Activated Dolomite Adsorption – Gaseous Effluent Treatment
Hanna, J-A. (2010). Activated Dolomite Adsorption – Gaseous Effluent Treatment. Invest Northern Ireland.
Document Version:Early version, also known as pre-print
Queen's University Belfast - Research Portal:Link to publication record in Queen's University Belfast Research Portal
General rightsCopyright for the publications made accessible via the Queen's University Belfast Research Portal is retained by the author(s) and / or othercopyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associatedwith these rights.
Take down policyThe Research Portal is Queen's institutional repository that provides access to Queen's research output. Every effort has been made toensure that content in the Research Portal does not infringe any person's rights, or applicable UK laws. If you discover content in theResearch Portal that you believe breaches copyright or violates any law, please contact [email protected].
Download date:11. Oct. 2021
The QUESTOR Centre
Applied Technology Unit
Report on behalf of Green Energy Engineering
Activated Dolomite Adsorption
– Gaseous Effluent Treatment
Prepared by ______________________
Dr Julie-Anne Hanna & Manus Carey
Approved by ______________________
Dr Elaine Groom
Date: 6th July 2010
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
1.0 Summary
This project involves trialling dolomite and activated dolomite in a commercial
flue to investigate their ability to remove major gaseous pollutants. Recent
investigations into utilising activated Dolomite have proved extremely
encouraging; in terms of phosphate, nitrate and dye removal from wastewater
and lab based removal of gaseous pollutants.
2.0 The Experimental Objectives
The following areas have been previously been researched:
I. An investigation into the charring of dolomite to optimise the specific
surface area
II. An investigation into the effectiveness of activated dolomite for treating a
range of industrial pollutants
III. Comparison of activated dolomite to activated carbon and other
adsorbates.
IV. Application of standard mathematical isotherm models to experimental
data to predict adsorptive behaviour.
V. Economic evaluation of using biological dolomite as an adsorbent/filter
for industrial gaseous treatment.
During this trial a small filter was produced and fitted in the flue to allow real
time data to be collected. Data was collected on 4 occasions;
With no filter
Raw dolomite filter
Activated dolomite filter
And an activated carbon filter
3.0 Introduction
3.1 Dolomite
Dolomite (the double carbonate of calcium and magnesium) is a compound
rather than a mixture of calcite and magnesite. Dolomite has a chemical
formula of CaCO3.MgCO3 with a molecular weight of 184.4 and a specific
gravity of 2.84g/cm3. Theoretically, pure dolomite contains 45.7% MgCO3 and
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
54.3% CaCO3. Its hardness is 3.5 – 4.0 on Moh‟s scale and its rhombohedral,
crystal system can be seen in Figure 1, (1). Pure dolomitic limestone has
30.4% CaO, 21.8% MgO, and 47.8% CO2. Impurities such as silica, chert,
clay, shale, feldspar, etc, are usually associated with the dolomitic limestone.
Figure 1: Dolomite structure
Dolomite is used in agriculture for neutralising soil acidity through a base
exchange, with calcium and magnesium cations displacing the hydrogen ions
in the soil. This process has been reported to increase crop yield by 14 –
40%, (1). Furthermore dolomite is used to make-up for the magnesium loss in
the soil due to plant growth and is also extensively used to counteract the
acidity of urea. The uses of dolomite can be classified into the following three
areas: (as shown in Table 1)
Direct applications,
Uses of selectively calcined dolomite,
Chemicals from dolomite.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Direct Applications Semi calcined Dolomite Chemicals from
Dolomite
Agriculture Magnesium Oxy-chloride
Cement
Magnesium Oxide
Cement Mortar
Clinker
Magnesium Oxy-sulphate
Cement
Magnesium Hydroxide
Treatment of Cracks Inorganic Magnesia
Foams
Magnesium Carbonate
Road Filler Silicate Bricks
Table 1: Uses of dolomite
3.2 Acid Rain
Acid rain is a term which describes the acidity of wet and dry deposition. This
includes acidity falling as rain, snow, hail, mist or fog (wet deposition) and the
dry deposition of gases and particles(2).
Rainfall is naturally acidic due to the presence of carbon dioxide in the
atmosphere which combines with the water vapour to form weak carbonic
acid. However the combustion of fossil fuels produces waste gases such as
sulphur dioxide (SO2), oxides of nitrogen (NOX) and to lesser extent, chloride
(Cl). These pollutants, over time, undergo a series of reactions which
produce sulphuric acid, nitric acid or hydrochloric acid, thus increasing the
acidity of the rain.
The main sources of SO2 are fossil fuel combustion, smelting, manufacture of
sulphuric acid, incineration of refuse and production of elemental sulphur.
Coal burning is the single largest man-made source of SO2 accounting for
50% of annual global emissions, with oil burning accounting for a further 25-
30%(3).
Globally, quantities of nitrogen oxides produced naturally far outweigh man-
made emissions. These man made emissions are mainly due to fossil fuel
combustion from both stationary sources i.e. power generation (21%) and
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
mobile sources i.e. transport (44%). Other contributions come from non-
combustion processes, for example nitric acid manufacture, welding
processes and the use of explosives.
Due to pollutant gas migration acidification is an international problem. For
this reason the European Union have agreed on air quality limit values for
specified pollutants in a series of „Daughter Directives‟.
The first Daughter Directive (1999/30/EEC), covering SO2, NOX,
particular matter as PM10, and lead, came into force on 19 July 1999.
This Directive contains values for these pollutants.
The second Daughter Directive (2000/69/EC) covers carbon monoxide
and benzene. It came into force on 13 December 2002.
The third Daughter Directive (or EC Ozone Directive, 2002/3/EC) came
into force in 2002 and is scheduled for transposition in 2003.
The air quality strategy sets out a strategy framework with in which air quality
policies will be taken forward in the short to medium term, and also details
objectives to be met by 2005 for the air pollutants covered(4).
The Large Combustion Plant Directive:
The Revised Large Combustion Plants Directive (LCPD, 2001/80/EC) applies
to combustion plants with a thermal output of greater than 50 MW. The
revised LCPD takes into account advances in combustion and abatement
technologies. It will replace the original LCPD (88/609/EEC) adopted in
November 1988. The LCPD aims to reduce acidification, ground level ozone,
and particles throughout Europe by controlling emissions of sulphur dioxide
(SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), and dust (particulate matter (PM)) from large
combustion plants (LCPs). These plants include power stations, petroleum
refineries, steelworks, and other industrial processes running on solid, liquid,
or gaseous fuel.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
3.3 Global Warming
Global Warming is also referred to as the greenhouse effect or climate
change. Greenhouse gases such as, water vapour, carbon dioxide (CO2),
methane and nitrous oxide (N2O) trap the infrared radiation emitted by the
Earth‟s surface. The atmosphere acts like the glass in a greenhouse, allowing
short-wave UV radiation to travel through but trapping some of the long-wave
infrared radiation. This process makes the temperature rise in the
atmosphere just as it does in the greenhouse (2).
Increasing the concentration of the greenhouse gases traps more radiation in
the lower atmosphere, enhancing the natural greenhouse effect. The
„enhanced‟ greenhouse effect is the direct result of human activities.
Processes such as, the burning of fossil fuel, industrial operations and
deforestation, increase CO2 and methane in the atmosphere. The effect of
this global warming has a profound effect on rainfall, plant growth and rising
sea levels.
Carbon dioxide is the gas most commonly thought of as greenhouse gas. It is
responsible for approximately half of the atmospheric heat retained by trace
gases. It is produced naturally through respiration. However man-made
sources of CO2 include fossil fuel combustion, forest clearing, biomass
burning and manufacture of cement.
Figures produced by the Government show that emissions of the basket of six
greenhouse gases fell by about 14½ per cent between the base year and
2005. The UK has agreed to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 12.5 per cent
over the 2008-2012 period to meet its Kyoto Protocol commitment.
Provisional 2005 data suggest carbon dioxide emissions in 2005 rose by a
quarter of one per cent on 2004 figures. The increase is due mainly to the rise
in energy consumption, coupled with a small switch from gas to coal in power
stations. Net emissions of carbon dioxide fell by about 5½ per cent between
1990 and 2005.
Methane is formed naturally in wetland regions as a by-product of the decay
of organic material. Rapid increases in methane levels are attributed to a
number of factors resulting from human activities. Among these are, direct
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
leakage of natural gas, by-production emission of coal mining, and disposal of
domestic refuse in landfill sites. Nitrous oxide is naturally produced by oceans
and rainforests. Man-made sources of N2O include nylon and nitric acid
production, agricultural practices, cars with catalytic converters and biomass
burning.
3.4 International Response to Climate Change
In June 1992 at the Rio Earth Summit, 162 Governments signed the
Framework Convention of Climate Change. This Convention calls for nations
to adopt a precautionary approach towards the threat of global warming. At
the Kyoto Conference of Parties (1997) nations agreed to reduce greenhouse
gas emissions by 5.2% by 2008-2012, relative to 1990 levels (the Kyoto
Protocol)(4). The Kyoto Protocol was finally ratified by 146 countries and
came into effect on 16th February 2005.
The Kyoto protocol expires in 2012, thus the United Nations Framework
Convention for Climate Change created to combat climate change beyond
that date.
The Convention on Climate Change sets an overall framework for
intergovernmental efforts to tackle the challenge posed by climate change. It
recognizes that the climate system is a shared resource whose stability can
be affected by industrial and other emissions of carbon dioxide and other
greenhouse gases. The Convention enjoys near universal membership, with
189 countries having ratified.
