �w¯ ' ����� ' ®n��'� � �h¯ê�[� '�� ' � ®n��'� ��¯ 'A' ��� ' ® ���w�a� ® ��?��� ��¯ ��� �

d��[¦�©§j¨��P1o1�[²?�«i��[© � ��|�~z��{_xk{?|hi¦Fj6~�v1·9j6²w�h©§���*�§x°����¶v���e�j6ikj�¹ª9��~�xzehj ª9��|h~��w�1;3j6~zj6{XxCv��P�'x����[©vz��ehjai�j�v�·y�0I��[{���©§uwv��«v�¹

��v��_¦wxz���§{hj��U¬�� xze¶��{ù���wj��_|P�'x�j���eh�_�«�6j��[ª�x�ehjkxzeh~zj6j°�*�?j�8��6�§ja{Xxzva¯JBh�_~�x�eh��v�©���v�x�6�_v�j_�Q¦h|wx�¬��§x�e� N O �?x�e�j6{ ¬�jô�_j*x ���*ja{_xz~z��© ® �w�1;Fja~�ja{��*j��Cv�� ²?xzew®N�_~z�hj6~f���6�6|h~��'x�j�vz��ehj6ikj_¯!�" ! ,$?�� (� �+(/D�� ,$D����*C(��g,$. ,x*��¥ j��6��{ �6��i�¦h�§{�jÃxzehj��[¦F�'±�jôvz��ehj6ikjô¬�� xze x�ehj�v�xz��{��h�[~�� ��|h{h�_j*®��ô|wx�x���xz�§ikj�_�w±'�[{��6�§{h�P¯

s?�«{��6j@x�e�j@�h|h~z�P�Xv�j/�«vüx��n�6��ik�h|wxzj@©§�«{hj��[~��_�*�_|�vyxz�«�av6�a¬�j��6�[{�v��«i���©§�§ª9upx�ehj/� |h{h��j6®��ô|hx�xz��vz��ehjai�jxz��x�ehj�©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j����_�[ikjav���{±'�[~z�«��{_x�·H- �7/9¹�¬�eh����e ¬�~��§x�j�v���v�ª9��©«©«�'¬ v�P

m����! N m�"m �$#% N m ���! H v'&

W y)( H > �+*tm �$# `1j -, e ( N >$@7@�@$Wm " f j N m �/.0

·S�_¹

¥ j�~zja�a�[©«©Q�«{�d��[¦h©«j���v���ikj�xyu?�h���6��©�i��[²?�«i��[© � B � {?|hi¦Fj6~�v ª9�_~ xzehj�v�� ²?® vyx��[�_j�� v���e�j6ikj��¬�e��«��e�ja{�v�|�~�jn����©«��¦���©P���a�*|h~����6u��[ª53P±�j�ª9�_~@x�e�j xy¬���¦Pj�vyx�v���ehjaikjav@��ª(x�ehjÃ�h~z���F�_v�ja��ªS�[ik�«©§u_¯"dfe��«vx��[¦h©«j�«©«©§|�v�x�~��'xzjav x�e��[xnx�e�j��[¦F�'±�j�v���ehjaikjavn�a�[{1¦Fj|�v�ja�¨¬�� xze � B � {?|hi�¦Pja~n�[ªJxzehj�_~z�hj6~n��ªJx�ehj|�{h� xyu_¯

1 � ��(���"�C�/�������� �@� �p��� )a#$� �C��)*����-����Q�

dfe�j ªS�[ik�«©§uk��ª���I v���ehjaikjavJxze��'x��«v��*�_{�v��«�wja~�j��k�«v�� % � ��� 02C�@� �L���L �������%&��2$�G� �����H���1��%&���<�C��� �!������� �%&��� � ��� ���[���h©§u?�«{h�p��{�xz~����[{���|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6�[��{�����ª ������L�<�A�H�����<�L���� xyu?�Pj_¯ ¥ jf~�j6ª9j6~�x�� - ��/wª9��~J�p�wj*x��[�«©§j���hjavz�*~z�§�wxz�§�_{��ªQxzeh�«v�ªS�[ik�§©«uC��ª�vz��ehj6ikj_¯

Á ~��_|h{�� ja�_��eC±�ja~�xzj*²C��vf¦h|h�«©§xÃ�k�*j6©«©3ª9��©«©«�'¬��§{h��xz��i����§{ ���hx��«��{�v7P®@ja� xzehj6~ x�ehj��*ja©§©Q�«vf©«�§ik�§x�j�� ¦XuC���[~�x��[ª�x�ehj�ikja�h�«��{�vf�[ª"v�|h~z~z��|h{��h�§{h��x�~z���[{h�_©§j�v6�®���~nx�ehj��*j6©«©��«væh|h�«© xô���a�*��~��w�«{h�kx�� �[{1���wja�C�[ª$Mf�[~�x�eA·H- 6�/ß¹ ¦Xu��y�_�§{h�«{h��xzehjk�*j6{Xxzj6~n��ªJja�w�_jav ¬��§x�exzehj��*ja{Xx�j6~���ª�v�i��[©«©§j�vyx �*�«~��*©«jô�6��{Xxz���§{��§{h��xzehj��*�_{�v����wja~�j���x�~z���[{h�_©§j_¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 10: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �

I

J

B��«��|h~zjk�AP/o j��w���[{ �*j6©«©Q�6��{�v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{

I

J

B��«��|h~zj¸�OP � �§~��*|hi��6j6{Xx�ja~ D�Mf�[~�x�e�E­�*ja©§©��6��{w®v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{

B��«��|h~zj ' P�d�~z�_�*jk�[ª�x�ehj�ikja�h�«��{�v��w�«±X��v��§�_{U�_{xy¬��&Bh~z�§j��w~z�«��e�v�®��ôj6©«©§ja~�ja©§jai�ja{Xxzv

B��«��|h~zj��!P¸d�~z�_�*j-�[ª Mf�[~�x�e �w�«±X��v��§�_{ ��{ xy¬��B�~��«ja�w~z����e�vy®��ôj6©«©«j6~�j6©«j6ikj6{Xxzv

dfehj�+�|w²wjav���~�j°�_v�v�j6i�¦h©«ja�-��{ù�[{¶ja�h��j*®´¦��_v�j����h~z�w�*j�v�va�Q�N¯ j_¯Cª9�_~�ja�_��e-j��w��j � U¨¦Pj6xy¬�jaj6{¶xy¬��{��?�hjav �/��{��VU��h��{��x�ehja{1v�|hikikja�ª9�_~�ja����e {h�w�wj �/�_v�ª9��©«©§�'¬ v7P

������������� F � H� w�� R N O · 6_¹¬�e�j6~zj w � R��[~zjÃja©§jai�ja{Xxz�[~zu&+�|h²?j�v��*�_i���|wx�j��¬��§x�e1���«j6i���{h{1v��_©§±_j6~�v6¯¥ j,3�~zv�x�~zja�a�[©«©�xzehjê9ja�'xz|h~zjav@��ª��[{Cj*²?x�ja{��wja�C±�ja~zv��§�_{��h~z���F�_v�ja�k�«{4- ��/´� -ê��/Fª9��~fÄJ|h©«j6~��a�[©��*|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6¯

dfehj�{X|�i�ja~����6��©��§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{ ¬��§x�e ��{ |h�?¬��§{�� vz��ehj6ikj1�_j6{hja~z��©§©«uù©§j����hv�x��A�[���h~��;²w�«i��'x��«��{Pv¬�e��«��e���~�j@�_{h©«u,3P~zv�x�®´��~��wj6~ü�_�6�6|h~z�[x�j_¯Qdfehj�o¨mÃs � � i�j6x�eh�w�w�_©§�_��up�[ªh±'�[{ � j6ja~Qe��_vQ¦Fj6ja{�j*²?x�ja{��wj��xz� ±�j6~�x�j6²?®´�6j6{Xx�ja~�j�� |h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��¨ª9�_~�i�|h©��'x��«��{Pvn�«{¶��~��wj6~Ãx�� ~zja����e-v�j��*��{P���_~z�wja~p�_�6�6|h~z�_�*uù·Sv�j6jª9�_~Jj*²h�[ik�h©«jG- ��/ß¹*¯�dfeh��vJj6²Xxzj6{�v��«��{~zj6©«�«jav"��{�x�e�j�j6±'�[©«|��'xz�§�_{ +�|h²?j�v"¬�� xzekj*²?x�~��[�F��©��'xzja��±'��©§|hj�v �� R �� R � �[x�x�ehj��«{Xx�j6~�ªS���6jô�[ªQxzehj��*ja©§©�v�· B��«��|h~zj��¹�P"¬�� xze P

� � � R N � � H O @ � [��� � \ � R @ �� U� R � N � R y O @ � [��� � \ R � @ �� U ·��a�_¹

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 11: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

- +S Sji

W WWWi ij ji j

Iij

B��«��|h~zj���PJ���_v�� xz�§�_{��ª � � R���{�� � R � �_{ -�� � ���GR�/¬�e�j6~zj�x�ehj.Dyj6²?x�~��[�F��©��'x��«��{¶v�©§�_�Pj�vLE [ �� � \ � R � R � ��~�j°�_¦wxz���§{�ja�¶|�v��§{����¨�*�_i¦h�«{��[x��«��{ù�[ªn�6j6{Xx�ja~�j����{��|h�?¬��§{�� �_~z�_�w�§ja{Xxzva¯

³ {��_~z�wja~Jx����«{��6~�j���v�jfx�ehjn�_�6�6|h~z�_�*u���ª3x�ehj ¦P��v��«� o1mps � � �6��{�v�x�~z|��Åxz�§�_{ü��¬�j��h~z���F�_v�jfx���hj�3�{hjxzehjav�j�v�©«���Fjav��_v�ª9��©«©§�'¬ v=Pdfe�jô�6j6{Xx�ja~�j��C�_~z�_�w�«j6{Xx [ �� � \ �� R ��v �wj�3�{hj�� �_v [��� � \ �� R @ �� U N � R y � � ¯dfe�jn{h�w�h��©P�_~z�_�w�§ja{Xx [��� � \ � ��v��a�[©��*|h©��'xzja�k�_{�x�ehjô�*ja©§© ] � �_v@xzehjô�;±�j6~��[�_jf�[ª(x�e�jÃ�_~z�_�w�§ja{XxzvJ��ªüx�ehjxz~����[{���©«jav�¬�eh����e �«{��6©§|��hjÃxzehj��*�_{�v��«�wja~�j��C{��?�hj P

[ �� � \ � N >� � ��� [ ] � \ �

������� � ��� [� \

��# ��� � # �

� w � # ·�����¹

dfe�j°|h�?¬��§{P�¶��~����w�«j6{Xx��«v��*�_i���|wx�j��ù���6�6��~��w�«{h� x��1xzehjC�wj�3�{h�§x��«��{A��ª�xzehjC�w�'¬�{Pvyxz~�j��[i ��{��¶|h�w®v�x�~zja��i xz~����[{h�_©§j�vf¬�eh����e¨�6�[{ ¦Fj��_v�v��w�*���'x�j��C¬��§x�e¨��{1ja�w�_j _ � � � R h · B��§�_|h~zj��_¹Å¯�dfehj��h�'¬�{�vyxz~�j��[i��{��|h��v�x�~zja�[i x�~z�«��{h��©«javf�[~zjô~�j�v��Fja�*x��«±�ja©§u°{��[x�j�� � R ��{�� R � ¯ FÃ{hjôe��_v�v�� P[��� � \ �� R N �� �� ����� �[{�� [��� � \��� R N �� �� ����� ¬�ehja~�j �� �� � N �

# ��� � # �� w # � ��~�j�xzehj����*®

Kô��©§ja~�*?�«{°��~����h�§ja{_x�v/�_{°xz~����[{h�_©§j ¯"dfeh�«vf�_�wx��«��{�[©«©§�'¬ v�j*²?x�ja{�v��§�_{�v�x�� � �w�6��©FÄ"²?xz~�jai|hi IÃ�§ik�«{w®��v�eh�§{�� · � Ä$Iô¹�vz��ehj6ikj�v���v�v�eh�'¬�{C�«{ - ��/N¯

¥ j@{h�'¬¶v��Fja�6� ª9uÃ��|h~Qi�j6x�eh�w�pª9�_~Q�*�_i���|wx��«{h�fx�e�jJj*²?x�~��[�F��©��'xz�§�_{pv�©§�_�Pj�v [��� � \ � R �[{P� [��� � \uR � P[ �� � \ � R @ �� U N [ > y � \ [ �� � \ �� R @ �� U H � [ �� � \��� R @ �� U

H�� ��� [��� � \��� R @ �� U y l [��� � \ �� R @ �� U H [��� � \ �� R @ �� U��H�� � � [��� � \�� ��!� @ �� U y l [��� � \ � @ �� U H [��� � \ R @ �� U � e

·�����¹

ó È�û ó æ

Page 12: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� 6

dfehj��6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��ª � R � ��v �[{���©§�_���_|�v�P[��� � \ R � @ �� U N [ > y � \ [��� � \ �R � @ �� U H � [��� � \��R � @ �� U

H�� � � [��� � \��R � @ �� U y l [��� � \ �R � @ �� U H [��� � \ �R � @ �� U��H�� � � [��� � \ � ���� @ �� U y l [��� � \ RA@ �� U H [��� � \ � @ �� U � e

·�� ' ¹

dfehjpxzj6~zi � �� ��� � ��!� ��v�x�ehjô�_~z�_�w�§ja{Xxf�[x�xzehj��P�_�§{Xx����� R ¯Jdfeh��vf©���v�xf�_~z�_�w�«j6{Xx���v��*�_i���|wx�j��C¦?u�«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{¨�[ª@xzehjk{h�w�h�[©���~����h�§ja{_xp±'�[©«|hjavô�'xpx�e�j�{h�w�wj�vô�*��{Xx��[�«{hja���§{�x�ehj�ªS���6j��_�h�F�_v�� xzj�x�� ��«{ x�ehj�|��X¬��«{��Cx�~z�«��{h��©«j � R�¯

