+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

Date post: 07-Apr-2018
Category:
Upload: ugur-oezkan
View: 218 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend

of 100

Transcript
  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    1/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    2/100

    AlwAys DIsADvAntAgeDIscrImInAtIonPrActIces In turkey:VIctIms and ProfessIonalsshare theIr storIesx 2 ii

    Ppad bfy s

    Iin tk tnj t

    taad f ti bh Kku

    edi f ti vi ak

    Pfci ty

    Ppaai f Pbiai

    Gz Gkgapi DiBu i

    Ppaai ad Pii

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    3/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    4/100

    contents

    P .....................................................................

    P s eii...................................

    diiii Pibii diiii .

    Viw equiy diiii .......................

    G diiii ..............................................

    sxu oii b diiii ...................

    diiii gi dib Pp .....................

    diiii gi ei, cuu, rigiu

    nGo cibui sugg gi diii

    dvp i f a i sugg

    diiii ...........................................................

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    5/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    6/100

    PreFAceti bk, pp by stGm iuig ub p i wi i i i ig i w i b bipubii i xp w iiii i i i u

    pi xi piip quiy wiig w i by bi u i p, i i y ugg gi.

    t ugg gi iiii i giig ip

    b wg pupp iiii wi gi i uu. f w iiui wiub iiui piiy wi iui p iiui pb u b x. a i

    v i i . aug iui iu bu ii .

    t ivi iy i vy iiv bu ii u ig i iiii i w . I ivi iy u b ipv

    pi, -gv gizi u v iv wi vy g piiv ii, ig gi iiii. hwv, i ivi iy gv ii, ugg gi iiii b w xp big giv

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    7/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    8/100

    PreFAce to the seconD eDItIofwig ib i wi i

    w i pubi i 2007 i ii i b

    w pp b ig pu u

    i tuky. a w iiiiv iu pu pb, iui izi p

    iii upp i p wk

    ppui tuky. nv, u

    i y gi i tuky y pp

    i ig , v pp v

    i i. ti iui wi y g i tuk

    y g ig g p

    kpig wi ii gi u ig.

    si i pubii i bk y

    v b i u iy by -gv pubii iu xp ui

    iiii pb w ip gup i

    cii.

    I i egi gug vi viw ppwi w giv i i iviw v b

    ii xpi v b giv i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    9/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    10/100

    DIscrImInAtIon AnD the ProhIBItIon ot pibii iiii1, g wi pb w i wiu y iiiu w i p bi g piip u ig. t pibii iiii i

    u ig big g pibiii gvi bw pp, iuig , u, iigi, xu ii, i u ibiiy i big pi iequ vy i wi wy. s iui qui i

    ii giv w pibii g-b iiii gi wg pi kig i u i g v pi .

    aig biig ipi ig ipibii iiii u b u i Pii rig Ui ni hu rigiiii i ib y ki ggi p wi pup upiip ig b u

    jy quy by iiviu wiu ii, u, x, gug, igi, pii igi, ppy, bi u2.

    aig i, jyig ig

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    11/100

    a biig iii iiii i giv Un Ii cvi eiiidiiii: i iiii xui, ii p b , ui igi wi pup uiyi u ig u i p

    uu y i pubi i4.

    t i i pi pibi by iw. I i uu i pi b :

    Direct Discrimination:

    ti i vub i iiviu bi pibi gu u , ibiiy.

    Indirect Discrimination:

    ti u w pi, u, qui i

    bu ip ippiy up piu iiviupi, u, qui ii i juii.

    Harassment:

    ti i uw uw u u wi pup viig p iiiig, i, gig, uiiig iv

    Denial of Reasonable Accommodation:

    ti u i i y

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    12/100

    vIews oF equAlIty AnD DIscrImt w pipi ui u i

    pi iiii giv i i p

    diiii i pipi i xi

    t p iiii xi i pipy, i i y. equiy i p igi

    y pi piu ip

    by i v ipv i i

    i p.

    t p quiy i uy i

    y b u i big. o

    i i i iuig iui w

    uy i. t i w xp

    v i, i, iquiy bw w

    I ii vp i

    pb quiy iquiy g. a x

    w, wi i xi i p. f x

    w w u g pb, wv,

    pp u ii w u, i

    pb, pp w ub qu b k qui quiy i w

    w uuy p. W y

    w . a w iquiy bw vp u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    13/100

    u iui. a wig i i quug i iv ig i

    quiy. I b ib

    quiy , wv, ig ib

    ipi w i p i p. sii

    viw quiy i pii . t

    qui i b i i i u

    igig quiy, uiii uig u

    ib uig i b quiy.

    The Idea of Formal Equality

    t i quiy i i i ai

    b i ig ik ik. ti

    p b ju, i ig

    i yu y y yu b ju

    iy. I w ig ik ik

    ai i yu ik jui i. I i ipiv,

    ju, qu b quy i i b ju,

    ii v b i ii wy. owi y

    b ju. t pb wi i pi qu

    ty b iu i u wy.

    t i pb i bu iig w w

    iui. aig i quiy

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    14/100

    pp i b qu p, juii. t i i pp pp u

    i w ii b iii

    t igi i i wi bk wi pp

    b igi, pii, v iii. f i

    i i v w g ppig wi

    . tu i i iu i p

    piu ig w p i gi

    i i i gizi u b i

    vi. t, i b i i pp

    gup ig i ppiv y u

    i iu i u w b k

    ig i quiy. cquy

    i iuii i iquiy bw

    a u pb u i gy evy iy y kwg

    iii, iii, gizi b

    iu vy iiviu i iy. f xp

    iii i iy. su uu viw i

    v i i u i ppiv. t w i by iy. h i

    i b i by iy ii.

    b piu igy i iy i g pi

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    15/100

    t i pb ig i quii pb. a i

    iu jui . aig ai

    , wv, i i iv piip. h

    ii iiy. t pb i

    ii ii by i b quiy

    Pp i ii ii wi iy b

    aig i quiy, i i ii

    by, i g pb wi pp. f i

    pp by i ju qu i y

    big bk. Pyig w w i

    ju ! o jig w xu i quy i jui (puy i

    quib iu). h i

    iu quizig b, i, , pp b q

    b.

    t i i pb i i quiy

    i i i p, i qui

    p w jug w w pp

    u p qui ig bi

    jug b b i gu. f xpig pyi g, yu ivi i

    , yu y y qu py

    i p i Jp y u k v

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    16/100

    i jug, bu i i u iui cuig u jug i u pbi

    i i ig pii pp i

    t pii pp i i iip w

    ii pp i iy, i pii,

    iy. h ii i i

    ii iui pp

    Gy, pui uui

    g i. tu pii w i g

    ii i qui i. ti i ju

    Upp iui iiui b ijuii y, ui . evyig

    jug, .

    t u pb i y w

    quiy. aig i pp b w i. I yu i iui

    wy. I w pu wk

    b pi . hwv u pb i

    i qu . I p

    i iy i i !