Under the Convention, governments:
gather and share information on greenhouse gas emissions, national
policies and best practices
launch national strategies for addressing greenhouse gas emissions
and adapting to expected impacts, including the provision of financial
and technological support to developing countries
cooperate in preparing for adaptation to the impacts of climate change
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
4.0 Literature Review
4.1 Adsorption
In adsorption, molecules distribute themselves between two phases, one of
which is a solid whilst the other may be a liquid or a gas (5). It is a physical-
chemical process by which molecules diffuse from the bulk of the fluid to the
surface of the solid forming a distinct adsorbed phase.
The solid, which takes up the gas, is called the adsorbent, and the fluid taken
up on the surface is called the adsorbate. It is not always easy to tell whether
the gas is inside the solid or merely at the surface because most practical
adsorbents are very porous structures with large internal surface areas. It is
not possible to determine the surface areas of such materials by optical or
electron microscopy because of the size and complexity of the pores and
channels of the materials. The gas adsorption itself, however, can be used to
determine the accessible area of the adsorbents.
Molecules and atoms can attach themselves onto surfaces in two ways. In
physisorption (physical adsorption), there is a weak van der Waals attraction
between the adsorbate and the surface. This attraction although weak is long
ranged. During the process of physisorption, the chemical identity of the
adsorbate remains intact, i.e. no breakage of the covalent structure of the
adsorbate takes place.
In chemisorption (chemical adsorption), the adsorbate attaches to the solid by
formation of a chemical bond with the surface. This interaction is much
stronger than physisorption, and, in general, chemisorption has more stringent
requirements for the compatibility of adsorbate and surface site than
physisorption.
Any potential application of adsorption has to be considered along with
alternatives such as distillation, absorption and liquid extraction. Each
separation process exploits a difference in a property between the
components to be separated.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
4.2 Characterisation by Physical Gas Adsorption
Physical gas adsorption is often the most widely used technique to study the
pore characteristics of solid materials. The technique accurately determines
the amount of gas adsorbed (adsorbate) on a solid material, which is a direct
correlation to its structure and porous properties.
When the quantity of adsorbate on a surface is measured over a wide range
of relative pressures at constant temperature, the result is an adsorption
isotherm. Similarly, desorption isotherms can be obtained by measuring the
quantities of gas removed from the sample as the relative pressure is
lowered. All adsorption isotherms may be grouped into one of five types
shown in figure 2(6).
Figure 2: The Five Different Adsorption Isotherms
Type I physisorption isotherms are exhibited by microporous solids having
relatively small external surfaces, for example, activated carbons. Type II
isotherms are the normal form of isotherm obtained with a nonporous or
macroporous adsorbent. This type of isotherm represents unrestricted
monolayer – multiplayer adsorption. Type III isotherms are convex to the
P/Po axis over its entire range. An example is the adsorption of water vapour
on nonporous carbons. Type IV isotherms are associated with capillary
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
condensation in mesopores, indicated by the steep slope at higher relative
pressures. Type V isotherms corresponds to the type III isotherm, except that
pores in the mesopore range are present. Types IV and V, associated with
mesoporosity, usually exhibit hysteresis between the adsorption and
desorption isotherms.
The isotherm obtained from these adsorption measurements provides
information on the surface area, pore volume, and pore size distribution.
Different probe gases including N2, Ar, and CO2 are frequently used as the
adsorbates, depending on the nature of the material and the information
required. For example; in the case of activated carbon, CO2 is often the
preferred adsorbate, since these adsorption measurements are mostly
performed at temperatures near ambient, which will improve the diffusion
properties in the highly microporous system compared to the low
temperatures used in N2(7).
N2 adsorption at 77K and at below atmospheric pressures, has remained
universally unsurpassed and can be used for routine quality control, as well as
for investigation of new materials. If applied over a wide range of relative
pressures, N2 adsorption isotherms provide information on size distribution in
the micro-, meso-, and macro- porosity range (approx. 0.5 - 200nm).
4.3 Adsorption Isotherms Theories
4.3 1 Langmuir Isotherm Theory
The Langmuir theory (8) is based on the assumption that localised adsorption
takes place on a surface that is energetically homogeneous with no
interaction between adsorbed molecules. The surface has a specific number
of sites, each of which can adsorb one molecule. Maximum adsorption
corresponds to a saturated monolayer and is represented by a plateau in the
isotherm. The Langmuir isotherm has the form
pK
pK
L
L
1 (1)
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
linearization of equation (1) allows the Langmuir constants KL and vm to be
evaluated.
mmLads
pp
K
pp 00 /1/ (2)
Plotting (p/p0)/vads (or (p/p0)n) against (p/p0) allows vm to be determined from
the slope (1/vm or 1/nm) and KL from the intercept (1/KLvm or 1/KLnm).
4.3.2 Freundlich Isotherm Theory
The Freundlich theory (9), empirically derived to fit the parabolic shape of the
adsorption isotherm, and is described as;
Fn
F pKq
1
0<n
1<1 and n >1 (3)
By plotting the linear form lnq against lnp, nF, the heterogeneity factor, can be
determined from the slope (1/nF) and KF from the intercept (lnKF).
The Langmuir and Freundlich Isotherm Models when applied to the
adsorption on the various adsorbents at 20°C. These constants were
determined using linear regression techniques on the isotherm data.
The nomenclature is as follows:
nm = number of moles of adsorbate required to form a monolayer on the
adsorbent (moles)
KL = Langmuir constant (N-1m-2)
Nf = Freundlich heterogeneity factor
KF = Freundlich constant (N-1m-2)
r2 = square of the Pearson product moment correlation coefficient
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
4.4 Adsorption of Carbon Dioxide The pressure on industry to decrease the emission of gaseous pollutants has
increased in recent years due to the strict regulations brought in to force,
coinciding with the Kyoto Protocol. It is generally accepted that the cost
associated with the separation of CO2 from flue gases introduces the largest
economic penalty to the industries involved.
The major sources of carbon dioxide are from fossil fuel power stations,
natural gas treatment, purification of hydrocarbons, production of hydrogen
gas and aerospace industry. Therefore a broad spectrum of cost effective gas
separation processes have been developed. In relation to price/performance,
physical adsorption is one of the most important techniques to control air
pollution.
A suitable adsorbent required for the adsorption of CO2 from industrial
streams must have the following properties (10):
High selectively and adsorption capacity for CO2 at high temperatures
Adequate adsorption/desorption kinetics for CO2 at operating conditions
Stable adsorption capacity of CO2 after repeated adsorption/desorption cycles
Adequate mechanical strength of adsorbent after cyclic exposure to high
pressure streams
The concept of using thermally treated dolomite as an adsorbate optimises
the carbonation reaction of CaO and the reversible calcination of CaCO3 as a
suitable separation process for CO2. The background for this separation was
first proposed by DuMotay and Marechal which used lime to aid the
gasification of carbon by steam (11). Silaban et al. (12) studied the reversibility
of this reaction in dolomites and limestones as the base of a high temperature
separation of CO2 to produce hydrogen (13).
4.5 Removal of Sulphur Dioxide (SO2).
SO2 is a colourless gas, formed during the combustion of fuels containing
sulphur. It is a respiratory irritant, and is toxic at high concentrations. It is
also damaging to ecosystems and a major precursor in the formation of acid
rain.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Total SO2 emissions in 2000 were 1,125,000 tonnes, which is a reduction of
70% since 1990. Power stations account for 66% of total SO2 emissions. By
2010, total emissions, according to guidelines must be below 625,000
tonnes(14).
A reduction in the atmospheric emissions of SO2 produced by fossil fuel
combustion process can be achieved at one of three stages (15).
1. Reducing the sulphur content before combustion:
The majority of coals currently in use within the UK, have a sulphur
content in the range of 1-3% by weight. Sulphur in coal is found in
sulphate, inorganic and organic forms. Inorganic sulphur, in the form of
pyrite (FeS2), can be removed and can result in a reduction of 10-50%
of the total sulphur content. However this process subsequently
produces large quantities of wastewater. Washing can also change the
physical characteristics of coal; therefore operational problems may
occur when combustion takes place.
2. Sulphur removal during combustion:
The most developed commercial technology for the removal of sulphur
during combustion is the Fluidised Bed Combustion (FBC) process.
This process involves the combustion of coal in a bed of inert material
such as sand, with air being blown up from beneath the bed at high
velocities. The fluidised movement within the combustion chamber
results in a greater heat transfer efficiency and therefore operational
temperatures are lower than in a conventional system. SO2 emissions
are controlled by adding a sorbent (limestone) to the bed of inert
material. The limestone effectively absorbs the SO2 as it is released;
retaining it within the ash. The FBC can achieve in the region of 80-
90% SO2 removal. Two main disadvantages of this system are large
quantities of sorbent required and the large quantity of alkaline waste
produced.
3. Removal of sulphur after combustion:
Emissions of SO2 generated during the combustion of fossil fuels can
be reduced by treating the flue gases before they are emitted into the
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
atmosphere. This is termed Flue Gas Desulphurisation (FGD). The
most globally used FGD system involves the use of crusted
limestone/lime mixed with water. This mixture is sprayed into the
sulphur containing flue gas, the sorbent reacts with the SO2 to form an
aqueous slurry of calcium sulphite. Compressed air blown into the
slurry oxidises the calcium sulphite to produce calcium sulphate. This
product is then treated to remove the excess water and either sold to
the building trade or disposed of as landfill. SO2 removal can be in the
region of 90%.