D*ij D*ji

S

Tij Tji

S

m

i j

n r

s

B��«��|�~�jô�OP � �?�a�[©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{C��ªQx�e�j�j*²?x�~����§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{�F���«{Xxzv����� R ��{�����R � ��ª�{��?���[©(��~����h�§ja{_x�v

B��§�_|h~�j ��P"Ä/�w��j6®N|h�?¬��«{��Cx�j*xz~z��ehja�h~z�dfehj��6�?j�8°�*�«j6{Xxzv��@� � � �[{�� � � ��~�jô|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h������~z��i�j6x�ja~zv�x�eP�'xÃ�6��{Xx�~z��©Fx�e�j�*�_i¦h�«{��'xz�§�_{��ª

ª9|�©§©«uC|h�?¬��«{�� �[{�� �*ja{Xx�j6~zja� v�©§�_�Pj�v6¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 13: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

� � � � � � FÃ~��wj6~

�(® vz��ehj6ikj ��� ' � � � '

�(® vz��ehj6ikj ��� ' � � � �

�J~�j�v�ja{Xx o1j*x�e��?� ��� ' ®���� ' � ®y���w��� � �

�J~�j�v�ja{Xx o1j*x�e��?� ��� ' ®���� ' � ®y���w��� � �

d��[¦h©«j ' P Á �6�6|h~����*u���ª"�h�9;3j6~zj6{Xx�±�ja~zv��§�_{�v��[ª�x�ehj�{�j6¬ vz��ehjai�jô�«{¨��I�~zj6�_|h©«��~��a��v�j

d�� v�|hir|��ü�3x�ehj�v�j�vz��ehj6ikj�vne��;±_j�_{h©§u¨v��§²Xxzew®´��~��wj6~ô�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{-�[{��-�[~zj��«{��_j6{hja~z��©�v�ja�6��{��?®�_~z�hj6~n�_�6�*|�~z�[x�jô¦h|wxÃx�ehjau ¦Fja�6��ikj�eh�«��e�j6~�®N�_~z�wja~����6�6|h~��'x�j��«{1xzehj�©«�§{hj��[~p�6��v�jôª9��~pv��_ikj�±;��©§|�jav ��ªxzehj�����~z��i�j6x�ja~zv � ·Sv�j6j&-«�a��/9¹ � � ��{�� � �_��v�j6j.-«���0/��[{�� d���¦h©«j ' ¯� � )6�������)6�Q�ô�")*��dfe�j°{��'xz|h~��[©@ik�w�wj6©/ª9��~�xzehjC��~��_���[�X�'x��«��{U�[ª����6��|�v�x����6v��§{­� +P|h�«�A�«vôxzehj�6��ik�h~zjavzv��«¦h©«j�ln�;±?�§ja~�®s?x��A*_javJj��X|��'xz�§�_{�v6¯ Q �'¬�j6±_j6~�x�e�j6�«~/|�v�j�ª9��~@x�eh��v/��|h~��F�_v�j���v/�w�18°�*|h©§x�v�ik��©§©F�[ik�h©«� xz|��wj ��ª(±;��~����'xz�§�_{xze��'xn�6��~z~�j�v��F��{P�hv@xz�°���6��|�v�x����6v��hehja{h��ikja{��h¯

³ {x�e��[x"�a��v�j@x�e�j�©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j���ÄJ|h©«j6~"ik�?�hj6©?�«v���ja{hj6~��[©«©«uô�n~�j���v���{���¦h©«jJ��{hj_¯�dfehjfÄJ|h©«j6~"ja�X|��[x��«��{�v��~�jô�wja{h�[xzja� ¦?u P � F H � [ � \ M)H�� [ � \�� N O ·��6�X¹��{��Cx�ehja�§~ ©«�«{hja��~���v��[x��«��{{hja��~f��v�x�j����wu�+��'¬ � � ¬�~��§x�j�v�P

� F H [ ��� [ � � \ � \ M H [�� � [ � � \ � \ � N O @ ·�����¹

³ {A��{ù�«�wj��[©/v��§x�|��[x��«��{ü��¬�j�¬���v�eA�[{ù�[�h��~��;²w�«ik�[x��«��{U�[ªfx�e�j°©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja�¶v�u?v�x�jairxze��'x¦Fj �����!������� ���� � �� �[{P� � ��� i� ����� �O��� � �� ¯A³ { �h~����Åxz�«�6j��J¬�j{�j6ja�ùx��U�§{Xx�~z�w�w|��6jv���ikj�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{A¬��§x�e �� �§jaik��{h{ v��_©§±_j6~�¯

�)"$# 7n,$D �1( =@, � (+*�,-;>D ;^9 (� ,-� ? (/D)D � ;>.�� � =dfe�j��«{Xx�j6~zjav�xô�[ª�����?�w�1|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h���vô�C~��'xzehj6~p~��'x��«��{P�[©�¬��;u �«{��«{_xz~��w�w|P�*�«{h� �h�«vzv��«���[x��«��{ü¯�dfehj+P|w²�w�1;Fja~�ja{��*j�v��h©«� x�x��«{h���h~z���F�_v�ja�C¦Xu���?j�¬�~��§x�j�v�P

[ � [ m� \ H � [ m�� \$\ � l y [��m \ [ m�� y m� \ � l ·��a�_¹¬�e�j6~zj �m e���©��hv@ª9�_~�x�ehjô���?jp�;±_j6~��[�_j��[ª m��U�[{�� m��¯Jdfeh�«vf�;±_j6~��[��j�ja{�v�|h~�j�v@xze��'x����?j�� vfv���©§�§x�xz�§{h���v@|��X¬��«{��k�«{°v�|��Pja~zv���{h�����6�_v�j_��¦h|hx/x�e��«v/eh��©��hvJ�_{h©§u��«{�{h��{h©«�«{hja��~/�6�_v�j_¯ Á {��[x/���wj6{Xxz�«�a�[©N�_¦h|hx/±�ja~�u

ó È�û ó æ

Page 14: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �_�

�6©§�Xv�j_�?ª9��~zi|h©��'xz�§�_{C��vfx�e�jôª9��©«©§�'¬��«{h�<P

[ � [ m \ H � [ m �>\ \ � l y ������� [ [ �m \$\ [ � [ m �>\ y � [ m 1\$\ � l ·���[¹�«{ ¬�eh����e ������� [ \ ª9�_~n���w���[�_��{���©§��v���¦h©«jÃi��'xz~��§² N `1j � �h¬��§x�e � N � � � � [�� j e � � e � ��\ eh��©��hvª9�_~fx�ehj�j6²w�h~�j�v�v��«��{ P

������� [ \ N `1j � � � � [ ��� ��� [�� j \ e ������� [�� � \ e ������� [�� � \$\ @ ·��a�_¹¥ jô�6�[{ja�_v��«©§u���ehj���*�x�e��[x�xzeh�«v�ª9�_~�i ��©§©«�'¬ v@ª9|�©§©(|h�?¬��«{��w�«{h��§ª���©§© � � �[~zjn�[ª�v���i�jpv��«��{Q�_xzeh��v/xz�§ikj¬��§x�e���|wxn�_v�v�|hik�§{��xze��'x �m ��v�x�ehj����?j��;±�ja~z����j_¯ Á vn��©«�«{hja��~���v�j��C±_j6~�v��«��{Q�X¬�j�v�|�����j�vyx0P

[ � � [ m� \ � H � � [ m�� \ � � \ � l y ����� ��� [ [ �m \ \ [ � [ � � \ y � [ � \ \ ·��76_¹¥ ehja~�j �m �6�[{¶¦FjC�h~z�w�w|��6ja�U¦?uU��{XuUv�u?ikikj*xz~����°�;±�ja~z�����«{h��¯ � �Xj�8°�*�«j6{Xx � �«v�x��¨¦FjC��eh�Xv�ja{

v�i��[©«©Ø�w�«{ ��~��wj6~�xz���X�[�«{¦Fj6{�j�3hxn��ªQxzehj�j*²?x�~��kvyx��[¦h�«©«� xyu°��ª"��©«�§{�ja�[~fª9�_~�i�|h©��'x��«��{Q¯

�)" ! 7n,$D �1( =@, � (+*�,-;>D (/D �>.$; �)(/.n( &)&)=@;��c,$? (+*�,-;>D¥ j/{��'¬Uj6²?x�j6{P�ôx�ehj�eh�«��ew®´��~��wja~Q���a�*|h~��'xzj@�*��{Pvyxz~�|��*x��«��{���ªwx�ehjC3�~zv�x�v�ja�*x��«��{ôxz� x�e�j��6�_v�j/�[ªh±'�[~z�«��¦h©«j�6�?j�8°�*�«j6{Xxzva¯ ¥ j=3P~zv�x vyx��[~�x�ª9~z��i � �7I�vz�6�[©��[~��a��v�jAP

� F H [ J�[ Q \ E+[ Q \$\ M N O @ ·N�[�_¹

FÃ{hjÃ{h�'±�ja© xyuk¬��§x�e~�j�v��Fja�*x/x�� - �A/ü�[{��?-ê�0/´�w�«v/x�eP�'xf¬�jì���{_x�x���v��;±_j�x�ehjp��~��wja~/�[ª����6�6|h~����*uª9��~��{h�_{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi ¦�����*?��~z��|�{��.+��'¬��w~zj6�h~zjav�j6{Xxzja�°e�j6~zjp¦?u Ji[ Q \ ¯ FÃ|h~f�h~z���F�_v�� xz�§�_{°ª9�_~fx�eh��v��h|h~z�F�_v�j��v�x��°���h�h©«u�x�e�j�eh�§�_e�_~z�hj6~ �wja~��«±'�'x��«��{���Fj6~��'xz��~�v/xz��x�ehj�� ������� J�[ Q \ E+[ Q \ ¯

dfeh��v��«vk�w�_{hj ¦Xuù�«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§{h�-±'�[~z�«��¦h©§j J E+[ Q \ �@ª9~z��i �§xzv�±'�[©«|hjav [ JaE \ � �_{­j�����eA{h�w�wj_�/�[{P�ª9~z��iÂ�§xzvô{��?���[©J��~����h�§ja{_x�v [ � E \ � ¯ ¥ jk��¦hxz�[�«{¶�*j6©«©J�«{_xzj6~�ªS���6j�±'�[©«|hj�v [ J E \ f� f j � ��{�� [ J E \ `� fkj � �'x��¦�vz�*��v�vz�[j Q � f j� � ¯dfehj�~zjav�|h©§x��«{h��v��P�'x����[©«©«uCv�jaik� ® �w��v��6~�j6x��«µ6ja�v���e�j6ikjô¬�~��§x�j�v�P

������� [ � \ � � � F HXw � fkj � y w � `1j � N O ·N�w��¹¬��§x�e

w � f j� � N O @ � [$[ J E \ f� fkj � H [ J E \ `� f j� � \ ·N����¹dfe�j¨�[¦F�'±�j �;±�j6~��[�_�§{����[ªô�h©«|�v°��{��¸i��«{?|�v�±'�[©«|hj�v°�*�_~�~zjav��P�_{��hv�x��A�¶�6j6{Xx�~��[© �w�1;3j6~zj6{��6�§{h�¶ª9�_~�®i�|h©��'x��«��{¸·1D�{h� ���§jai��[{h{Uv��_©§±_j6~HEy¹*¯ Á �a�*�_~z�w�«{h�Cx�� x�ehjk��eh�_�«�6j���i��_{h�°xzehj��[¦F�'±�j,D��«{_xzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{�v�P�[~��[ikj*xzj6~�vLEÅ�h�§xp�6��{1¦Pj��[ª@v�ja�*�_{�� x�� v��§²?x�e1�_~z�wja~Ã�_�6�*|�~z�_�*u�¯ ¥ j{h��x�j��«{¨���_v�v��«{h��x�eP�'x xzehj���wja���ª@��eh�?�_v��§{h� +�|h² �«{Xx�j6~z�F��©��'x��«��{1��©§©«�'¬ v�x��°j�v��a�[�Fjôx��kxzehj�v�ja�6��{��?®´��~��wja~�©«�«i��§xz�[x��«��{¨�_�w±��w�6�[x�j��C¦?u¥ |1�[{�� ¥ �[{h�¨·H-§� ' /ß¹�ª9�_~no1mÃs � � v���ehjaikjava¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 15: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�;� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

�)"�� % *C( �z,$. , � (+*C,$;>D³´x��a�[{U¦Pjk{hj��*javzvz�[~zuxz�1vyx��[¦h�«©§��v�j�xzehj�v���e�j6ikj��wj�3�{�j��«{-x�ehj��h~zj6±?�«��|�vôv�ja�*x��«��{ü�(j�v��Fja�6�«��©§©«u¨¬�ehja{{���{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi ikjav�ehjav���~�jp|�v�ja�(¯

Á v��6~��§x�ja~������[ªQ�hjav��§�_{kª9��~f�wjav��§�_{h�«{h��x�e�jÃv�xz�[¦��§©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{kx�ja~�i�va�_¬�jn�h~z���F�_v�jfx�e�jnª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{�����{hj�v�P·S��¹ ®(v�xz��¦h�«©§��v��[x��«��{���v��h�§~zja�*x�©«uÃ�_�'±�j6~z{hj��æ?upx�e�j��w��v��6��{Xx��«{?|h�§x��«jav��h~��w�w|P�*ja�ô¦?upx�e�j/�«{_xzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{�v

