STRONGLY CORRELATED ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS AS UNCONVENTIONAL SEMICONDUCTORS
IN UNCONVENTIONAL CONDITIONS
Comparisons: Charge Density Waves
Conducting and optically active polymersSemiconducting and superconducting oxides
Organic conductors with charge ordering and ferroelectricity
After collaborations with :C. Brun & Z.Z. Wang Marcoussis FranceN. Kirova Orsay FranceYu. Latyshev Moscow RussiaP. Monceau Grenoble France
Preface 1:
Fundamental intrigue of many nonstandard conductors:The energy gap is formed spontaneously by electronic correlations through various symmetry breakings: Charge/Spin Density Wave,Antiferromagnetism, Charge OrderingCharge Disproportionation, Orbital Ordering.
These are volatile states, locally affected by electrons’ injection.
STRONGLY CORRELATED ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS AS UNCONVENTIONAL SEMICONDUCTORS IN UNCONVENTIONAL CONDITIONS
Help from CDWs: very small electric field deforms the ground statequite moderate field reaches the microscopic energy scale.
Preface 2:
Real time dynamics for reconstruction of a CDW state under applied field in restricted geometry
Collaboration:S. Brazovskii LPTMS, CNRS, Orsay, FranceN. Kirova LPS, CNRS, Orsay, FranceY. Luo Université Paris-Sud, France MSA. Rojo-Bravo Boston University, USA PDTianyou Yi LPTMS, CNRS, Orsay, France PhD
Simulations of CDW vortices under increasing voltage – the CDW amplitude
4
Outline
• CDW as an electronic crystal and its deformable ground state.• Experiments on nano-junctions.• Dislocations – the CDW vortices.• Time dependent GL approach to numerical modeling.• Results for realistic experimental geometries and parameters.• Stationary and dynamic multi-vortex configurations.• Conclusion
Vortices – the CDW phase
Profiles along the defected chainvs its nearest neighbor
Defected chain vs theory
Zeros of the CDW amplitude at a microscopic scale identified by the STM as amplitude solitons
C.Brun, Z.Z.Wang, P.Monceau and S.Brazovski 2011
))/)arctan((/2sin()/)tanh((
lxxxxx
s
s
Topological defects in a CDW.Solid lines: maxima of the charge density. Dashed lines: chains of the host crystal. From left to right: dislocations of opposite signs and
their pairs of opposite polarities.
Embracing only one chain of atoms, the pairs become a vacancy or an interstitial or ±2 solitons in CDW language.
Bypassing each of these defects, the phase changes by 2 - far from the defect the lattice is not perturbed.
Can be viewed also as branching of stripes at field-effect dopping.
7
Dynamic origin of dislocations
CDW sliding in the applied external electric field – collective motion of electronic crystal .To set it in motion at different velocities:Transfers flow of vortices – thick channels, Ong and MakiCoherent phase slip - thin cannel Gorkov; Bielis et al.
source drainv=0
v~I
Formation of new planes in the electronic crystal
Elimination of additional planes
Another reason for dislocations – static equilibrium structures due to applied transverse voltage or current
Direct access to the current conversion via dislocations: Cornell – Grenoble, late1990’s
8
Dislocation in CDW versus vortex in SC
)exp( iACDW
teAjCDW
2
xeAnCDW
2
xevCj FSC
2
tveCnF
SC
2
scr xn n 2 2 2
AjAAA
AjAA
ext
ext
222
22
][2
][
xyzyy AHE
Equivalence of given Ey and Hz upon the order parameters.Dislocations in CDW appear as vortices in SC.Reverse effect of order parameters upon the fields are opposite:CDW – electric field is screened via dislocations. SC - magnetic field enters via vortices
)exp( iCSC
xA
9
Intra-plain elasticity (∂x)2 + Coulomb energy (y)∂xforce to shift the equilibrium CDW charge density ∂x-(y), i.e. the CDW wave number =Qx -(y)x
Breaking of inter-plane correlation.Resolution : dislocation lines allow to bring new periods in a smooth way, except in a vortex core.
10
Minimal model: Interlayer decoupling as an incommensurability effect. Only two layer 1,2 kept at potentials ±V/2
Critical voltage = the energy necessary to create the first discommensuration: J1/2
Decoupling threshold: arrays of solitons or dislocations. Discommensurations in a two layers model.
21
212
22
1 cos24
Jdxd
dxdV
dxd
dxdvdxW F
Lattice of discommensurations (solitons in phase difference )Develops from the isolated discommensuration = the 2π soliton in ∆.
2/112 ))/cos(tanh(Arc2 Jllxxxx
11
In reality : CDW junction as an array of dislocation lines DLs.A bulk of many planes, voltage difference monitored at its sides. Lattice of discommensurations => sequence of DLs - vortices of the ICDW phaseCritical voltage - DL entry energy, like Hc1 in superconductors.(Old theories by Feinberg-Friedel, S.B.-Matveenko)
Recall a parallel topics – plastic flows of ICDW with multiple generation of DLs within the current conversion area of a junction.Space-resolved X-ray experiments of Cornell and Grenoble, theory by N.Kirova and S.B.
Pair-breaking energy Eg=2 (to be précised) One-particle adding energy ∆1 (≠ in general)
In 2D,3D ordered phases, T<Tc<< :Dislocation = 2 vortex of
Addatoms/vacancies = particles with charges ±2e = minimal pairs of dislocations (2D) /dislocation loop (3D) on one chain = 2 solitons
Excitations or stable perturbations
Phase slips:Microscopically – a self-trapping of electrons into solitons with their subsequent
aggregationMacroscopically – the edge dislocation line proliferating/expanding across the
sample.Low T: the energetics of dislocation lines/loops is determined by the Coulomb
forces and by screening facilities of the free carriers.
Electrons Amplitude solitons 2 phase solitonsD-loops/lines
Phase slips
13
Yurii Latyshev technology of mesa-structures:fabrication by focused ion beams.All elements – leads, the junction – are pieces of the same single crystal whisker NbSe3
Overlap junction forms a tunneling bridge of 200A width --only 20-30 atomic plains of a layered material.
Motivation for our modeling : Experiment on tunnel junctions
14
Direct observation of solitons and their arrays in tunneling on NbSe3
peak 2 for inter-gap creation of e-h pairsabsolute
threshold at low Vt≈0.2
creation of solitons at ≈2/3 : Es=2/ !
oscillating fine structure All features scale with the gap (T) !
Y. Latyshev, P. Monceau, A. Orlov, S.B., et al, PRLs 2005 and 2006
First degree puzzle: Why the voltage is not multiplied by N~20-30 - number of layers in the junction- It seems to be concentrated at just one elementary interval.
In similar devices for superconductors the peak appears at V=2*N
15
Recall a new science: field effect transformations in strongly correlated materials Their symmetry broken phases will be subject to reconstruction.
Fine structure is not a noise ! It is : sequential entering into the junction area of dislocation lines = CDW vortices = solitons‘ aggregates.
Need a complex modeling for intricate distributions of the order parameter (amplitude and the phase), electric potential, normal density and normal current.
Junction reconstruction by entering of dislocations
16
3d and contour plots ±y(x) for surfaces Ф(x,y)±∆ where the tunnelling takes place.
Known from analytic static solutions for an infinite CDW media:
Potential distribution in a DL vicinity. Notice concentration of potential Ф(x,y) drop facilitating the tunneling.
17
±2π phase solitons stretching/squeezing of a chain by one period with respect to the surrounding ones: elementary particles with the charge ±2e and the energy E~Tp 3D ordering temperature Tp.
Outcome : pair of 2 solitons can be created by tunneling almost exclusively within the dislocation core, The process can be interpreted as a excitation of the dislocation line as a quantum string.
What does tunnel at these low subgap voltages ?
18
Distribution of potentials (values in colours, equipotential lines in black) and currents (arrows) for moderate conductivity anisotropy (||/=100).
Before the reconstruction:
19
Junction reconstruction with cross-sections of dislocations.
The very low sharp threshold voltage Vt ~ 0.2 Δ can be provided only by the low energy phase channel, and the experiment also indicates that the voltage applied to the whole stacked junction drops mostly at a single elementary interlayer spacing. It can happen when the electric field in this junction exceeds a threshold value for phase decoupling in neighboring CDW layers. This decoupling is expected to proceed via the successive development of dislocation lines entering to the junction area.
Junction scheme with crossections of dislocations
20
esyxsrdHCDW
22
0
0
22
2003 ln
24
GL – like model
)(8
/))0()(( 22
3 nFdnnx
As
rdH zel
H=HCDW+Hel
)exp( iA
teAjCDW
2
xeAnCDW
2
T
Tnn F
F
exp1ln)( 00
0 Fv
EF
-PF PF
Only extrinsic carriers n are taken explicitly.Intrinsic ones, in the gap region, are hidden in the CDW amplitude A.
21
tAA
xA
22200
2
tAAAAA A
2
0
02200 ln)(2
zdnn
xs02 )(1
4
0
tn
tnj
;V
CDW stress vanishes at the boundaries:Natural for sides, for drain/source boundaries the no-sliding is implied
Boundary conditionsEquations
Normal electric field is zero at all boundaries: total electro neutrality andconfinement of the electric potential within the sample
No normal current flow at the boundaries except for the two source/drain boundaries left for the applied voltage. There, the chemical potentials are applied:
22
Simplified rectangular geometry assuming passive role of other parts
Phase: wider sample, higher V
Amplitude V=7meV, 9 meV, 11 meV; t~10-8 sec
Many vortices appear temporarily in the course of the evolution.For that run, only two will be left.
Time unit – 10-13 sec given by the inverse CDW conductivity.Here, t~100ps – 10GHz
24
Phase deformations energy - cannot relax fast enough following therapidly moving vortex.
Unexpected result: long living traces of the amplitude reduction following fleshes of vortices.
2
22
2)(yx
AW
Real geometry: initial short time fast dynamics, t=3.4x10-10 sec
Amplitude A
1
W()+W(A)
W()=0
A
Phase
Composite energy W()+W(A)
All these 5 flashes are the phase-slip processesserving to redistribute the CDW collective charge
25
Strong drop of the electric potential (with inversion !)and of thecurrent concentration.
Perturbations are concentrated near the vortex core – the location of tunneling processes.
Real geometry: final stationary state at the first threshold voltage
A
V=7-8 meV, t=10-7 sec
z
26
20110615V7.2.u+v.dnt.avi
Movie for a full multi-vortex evolution to the junction stationary state with just one remnant vortex
27
Distributions of the chemical potential zeta, electric potential phi, electro-chemical potential zeta+phi; lines of current.
28
I(V) and dI/dV,slits geometry
I(V) and dI/dV,rectangular geometry
29
30
Modeling of stationary states and of their transient dynamic for the CDW in restricted geometries is reachable.Model takes into account multiple fields in mutual nonlinear interactions: the complex order parameter Aexp(i) of the CDW, and distributions of the electric field, the density and the current of normal carriers. Vortices are formed in the junction when the voltage across, or the current through, exceed a threshold; their number increases step-wise - in agreement with experiments. A much greater number appears in transient processesThe vortex core concentrates the total voltage drop, working as a self-tuned microscopic tunnelling junction, which might give rise to observed peaks of the inter-layer tunneling . Parameters need to be adjusted – e.g. the conductivity increased.The reconstruction in junctions of the CDW can be relevant to modern efforts of the field-effect transformations in strongly correlated material which also show a spontaneous symmetry breaking.
Conclusions.
31
Conclusions II:Specifics of strongly correlated electronic systems :
inorganic CDW, organic semiconductors, conjugated polymers, conducting oxides, etc…
Electronic processes, in junctions at least, are governed by solitons or more complex nonlinear configurations.As proved by presented experiments and recent oneson charge ordered states, they can lead to :
• Conversion of a single electron into a spin solitons• Conversion of electrons pair into the 2 phase slip• Pair creation of solitons (tunneling and optics)• Arrays of solitons aggregates – dislocation lines, stripes, walls of discommensurations –
reconstruct the junction state and provide self-assembled micro-channels for tunneling;