4.6 Removal of Oxides of Nitrogen (NOX).
A mixture of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and nitric oxide (NO) are emitted during
combustion processes. This mixture of oxides of nitrogen termed NOX. NO
produced is subsequently oxidised to NO2 in the atmosphere. NO2 is thought
to have both acute and chronic effects on airway and lung function,
particularly in people with asthma.
Total emissions of NOX have declined by 39% between 1990 and 2001. The
total NOX emissions in 2001 were 1,680,000 tonnes. By 2010, the UK have
agreed to cut the emissions of NOX to below 1,181,000 tonnes(14)
A reduction in the atmospheric emission of NOX produced by fossil fuel
combustion processes can be achieved at one of two stages (15).
1. NOX removal during combustion:
Low NOX burners ensure that initial fuel combustion occurs within fuel
rich conditions (low oxygen concentrations) resulting in any nitrogen
derivative produced being reduced to N2. Once initial combustion has
taken place, further air is introduced to the combustion chamber to
ensure complete combustion of the fuel. This greatly reduces the
opportunities for NOX production. Advanced low NOX burners can
reduce NOX concentration by up to 30%. Low NOX burners can be
installed on either new or existing combustion plants, and as such have
been retrofitted to a number of UK power stations.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
2. NOX removal after combustion:
Emissions of NOX generated during the combustion process can be
reduced, as with SO2, by treating the flue gases. There are a number
of systems available;
Selective Catalytic Reduction (SCR)
Within the SCR, ammonia is injected into the flue gas. The NOX
present in the flue gases react with the ammonia and are converted to
nitrogen and water. This reaction occurs in the presence of vanadium
or tungsten oxide catalyst. This process can achieve a NOX reduction
of up to 80-90%, with minimal waste production. The main
disadvantages with this system are the high catalyst costs and the
short (2-3 year) operational life of the catalyst. This system is not
operational within the UK, although it is being used extensively in
Japan.
5.0 Material and Methods
5.1 Materials
The primary adsorbent used in the research was dolomite. A number of other
adsorbent materials were also used for comparison purposes. The materials
used as adsorbents during the research were:
5.1.1Dolomite Dolomite was obtained from Acheson and Glover in Co. Fermanagh, where it
was extracted from an open mine. Dolomite was used in three physical states,
untreated, charred and charred and washed in the lab trials. The chemical
formula was CaCO3.MgCO3 and is a common double carbonate mineral with
an ideal formula CaMg(CO3)2, rather than a mixture of calcite and magnesite,
with a molecular weight of 184.4 and specific gravity of 2.84g/cm3. Dolomite
forms rhombohedrons as its typical crystal habit but possibly due to twinning,
some crystals curve into saddle-like shapes. These crystals represent a
unique crystal habit that is well known as classical dolomite but is difficult to
distinguish from calcite
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Some of the main physical properties are summarised below:
(i) colour is often pink or pinkish and can be colourless, white,
yellow, grey or even brown or black when iron is present in the
crystal
(ii) luster is pearly to vitreous to dull
(iii) crystals transparency ranges from transparent to translucent;
(iv) crystal System is trigonal bar 3
(v) crystal habits include saddle shaped rhombohedral twins and
simple rhombs some with slightly curved faces, also prismatic,
massive, granular and rock forming. Never found in
scalenohedrons
(vi) cleavage is perfect in three directions forming rhombohedrons
(vii) fracture is conchoidal
(viii) hardness is 3.5-4, (Mohz Scale)
(ix) specific gravity is 2.86 (average).
5.1.2 Activated Carbon
Chemviron Carbon supplied the Activated Carbon. The product known as
HGR US pellet of activated carbon designed for air and gas purification
applications. The product is produced by high temperature steam activation
of coal which resulting in a porous material with a high surface area allowing it
to adsorb a wide rang of organic compounds. The coal-based raw material
also ensures a high density product with good mechanical strength and low
dust content.
The extruded activated carbon has several properties that explain the
performance in a wide range of applications:
High loading capacity for a wide range of organic compounds.
Low outlet concentrations obtainable ensuring the emission
requirements.
High hardness to ensure excellent resistance to mechanical and
thermal stress.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Low stream to solvent ratio to minimise energy costs for steam
consumption, easier product recovery and reduced waste water in
solvent recovery applications.
This activated carbon was used in two different physical states, one in the
manufactured pellet form. The other was broken or ground form; this was
equivalent to the particle size range of that of the dolomite used.
5.2 Experimental Methods
5.2.1 Charring procedure
Dolomite was charred at a temperature of 800oC ±10%. Four crucibles were
filled with approximately 100g of dolomite. The furnace used was a Carbolite
type RHF 14/4. The dolomite filled crucibles were placed into the furnace
chamber, when the furnace was at the required temperature. The samples
remained in the furnace for an allocated time period of 12 hours at which point
the furnace chamber door was opened and the furnace switched off. The
dolomite remained in the furnace for a further hour, then it was removed to
cool.
5.3 Experimental Methods
5.3.1 Static Equilibrium Isotherm Determination
Initially, the sample to be studied was outgassed at 250 oC for at least 12
hours to ensure that the sample was completely dry, as this would affect the
adsorption properties.
The main sample vessel consisted of a 500ml Quickfit Pyrex reaction flask
and flask cover. The flask cover provides ports to allow pressure
measurements, temperature measurements, connection to a vacuum source
and a port to allow the introduction of adsorbate into the vessel. It was
ensured that all ports and connections were gas tight by use of Swaglock
connectors, silicon vacuum grease and finally wrapping of joints with Parafilm.
A known mass of the outgassed sample (approximately 0.5g ±0.5mg) was
placed into the vessel and sealed. The vessel was then placed into a 20 oC
(±0.5 oC) environment and put under vacuum for 2 hours at which point it was
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
isolated form the vacuum source, and the pressure monitored for 30mins so
as to ensure no leaks were present. The atmospheric pressure was recorded
using a mercury barometer also the initial pressure of the system was
recorded before the vacuum source was applied.
When the vessel was deemed to be at constant temperature and pressure,
these were recorded, and the first 50ml dose of adsorbate was introduced to
the vessel. The instantaneous pressure at injection and the pressure at
equilibrium was observed and recorded. Equilibrium would take anything
from up to 10-15 minutes to be achieved.
This process of injecting adsorbate and monitoring the pressure was
continued, whilst ensuring that the vessel was kept at a constant temperature,
until the relative pressure reached approximately 1.
This process was carried out a further two times so as to ensure the results
were repeatable. Any isotherms determined which deviated from the mode
observation was neglected and the procedure repeated.
5.3.2 Site Investigation
A filter was produced using a series of metal meshes which were coated in
the adsorbent material which was being investigated. The filter was fitted into
a flue joint for ease of fitting.
Figure 3: Joint in the flue were the filter was fitted
There was a small sample point drilled in the flue approximately 15inches
above the filter to allow the gases to be monitored. The probe of the gas
analyser was inserted into the flue to stabilise for approximately 15minutes
before the start of trial. During this time the boiler was ramped up to
maximum operating conditions. There were a number of gas samples taken
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
before the filter was fitted to be used a baseline. The filter was fitted and the
trial started with samples analysed regularly during the test period. The boiler
was fed wood pellets during the trial.
Figure 4: Feed stock and boiler
6.0 Investigation of Dolomite and Dolomite Adsorbents
6.1 Particle Size Distribution
The raw dolomite sample was placed in sieves and shaken for 30 minute
periods until the weight fractions remained constant. Sieves ranged from 90
micron – pan for the powdered dolomite to 2mm – pan for the grit. The results
displayed in figure 5 are those obtained from the initial analysis, which clearly
shows an uneven spread of particle size. The majority of the sample, 73.73%,
actually falls below 0.5mm. The results, figure 5, confirm that powder dolomite
is extremely fine, which may pose problems of blockage in any column
applications. The aim of this work is to develop dolomite usage for gaseous
effluent treatment, which would require a particle size more suited to column
and industrial scale work, i.e. grit size. As a result; dolomite samples used in
the charring and future experimental will have a particle size range of
2mm<X>0.5mm.
Figure 5: Sieve Analysis of the Dolomite Grit
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
6.2 Metal Analysis
The amount of selected metals present in the dolomite sieve analysis was
determined using an Inductively Coupled Plasma Optical Emission
Spectroscopy (ICP/OES). The ICP data in table 2, it was observed that all the
sieve fractions contained no or undetectable amounts of arsenic, cadmium,
cobalt, mercury or selenium.
Metals
(ppm) X>2mm 2<X>1.4 1.4<X>1.0 1.0<X>0.5 0.5<X>0.15 0.15<X>0.09 0.09<X>Pan
Al 16.640 21.020 19.900 27.620 47.530 58.045 110.675
B 0.262 0.120 0.108 0.116 0.153 0.148 0.269
Ba 0.108 0.083 0.074 0.090 0.117 0.139 0.289
Ca 6193 6698 6157 6534 6407 5962 5911
Cr <LOD 0.061 <LOD 0.066 0.178 0.281 0.754
Cu 0.063 0.221 0.252 0.144 0.221 0.21 0.344
Fe 66.33 71.32 60.94 66.19 75.86 82.00 128.65
Mg 3634 3523 3300 3616 3642 3387 3326
Mn 10.84 10.81 10.24 11.00 11.14 10.80 13.34
Ni 0.026 0.059 0.044 0.062 0.123 0.189 0.522
Pb 0.105 0.398 0.569 0.342 0.367 0.370 1.004
Sn 0.078 0.188 0.166 0.103 0.122 0.209 0.515
Sr 1.035 1.460 1.401 1.294 1.136 1.096 1.350
Ti <LOD <LOD <LOD 0.422 0.416 0.625 1.524
V 0.129 0.211 0.225 0.313 0.449 0.550 0.981
Zn 0.128 0.165 0.141 0.197 0.204 0.293 0.170
Sieve Analysis - Sieve Fractions
Table 2: The metal content of the various materials considered
As expected the majority of the metal cations present are that of calcium and
magnesium. The large quantities present are due to the calcium-magnesium
carbonate structure of dolomite. From the ICP/OES data, the percentage
composition of the Calcium and Magnesium oxides were found to be 35.6%,
22.8% respectively.