    The Idea of the Equality of Results

    t uig quiy i pp

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    17/100

    pii, wi i wy i i pu i i i i u viw iy w

    ti uy i b i pi i

    ii. d u i y i

    ii ui. o quiy u

    i iquiy b ju. f i

    w u wk b pi b p

    I quiy qu i py

    u i v i i ig b

    pyig up wk quy wiu iig

    auy i pi. ti pp

    pb i pig i. t i, xu

    y w i b quiz. ty

    i giiy i big

    quiz iig qu ii

    xp i i i i wi i viw pi ppyig jb pig piu

    I i quiy qu w

    iquiy quiy. s pi

    b y i pb vui y i w pppi qu wi b

    i jug gi. t u, u, y

    iui: i u piu p

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    18/100

    si i i i b viw pp u ppuii u b vib g

    u . t w yp ppuii

    ppuii , pu ppuii, pp

    I pu ppuii i i pi w

    pu quizig ppuii i

    vy ig xii. a i

    i y iiii vy

    p i wi v w

    quiz i pu , u

    t quiy ppuii i bi

    ppuii pp. Pu quiy i

    ii u b quiz i u

    ib. I b b jy quiy,

    x bu y u b pvi qu

    giv qu x bu i ii quwi qu ppuii x uk

    i, w w i wu

    v i w p x.

    ciuig wi xp xii: xbu w i ib p g upi w

    h pu quiy i vi. t iv

    p u b k u ib p u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    19/100

    Y xi i w v b qu. B i qu

    quiy u, v i i qu

    y p vu. hwv, i iu

    i i ui. f i i tuky, vi

    cu ig quiy iy b i

    i pi i i quiy i vy w

    ciui cu ivi v wi ig u

    u i gy, i qui w

    quiy wii . ti i p qui

    w w gup iquiy i. t c

    w x; wv, juiik iiiiv i iu. f i eup

    (echr), i i vi, i i

    uquy i gi piip quiy.

    Some Causes of Discrimination

    diiii i iu u w u b

    p i b gizi iiii

    u uig p iibui

    i gizi. tu iiii i pu

    iv i uii; bu i i puiiii i bu, i, i i iy i

    i i u uii i y pu

    g pui. t i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    20/100

    iiii by pig piip quiy bubu i viw. aig ii

    quiy i w iiz. f x

    qu i y iiz, , y i

    . l i ai G igi gi

    i i i pi viw. rigi ip

    piuy i i igi quiy b

    big up i ik pig uiig

    uiy. rigi, , i vp i

    uqu pi w w

    igi. f , i pi

    piz.

    Direct and Indirect Discrimination

    t i g iii iiii; i

    i i u y i i iiii. a ig

    i ig b i iy. I ig b viy, . di iiii i pp

    iii by i iiii v b

    w ii, u ugg gi i

    i iy, i i iiii,

    ii iiii b pv i, ii iiii i pibi

    piig giv i

    pi. t i, y b w i i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    21/100

    pu i pi. h i i pi bg iiii, xp, kig u

    pp i pyi pp yig

    i wk, i i iiii. I w

    u i u vy y, i b

    i i iiii. a iu i viiizi.

    w ugg gi iiii puig i

    i iiii.

    suggig gi iiii i uy

    pjui i iy, i y b iiu pu gi

    , w i uu pu iy, ip bu u b vp bw.

    i qui igii, i iu iy,

    iiii by uig piiv iu. I y

    k p i.

    abu tuki i b , iy

    iu i g x, iui w. I

    b ibiiy, g, g iiy y

    y. oy iiii gi ib b

    P c. nv b pu

    I tuky 87% ib v

    ui upy i gup i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    22/100

    genDer DIscrImInAtIondiiii gi w i i y

    ii bi x wi

    uiyig gii, jy xi b

    i i u, bi quiy

    u i pii, i,

    i. a i qu u.

    Yk ek, w pi ppu i tuky

    p p ui6. s

    vii ik vy, i ig, gi, i iy, i i uiv pi

    g iu uiy. G iquiy

    u i iviizi. f i,

    eig, J Jqu ruu, wu v

    i wi u w : I i bviu w ig i iy bu u iy

    bg igi iy. a qu wi

    b iby g i vu g

    by iiviu iv w i

    f i b pib, g pii i g quiy i pubi piy, ig eu

    xiig ii g wk pi

    u ig w, w i u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    23/100

    big, p, u v u by i w

    b p piv i iy pivy u,

    u ig ugg. mv, i w u

    vi gi w w iqu

    uig u vii

    i w kp big pi i ; i

    by piv . ti pi w ugg ii w v,

    w i wy, bu iiii

    u b ii w i i

    rig c i Vi i 1993 (

    20 uy vi gi w u g pi gv. t cvi e

    diiii agi W (cedaW), wi w

    w w ig, w pug i 1979 wi

    Y, iig vp i 1980,

    iiyig vi wi iiii i G pib iii vi

    w qui iu i iig vi gi

    cedaW p.

    I G ri n.19, p i 199i ib iiii iu

    ig by w qu

    iiii iiii iu

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    24/100

    p y, jy g pi

    quiy wii iy, ig wk i b

    pygiy y, pppi ii.

    Vi i iy i iiiu

    w b i ii. Wii

    xp vi, iuig bigxu k, pygi vi

    ii u. lkig ii

    vi iip. fbiig w uk

    i iy by b vi

    vi, w puig i iv ik, wkpiip i iy i i quy wi .

    tii iu b i

    y pii i i y v

    pi vi u i iy. t pjui pi

    giiizig g-b vi wy pi

    i i pyi pyg

    iii by w k kwg i

    bi u ig . t pi gi iui y pii w

    piipi i pii, ui py.

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    25/100

    aig

    8

    , b w vy, iquiy i pubi p p

    p, . pi u i pi y

    iu iquiy y i ii

    ig ii w piv

    wi iy p. I iviw x

    The existence of a statistical equality does not mean mu

    in an awareness of differences is not enacted in a countr

    can spend a large part of her life ensuring that her

    sending her husband neatly dressed to work, doing a

    housework, and she can receive thanks and appreciation

    the same time she can feel that her work is undervalu

    situation when a womans husband dies, or she leaves t

    of violence, or she desires a better life. Since she wa

    home and except for her immediate neighbourhood, she

    by which she can find work. Hence the possibility of s

    life is left at the mercy of her childrens or relatives

    hand a woman can live her whole life without any su

    again she would not enjoy the opportunities that life and

    Spending her life constrained within a house deprives h

    and the opportunities for self-development. This can ofhidden form of discrimination. Even when a woman ha

    constructed in a way that she is confined to a very narr

    of prestige, career, or income. The roles of women in p

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    26/100

    . ti i qui bu g w u u upi ii uu.

    w w w w i i i i

    g ip by iy. s w ivi

    ui g

    bu y i u w w w

    iiii i iuy ivv i p

    iiy. W i gi kik g w

    i ju pp, uii. s i

    , ugi ig bviu

    piy p w w u

    bgiig.

    n y w bu i i g

    i wy piy i y u y w

    bu, piy, i pi pig g

    xu w bg i uu. I u , v ii

    iu i iv uig. i

    piu g ui igu . t

    i u iy, ig, pk.

