Camp Checkmate
The Simple “Paint by Numbers”
Ad Testing Method 14 May 2010 | Howie Jacobson, PhD
!"#$%&'%(%)*+$,%
•! !"#$"%&'%()*$+%
•! ,)+-(./%012+%
•! 3.-)4.()5.4)&*%
•! 6/*&*/7+%
•! 89:(.7.4)&*%-&)*4+%
•! ;<$+4)&*%7."=+%
•! !''$"+%
•! >$.4<"$+%
•! ?$*$@)4+%
•! 3.((+%4&%.:4)&*%
•! ,)''$"$*4%A&):$+%
•! 3"$#)B)()4/%8($7$*4+%
•! 87&4)&*.(%.--$.(+%
•! A)+<.(%#)''$"$*:$+%
•! C<.".*4$$+%
•! D$+4)7&*).(+%
•! ,)''$"$*4).4&"+%
•! E"&&'%$($7$*4+%
•! D"<+4%$($7$*4+%
•! 6F&"4%G+%(&*H%()*$+%
•! !*&7.4&-&$).%
•! E$":$-4<.(%I&#.()4/%J%A)+<.(K%L<#)4&"/K%&"%M)*$+4F$4):%
•! C$&H".-F):%4$"7+%J%,<"F.7K%E)$#7&*4K%4F$%D").*H($K%1$+$.":F%D").*H($K%C"$.4$"%1.($)HF%
•! E"&-")$4."/%*.7$+N%3F$:=7.4$%O&<"%3&7-$4)4)&*%G+%P7-"&G$%O&<"%L#Q&"#+%1$+<(4+%
•! 1$@($:4%-&-<(."%:<(4<"$%
•! 6-$.=%4&%.%R+<BSH"&<-T%
•! 6-$:)@):)4/%
•! 64.H$%&'%4F$%B</)*H%:/:($%
•! QF$"$%4&%-<4%=$/U&"#+%
•! ,/*.7):%M$/U&"#%P*+$"4)&*%%
•! V)HF()HF4%.+-$:4%&'%06E%
•! 0+$%&'%W."H&*%
•! 84:X%
•! 84:X%
•! 84:X%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
)"*%@='A:*B%./$"%)*+C1<%
•! 0'1DE+/1<%
•! F>*=."*:B/1<%
•! (1*G2/*1$%
•! H/I*%B*%JE<<:/1<%K%A#::+%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
)"*%L':EC'1%
•! 9%+$*M8AN8+$*M3%9O03%@#/1$8AN8PEBA*=+%
Q=#B*.'=I%D'=%)*+C1<%
•! L'%N'E%I1'.%!R9)%$'%$*+$%
•! (1%!R9)%F;&S;%
•! 91?%!R9)%)F%&F%!()R%)RS%;SLTH)L%
•! Q'=%U#V/BEB%@='W$+%/1%U/1/BEB%)/B*%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
)"*%X*NY%Z'E=%(?*#:%0E+$'B*=%
!"#$"%&'()&'
U#NA*%[%L'B*?#N%
9::%L*#=2"*=+%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
R/*=#=2"N%'D%L/<1/W2#1$%\E*+C'1+%
!"'% ]!!"'%#=*%$"*N,%
!"#$% ]!!"#$%=*+E:$%?'%$"*N%.#1$,%
!"N% ]!!"N%?'%$"*N%.#1$%/$,%
R'.% ]!R'.%?'%$"*N%.#1$%/$,%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
*+,'#=*%$"*N,%
&*B'<=#M"/2+%
@+N2"'<=#M"/2+%
(1%^*1*=#:%
;':*%
9.#=*1*++%
L'M"/+C2#C'1%
(1%$"/+%L*#=2"%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
*+-&'=*+E:$%?'%$"*N%.#1$,%
(1D'=B#C'1#:%
P#>/<#C'1#:%
)=#1+#2C'1#:%
)NM*%'D%L*#=2"%
(1D'=B#C'1%'1%<'E$%_%2#E+*+%#1?%$=*#$B*1$+%
9%=*D*==#:%$'%#%:'2#:%?'2$'=%