The percentages were calculated using the following methods:
Calcium
Average value for Ca present in the sample 6192.88mg/l and using the
molecular weight ratio for Ca: CaO 40:56. It was calculated that there was
8670.0332mg/l of CaO available in the sample. As the average dolomite
sample weight which was digested in acid was 0.2435g, it produced a solution
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
with the following concentration of dolomite 24354mg/l. The percentage of
CaO present was then calculates by
8670.0332mg/l divided by 24354mg/l = 0.35600033 this is multiplied by 100 to
produce a percentage 35.600033% shortened to 35.6%
Magnesium
Average value for Mg present in the sample 3330.92mg/l and using the
molecular weight ratio for Mg: MgO 24:40. It was calculated that there was
5551.51127mg/l of MgO available in the sample. As the average dolomite
sample weight which was digested in acid was 0.2435g, it produced a solution
with the following concentration of dolomite 24354mg/l. The percentage of
MgO present was then calculates by
5551.51127mg/l divided by 24354mg/l = 0.22795069 this is multiplied by 100
to produce a percentage 22.795069% shortened to 22.8%
This result provides a comparison to other leading dolomite research (Table
3). The Fermanagh dolomite contains a much higher percentage of both
oxides, suggesting dolomite with the potential to be a superior adsorbent.
Dolomite
Source
CaO
(%)
MgO
(%)
Fermanagh 35.6 22.8
Poland(8) 29.5 19.4
Hungary(9) 29.8 21.4
Table 3: Comparison of the different composition of Dolomite
On further inspection of the ICP data, it was seen that the majority of
impurities present in the samples, are varying amounts of iron, aluminium and
manganese. Figure 6 shows these impurities in relation to the different sieve
fraction, i.e. particle size. The increasing quantities of iron and aluminium
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
relate to the decreasing particle size. The results also suggest the amount of
manganese present is independent of particle size.
Figure 6: Metal Impurities present in Dolomite
6.3 Dolomite Charring
The thermal processing or „calcining‟ process is based on the fact that the
magnesium carbonate component of the dolomite decomposes at
temperatures around 800°C. The decomposition of dolomite at 800°C leads
to changes in the chemical composition of the surface and surface area of the
mineral. Generally, the products of partial decomposition of dolomite contain
calcium carbonate (calcite) and magnesium oxide and show a significant
increase in specific surface area and pore volume.
Partial decomposition results in the decomposition of magnesium carbonate
only, the calcium carbonate remains as a stable and mechanically resistant
structure of pumice type. As the time increases, the calcium carbonate
structure starts to breakdown and collapses in on itself, reducing the surface
area.
6.4 FTIR Spectroscopy
Infrared spectroscopy is an important technique in organic chemistry. It is an
easy way to identify the presence of certain functional groups in a molecule.
Also, one can use the unique collection of absorption bands to confirm the
identity of a pure compound or to detect the presence of specific impurities.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
FTIR spectroscopy relies on detection of molecular vibrations. Mineral
identification is possible because minerals have characteristics absorption in
the fingerprint region of the infrared (1500-400 cm-1).
FTIR of Untreated Dolomite
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
4006008001000120014001600
Wavenumber (cm-1
)
Ab
so
rba
nce
Figure 7 FTIR spectroscopy of untreated dolomite
This fingerprint spectroscopy was obtained for the untreated dolomite (figure
7) displaying a number of regions were absorption occurred. From figure 8, it
can be seen that the major absorption peaks are present in the same areas
for charring time up to 4 hours however the gerenal trend of the absorbency of
these peaks has decreased due to the increased char time. As the charring
time becomes more extensive i.e. 6 and 8 hours (figure 9) these absorption
peaks do not appear. This observation would seem to suggest the breakdown
of the structure of these samples which are present in the other samples,
namely the complete decomposition of the calcium carbonate structure.
FTIR of Charred Dolomite Samples (I)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
4006008001000120014001600
Wavenumber (cm-1
)
Ab
so
rba
nce
30min
1hr
2hr
4hr
Figure 8: FTIR spectroscopy of charred dolomite samples (I)
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
FTIR of Charred Dolomite Samples (II)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
4006008001000120014001600
Wavenumber (cm-1)
Abs
orba
nce
6hr
8hr
Figure 9: FTIR spectroscopy of charred dolomite samples (II)
6.7 X-ray Diffraction
The X-ray Diffraction technique provides data, in the form of fingerprint
spectrum, characteristic of the minerals present in the material. To
investigate in detail the effect of the charring process, dolomite samples were
analysed using x-ray diffraction (XRD) and the resultant scans are presented
in this section.
Figure 10: Crystalline Structure of Untreated Dolomite
The first scan analysed was for untreated dolomite (figure 10). As expected,
the scan indicates that dolomite has a very crystalline structure and the
presence of a small amount of natural calcite (single calcium carbonate)
impurity in the samples.
Calcite
Dolomite
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 11: The effect of 30min charring on the Dolomite structure
The XRD data relating to 30min (@800°C) char sample, figure 11, show a
reduction in the presence of dolomite compared to the untreated dolomite
sample (figure 10). This reduction is by almost a half, with the count falling
from 14000-7000. The presence of dolomite in this 30min char sample
confirms what was suggested in the FTIR results (figure 8 & 9) that this is not
a sufficient amount of time for the decomposition of the calcium-magnesium
carbonate structure of the dolomite.
Figure 12: The effect of 1hr charring on the Dolomite structure
From the XRD data relating to 1hr char (@800°C) sample, figure 12, it can
be seen that only a very small amount of the dolomite structure remains, with
the count falling from 7000 to 600. The decomposition of the dolomite
structure requires more than 1 hour at this char temperature.
XRD Graph of Dolomite (1hr Char @ 800°C)
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
2 Theta
Co
un
tCalcite
Dolomite
Dolomite
Calcite
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 13: The effect of 2hr charring on the Dolomite structure
From figure 13, the XRD scan shows that the complete decomposition of the
dolomite structure has occurred at this char time. It can also be noted that
over the three char times 30mins, 1hr and 2hr, the presence of calcite has
increased with counts of 1700, 5000 and 7800 respectively. This suggests
that calcite is one of the main components gained by the decomposition of
the calcium-magnesium carbonate structure.
Further XRD investigation into the other char temperatures (750°C & 850°C)
and the decomposition of the dolomite was completed. The XRD scans
relating to the different char temperatures are shown in figures 14-17. As
expected, the higher char temperature correlates to the more rapid
decomposition of the dolomite. At the lower char temperature (figures 14 &
15), this point was observed at 4 hours, while for the higher char temperature
(figures 16 & 17), it was noted at 1 hour.
Figure 14: The effect of 2hr (@750°C) charring on the Dolomite structure
XRD Graph of Dolomite (2hr Char @ 750°C)
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
2 Theta
Co
un
t
XRD Graph of Dolomite (2hr Char @ 800°C)
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
2 Theta
Co
un
tCalcite
Calcite Dolomite
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 15: The effect of 4hr (@750°C) charring on the Dolomite structure
Figure 16: The effect of 30min (@850°C) charring on the Dolomite structure
Figure 6.15: The effect of 1hr (@850°C) charring on the Dolomite structure
6.8 Surface Area Analysis
Analysis of all samples produced was carried out using the Nova 4200e,
Surface area and pore size analyser and Quantacrome software. By use of
standard isotherm models, it was possible to interpret the adsorbed data
obtained to calculate the adsorbent BET surface area.
XRD Graph of Dolomite (4hr Char @ 750°C)
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
2 Theta
Co
un
t
XRD Graph of Dolomite (1hr Char @ 850°C)
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
2 Theta
Co
un
t
XRD Graph of Dolomite (30min Char @ 850°C)
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
2 Theta
Co
un
t
Calcite Dolomite
Calcite
Calcite
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 18: Sample Isotherm of Charred Dolomite
The isotherm developed by the Nova indicates that the dolomite chars are
Type II isotherms. Reversible Type II isotherms are generally observed
when the adsorbent concerned has a wide range of pore sizes. The shape
of the plot indicates unrestricted monolayer-multilayer adsorption, where the
point of inflexion, at the start of a nearly linear section, indicated where
monolayer coverage is complete and multilayer coverage commences. Type
II isotherms are also typical of physical adsorption.
Figure 19: Sample Isotherm of Washed Charred Dolomite
Figure 19 displays a typical isotherm observed for the borax washed charred
samples exhibit a similar type II isotherm. The presence of a type A
Sample Isotherm of Charred Dolomite
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2
Relative Pressure (P/Po)
Vo
lum
e (c
c/g
) Adsorption
Desorption
Sample Isotherm of Borax Washed Dolomite
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2
Relative Pressure (P/Po)
Vo
lum
e (
cc/g
)
Adsorption
Desorption
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
hysteresis between the adsorption and desorption isotherm, correlates to an
adsorbent which have slit shaped pores due to the sorbent being formed
from an aggregate of plate like particles.
