Date post: | 04-Jun-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | darvin-mcmaster |
View: | 216 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 20
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 1/20
Operating Seamlessly:Integrating Operationsto Deliver the Non-StopCustomer Experience
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 2/20
Introduction 1
Toward seamless retail 2
Evolving to the future 3
The customer experience 4
is everythingTraditional channel boundaries 8among teams are over
New roles for store associates 10and stores
The evolution of the elastic supply chain 12Metrics for a new reality 14
Getting started 15
Looking ahead 16
Get in touch 17
References 17
Contents
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 3/20
Operating Seamlessly
To keep up, retailers must evolve. Its a future where
they transform into integrated retail organizations thatdeliver seamless experiences for non-stop customers.
Todays non-stop customers are online, on the
go, in stores and in touch with social networks
from Facebook and Twitter to Pinterest and
Instagram. These customers have more tools
than ever to learn about products, compare
prices and gather insightsthe options are
always evolving. And these customers want
a relevant experience while paying less.
In fact, Accentures survey of 6,000 consumers
in eight countries reveals that the majority of
respondents believe that integrating in-store,
online and mobile is the number one thing
that retailers can do to improve the shopping
experience.1Survey data shows that when it
comes to in-store shopping, consumers want
the basicsthe right products, the right prices
and an easy shopping experience.
To attract these customers and succeedin a complex, fast moving and hyper-
competitive environment, retailers must
change their game to remain relevant.
They must become seamless retailers
(see Toward seamless retail overleaf).2
As part of Accentures series on seamless
retailing, this point of view addresses
the seamless operations aspect of this
transformation. This is a future in which the
retail organization becomes as connected as
customers are. The focus is on reinventing the
status quo across marketing, merchandising,
supply chain and channel teams, talent andmetricsconnecting isolated functions and
roles in new ways.
How can retailers organize to meet
consumers evolving needs without adding
cost and complexity? While there is no one-
size-fits-all guide to becoming a seamless
retail organization, the potential rewards are
significantso are the risks of inaction.
Retail will changemore in the nextfive years than ithas in the past 50.
COMEIN
OPENWERE
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 4/20
2 Operating Seamlessly
Toward seamless retailDelivering a consistently personalized, on-brand experience for every
customerevery time, across every channel is the holy grail of seamlessretailing. Its essential for retailers to remain relevant, build loyalty and
boost sales in a turn-on-a-dime market.
Seamlessness requires a new breed of customer experience, operations,
platforms and partnerships. Retailers must evolve to:
CustomizeUnderstanding individual shoppersin context and across channels
ConnectIntegrating operations to sustain
a single customer conversation
ConvergeBuilding standardized IT platformsthat unify divergent data sources
CollaborateForging partnerships to strengthenthe customer value proposition
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 5/20
Do we have the right
people, the right
skillsand the right
accountabilities?
How can we address the
political realities when
trying to transform
our organization?
How should we
prioritize short
and long-term
strategies?
Evolving to the futureFrom empowered customers and channel complexity to warp-speed innovation and the
competitive threat of online pure plays, the new face of retail is not for the meek.
In fact, Accentures evaluation of 60 global retailers reveals a significant gap between realityand customer expectations.3Yet forward-thinking retailers are realistic and pragmatic enoughto understand the need for change.
What is clear is that there is no single
cure-all for every retailer in transforming
the organization. Each will take a distinct
and nuanced journey to seamlessness,
some faster than others, some more
streamlined than others, and some more
boldly than others.
No retailer has yet to realize every aspect of
seamless retailing. However, we are seeing
companies exploring seamless options more
and more. For example, Macys and Saks are
among retailers that have created new
senior level positions to drive integration
and seamlessness around the
customer experience.
While there will be changes in IT, human
resources and other enabling functions, this
discussion focuses on customer-facing area
where retailers must change in five key area
These include actions that retailers can take i
marketing, merchandising, supply chain and
channel teams, and talent and metrics and ar
explored in detail on the following pages.
Even with thiseyes-open approach,becoming seamless
raises more questions thananswers as retailers take a
hard look at what theirfuture organizationmight look like:
Operating Seamlessly
Where do we start?
How should we organize
and operatewhat specifi
changes must be made?
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 6/20
4 Operating Seamlessly
It is not enough for retailersto simply agree thatcustomers are empoweredlike never before. They mustmake substantive operationalchanges where awareness
of and attention to thepersonalized, relevant anddistinct customer experienceis a primary focus.
Leading the way, traditionally independent
merchandising and marketing organizations
must converge under a customer experience
umbrella. The emphasis must be on the
customer experience as much asif not more
thanproducts and pricing. Having the right
products and pricing is a given for success.
But the real source of differentiation will be
the customer experience.
Trumpet the brandvoice loudlyAs part of this focus on the customer
experience, marketing and merchandising
must present a cohesive brand to the non-
stop customer. This requires a laser focus on
developing consistent brand campaigns across
existing and new channelsalways with an
eye to the horizon. The pace of change is
simply that swift.
Yet marketing cannot stop here. The brand
presence must be bold, clear and consistent
to connect with customers and to rise above
the noise of consumers always-on lives.
The execution of such campaigns is of
singular importance.
While print and circular were once retailers
marketing vehicles of choice, todays focus
is on ever-evolving online, mobile and social
vehicles. These channels are here to stay, and
their impact is increasing at a rapid pace.
Forrester Research estimates that the social
media, email and mobile marketing market
a $6 billion market opportunity todaywill
skyrocket to $16 billion in just three years.4
Having ongoing brand interactions with
consumers across all channels requires new
competencies including deep fluency in
cutting-edge interactive technologies and
an ability to sense, evaluate and respond at
speedand at scaleto customer interaction
Whats more, success will require increased
collaboration with operationsboth
online and in storeand approaches that
synchronize consistent, non-stop customerexperiences across all customer-facing teams
There are retailers making inroads in this
area. Consider Williams-Sonoma, a home
furnishings retailer in the United States and
Canada with a number of niche brands. The
company has evolved its legacy marketing
approaches to an omnichannel one with a
strong social media focus while maintaining
the integrity of its brand family.5
The customer experienceis everything
1
$6bnsocial media,
email and mobilemarketing market
opportunitytoday
willskyrocket to
$16bnin just
three years
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 7/20
Operating Seamlessly
Infuse merchandisingwith customeradvocacyThe future of merchandising must be about
leading customers to their desired purchases
with a personalized, end-to-end experience
that has no seams from either retailers or
customers perspectives.
This means trading product centricity for
customer advocacy and offering customers
the right price, assortment, promotionand
now customer experienceconsistently
across channels. Moreover, the customer and
product agendas must be in lock step and
inform merchandising tactics at every turn.
This strategic combination of customer
experience insight and merchandising
acumen must become a core competency
for retailers. Customer insight data is the
glue that holds this customer experience
function together. Without data-driven views
of customerswho they are, what they want,
how they behaveretailers cannot offer
authentic and effective customer experiences
even to their most brand-loyal shoppers.
To truly understand and deliver the right
customer experiences, the customer insight
group must become more embedded
with merchandisingeither physically or
operationally. This integration eliminates
insight islands, making it easier to incorporate
insights at the point and place of decision.
Such changes will certainly impact
existing leadership and cross-functional
organizational structures. More and more,
retailers will need to consider creating
customer experience organizations.
These can take on many forms. For one,
customer experience teams could be located
within marketing and influence merchants
from there. In another scenario, the customerexperience team could be fully embedded
in merchandising with an equal voice at
the table. Or separate customer experience
function with individual team members
matrixed into each merchant buying team.
Customer experience organizations can take on different models.
Customer experience teamscould be located withinmarketing and influencemerchants from there.
The customer experienceteam could be fully embeddedin merchandising with anequal voice at the table.
Separate customer experiencefunction with individual teammembers matrixed into eachmerchant buying team.
Matrixed
$ $
MerchandisingMarketing
$
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 8/20
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-13 9/20
Operating Seamlessly
Get up close and personal with customers
Meeting customers demands for a superior
customer experience will ultimately mean a
decline in mass marketing vehicles in favor
of highly-targeted micro-promotions. Thisis because non-stop customers preferand
are more responsive totargeted one-to-one
interactions and personal dialogues
with retailers.
Accentures recent consumer survey supports
this concept. Results reveal that 88 percent of
customers are willing to or would definitely
use personalized, real-time promotions sent
to their mobile phones. Of those customers,
38 percent say they would definitely use
such promotions and cannot wait until theirfavorite retailers offer them. Whats more,
nearly all consumers surveyed want the same
promotions in-store and online.6
As retailers become more seamless in how
they operate, strategic, real-time personalized
services and offeringsin line with the right
productsmust become the norm.