R*=A#:%=*B*?/*+%
^E/?#12*%'1%2"#1</1<%$"*/=%?/*$%
LM*2/W2+%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
*+.'?'%$"*N%.#1$%/$,%
Q*#=%
&*+/=*%
;*$=/AEC'1%
SB'C'1#:%$=/<<*=+%
R*='*+%
`/::#/1+%
L$'=/*+%
Q/1#12/#:%
L$#$E+%
;*:#C'1#:%
0'+$%'D%D#/:E=*%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
/,0'?'%$"*N%.#1$%/$,%
S8A''I%
LM*2/#:%;*M'=$%
SB#/:%2'E=+*%
`/?*'%
Fa*=+%
;*2/M*+%
@#1$=N%<E/?*%
R'.%$'%'=?*=%/1%=*+$#E=#1$+%
Q*#$E=*+%
&'.1:'#?%1'.%
Q/1?%'E$%B'=*%
S1?%$"*%+Ea*=/1<%
)#I*%2'1$=':%
0#::+%$'%#2C'1%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
SV#BM:*Y%^'E$%b#=$"=/C+c%
!"'% ]!U*?/2#:%[%9:$*=1#C>*%
!"#$% ]!(1D'=B#C'1%[%@='?E2$%[%L*=>/2*%
!"N% ]!&*M=*++/'1%[%FE$%'D%2'1$=':%
R'.% ]!\E/2I%[%0'BM=*"*1+/>*%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"',%
•! )=E+$+%B*?/2#:%*+$#A:/+"B*1$%
•! @=*D*=+%1#$E=#:%#:$*=1#C>*%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$,%
•! (1D'=B#C'1#:%
•! )=#1+#2C'1#:%_%@='?E2$%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"N,%
•! L$'M%A*/1<%?*M=*++*?%
•! ;*<#/1%2'1$=':%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
R'.,%
•! Q=**%)/M+%_%dE/2I%#1?%*#+N%
•! 0'BM:*$*%=*+'E=2*%8%2'BM=*"*1+/>*%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
LEBB#=N%'D%)*+C1<%@='$'2':%
L$#=$%./$"%$"*%!RF%
O=#/1+$'=B%M'++/A/:/C*+%
0=#e%#?+%$'%$*+$%*#2"%M'++/A/:/$N%
U*#+E=*%0);3%)FL3%#1?%0'1>*=+/'1+%
S+$#A:/+"%$"*%!RF%#1?%B'>*%$'%$"*%!R9)%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
)*+C1<%@='$'2':%f%;*2/M*%
Z'E%+C::%1**?%$"*%=/<"$%/1<=*?/*1$+%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
(1<=*?/*1$%g7Y%&**M%(1+/<"$%
/1$'%N'E=%(?*#:%0E+$'B*=%
1,2#'34"#'
1,2#''56"-7'
829&,:"#'
1,2#'8,:;"<<,='
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
(1<=*?/*1$%g5Y%&**M%(1+/<"$%
/1$'%N'E=%0'BM*CC'1%
1,2#'34"#'
1,2#''56"-7'
829&,:"#'
1,2#'8,:;"<<,='
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
(1<=*?/*1$%ghY%O=*#I$"='E<"%0=*#C>/$N%
1,2#'34"#'
1,2#''56"-7'
829&,:"#'
1,2#'8,:;"<<,='
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