    i i iy, b wii uu it gi i g i y

    i wy i i pii . W u b j

    igy pp ub u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    27/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    28/100

    i wi vp w gi. f

    w w i pii ii kig

    u b , gv py gy

    w upp i w pii. ty i

    ipb u pii by wig

    w v b uu. ti ppg i

    w i ivi qu i uiy

    o , gig p iui

    tuky i b y iv g

    Ii, Kui, tuki, ., vk

    i u b i 80. I, y i 90, uu i big bui, i w

    kwg u by big

    t w uy iui i y 2000

    by i iu p 80 w

    i ii wk pp i u pii i i iu p v i tu

    i g y yi i

    pip w bi b b k p

    pb i tuky ug piiizig i v

    iiii ii i py iu w v. s w,

    iii v, bg g w

    i pi i ii pi

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    29/100

    igi, y gu

    ty g p vuii i p

    w gig pii, u u

    pi, pip iy b bk. ti

    tuky; ii iu w i i v

    piu i iu.

    t ui quiy pii wy p

    piv p xp i pii eu

    i kp p piv p i w

    hwv, wiu iiig iquiy piv

    qui v i pubi p, ii pii u i i i pubi .

    si pii i g i wi i u gv

    pw, g pubi i i k w p

    t pwu wi gv y wi i y i i. W k i b

    iy i. I , w ug

    i w p i ig g

    qui. fi w gizi u b

    u v g ik wi i iy wgi xu. ti i u ,

    b g w ig wi w u gy

    W wk pw b wi y

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    30/100

    Wi i bi wy iiig i

    y xp iiiiv pii,

    . gi w, i pib ug pii p

    u i b y i wy, ,

    pip. Y, ui b w

    ugg i u b bi

    quiy.

    The cycle of violence continues

    Uuy i g iiii b

    iv, , w w u

    iviib. o bi iii y puwiig ui pii piii

    i y i wi vi wii iy b

    wi i i i uy ai giv b

    pig y vi i iy, b

    b by ub i ug i bai vy igiiy: ti y vi

    t y ai, 42, y i u, bu i i

    b i u igbu, i u bk, v

    g-bi k u pi g. a iy, w b i dik i mi v

    wy y ig. s i i q

    i, i i i gi, bu ukiy

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    31/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    32/100

    w . I i gv i i bu

    bk . I ig k wy I

    I giv i i bu bu

    yig w I w i bk. si

    ik by i. t y I i y I w

    wi y b b. h gu wi

    h w b. W I uy, w I k bk

    b bk i xp

    t y w uig pi i. my ub

    i v. I i y, i w ug, y gu

    I u v g i. hw u g ... vyig

    y bu u i

    i. t i iv ii

    iv big I w i y ig i

    gu u upp y i iv bu iy i

    u ug, i y g, I i

    wy I u gi ig bu

    wy w g i ig

    y. s I iv ig. I iv wi . I v jb k y

    y ub i bu i w

    . h w p. h

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    33/100

    my ug g i w w 22

    . su I y i i , I kw,

    pu I u . I wi y

    ig. s b i ix ,

    kw w wi i. I i. h

    s i pg b yig wi .

    I wi k i. t y i y ug y iv, I gv

    u u b ik . tk g y i i

    y xpi ig wi vi

    g w wi i wi. h y

    iv bu vi! h kw w u i w iiy , y w

    ug xpi vi, i

    v bu i wy ik

    y w uig

    i i i xp vi. h ubw pg, kik jw w i

    , y i pg i u

    w ix wi k. s i i ik. a

    y. s i ju y

    ik 60-y-. nwy, ju. W vyw. my p

    y i uiy. my w

    g. tugu i i b xp

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    34/100

    sexuAl orIentAtIon BAseD DIsc

    Piy wk w kpig iig giiviu w vi i xu ixu big up, ik pv. t iiviiiiiv pi by i gup,

    i w / vi i u wiibi pi /i xu ii ui

    I i wb pg ribw gy gizi y ii g viw xby ii px bigi, pygi

    u y g. r w pg i g xuiy xu i. I gi i wi xuiy i g i i gii pu xu.

    sxu ii-b iiii i pi giv ig, iu bviUuy, pbi xi y wii piy g piy. h wkig w i i xuiy pbi iu i p i p:

    W mui i. I tuky ikw w. W kw wi uk bby, wi ,

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    35/100

    W pp iiu bj, mpbi i big iiuiiz. I jG B miiy cu dp i xuiy i pyxu iug i uig i ig iiuy bj xu bu iiz bu wi i

    xuiy i i p. t iiy y iiy vi bi pyxu i w xu wi w wy vi. ti w i vi pubi bji iiy vi. t wig iviw w

    i by Ggi

    12

    :

    o 8 api 2005 I w i Izi ui i tk, siv miiy cui u I w k siv miiy Pi iiy pi y

    y xuiy. I y i I I w xu pgig iu y gi i i i b i irgui tuki a f (tsK)

    ii u iuig p p, , ubivby, pgp vixu iu. o u, I j ii i u xu

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    36/100

    iiii, pjui, ypi jug i iy i i i ppi wi i i xu iii. Ggi uib y pb xu bu i jui .

    aig Ggi, pjui iu gib k ubj i 1970 by i i pygy. I i puizi pb i p w u iiviu pgy i i ii

    xuiy. hwv, y pbi g ii bi, piig igup ppii u p uu iiui i ii.

    hpbi b igy ig

    iu by p (piy, ppuu, .) p, p by puizui gup pi by piu yp pp by i iiviu ii,uu x. dpi i i uu

    p, y ipygi ik pbi i wi i xi. hpbi, i wp xi. Vi gi pp w v xuiy i big i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    37/100

    iy u big gup i u,

    uy upi y w ybi i.

    a p i ppi pigy i i igup iip, i

    bi u xpi i gup. t i iii ig ii b bk y 1950. hvig bi iii piy vig pjui iy w i uiy. ei

    bi wi pjui iu uig giiv : bi ig u ibi, wi g b i wi ugig quii wi ui iiiiv igy y w u iiii, bu i iiviu b

    gup i p bi ig p buiig iiy gup iiii. hxuiy b ii xuiy iip i . a ipygi p

    iiii gi xu bu y iy wi i ip. diiiipjui ypi jug gi ibg vig, w i y

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    38/100

    xu iiy i tuky. I iui Gu, u

    iiii xu xp i tuk

    W w iu g uv w ibpvi i p big[xu] i v iiui i

    py u i iiii bui iiii i y i. oiy igizi i tuky w gyIi (aI) b i y i iiu w pp b

    y xuiy pb. f i wig, w pp b w wig up ig gv y piipbu xu, i . tw ivy iy wy W, Uu, w w giI y vy u, w

    bu , bu bu pp ig pu i pii i k w w v i pb! w y pb; y v pb ww ig ii y. I w

    iig i, wi I guy , i ig xuiy. o p w w bu xu Bu i i p I

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    39/100

    xuiy iu? f i xu

    . W xu pp, ik / i bu

    su ig pp bu I biv y v y b i ug

    g v u v iy bu I uiy bu I kw gy pby u xpi. f y I bijui i y xuiy bu I k ug y xuiy wu u pb i vi. I ju ig bu i p-by yty w i y xuw u .

    auy i i uy iui wi .

    xuiy ui y p i I wpyii ig i w bu I w b wi y xuiy ui, w I i v w pI kw y gg. a ig

    I ji u gizi uiviy bu pp w y i. Bu dp si svi hpwik gg uig i I

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    40/100

    p ig i b i

    i. W b vii ii bu, y k qui i i wkw i bgi.

