Date post: | 20-Jun-2015 |
Category: |
Business |
Upload: | ampideainc |
View: | 567 times |
Download: | 2 times |
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
www.ampideainc.com
Optimize the Role of Predictive Analytics For Rep Effectiveness Using Patient Longitudinal Data
Amp Idea, Inc.Amplify your idea
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Historical Pipeline - New Product Launches
2
Drug-1Drug-2 :Drug-N
High Revenue
$$$
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Current Pipeline - New Product Launches
3
Drug-1Drug-2
LowRevenue
$
Drastic Reduction in New Drugs Approval
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Problem
Reduced revenue and margin due to shrinking drug pipeline.
4
Historical
Current
Marketing and sales budgets are shrinking while the pressure is mounting
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Traditional Call Allocations
Sales Practices Losing Effectiveness
5
List of “No See” doctors is increasing,
Average length of sales calls has been reduced by physicians.
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Traditional Call Allocations
Improved Call Plans Using Patient Data
Optimal Call Allocations
6
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Result
Millions of dollars of wasted sales resources in sub optimal sales territories
Research shows that over 80% of sales territories have significant design flaws and targeting issues.
7
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Traditional Marketing Analytics
8
PromotionData
Resource Allocation Analytics
SalesData
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Traditional Marketing Analytics
9
PromotionData
Resource Allocation Analytics
SalesData
“90% reps finds Call Plans to be inadequate”.
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Filling Blind Spot
10
PromotionData
Resource Allocation Analytics
SalesData
PayerData
PatientData
“90% reps finds Call Plans to be inadequate”.
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Patient/Payer Data
Conventional resource optimization solutions are silo-based, and often ignore other local market dynamics, including:
Patient and disease indication composition
Formulary tier and co-pay differential
11
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Why does Brand A have low share among Physician Cluster V-L?
Formulary Status
Disease Indication
Brand A Increases Marketing Budget - No Sales Impact
Physician Cluster
DoctorsMarket('000)
Specialty DecileBrand A (Share
Segment)
Brand AShare
Brand BShare
V-L 800 $80,000 Primary Care Very High Low 25% 75%V-H 1,200 $120,000 Primary Care Very High High 60% 40%
12
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Prescription - Marketing Efforts Physician Focused
Physician
Patient PharmacyManaged Care
Plan
Medicine Dispensed
Claim Sent
E-prescription
Prescription
Co-pay
PhysicianApproval
Claim
Y/N
13
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Physician
Patient PharmacyManaged Care
Plan
Medicine Dispensed
Claim Sent
E-prescription
Prescription
Co-pay
PhysicianApproval
Claim
Y/N
Prescription – Pharmacy Makes Switch
Alternate DrugIf High Co-pay
14
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
360 Degree View Of Data
Prescribers
Patients/Caregivers
Payers and Plans
Brand Promotion
Market Events
Historical Data, Market Research, Analytic Results
Brand Performance
Traditional Optimization
Not Utilized in Optimization
15
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Integration of Payer Data with Physicians Sales Data
Able to more effectively target the right physicians, with the right message, at the right time.
The time needed to communicate formulary updates to physicians can be shortened, thus increasing revenues.
16
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Patient Segmentation
17
Age Gender RaceDisease
IndicationDiseaseSeverity
Physician Segmentation
Region Specialty Volume ShareProduct
DominanceManaged
Care
360 Degree View Of Data – Patient Longitudinal Data
PatientSegment
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Traditional Forecasting Framework
Historical Class Volume
(Brand-A)
Rx (Brand-A) Rx (Brand-B)
Market Definition
Rx (Brand-C)
Class Volume = Retail Sales of all the Competing Brands,Brand Forecast = Projected Market Growth and Brand Share By Region/Segment
18
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Traditional Segmentation Framework
SpecialtyClass Volume
(Brand-A)Product Group
DominanceShared Trend
Rx (Brand-A) Rx (Brand-B)
Traditionally Class Volume is Calculated by Adding TRx of all the Brands Defined in the Class.
19
Managed Care(Co-pay By Plan)
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Data Quality Management using Managed Care Plan Data
Physician Cluster
DoctorsMarket('000)
Specialty DecileBrand A (Share
Segment)
Brand AShare
Brand BShare
V-L 800 $80,000 Primary Care Very High Low 25% 75%V-H 1,200 $120,000 Primary Care Very High High 60% 40%
Physician Cluster
DoctorsMarket('000)
Specialty DecileBrand A (Share
Segment)
Brand AShare
Brand BShare
L-L 800 $24,000 Primary Care Low Low 25% 75%V-H 1,200 $96,000 Primary Care Very High High 60% 40%
Data Pre-ProcessingAnd Staging
(Business Rule)Payer Data
Market Potential
20
Market Potential By Access
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Focus on Disease Indications
Physician Cluster Indication - 1 Indication - 2 Indication - 3 Indication - 4 Doctors DecileShare
SegmentV-L 5% 5% 50% 40% 800 Very High LowV-H 40% 60% 0% 0% 1,200 Very High High
Market Rx By Disease Indication
Conclusion: Based on Patient’s Disease Indication, Brand-A should receive significantly less Details for Physician Cluster V-L
Indication - 1 Indication - 2 Indication - 3 Indication - 4Brand-A Yes Yes
Brand-B Yes Yes Yes Yes
Brands - Disease Indications
21
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Data Quality Management using Drug Indication
Physician Cluster
DoctorsMarket('000)
Specialty DecileBrand A (Share
Segment)
Brand AShare
Brand BShare
V-L 800 $80,000 Primary Care Very High Low 25% 75%V-H 1,200 $120,000 Primary Care Very High High 60% 40%
Physician Cluster
DoctorsMarket('000)
Specialty DecileBrand A (Share
Segment)
Brand AShare
Brand BShare
L-L 800 $8,000 Primary Care Low Low 25% 75%V-H 1,200 $120,000 Primary Care Very High High 60% 40%
Data Pre-ProcessingAnd Staging
(Business Rule)Patient Data Drug Indication
22
Market Potential
Market Potential By Indication
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Market Definition : Traditional Approach – Treated Market
Calcium ChannelBlocker
HypertensionMarket
ACE InhibitorAngiotensin II
Receptor Antagonists
Beta Blocker
AzorTribenzorCardizemExforgeLotrelNorvascTarka
AzorBenicarBenicar HCTDiovanLasixMicardisEdarbi
LopressorToporol - XLBystolicCoregInderalMetoprolol
LotensinCapotenZestrilPrinivilAccuprilAltaceTarka
Traditional approach defines the market based on treatment option.