;*2/M*%i%h%(1<=*?/*1$+%f%%
U#=I*$%&'B/1#C'1%
•! R/<"*=%0);%
•! R/<"*=%`/+/$'=%`#:E*%
•! H'.*=%0'+$%M*=%H*#?[L#:*%
•! R/<"*=%@='W$+%
•! U'=*%B'1*N%$'%+M*1?%'1%2:/2I+%
•! `/=$E'E+%2N2:*%D'=%N'E%
•! `/2/'E+%2N2:*%D'=%N'E=%2'BM*C$'=+%
8/>8?@AB>CC'-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%
;*+*=>*?4%
0"*2IB#$*%Z'E=%0'BM*CC'1%
•! jE1*%76877%b)"E=+?#N8Q=/?#Nc%5676%
•! 0"/2#<'%%
•! 5%&#N+%$"#$%./::%$'$#::N%$=#1+D'=B%N'E=%AE+/1*++%
•! !"#$%./::%N'E%<*$,%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
)"*%0"*2IB#$*%^E#=#1$**Y%Z'Ek::%^*$l%
m%'=%B'=*%I/::*=%#?%/?*#+%$"#$%N'E%.'E:?%1*>*=%"#>*%2'B*%EM%./$"%'1%
N'E=%'.1%
h8K%1*.%:#1?/1<%M#<*%"*#?:/1*+%$"#$%./::%2'BM*:%/1$*=*+$%#1?%
n#B*%?*+/=*%
o%.#N+%$'%"#1?:*%$"*%B'+$%/1+/?/'E+%'AJ*2C'1+%b$"*%'1*+%N'E%?'1k$%*>*1%I1'.%#A'E$%_%N'Ek::%A*%+E=M=/+*?%#1?%+"'2I*?c%
h%/?*#+%D'=%M'.*=DE:3%E1B#$2"#A:*%<E#=#1$**+%
$"#$%./::%$"='.%N'E=%2'BM*C$'=+%/1$'%2"#'C2%
/1+$#A/:/$N%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
)"*%0"*2IB#$*%^E#=#1$**Y%Z'Ek::%^*$l%
Q/1#::N3%#e*=%N*#=+%'D%"*#=/1<%#A'E$%/$3%=*#?/1<%#A'E$%/$3%?/+2E++/1<%/$%_%N'E=%'.1%78h%:/1*%TL@%
R'.%$'%#1C2/M#$*%N'E=%2'BM*C$'=+k%+$=#$*</*+%_%#1?%A*#$%$"*B%#$%$"*/=%'.1%<#B*%
Z'E=%'.1%2E+$'B/p*?%qP'%^E*++/1<r%$*+C1<%M:#1%_%N'Ek::%I1'.%
*V#2$:N%."#$%$'%?'%&#N%73%&#N%53%&#N%h3%*$24%
9%AE=+$%'D%:/A*=#C1<%2=*#C>/$N%_%#1?%$"*%
#A/:/$N%$'%=*2=*#$*%/$%#$%./::3%/1+$#1$:N%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
UN%@*1#:$N%/D%(%&'1k$%&*:/>*=%
•! (%./::%.=/$*%N'E%#%2"*2I%D'=%$"*%2'+$%'D%N'E=%
$E/C'1%'1%$"*%+M'$%%
•! @:E+%(k::%$"='.%/1%stK6%$"#$%./::%B'=*%$"#1%
2'>*=%N'E=%$=#>*:%*VM*1+*+%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
)"*%Q/1*%@=/1$%8%0'1?/C'1+%
•! Z'E%"#>*%#%AE+/1*++%
•! Z'E%+"'.%EM%
•! Z'E%M#=C2/M#$*%DE::N%
•! Z'E%#=*%'M*1%$'%1*.%/?*#+%
•! Z'E%#=*%./::/1<%$'%+"#=*%/?*#+%./$"%'$"*=+%
B+"=')&D9'E-:"'3=CC'
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