    I w vy uiviy. ev i I w i

    i w I w i . I w vy i b . I i ii pi i y . I pb wiI b i i b I avi15 i. evy i16, pp u k i i w a

    t w , wi ipi I w wk wi gi, gi uiviy, v i iu ug i w . my egi iu g w

    y ik , w y g. s, b iuW I i yu b xp wy. I g w wi vy w pii xu w pii

    p uig pii I upy. I qui ik y wk bu w ik y iiy i y u i iy i v

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    41/100

    i xuiy u b p

    I k i w . f ixu b , u pk tu pk egi? ti i uy xu w w i, w y py uki pp w

    pi xpi quiii. tx wk w bu i xpi. W ik i w wi pj ixp i g pj g. f i g i f lgug liu. Wi K Gl i piu ii w piui y , wi u uii bw K Gl i p xu ; w y b

    b w y wk wi . t guui big bw u. hwy ug i u i w piwk. t pp w u i y bg wi .

    W ig ugg gi iiiw w pp p w vu i i iui iv y g, I w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    42/100

    I wu ik i yu w w

    by nGo. f i, w pb hd (hu rig aii) bu pwi iiui uu hd; i w iii i w y b xpiwy xu wkig i cii

    lbi i ak i hd, w wkig i cii W righd w big p y x w w xp iiiigii i pig ivi iy i tuky xu ig. my igiy iv

    pup, gi viy i ppv u pp u i g by. Bu w iu u i hd. ty p i u i ig gy pp i tuky.

    I 2001, i giz iig pp gi w pb i ak ip pi i u gW w k ii ppy i Yu u i wk

    uu hd, yu u w i v y i iip wi y uu u bu hpb wi gizi bu u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    43/100

    ejyig ivi vi i qui. G

    iui pi wy bu I ik u ig. f i, v i I b i wk, i I ppy jb y i. I v ii y wk I u b piy quii

    wv I g y xu iiy wi i yu b ivi v, wv yyu , yu xu iiy i ib ub. t i wy yu i v y yu xu ii u yu p ii

    I v b ivig wi y byi y y byi pi pi iy w gui, i i w b i. byi u vii i

    iv. t pb ik bu t ig ipi y i. myu xpi. W vi i p vii i.

    W u i p pig ww v u x p w w bup u ikig w w uiviy 40 i byi 36, y v b iv

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    44/100

    pb; i y ubi i p, i

    w ui i ig y pv ipppi iu ib i tuky wi pp wi vi. W yu pubi pi yyu , v u x

    i yu ii wi b u vi i u i xu ig pi bu y uuy u bwi b xp iiii bu y ug i. si xu i xp iiii i iiui bu i y, , w g bu w gup i p

    W v y iiuy i iig u u gy b wu ik upp

    xp iiii. W ik w i pib y by vig pb b iz. W u k gup pyig i u pb.

    Always Disadvantagedhy t, ub pp wiig i xu ii, iv i G, bi, , u b viib i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    45/100

    w x. s w i uv uu wi

    i uii i b xp uv. I w yu big wy ivg.

    t piz iiiiv p

    bi i xu iy. lbi uby w y v b i iuu xu-i iiii. aig tpp ubj i pgpy i pub bi ig big upp. t

    ai u b pi i pbs pu ik pi b xu bu u xu p bi v i i vy iiu ii bu bi x. [I tuk

    bi gy i p. tyxu iv i ig i i i g u g, y v ii ppjb, y y b b i i p. ev i bi w i

    ii uiy, big bi b ii vi, i big, x. I wu b i b v gtuky i wi u wy i i b

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    46/100

    j ; i u bu

    pi by jig i. Pp b ppi xu ii i iv y b i [i p] .

    aig t, bi

    pp i Gy i igy i . s i ivy ib i u v p . s vg k i ig y iv wp iui i tuky. t i upi/w v u i v, piz pi gy i jb ppii ig b j bu i Gy wk wk bu /i xu ii. f i iu ig k u g

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    47/100

    DIscrImInAtIon AgAInst DIsABDiscrimination against any person on the basis of disab

    inherent dignity and worth of the human person.17

    dib18 pp wy giiz g

    fig y igu ib pp piii iy i. t iviibiiy pp

    ip i g u ib

    i i g xui

    xp viy u big. t ui

    y w i i pp ip w g ub vii w ib

    gv w ib w iy

    ii g wi Jw, xu, gyp

    i pu i iy hi Gy.

    Igig ib pp igig

    pp ig. s ubgup ib pp,

    i ib b vk. I i

    ivi iv ib i ik, ui

    w. dib w vii ub wi ibiii gup v

    v i y ii.

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    48/100

    i pi by xui, ii, uig u

    ivg, uppig pppi uig bypx, iig i jy i, i

    qu , qu pi

    gig, ig, pjui, wg u

    iiii gi ib pp i pi

    py, gig, pi, uu i vi.

    h i y ixy--y- , w

    b v, w gv bi u i w

    u b ipp. ti i y iu gv pi iiii g

    w , s, w u ypu i

    v by i i. s y,

    I u g y u s iy, w i hp hpi. W

    y i, y vi

    ug, ix y s

    u pib. I quy i

    vy i w u, I g up. m

    pp by bu w y w y

    y ju p u. I w u

    vy w yig i bu

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    49/100

    i wi ii ik i i uuy

    iy bu w i u ik . I b iy p i iui, i p

    y p i p k

    ii ib i, yu wi

    y iy I k i bu; I y yig

    ui I ii . I w cc i diybk s ui,

    g. t w w pi u

    diybk w y w ui

    tuky. I w mp cuig r

    w I u u y i; I w y g iiz I

    u y w y. W w v w

    ii piy i u i i

    w . I u p u i

    i w bu i g

    ci b u. I w y ig

    s w u vy u. I I

    v b v w. o w

    i; I i iy

    i yig v pp y . I w w

    u b xp y ig y by

    bu pp ui. t w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    50/100

    i i Gy, u i

    iy; y u ig i pbigy. tuky i qui ixpi i

    I g s bkbiig w u ipv i u ki. t

    upp u gu jb i miiy cuu. f ix y pyig i y, I ppi pubs. t w 3% qu pypubi vi. I wi i G y wk pii ib

    t pii w p s s wi bu u i ig u vyig. h p w w i w. I g s pp i w w vu i g I i g ug ik i gvi ig g jb I w ws jb, w b ivi wk i biig wkp ou g ip w i bkbii b . s ii g u

    i xp w g g ui vy w v i. f i, w y I v b g g bu g wk. W

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    51/100

    I v b wkig wi aii

    Pp i 1993. W w g i. t i wy eg wi p gv buiig. I ui yu t bu e ii i. I w givby gv gii y[ ui ib i]. nw I ii . I wk i i i p- ii. I 2001 i diybk. I w ig ivvy iy wi ib i

    vii vy p buiig, ib i i i. ii giz w u. auy uuy i i i, y w y uuy u. t i wy y bu y i y I iy u p i i ii

    I i y ywy; p iub iy, i v b u b i ii

    . t , u b, u i pp t k pibiiy w. Yu vyig by yu; b

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    52/100

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    53/100

    v g iiui bu pkig b

    ui iy. I i pb. si pp v iiui i y i ig.