With the influx of consumer data, advanced
analytics capabilities and the right technology
platforms, retailers can do what once seemed
contradictory if not impossibleconnect with
individual consumers at scale.
The chief marketing officer of Macys explains
just how personal micro-promotions executed
at scale can be. There are times well send out
18 million unique emailsdown to the point
of emailing a shopper with a message like:we saw you last night on the womens shoes
part of the website, and then send that
shopper a targeted show promotion.7
Rethink support functions andfuel the innovation engine
To enable these new capabilities and teams
of the future, something has to give.
To reinvent operations, retail organizations
require specialized support functions and
new capabilities to free up capacity and
infuse innovation into the business. Without
this, retailers are working against the tide of
increased market complexity, the big data
onslaught and the sheer pace of innovation.
Affecting change can begin by taking an
objective look at roles and responsibilitieswithin these functional areas, redefining and
prioritizing to optimally support both tactical
and strategic needs. Specialized execution
teams must take on tactical activities. One
of the worlds largest retailers has done just
that. The company relies on the commercial
division of its India-based global service center
to handle marketing and merchandising
functions including sourcing, forecasting,
supplier management and analytics.
Several tactical areas must take on a new
importance and evolve in the seamless
organization. Retail data management,
including master data management and
content management, is essential to enable
clean and common data across functions. And
strong analytics capabilities are essential to
produce actionable insight for faster, better
decision making.
With their rate of innovation typically
underperforming the online pure plays,
traditional retailers can use this opportunityto redirect freed up resources to support a
strategic innovation agenda. One way is to
consolidate and redirect execution functions
in-house or externally and develop innovation
labs to launch horizon programs and products.
Outsourcing commodity functions can free up
funding to invest in innovation.
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 10/20
8 Operating Seamlessly
Many retailers today haveindependent marketing,merchandising and supplychain teams that focus on asingle channel. But in the eraof the non-stop customer,
this model is out of synchwith the times.
As retailers prepare for a seamless future,
they must work to eliminate these channel
boundaries on their own timetable. The key
will be to strike the right balance between
bringing functions together and the need
to incubate newer online businesses by
determining the right threshold for change
against the retailers business strategy.
But in the end, these teams must be
connected to serve the entire enterprise. Its
about working more effectively and cost-
efficiently as a seamless retail organization,
smashing antiquated internal silos to function
just as cross channel as customers shop.
Without a doubt, this is a significant and
transformational change. It will mean holistic
ownership of product categoriesand,ultimatelyholistic customer and product
P&L responsibility across all channels.
Governance, guidelines, skills and capabilities
must be initiated or updated to enable
a consistent cross-channel experience.
Leadership and organizational changes will
also be in playfrom the executive suite to
the showroom floor.
The good news is that such changes are
possibleand profitable. In fact, some retail
pioneers have already made strides in this
area. Macys, for example, recently named a
chief omnichannel officer with responsibility
for integrating store, online and mobilea
move that demonstrates the retailers desire
to align operations with how customers
shop.8Staples is poised to bring its U.S. retail
business and staples.com under unifiedleadership. Whats more, Apple already
operates with a single P&L.9
In the United Kingdom, the John Lewis
department store has strengthened its ability
to offer customers cross-delivery options and
click-and-collect services by unifying online
and store businesses under a single reporting
function. The initiative has generated
outstanding results. Between 2011 and 2012
John Lewis reported an 8.7 percent lift in
gross sales, to 4.4 billion.
2 Traditional channel boundariesamong teams are over
Customer placesorder online
Customer notifiedof order status
Customers orderdelivered to store
Customer collectsorder from store
John Lewis, in the United Kingdom, reported an8.7%liftin gross sales, to 4.4 billion from click-and-collect services.
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 11/20
Traditional retail teams will need to explore different organizational approaches to be ableto give customers the seamless experiences they want. While there is not a single right
answer, possibilities include:
Chief seamlesschannelsofficer model
Several retailers have
recently created a chief
omnichannel officer
position, which is anexcellent step toward
eliminating traditional
channel boundaries and
delivering one customer
experience in-store, online,
through mobile, etc.
The authoritychief customerofficer model
A chief customer officer
oversees a consolidated
marketing and
merchandising function,with a dramatically
higher level of integration
across product, offer
and customer experience
decision making. This can
be a new position or a role
filled by the current chief
merchant, chief marketing
officer or channel leader.
The facilitatorchief customerofficer model
A chief customer officer
position is created to work
closely with the chief
marketing officer, the chiefmerchant, CIO and other
leaders to drive customer
experience orientation
throughout organization.
The collaborationmodel
If structural changes
are not possible initially
or even in the long
term, leadership must
support an environment
where cross-functional
collaboration is a priority.
Strong governance
with a clear decision
approach and adherence
to customer-focused
processes is required.
Ultimately, the chief
merchant, chief marketing
officer, chief channelofficer, chief customer
officer and CIO must
work as equals to deliver
the desired seamless
customer experience.
Changing the leadership structure
Operating Seamlessly
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 12/20
10 Operating Seamlessly
Retail customers move backand forth across channelswith intention to completetheir shopping missions.Yet even in a multichannelenvironment, physical stores
still matter. In fact, 89 percentof respondents to AccenturesSeamless Retail Survey ratein-store as the easiest retailchannel in which to completea purchase.
Moving forward, realizing seamless retail
operations requires two distinct roles for
store associates. Retailers need the right mix
of customer facing and fulfillment focusedassociates. And each type plays a specific
role in connecting online and in-store
environments in new ways.
Keep people comingback with highlyskilled talentTo drive seamless operations, customer-facing
store associates must evolve to become
the frontline stewards of an increasingly
sophisticated customer experience. These
new store associates must understandcustomers, products, prices and promotions,
using technology tools to gather and share
information to meet customers needsand
connect with their aspirations.
Aligning technology, mobility, customer and
product knowledgewithin and outside
the physical boundaries of the storeis a
core competency for this store associate.
Associates essentially become cross-channel
customer ambassadors. This shift helps
retailers capture the highest share of walletfrom customersin-store shoppers become
online shoppers, and when online shoppers
visit the store, they want to come back.
To create a compelling in-store experience
that resonated with cross-channel shoppers,
John Lewis piloted a virtual fashion mirror
over six weeks in 2012. This innovative tool
allowed customers to try-on outfits and
get recommendations for coordinated pieces
without browsing the racks. Store associates
helped guide the experience, and customers
could make purchases in-store or online
via an in-store kiosk. Sixty-seven percent ofparticipating customers reported that they
enjoyed this experience.10
Wal-Marts Scan & Go program is another
example of how retailers are using technolog
tools to offer customers new control over
their shopping experiences. Using their
iPhones, customers scan and bag groceries
while shopping and then pay quickly and
conveniently using self-checkout. As retailers
provide options like this, sales associates will
have to be far more sophisticated in helpingcustomers use their own devices than they
are today.
3 New roles for store associatesand stores
Add item
Scan & Go!
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 13/20
Operating Seamlessly 1
To provide experiences like this, retailers will
have to re-skill and appropriately incent
their sales workforce to support them. New
and continuous training programs will be
essential. Not only will associates have to
understand products and promotions across
channels, they will have to be trained on
enhanced customer experience tools.
Training in a seamless retail organizationmust be real-time and at the point of
experience with customers, using the latest
mobile tools. To accomplish this, retailers will
need training approaches that are dynamic
and also cost effective and efficient.
According to Motorolas most recent Holiday
Shopping Study, 47 percent of shoppers
reported better experiences when store
associates consulted technology tools for
product information.11And better shopping
experiences usually translate to betterbuying experiences.
Enable stores asfulfillment centersJust as store associates need to deliver
a more sophisticated in-store customer
experience, these associates must meet
the needs of customers who never even
enter the store. More than an important
operational shiftthis is a cultural shift
in which stores and associates treat every
online order as if it came from the brands
most loyal customer.
An important part of making this happen
is a shift where stores become fulfillment
centers. Its about increasing real-time
order fulfillment with store associates who
provide non-stop customers with what they
want faster. Rethinking stores as fulfillment
centers provides customers with the highly-
coveted immediacy that shipping fromdistant distribution centers rarely achieves as
easily and inexpensively. This translates into
better, more customer-centeredand more
profitablefulfillment.
To drive this shift, retailers must identify
another type of store associate, apart
from the customer experience ambassador
mentioned earlier. These associates do not
necessary sell. Instead, they pick, pack
and ship orders just as distribution center
associates do today. This is similar to apparel
retailer Zaras approach where sales associate
have traditionally spent time focused on
logistics related activities.12This transitionwill mean that retailers must rethink store
processes, reconsider talent and manage
labor differently. Store leadership at all levels
and across functions will also change to
effectively manage these new specializations
But this shift can work. Consider that Macys
and Nordstrom are using stores to support
online order fulfillment today.