%q)"/+%.#+%A=/::/#1$%#1?%#:B'+$%*>*=N'1*%/1%$"*%=''B%&(&%*VM*=/*12*%#%A=*#I$"='E<"4%(12:E?/1<%US4%(%A*#$%#%:'1<8+$#1?/1<%^''<:*%2'1$=':%#?4%9:+'%<'$%#??*?%/1+M/=#C'1%D'=%BN%uL./++%9=BN%X1/D*u%$*2"1/dE*3%#%+B#+"%"/$%(%$"*1%/1$='?E2*?%D'=%$"*%W=+$%CB*%/1%U#E/4%@:E+%/$%.#+%+EM*=%DE14%)"*%CB*%n*.%AN%#1?%+E??*1:N%.*%#::%"#?%#%1*.%+*$%'D%$'':+%D'=%M*=+E#?/1<%2E+$'B*=+4r%_%!"##.'@-#9+-77'
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
%q!"#$%=*#::N%/BM=*++*?%B*%#A'E$%R'./*%/+%"/+%#A/:/$N%$'%2=*#$*%#%+*dE*12*%'D%*>*1$+%."*=*AN%N'E%#=*%#A:*%$'%E1?*=+$#1?%N'E=%2E+$'B*=%A*v*=4%(%"#>*%+**1%B#1N3%B#1N%M*'M:*%#='E1?%$"*%.'=:?%$=N%$'%$*#2"%M*'M:*%"'.%$'%+*::%$"/1<+3%AE$%R'./*%*1#A:*+%N'E%$'%?'%$"/+%+EM=*B*:N%.*::%/1%#%.#N%$"#$%/+%#:B'+$%2"/:?/+":N%+/BM:*%AE$%"E<*:N%*a*2C>*4%Z'E%+"'E:?%</>*%"/B%#%+"'$4r%_%F#-.&,='G)#63%H*<*1?#=N%&/=*2$%U#=I*C1<%0'MN.=/$*=%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
%q)"/+%.#+%./$"'E$%#%?'EA$%$"*%B'+$%M='D'E1?%*V*=2/+*%(%"#>*%*>*=%?'1*%$'%$=N%$'%E1?*=+$#1?%BN%2E+$'B*=%'=%2:/*1$%#1?%"'.%$'%2'B*%EM%./$"%.#N+%$'%B#=I*$%+M*2/W2#::N%$'%$"*B4r%_%F#H'A=6#"0'8,7."#3%R'.)'UE+2:*)*+$42'B%%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
•! q(%"#?%$"#$%D**:/1<%'D%*V2/$*B*1$3%$"#$%w2#1k$%+:**M%#$%1/<"$%#1?%N'E%"#>*%$'%<*$%'E$%$"*=*%#1?%$*+$%$"/+%#1?%<*$%/$%'1:/1*k%D**:/1<4r%_%G"='@,9I"73%o%Q/<E=*%9G:/#$*%U#=I*$*=%%
•! qF1*%'D%$"*%A*+$%+*B/1#=+%(k>*%*>*=%#v*1?*?4%`*=N%+CBE:#C1<3%>*=N%M'.*=DE:4r%_%J,K"#&'@)667"&,=3%92C'1@:#142'B%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
%q!"*1%(%:*e%(%"#?%o%2=*#C>*%#?+%$"#$%.*=*%.=/v*1%AN%'$"*=%M*'M:*%#1?%(%=*#::N%<'$%>#:E*4%)"*%M='A:*B%./$"%B'+$%+*B/1#=+%/+%/$%+**B+%:/I*%N'E%=*B*BA*=%#A'E$%76x3%AE$%/1%$"/+%2#+*3%(%.#:I*?%#.#N%./$"%+'B*$"/1<%'1%M#M*=%$"#$%/+%'D%>#:E*%$'%B*%#1?%$"#$%.#+%/BM=*++/>*4r%_%G,K'G-#"3%R*#=/1<R#>*142'B%bS2'BB*=2*%+$'=*%'.1*=c%%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
%q)"*%0"*2IB#$*%U#=I*C1<%LN+$*B%.#+%M"*1'B*1#:4%(%"#?%1'%/?*#%(%.'E:?%<*$%#+%BE2"%>#:E*%'E$%'D%/$%#+%(%?/?4%(%<'$%M#+$%+'B*%$'M/2+%'1%."/2"%(%.#+%=*#::N%+$E2I%.'=I/1<%'1%+'B*%*B#/:%B*++#<*+%$'%BN%$#=<*$%M='+M*2$+3%$=N/1<%$'%2'11*2$%./$"%$"*B%dE/2I:N%#1?%*B'C'1#::N4%%