    Fed up with making excuses for others

    Uuy s i i w y, i w i . I s i w y, w w ikigy. h i y ti, b i 195w w bby; i p u

    I gu s mi ak U

    ipwi. I ug piyii wI i g y ib p buy iip wi y i i y jxpi, wv, i w i ii bv i i wy u by . I w uky, ug, v u

    ik i. my p v vu y by iu i gu iipiy a u ibv i u i w gp. si w iiii i I i i.

    iy. W yu yu b i pp iii gi yu ig g yu giv .

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    54/100

    t w p pyipy. I b

    pyipy. I u iui w quiu b pyi wiib bu i i iy ibqui iig wi .

    my i piy w ubg w giv jb gig y Id,i bu . my g g y Id iiy i I w gi iiy vi. tu, w i p y bi gii

    pb i gii. ti w b bi i I i v y y ui, I i pby piy . h u k bu i y I k i

    i. W I g u wi u i w . Ppui vy i wy yu quk. my i u b y by u b w w.xu ! Pubi i ig

    u y uy w uiv wk I u y g upi wi g ui bu w wk k xu ji y

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    55/100

    w i w gii ib p

    pi vi pubi iiuwk; b ib i xpiv. t b w yig u y

    Ju ik gv, ivi iy w i pibiii ib pp ii bu I biv I vii ii I w i w w pyig oky. I y b i ipi y u ii

    m u b g ig t i g i uiipiy up v ug i g.y wy w Biv , I i yu. W u y, Yu b

    , bu I w xpi vig ig bi , i p , u v k y v i m wW I bug up pi pi W i g

    upp ig bu y p pp uy g pu gup, ii, , piii y h piii I k

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    56/100

    W I v y p, pv

    wiu p. I kp ig wk y d w i tk yu vy u bu I u p. Yu b wy . Ju b b p wiu p. nw y p y p bp . a u gui gv py i i y wk. a ui bi wiu y guig i. s iv u u b

    piu gui bu i I u y [tuki] pp w gwW u p i pjui vipubi i g ii iu iy.

    nw i ig piy vu y bu y ip yu wgy u yu . t i i ip wi vu ypiy. I v v ; i i I

    piy y. a y i, v ppy y v w ib bu. Yu giv u g wi yu b b k

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    57/100

    o I ppi pii i p

    u u w bu bviuy i jb bu I wi gii

    uig iviw, iviw,i iiui, , Yu v p

    wk, w wi giv yu pi vi

    i yu viw ppiv yu pkh w, I i u y viw bu I i iiui, I i, I

    ip w .

    iiui. I w i i iqu p

    i v b by xpig i ui. mv, i I g yw

    y wi gy k . o u

    w giv.

    I w y iviw; p

    uig y iig pi w p i p i iiui. W tV pg, gv y . I i

    ou g yu w w

    p p Yu g

    bu i i yu w i gig wk wi , pp w

    wk wi ig w wi iu

    w I w wk vi bu

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    58/100

    pi i vy . W I

    iy y w ju b . t p bi

    Bu i i wpp vi i pppi iii i .

    I iy I y v by xi. Bu g . I y up yiui yu g up. l y wbu y ub w iv piz i k i iy, wi w u b ub k. W i v

    i . I k bu i xkig wk w u ; 400 tuki li. I I g p u y. o u i I Yu u g , I w wi yu,

    u xpi w quy w w tuki aii (thY) i w wi ik ay. t w 20% iI k i iu i vi yy w buy ik bu pvig y ibiiy. I w pi 110 t

    I w iiu xpi y pbi thY. I k i y w y g

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    59/100

    wu k p wu i

    b vi k ik i, i iy! W I w k p w I wupu i -w i i up byv. si p w ug i y wi. ty -w

    -ib p wu y b b bw k i p u wi. Wwi u p ug i uy u. I w pw i b bu i w is y ub b y b

    k . I w w i bw. t i u, P ik pg w . I w ug. fiy w b p. Bu u y wi g y w w

    . t qui ig ib pp, k wy. my ub y y w y wu i ib p y ju y ig by i ub wi bu i w w i

    Yu kw iiii gi bk ppik bk p i tuky. hwv, I I v ig v vyik i i i a k a

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    60/100

    DIscrImInAtIon AgAInst ethnIc, cultur

    mInorItIes

    ti p bk wi i uu

    gup i tuky. ei, uu igiu ii

    g u igi i! t

    g iiiiv pi b vig igiu uu gup i tuky w

    gup igiu iii iv g.

    The name Muharrem spoils everything

    mu k, w b i 1968 i avi wgup i tuky wi w pi i bi

    gu h Bk Vi cuu aii. h

    iiy w wy i ppii p

    j. k xpi iiui

    i i iy i i tuky:

    I u g jb. I ppi Bota bu

    ug I pppi quii, bu

    ty i iy w

    i w wk Yu i m

    vyig. f I u g

    w i, by gi. W I u

    I wk i uu ii w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    61/100

    v i y avi iiy. my wi

    u pb bu i y i w w uigbu. W I w v ig I

    w bu i wy.

    I 2003, w y ug w i u g

    . Wi w uu u pp py. W

    k u ug bu u jb Bk cuu aii. t u v

    i i. W I w y ug

    ppi wi piip I w

    k i w i x. t I i

    i x, u v i y i

    v b i bu ig. a w i xp iiii bu I

    f , y b i iy ug g i ubj rigi

    p p i gy i ig. t y gv g

    Wi uuiv i pviu w

    w by , i w 4.00. t I i . s p . nw i i v g. W

    i i u uuiv w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    62/100

    I tuky i pubi uy, vy

    y ik, b i avi xu; vy xu ii. W wy gi i

    si, Gypi. I w gy w y

    hxuiy vp , i b

    i xu ii i wy. Ju ik

    gu bw ub wi, bw gy up.

    Of course we live separately

    Kpig i i y k i

    iii bi i w gup, i w Yuu aayi uiy y g ig,

    uig iiy vi v i i

    gi igiu iii i tuky:

    I w b i miy i 1964. I v b w

    cu i 1993. I v ix i. I

    ayi. I w ppi cu i

    W I w i miy I u u igi

    y uiy. o u, b

    pubi . nw pb

    b i p, ju pb. f

    I iv y

    iu by w w ig

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    63/100

    wkig pp. ayi u

    ayi wk i u miy. o b w iy up u

    pi ivig i i uy y u

    Y, w w xp vi, yu u

    w , u u bu w v y uuy g I

    y w w pp u

    i I w viig iui. s iv

    u y. W i kw y

    igbu. ty w ww kig. t u b i u

    k i i w u,

    G. t g

    ig ik, Yu ii. I wi u yu i

    w I iv I u by i syi

    . W I g b

    i p. t w

    pi i tbz?19 I i

    I y i pi iy y yu. I

    k wy w ig ik . t k

    ig Iq ik . I i I v igI i w y b u. By y

    Wi w w guig w wy puig i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    64/100

    gu wi . a I w i

    bu ii wiu i I k pi. ty i

    piv uiy gu bu y u

    uy v uvi y bu pxp, w y g u uvi

    bu w vg. t w uky bu u w bk vyig. W k y

    u i G. W iv w iv puy

    g k w iv g pu

    w ig w k i. t

    igbu k bw i w y . ou i u

    w pyig ui. tk uiipiy

    uy. ou i w py

    abu wy y g w I w ig y w b g w p w, I u b g bu I w

    ayi i eup w v v g

    xp, swi eui mii. W,

    b y i iiy viI ppy wi . ou pi w b

    I bu i w b,

    gi I bu w w u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    65/100

    ou i p vy. f xp, i

    w wi p u w i i. W w Bib w

    wi w pp. I i igi

    v w w i uy,

    k p iy. I u u

    pp w w vi i wiv bu i i w wiu .