47%of shoppers reported betterexperiences when store associatesconsulted technology tools forproduct information.
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 14/20
12 Operating Seamlessly
The retail supply chain is thelifeline of the retail enterprise,getting the right products tothe right stores, distributioncenters and customers at theright time. Changes to the
supply chain and inventorymanagement are key tofulfilling the promise ofseamless retailing.
Make visibility anddynamic fulfillmentmandatoryJust as single-channel teams create blind
spots in serving cross-channel customers, so
does a supply chain focused only to a single
area of the business. Instead, inventory must
be managed at the enterprise level. All nodesof the supply chainstores, suppliers and
other partners includedmust work together
to increase product visibility, availability,
profitability and speed to customer.
This integration is also important for retailers
because it is essential to helping them
meet non-stop customers expectations for
inventory visibility. When asked to name the
most important information to have prior
to visiting a physical store, 66 percent of
respondents to the Accenture Seamless RetailConsumer Survey selected product availability
information. Simply put, when customers
want something, retailers must make sure
they get it.
Achieving a single view of inventory
availability will mean that accountability
must shift from location inventory
ownership to enterprise inventory
ownership. Existing supply chain
organizations must transform into a single
supply chain team that includes digital
fulfillment centers, digital fulfillment from
stores and enterprise forecasting capabilities
It is about replacing fragmentation withcommon teams and processes.
Perhaps not surprisingly, data indicates that
retailers recognize the need for a new kind
of inventory management. Eighty percent of
mega retailers recently surveyed by the Retai
Systems Research identified shared inventory
for in-store and online fulfillment as a top
priority, though many are still not there.13
Getting there, and making profitable decision
with a streamlined supply chain, will requirespecialized teams and capabilities to analyze
and optimize inventory data and practices
across channels.
4 The evolution of theelastic supply chain
The retail supply chain is the
lifelineof the retail enterprise.
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 15/20
Operating Seamlessly 1
Emphasize returnsmanagementIt is increasingly common for customers to
purchase a product in one channel and to
expect to return it in another. The non-stop
customers path to return is just as fluid
as the path to purchase. In fact, Accenture
survey data reveal that the majority of
consumers will seek out the least expensive
return option even if it is not as convenient
as other options.
As such, retail organizations must
manage returns more holistically.
Returns management must become a
core competency for all customer-facing
employees at stores, distribution centers and
call centers. Retailers must focus equally on
moving product through the forward and
backward supply chain.
This focus is about aligning returns with
customer behaviorskeeping customers
happy while maintaining profitability.
However, it can be quite challenging because
managing returns is highly complex today.
Retailers must now solve for disposition,
fraudulent and multichannel returns with
more risk of getting taken advantage of than
ever. In 2012 alone, retailers lost an estimated
$8.9 billion to return fraud.14
Moving through this complexity, retailers
must consider how to standardize, streamline
and monitor return processes, so returns are
painless and profitable.
It will be essential to train store associates
in this area. While doing so, leadership must
account for labor management implications
around the measurement/incentives of
multichannel returns. They must also get
better about scheduling and capacity asreturns will continue to play a growing role
in retailers business. But with updated core
processes, technology and skills, returns
management can be a source of customer
loyalty and added value.
Nordstrom is one retailer that has historically
gotten returns right. The Seattle-based
fashion retailer has a sterling reputation
for returns.
Retailers must consider how to standardize,streamline and monitor return processes, soreturns are painlessand profitable.
REFUND
Online purchase
Return to store
Receive refund
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 16/20
14 Operating Seamlessly
As retail organizationsevolve to become seamless,traditional metrics mustevolve too. This includesboth the way that retailerstrack their performance
holistically and how they areviewed externally, as well ashow companies internallymeasureand, ultimatelychange behavior. Changingmetrics at both of theselevels is essential for retailersto become truly seamless.In essence, incentives must
influence behavior change todrive sales across all channels,powering the dissolution ofexisting seams.
Looking at the macro level, existing metrics
like comp store sales are not going away any
time soon, but they must reflect what the
reality of the business is. The comp store sales
need to reflect total sales growth for in-store
and online purchases holistically. Retailers
must introduce comp customer sales to
work in tandem with traditional comp store
sales. Its about measuring total category
performance online and offline.