As previously stated, from the isotherm data obtained, the BET surface area
can be determined. The BET values derived for the adsorbents studied are
regarded as being amenable since all the isotherms obtained were
essentially Type II in nature. Table 4 is a summary of the surface area
results for all dolomite chars, borax washed chars and untreated dolomite
Char
Time
(hrs) 750 800 850 750 800 850
0.5 1.35 2.48 4.63 2.91 2.03 1.88
1 2.92 4.44 5.05 2.46 3.72 4.16
2 3.58 4.74 4.00 4.99 5.49 5.83
4 5.81 7.00 5.80 6.60 8.63 8.83
6 5.01 5.73 6.28 6.27 7.89 8.60
8 5.19 6.12 7.10 4.62 10.84 10.31
12 4.38 7.43 9.98 4.69 11.88 9.92
Untreated Dolomite 1.36 m2/g
Char Temperature (°C)
Dolomite Charred Samples
Char Temperature (°C)
Washed Charred Samples
Table 4: Summary of Surface Area (m2/g) results observed for the various Dolomite Samples
Figure 22 shows how the BET surface area observed for the dolomite
charred samples varied. The untreated dolomite sample was found to have
a BET surface area of 1.36m2/g. It can be seen from figure 20 that charring
the dolomite greatly increased the BET surface area.
Figure 20: The correlation between Surface Area and the char duration of the Dolomite
Surface Area Of Dolomite Chars
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Char Time (hrs)
BE
T (
m2/g
)
750°C
800°C
850°C
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
There are two areas of interest in figure 20 for each char temperature (750,
800 & 850°C). Firstly the results obtained from 0.5-4hrs char times, were
each temperature trend contains both peaks and troughs. This period of
time relates to the decomposition of the calcium-magnesium carbonate
structure of the dolomite. At these points, the structure is undergoing the
most significant changes which results in the most likely explanation for
these observations.
Secondly the results obtained from 6-12hrs char times. For the 800°C and
850°C char temperatures, the surface area trends increase rapidly at this
point however for 750°C char temperature the surface area gradient levels
off. This suggests that at the higher char temperature at this time period of
charring the decomposition of the remaining calcium carbonate structure has
initiated however at this lower char temperature this has not occurred.
6.9 Scanning Electron Microscope
The topography (visible analysis) of the surface of the samples was carried
out using a scanning electron microscope (SEM). SEM is a microscope that
uses electrons rather than light to form an image. There are many
advantages associated with the SEM in comparison to a standard light
microscope. Electron micrographs of the surface of each material and are
typical of the overall surface of each sample are represented in figures 21-
24. These include untreated dolomite and a number of char times (@800°C)
at two magnifications.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 21: Untreated dolomite at 1000 X 25mm
Figure 21 shows the SEM of the untreated dolomite sample. It can be seen
that although the surface seems quite rough in nature, the dolomite itself is
quite homogenous, with little porosity in evidence.
Figure 22: 30min char at 1000 X 25mm
Figure 22 shows the SEM of the 30min char (@800°C) sample. It can be
seen that due to the charring process, small cracks have appeared
throughout the structure.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 23: 1 hr char at 1000 X 25mm
Figure 24: 1 hr char at 2000 X 25mm
Figures 23 and 24 shows SEM‟s of 1hr char (@800°C) sample. It can be
seen that this char time the appearance of cracks and cavities. This would
confirm the macroporous nature of the dolomite displayed in the Type II
isotherm study.
6.10 Mechanical Strength
From the analysis already completed, included the SEMs, it has been noted
that the dolomite structure undergoes a large amount of change during the
charring process. The decomposition of the dolomite can be visually seen,
as the charred sample become more powder-like at the longer char times.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
The mechanical strength of the dolomite charred samples were analysed
using a Texture Analyser by means of a Crush Test. The strength or
crushability of the dolomite charred samples is an important factor when
considering scale-up column work or industrial applications.
Figure 25: A graph which displays the effect of the Charring Process on the Mechanical
Strength of Dolomite
From figure 25, it can be seen that, at char time of 0.5 hours, there is a large
decline in mechanical strength with little variation between the char
temperatures (750°C, 800°C & 850°C).
Generally as the char time increases the mechanical strength of the samples
continues to decline. It is noted that the effect of the higher char temperature
(850°C) is more significant than the other char temperatures, with the
mechanical strength of the samples becoming undetectable after a char time
of 6hours.
7.0 Static Equilibrium Isotherm Determination
The method to determine the equilibrium isotherms of the adsorbents
studied, with CO2, NO2 and SO2 (single component), has been outlined in
greater detail in section 5. This section describes the isotherms observed for
the various dolomite adsorbents studied and compares them against other
commercial adsorbents.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
7.1 CO2 Analysis
7.1.1 The Isotherm Observed:
A typical graph is shown below (figure 26); this demonstrates a Type II
isotherm. A typical type II isotherm is „concave to P/Po axis then almost
linear and finally convex to the P/Po axis‟ (7). The observed isotherms for CO2
obtain a small degree of the concave to the P/Po axis however the
description fits well subsequently.
A Typical Example of Isotherm Obtained
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00
P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)
Figure 26: A graph which displays a representative example of the experimental isotherms observed.
This type of isotherm corresponds to previous work completed using
Nitrogen. The Type II isotherms are obtained with macroporous adsorbents,
which allow unrestricted monolayer – multilayer adsorption to occur at high
partial pressures.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
7.1.2 Carbon Dioxide Uptake:
CO2 Isotherms for 750oC Chars
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
1.2E-05
0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00
P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke
(km
ol/
g)
1h750
4h750
8h750
Figure 27: This graph shows the gas uptake (Kmol/g) of Carbon Dioxide on the
chars thermally treated at 750°C
CO2 Isotherms for 800°C Chars
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
1.2E-05
1.4E-05
0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00
P/Po
Gas
Up
take
(k
mo
l/g
)
1h800
4h800
8h800
Figure 28: This graph shows the gas uptake (Kmol/g) of Carbon Dioxide on the
chars thermally treated at 800°C
The isotherms observed from the adsorbents charred at 750°C (figure 27)
follow a comparable trend, with many points overlapping at lower partial
pressures. The sample with the highest gas uptake (1.017x10-5 kmol/g) was
the 4h char. This result correlates to the surface area data obtained from
section 6.8. The surface area determined for the 4h char sample was
5.81m2/g.
In the case of the 800°C chars, the 8h char having as expected a greater gas
uptake capacity overall. The 1h and 4h char isotherms merged over the
entire range of partial pressures. The 8h char (1.27x10-5 kmol/g) had a
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
greater gas uptake than the 4h char (1.036x10-5 kmol/g) however the surface
area for the 4h char was larger at 7.00 m2/g than the 8h char at 6.12m2/g.
CO2 Isotherms for 850oC Chars
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
1.2E-05
1.4E-05
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)1h850
4h850
8h850
Figure 29: This graph shows the gas uptake (Kmol/g) of Carbon Dioxide on the chars thermally treated at 850°C
CO2 Isotherm for Untreated Dolomite
0.0E+00
2.0E-03
4.0E-03
6.0E-03
8.0E-03
1.0E-02
1.2E-02
0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00
P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)
Figure 30: This graph shows the gas uptake (Kmol/g) of Carbon Dioxide on the thermally
untreated dolomite
The isotherms observed from the adsorbents charred at 850°C also are very
similar and followed the same trend (figure 29). The adsorbent with the
highest uptake of gas was the 8h char (1.26x10-5 kmol/g). This sample is
also the char with the largest surface area at 7.10m2/g.
The untreated dolomite isotherm also observed the same trend (figure 30) as
all other samples analysed. The gas uptake of this adsorbent (9.708x10-6
kmol/g) is notably lower to the other values stated in this section. This also
corresponds to its lower surface area at 1.36m2/g compared to the other
samples.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
The adsorbent with the largest surface area was the 8h 850°C, which along
with the 8h 800°C sample, obtained the highest gas uptake over all samples
investigated.
7.2 NO2 Analysis
7.2.1 The Isotherm Observed:
A typical graph is shown below (figure 31); this demonstrates a Type II
isotherm. A typical type II isotherm is „concave to P/Po axis then almost
linear and finally convex to the P/Po axis‟ (7). The observed isotherms for NO2
lack the initial concave to the P/Po axis however the description fits
subsequently.
A Typical Example of Isotherm Obtained
y = 6E-06x + 2E-07
R2 = 0.9993
0.0E+00
1.0E-06
2.0E-06
3.0E-06
4.0E-06
5.0E-06
6.0E-06
7.0E-06
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0P/Po
Ga
s u
pta
ke
(k
mo
l/g
)
Figure 31: A graph which displays a representative example of the experimental isotherms
observed.