    We do not expect anything from the state

    t iiuy big cii i tuky b u

    w a Gv, piiu

    cii xp iiiiv p

    bu by i y

    , wi i upp b jug i iu

    p igiu iii [i tuky] y v u i ig

    ik i i b iii gi b

    y y up i y g

    bi y y xp i ig by wi

    iy. Gv y:

    I w b i 1965 I v wy iv i diy

    I K i b I k

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    66/100

    I u Kui bu I pk

    tuki. t pp i uiw. ty p i i w y. W

    pb.

    auy I p i igi, igiy I w

    p igi Ju ci. o u, wI i v iiui bu y igi

    pb i i i iv bu

    ty . I iv ug

    ig , i wv i piy

    g, w v pb bu i . t

    rbk, i e, s i ig

    svgi. t w y

    yug i v pb b

    wi i i u y cii.

    ii y iu. t

    i y g up. f i, y

    pi by i i. t

    i i u uiy v

    W i v pb wi . Yv ig p igi . hwv

    bu y bu I

    b t i b

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    67/100

    b . t i yug b u

    w. I i bu pp g u w g uiviy bu wkig i pubi i

    xii, piy i uiy iiui

    vi u w ui. W xp y

    W yu y yu cii yu gig, .g. ai, Jwi, eup

    pp v iv puy wi mui. t

    pi i

    i , I pi u, Yu i,

    i, p i ; i i pi y

    wk . ti uy i

    y p vy, pi

    pp, y u w pp

    by vy i-cii ppg

    w xi.

    l wk P Zkiy Byz20 i i

    ji, i w ib, , G bug

    bug h, y v y

    gv U tV pg v pi b ,

    K hig v p i . t

    k m i! h i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    68/100

    uk -mui! h i

    v wi piu uk. I y yig -mui! t fiy

    by i qu bu i i b v

    98% ppui tuky i mui;

    cii i iig 2%. W

    i uy, w v ii iv; u bi.

    evy Wy w g Bib

    ig y. W w

    i w u. o ubu i bviu i bviuy u

    i.

    t y i ui y

    i u uy bu w yu k

    yu wi i ju pg w

    u iu iig ciiiy w i

    g. t i u Jui. o u

    i ii i. t i wy

    b iu i ii ju w

    W v b pig ug vy iiu

    i bk u wy. W

    w big i pp i b

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    69/100

    w big i pp i b

    oy b . W ww w u b ii. B

    ii, w u. W pp

    ik yiu buiig w wi

    i ig wi u. t u

    W u b k , v pbuiig. W w wi u

    w ? t w u pp. W

    w b i pi wy, w w

    pp i y p

    y. W w u w buiig i wi

    I w yu by xi. I yu k

    v k W i cu diybk

    pbby b Wy yu gig u

    , g ! o w

    w Wy yu gig u

    u i p p i

    u g i viw i pi. lw

    pb bu w y i

    w.

    miiy ivii ibu wi

    iiy; yu wi iiy i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    70/100

    diiii gi cii i tuky i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    71/100

    diiii gi cii i tuky i

    i i tuky. t i iiii i pig piy , n

    gv, y pi P

    s u igiu ivii w i i p pi e

    pu u pu gup i w p iu py. a iy iiy by i ju

    t i iiii i i i: u b g p

    wi y xpiig bi bi, wi i ju i by [tuki] iyiu viu yp ppg. o iii, ig pu ki

    jui iig y v ug b , y i jb, , w y v w i iiy i igi y jug, py, ivi v.

    cii u v k igiu ig , y g iby bu i w igi i i. a y ug

    x i i g. I u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    72/100

    g

    u yig. W k w u pi w y ug i

    cii u y iiui

    iig jb. t w pp i u

    uiviy. t ii i y

    y u i v p ci

    ty w piy uiviy i

    iuu ivigi bu w

    i Pd wu b p

    iu xiy.

    cii ivig i tuky i vi

    t i wy y wiw i i . c

    iiy : d y yig,

    ub, t ig iu i,wi ig pi bu i bi i

    i vy i b i

    pp; y xu. t uu a

    bwig u 22 P

    ji igi g ig bwcii w i v

    gup. t uu u. Yu

    u pibiiy xp ig

    bi. I viu ii u ii w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    73/100

    u nGo u wk .

    a qu u bi i i u

    iiii. nv, vy w g

    u uu. I i, wv y,

    w iiiiv. my iu gi iy i u i i wg. ti i

    b g y iu. I iy i

    i , ui upvii

    iiii. t pubi u b u b

    vii u b ug k i ig

    xi i b ipp y

    t y vii u b . dii

    u b bug u.

    The painful memory of having my toy horse torn out of my

    mii Viii y i kig wi w i k i vy

    ib pi i i i

    xp iiii. Viii, w w b i

    bv y [i tuky] giv pp

    gup bgig vig pw. t i Viii w xp vi vig p

    i bu w Gk igi.

    w u x vi u w u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    74/100

    pig wpu i p. p w y ugy. t

    kig w p w

    i u p w vi. ty k y

    pu i gu k wy b. t

    p, iuig b, pu . W y w kig y i

    p , i u i,

    yu uky i i b,

    y ak23. Yu uky

    k bu p v.

    I tb, Gk y tu

    t w y Jwi y iv

    Kuibi. my tuki qui

    u v v ig vg

    u pk Gk i u igbu. m w mui abi w pk

    I w Gk piy ay

    ui. s y i I w

    i u gi bu G di u . I ii Zy hig s

    vg v u u I

    t b xpi u w I w vii

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    75/100

    u i Gk wi u Gu, ti i uy ii

    gug ii! W w pi, , s, yu ig, I

    pp. h w, hw I p ?

    p

    24 i k uy.

    a I wk jui i xi y i Kuu. I wk

    1975. my b w Jwi Gk iiz

    I w G i 1975. a i Py

    miiy.25 h w gi Gk i giig u G wy!