This is a necessary shift because customers
shop across all channels, and retailers must
be measured, rewarded and incented on
enterprise customer sales.
Changing measures and metrics at a micro
level is also essential to eliminate potentially
dysfunctional behavior that can block
seamlessness. Retailers must incent different
departments and functions to operate with
a seamless mindsetaligning incentives with
metrics and measurement. For example, if
stores and associates are not credited for
online purchases, they have little incentive to
make online order fulfillment a priorityandthe customer experience suffers.
Some retailers are making changes to alleviat
challenges like this. As part of its commitmen
to integrate in-store and online channels,
Nordstrom recognized the importance of
aligning teams across channels around
customer sales over fostering an environmen
where teams fight over credit.15
This issue of giving stores credit for sales
initiated in other channels will continue tobe significant. If retailers want to continue
to rely on stores to alleviate out-of-stocks
for online orders, they must look at customer
value and related incentives with much more
of an omnichannel eye.
Customers shop across all channels,
and retailers must be measured,
rewarded and incented on
enterprise customer sales.
In storeVsonline
5 Metrics for a new reality
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 17/20
Getting startedRetailers can create momentum towards becoming a seamless retail
organization by considering the following steps:
Acknowledge the burning platformWhether you have explicitly acknowledged it or not, the
retail industry is dramatically changing, and no company
will survive without transforming over the next five years.
Determine how proactively and quickly your business
will migrate categories to online customer purchase and
understand the radical implications of those transitions
across store size and overall count, assortment, space,
pricing, inventory and store labor.
Identify target customer experiencesWhile we may not be able to predict exactly how customer
experiences will change, we do know they will change
significantly as technology transforms how customers
shop. As inventory visibility, scan & go and other
technologies rapidly gain adoption, are you organized to
rapidly deliver those customer experiences? Determine the
seamless product-specific customer experiences that will
define how your customer will want to shop.
Put the right leadership in placeRegardless of which organizational model is right for you,
some level of new leadership is critical to be a catalyst
to help others throughout the company think differently
and drive the change. Consider whether establishing a
new chief customer officer to define the overall customer
experiences, or a chief channel officer to unite all customer
touchpoints, is right for your business.
Involve the right people from
the beginningBecause the need to become seamless will touch on
customer-facing and enabling functionsfrom IT to
merchandising, to marketing, to channels to supply chain
representatives from all areas must actively participate from
the outset to ensure that the left hand knows what the
right hand is doing. Establish the right governance model to
ensure the collaboration takes place.
Know that making the business
case will be challengingWhile we know that customers demand seamless
experiences across all channels, defining a business case
as is historically done for traditional initiativescan be
challenging. It is easy for companies to estimate sales lift,
cost take-out and other potential benefits. But the reality is
that it is as much a defensive play to maintain your current
customer base, your current share of wallet and preventdefection to online pure plays and other competitors as it
is about driving an upside. Realize that becoming seamless
is about survivaland then establish operating metrics to
monitor progress to ensure your business is moving ahead.
1 4
52
3
Operating Seamlessly 1
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 18/20
16 Operating Seamlessly
By building a seamless retail organizationone
step at a time and at their own paceretailers can
deliver non-stop customer experiences that defy
the limitations of a single channel. Only throughthis type of transformation will retailers be able to
surviveand thrivethrough the dramatic changes
driving a reinvention of retail as we know it.
Merchandisingand Marketingconvergewith a unifiedposition withthe customerexperiencebecomingequally
importantas productand price.
Sales associatesmust providesophisticatedcustomerexperienceswhile fulfillmentassociatesenable complexdelivery options.
Single-channelteamsmarketing,merchandisingand supplychainmustconsolidateto servecustomers
across theenterprise.
The supplychain mustevolve tomanageinventoryholisticallyforward,backward andsideways.
Metrics andincentivesmust expand toinclude holisticcustomervaluecompcustomer salesare as importantas comp store
sales.
Looking aheadIn the coming years, customers demands will change, evolving in ways that we cannot yet
imagine today. Engaged and delighted by shopping missions suited to their needs, non-stopcustomers want the ideal experience from retailers. And if they dont get it, they simply changecourseexploring other channels and competitors.