%q(%"#>*%A**1%+M*1?/1<%?#N+%'1%$"/+%<'/1<%A#2I%.=/C1<3%=*8.=/C1<%#1?%=*8?=#e/1<%#1?%$"#$%+'=$%'D%$"/1<4%($%.#+%$"='E<"%$"*%M='2*++%'D%.'=I/1<%./$"%R'./*%$"#$%+E??*1:N%(%=*#:/p*?%$"#$%wF"%BN%<'+"yk%)"*=*k+%#%$*==/W2%#MM='#2"%"*=*%$"#$%(%"#?%1*<:*2$*?%#1?%/$%.#+%2'11*2C1<%./$"%$"*%M*=+'1%/1+$#1$:N%#1?%*B'C'1#::N4%%
%q(%2#1%+**%*1'=B'E+%#MM:/2#C'1+%D'=%$"/+3%1'$%JE+$%/1%*B#/:%B#=I*C1<%AE$%9?!'=?+3%$'M/2+%D'=%."/$*%M#M*=+3%"*#?:/1*+%#1?%+'%'14%(%$"/1I%$"/+%/+%=*#::N%.'=$"."/:*4r%_%F-L"'M#-=)%-#3%@='D*++/'1#:%0'MN.=/$*=%#1?%L#:*+%0'1+E:$#1$%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
%q(%.#+%=*#::N%#B#p*?%$"#$%/1%JE+$%o%+/BM:*%B/1E$*+%(%.#+%#A:*%$'%2'B*%EM%./$"%z%?/a*=*1$%#?+4%(%D'E1?%I*N.'=?+%(%1*>*=%$"'E<"$%'D3%#?%2'MN%(%1*>*=%$"'E<"$%'D3%#1?%(%.#+%#B#p*?%$"#$%/1%JE+$%o%+/BM:*%B/1E$*+%"'.%BE2"%/BM#2$%N'E%2'E:?%B#I*4r%_%N-:".'G#)6O"93%(1$*=1*$;*#:S+$#$*LE22*++42'B%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
!"#$%@*'M:*%R#>*%L#/?%
%q(k>*%2'B*%A#2I%./$"%#A'E$%#%"#:D%#%?'p*1%1*.%#?+%$"#$%(%1**?%$'%<'%#1?%+M:/$%$*+$%#1?%(%#B%>*=N%*V2/$*?4%(%2#B*%EM%./$"%+/V%?/a*=*1$%#1<:*+%$'%M='B'$*%$"/+%M='?E2$%$"#$%(%"#?%1'%/?*#%*>*1%*V/+$*?%'=%*>*1%$"'E<"$%#A'E$4%L'3%(%#B%>*=N%>*=N%*V2/$*?%#A'E$%$"/+%#1?%(%JE+$%.#1$*?%$'%+#N%w)"#1I+%R'./*ykr%_%(-)9-7'?+-=3%0'=?'A#%Q/1#12/#:%^='EM%%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
R'.%UE2"%&'*+%0"*2IB#$*%0'+$,%
•! sPQQR'E1C:%U#N%h7%
•! ^'*+%EM%$'%s57zt%'1%jE1*%7%
•! (12:E?*+%*1C=*%0"*2IB#$*%R'B*%L$E?N%
0'E=+*%b+*::+%D'=%s{ztc%
•! (12:E?*+%7%DE::%N*#=%'D%<='EM%2'#2"/1<%/1%$"*%
0"*++%0:EA%b>#:E*%'D%szztc%
•! OE$l%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
LM*2/#:%&*#:%D'=%^:*11k+%H/+$%
•! (k>*%A**1%+:'.%$'%M='B'$*%0"*2IB#$*%$'%j`%
M#=$1*=+%
•! P'$%D#/=%$'%N'E%$'%B/++%$"*%A*+$%M=/2/1<%
•! ;*$='#2C>*:N%<*$%$"*%S#=:N%S#=:N%O/=?%@=/2*%'D%
s7{zt%b'G2/#::N%*VM/=*?%9M=/:%h6c%_%M:*#+*%
?'1k$%MEA:/+"%$"/+y%
•! ^''?%E1C:%jE1*%73%5676%
•! "vMY[[0#BM0"*2IB#$*42'B[<:*11%%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%
"vMY[[0#BM0"*2IB#$*42'B[<:*11%
-%"'./*0'11*2$3%(124%5667856764%9::%;/<"$+%;*+*=>*?4%