    . I wi w Pyi

    w i iiy wpp wi i. t I wii

    eb. I w i-i-i i wky gup Gk iu. I 1964 I w

    ppg ipi i uiy wdz26 gv I w g wi b

    141, 142 163 tuki P c. m

    piu p w Gk. Uii b pi. t u w

    w qui i i pi. my

    qu pi bu i qui

    i i ub wy bv, I wi i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    76/100

    I u i y wy wi y w tuki wy w

    I y. W I w u g bu y i

    pgiz i b

    yb wg, I kw. n tuki bu i wu b ik y.

    f iig iiy i iub

    iiy. hwv, i u u ub. p ti Bb w, yug pp

    o w I w wi tuki gii u pi i. a ig y ii

    w Gk i 500 li. a i w 400 li.

    o iv y i w b y i iv, . h

    f bg pigiu iy

    yig tuki gi u

    bu iy i bu

    iy ug y i k y gy I pp bk i i i

    I wu v u . t , I f xp I

    bk ii. t igi p w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    77/100

    j i i ppii igu, .

    I u igbu I vy tuki

    W 16 pi ug u

    mg, ai, B I. ai w I w i y i Byu nwp

    igbu u g vy w. a

    u. fwig y

    ui Ju ci i w i

    y wiu bwig

    . W w u, tuki

    y bw u u , wv

    u igbu u p u kp

    tuki i u u y bw u

    i igbu!

    I ai g kw mii mii mi

    wi b y pb bw b

    Gk, i bviu w i g. t

    i: uig v spb 6 7

    iv u p buiig yk k tuki g i

    i bi i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    78/100

    I, w w i Gk i Ibu, w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    79/100

    by gup i G. I pubi wp wy I i i tuky. I y i I w

    bw tuky G, wi i

    bu tuki iiy i W t

    ppi bu I, w iv

    w ppi w. t w w y i i wiig.

    o spb 6 7 i 1955 u p

    y y Gk ppy bu G

    6 7 i 2005, w y wy p

    viig pgp xibii 195

    uiy. I yu k w i ii

    o u i. I p w

    pp w kw w

    i, i i y bu w xp

    uiy. t ui ppi ib u uiy. ou ui

    ui. W bj i ipi

    ig ui i g u. hw

    , y i i i i ki

    i i ib iiy ui by eup Ui, tuky wi b

    iiy ig i eU g qui.

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    80/100

    W I ii ig I i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    81/100

    u bk by u Yk w i w vi i -

    v I I w y ip

    ug I mui by bi I pi

    i y. I upp b igiu bu

    i ui -ii! I k

    . s ! t I i v

    big b iu mui

    tuk v w i

    b viib i iviib. s y,

    W yu k w qui

    ik? W y iv? W

    ipy, w y g b

    y iv i iv ju wy vy

    pu gi i b b qui viib iviib. I b

    u i yu bu

    vyig. s w yu k bu ,

    u w b

    k bu, y g, kik u b piu pi pp, iiviu

    w ii jy, u yu

    i piy w ipi 68%

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    82/100

    my w p b upy uvi v w w

    i i ui. tuk wi

    ub i uivii, yug v w

    uv i ig uiz,

    i ui wig wig. s biv y iiii gi v w

    ev i v w u iu

    , y i vii. ty u

    rig gizi Pi miiy hgi pibii ub

    uy.

    tuk ip

    ub u by pibii ub i

    ii i w

    ui gv by - Ii gi

    pibii ub w

    upp i i pibii uy ps y

    I tuky v w w y i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    83/100

    28 my 1997. W w pibi vui iiui, iuig givig igi

    y w wkig i pubi iiui w i

    w ii ivi vi. a ii

    uiiy ub bu iv u

    ii pii aii cpi ciu ub w w i jb i p

    Bu iig pu i pi

    piv w ii wk v

    w y u b iy . I v

    ui .

    a u cpi ciy W P

    rig aii gi diiii), cedaW

    tuky w i Un cedaW ci bu

    ub, t ci u i pibii

    tuky p tuki gv

    ub w w xu i py

    bu i pibii. nv,

    tuki gv iv y.

    Is betrayal in the genes of erkes Ethem28?

    cuu B, w i g i f

    aii29, wi i iy-ix ii,

    e b pui, w i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    84/100

    tuki rpubi, w ibu w cuiy i i iii, i iv

    cui i, ipy y

    wii i w uu. l B b

    fi viw B, i cui,

    cui iiii y :

    t cuu gi i y i

    n cui, su cui,

    eup y, ai, azbiji, G

    tuki, rui. auy

    gup i cuu. W uv cu

    i cui i uy ubj i

    giv u by . s y u i

    ayg, abkz Ubyk,

    tuky w u uu a

    c ii w iigu

    my pp i i i c

    w i cui iy ib

    i w tuky i xi i 1

    ppui v ix ii. ti i iKp30 w gg i i

    h y u v b bu ig

    cui y v k p i

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    85/100

    cui ii. Y w K y u y w tuki

    ivy g ppui, p

    a u pii gup pp

    c aii cui abkz a

    bg n cui cui

    W i py u i iiii

    b pi i tuky. W xp

    i bu w w v

    jiy [i tuky]. I w ub j

    ivg w ik u b p

    u. I ivg gup v b i

    u y, i ivg

    piiv iiii.

    cui v b ivig i tuky uy bu y cui y u

    jiy ppui. ou ii

    . s w w b

    i iiy bu i u v

    cui piv i i qu. Bu w p i

    , xp, p,

    In Turkey, the Caucasian identity could not ack

    this is partly because of the erkes Ethem ev

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    86/100

    so many books on Cerkes Ethem, one of the mo

    written by Cevat Kutay ( source?) . erkes Ethem

    a traitor or a hero, both are possible. Yet he wa

    but then in front of his name first Cerkes an

    became the Caucasian traitor so all the Caucas

    People of my age and older all witnessed examples of th

    experience of Ms Gliek, now a retired teacher, when

    teacher training school:

    o y u iy y cui i W I

    w u pi i xbk wi u

    ubj w ck e bu

    o u i w

    iy u ivuiy u cui gi w bu.

    I v wi u xp

    bk. I i i g pygi

    u y, s, y yu cii cii . o ig i I u

    cii i ig y b. W I

    ig yu jug

    w u ii ; yu

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    87/100

    i yu vi wi ck e. t

    w u i vig

    iy i i igi v i i. igy y bu ck e. Bu yKuy y i ck e b

    Ip W. Bu i p u hw y b p?

    I u bu iui y bu i b pi gi pig pig

    ii pii. W biv i w pi ig py gi. ev yigy y giv up iu cui bu i i ig mt (ni Iig ogizbu w w iui w ig pii bu i i iiy. tip pii u i w y iv i p by wkig w y v i pii buiig, puiv

    W y w kw cui i pii bu i i iii. Yu

    y w i , tuki. s vi y w tuki. Bu w tuki, w

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    88/100

    rui, w cui w iv i w.

    I w i wi i cupb. Y w w v i

    cui gug. s v cui tuki ii u i w wib v iiz tuki rigi. W gup wy u B abkzi. W v yu p w giv

    u. ou i bg W cug uppy ip u. I i w u u cui gug i w upp b. t i i abi i J, tuki i tuky rui gug w ig. W c

    a I i b, w u i cugug u uu. t w pp w pb bu i i kig i vy iuy. nv, tu

    iu k . W y y ig g cuu gi w v giv up u tuki iizip. ou

    ii gup i u i giy gizi kw bu c

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    89/100

    azbiji iii. ti iii vy iig wy. ov u pii pii w w w if xp, hu rig aii gup. ti, b , i k

    pkg izi p wi eu ii iu i 2002.