To deliver seamless experiences, retailers must operate seamlessly themselves. Navigating allof the decisions that must be made can be overwhelming, but retailers can focus on these keycustomer-facing areas:
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 19/20
Operating Seamlessly 1
Get in touchAccenture has a dedicated team focused
on the issues retailers face competing
in the online economy for more
information please contact:
GlobalChris Donnelly
Asia PacificTakaaki Haraguchi
EuropeAdrian Bertschinger
North AmericaDave Richards
1 Accenture Seamless Retail Consumer Survey, November 2012.
2 See Accentures Seamless Retail: Customize. Connect. Converge.
Collaborate. for more detail.
3 Accenture Seamless Retail Consumer Survey,November 2012
4 Forrester Research Inc., US Interactive Marketing Forecast, 2011 To 2016,
September 2011.
5 Fiorletta, Alicia. (October 30, 2012). Social Advocacy Summit: Retail and Facebook
Execs Discuss Shift to Converged Marketing. In Retail Touchpoints Web site.
Retrieved March 5, 2013.
6 Accenture Seamless Retail Consumer Survey,November 2012.
7 Kalakota, Ravi. (January 19, 2012). Multi-channel to Omni-channel Retail
Analytics: Big Data Use Case. In Practical Analytics Word Press Web site.Retrieved
on March 5, 2013 from http://practicalanalytics.wordpress.com/2012/01/19/omni-
channel-retail-analytics-a-big-data-use-case/
8 Demery, Paul. (January 29, 2013). Macys Names a Chief Omnichannel Executive.In Internet RetailerWeb site. Retrieved on March 5, 2013 from http://www.
internetretailer.com/2013/01/29/macys-names-chief-omnichannel-executive
9 Eisenberg, Bryan. The Steve Jobs Way to Marketing Integration. In State of Search
Web site.Retrieved on March 5, 2013 from http://www.stateofsearch.com/the-
steve-jobs-way-to-marketing-integration-by-bryan-eisenberg-thegrok/
10 Cisco. Leading U.K. Retailer, John Lewis, Pilots Unique Cisco StyleMe Fashion
Mirror to Help Capture More Cross-Channel Shoppers.http://www.cisco.com/web
about/ac79/docs/retail/John-Lewis-and-Cisco-Virtual-fashion-mirror-case-
study.pdf
11 (January 2, 2013). Nearly 50% of Consumers Believe They are More Informed
than Store Associates. In Retail TouchPoints Web site.Retrieved on March 5, 201
from http://www.retailtouchpoints.com/in-store-insights/2162-nearly-50-of-
consumers-believe-they-are-more-informed-than-store-associates-
12 (April 18, 2011) Why Logistics Personnel Should Work in Stores? In StoreLogisti
Web site.Retrieved on March 5, 2013 from http://instorelogistics.wordpress.com
13 http://www.epicor.com/host/retail/RSR2012StoreReport.pdf
14 Winter, Caroline. (December 30, 2012). When Christmas Brings Retailers Many
Unhappy Returns. In Bloomberg Businessweek Web site.Retrieved on March 5,
2013 from http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2012-12-30/when-christmas-
brings-retailers-many-unhappy-returns
15 Taylor, Heather. (September 20, 2012). Nordstrom VP Warns RetailersPut Customers in Drivers Seat, or be Dead by 2020. In EConsultancy Web site.
Retrieved on March 5, 2013 from http://econsultancy.com/us/blog/10736-
nordstrom-vp-warns-retailers-put-customers-in-driver-s-seat-or-be-dead-
by-2020
References
8/13/2019 accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-130819124120-phpap
http:///reader/full/accentureoperatingseamlesslyintegratingoperationstodeliverthenon-stopcustomerexperience-1 20/20
About Accenture
Accenture is a global management
consulting, technology services and
outsourcing company, with approximately
261,000 people serving clients in more than
120 countries. Combining unparalleled
experience, comprehensive capabilities
across all industries and business functions,
and extensive research on the worlds
most successful companies, Accenturecollaborates with clients to help them
become high-performance businesses and
governments. The company generated net
revenues of US$27.9 billion for the fiscal
year ended Aug. 31, 2012. Its home page is
www.accenture.com.
Follow us on Twitter @AccentureRetail
Learn more at www.accenture.com/retail
Copyright 2013 Accenture. All rights reserved.
Accenture, its logo, and High Performance Deliveredare trademarks of Accenture.
Rights to trademarks referenced herein, other thanAccenture trademarks, belong to their respectiveowners. We disclaim proprietary interest in the marksand names of others.