This type of isotherm corresponds to previous work completed using
Nitrogen. The Type II isotherms are obtained with macroporous adsorbents,
which allow unrestricted monolayer – multilayer adsorption to occur at high
partial pressures.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
7.2.2 Nitrogen Dioxide Uptake:
NO2 Isotherms for 750°C Chars
0.0E+00
1.0E-06
2.0E-06
3.0E-06
4.0E-06
5.0E-06
6.0E-06
7.0E-06
8.0E-06
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
P/Po
Ga
s U
pta
ke
(k
mo
l/g
)
1h750
4h750
8h750
Figure 32: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Nitrogen Dioxide on the
chars thermally treated at 750°C
NO2 Isotherms for 800°C Chars
0.0E+00
1.0E-06
2.0E-06
3.0E-06
4.0E-06
5.0E-06
6.0E-06
7.0E-06
8.0E-06
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
P/Po
Ga
s U
pta
ke
(k
mo
l/g
)
1h800
4h800
8h800
Figure 33: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Nitrogen Dioxide on the
chars thermally treated at 800°C
The isotherms observed from the adsorbents charred at 750°C (figure 32). In
particular, the 1h and 8 h char times resulted in similar trends with the 8h
char having as expected a greater gas uptake capacity overall than the 1 h
char. However, the 4h char, initially (low partial pressures) mapped
alongside the 8h and at higher partial pressures verged closer to the 1h char.
In the case of 800°C (figure 33), all three char times gave comparable
trends. At partial pressures below 0.5, the gas uptake capacity increased in
the order of 1h, 4 h and 8h, respectively. However at higher partial
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
pressures the 1h and 8 h char times, merged while the 4 h char gas uptake
fell below that of both other char times.
NO2 Isotherms for 850°C Chars
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
1.2E-05
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1P/Po
Ga
s U
pta
ke
(k
mo
l/g
)
1h850
4h850
8h850
Figure 34: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Nitrogen Dioxide on the chars thermally treated at 850°C
NO2 Isotherm for Untreated Dolomite
0.0E+00
5.0E-07
1.0E-06
1.5E-06
2.0E-06
2.5E-06
3.0E-06
3.5E-06
4.0E-06
4.5E-06
0.00 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 1.00P/Po
Ga
s U
pta
ke
(k
mo
l/g
)
Figure 35: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Nitrogen Dioxide on the
thermally untreated dolomite
The isotherms observed from the adsorbents charred at 850°C also gave
comparable trends (figure 34). However, the 1h and 4h char times are
merging over the entire partial pressures range. The 8h char as expected
has a substantially higher gas uptake than the 1h and 4h char times.
For all three char temperatures, 750°C, 800°C and 850°C the adsorbent
charred for 8 h obtained the greatest adsorption capacity, 7.06x10-6, 6.83x10-
6 and 9.93x10-6 kmol/g respectively.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
The untreated dolomite isotherm also observed a similar trend (figure 35) to
that of the other samples analysed. The gas uptake for this adsorbent,
4.23x10-6 kmol/g is notably lower to the other values obtained.
7.3 SO2 Analysis
7.3.1 The Isotherm Observed:
A typical graph is shown below (figure 36); this demonstrates a Type II
isotherm. A typical type II isotherm is „concave to P/Po axis then almost
linear and finally convex to the P/Po axis‟ (7). The observed isotherms for SO2
lack the initial concave to the P/Po axis however the description fits
subsequently.
A Typical Example of Isotherm Obtained
y = 1E-05x - 2E-06
R2 = 0.9928
-2.0E-06
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
1.2E-05
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)
Figure 7.36: A graph which displays a representative example of the experimental isotherms
observed.
This type of isotherm corresponds to previous work completed using
Nitrogen. The Type II isotherms are obtained with macroporous adsorbents,
which allow unrestricted monolayer – multilayer adsorption to occur at high
partial pressures.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
7.3.2 Sulphur Dioxide Uptake
SO2 Isotherms for 750°C Chars
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)
1h750
4h750
8h750
Figure 37: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Sulphur Dioxide on the chars
thermally treated at 750°C
SO2 Isotherms for 800°C Chars
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)
1h800
4h800
8h800
Figure 38: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Sulphur Dioxide on the chars
thermally treated at 800°C
The isotherms observed from the adsorbents charred at 750°C (figure 37)
follow the same trend, with many points overlapping initially. The sample
with the highest gas uptake (8.972x10-6 kmol/g) was the 4h char. This result
correlates to the surface area data obtained from the Nova. The surface
area determined for the 4h char sample was 5.81m2/g.
In the case of 800°C (figure 38), all three char times gave comparable
trends. At lower partial pressures (below 0.4), the gas uptake capacity
increased in the order of 1h, 8 h and 4h, respectively. However at the higher
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
partial pressures the 8h and 4 h char times merged, while the 1h char gas
uptake fell below that of both other char times.
SO2 Isotherm for 850°C Chars
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
1.2E-05
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)1h850
4h850
8h850
Figure 39: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Sulphur Dioxide on the chars
thermally treated at 850°C
SO2 Isotherm for Untreated Dolomite
0.0E+00
2.0E-06
4.0E-06
6.0E-06
8.0E-06
1.0E-05
1.2E-05
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
P/Po
Gas U
pta
ke (
km
ol/g
)
Figure 40: This graph shows the gas uptake (kmol/g) of Sulphur Dioxide on the thermally
untreated dolomite
The isotherms observed from the adsorbents charred at 850°C also gave
comparable trends (figure 39). Each isotherm is distinct and the 8h char as
expected has a substantially higher gas uptake than the 1h and 4h char
times.
For the higher char temperatures, 800°C and 850°C the adsorbent charred
for 8 h obtained the greatest adsorption capacity, 8.565x10-6 and 1.133x10-5
kmol/g respectively. However for the char temperature of 750°C the greatest
adsorption capacity was observed was the 4h char, 8.972x10-6 kmol/g, which
coincides with the higher surface area.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
The untreated dolomite isotherm also observed a similar trend (figure 40) to
that of the other samples analysed. The gas uptake for this adsorbent,
1.033x10-5 kmol/g is notably higher than values obtained for dolomite chars
of lower char time.
7.3.3 SEM: INCA Probe
The SEM unit has an INCA Probe, which allows the ability to scan the
sample surface for the presence of elements and calculate the atomic
percentage of the sample. Samples treated by CO2, NO2 and SO2 were
investigated however only SO2 treated samples obtained significant results.
Sulphur Calcium Magnesium Carbon Oxygen
5.27 7.65 1.12 18.47 65.19
1.19 7.28 2.09 25.03 63.90
0.71 14.13 2.62 21.10 61.01
/ 13.98 10.04 19.73 56.36
1.21 6.53 7.57 25.54 59.15
0.05 4.04 10.25 28.21 57.44
1.02 9.92 16.18 / 72.88
0.38 3.42 6.42 36.15 53.65
0.62 9.14 8.74 18.64 62.86
0.28 15.51 14.54 / 69.67
/ 6.00 5.43 25.34 62.82
8h850
Untreated Dolomite
4h800
8h800
1h850
4h850
1h750
4h750
8h750
1h800
Atomic PercentageDolomite Sample
(SO2 Treated)
Non-charred
Table 6: SEM-INCA probe data observed for the various dolomite samples
From table 6, it can be seen that the atomic percentage for untreated
dolomite contains no sulphur present, therefore any sulphur present in the
remaining samples are due to the SO2 treatment.
Non-charred dolomite sample treated with SO2 was substantially higher than
any of the charred dolomite samples. Generally the lower char times and
char temperatures tended to have the greater percentage of sulphur present.
Figure 41 shows the SEM of the non-charred dolomite sample treated with
SO2. It can be noted that the surface of the dolomite has a covering of
needle-like crystals; this confirms the formation of sulphate/sulphite
compounds.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 41: SEM of Non-charred dolomite surface treated with SO2.
Similar work was completed for the commercial adsorbents. Activated
carbon was the only adsorbent to show the presence of sulphur. The atomic
percentage, 1.53%, was a smaller amount than that observed for the non-
charred dolomite sample but similar to the dolomite charred samples.
7.4 Comparison between the Gases Analysed
This section will discuss the adsorption capacity of the adsorbents with
respect to SO2, CO2 and NO2. A summary of results for all gases and
adsorbents investigated are displayed in the Graphs 42 - 45. These results
related closely to the surface area of each sample therefore these results are
also included in Table 7.
The isotherms observed for the adsorption of CO2 have comparable trends
and deviate little between the different adsorbents (figure 42). The results
indicate that the greater capacity for adsorption is related to the longer char
times and higher char temperatures, that is the 8h800°C and 8h850°C chars.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 42: This graph shows the gas uptake (mg/g) of Carbon Dioxide on the thermally
treated dolomite
Figure 43: This graph shows the gas uptake (mg/g) of Nitrogen Dioxide on the thermally
treated dolomite
The isotherms observed for the adsorption of NO2 (figure 43) have a more
linear trend compared to that obtained for CO2. Also the isotherms tend to
be quite distinct at lower partial pressures with the individual isotherm less
uniformed over the range of chars. The adsorbent 8h800°C obtained the
greatest adsorption capacity however two other chars, 4h850°C and
4h800°C were equally as effective.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 44: This graph shows the gas uptake (mg/g) of Nitrogen Dioxide on the thermally
treated dolomite
The isotherms observed for the adsorption of SO2 (figure 44) display a
comparable trend to that observed for CO2 however there is a greater
deviation of the isotherms throughout the range of chars. The isotherms are
uniformed and at lower partial pressures have merging regions. The
8h850°C char has a substantially higher gas uptake than that of the other
adsorbents.
Figure 45: This graph shows the gas uptake (mg/g) of the three gases on the untreated
dolomite
The isotherms observed for the adsorption of all three gases to the untreated
dolomite (figure 45); relate the same trends discussed for the dolomite chars.
The isotherms for CO2 and SO2 are comparable however the NO2 isotherm
is again more linear. This disparity is in relation to the degree of adsorption
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
rather than alternative isotherm type. The adsorption capacity for untreated
dolomite is substantially greater for Sulphur Dioxide than the other gases.