    I tuky y cui bu y gi, xp, xu. hxu

    pp by i i wy. ti i i pgy gi iiii pbu ig i pv iiii viy pi by , iy pp. I i pib y w

    ii iiii gi xu

    aig u ii w y p gi, w i vig, i iy, i iiviy gi iiii. Pp i

    cui wi i i ig i w i pp w uuy i biu.

    ngos contrIButIons to the struggle AgAIn

    k

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    90/100

    t viu gizi i tuky wiiii pjui, i i ui uk.

    cii si Dp c Aiai

    I i u u-y iig pg uggi ekii, dizi, a, diybk. t pibii iiii i x ii -gv gizi i ugg bi piip iizi i gpg ppi i pi.

    meDZ- w mdia wa gp (.diz.miz31, wi i i by fi Wwig xi i i wkig iiug i i 2006. I 2008 miz u

    sxi i mi g bupg i, vii i yi tV pg i u i, g gi b w gi32 i pii w ki big iviib. t gup w wk uy t r W r

    t u i w xi i f n-sxi mi. t i xpi, bui, viu i w

    Ai ca Aiai (AkD) ad Ai Iit avi cuu aii (aKd) avi Iwi dp sigy mi e ti

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    91/100

    wi dp sigy mi e tih Bk Vi ai cuu fui (hBVpj mv sugg gi diit pj i ug n-Gv ii ig wi ii iu ugg g

    f, u ig iii i vi bu iiii

    Iaia ha Di Fdait fui i ukig pj Wi mi i guy w u

    wpp iui wy i iii.

    mazdI 2008 mzu iu w ip p i

    iu iiii b , iiy igi p big pubi bk.

    Iab Bii uii ha ri la rati bk pj cbig ug duig rpig i 2009. t

    i ugg gi iiii gig iiiiv pi. t iv i nGo ig gi iiii

    iiui i ugg gi iiii. t iiui iig i i pig iiiiv pi

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    92/100

    pig iiiiv pi.

    ha ri Ji Paf (hoP)hoP w u i 2005 i hu rigciiz aby, mzu ay Ii

    wi i u i ui i v ii, xp i tuky, pp bi i suggmiiy rig Gup wi upp miiy rigi n-Gv ogizi. t bituki Pi i ob 2009. hoP wig i pvi tuki i

    p ci eiii ri i pib p b by g Wbg pj i equiy Pii sugg gi diiii wi upp huii lw Iiu i

    kk muiipiy, Bu Byki mmuiipiy i Juy 2009.

    hoP iu ppig iiiiv ptuky. t i p pj wi k 18 -uppiv i:

    - i y iiiiv pi bi igi, gug, xu ii pyi b xp i y i i i iy i

    DeveloPments In the FormAl ArenA In theDIscrImInAtIon

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    93/100

    Bw i ii i bk

    p iiii i tuky,

    tBmm (ti gad Ab) t ci

    w ad m35

    t w t ci equ oppuii W

    w iu pubi i oii Ju 24

    i pi vp W

    i ii vp i iu

    bu , vuig b i ii kpiy ii vi w, w p

    a w, i ig w

    G aki w Pi i

    t ci equ oppuii W

    xii pi bu vii

    bu g-b iiii i

    p i i i u y. Pp pii

    pi.

    un ci ri f P i Diabi

    u p u izi u

    p wi ibiii wiu i

    bi ibiiy 37

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    94/100

    bi ibiiy.

    cidiiii, wi i ip

    u jy u ig

    v, i pibi by ii u ig vib y ki ggi, xui, i

    pup uiyig ipiig

    b u jy quy

    iiviu wiu iii y ki, u

    igi, pii pii, i i u. 38

    Ii v gi iiii v

    i big iy

    i igi, bi, uu, , i igi, gug, xu ii, quii. s v

    ugg gi iiii. ty v u

    gi iiii, k pui ii

    k y p gi iiviu i

    iiii. Bi i, i i g wi g g b iiviu jy i

    , vi ii jy

    Appdi ouid nai (un) uia Daai f haai 2:

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    95/100

    ai 2:evy i i ig wiu iii y ki, u , u,pii pii, i i igi, u. fu, iii b

    juiii ii u uy bg, w i b ip, u, --gviii vigy.

    Ii cv civi Pii rig39

    ai 2.1:e s Py p cv uk iiviu wii i iy ubj igiz i p cv, wiu iii, u, x, gug, igi, pii igi, ppy, bi u.

    Iaia ca ei, sia ad cai 2:e s Py p cv uk ug ii i -pi,

    i, xiu i vib u, pgivy u izi ig gizby pppi , iuig piuy

    Iaia ci eiiai f DiiiaiAi 1

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    96/100

    Ai 11. I i cvi, i iiii

    xui, ii p b ,

    i igi wi pup u

    gii, jy xi, qu i

    u i pii, i, ii pubi i.

    4. spi u k pup ui

    i i i gup iiviu quii

    b y i u u gup iivixi u ig u

    iiii, pvi, wv, u u

    i p ig i

    y b iu bjiv w

    b iv.

    Ai 21. s Pi i iiii

    by pppi wiu y p

    iiii i i pig u, i :

    () e s Py uk gg i

    () e s Py pibi big ,

    iuig gii qui by iu,

    y p, gup gizi;

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    97/100

    y p , g p g ;

    () e s Py uk ug, w

    uii gizi v

    bi bw , iug yig

    g i ivii.

    2. s Pi , w iu w

    i, uu i, pi

    qu vp pi i

    bgig , pup guig jy u ig u .

    i qu i u

    i i gup bjiv wi

    b iv.

    ci eiiai f A F f Dii

    Ai I

    f pup p cvi,

    w y iii, xui

    x wi pup ipiig jy xi by w, ipiv i

    quiy w u ig u

    u, ug w pppi

    izi i piip;

    (b) t p pppi giiv u

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    98/100

    (b) t p pppi giiv u

    w pppi, pibiig iiii g

    () t bi g pi ig w

    u ug p i

    iiui iv pi w gi

    () t i ggig i y pi

    w u pubi uii

    iy wi i bigi;

    () t k pppi u ii iby y p, gizi pi;

    () t k pppi u, iuig

    bi xiig w, gui, u p

    iiii gi w;(g) t p i p pvii wi iu

    w.

    ci ri f cid

    Ai 21. s Pi p u ig

    c i i ii i j i i i

    Appdi ci f Pi f ha rFd

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    99/100

    Ai 14 Pibii f diiiait jy ig i

    u wiu iiii y gu u

    igi, pii pii, i i

    i iiy, ppy, bi u.

    P n. 12 ci f t PiFdaa Fd41

    Ai 1 . ga pibii f diiiai1 t jy y ig by w

    iiii y gu u x, , u,

    igi, pii pii, i i

    i iiy, ppy, bi u.

    2 n b iii gi by y pubi

    u i i pgp 1.

  • 8/6/2019 Always Disadvantaged Discrimination Practices in Turkey

    100/100


Recommended