��e��_v�j6{C�«{ x�ehj��6j6{Xx�~��[©ü�h�9;3j6~zj6{��6ja�Cx�ja~�i·S�§�ß¹´®/v�xz��¦h�§©«��v��[x��«��{Cv�eh��|�©«�°��©§©«�'¬ ª9|h©«©3|h�?¬��§{��h�§{h� ·S�_v�ªS�[~f��v��[©«©3��eP�[~����Åxzj6~z� xz�«�av@�[~zjn�«{°xzehj�v���ikj

�h�§~zja�*x��«��{ü�h��{��°xzehj��«{_xzj6~z�P�_©«�[x��«��{ �«v���©«v���ª9|h©«©ü|h�?¬��§{P��¹·S�§�«��¹ ®Fv��§{P�*jJxzehj@©«ja���h�§{h��ja~�~z��~(¬��«©«©[¦Pj��w�§~zja�*x�©«uÃ�_�'±�ja~�{hj�� ¦?uÃx�ehj 3P~zv�xQ�wj6~z�«±;�[x��«±�j�v(�[ª?j6�«��ja{X±'��©§|hj�v6�

¬�j��w�k{h�[x {�j6ja�Cx����«{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xzjÃxzehj6i!�§{1�k�*�Xvyxz©§uC¬��;u_¯

w ����� � " �� f j � N w � f j� � y � � f j� � ·N� ' ¹¬��§x�e � � f j� � N O @ � � ������� [ J � f j� � \ [ [ J E \ f� f j� � y [ J E \ `� f j� � \ ·N�'�X¹¬�e�j6~zj J � f j� � ��v�x�ehjôv��«ik�h©«jp�;±_j6~��[��j [ J � H J � f j \ � l ¯Jdfehjô�*�?j�8°�6�§ja{_x ��¬��«©§©ü��©§©«�'¬ � 3�{�jnxz|h{h�«{h����ªxzehj ������� � ��� �w��v�v��§�P�'x��«��{ �[ª�x�ehj�vz��ehjai�j���{��v�eh�_|h©«� ¦Fj�©§j�v�vf�_~fja�X|��[©üx�� >�¯�)" � # 0 . ,$D� (+=G, � � ���Ag.-�1=��;^=@? A).-(+*�,-; Ddfe�j��§{Xx�ja~��F��©��'xz�§�_{���vJ{h�'¬¸�[�h��©§�«ja��x��ôxzehj�±'�[©«|hjav@�[ªFx�ehj�©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j�� +�|h²?j�v � � [ m \ � ¯Js?xz�[¦��§©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{��vf�«{�v����§~zja�¦?u°x�e�j����§jai��[{h{ v��_©§±_j6~f�h~z���F�_v�ja�¦Pja©§�'¬�¯Jdfeh��v�~zjav�|h©§xzvf�«{ P

w ����� � " �� f j � N w � f j� � y � � f j� � ·N����¹

¬��§x�e Pw � f j � N O @ � [ [ � � [ m \ � \ f� f j� � H [ � � [ m \ � \ `� fkj � \ ·N�[�_¹

��{��5P � � fkj � N O @ � �&������� [ � f j � \ [$[ � � [ m \ � \ f� f j� � y [ � � [ m \ � \ `� fkj � \ ·N���[¹�)"� !^0 . ,$D� (+=G, � � ���Ag.-�1=��;^=@? A).-(+*�,-; Ddfe�jôÄ@|h©§ja~ ja�X|��[x��«��{�v���~�jp¬�~z� x�x�j6{ �«{1v�eh�_~�x0P

�'F H � [ � \ MBH � [ � \ � N O ·N�[�_¹�_~7P

�'F H � � �� N O ·N��6_¹� j*x�|�v�wj6{h��x�j � � R�xzehj��«{_xzj6�_~z��©J�[ª�x�ehj�{h�_~�i���©J±�ja�*x��_~��[©«��{h� x�e�j��§{Xx�ja~�ªS�_�*jk¦Fj*xy¬�j6j6{Uxy¬��1�*j6©«©�v6�] ����� � ��{�� ] ����� R ¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 16: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� � '

dfe�j��«{Xx�j6~z�F��©��'x��«��{-�«vp{h�'¬ �[�h�h©«�«ja�1xz� x�ehj�±'�[©«|hjavp�[ª�x�ehjk©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j�� +�|w²�±_ja�*x���~�v �«{-x�ehjk{h�_~�i��[©�h�§~zja�*x��«��{

�� [ m \ � @ � � R�¯@dfeh��vf���«±�j�v�P

w � ��� � " �� R N w�� R y � � R · ' �_¹¬��§x�e P

w � f j� � N O @ � [ [ � � [ m \ � \ � R�@ � � R H [ � � [ m \ � \ R � @ � � R \ · ' ��¹��{��5P

� � f j � N O @ � � ������� [�� � Ri\ [ [ � � [ m \ � \ � R @ � � R y [ � � [ m \ � \ R � @ � � Ri\ · ' ��¹¬�e�j6~zj � � R��«vn�wj�3�{�ja� ¦?u P

� � R N �� [ [ m � H m+R \ � l \ @ � � RA@ · 'A' ¹

�)"�� %�A)? ? ( = � ;^9 *�� � � &g(k*�,$( . � ��� � ?��dfe�jp�_©§�_¦��[©ü��©§�_��~z� xzehi ª9��~ �6��ik�h|wxz�§{��kx�ehj=+�|h²?j�v��6��{¦Fj�v�|�i�ikj�� �_v�ª9��©«©§�'¬ va¯

��¯ Á ¦�����*?��~z��|�{��.+��'¬ m N [� e � E e � Ge� \ �[{�� ���Pja~�xz|h~z¦��'xz�§�_{� N [ � � e � [� E \ e � [�� \ e � \ �P��{ ja�_��e±_j6~�x�j*²°��ª�xzehj�ikjav�e ��~�jô�_�§±_j6{ü¯�_¯ � ��ik�h|wxzj�xzehj©«�§{�ja�[~z��v�j��J+P|w²wjav �� N � � [ m \ @ � e �� N � � [ m \ @ � ��{¨j�����e ±�ja~�xzj*²ù·9±�ja~�®

xzj*²w¬���v�jô©«�X�_�P¹Å¯

�h¯ � ��ik�h|wxzjkx�ehj�{h�w�h��©J��~����w�«j6{Xx�v ���� e ���� �[ª/xzehj�©«�§{hj��[~z�«v�ja�4+�|w²wj�vô��{¶ja�_��e�±�ja~�xzj*² ·Sj6©«j*®ikja{_xy¬���v�jp©«�?���P¹*¯@dfeh��vf�«v �h��{hjô¦?uC�[���h©§u?�«{h��x�ehj�{��?���[©(��~����h�§ja{_xfª9�_~�i�|h©«�<P

[������ \ � N >� � ��� [ ] � \ �

����� �� � ��� [� \

��# � � [

�� \ # �� w � # · ' �X¹

' ¯/sXxz��~�x �� �"#���/� ���.��������%&��� ���1�0��� P�6��ik�h|wxzjpx�ehj�j6²Xxz~z���P�_©«�[x�j��v�©§�_�Pj�v=P

[������ \ � R @ �� U N [ > y � \ [������ \$\ �� R @ �� U H � [������ \ \��� R @ �� UH�� � � [������ \$\�� � R @ �� U y l [������ \ \ �� R @ �� U H [������ \ \ �� R @ �� U �H�� � � [������ \$\ � ��!� @ �� U y l [ ����� \$\ � @ �� U H [ ����� \$\ RA@ �� U�� e

· ' ��¹

·Ø�[{�� �[{P�[©«����ª9��~ �� [ �� [ m e�� \$\ \ � RX¯dfe�jô�6j6{Xx�~��[©ü�h�9;3j6~zj6{��6ja� +�|w²�«v �hja�w|��6ja�5P

w�� R N O @ � [ �� �GH ���� � R H �

�R y ���

�R � \ @ � � R · ' �_¹

�«{ ¬�eh����e P�� N [ �� e �� \ · ' �[¹

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 17: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�a� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

�P¯@ÄJ±'�[©«|��'xzjÃxzehj�v�xz�[¦��§©«�«vz�'xz�§�_{Cxzj6~zi P

� � fkj � N O @ � � ������� [ � � R \ [$[ �� � R&@ � � R y [ �� R � @ � � R \ · ' �_¹¬�e�j6~zj � � R �«vn�wj�3�{�ja� ¦?u P

� � R N [ � � e � � \ [$[ m � H m+R \ � l \ @ � � RA@ · ' 6_¹�h¯ � ��ik�h|wxzjÃxzehj=3�{���©üja�h��jG+�|w² ��v7P

w ����� � " �� R N w � R y � � R ·S�_�_¹

��{�� ���h�¶·Sv�|h¦�v�x�~����*x�¹��§x�x�� +�|w² ��vzv�jai¦h©«u°�'x ±_j6~�x�j*² �p· U?¹Å¯�)" � � ; A)D )( = � �L;>D� ),-*C,$;>D �M��_|h{��h��~�u��*�_{��w�§x��«��{�v�e��;±_j��p�*~z|��*���[©?�«{�+�|hja{��*jf�_{�x�e�jf�X|���©§�§xyu��[ªF�h~����Åxz�«�a�[©?���6��|�v�x�����v��«i|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6¯ln��{w®´~zj�+�j��Åx��«{h��¦F��|h{P�h�[~zu��6��{��w�§x��«��{Pv/�[~zj�{hj��*javzvz�[~zu��§{��_~z�hj6~Jxz��;±��_�«��v���|h~��«��|PvJ~�j�+�ja�*x��«{h��¬f�;±�j�vxz��xz~z�;±_j6©f�«{­xzehj1�*��ik�h|hxz�'xz�§�_{��[©��w�_i��[�«{ü¯­³ { x�eh��vk�h~zj6©«�§ik�«{��[~zuAv�x�|��wu_�/¬�j1v�e���©§©f{h��x°�*��{Pv����wj6~��~��_¦h©§jai�v�¬�� xzeA�F�_vzv��«¦h©«j°~�j�+�ja�*x��«��{�va�J�[{��¶¬�jCv�e��[©«©/|Pv�j°�«{ùxzehjC�h~zjav�j6{Xxzja�¶�6��©«�6|h©«�[x��«��{�v|h�?¬��§{P�ªS��~H3Pj6©��ù�*��{P�w� xz�§�_{�v�~zj6©«u?�§{��¨��{¶xzehj s?x�j6�_j6~�® ¥ �[~zik�§{�� +P|w²Av��h©«�§x�x��«{h�P¯�³ {­v�eh��~�xa�R+�|h²?j�v�¦Fj*xy¬�j6ja{¦F��|�{��h�[~zuC�6j6©«©ü�[{��j*²?x�ja~�{P�[©(ikja�w�«|hi �[~zjô�6��ik�h|wxzja� ��v�ª9�_©§©«�'¬ v7P

w�� M�F ��� " ���� N f [ m � \ � � H

` [ m \ �

¬�e�j6~zj N � ����@ �J� � ¦Fj6�«{h�¸x�e�j-{h�_~�i���©nxz�¸¦F��|�{��h�[~zu��Tm ��{�� � ~zjav��Fja�Åxz�§±_j6©«u x�ehj

¦P����*?��~z��|h{P�.+��'¬ ��{�� �Pja~�xz|h~z¦��'xz�§�_{ v��Pj��*�13�ja� �'x�ªS��~H3Pj6©��(¯

�)"�� ,$?�� (� �+(/D�� ,$D�dfe�j�xz�§ikj°�_�w±'�[{h�_�§{h� ��v���vpª9�_~ôx�ehj1�0I v���e�j6ikj�� � |h{h��j6®��ô|hx�xz� �_{hj��(xze��'x�a�[{U¦Pj�|Pv�j��-�«{Ux�ehj©«�«{hja��~���v�j��°±_j6~�v��«��{ �wj�3�{�ja� �§{ù·Ø�_¹Å¯

� ) ���������� � )6#$� ���)6��C�

�"$# 2 � ),$( D�� � � . . �ÄJ²Xxzj6{�v��«��{°xz� ' ®LI ��ª�ikja�h�«��{�*ja©§©�v��«vf{��[x��*��ik�h©«���6�'xzja�(¯ FÃ{�j/�y|�v�x�e��;±�jnx���xz�A*�jô��v�x�e�jÃj6²w��eP�[{h�_jv�|h~�ªS���6jæFj*xy¬�j6ja{xy¬��k±�ja~�xz�«�6jav��[ªJ�[{ j6©«j6ikj6{Xx��wx�ehjôxz~����[{���©«javf�*�_{h{hja�*x��«{h�<P

� x�ehj�ik���h�w©«j��[ª�x�ehj�¦P�[~�©«�§{O*?�«{h��x�ehj��6��{�v����wj6~zja��[�h���*j�v6�

� x�ehj��6j6{Xx�ja~��[ª"��~��;±?� xyuk�[ª�x�e�jôªS���*j�vf�[ª�x�ehj�ja©§jai�ja{Xx e��;±?�§{h��x�e��«v�¦P�[~ ��v���{j��w��j_�

� x�ehj��6j6{Xx�ja~��[ª"��~��;±?� xyuk�[ª�x�e�j�j6©«j6ikj6{Xxa¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 18: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �;�

M�u1�[{���©§�_��u¬�� xze-�;®LI�F��{�j�v�eh��|h©�� ~��'x�e�j6~Ã�6��{�v�x�~z|��*xp�*ja©§©�vn�_v ~zj6�_|h©«��~Ã�_v �F�_vzv��«¦h©«j�¬�ehj6{�x�ehjikj�v�e��«v"{h�_{w® vyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja�ü¯Qdfehj6{Q�[��{hj�¬���|h©���¬���v�e�x�e�jf�6j6©«©«v�¦Fjf~�j��Åxz��{h��©«j/�P�[~��[©«©§ja©§ja�h�§�Fja��v��6j6{Xx�ja~�j����~��_|h{��x�e�j��[���«�6jav ¬�e�j6{ x�e�jikjav�e¨��v�x�e�j ' ®LI j��X|h�§±'��©§ja{_xnx��JB�~��«ja�w~z����e�vy®��ôj6©«©«j6~�ikjav�eü¯:B��«~zv�xa�F� x��vf�«i��F��~�xz��{Xx�xz�°�wj�3P{h� xzjôx�ehj�v�e����Pjô�[ª�x�e�j�±���©«|hikj*xz~����Ãj6©«j6ikj6{Xxzva¯

�" ! � D��� * � *C=�( �� c=@,�� (k*�,$;>D³ { ' ®�I��hv��P���*jô��v 3�~�vyx �w�«±?�«�hja� �§{Xxz��ehj*²h�[e�ja�w~��h¯ Bh�_~ v��A*�jô�[ª"v��«ik�h©«�«�6� xyu_�wx�ehj��a��v�jô�[ªJ� � ��~�xzjav��«��{ikj�v�e ��vn�*�_{�v��«�wja~�j��(¯�dfe?|�va��¬�j��*�_{�v��«�wja~�~�j��Åx��[{h�_©§j�vf���[~��[©«©§ja©§ja�h�«�Pj��hv�·ßxzehj6~zja�[ªßx�ja~n�6��©§©«ja��� ����J ( �;¹Å�¬�e��_v�j ±��_©§|hikj�v/�[~zj � � N v Q v�� v� ¯�³´x��«v��wj�v��«~z��¦h©«j x���j6{��°|h�C¬��§x�e�xzj*xz~z��ehja�w~��[©Pj6©«j6ikj6{Xx�v {xze?|�v6�?�_{hjÃi�|�v�xfv��h©«� xfx�e�jav�jæh©«�w��*wv6¯ � j6x�|�v�ª9�w�*|Pvf��{�xy¬����h�§±?��v��«��{�v��*�_{�v��«�wja~�j���¦Fj*ª9��~zj�¯Jdfehj,3�~�vyx·����w¹pik�§{��§ik�«µ6jav�x�ehj�{?|hi�¦Pja~��[ª�v�|h¦h®Øxzj*x�~��[e�ja�w~��h�(¦h|hx��ja{hj6~��'xzjavô� ¦h�§�¨�6��~zj�ja©§jaikj6{Xxa��·9±��_©§|�i�j� � � ���_¹*�Q�[{��-ª9�_|h~��Pja~��«�hehja~z��©Jj6©«j6ikj6{Xx�v�·��J��©«|hikj � � � �(X¹Å¯�dfehj°v�ja�*�_{��U�w�§±?��v��«��{ ·����P¹puX�«j6©��hvxy¬������wja{_xz�«�a�[©��h~z�«v�i�v6�Jj�����eA¦Fj6�«{h�-v�|h¦3�w�«±X���wj��A�«{_xz��xzeh~zj6j°xzj*xz~z��ehja�w~��h¯ M�|wxa�@�«{­�_~z�hj6~�xz��x���*_j�«{Xx��C�_�6�6��|h{Xx�x�e�j{hja¬ �6j6©«©«v x�e��[xì��«©§©�¦Pj��wj�3P{hja�(�3�[{P� ��|h~n��i¦h�§x��«��{ xz�C�*�_ikj�¦�����*Cx��C�JB��«{h�§x�jIÃ�1;Fja~�ja{��*j�vnvz��ehj6ikj��P� ' ®LI x�~z���[{h�_|h©«�[x��«��{ ���wj6{Xx����6��©üxz�kx�ehj Bh~z�§j��w~�����e�v�®��ôja©§©«j6~�xyu?�Fj�ikjav�e1�§{��'®�I��vf�h~z���F�_v�ja�(¯

dfehj���~��_�P�Xv�j����w�«±?�«v��§�_{¸·����1»X¾�� »���» ¡'¢w ! ¿"� In�«±?�«v��«��{ü�ü�_~#���$� ¹pv��h©«� x�vôx�ehj%� ����J ( �§{¶v��§²���wja{_xz�«�a�[©wxzj*xz~z��ehja�w~z��{Pv6�'¬��§x�e�±_��©«|hikjav � � ��(h�[j�����e�¦Pja�§{h�ôxzehj �«i��[��jf��ªF�§xzv/{hj6�«��e?¦F��~�v��«{°�ôik�§~z~z��~�¯Á ©§©"xzehjav�j�j6©«j6ikj6{Xxzvpe��;±_j�«{U�6��ikik��{U�C�w���[�_��{���©���ª/x�e�j�� ����J ( ¯dfe�j��6�X�_~z�h�§{��[x�j�vn��ª@x�ehj�xzj*x�~��'®e�ja�w~z��{�v�~zjav�|h©§x��«{h��ª9~��_i x�ehjpxzeh~�jaj��w�§±?��v��«��{Pv��[~zjpv�eh�'¬�{C�«{?B��§�_|h~�j�vp�a�k�[{��-���_�w�wj6�Fj6{��h�§{h��|��P�_{xzehj�©«�?�a�[©({?|hi�¦Pja~zvf��ªQx�e�j�¦h©§�w��*°±_j6~�x����*j�v6¯ B��§�_|h~zjav��k�[{�� 6kv�e��'¬ x�e�j#���°��{��&���$�r�w�«±X��v��§�_{�v6¯

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z

0

2

4

6

X0

2

4

6

Y

Y

X

Z

B��§�_|h~zjô�<P'���C�h�§±?��v��«��{

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z

0

2

4

6

X0

2

4

6

Y

Y

X

Z

B��«��|�~�j 6OP'���$�r�h�§±?��v��«��{

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 19: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

1 2

8

34

5 6

7

������������ �������������������� ���!�����"$#%��'&'�(�)�*+���,�.-0/!132)4

56����7��8& #���9&�����*:<; :>= ?<@A:

� BDC�E F�EHG8EJI�K BL�%E C�E M�E F8K BNC�E!�%E OPE F8KC BDC�E M�E O�EHGQK BL�%E I�E F�ERG�K BSM�E C�E OPE F8KM BDI�E T�EHG8E O8K BSF�E!�%ERG�E M8K BUG�E M�E OPE F8KO B9��EJC�E O�EJI�K BL�%E I�ERG�E T8K BST�ERG�E OPE F8KI BDC�EJI�EHG8E O8K BL�%ERG�E M�E T8K BNI�E T�E OPE F8KF BL�%E M�E OPE T8K BL�%E I�E OPE F8K

���!�%���V���%�$W�����XN&)&'�0��Y��Z��0��#���9&�����*[��Z���8&'�!\��Z"]����^�����������������0_`������� ���!���V"]�%�$&Y�a&'Y����Z��!"bX"]����8&V*'c����H&�!���8*

d+eDf gihkj�lnmoj[p'p9qsrtj[hVj�u�v�w�xLyzh{ ��|*'Y������ �����7~}�?,�8��@A���[�8�Q�����S� �������]�]��}ABS����?<@,��K6&Y���������c���"[c ������Y��Z�����P*�*'���0Y�&Y��Q&&Y�`)���0Y��������*'���9"S�%�)|�P�&L������&L�a���������Y��P�%�'������#���9&�����*$�L������*�E�"]���k������#���A��!��7��8&��

� &'Y�`�7�(Z�Z���`��"�&'Y�`3Z���`��������3��&�!����&Y��*'|&L���7#���9&�����*�E

� &'Y��}%�����Q�U�����<����� ���8��}7��"[&'Y��"S���)3*+��"�&'Y�`��!��7��8&�Y���#��!����&Y���*k�Z��%|���,�)�%���7�%��E

� &'Y���)#��%�!���7`�)��8&'��Q�V��"�&'Y�`��!�����8&�E

��Y���

� &'Y��}%�3�[�Q�D����������� ���8��}<��"k�>�%�!#%�� "S�%�)��(*��!&*���¡ ��¡ ��¡<�H"k�!&������7c����*'�*�������� ���)��&'A���������*��&Y�������*'�E��!&k�(*a&'Y�¢���!�8*93*L&�c �����%&k��"[&Y��&'������������E��D¡ �¡£&'Y�`���(Z�Z���`��"��H&0*��������%�*9&+3Z���%E

� &'Y� }�¤ �P�N�$¥ �¦����� ���8��}.��"k��� �����7��%&���*¢�H&0*���¡ ��¡ *�¡§�H"+&'Y��"]����7��¢�(*¢��������&'�Zs����*'��Z��&'Y������7��8&3¨6��&'Y�������*'�E$�H&��(*`&Y�����!�8*93*L&`c �����%&3E£�N¡ �¡A&'Y�s}������Q�U���%�©�%��� �3�8��}>��"a&'Y�������'�%�*9&*9���9"S�%�)�¡

{ �� ����������&'�(�)>&Y��Q&§��Y����&'�&'�0��Y�3Z��0���'3*9���H&�"]�'�%�ª?<@A:«&Y���¬�����V&Y�s�����7��8&*�"S�����*���'A�'3��&0�����%�!�&'������������*�¡�­®�¯&Y���*~����*'�E6&Y�§�)����£�L������*�&'Y�A�7�(Z�Z������"k&'Y�����������*9&7�Z��%���"°&'Y�&)&���Y��Z�����§&��&Y�����(Z�Z����*|��"t&'Y����&Y���|�Z����*�¡`±+Y�7�)����(*°�%�������&'3Z§�!�.&'Y��(*|�a���,�������!���0_�*�E����8&'��'3Z§���������Z�&'Y�¢#���9&�����*���"$&Y�¢�7�*'Y�¡����!�%���'3*��3C7����Z ��M7*'Y��Q�²&Y�`&��%�)`��"�&'Y��Z���#8�(*'�!�%���"�������!��7��8&��!�8&'���������*�E������)�%�Z�������&'��&'Y�`���(ZA����Z�����³���&'Y���Z�*�E���*'cP3��&�!#%�����¡

­®�<\��0*L&��!�P*L&0�������E������*'Y�������Z.cP�%�!�8&�����&|&'Y���&�&'Y���������0�Q&�Z>�������*|�7�!���!�7��´��&'Y�7�����7���(�����Z���**9��c���&'�����7���'�%�6Z����&��&'Y�V���������*£� )&L�a����&'Y�kc ��c ���Z��(�)�������6&'��&Y�V�)��!�(*t����Z�&'Y�k3Z���3*£&'Y������'�8*'*�¡ { ��&'Y�°��&'Y���zYP����Z�E��!&a�����~� °*'Y��Q���7&'Y���&a���~?<@A:µ&')&���Y��Z��'��´���&'���������PZ�&'Y�°������������*Z�)\����!&'�����P*�E��!&V�(*�c �%**9�������&'�~�����)���%*9°&'Y�����0Z������"$&Y�¢*9cP���)¢*�0Y����%¡t­®��Z���Z�E���*9������¶¸·¢¹6º�»���!&'Y>�7����Z�������c�������Z§���0��Z��!��%&3E�Z��\����Z§���§&'Y��*'���7`�a�����%*����.C�X®¼½�!��¾ OQ¿UE��%����)�%�7�*+���%�0_�&'�

À]Á�Â�ÀbÃ

Page 20: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� ���

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z0

2

4

6

X

0

2

4

6

Y

XY

Z

B��«��|h~zjô���OP�d�~z�_�*j��[ª3ikja�w���[{Pv@�*ja©§©�vJ��{��pxzj*x�~��'®e�ja�w~z��{ ~�j�v�|�© xz�§{h��ª9~z��i ���$�

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

Z

0

2

4

6

X

0

2

4

6

Y

XY

Z

B��«��|h~zj�� ' PJd�~z�_�*jp�[ª ����� ��{ �x�j*xz~z��ehja�h~��_{~zjav�|h©§x��«{h��ª9~��_i ���$�

B��«{h�§x�j IÃ�9;3j6~zj6{��6java¯CFÃ{hj��6�[{x�e�j6~zj*ª9��~zjpj*²w�Pj��Åxfx��k{h��x����*j��[{ ��~��wja~���¦P�'±_jô� ·Svz��ehjai�jô�_~z�wja~�¬��§x�exzehj��h~zj6±?�«��|�vf�w�«±?�«v��§�_{P¹Å¯

� � � #$���")*����U���°�����")6#$� ���� )6� �z�¥ j�v�eP�[©«©ü�*��{P�*j6{Xxz~z�[x�jp��{ |h{h�§ª9��~zi ¦�����*?�_~��_|h{��&+P�'¬�¯ Á {j6²h�[ik�h©«jp��ª�{h�_{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi ¦�����*?�_~��_|h{��+P�'¬��«vp���«±�ja{¨�«{ -«�6��/@�[{P� -«���0/´¯dfehj�{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©�j*²w�Pja~��«ikj6{XxzvÃ�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��1ehja~�jk�[~zj��ª@xy¬��Cxyu?�Pj�v6¯B��«~zv�x�©«u���¬�j���ehj���*1x�e�j°���6�6|h~����*u1�_~z�hj6~ô�[ªf��|h~�vz��ehjai�j�v6¯°s?j��*�_{��w©«u��Q¬�j��*�_i���|wx�j°� ¬�j6©«©$*?{h�'¬�{xzjav�xn�6�_v�jp�§{ �_~z�wja~�x���j6±'��©§|��[x�jpx�e�j6�«~ ���6�6|h~����*u��«{1��i��_~�jô�h~����*x����6��©3�6��{Xx�j6²?xa¯