Table 7: The maximum adsorption capacity (kmol/g) for the samples investigated for all three gases,
and the surface area of the samples.
When considering the maximum gas uptake (kmol/g) it is the number of
moles adsorbed compared to the isotherm were the mass (mg/g) of gas
adsorbed is considered. This distinction allows a different trend to be
observed as the molecular weight of the gases is every different. It is
apparent that the SO2 results (table 7) are substantially lower than NO2 and
CO2, which is the opposite observation of the isotherm obtained.
The adsorbent with the largest surface area was the 8h 8500C, which along
with the 8h 8000C char, obtained the highest gas uptake over all CO2
investigated chars. However the overall range of CO2 results obtained was
quite narrow 0.845-1.269 x10-5 kmol/g.
The NO2 maximum gas uptake varies considerably with char temperature,
the results observed for the 750°C char temperature is significantly lower
than the other temperatures. The 8 h 800°C char obtained the highest
adsorption capacity than any other char. The overall range is considerably
larger 0.507-1.224 x10-5 kmol/g.
Char Temp Char Time
(oC) (hrs)
750 1
4
8
800 1
4
8
850 1
4
8
1.361.033
2.91
5.81
5.19
4.44
7.00
6.12
5.05
5.80
7.10
0.784
0.644
0.897
0.832
0.652
0.852
0.857
0.959
0.988
1.133
0.971
0.507
0.603
0.706
0.896
1.171
1.224
1.000
1.206
1.269
0.845
1.043
1.256
Untreated Dolomite
Nitrogen Dioxide Sulphur Dioxide
1.017
1.104
1.036
0.929
0.986
Maximum Gas Uptake
0.993
Surface Area
(x10-5
)(kmol/g) (m2/g)
Sample
Maximum Gas Uptake Maximum Gas Uptake
(x10-5
)(kmol/g) (x10-5
)(kmol/g)
Carbon Dioxide
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
The extent of SO2 adsorption is directly related to the higher char
temperature and longer char time. The adsorbent with the largest surface
area was the 8h 8500C, which also obtained the highest maximum gas
uptake.
7.5 Comparison with Commercial Adsorbents Analysed
When considering the maximum gas uptake of the commercial adsorbents,
table 8 it can be seen that the Activated Carbons and Industrial Zeolite
obtained similar results for each gas investigated.
437.64
Maximum Maximum Maximum
Ind. Zeolite 1.085 1.653 1.445
14.79
Clintoptlilte 0.798 0.971 1.020 130.78
Mordenite 0.712 0.956 0.806
677.57
A.C.Broken 0.626 1.694 1.571 668.68
A.C. Pellet 0.802 1.400 1.566
Surface Area
Adsorbents (x10-5
)(kmol/g) (x10-5
)(kmol/g) (x10-5
)(kmol/g) (m2/g)
Commerical Gas Uptake Gas Uptake Gas Uptake
Carbon Dioxide Nitrogen Dioxide Sulphur Dioxide
Table 8: The maximum adsorption capacity (kmol/g) for the samples investigated for all three gases, and the surface area of the samples.
The Industrial Zeolite observed the highest value, 1.085x10-5 kmol/g, for
CO2. This valve is similar to the 4h850 charred sample which observed a
value of 1.043x10-5 kmol/g.
Activated Carbon (Broken), observed a maximum gas uptake for NO2,
1.694x10-5 kmol/g, the highest value of the commercial adsorbents. This
value was higher than any of the dolomite charred sample, the highest being
8h800 char at 1.224x10-5 kmol/g.
The Activated Carbon (Broken), observed the highest maximum gas uptake,
1.571x10-5 kmol/g, for SO2 which was substantially higher than any dolomite
charred samples. The highest maximum gas uptake value for 8h850
dolomite char was 1.133x10-5 kmol/g.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Overall the Activated Carbon and Industrial Zeolite samples obtained greater
maximum gas uptakes for NO2 and SO2 than the dolomite charred samples.
However when considering the difference in surface areas, Activated Carbon
(Broken) observed the higher value of 677.57m2/g against the highest
dolomite charred sample, a surface area of 7.10m2/g. It can be seen that the
extent of gas uptake for dolomite samples was excellent when considering
the low surface area.
8.0 Adsorption Isotherm Modelling 8.1 Summary of Langmuir Modelling
8.1.1 Comparison between the Gases Analysed
The application of the Langmuir model to the CO2, NO2 and SO2 adsorption
isotherms resulted in the model constants shown in Table 9. The constants
Nm and KL are the number of moles of adsorbate to form a monolayer and
the Langmuir coefficient, respectively. The r2 value is derived by linear
regression analysis of the fit of the linearised model expression to the
experimental data. r2 is equal to or less than 1 and the closer the value to 1
the better the fit.
When considering the Langmuir isotherm model, the higher the values of KL
and nm the better the sorbent is for the particular absorbate. The KL values
obtained for the adsorbents (table 9) vary greatly between the adsorptive
gases. The NO2 constants obtained the higher KL values and also the
greatest range, 6.066-1030.3 N-1m-2. The CO2 and SO2 constants, 1.025-
9.431 N-1m-2 and 1.092-4.395 N-1m-2 respectively, were similar and of a
narrower range.
The Nm values obtained for the SO2 adsorptive were greater than the other
two gases however the values are small and of a narrow range for all
adsobates. There is little relationship between the values of KL and Nm
observed for the samples. These values would have been expected to
increase the most for the optimum adsorbents compared to the values
observed for the adsorbents with the lower uptake of adsorbate. This was
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
not seen to be the case for the KL values and only slightly visible for the Nm
values.
8.4.2 Comparison with Commercial Adsorbents Analysed
When considering the Langmuir adsorption constant of the commercial
adsorbents, table 10, it can be seen that for the KL values, for the CO2 and
NO2 data, fell within the same range observed for the dolomite charred
samples. However the KL values obtained by the SO2 data, notable the
Activated Carbons values, were much higher than the values observed for
the dolomite samples.
The Langmuir Nm values observed from the commercial adsorbents were
very similar to that of the dolomite chars for each of the gases analysed. The
r2 values which represent the fit of the experimental data to the Langmuir
model data show that for NO2 and SO2 the commercial adsorbents were a
better fit than the dolomite samples.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Sample Carbon Dioxide Nitrogen Dioxide Sulphur Dioxide
Char Temp Char Time nm (x10-4
) KL r2 nm (x10
-4) KL r
2 nm (x10
-4) KL r
2
(oC) (hrs) (moles) (N
-1m
-2) (moles) (N
-1m
-2) (moles) (N
-1m
-2)
750 1 3.171 3.313 0.922 1.079 12.519 0.624 3.645 3.368 0.968
4 2.488 6.678 0.968 1.614 12.978 0.857 4.451 1.756 0.789
8 2.629 6.383 0.962 1.444 1030.3 0.922 3.394 4.395 0.891
800 1 2.62 3.443 0.936 2.025 12.288 0.886 4.264 2.354 0.955
4 3.158 3.661 0.931 1.678 16.192 0.979 3.880 2.262 0.815
8 2.731 4.981 1 1.980 198.10 0.964 3.420 3.126 0.906
850 1 4.959 1.025 0.963 2.461 6.066 0.815 5.466 1.466 0.846
4 3.008 4.287 0.958 1.427 11.394 0.854 5.844 1.092 0.781
8 2.375 9.431 0.952 2.035 7.531 0.735 3.761 3.216 0.931
Untreated Dolomite 3.156 2.963 0.948 2.318 8.804 0.92 5.320 1.697 0.778
Table 9: The Langmuir Model constants obtained from the experimental data for the gases investigated CO2, NO2 and SO2.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
nm (x10-4
) KL r2
nm (x10-4
) KLr2
nm (x10-4
) KLr2
(moles) (N-1
m-2
) (moles) (N-1
m-2
) (moles) (N-1
m-2
)
3.740 1.953 0.731 1.557 9.701 0.959 2.479 17.037 0.974
1.753 6.294 0.813 2.051 41.881 0.958 3.000 401.399 0.990
2.206 7.940 0.927 2.303 18.158 0.983 3.660 3.782 0.962
2.433 3.463 0.841 1.943 30.305 0.967 3.774 3.114 0.947
2.494 5.230 0.933 2.128 18.410 0.903 3.440 3.765 0.931
Mordenite
Clintoptlilte
Ind. Zeolite
Other
Adsorbents
A.C. Pellet
A.C.Broken
Sample Carbon Dioxide Nitrogen Dioxide Sulphur Dioxide
Table 10: The Langmuir Model constants obtained from the experimental data for the gases
investigated CO2, NO2 and SO2.
8.5 Summary of Freundlich Modelling Data
8.5.1 Comparison between the Gases Analysed
The application of the Freundlich model gives an analytical expression for
the experimental data rather than a precise picture of the mechanism of
adsorption. The Freundlich constants, KF and nF, along with the fit coefficient
r2 are given in Table 11.
Linearisation of the model expression overall gave exceptionally good
straight-line plots. This is reflected in the high r2 values, 0.990 or above for
the adsorbates investigated for CO2 and NO2. The same degree of
linearisation is not shown for the SO2 adsorption with low r2 values ranging
from 0.776-0.963.
