Date post: | 05-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | melissa-adams |
View: | 224 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 21
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
1/21
Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary
Charles Haddon Spurgeon
A Research Paper Submitted to
Fulfill the Partial Requirements of
CHHI 694 History of the Baptists
Dr. Almer Smith
By
Melissa L. Adams
Barnesville, GA
October 16, 2011
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
2/21
1
Table of Contents
Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
Family Background and Early Life. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Conversion Experience. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
First Pastorates. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .7
Metropolitan Tabernacle. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12
Pastors College. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .13
Down-Grade Controversy. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13
Writings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..17
Theology. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
Bibliography. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
3/21
2
Introduction
Charles Spurgeon was a very influential Baptist preacher in London, England in the late
1800s. He is also known as the Prince of Preachers. He preached to thousands of people each
week. He led countless revivals, founded a college, an orphanage, a very famous charitable
organization that still exists today, and was an active member of the Baptist Union of Great
Britain. However, what made him the Prince of all Preachers? What character traits did he had to
have possessed to have achieved so much? James T. Allen, author ofThe Life Story of Charles
H. Spurgeon, describes the measure of a great man. We do not measure great men by their
specific opinions on this or that question, or by their adherence to this or that dogma. We rather
estimate them by their volume of moral and spiritualizing power, by the essential qualities of
their manhood, by the leavening influences for righteousness that emanate from their own
lives.1So what were the qualities of Charles H. Spurgeons manhood? What qualities drew so
many people to him? To determine this, we have to study his life closely. What have to study
what made him successful in his endeavors. Mac Brunson, author ofThe New Guidebook for
Pastors,speaks briefly on the success of Spurgeons church in London. It is easy to suppose
that the church was built on Spurgeons preaching. However, I personally believe Spurgeon
would tell us it was prayer that built it.2 So he was not just a great orator but a man of prayer.
However, there is more to Spurgeon that this. We will explore certain key aspects of his life and
from his actions; so that we deduce what the other qualities that made him such a success. First,
let us explore his family roots.
1James T. Allen, The Life Story of Charles Spurgeon (Albany, Oregon: The Ages Digital Library
Biography, 1997, 4.
2James W. Bryant & Mac Brunson, The New Guidebook for Pastors (Nashville, TN: B&H Publishing
Group, 2007), p. 47.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
4/21
3
Family Background and Early Life
To begin with, Spurgeon came from a line of preachers. The Spurgeon line was one of
Puritan lineage and it is said that the founders of the family in Norfolk and Essex came from the
Low Countries to escape the persecution of the bloodthirsty Duke of Alva, in the sixteenth
century.3
It is also said that they were devout nonconformists. Spurgeon even had one famous
ancestor, Job Spurgeon, who, during the reign of Charles II., lay in Chelmsford gaol for fifteen
weeks, rather than be a traitor to his convictions.4Charles grandfather was the pastor of the
Independent Church of Stambourne for 50 years. He devoted his life to ministering to the village
folk that he loved so much. John, Charles father also pastored an Independent Church at
Cranbrook, Kent for over a decade. Charles received a rather profound Christian upbringing and
he was afforded this best education from his grandfather, whom he went to live with at an early
age.
Robert Schindler, author ofThe Life and Labors of Charles Spurgeon, describes his life
at Stambourne. Under the immediate oversight of the grandfather, he soon developed into a
thoughtful boy; commonly fonder of his books that of his play.5 He was rather like Jesus. He
regularly astounded the grave deacons and matrons, who met at his grandfathers house on
Sabbath evenings, by proposing subjects for conversation, and offering pertinent remarks about
them; and there were at that early period of his life palpable indications of that decision of
character and boldness of address for which he has become so remarkable. 6 Growing up at
3Allen, Spurgeon, 5.
4Ibid.
5Robert Schindler,From the Usher's Desk to the Tabernacle Pulpit: The Life and Labors of Charles
Haddon Spurgeon (New York: A.C. Armstrong and Son, 1936), 24.