��"$# � � � Ac=�( � � � (/.$, c(+*�,-;>D³ {C��~��wj6~/x���e��;±_jn�[{�[{���©§uXx����6��©P�6��{Xx�j6²Xx/ª9��~f���6�6|h~����*u�±'�[©«�«�h�[x��«��{ü�X¬�jn��eh�?�_v�jn�v���©«|wxz�§�_{�¬�eh�«��eC�«v±_j6~zu�v�i��[©«©�{hj��[~@xzehjn¦F��|�{��h�[~z�«jav@��ª3x�ehjô�*�_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���©��w��i����§{ü¯ B���~/~zja��©§�«µ6�«{h�ôxzeh�«v��h~z���_~z��i�ikj_�¬�jôe��;±�jÃx����«{Xx�~z�w�w|��*j�v���|h~��*j�v�x�j6~zi�vf�§{ �_|h~fª9��~zi|h©��'xz�§�_{ü¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 21: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

��� � � � ��» �a k£_¢h� » À » ��£[¡ ���  ¿"�¥ j��wj�3�{hjôx�e�jp¦P����*?��~z��|h{P�&+��'¬ �m �_v�P

m N����

> @ O M �>���

�� � @

dfe�jv�u?v�x�jai ��ª ©§�«{hj��[~z�§µaja�ùÄJ|h©«j6~�ja�X|��[x��«��{�v¬�� xzeùx��«ikj ��{��ùv������6jC�wj6�Fj6{P�wj6{Xx�v��_|h~z�6j�x�ja~�i�v�«v��~�j�v��6~��«¦Pj���_v

� �� &H � [ M �zH E \

� Q H � [ � �zH \� �

N����������a[�� & \ � [ `�� [ M d f � d \ \ N� E� &

H � [ M�E H�� \� Q H � � E

� �N

� * y M�������� [�� & \ H l �M Q �! #" [�� & \ y l �! $" [�� & \ Q H l � M%�! #"1[�� & \ � , � [ `�� � M d f � d \� � &H � M E f

� Q� [ � H&� \

� �N

� * y � �'������[�� & \ H l M � �( $" [�� & \ Q H l �� �( $"L[�� & \ � y l �! $" [�� & \ � , � [ `)� � M d f � d \� �� &H � [ M �nH�E \

� Q H � [ � �nH \� �

N*�+������� [�� & \ � [ `)� [ M d f � d \<\·S����¹

dfehj��«{h�§x����[©Q���'xz����v�xz�A*�j6{ ja�X|���©3x���µaj6~z�xze��'x ��v

� [ O e Q e � \ N O e E+[ O e Q e � \ N O e [ O e Q e � \ N O e �1[ O e Q e � \ N O ·S�X��¹dfehjp~zjav�|h© xz�§{����§{�� xz�«��©F¦F��|�{��h�[~zuk±'�[©«|hjn�h~z��¦�©§jai ·S���;¹´®Å·9�X�_¹"e��_v@xzehj ª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{����[{P�[©«u_xz�«�a�[©Fv��_©§|w®

xz�§�_{� [ Q e � e & \ N,�-�! #" [�� & \ � [ `�� [ M d f � d \ \E+[ Q e � e & \ N y M �-�! #" [�� & \ � [ `�� [ M d f � d \ \ [ Q e � e & \ N y � �-�( $" [�� & \ � [ `)� [ M d f � d \$\� [ Q e � e & \ N �G[ Q e � e & \ @

·S� ' ¹

dfehjC���[~�x����*|h©��[~z�§xyu��[ª�x�e��«v�v��_©§|hx��«��{¶�«v�x�e��[x�§x�«v�� ª9|h{��*x��«��{ù��ª 3P{h� xzjCv������6j°v�|h���P�_~�x�¯ dfe��«v��~��_�Pja~�xyu���v�j*²w�Fja�*x�ja�Cx�����~�ja±�j6{Xxfª9~z��i xz~��_|h¦h©«jav��*�_{h{hj��Åx�j��C¬��§x�e ª9~zj6jô¦F��|h{����[~zuC�*�_{��w�§x��«��{�va¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 22: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �06

��� � � � � ¿ À ���£_¢w  ¿ � ¿��  ! � » �   »�� ¡'¢w  ¿"� ��¡ ¿ £ » À ü¡ »� j*x�|�v�v�x�|��hu°x�e�jÃxz�§ikj��«{Xx�j6�_~z�[x��«��{�[ªQxzehjôja�X|��[x��«��{�v�v�uwvyxzj6ir·9�P��¹*¯J³´xf��vfja�_v�u°x��k±�ja~��§ª9ukx�e��[x�x�ehj|Pv�|���© �_�[ikj�v��_{°�h~z�?�6ja�w|�~�j�·S�_¹/�h~z�'±?�«�wj�v��eh�«��eC�_~z�hj6~��[ªüxz�§ikj��[�h��~��;²w�«ik�[x��«��{��_{h©§u�ª9�_~��_~z�h�§{���~�u©«�«{hja��~��w�1;Fja~�ja{Xx����[©Fja�X|��'xz�§�_{�v@��ª(ª9��~zi � � � � & N � � H� & ·S¬�ehj6~zj � �[{P� � ��~�jÃ�*��{Pvyx��[{Xxzv�¹@��{��k��{h©«uxzehj�v�ja�*�_{����~��wj6~�ª9��~ ��{?u°�[xzehj6~�~z�§�_eXx�e���{�� v����wjô�[ª�x�e�j FGIÃÄ�¯

³ {U����ja{hj6~��[©��6��v�j��«{��*©«|��w�«{h�Cx�ehj�±'�[©«�«�h�[x��«��{ xzjav�xô�a��v�j���¬�jeP�;±�j�xzehj�ª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{��°��~��w�«{��[~zu �h� ªß®ª9ja~�ja{Xx����[©(ja�X|��[x��«��{�v

� m� & N � [ m \ H s+[ & \ ·S���X¹

¬�e�j6~zj��¨��v �� ��» ¢w¡ �w�1;Fja~�ja{Xx����[©?���Fj6~��'xz��~���{�� s+[ & \ ��v�x�ehjfv��_|h~��*j@xzj6~zi �Q¿"�(½ �� ��» ¢w¡ � ¼ À » � » � À » �  ¿"�   � » & ��{�� � À » � »�� À »��   ¿"�  �� » � ¿ � Q  ¿ � m�¯

³ {°�_~z�hj6~@xz��h~z�'±?�«�hj eh�«��eC�_�6�*|�~z�_�*u�_~z�hj6~���¬�jÃv�eh��|h©��kik�w�w� ª9ukxzehj �_�[ikj�v��_{kx��«i�jÃ�§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{ª9�_~"x�ehj �a��v�jf�[ªP{���{h©«�§{�ja�[~J�_{ & v���|h~��*j�x�ja~�i�va¯Q³ {��w�_�§{h��v�����v"|�v�|��[©«©«u���©«j*x@|PvJ�[�h�h©«u�xzehj d��;uX©«��~�j*²?®�P�[{�v��§�_{k�[ª3ª9|h{��*x��«��{ � �wj�3�{�ja�k¦?u�xzehjnj��_|P�'x��«��{1·S���X¹*��~zj6�h©����6jfx�ehjÃ�*��~z~zjav��P�_{��w�«{h�px��«i�jn��~����w�«j6{Xxzv¦?ux�ehja�§~p±'�[©«|hjav xz�A*�j6{¨ª9~��_i&·S���X¹n�[{�� ~zja��~�~��[{���jpx�ehjx�ja~�i�va¯ Á vp�°~zjav�|h©§xa�Px�ehjx��«i�j��§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{xzja��eh{��«�X|hj��6��{¦Fjôª9��~zi|�©«�[x�ja� ��v�xzehjôª9��©«©«�'¬��§{h�k©«�'¬ v�x���~��[�_jÃi�|h©§x��§®´v�xz����j�·Sl ®´v�xz����j�¹���©§�_��~z� xzehi

m ��� N m "m �$#% N m �$� H v &

W y ( H > � * m �$# ` j , H [ W y ( \� #� �� j v'& �[ W y ( H � \�� �

� `1j s� & � ` j e ( N >C@�@�@ W

m " f j N m �/.0 ·S�X��¹

��� � �� � �� » ¡ 9£�¢ ��¡ » � �ß ��dfe�j°x�j�vyx��*�_{��w�§x��«��{�v��[~zj�ª9|h~�x�ehja~�v��Fja�6�93�j��ù¦?uù��eh�?�_v��§{h� M N � N�O @ � ��� � [�� ��� \ ��{�� �NO @ O�O l � � N O @1>_¯@dQ¬���±'�[~z�«��{Xxzvf�[~zj��*��{Pv����wj6~zja�ü¯/dfehj6u�w�9;3j6~Ã��{h©«u°¦?u°xzehj���eh�_�«�6j��[ª�ª9~�j��_|�j6{��6u ��«{ù·9� ' ¹��[{�� �w�1;Fja~�ja{Xx 3�{��[©3xz�§ikj�v �� � " ��� P

� d�Ä/swd �AP � N l � O @ O > l �h� N l � � � N���O @§� � � " ��� N l O @� d�Ä/swd ��P � N l � O @2>�� N l � � � N > O @«� � � " ��� N � O @

dfe�j��§{Xxzj6��~��'xz�§�_{ e���vn¦Pjaj6{¨�w�_{hj�¦F�[x�e-���6�6��~��w�«{h��x���xzehj�xzja��eh{h���X|hjC·S�X��¹ �[{����6�*©���vzv����6��©��nª9��|�~�xze�_~z�hj6~���|h{h�_j*®��ô|wx�x���i�j6x�eh�w� ¬��§x�e x�ehj�|�{h�«�X|hj � �_|h~��[{Xx�{?|hi�¦Pja~�ja�X|���©3x�� O @ l �h¯Á ©§©�xzehj��6��ik�h|wx��'x��«��{Pvne��;±_j�¦Fj6j6{U�w��{�j��{-~�ja��|h©��[~ni�j�v�e�jav�·S�*�X�[~�v�j_� v Q N v�� N l @F��{��?3P{hj��v Q N v�� N >A@ê¹/¬��§x�e xzehj�|�v�j��[ªRMf��~�xze �6j6©«©«va¯Á v�x�|P�wu°�[ª�x�e�j��*��ik�h|hxz�'xz�§�_{��[©ü�_�6�6|h~z�_�*uk��v��h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��C¬��§x�e x�e�j�|�v�jô��ª�xzeh~�jaj��w�9;3j6~zj6{Xx {h�_~�i�va�

� E � � N���� �j"! � ! . � y � � M � � F e� E � b N .#� j � y � � M � � F %$ ��� � [ ] � \ e� E � d N'& .#� j � y � � M � � F � $ ��� � [ ] � \)(j � ·S�_�_¹

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 23: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

¬�e�j6~zj $ ��� � [ ] � \ ��v �*�_ik�h|wx�j�� ¬�� xze x�ehj Mf�[~�x�e1�6j6©«©ü���wxz�§�_{ü¯ Á { {?|hikja~����6��©ü���6�6|h~����*u��_~z�hj6~��U�«v�a�[©��*|h©��'xzja�¦?u�x�ehjôª9�_©§©«�'¬��«{h�ª9�_~�i�|h©���v

� N y��" � � y � � M � � F ���������� � y �

" � � y � � M � � F �������� � �������" [ �VQ \��������� � y �

" [ � Q \������� � ���� � ·S� �[¹¥ j��*�_i��P�[~zj:3�~�v�x�x�ehjôxy¬���x�jav�x �6�_v�j�vf¬�� xzexzehj�¦Fjav�xnv���ehjaikj��h�*�_~�~zjav��F��{��w�«{h�x�� � N O ¯

³ {Ud���¦h©«javÃ��[{P�-�w�3¬�j�_j*x��*��{O3�~�i��[x��«��{ x�eP�'xpx�eh��vôv���ehjaikj���vn��ª�v�� ²?x�e-��~��wj6~p���a�*|h~����6u ��{��¨�§xzv�«ik�h©«j6ikj6{Xxz�[x��«��{ �«v ±;��©§���h�[x�ja�ü¯

� ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~�~z��~� �_��~zv�j �h¯ 6���� I ® � � ��¯ ���[� In® � ' �h¯ê���[�AIn®´�X�B��«{hj �h¯«�����AI ® ��� ��¯ �_�[�AIn® �_� �h¯ �X� ��In®´� �

l |hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~ �w¯ � ��� �w¯ ���?� �h¯ 6X���d��[¦h©«jô�<P IÃj6{Pv��§xyuCja~�~z��~�v@ª9�_~�� N O P � N O @ O > l � l � � N ��O @

� ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~�~z��~� �_��~zv�j �h¯ê�[� ��I ® � � ��¯ � ' ��In® �[� �h¯ ' �X��In®´�_�

B��«{hj �h¯ ' �[� I ® �A6 ��¯ �_� ��In® ��� �h¯ �_� ' In®´�_�

l |hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~ �w¯ �_�[� �w¯ê���[� �h¯ �C�?�d��[¦�©§j���P Inja{�v�� xyuj6~z~��_~zv/ª9��~�� N O P � N O @1> l � � N > O @

¥ j°���h�hja�-x�ehj°�6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{U��ª�d�Ä/shd!�k¬��§x�e¶xzehj°�w��v�v��§�P�'x��«±�jk±_j6~�v��«��{ü�(�N¯ j�¯°¬��§x�e � N >�¯d��[¦�©§j��k�w��v��h©��;uwv�x�ehj�~zjav�|h©§xzv�xze��'x�±'�[©«�«���'x�jôxzehjôx�e�j6��~zj*xz�«�a�[©(�[{P�[©«u?v���vp· 3hªßx�e1�_~z�hj6~Źů

s?�_ikjô�6��ikikj6{Xxzv��a�[{¦Pj�i����hj�¯Jdfehjôi��[�«{�F���«{Xxf��v�x�eP�'xfx�ehjôj6²?�Fja�*x�j�� �_�6�6|h~z�_�*uk��vf±�j6~z�13�ja�(¯¥ jôj6ik�he��_v��«µ6jpxze��'xfx�e��«vf±'�[©«���h�'xz�§�_{ �w�?j�vf{h�[x��«{��*©«|��wjpx�e�jp¦F��|�{��h�[~zu°~zj6�_�§�_{ü�Xv��«{��*jô��|�~ v��_©§|wxz�§�_{��vf±�ja~�u°v�i��[©«©3{hja��~�xzehj�¦F��|h{����[~zu�¯ Q �'¬�j6±_j6~���xzehjôx�~zja�[x�ikj6{Xxf�[ª�~zj�+Pja�Åxz�§{���¬f�[©«©(�*�_|h©«�¬��§x�e1v��_ikjvz��ehjai�j�v/¦Fj��*�_i���|wx�j��C¬��§x�e eh�«��ew®´��~��wj6~����a�*|h~����6u�¯�³ {C��|�~��_�wx��«��{Pv6�Xx�e�jp��~��_�P�Xv�j��°v���e�j6ikjÃ��v�{h�[x��¦h©«jxz� �h�Cxzeh�«va�Qja±�ja{�¬��§x�e¶� �a�[~�x�j�v����[{¨ikj�v�eü¯�dfeh��v��w�«vz���h±;��{Xxz�[�_j��vpx�ehjk~zjav�|h©§xô��ª/��|�~ô�hjav��§�_{

ó È�û ó æ

Page 24: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �h�

� ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~z~z��~ � ��ÄJ~�~z��~� �_��~zv�j �h¯ � ' � I ® ��� ��¯ ���A6AIn® �_� �h¯ê���w�7In®´���B��«{hj �h¯ê�[�[�#I ® � � ��¯ ���_�AIn® �[� �h¯ �_�[� In®´�_�

l |hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~ ��¯ 6��_� �w¯ ���h� �P¯ 6_���

d��[¦h©«j��OP IÃj6{Pv��§xyuCja~�~z��~�v@ª9�_~�� N >.P � N O @ O > l � l � � N ��O @�_�wx��«��{Pv6��¦h|wx�¬�j°~zja�a�[©«©Jx�eP�'x�_|h~�x��[~z��j*x�6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{ù�«v����*�_|�v�x����6v��«{­�*�_ik�h©§j6²-�_j6��ikj6x�~zu-�[{P��«{U��j6{�j6~��[©�x�ehj�ikj�v�e¶¬��«©§©J{h��x�¦Pj°�a�[~�x�j�v����[{-�§{-x�ehj°�h�§~zja�*xô±?���*�«{h�§xyu��[ª�x�ehj�¬f�[©«©�v6�ü¦�|wx�� x�a�[{U¦Pj�a�[~�x�j�v����[{�§{ x�e�j�~�j�vyx��[ª�x�ehj��6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��[©ü�w�_i��[�«{ü¯

��" ! (/? * � ��* �L( � �Á v�ja�*�_{��kxzjav�xf�a��v�jn��v/{h�'¬ �*��{Pv����wj6~zja�k�«{C�_~z�hj6~�x���v�x�|P�wukx�ehjô���a�*|h~����6u���ªüx�e�jÃ�h~z���F�_v�ja��vz��ehjai�j�_{1�ki��_~�jôxyu?�h���6��©Q���6��|�v�x����p�h~z��¦h©«j6i ¯fdfehj��h~z��¦h©«j6i x��Cv���©«±�jô��vfxz�A*�j6{ ª9~z��i x�ehj���� ������� � � �� ����0������ ��� �:��� �� %&������ ���#���1��% �n� � � ��%,�!���L��� � ��� ��� �:�����0�A��������� � ����� � �,��� ehja©«�1�«{ QÃ�[ik�w®xz��{ü���Ã�§~z���«{h�����§{4Fp�Åxz��¦Fj6~n�[�[®y�[�h�F�76 6[� · -«�a��/9¹Å¯

��� � � � ��» �a k£_¢h� » �´¿ ¡ � ��9¢w ! ¿"�¥ j��h|wxn���_���§{

m N����

>A@ O M �>���

�� �

��{��Cx�ehj�±_ja�Åxz��~��*�_ik�P�_{hj6{Xxzvf��ª��«{h�§x����[©Q�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�p�w��vyxz|h~z¦��[{��6jav���~�j��wj�v��6~��«¦Pj���_v

� [ Q e � e O \ N�� ��� [ y �" l� [ Q � H � � \$\ H O @2> � ���L[ y �

" ll � [ [ Q y (�� \ � H � � \<\E+[ Q e � e O \ N O @ O � � � ��� [ y �

" ll � [ [ Q y (�� \ � H � � \<\ [ Q e � e O \ N y O @ O � [ Q y (�� \ � ��� [ y �

" ll � [$[ Q y (�� \ � H � � \$\� [ Q e � e O \ N�� ��� [ y �

" l� [ Q � H � � \ \ @

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 25: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�_� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

dfe��«vf�«{h�§x����[©ü¦F��|h{P�h�[~zu°±'�[©«|hjô�h~z��¦h©«j6i eP��v�x�e�jôª9��©«©§�'¬��«{h���[{���©§uXxz�«�a�[©(v��_©§|hx��«��{

Ek[ Q e � e & \ NQ y M &l �

" ll ����!> H O @ O � [ � y � & \ � Q � [ y �

" ll � [ [ Q y (�� y M & \ � H [ � y � & \ � \$\

[ Q e � e & \ N�

l �" l� �

� > H O @ O � [ � y � & \ � Q � [ y �" ll � [$[ Q y (�� y M & \ � H [ � y � & \ � \$\

�1[ Q e � e & \ N >l �" l�

� l

�G[ Q e � e & \ N-� H O @2> � ���L[ y �" ll � [$[ Q y ( � y M & \ � H � � \ \

·S�_�_¹

¬�e�j6~zj

� > [ Q e � e & \ N�

� � ��� [ y y � ���" l \�� j [�� � \ � �( $" � & ���

� l [ Q e � e & \ N�

� � ��� [ y y � ���" l \�� � [�� � \ � ����� � & � �

� � �[{P� � jp�[~zjnxzehj��*�_~�~zjav��P�_{��w�«{h�.M�j�v�v�j6©3ª9|�{��Åxz�§�_{�v6¯��� � � � C» �� ��ß ��dfe�j�ª9��©«©«�'¬��§{h�°x�jav�xp�a��v�javÃ�[~zj�*�_{�v����wja~�j��(¯ ³ {1xzehj 3P~zv�xnxzjav�xÃ�h~z��¦h©«j6i ·Ød�Ä/swd ' ¹�x�ehj�ikja��{?+��'¬±_j6©«�w�*�§x��«jav��[~zj M N O @ �w� � N�O @ O ¬�eh����e �6��~z~�j�v��F��{���v�xz��xzehj1�6��v�jC��ªp� � e���~z�§µa��{Xxz��©�¬��«{����ª9~z��i x�ehj�©§j6ªßxa¯�³ { xzehj�v�ja�6��{��x�j�vyxp�h~z��¦h©«j6i&·Sd�Ä/swd �?¹�x�e�jav�j�±�ja©§�w�*�§x��«javn�[~zj M N�O @ � ����� � � � � � M N O @ � ��� � � � � � ¬�e��«��eù�*�_~�~zjav��F��{��hvpxz�¨� � �h�«������{P�[©J¬��«{����üª9~z��i x�ehj�©«j*ªßx�¦P��x�x��_i&�6��~z{hj6~���ª�¶�6��ik�h|wx��'x��«��{P�[© �w�_ik���§{Q¯ M��[x�e �h~z��¦�©§jaikv���~�j1v���©«±�j��A�«{ �Uvz�X|��[~zj�QLj N y > O�O �^Q � N > O�O �� j N y > O�O � � � N > O�O ¯

Á xyu?�h���6��©ü{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©3~�j�v�|�© x ��vf~�ja�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��°ª9�_~fx�ehj��wja{�v�� xyu �w�«v�x�|�~�¦���{��*j�v��§{?B��§�_|h~zj��6��¯Jdfehjv���©«|wxz�§�_{ �6|wxzv���~�jô���«±�ja{ �[xfx�ehj�vz�[ikjG3h²wja�x��«ikj�ik��ikj6{Xx & N � O ¯��� � �� � ¿ � » £ ¿ � � »��  a� ¿ � ¡ » � �ß ��dfe�jô��¦P�'±_jô~�j�v�|h©§xzvf©«ja�_�°xz��x�ehjôª9�_©§©«�'¬��§{��k�6��ikikj6{Xxzva¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 26: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� � '

� �[~�x�jav����[{ i�j�v�e mn{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j�� i�j�v�ed�jav�x�� dQj�vyx '

� �_�[~�v�jÃikjav�e B��«{hj�ikjav�e � �_��~zv�jpi�j�v�e B��«{hj�ikjav�e���_�[���Ã{��?�hjav �_���_�h�Ã{h�w�wjav 6�� 6 ' {h�w�wjav ' 6_�_����{h�w�wjav

o � ��� N > � @ � > O > O ` j >A@ � � (� > O `1j >A@ O > � > O � > @ � O ( > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �h¯ ' 6 ' ��¯ 6A6o � ��� N O > @ l O l > O � >A@ � O (� > O `1j >A@ l ���# > O � � @ � � � > O ` �l |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ ' ¯ ���_� �w¯ê�'�M � �� N > ��@ ��l � > O ` j >A@ O � � > O `1j >A@ O�O � > O � > @ � l O > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �h¯ 6X��� ��¯ 6 �M � �� N O � @ ( � � > O ` j ��@ l > �# > O ` � >A@ l�� � > O � > @ � � � > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �P¯ �X� ' ��¯ 6��

� �_i��P���Åx�®´� ��· � �_¹ O @ ��>�� > O � O @ � � �# > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ ' ¯ �X� 'Ip� � · � ��¹ O @ ���� > O � O @ � � > > O `1jl |hi ¯�FÃ~z�wja~ �h¯ � �?�

d��[¦�©§j ��PGInja{�v��§xyu � �Cj6~z~z��~�v�ª9��~pª9�_|h~ô±�j6~�v��§�_{�v ��ª@x�ehjk�h~zjav�j6{Xxzja��vz��ehjai�j_�(�د j�¯¬�� xzeU�w��vzv��«���'xz�§�_{�P�[~��[ikj*xzj6~��v�j*x j��_|P�[©Fx��?>��[{P�°xz� O �h�[{��¬��§x�e1�*ja©§©Qv�e����Pj�vf�[ª�ikj��w�«��{Cxyu?�Fj°·Øo � ¹��_~f�[ª M���~�xzexyu?�Fj1· M � ¹Å¯üdfehjk~zjav�|h©§xzvô�[~zj��6��ik����~�j��1¬�� xze�xzehj���{�javp�[ª��a�[~�x�j�v����[{U�6�[©��*|�©«�[x��«��{�v -§���7/@¬��§x�eUx�ehj|Pv�jô�[ª�ª9��|�~�xzew®N�_~z�hj6~f�*��ik���_�Åx 3�{h�§x�j6®´�h�9;3j6~zj6{��6j��[{�� Ip� � v���e�j6ikjava¯

� l |hikja~����6��©h���6�6|h~����*uô�_~z�wja~"±;��~��«jav�ª9~z��i l @ �Ãx�� �<@«�[¦h|hx@i��XvyxJ��ªPikja�_v�|h~zj6ikja{_x�v���~�j�{h��x�ª9|�©§©«u�wj6ik�_{�vyxz~z�[x��«±�j�v��§{��6jpx�ehj�~zjav�|h©§xzvf��{x�e�j��*�_��~zv�jpi�j�v�e�javf�«{X±_��©«±�jp�_vz�*�«©§©��'xz�§�_{�va¯

� dfehj�Mf�[~�x�e¶�*ja©§©J�_�wx��«��{U¦Pjae��;±�j�vp¦Pj6x�x�ja~��«{-xzehj°�6��~�xzjav��«��{-�a��v�j���{��-v�©«�§�_e_xz©§u�¬��_~zv�j��«{Ux�ehj|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja� �6�_v�j_¯

� l |hikja~����6��©P�w��v�v��«���'xz�§�_{��«ik�h~z�'±�javJx�ehjnv���©«|wxz�§�_{k�X|���©§�§xyu���{�v��_ikjn�*�X�[~�v�jfikjav�ehjav/¦h|wx/{��[x/�_{�[©«©ü�[ª�x�ehjai ¯

� dfehj��6��ik����~���v��_{ô¦Pj6xy¬�jaj6{�|h{�v�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja�ôikjav�ehj�v���{���vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j��ô��{hj�vü��vü�F�_vzv��«¦h©«j/v��«{��6j@x�j�vyx�6�_v�j�v ' �[{��C���[~zjn��ªQja�X|h�«±'�[©«j6{Xx��h�98°�*|�© xyu_¯J³´x���v�{h�[x�v����wj*ªS�;±_��|h~��[¦�©§jfxz�xzehjÃ|�{�vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j���6�_v�j_¯ dfehj�ja~�~z��~��_{ù�*�_��~zv�jkikjav�ehjav��h�9;3j6~�v��_j6{hja~z��©§©«u¨�[ªf��{�©§u¶� ª9j6¬ �F��|h~��*ja{_x�v6¯?FÃ{¶x�ehj3�{hj1ikjav�ehj�v6�/x�ehj1v�ik��©§©«jav�x�|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja� j6~z~��_~ · � @ � > O ` � ¹���vk{h�[xkxy¬����*j ©��[~z��j6~�x�eP�[{¸x�ehj¦Pj�vyxnv�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja���{hj°· ��@ l > O ` � ¹*¯J³ { i��Xvyxn�6��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{�_{Cxzehj�|h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja�i�j�v�e�java�wx�ehj�_vz�*�«©§©��'xz�§�_{�vk�[~zj�_¦�v�j6~z±�ja�­�'x�©§j���v�x���{ x�ehj1�*�X�[~�v�jikjav�ehjava�/¦h|hx�x�ehj {?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©f��~��wja~���ª���a�*|h~����6u°vyx��;u?vf{��[xz��¦h©«u°©«��~��_j6~�x�e���{ l ¯