Generally when considering the Freundlich Isotherm Model, the higher the
value of nF and KF, the greater the amount of particular adsorbate will be
absorbed by the adsorbent. The closer the nF to zero, the greater the
heterogeneity of the adsorbent. It can be seen from the Table 11 that for the
adsorptive NO2 the nF values were the smallest and within the range of
0.727-1.390. This indicated that all the adsorbents studied were
heterogenous in nature.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Sample Carbon Dioxide Nitrogen Dioxide Sulphur Dioxide
Char Temp Char Time nf KF (x10-2
) r2 nf KF (x10
-3) r
2 nf KF (x10
-2) r
2
(oC) (hrs) (N
-1m
-2) (N
-1m
-2) (N
-1m
-2)
750 1 1.754 2.794 0.991 1.390 18.674 0.999 1.7541 0.02794 0.991
4 1.574 1.799 0.995 0.902 2.084 0.994 1.5741 0.01799 0.995
8 1.576 1.837 0.995 0.933 2.068 0.998 1.5758 0.01837 0.995
800 1 1.665 2.373 0.997 1.209 6.349 0.999 1.6647 0.02373 0.997
4 1.793 2.899 0.985 0.781 0.295 0.998 1.7928 0.02899 0.985
8 1.639 1.901 0.997 1.166 4.213 1 1.6385 0.01901 0.997
850 1 1.737 2.882 0.99 1.193 5.670 0.996 1.4981 0.01400 0.995
4 1.593 1.909 0.995 0.883 0.710 0.999 1.5926 0.01909 0.995
8 1.477 1.287 0.997 0.727 0.246 0.996 1.4773 0.01287 0.997
Untreated Dolomite 1.623 2.247 0.998 1.339 10.401 0.999 1.6234 0.02247 0.998
Table 11: The Freundlich Model constants obtained from the experimental data for the gases investigated CO2, NO2 and SO2
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
8.4.2 Comparison with Commercial Adsorbents Analyses
When considering the Freundlich adsorption constants of the commercial
adsorbents, table 12, it can be seen that for the KF values with regards to the
CO2 data, the values are similar but slightly higher than the observed values of
the dolomite samples. For NO2 and SO2 data, notable Activated Carbon, the KF
values are considerably lower than the other commercial adsorbents and the
dolomite samples.
The Freundlich nf values observed for the commercial adsorbents were similar
to that of the dolomite charred samples for all three gases investigated. The
one exception to this trend was Activated Carbon as again the values observed
for nf for NO2 and SO2 are considerably lower than the other commercial
adsorbents or the dolomite samples.
nf KF (x10-2
) r2
nf KF (x10-3
) r2
nf KF (x10-2
) r2
(N-1
m-2
) (N-1
m-2
) (N-1
m-2
)
1.846 3.306 0.990 0.654 0.043 0.985 0.966 0.066 0.990
1.709 3.332 0.985 0.669 0.043 0.983 0.979 0.076 0.994
2.094 4.987 0.973 1.296 8.164 1.000 1.680 2.048 0.997
1.863 3.249 0.992 1.182 5.178 0.999 1.657 1.767 0.998
1.775 2.470 0.991 0.831 0.336 0.992 1.601 1.226 0.998
Mordenite
Clintoptlilte
Ind. Zeolite
Other
Adsorbents
A.C. Pellet
A.C.Broken
Sample Carbon Dioxide Nitrogen Dioxide Sulphur Dioxide
Table 12: The Freundlich Model constants obtained from the experimental data for the gases
investigated CO2, NO2 and SO2
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
9.0 Trial Results
9.1 Baseline data
The baseline data was collected as described previously figures 46 & 47.
The carbon monoxide reading range between 1000 to 2000 ppm. The peaks
which are noticeable on both graphs indicate changes in the burn as fresh
material is added.
Figure 46: This graph shows the carbon monoxide baseline data
Figure 47: This graph shows the NO, NO2 & SO2 baseline data
9.2 Carbon Monoxide data
The follow graph indicates that all the materials trialled significantly reduced
the carbon monoxide reading. It had been expected that the activated
dolomite would outperform the other materials but this was not the case the
raw untreated dolomite outperformed the other materials. The only possible
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
explanation for this is the increased temperatures which occur in the flue as
all previous trials have been completed at room temperature.
Figure 48: This graph shows the CO data recorded for each trial
9.3 Nitrogen Dioxide and Nitrogen Monoxide data
The following figures (49 &50) illustrate the data obtained for nitrogen dioxide
and nitrogen monoxide respectively. Again there were some unexpected
results raw dolomite and activated carbon reduced the NO2 to zero and the
activated dolomite reduced the nitrogen dioxide by approximately 40%. This
was not repeated with nitrogen monoxide were all materials performed
similarly. There was no significant difference between the performance of
activated and raw dolomite.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 49: This graph shows the NO2 data recorded for each trial
Figure 50: This graph shows the NO data recorded for each trial
9.4 Sulphur Dioxide data
The following figure (51) illustrates the data obtained for sulphur dioxide.
Again there were some unexpected results raw dolomite and activated
carbon reduced the SO2 to less than 3 where as the activated dolomite had
no effect on the concentration sulphur dioxide.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
Figure 51: This graph shows the SO2 data recorded for each trial
Conclusions
It was evident from the experimental data that the dolomitic sorbents have an
affinity to both carbon dioxide and nitrogen dioxide. From the equilibrium
isotherms there is a difference in isothermal shape between gases. This
disparity is in relation to the degree of adsorption rather than alternative
isotherm type. The maximum gas uptake results in Table 7 indicate that
dolomitic sorbents have a higher capacity for carbon dioxide than nitrogen
dioxide. Results with respect to the untreated dolomite, show the capacity for
carbon dioxide is twice that of nitrogen dioxide. The constants determined
from the Freundlich isotherm model for both gases in Table 11, also observe
this trend.
The charring process was successful in the production of dolomite
adsorbents with high adsorption capacities. It was determined be means of
analytical and visual methods that this increase in capacity was due to the
decomposition of the calcium – magnesium carbonate structure of the
dolomite to magnesium oxide and calcium carbonate.
Prolonged charring times resulted in the decomposition of the remaining
calcium carbonate structure. This was seen to have a detrimental effect on
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
the mechanical strength of the material resulting in a powder-like appearance
of the samples. A compromise may have to be reached between the
adsorption capacity required and the structural integrity of the dolomite.
The charred dolomite was expected to displayed high affinity for the
adsorption of carbon dioxide but this was not the case during the site trial.
However, the unpredictably high adsorption rates achieved by the untreated
dolomite and the lack of sample preparation required, would thus
recommend itself as the appropriate sample for carbon dioxide adsorption. It
is still unconfirmed why this occurred but it is suspected that the increase
was due to the increased temperature in the flue.
Activated Carbon and untreated dolomite displayed comparatively high
adsorption capacities for the adsorption of nitrogen dioxide. The charred
dolomite samples analysed displaying little affinity to the adsorption of this
gaseous pollutant. Although the untreated dolomite resulted in marginally
lower adsorption rates, than the commercial adsorbents, dolomite could still
be a viable option for the treatment of nitrogen dioxide due to the economical
raw material and preparation costs involved with this adsorbent.
For sulphur dioxide adsorption, both Activated Carbon and untreated
dolomite displayed comparatively high adsorption capacities. The charring
process resulted in a reduction in the adsorption capacity of the dolomite
samples. The presence of sulphite/sulphite crystals on the surface of the
untreated dolomite and to a lesser extent the charred dolomite sample,
suggests that the reaction of the gas to the surface is chemisorption rather
than physisorption. As Chemisorption is reversible the recovery of the
sulphur formed on the dolomite surface could be a possibility. Currently
there is a shortage of sulphur on farming land and as the dolomite is
currently used as a soil conditioner this could be a possible added value
route for spent filter media.
The QUESTOR Centre Applied Technology Unit
References
1. Anani, A., (1984). „Applications of Dolomite‟, Industrial Minerals, 45-55
2. Kiely, G., (1997). „Environmental Engineering‟, McGraw Hill, London
3. Manahan, S.E., (1994), „Environmental Chemistry‟, Lewis, London
4. Department of Environment, Foods and Rural Affairs, UK Government.
„Air Quality Legislation‟. 5. Coulson, J.M., „Chemical Engineering. – Vol 2: Particle technology and
separation processes‟. 5th ed., Oxford, Butterworth-Heinemann. 6. Brunauer, S. et al., (1940), J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 62, 1723 7. Tien, C., (1994), “Adsorption Calculations and Modelling”. 1st ed.,
Butterworth-Heinemann, series in Chemical Engineering. 8. Groen, J.C. et al., (2003), “Microporous and Mesoporous Materials”, 60,
1-17.
9. Langmuir, I., “Adsorption of Gases on Plane Surfaces of Glass, Mica and
Platinum”, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 40, (1918), 1361-1403
10. Freundlich, H., “Adsorption in Solution”, Phys. Chemie., 57, (1907) 11. Yong, Z., Mata, V., Rodrigues, A.E., (2002), “Adsorption of carbon dioxide
at high temperatures – a review”, Separation and Purification technology, 26,195-205.
12. Squires, A.M., “Cyclic use of calcined capture dolomite to desulfurize
fuels undergoing gasification”, Adv. Chem. Ser., 69, (1967), 205-229. 13. Silaban, A., Narcida, M., Harrison, P.,”Charactertics of the reversible
reaction between CO2(g) and calcined dolomite, Chem. Eng. Commum. 146 (1996), 149-162.
14. Balasubramanian, B., Lopez-Ortiz, A., et al., “Hydrogen from methane in
a single-step process”, Chem. Eng. Sci. 54, (199), 3543-3552. 15. Seinfeld, J.H., (2004). „Air Pollution: A Half Century of Progress‟, AICHE
Journal, 50, 6, 1096-110