Acid Gas: When to Inject and
Acid Gas: When to Inject and
QUESTOR TECHNOLOGY INC.QUESTOR TECHNOLOGY INC.QUESTOR TECHNOLOGY INC.QUESTOR TECHNOLOGY INC.
When to Inject and When to Incinerate
International Acid Gas Injection Symposium
Calgary,Calgary, 20092009Audrey Mascarenhas, P.Eng, M.Eng.Audrey Mascarenhas, P.Eng, M.Eng.
When to Inject and When to Incinerate
International Acid Gas Injection Symposium
Calgary,Calgary, 20092009Audrey Mascarenhas, P.Eng, M.Eng.Audrey Mascarenhas, P.Eng, M.Eng.
Safety is top priority in design
Regulatory requirements dictates when continuous combustion is permissible
Combustion is subject to SO2 dispersion compliance
Acid Gas Injection and Incineration
compliance Stack top temperature monitoring may be
required Field SO2 monitoring may be required
Part of Emergency Response Plan
Emergency Combustion As per Regulatory, A.G. processing/injection required
for continuous operation i.e. In Alberta sulphur to plant inlet > 1 t/d requires sulphur
recovery and/or A.G. injection
Proper combustion for emergency/temporary
Acid Gas Combustion
Proper combustion for emergency/temporary situations is required
Combustion parameters will fall within the permit to operate the facility
Other factors such as combustion duration and volume shall be part of the permit
Continuous Combustion Limits set by regulations
i.e. if Sulphur to plant inlet < 1 t/d, A.G. may be continuously combusted
Dispersion of SO2 must be modeled and be compliant with regulatory requirements or objectives
Acid Gas Combustion
Monitoring of stack top temperature i.e. maintain > 538C
Economics of combustion vs A.G. injection for lower flows and/or H2S content
SO2 monitoring may be required and dictated by modeling results
Safety Protection of public and personnel highest priority
Combustion of H2S must result in maximum conversion to SO2 99.99% combustion efficiency ensure measurable performance Efficiency assumptions not acceptable
Performance and Fuel Efficiency
Why Incinerate?
Performance and Fuel Efficiency Refractory and heat retention, high temperature and plume rise Minimal fuel reduces operating costs
Environment Shorter incinerator yields same plume height as significantly taller
flare stack
Smaller physical footprint with shorter stack less piping and forestry clearing
Difficult to measure efficiency and it varies significantly
Crosswinds decreases efficiency significantly and allows gases to escape unburned
Any combustion/mixing occurs outside stack
Flaring Concerns
Difficulty burning rich gases, entrained droplets
Poor for low heat content gases
Visible flame and poor air quality
Unknown and inconsistent performance
Based on ARC and U of A Research
Opportunities to ImproveOpportunities to ImproveAcid GasAcid Gas Sour Facility
Sour WellTesting
Combustion of Acid GasCombustion of Acid Gas
CH4 + 2 O2 = heat + CO2 + 2 H2O CH4 + 2 O2 = heat + CO2 + 2 H2O
99.99% efficiency requires the precise mixture of fuel and air
H2S + 3/2 O2 = heat + SO2 + H2O
Inefficient combustion results in uncontrolled emissions of: H2S CH4, CO, particulates Over 250 compounds Volatile organic hydrocarbons or VOCs - benzene Sulfur compounds - H2S, carbon disulfides, mercaptans
Negative impact on safety, air quality and human health
Incineration Measured independently and consistently at 99.99%
Auditable for compliance
Closed chamber unaffected by winds
High temperatures efficiently burn rich gas
Incineration Measured independently and consistently at 99.99%
Auditable for compliance
Closed chamber unaffected by winds
High temperatures efficiently burn rich gas High temperatures efficiently burn rich gas
Liquid droplets vapourized
Air pre-mixed
No smoke or odour
No visible flame
Reliable
High temperatures efficiently burn rich gas
Liquid droplets vapourized
Air pre-mixed
No smoke or odour
No visible flame
Reliable
TYPICAL APPLICATIONSTYPICAL APPLICATIONSTYPICAL APPLICATIONSTYPICAL APPLICATIONS
Each System is Custom-Engineered
Each System is Custom-Engineered
How It WorksHow It WorksHow It WorksHow It Works Proprietary gas burner
control creates a high velocity vortex
Air is naturally drawn in and pre-mixed with fuel
Proprietary gas burner control creates a high velocity vortex
Air is naturally drawn in and pre-mixed with fuel
No moving components and optimal air intake and mixing result in high reliability
Refractory lined chamber
Optimal SO2 dispersion with high velocity, temperature, and effective height
No moving components and optimal air intake and mixing result in high reliability
Refractory lined chamber
Optimal SO2 dispersion with high velocity, temperature, and effective height
Acid Gas and H2S ExperienceAcid Gas and H2S Experience