6Ibid.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
5/21
4
Stambourne was a treat for young scholar because of his grandfathers ministry there. Most of
his time was spent studying scripture and Puritan theology. It is obvious that he was very curious
about the inner workings of his grandfathers church. So much so that an incident occurred in the
year of 1844, which had a considerable influence on him at the time, and would definitely have a
profound effect on him in his first few years as a pastor.
At the age of ten, he was at his grandfather's when Mr. Knill, then of Chester, now of
New Jerusalem, whose name is a household word, and whose memory is precious to thousands
at home and abroad, stayed at the ministers house on Friday, since he was to preach at
Stambourne for the London missionary Society on the following Sunday. He heard the boy read,
and commended him.7
Later, Rev. Knill took the young Charles for a walk and discussed the
Bible with him. Young Spurgeon had lots of questions with which Mr. Knill answered with
earnestness and wisdom. Later on the next day, Knill went and talked with Charles grandfather.
Here are his words:
I do not know how it is, but I feel a solemn presentiment that this child will preach the
gospel to thousands, and God will bless him to many souls. So sure am I of this, that
when my little man preaches in Rowland Hills chapel, as he will do one day, I should
like him to promise me that he will give out to hymn commencing- God moves in a
mysterious way, his wonders to perform.8
The prophetic word that Knill gave that day was fulfilled later when Spurgeon was 18. He
preached at Surrey Chapel (Rowlands Hills Chapel) and he made sure the hymn was sung. Mr.
Knill even heard about it and told all his peers that he knew the young Charles Spurgeon who
was making quite a name for himself. Schindler writes that to preach at Surrey Chapel was a
high honor for any young or old preacher for it was the largest nonconformists place of worship
7Schindler,Labors of Spurgeon, 27.
8Ibid., 28.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
6/21
5
in London, at least south of the Thames.9
In the next few years after he preached there, he saw
his church at New Park Street grow in the thousands. However, this part of his life will be
discussed later on in more depth. Now let us return to his early years as a youth in Stambourne
and see the type of education he received. From what we have already seen, several habits
marked the character of the young Charles Spurgeon for future greatness in the ministry. For
example, he had a great love of truth, a love for the house of God, of worship, and most of all,
prayer. His father says that Charles was often found in the hay-rick, or the manger, praying, or
reading aloud, and sometimes talking and preaching to his brothers and sisters.10
The young Spurgeon stayed with his grandfather for six consecutive years and received
his elementary education locally. John D. Woodbridge, author of the bookGreat Leaders of the
Christian Church, describes his time there. Charles spent many delightful holidays there,
precociously exploring the library of Puritan works that had once belonged to the first
Independent minister of the village in the seventeenth century.11
Spurgeon received his
elementary education at Mr. Walkers School at Colchester, and afterwards spent four years in
the same town at a school conducted by Mr. Henry Lewis.12 He attended an Agricultural College
at Maidstone for one year; and afterwards he went to Newmarket (Suffolk) to be a student
school-teacher in the school of a Mr. Swindell. There he pursued his studies with remarkable
diligence. His faith in the Lord and his sense of self-humility grew by leaps and bounds. As you
can see from his family background and early life, it is obvious that he had great potential and
9Schindler,Labors of Spurgeon, 32.
10Ibid., 37.
11John D. Woodbridge, Great Leaders of the Christian Church (Chicago, Illinois: Moody Press, 1988), 336.
12Schindler,Labors of Spurgeon, 33.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
7/21
6
that his future looked bright. However, there was one thing still missing from his life. He had yet
to become a true Christian. Even though he grew up in church and was the son and grandson of
ministers, he had not yet accepted Christ. His conversion story is very interesting and gives a lot
of insight into how he perceived God even as a young man.
Conversion
Spurgeon wrestled with sin during his young life. He went from church to church
searching for answers. He wanted to know this one thing. How could he be forgiven? No
minister he had ever heard preach had taught him this simple answer to this huge dilemma all of
us face at one point in our lives. It was not until one snowy day that he got his answer. Below are
the details in his own words:
At last, one snowy day, -- it snowed so much I could not go to the place I had
determined to go to, and I was obliged to stop on the road, and it was a blessed stop to
me, -- I found rather an obscure street, and it turned down a court, and there was a little
chapel. It was the Primitive Methodist Chapel. I had heard of these people from many,
and how they sang so loudly that they made peoples heads ache; but that did not matter.
I wanted to know how I might be saved, and if they made my head ache ever so much. I
did not care. So, sitting down, the service went on, but no minister came; at last a very
thin-looking man came into the pulpit, and opened his Bible, and read these words: Look
unto Me, and be ye saved, all the ends of the earth. Just setting his eyes upon me, as if he
knew all my heart, he said, Young man, you are in trouble. Well, I was, sure enough.
Says he, You will never get out of it unless you look to Christ. And then, lifting up his
hand, he cried out, has only a Primitive Methodists could do, Look, look, look! It is only
look, said he. I saw at once the way of salvation. Oh, how I did leap for joy at the
moment! I know not what else he said. I did not take much notice of it; I was so
possessed with that one thought. Like as when the brazen serpent was lifted up, they only
looked and were healed. I had been waiting to do fifty things, but when I heard this word,
Look, what a charming word it seemed to me! Oh, I looked until I could almost havelooked my eyes away; and in heaven I will look on still in my joy unutterable!
13
What a funny and amazing story. However, as a man who grew up in a Christian home, it is a
wonder why he was not saved already. Surely his grandfather or father shared the gospel with
13Schindler,Labors of Spurgeon, 35-36.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
8/21
7
him? Maybe they just assumed he was saved since he studied the Bible with great fervor and
attended church throughout his childhood. This experience would impact his future minister.
Specifically, you can say that this unique experience enhanced his ministry. This is because it
taught him a valuable lesson. Spurgeon's conversion experience imprinted on his heart the
importance of preaching to sinners. He vowed that he will never preach a sermon without a
sinner present. Having this philosophy is probably one of the main reasons he was able to reach
so many thousands of the Lost in England. He learned from his own experiences early on and
applied them to his ministry. Several years after his conversion, on 11th October 1864, Mr.
Spurgeon preached in the Primitive Methodist Chapel at Colchester, and took for his text the
ever memorable words (Isa. Xlv.22), "look unto Me, and be ye saved," & c. That was the text,"
said he, "that I had heard from in this chapel when the Lord converted me.14 He also then he
pointed out the pew he was sitting in when he was converted. The last school stop for school was
new Cambridge. It was in Cambridge that he took his first church.
First Pastorates
The story of his first church is another interesting story. One night he went with a fellow
Cambridge student to a bible study thinking his friend was leading the study. He wished his
friend good luck with the sermon and his friend replied , Me preaching? No I have no idea
how.15
Ironically, there was no pastor to lead the gathering, so the young Charles took it upon
himself to bring the Word that night. This was his first public sermon. So he then became a
village minister, preaching in various churches and at in home gatherings much like the first one.
His reputation spread amazingly, and in a short time he was engaged in week-night
services in the pulpits of Cambridge, the first pulpit he occupied in that town was Water-beach.
14Schindler, Labors of Spurgeon, 37.
15Ibid., 50.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
9/21
8
The Baptists of Water-beach gave him a call to be the pastor of their church, promising he should
not be overburdened with an exorbitant stipend. Spurgeon at the age of 17, after much prayer and
meditation, accepted the call, and went to minister to the people in an old square building,
although many of its attendants looked upon it as sacred as the Ark of the Covenant.16 He
preached here for three years. He was very happy. However, God had bigger things in store for
Spurgeon. One day he received an important letter from London.
John D. Woodbridge, author of the bookGreat Leaders of the Christian Church,
describes Spurgeons call to New Park Street. His growing fame as a preacher brought him to
the attention of the New Park Baptist Church in south London, once the congregation, once the
congregation of John Gill, the greatest of eighteenth-century theologians among the Baptists, and
of John Rippon, their leading figure at the turn of the nineteenth century.17
It was on the last Sunday morning in November, 1853 when Charles received a letter of
appointment from the New Park Street Chapel in Southwark. At first he thought the letter was
for another pastor with the last name Spurgeon. However, deep down he knew that there was no
mistake. Although, he was surprised that people in London had heard about him in such a small
amount of time. This shows how humble he was even though he had just been offered a job at
one of the more well-known churches in London. He was becoming famous but he did not let it
go to his head. He was flabbergasted at this development. He immediately wrote the church back
accepting the position and notifying them when he would arrive. Here are his words upon his
arrival in Southwalk: At the site of the New Park Street Chapel I felt for a moment amazed at
my own temerity, for it seemed to my eyes to be a large, ornate and imposing structure,
suggesting an audience wealthy and critical, and far removed from the humble folk to whom I
16Allen, Spurgeon, 17.
17Woodbridge, Great Leaders, 336.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
10/21
9
ministry had been sweetness and light.18
He was not even twenty years old when he took the
pastorate. This is quite an accomplishment at such a young age! Most ministers of this modern
age have not even finished with their bachelors degree at twenty, never mind being a famous
pastor! Surely Gods hand was upon him. What was his secret? Was it just his charisma and call
of God on him that drew people?
People were drawn to him because he was a real man of God and because he was a
dynamic preacher. He was a man of prayer. The church at New Park Street was well-known but
it had been much diminished in its attendance of late and young Charles said that he prayed for a
period of prosperity for them during his time there.
19
His prayer was brought to fruition because
the numbers began to rise and rapidly at that! Spurgeon, having realized his immediate success,
went in to a depression of sorts. Here are his words on the subject:
My success appalled me; and the thought of the career which it seemed to open up, so
far from relating me, cast me into the lowest depth, out of which I uttered my misery and
found no room for a gloria en excelsis. Who was I that I should continue to lead so great
a multitude?20
Again, it is amazing to see his huge humility. He was worthy of the admiration and success
bestowed upon him. Woodbridge describes how much people loved and came from all over
England to hear his preaching: Elaborate sentences replete with poetic phraseology had become
fashionable in the London pulpit in recent years, but Spurgeon spoke with a pithy directedness
that started his audience.21
They say he was also funny and had a powerful but melodious voice.
18David Otis Fuller, C.H. Spurgeons Autobiography, Edited and Condensed from the 4 Original
Volumes, 1500 Pages (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House, 1946), 68.
19Ibid., 69.
20Fuller, Spurgeons Autobiography, 73.
21Woodbridge, Great Leaders, 336.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
11/21
10
Finally, he possessed a gift for the dramatic. Within twelve months Park Street Chapel had to be
enlarged.22 However, during this fruitful period, disease struck the community in 1854.
After his one year anniversary of being at New Park Street, the neighborhood around his
church was visited by cholera, and many families belonging to his congregation suffered greatly
and died. He was constantly giving funerals and standing in the graveyard mourning the loss of
yet another member of his beloved chapel. Later God gave him comfort by directing him to read
which had been placed in the window of a shoe makers shop. It bore these words: Because thou
hast made the Lord, which is my refuge, even the Most High, thy habitation; there shall no evil
befall thee, neither shall any plague come nigh thy dwelling.
23
He was also comforted when he
was sent to attend a dying woman. This woman was not sickly looking but happy and she was
singing. She died with a smile on her face. These events helped Spurgeon through the heavy loss
his church had that year.
In the year 1856, Spurgeon married Susannah Thompson in London. His church
continued to grow so much so that Spurgeon and his congregation started raising money to build
a new church. By January, 1868, the amount in land was 6100 pounds, and within the next year it
reached 9639 pounds. 5000 words set aside for the purchase of the site.24 On Tuesday, 16th
August, 1859, the first stone of the Metropolitan Tabernacle was laid by Sir Morton Peto.25
Meanwhile services were held in the Exeter Hall and later, when it could no longer hold the
vastly growing church, at Surrey Gardens Music Hall. At the first service in the Music Hall,
22Allen, Spurgeon, 22.
23Fuller,Autobiography of Spurgeon, 75.
24Schindler,Labors of Spurgeon, 110.
25Allen, Spurgeon, 23.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
12/21
11
there were 10,000 people who filled the hall to overflowing. Lets compare how the church as
grown my comparing the stats from one he started up to this point. Allen writes, When he first
preached in London he had 200 hearers, now they numbered 1,178 members. During that period
he had received into fellowship by baptism no less than 3,569 persons.26 None can deny he was
a Prince of Preachers.
Many ministers from other denomination and public figures ridiculed Spurgeon for his
inexperience and youth. Spurgeon was very aware of this and yet he did not waver in his
devotion to the chapel. Furthermore, even though his church in London increased to that of
thousands, Spurgeon remained humble. In fact, he till fought against this success. Here are his
words on the matter:
God gave me souls by hundreds, who were added to my church, and in one year it was
my happiness personally to see not less than 1000 who had been converted. I do not
expect that now. My name is somewhat esteemed, and the great ones of the earth think he
had no dishonor to set at my feet, but this makes me fear lest my God forsake me while
the world esteems me. I would rather be despised and slandered than aught else. This
assembly, that you think so grand and find, I would really part with, if by such a loss I
would gain a greater blessing. It is for us to reflect, in all times of popularity, that
Crucify Him! Crucify Him! follows fast upon the heels of Hosanna! 27
Metropolitan Tabernacle
Two years since the beginning for the construction of their new church started, in 1861,
the congregation moved to its permanent home, the Metropolitan Tabernacle.28
The first service
in the new tabernacle was a prayer- meeting. It was held at seven o'clock in the morning, on
Monday, March 18, in 1861. The first sermon was preached by Mr. Spurgeon on Monday
afternoon, 25th of March, 1861, from Acts: and daily in the temple, and in every house, they
26Ibid., 26.
27Fuller,Autobiography of Spurgeon, 78.
28Woodbridge, Great Leaders, 336.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
13/21
12
ceased not to teach and preach Jesus Christ.29
Allen describes the services at the Met: The
service at the Tabernacle was utterly devoid of such accessories of worship as good music and
imposing ritual, and yet Sabbath after Sabbath that great congregation of 6,000 souls assembled
for more than thirty years. Without undue exaggeration, we can affirm that his record as a
preacher is absolutely without parallel in the history of the world.30
It was said that the
Metropolitan Tabernacle sat 3,600 but that an additional 2,000 others were usually there on a
given Sunday and there was standing room only.
The Pastors College
After three months in the Tabernacle a young man, only four months younger than
Spurgeon was came to inquire on his salvation. He was a learned man and whose intellect
Charles found refreshing. The young man became a Christian soon after that and then began to
do ministry at the Tabernacle with Spurgeon. Schinder writes, At first Spurgeon mentored the
boy himself but as his duties with the Tabernacle grew, he put him under the tutelage of Rev.
C.H. Hosken, then pastor of the Baptist Church at Crayford Kent.31 This was really the
commencement of the Pastors College, and the young men above mentioned, Mr. Thomas
William Medhurst, was the first. The Rev. George Rogers, of the Albany Congregational
Chapel became the principal of the college and Mr. Camberwell its theological tutor. Other early
students of the college include Mr. Davies of Greenwich; Mr. Genders of Ifracombe; Mr.
Archibald Brown of the East London Tabernacle; Mr. Cuff of the Shoreditch Tabernacle; Mr.
29Schindler,Labors of Spurgeon, 114.
30Allen, Spurgeon, 28.
31Schindler,Labors of Spurgeon, 132.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
14/21
13
Burton; and professors Gracie and Marchant, who are now tutors of the college in which they
were former students.32 Spurgeon had three specific reasons for why he started the new school:
(1) No other college, at that time, appeared to him to be suitable for his students.(2) This was because they were mostly poor, and most of the colleges involved
necessarily a considerable outlay to the student; for even where the educationwas free, books, close, and other incidental expenses required a considerable
sum per annum.
(3) Moreover, it must be frankly admitted that my views on the gospel and of themode of training preachers were, and are, somewhat peculiar. These and other
considerations led me to take a few tried young men, and to put them under
some able minister, that he might train them in the Scriptures, and in other
knowledge helpful to the understanding and proclaiming of the truth.33
Woodbridge tells us that since the colleges foundation in the late 1850s, trained nearly 900 men
before his death.34
Spurgeon also wrote textbooks for the school,His Lectures to My Students,
was a classic for those at the school preparing for the ministry. He also published his own
monthly church magazine, The Swordand Trowel. Spurgeons life and ministry seemed to be
successful and must have brought great joy to the great preacher but the hardest battle he had
ever fought came in the 1880s.
Down-Grade Controversy
By 1830 all religious disabilities had been relaxed and Baptists enjoyed a period of great
religious freedom. Baptists like Henry Jessey, John Tombes, and John Bunyan, began to favor
the laxer practice of communing with all Christians.35 Also, The Particular Baptists formed a
Union in 1813. This union was established for six reasons. Two of the six were (1) to raise
money for missions and (2) provide religious education. The forming of the Union would no
32Ibid., 133.
33Ibid., 135.
34Woodbridge, Great Leaders, 338.
35Henry Vedder,A Short History of the Baptists (Valley Forge, Pennsylvania: Judson Press, 1978), 181.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
15/21
14
doubt be beneficial to many Baptists but this type of external body existing outside of the local
assembly was something the Free Church movement had been against forming for hundreds of
years. The Baptists had always coveted their local autonomy. However, I guess they thought that
the advantages far outweighed old superstitions. At first, the Union was for formed for
ecumenical purposes but later it would become so much more but not in a good way.
Apparently the laxer practice of communing with all Christians influenced the Particular
Baptists so much that they sought to merge with the General Baptists. Their rational for this was
a misconstrued wanting to obtain unity within the national Baptist body. Their intentions were
pure but for the unification to commence, compromises were made. There was a disastrous side
effect to this compromise:
The Attempt to Unify the Two Groups necessitated the need to drop doctrines,
dropping these doctrines allowed the infiltration of liberalism and the infiltration of
liberalism became the biggest enemy Spurgeon every faced.
-Dr. Avril Caner, Professor of Church History, Liberty University
Essentially, the newly found religious freedom of the Baptists and the idea of open communion
opened the door for liberalism and a new type of theology (that was actually heresy), which
started to eat at the already shaky Baptist foundation.
Committed Biblicists in England began seeing that a new type of heresy was creeping
into the pulpits and leadership of Baptist churches.36 Spurgeon was among this group of
committed scholars. Darwinism (1859) emerged to challenge the biblical view of creation. The
establishment of Biblical criticism by D. F. Strauss and Julius Wellhausen paved the way for a
new and heretical theology. Biblical criticism attacked the validity of divine inspiration and
36Ergun Caner, The British BaptistsDecline and Downgrade 1845. Historyof the Baptists, Lecture18.
Lynchburg, VA: Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary: Lectures on DVD, 2001, 4.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
16/21
15
inerrancy of the Bible. Wellhausen insisted that Moses did not write the Pentateuch and Strauss
tried to deny the divine origin and significance of miracles in the New Testament.
These men were attacking one of the most important fundamental doctrines of the
Christian faith, a doctrine that not just the Baptists held to. Scripture is the divinely inspired
Word of God. It is the blueprint on which our entire faith is built. If we deny the authority of
Scripture, we also deny the deity of the Father and Jesus alike. The main leader of this heresy,
who insisted that the Bible was not of divine origin, was a man by the name of John Clifford.
Although the absurdity of the New Theology was more than obvious to anyone who had
actively studied scripture, many ofthe Unions members began to accept it.
At first, the acceptance of this theology by Baptist ministers was not tolerated but later on
those who had objected to its intrusion began to look the other way. However, there were still
many who were against it but those who did remained silent. So why did those rejected this view
not speak out against it? Iain Murray, author of the Forgotten Spurgeon, answers this question,
There were undoubtedly genuine evangelical Baptists who would have been glad to see the
spreading error arrested, but to achieve this at the cost of the disruption of the Union was a
possibility they could not bring themselves to face.37 The next big question is this: Was the
perpetuation of the Union more important that the cost of truth? Was it really worth
compromising all that they had ever stood for? The answer is yes because the great majority of
Baptists had come to regard a national organization of their churches as essential to their well-
being.38
Disrupting this great new enterprise was apparently not worth upholding the truth.
When no one else would make a stand, Charles Spurgeon took it upon himself to be antagonist of
the New Theology Movement.
37Iain H. Murray, The Forgotten Spurgeon (London, England: London Banner of Truth Trust, 1973), 153.
38E. A. Payne, The Baptist Union: A Short History (London, England: Carey Kingsgate Press, 1959), 143.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
17/21
16
The first thing he did was encourage the Union to establish a new doctrinal statement
clearly outlining what they believed and did not believe in. This statement would help restrict the
influence of such heresies and keep them from spreading any further within the Union. However,
since Baptists are against creating creeds and such, they refused to do so. Furthermore, Spurgeon
was chided for giving material to Anglicans to strengthen their position.39
However, he was not
through. In 1887, Spurgeon wrote an article in The Swordand Trowel. In the article, he openly
condemned the New Theology. He called it the New Cult and said that it challenged the very
fundamentals of Christianity itself. He feared this controversy would be the end of the Baptist
Union because it was destroying it from the inside out. However, no one sided with him and
being severely wounded by his fellow brothers, he left the Union in October of 1887.40
Many in the Union wondered why he did not stay and fight it since he had some much
influence among them. Spurgeon did not stay because it went against his principles to do so. He
told this to an assembly of pastors in April of 88, I care for no man and for no newspaper, but
only for God.41 He was more loyal to God than to a denomination. We all can learn something
from this man and the fight he did not win. Jesus is the way, the truth, and the life. Jesus is more
important than some made-up heresy that tries to be passed off as truth. As ministers of the
gospel, we must be able to recognize these heresies when we encounter them in our churches.
We also need to know when to let go of something. Spurgeon knew he could not win this fight,
so he withdrew. Plus, it had a negative effect on Spurgeons mental and physical state.
In the years following the Down-Grade Controversy, Spurgeon began to isolate himself.
His health also declined. Many thought he was heart sick because of his flight from the Union.
39Murray, The Forgotten Spurgeon, 153.
40Ibid, 161.
41Ibid.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
18/21
17
Standing on the platform at Herne Hill station on October 26, 1891, before he went to Mentone
for the last time, his parting words to his friends were, The fight is killing me.42 He soon
developed a disease of the kidneys and he died on January 31, 1892. The last thing he said was,
My work is done.43 So in light of his last words, the age-old verse of Pauls, I have fought a
good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith; was etched on his tombstone. Let us
now review Spurgeons literary work.
Writings
In addition to his textbook writings and his magazine The Swordand the Trowel, he
wrote a best-selling book entitledJohn Ploughmans Talkand Sermons in Candles. His most
substantial literary work was a six volume commentary on the Psalms, The Treasury of David
(1870-1885).44 Many compilations of his sermons were printed along with various other Biblical
commentaries. What about his theology?
Theology
Deeply rooted in the strong Puritan traditions of East Anglia, Spurgeon had a firm grasp
of what he believed and a remarkable ability to communicate his convictions. 45 The structure of
his theology was primarily Calvinistic in nature. However, he did change some of his original
views during the course of his ministry, especially during the Down-Grade Controversy. These
modifications consisted of a rejection of ordination, and he came to embrace the idea that funds
for Christian work should be sought primarily through prayer, unsuccessfully urging this faith
42Murray, The Forgotten Spurgeon, 163.
43Ibid., 164.
44Woodbridge, Great Leaders, 338.
45Ibid., 334.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
19/21
18
mission principle on the Baptist Missionary Society in 1863.46
He also urged evangelical clergy
members to break with the Anglican Church because it was morally corrupt. He was firm in his
belief in Calvinism but said this about it: I am a very bad Calvinist, quite a CalvinistI look on
to the time when the elect will be all the world.47 A historian by the name of J. C. Carlile admits
that illogical as it may seem, Spurgeons Calvinism was of such a character that while he
proclaimed the majesty of God he did not hesitate to ascribe freedom of will to man and to insist
that any man might find in Jesus Christ deliverance from the power of sin.48 Charles was surely
an interesting character. He was brutally honest about everything, unlike many other famous
reformers/leaders, while being a humble man of prayer. He was also very smart and fought for
what he believed in.
Conclusion
There was certainly no lack of moral stamina, or of unflinching courage for conscience
sake in these lowly refugees from the Netherlands, who came to settle in our eastern counties
and who were Spurgeons ancestors.49 This is obvious in the character of Spurgeon. He was of
strong, moral character and stood up for what he believed in. He showed his congregation this
character every time he stood behind the pulpit. Allen states, It is no doubt as a preacher that
Spurgeon is best known, and it is to his unrivaled power in the pulpit that he owes his renown. 50
However, his power in the pulpit may be what he is famous for but it is not what made him so
successful. It was having a strong character, much like that of Christ that made him the Prince
46Woodbridge, Great Leaders, 337.
47Caner,Down-Grade Controversy, 6.
48Ibid.
49Allen, Spurgeon, 5.
50Ibid., 28.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
20/21
19
of Preachers. God worked through him because of the strength of his integrity, humility, and of
his prayer life. A truly great leader is one that follows God earnestly and emulates the character
of Christ in front of those who follow him. We must estimate Charles Haddon Spurgeon not by
how great an orator he was but by the essential qualities of his manhood, and by the leavening
influences for righteousness that emanated from his life. It is these characteristics that make a
leader. It was Spurgeons strength of character that most impacted the history of the Baptists.
8/2/2019 Adams+CHHI+694+FP+TP
21/21
20
Bibliography
Allen, James T. The Life Story of Charles Spurgeon. Albany, Oregon: The Ages Digital Library
Biography, 1997.
Caner, Ergun. The Baptist BaptistsDecline and Downgrade 1845. Historyof the Baptists,Lecture18. Lynchburg, VA: Liberty Baptist Theological Seminary: Lectures on DVD,
2001.
Fuller, David Otis. C.H. Spurgeons Autobiography, Edited and Condensed from the 4 Original
Volumes, 1500 Pages. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan Publishing House, 1946.
Murray, Iain H. The Forgotten Spurgeon. London, England: London Banner of Truth Trust,1973.
Payne, E.A. The Baptist Union: A Short History. London, England: Carey Kingsgate Press, 1959.
Schindler, Robert. From the Usher's Desk to the Tabernacle Pulpit: The Life and Labors ofCharles Haddon Spurgeon.New York: A.C. Armstrong and Son, 1936.
Vedder, Henry.A Short History of the Baptists. Valley Forge, Pennsylvania: Judson Press, 1978.
Woodbridge, John D. Great Leaders of the Christian Church. Chicago, Illinois: Moody Press,1988.