� dfehj�xzjav�x��6�_v�j���vJ~��'x�e�j6~@¬�j6©«©��*�_ik�h|wx�j��k¬�� xzekx�ehjÃ�6�[~�x�j�v����[{ 3�{hjni�j�v�eQ¯$FÃ|�~/v���e�j6ikj��«v@¬�ja©§©�*�_i��P�[~zja��¬�� xze�x�e�jÃv�xz�[{P�h�[~��kv���ehjaikjavJª9�_~�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja����~��6�[~�x�j�v����[{kikjav�ehj�vn· Ip� �Avz��ehjai�j-§��/N�Ã�*��ik���_�ÅxC��|�{h��j6®��ô|wx�xz�ùikj6x�eh�w� -«��7/9¹Å¯ ¥ j-j6ik�he��_v��«µ6j1xze��'x{h��{hj-�[ªôx�e�j-vz��ehj6ikjavx�e��[x�¬��_v�x�~z�«ja�¨�_{¨xzeh�«vô�a��v�j��*�_|h©��¨�h~z�w�w|��*j��C{?|hikja~����6��©��_~z�wja~Ã��ª����a�*|h~����6u �6©§�Xv�jx��x�ehj

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 27: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�[� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

-0.06

-0.04

-0.02

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

-100 -50 0 50 100

Den

sity

per

turb

atio

n

x

Calculation

Exact

B��«��|h~zj��a�<P ��� � ��� � �k£ ¿ Q�a  9£ ¾ ¢�� » � � À 9¢ �F¿"� ¢ � ¾ � À �s?x�~z|��Åxz|h~�j��Cikj�v�eü� � N O �wikja�h�«��{ �6j6©«©«v�·S�_���_�h�Ã{h�w�wjav�¹

x�ehja��~zj*xz�«�a�[©���{hj_¯ôdfe��«vp��vÃj6²w�h©«���§{�ja�1¦?u x�ehj���~���v��«{h�°��ª��wj6xz�[�«©�vn�«{¨xzehj�j6²h���Åxôv��_©§|hx��«��{¨xze��'x�[~zj�v�i��[©«©«j6~�x�e���{ x�ehj�ikjav�e1v��«µ6j_�h�'x�©«ja��v�x�ª9��~fxzehj��*�X�[~�v�jÃikjav�eü¯

� ³´x/v�e���|h©���¦Pj�{h��x�j���xze��'xJxzehj�j*²h���*x@v��_©§|wxz�§�_{���vJ�_�§±_j6{�_{h©«u��vJ��v���©«|wx��«��{��[ªF©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja��ÄJ|h©«j6~ja�X|��[x��«��{�vp�[{����6�[{�{h�[xp¦Pjk�*�_{�v����wja~�j��¨��vÃ�°�he?uwv����6��©��_{hj�¯ôdfeh��v ªS�_�Åxô�«vp�wjai��_{�v�x�~��'x�j��1�«{B��§�_|h~�jC����¬�ehja~�jôxzehj�~zjav�|h© xÃ�[ªJ|�v��§{h��{���{h©«�§{�ja�[~ÃÄJ|h©«j6~nik�w�wja©Q��v ~zj6�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��(¯fdfehj��eh�_�«�6j�[ªüi��'xzehj6i��[x����6�[©Pik�?�hj6©Pª9��~@xzehjÃ�_�*�_|�vyxz�«� ¬��;±_jav@�wj�v��6~��«�wxz�§�_{��«v/±�j6~zu��§ik�F��~�xz�[{Xx�v��«{��*j ja±�ja{�§{°x�ehjô�6�_v�j ��ª(~z�[x�ehja~�v�ik��©§©3�w��vyxz|h~z¦��[{��6jav@x�ehjé§�«{hja��~/ik�w�wj6©�v��6�[{���~��w�w|��6j ±�ja~�u��«{����a�*|h~��'xzj~�j�v�|�© x�v�·Sv�j6j&-«�6��/´� -«���0/9¹Å¯

� � � #$���")*����U���°�����")6#$� ���� )6� 1T�dfe�j/xzjav�xJ�a��v�j���v�x�e�jf�h�§~zja�*x"�_�h�[�wx��'xz�§�_{�[ª�x�ehj��6�_v�j��h~zjav�j6{Xx�j����«{���¯§�_¯ ¥ jf|�v�j��Ã|h{h���X|hj��*��ik�h|hxz�'®xz�§�_{��[©F�w��i����§{kª9�_~@x�e�~�jajn�*�_i���|wxz�[x��«��{�va¯"³´x/�«v/x�e�jn����~z��©§©«j6©«���h�«�Fja� _ y > O�O e > O�O h �_ y l e l h �_ y l e l h ¯o1jav�ehjav��_� �h� ' ��~�j �wj�3�{hj���ª9~��_i ikjav�e°v��«µ6j�v�� � ���X�h¯ê�ô�[{��k�h¯ê���h¯�³ { ���ô¬�j �wja�h���Åx@xzehj � � {X|�i�ja~�®���6��©"��~��wj6~���vô�ª9|h{��*x��«��{U�[ª�x��«i�jkª9�_~px�ehj��*�_i¦h�«{��[x��«��{���ª�{hja¬ �6|h¦Pj°v��h©«� x�x��«{h�����$� �[{P��{hja¬

ó È�û ó æ

Page 28: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� �_�

-0.06

-0.04

-0.02

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0.12

-150 -100 -50 0 50 100 150

Den

sity

per

turb

atio

n

x

Nonlin. (calc.)

linear’d (anal.)

B��«��|h~zj­�;��P ��� � � � � ��¿ � ��¢w¡ 9� ¿ � � »   ¾»?»�� �� ��» ¢w¡ 9� » À � ¢ � ¢ � ¼  ! 9£�� � ¿ � Q  ¿ � ¢ � À��¿"� �� �Q» ¢w¡ � ¢ � �Q¡ ¿�� �¶¢h  » � ¿ ��»�6j6©«©«v �����C¯ Á ªßx�ja~nv��_ikjô�_�h�[�hx��«��{ �w|hjôx���v��§{���|h©��[~ v�xz��~�xz�§{h�P�?x�ehj�{?|hikja~����6��©(��~��wj6~f��v �*�_{�3�~zi�j���_v��*©«�_v�jnxz�C�w¯

� � �����a�C��)*��

¥ jCeP�;±�j��h~z���F�_v�ja�¶�¨{�j6¬ ªS�[ik�«©§u¶�[ª vz��ehj6ikj�v�ª9��~x�ehj©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja�ùÄJ|�©§ja~ja�X|��[x��«��{�v¬�� xzeh��|hx���~¬��§x�e1v���|h~��*j�v6¯

dfehj���~��_�P�Xv�j��vz��ehj6ikj�v��6�[{ ¦Fj��[�h��©§�«ja�x���|�{�vyxz~�|P�Åx�|�~�j��Cxz~����[{���|h©��'xz�§�_{�v6¯@dfe�j6u��~�j��[xf©«ja�_vyxv�ja�6��{��w®N�_~z�wja~����a�*|h~��'xzj��J�[{��¶�«{?±��_©§±_jC� x�|�{��[¦h©«jv�i��[©«©�v�xz��¦h�«©§��v��[x��«��{¶xzj6~zi&i��_�wj°¬��§x�e ��v��§²?x�ew®�_~z�hj6~��wj6~z�«±;�[x��«±�j_¯"dfe�j����6�6|h~����*uk��v�i|P��e¦Fj*x�x�j6~ x�e��[x�ª9��~�|�v�|��[©üv�ja�6��{��w®N�_~z�wja~�vz��ehjai�j�v6¯dfe�j�v���e�j6ikjav���©«v��ùj6{'�y�'u¸v�|��Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6j�h~z���Fj6~�x��«jav°��{ �6��~�xzjav��«��{ ikjav�ehj�v6�f|h� xz�­�ùv�i���©§©±?���*�«{h�§xyu°�[ª�x�ehj�¦F��|�{��h�[~zu�¯@s?|��Pja~z�6��{?±�ja~��_j6{��6jn��~��wja~���ª"�_�6�6|h~z�_�*u��6��{ ¦Pj���vfe��§�_e �_v ����~�(h¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 29: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

3.6

3.8

4

4.2

4.4

4.6

4.8

5

5.2

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80

dx=4,2dx=2,1

B��§�_|h~�jk���OP ' I vz��ehjai�j.PJ{?|hikj6~z���6�[©3�_~z�wja~���v�ª9|h{��*x��«��{ �[ª�x��«ikj

dfeh��vp��~��wj6~Ã�[ª��_�6�6|h~z�_�*u �«vÃ��¦Pv�ja~�±_ja� ª9��~��_�weh�w��xzjav�xô�a��v�java¯GB���~ô�°¦��_v�����_�*��|Pvyxz�«�av xzjav�xô�a��v�j·H-§����/9¹Å��x�ehj����6�6|h~����*un�«vQ���?�w�Ã�_{��6�[~�x�j�v����[{ôikjav�ehj�vü�[{���v�x��«©«©�~��'x�e�j6~(���?�w�p��{�|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja�pikjav�ehj�v6¯

B�|h~�xzehj6~�j6²w�Pja~��«ikj6{Xxzvô��ª/x�e�j°v���ehjaikjav��[~zj��§{U�h~z����~zjavzva¯³ {U���[~�x����*|h©��[~��3x�e�j°�*��ik�h|hxz�'xz�§�_{-��ªxzjav�xn�6�_v�jp��{1���6��|�v�x����ì��;±_jav��§{ {h�_{w®´|h{h�§ª9��~zi +��'¬ v 3�j6©��hv���vf�h~zjav�j6{Xx�j��C�«{ -§�a��/´� -§�;�0/´¯

dfehjn�h~��_�P�Xv�j���vz��ehjai�j�v@�[���Pj��[~/v�|h�§xz�[¦�©§jfª9�_~@x�e�jn���w±_ja�*x��«��{����[~�xzv@��©«v��ô¬�� xze°{h�_{h©§�«{hj��[~ +�|w²wj�v6¯dfe�j/v���ikj@���[�Fj6~�v@·H-§�a��/N��-«���0/9¹ü�6��{�v����wj6~(xzehj�vz��ehjai�jJik�w�w�13P�6�[x��«��{��_�6�*�_|h{Xx��«{h�fª9��~�{h��{�©§�«{hja��~üj�;3ja�*xzv�«{C�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�n¬��;±_jav@�wu?{���ik�«�av6¯ Á v��Fja�*���[©«©«u�ja©«��¦P�_~z�[x�j���x�jav�x��a��v�jn��v��6��ik�h|wxzja�(¯JdfehjÃ~�j�v�|�© x�v�v�eh�'¬xzehj��w�1;Fja~�ja{��*j��«{1©«�§{hj��[~ ��{�� {h��{�©§�«{hja��~�ik�?�hj6©�v ��vf¬�j6©«©Q��v�x�ehj��F�_vzv��§¦h�«©«� xyu°��ªJ{hj6�X�'x��«±�jô�«{�+�|hja{��*j��ª�~z��|h{P�C�A;�j6~z~��_~zva¯

ó È�û ó æ

Page 30: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

�������������� ���������������� ����������������! �����"#���!�$�������%&� � �

� ��%'����� �C�����

-«��/ � ¯ �k¯ ¥ ¯üd���i � ��¯ � ¯ ¥ ja¦h¦ü� IÃ��v��Fj6~�v��«��{h®´��ja©«�[x��«��{w® �J~zjav�j6~z±?�§{h��B��«{h�§x�j&In�1;3j6~zj6{��6jksw��e�j6ikjavª9��~ � �_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���© Á �*��|Pvyxz�«�av6¯�� ������� ��� ��� � ��%:� ������� � ��� ��� � ����� ��� � �����(�����h�*®y�[�����P�76A6 ' ¯

-ê��/���¯ Á ¦h��~��[©«©N¯ Á { j�v�v�j6{Xx����[©«©«uù{h��{w®´�_vz�*�«©«©«�[x���~zu¶~�j��*�_{�vyxz~�|P�Åx��«��{­�h~��w�6ja�w|h~zj ��{ 3�{h�§x�j1j6©«j6ikja{_xxyu?�Pjôikjav�ehjava�?�[�h�h©«���6�'xz�§�_{°xz���*�_ik�h~�j�v�v��«¦h©§j:+��'¬ va¯ � ��%,�!���L���4������0 ��I� � � � �!� � �� �N��������@� ������ � ��"i� � ����� � ��" � � � � �(�06A6[�P��6_�;®��a����¯

- ' / B�¯�Mf��vzv��w�[{P��s3¯'��ja¦��;u�¯ Á eh�«��ew®´��~��wj6~����a�*|h~��'xzj��w��v��6��{Xx��«{?|h��|Pv 3�{�� xzj�ja©§jaikj6{Xx�ikj6x�eh�w�ª9��~�x�ehj{?|hikj6~z�«�a�[©wv��_©§|hx��«��{���ªhx�ehj��6��ik�h~zjavzv��«¦h©«j/ln�;±?�«j6~�® sXxz�A*_javüj��X|��'xz�§�_{�v6¯�� ������� ���<� � � ��%,�!���L��� � ��� ���� ���� � ��� � � �F�(�76 6 �w�?��� ��®y����6h¯

- ��/ � ¯ Inja¦h�«j6µ�� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±?�§ja|w²(¯po �§²wja�¨ÄJ©«j6ikja{_x �J��©«|hikj�o1mps � � i�j6x�eh�w�hvì��§x�e¨¬�ja�A*±?��v��6�_v�� xyuª9��~ v�x�j����wuC��{�� |h{�v�x�j����wu&+P�'¬ �6��©«�6|h©��'x��«��{Q¯�� ��%:� ������� ��� ��C���C� �� ���76A6 6h� ���Q�?�A6'®������

-ê��/ � ¯ Inja¦h�§jaµ�� Á ¯ Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(� �k¯3o j6~��P��{��?Mp¯Pl��n�_{h�_��¯ � �_i���|wxz�[x��«��{1�[ªJ|h{Pvyxzja���hu�+��'¬ v�¬��§x�eik� ²wja� 3�{h�§x�j���3�{h�§x�j�j6©«j6ikj6{Xx�|h�?¬��§{���i�j6x�eh�w�hva¯�� �<�L����� ��� � ��� ��� � ������� ����������� ��%&��� � ������4��� ��7 ��� ���C���C� �� ���76 6��h� ���(�ü�06 ' ® �����h¯

- ��/ Mp¯J±'�[{ � jaj6~�¯¸d��'¬f�[~��hv�xzehj¨m ©§x��«i��'xzj � ��{�v�j6~z±'�'x��«±�j IÃ�9;3j6~zj6{��6j�sw��ehjai�j ³Å¯@dfehj �Ã|�jav�xk��ªo ��{��[x��_{h���*�§xyu�� ������������=� �������z� � � ���� � ��� �Q�76 �[�h� ���Q�w�ü¯§��� '

- �0/ Á ¯ �_�[ikjav���{ü¯ Á ~�x��13P�*���[©/�h�9;3|�v��§�_{ü��|��X¬��«{��¶¦h����v��«{h����©§�«ik� xzj6~�v�[{P��xzehj6�«~j�;Fj��Åx�_{ù���6�6|h~����*u�[{���i�|h© xz�§�_~������*��{?±_j6~z��j6{P�*j/�«{�x�~��[{�v���{h���f�[{���e?u?�Pja~zv���{h���C+��'¬ v6¯ � � �,� �O���O��������� ������� ¯ Á ³ ÁnÁ���6x�e � ��ik�h|wx��'x��«��{P�[© B�©§|��«� IÃuX{P�[ik�«�av � ��{hª9j6~zj6{��6j��!FÃ~z©«��{��w����B � �«�76 6 ' ¯

- ��/ Á ¯OInja~�±?�«j6|w²(¯JsXx�j����wu°ÄJ|�©§ja~ns?�§i�|h©��'x��«��{Pv�mÃv��«{h�km {�v�x�~z|��*x�|h~zja� o jav�ehj�v6¯ �J��{ ���[~zi��[{°³ {Pvyxz� ®x�|wxzj�ª9��~,B�©«|h���?Inu?{���ik�«�av6� � ja�*x�|h~zj�v�j6~z�§j�vô�76��X�;® �[�P� � �_i���|wxz�[x��«��{���© B�©§|h���?IÃuX{P�[ik�«�av�·y�06��X��¹Å¯��j6±?��v�j��C±_j6~�v��«��{���|h¦h©«�«v�ehja� ��vf����e��[�hx�j6~f��ª �*�"�[~�x����[© IÃ�9;3j6~zj6{Xx����[©üÄ/�_|P�'x��«��{Pv���ª�e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«���_|�jxyu?�Pj���{�� Á �h�h©«���6�'xz�§�_{�v �'�OKpj6u?ik��{��[x Ä@�(¯«� ¥ ��~z©«� sw�*�«j6{Xxz�93P���Ps?�«{h�_���P�_~�j_�3�76�� �?¯

- 6�/�dô¯5Mf�[~�x�eü¯ Á v��Pj��Åx�vÃ��ª�m {Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja� Kp~����hvp�[{�� B��«{h�§x�j6® �J�_©§|hikj�s?��©«±�ja~zv ª9��~Ãx�ehj�ÄJ|h©«j6~��[{P�ln�;±?�«j6~�® sXxz�A*_jav�Ä@�X|��'xz�§�_{�v6�?�«{ � ����� � ��� � ��������� ��� �R�O��� ���<��� ������ � � � !4������0 ��������,�, � ������ � ���� ��%n� � ���L�� "�C�1� � �$# � � �)�c����� �O�����%'&(% ���ü¯P�'®��nxz�k�[®´�����3�76 6_�h¯

-«�a��/��[® Á ¯AIÃjav��«�hj6~z�Ø� Á ¯ Kp��|P�;�y���X�[{����¯_swj6©«i��«{ü¯Fdfeh�§~��?®´��~��wj6~"{?|hikj6~z���6�[©hvz��ehjai�j�v�ª9��~@e?u?�Pja~�¦F��©«����h~z��¦h©«j6i�va¯ �,����������� ���L�O����� � �g� � �)#*� ��+�,�-�% �Q�76_� �w¯

-«����/p³Å¯ Á ¦��[©���*?�«{ü� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±?�§ja|w²(�ü�[{��Udô¯ �Ã��µ6|�¦�vH*'�;uX�h� Á ±�j6~�x�j6²��*ja{_xzj6~zja��eh�§�_e��_~z�wja~�o1mÃs � �v���e�j6ikj��[�h�h©«u?�§{���xz��©§�«{hj��[~z�«v�ja�ÄJ|h©«j6~n�_�*��|Pvyxz�«�av6¯ �:������������ ��� �O����� � �)� � �#*� ��+/.�.���� �F�[�_�_�h¯

-«����/ô��¯ � ��~��Fj6{Xxz�§ja~a¯ � � �!������� %.��� � ��� 10 ���������1��%&���!� � � �O������� � ���<� ��� �����2+R� �A�!� � ���� � ���43? ��� � �O�������� � � � �t��� �������7� � � �2���<� ��� ����� ¯/dfehj�v���v6�hmn{h�«±�j6~�v�� xyu°��ª"ln�«�6j*®ys?����eh�«� Á {Xxz�§�F��©«�«va�ü�06A6_�h¯

û�û Ò�S�ÛÅî�ï�î

Page 31: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

��� � ������ �� �L������:�"��� � ����1�� ��� � ���� �� ���������.�����!��������A�

-«� ' /=Q¯ ¥ | �[{�� � ¯ ¥ �[{h�P¯Ql �_{w®Nj6²w�«v�x�ja{��*jÃ�[ªüxzeh�§~��°�_~z�hj6~��_�6�6|h~z�[x�jpv�jai��§® �w�«vz�*~zj*xzjpo1mps � � ®Nxyu?�Pjv���e�j6ikjavê9��~�{���{h©«�§{�ja�[~��6��{�v�j6~z±'�'x��«��{�©«�;¬ vô�[{P�¨|h{h�13�j��U�6��{�v�x�~z|��*x��«��{���ª/eh�«��e¶���a�*|h~��'xzj�Ä@l=Fv���e�j6ikjava¯ � � � � � �<�L����� ��� � ��� ��� � ��%:�O��� � ��% ��� � ��%,�!���L��� � ��� ��� �C���C� V� ��� ��% � ��� �Qs?ja�wx�jai¦Fj6~�[® �h�(�06A6_�h� � ��*_jpd��[e��Xj_�hl ��¯

-«�6�A/p³Å¯ Á ¦���©«�A*?�§{ü� Á ¯#Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(�_dô¯ �n�_µ6|h¦PvH*'�;u_��¯ � ��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��[©Ps?x�|��wuk��ª(o1�[x�ehjai��'x����6��©Po �w�?®j6©�vfª9��~ ln����v�j IplÃs3� � � �,� ��������� �[�_�_�;®y�����_�

-«����/p³Å¯ Á ¦P�[©���*?�§{Q� Á ¯7IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h²3�'dô¯ �n�_µ6|h¦�v�*'�;u_��¯0Qn�§�_e Á �6�*|�~z�_�*uÃsXxz|��wuô�[ª�o1�[x�ehjai��'x����6��©_o �w�wja©«vª9��~ IÃlps��[ªül �_�«v�jn�[~z��|�{���s?x�ja�_�wu�o ja��{.B�©«�'¬��3�§{°�J~z�w�[¯_�[ª � ����� � ����� � �9"� � ������ )�$�2� � �>� ���1 � ���'��������� ������-�-�� � I�¯ Ä ¯��Fja� xz��|h{ü����¯/��j6~z�«��|w²(� ��¯ Á ¯$Inj�v����wja~��N�foù¯�o1�[~z�«{h�·SÄ/�hv6¯ê¹Å� � ³�o1lÃÄ��Mf�[~��*j6©«��{P�·N�[���X��¹

-«�a��/ �*³ ��Á swÄ � � �_� �$¥ ��~*wv�eh�_� ��{ M�j6{���ehi���~�* �J~��_¦h©«j6i�v �«{ � ��ik�h|wx��'xz�§�_{��[© Á ja~��X���6��|�v�®x����6v�· ��ÁÃÁ ¹ �[�Pl Á s Á � �_{wª9j6~zj6{��6j��J|h¦h©«�«�a�'xz�§�_{ü�<Qn��ik�wx��_{ü���n�«~��_�§{��«���!Fp�Åx��_¦Pja~n�'��® ���h�F�76A6���¯

-«���/p³Å¯ Á ¦���©«�A*X�«{ü� �¯:M��_¦O*��'±3� Á ¯:IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h²3��dô¯�Ã��µa|h¦�v�*;�;uX�h� ��¯Ãs?eh�«~zu_�[ja±3�ôsXxz|��wu �[ª�e��§�_e���a�*|h~����6u �_~z�wja~ vz��ehjai�j�v��{�� {���{w®´~�j�+�ja�*x��«{h�A¦F��|h{P�h�[~zu �*��{P�w� xz�§�_{�vª9��~ {h����v�j��h~z�������_�[x��«��{�h~z��¦h©«j6i�va� � �«���h|h{h�'±­³ {�vyxz� xz|wx�j-~�ja�P�_~�x�����~����yja�ÅxJ6 6'® �_�h���[�_�h�_���;±'�[�«©��[¦h©«j ��{ P�eXx�xz� P � �;¬�¬�¬f®v��_�ü¯ �§{h~z���h¯ ª9~ �;x�~z���h���6v � Á ©«���§{ü¯ IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h² �'©§���[��|h{h�'±3¯ eXxzi�©

-«�a��/°³Å¯ Á ¦P�[©���*?�§{Q� Á ¯ Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(�_dô¯ �n�_µ6|h¦PvH*'�;u_��¯�FÃ{��_�6�*|�~z�_�*u��[ª({h�_�«v�j��w�«~�j��Åx/�6��©«�6|h©��'x��«��{k¦��_v�j����{1ÄJ|h©«j6~�ik�w�wja©Ø� � �<� + � +5�,��������� � ��� ·ßxz�°�[�h�Fja��~�¹*¯

-«�76�/�s?x�}6��e��[{hj � j6i��[�«~zj��AKp�«©§¦Fj6~�x@�����_}�¯ Á }6~z�_�_�*�_|�vyxz�«�X|hj��[�h��©§���X|h}6j��[|h²�;±X�«��{Pv���� ��;3���§~zjav7PQ�J~z��¦w®©§}ai��'x����X|hj��Xik}*xzeh�w�w��©«���_�§j�j6x���|hx��«©«v/j6{?±?�«vz�[�_}avJ��ehjaµ:IÃ�_v�vz�[|�© x Á ±?�«�[x��«��{¨·9�«{�ª9~zj6{���eF¹ ��&���%.� ��������1���<� *0 �������0 ���� ��%n����<� ���A� � ����@���G�)�����0�A��������� ����<� ���: ����� �����1��� ��������� ����� ����<���=��� ��������������������#�:�,� � � Á ~��6�_��eh��{ ��®L6�w�*x���¦�~�j��[�_�_�h�

-ê�[��/�s(¯ � �[i���~�~z�Ø�Xo¶¯ ��¯Xsw��©§±_j*x�x��N� Mp¯ �Ã�?��¦h|�va� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±X�«j6|h²3¯3l |�i�ja~����6��©��w�1;F|Pv��«��{�¦��_v�j�����{keh�«��ew®��~��wj6~p�wj6~z�«±;�[x��«±�j�v �«{-o1mÃs � � vz��ehj6ikjavnª9��~ � Ä/s¨��{1|h{Pvyxz~�|��*x�|h~zja�¨��~z�«�hva�n�«{1xzehj�h~z�w�*jaja�w�«{h�_v�[ª �� � �!� .(#k� � ����� ��� ����" ��� � ���� � % ���2��� � ���<� � �Q� ��|h©«u¨�a�[® ���h�ê�[�������XdQ¬�j6{Xx�j�·�Q ��©«©��[{���¹

-ê�w��/�s(¯ � ��i��[~z~��N�Po¶¯ ® ��¯üsw�[©«±�j6x�x��N� Á ¯ Inja~�±?�«j6|w²(� Mï �Ã�X�_¦h|�va¯ Á ©«�'¬��w�1;F|�v��«��{-o1mps � � vz��ehjai�jª9��~ � Ä/s ��{ |h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja���~z�«�hva� �:����������� ��� ������� � �)� � �#*� ��+�.�.���� � �[|�©§u �[���X�

-ê����/�s(¯ � �[i��[~z~z�Ø�5Mp¯ �n�?�_¦h|�va�Qo¶¯ ��¯�sw��©§±_j*x�xz�Ø� Á ¯ IÃj6~z±?�§ja|w²(¯ Á ©«�'¬f®´�w�1;3|�v��«��{¶o1mÃs � � vz��ehjai�jª9��~ � Ä/s ��{ |h{�v�x�~z|��Åxz|h~zja���~z�«�hva¯ � ��%,�!���L����� ��� ��C���C� �� ·9x����[�h�Fja��~�¹

ó È�û ó æ

Page 32: A tetrahedral-based superconvergent scheme for aeroacoustics · Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis 2004, route des Lucioles, BP 93, 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France) Téléphone

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Futurs : Parc Club Orsay Université - ZAC des Vignes4, rue Jacques Monod - 91893 ORSAY Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38334 Montbonnot Saint-Ismier (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399


Recommended