Both emergency and continuous A.G. experience
Extensive H2S combustion
Extensive well testing; domestic and global
Complex terrain
Both emergency and continuous A.G. experience
Extensive H2S combustion
Extensive well testing; domestic and global
Complex terrain Complex terrain
Close proximity to public
Custom solutions based on thorough understanding and experience
Safe, reliable, consistent, compliant, auditable, high performing and efficient
Public confidence, acceptance and support
Complex terrain
Close proximity to public
Custom solutions based on thorough understanding and experience
Safe, reliable, consistent, compliant, auditable, high performing and efficient
Public confidence, acceptance and support
SafetySafety Low heat radiation ideal for
forested and permafrost areas
99.99% combustion efficiency
H2S and other waste stream constituents are combusted
Low heat radiation ideal for forested and permafrost areas
99.99% combustion efficiency
H2S and other waste stream constituents are combusted constituents are combusted and or converted to safe emissions
Reliable, continuous operation
Simple to operate
constituents are combusted and or converted to safe emissions
Reliable, continuous operation
Simple to operate
Public Support
A.G.I. Emergency Incineration Dominion West StoddartA.G.I. Emergency Incineration Dominion West Stoddart 75% H2S, 25% CO2 Multi-stakeholder project Major highway and public
camp in emergency zone
Safe A.G. combustion
75% H2S, 25% CO2 Multi-stakeholder project Major highway and public
camp in emergency zone
Safe A.G. combustion Safe A.G. combustion
Solution customized and integrated into facility PLC
Small footprint
Successful operation with no H2S or SO2 detection
Safe A.G. combustion
Solution customized and integrated into facility PLC
Small footprint
Successful operation with no H2S or SO2 detection
Continuous IncinerationContinuous IncinerationCompton Clayhurst Compton Clayhurst Continuous IncinerationContinuous IncinerationCompton Clayhurst Compton Clayhurst
20% H2S and 60% CO2 Regulatory approval
538C stack temperature 20 MJ/m3 heating value continuous SO2 monitoring
Incinerator performance resulted in
20% H2S and 60% CO2 Regulatory approval
538C stack temperature 20 MJ/m3 heating value continuous SO2 monitoring
Incinerator performance resulted in Incinerator performance resulted in regulatory agency eliminating heating value clause
Reduced fuel usage by 80%
Four month payout
No issues with air quality
Incineration earned public support after initial objection to flaring
Incinerator performance resulted in regulatory agency eliminating heating value clause
Reduced fuel usage by 80%
Four month payout
No issues with air quality
Incineration earned public support after initial objection to flaring
Continuous IncinerationGrimes EnergyContinuous IncinerationGrimes Energy
65% H2S80 ft Incinerator
InnovativeInnovativeSolutionsSolutionsDehydration Benzene/H2SDestruction
Meet regulations Integrated package Reduced footprint WEST VIRGINIA US Reduced footprint Smaller lease size Reduced piping 80% less fuel used Heat recovery
WEST VIRGINIA USNatco/QTI
Fuel gas reduced from 1.3 to 0.5 MMscf/d
$2 MM cost saving
6 month payout
Sour Gas Plant Tail Gas Destruction
6 month payout
SO2 GL conc. 383 g/m3
CO2e emissions reduced by 73,000 tonnes
$1.1 MM carbon credits
Well TestsNexenIn Calgary34 % H2S
Well TestsNexenIn Calgary34 % H2S
PORTABLE INCINERATIONPORTABLE INCINERATION
Well TestExxon
18% H2S
Well TestExxon
18% H2S
WELL TESTINGPuguang Field, China18% H2S and 10% CO2
WELL TESTINGPuguang Field, China18% H2S and 10% CO2
ConclusionsConclusions Incineration provides a safe, competitive, technically
sound and reliable backup for AGI and continuous AG combustion
Performance must be measurable and reliable
Proper design will retain heat, maximize plume rise and
Incineration provides a safe, competitive, technically sound and reliable backup for AGI and continuous AG combustion
Performance must be measurable and reliable
Proper design will retain heat, maximize plume rise and Proper design will retain heat, maximize plume rise and minimize fuel utilization
Extensive experience with varied terrains and modeling
Custom solutions for specific situations driven by experience
Proper design will retain heat, maximize plume rise and minimize fuel utilization
Extensive experience with varied terrains and modeling
Custom solutions for specific situations driven by experience
COST REDUCTION FOR CLIENTS
PUBLIC CONFIDENCE
www.questortech.comwww.questortech.com
#420 ,1414 - 8th St SWCalgary, Alberta(403) 571-1530
ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION