After Modernity
Fall 2010
Outline
• Marx, Weber, Durkheim’s subject matter• Grand Theory– Science, structuralism, Principia, Taylorism, Fordism
• Contra-Grand Theory– Conflict– Self-contradiction– Incompleteness and impossibility theorems
• Post-modern Theories
From Pre-Modernity to Modernity
Tradition, convention, prejudice, superstition
Rational, calculation, universalism, innovation, science, planning, problem solving, systems, control, society
Scenes of horror, that we may never forget
From Pre-Modernity to Modernity
Tradition, convention, prejudice, superstition
Rational, calculation, universalism, innovation, science, planning, problem solving, systems, control, society
No foundationinternal contradictions
same as it ever was
Limits of Reason
• Social constructionism• Garbage can theory• Bounded rationality• Anxiety of influence (Bloom)• Bricolage
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bricolage)
Dichotomy ViewModern Postmodern
Necessity (natural and social laws) Contingency or chance
Universality (across time and space) Locality and the particular (can only know own experience)
Certainty and predictability Uncertainty and provisionality
Truth and reality Critique of tradition-bound analysis
Transparency or understandability Undecidability
Order of nature and structures Ambivalence of human design
After http://uregina.ca/~gingrich/a400.htm after Bauman p.398
Four Issues
• Identity• Politics• Differences• Reflexivity
After http://uregina.ca/~gingrich/a400.htm
Identity• From: social world can be modeled as “individuals in groups” with
both individuals and groups having stable “identity” – I/me, the Germans, women, the poor
• To: identity as not unambiguously defined, shifting over time, generally unstable. Local circumstances and experiences important in shaping these identities.
– Thus: class, ethnic groups, or status groups may not “exist”
– Theories based on them may not be useful
– Shared situation (class, race) may be construct imposed by theorists
After http://uregina.ca/~gingrich/a400.htm
Politics
• From: left-right spectrum, politics as collective action problem – who gets what when and how?
• To: Perhaps collective action, social movements, and directed social change are impossible.
– Radical relativism
– Everything is power
– Politics, since it assumes concept of “right,” is pointless
After http://uregina.ca/~gingrich/a400.htm
Differences• FROM: lumping and splitting• TO: rejection of “metanarratives”
– Reject grand theory, don’t try to explain all of society
– Focus on variety of experiences of individuals and groups
– Emphasize differences over common experiences.
– World is fragmented, disordered, unstable and not understandable on a large scale
– Interpret texts, but never impose your interpretation on others
After http://uregina.ca/~gingrich/a400.htm
Reflexivity• FROM: reflection (and reflection on reflection) can yield
knowledge/truth about the world• TO: reflection only reveals the conditions of itself
– Social science, philosophy, etc. created possibility of knowledge of social world.
– Models can represent the natural and social world.
– More and more it is difficult to distinguish images of reality from the reality itself (TV, sampling, marketing)
After http://uregina.ca/~gingrich/a400.htm
…full of sound and fury…
…and signifying what?
or
after all that, can we still do theory?
Embrace the Dualities
• Structure and Agency• Making history but not from whole cloth• Langue and Parole
Structure and Agency
Marx : “The Eighteenth Brummaire”
Man makes his own history, but he does not make it out of the whole cloth; he does not make it out of conditions chosen by himself, but out of such as he finds close at hand.
The tradition of all dead generations weighs like a nightmare on the brains of the living. And just as they seem to be occupied with revolutionizing themselves and things, creating something that did not exist before, precisely in such epochs of revolutionary crisis they anxiously conjure up the spirits of the past to their service, borrowing from them names, battle slogans, and costumes in order to present this new scene in world history in time-honored disguise and borrowed language.
Langue & Parole
• La langue is the whole system of language (spelling, grammar, syntax, vocabulary, etc.) that precedes and makes speech possible. Signs are the basic units of langue.
• Parole is the actual use of language, the practical utterances of everyday people.
Destinations• Giddens/Bourdieu
– Structuration – duality – fields – embedded agency• Collins
– Confict theory• POMO practicalis
– dialectics and tensions, sociology of knowledge, networks, global flows of knowledge and capitals
• POMO extremis– re-particularization, impossibility of theorizing
• Computational Social Science– Emergence, self-organizing systems
OUTTAKES
The structural in post-structural
• Everything depends on everything else• Presence of absence
All the words
not used
All the words
not used
word
Marx
• Capitalism is different• Us vs. them dynamic• “seeds of its own destruction”• dehumanizing
Weber