23
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Market Definition: By Disease Indication – Market Potential
Calcium ChannelBlocker
HypertensionMarket
ACE InhibitorAngiotensin II
Receptor Antagonists
Beta Blocker
AzorTribenzorCardizemExforgeLotrelNorvascTarka
AzorBenicarBenicar HCTDiovanLasixMicardisEdarbi
High Blood PressureAbnormal Heart RhythmHeart FailureAnginaTremorPheochromocytomaMigraines.
High Blood PressureHeart Failure
High Blood PressureAbnormal Heart RhythmAngina
High Blood Pressure Heart FailureRenal Disease StrokeDiabetic NephropathyLeft-Ventricular Hypertrophy
LopressorToporol - XLBystolicCoregInderalMetoprolol
LotensinCapotenZestrilPrinivilAccuprilAltaceTarka
Identify product attributes that will maximize actual prescribing
24
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Realistic Physician Decile
Very High High Medium Low
Benicar 4,000 8,000 12,000 80,000
Number of Physicians By Segment (Traditional Approach)
Very High 1,600High 1,100
Medium 800Low 500
2003,0002,2002,600
1001,0008,0002,900
100900
5,00074,000
Total
2,0006,00016,00080,000
After applying access and disease indication filter, 1,600 very high, 3,000 high and 8,000 medium volume
prescribers retained their respective decile segmentation.
200 high volume, 100 medium and 100 low volume prescribers moved to very high segment.
25
Number of Physicians By Segment (Disease Indication and Access)
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Better Targeting, Call Allocations & Territory Alignments Compared to Traditional Call Allocation Methodology
Prioritizes Targets Based on Sales Data AND Local Market Demographics of the Patients, Plans and Physicians: “No See” doctors Based On:
Communication Preferences Formulary Status Disease Indication
Traditional Call Allocations
The Net Result: Improved Call Plan
Optimal Call Allocations
Remove “No See” Doctors New Called On Doctors
26
In this example, dropping lower-value doctors from the customer target list and adding higher In this example, dropping lower-value doctors from the customer target list and adding higher potential doctors would significantly improve market coverage and incremental sales.potential doctors would significantly improve market coverage and incremental sales.
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Next Gen Forecasting Framework
Historical Class Volume
(Brand-A)
Indication-1 Indication-2
Rx (Brand-A) Rx (Brand-B) Rx (Brand-A) Rx (Brand-C)
Class Volume = Retail Sales of all the Competing Brands By Disease Indication,Brand Forecast = Projected Market Growth and Brand Share By Region/Segment
+ Disease Indication + Managed Care Impact
27
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Next Gen Segmentation Framework
Specialty Class VolumeProduct Group
DominanceShared Trend
Managed Care(Co-pay By Plan)
PatientDiagnosis
Rx By Diagnosis
Interim Adjusted Class Volume
Business Rule(Co-pay)
Final Adjusted Class Volume
Co-Pay By Plan
Amp Idea, Inc. proposes that Class Volume should be Calculated after Filtering TRx from the Competing Brands Based On Disease Indication and Managed Care Plan.
28
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Resource Allocation Process – Optimal Reach and Frequency
Specialty
Rx/Sales Data
Call Data
Samples
Patient Data
Disease Indication
Payer Data
MarketSegmentation
HistoricalPromotionEvaluation
Product/PortfolioResource
Optimization
Call Planning
IncentiveCompensation
Changes in market segmentation will reflect in territory alignment/incentive compensation and territory alignment in the marketing resource optimization process.
29
TerritoryAlignment
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Market Research/Analytics Results
Sales/Marketing Data(CRM)
Key PerformanceIndicators (KPIs)
Excel BasedManagementDashboard
(Data Integration &Business Intelligence)
Provider/Patient
Payer
Excel Based Analytic Information Hub - Provide Better Insights into Brand Performance
Data Warehouse(SAS, DB)
DataExtraction,
Transformation,Loading
(Excel/SAS)
Analytic Engine(SAS)
Report Generation
30
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Benefits
Better physician targets, less wasted marketing resources.
Appropriate adjustment in marketing resources for targeted physicians based on: No see doctors Patient diagnosis information Managed care – Formulary status and co-pay
31
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Approach - Pareto Principle
The Pareto principle states that, for many events, roughly 80% of the effects come from 20% of the causes.
In other words, 80% of sales come from 20% of sales reps.
Review low performing territories using sales, promotion, patient and managed care data.
32
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Opportunity
By deploying a more robust patient-based analytical platform, and integrating a
broader set of local market intelligence metrics, we are better positioned to: Save millions of dollars per field force in annual sales team expenditures, and
potentially increase revenue in each territory.
Provide grounded, empirically-based decisions around the ROI of patient-based
marketing initiatives.
Based on proprietary research, moving beyond conventional resource
optimization techniques and incorporating a more robust localized solution,
brand sales performance can increase.
By increasing productivity and improving customer targeting, Pharmaceutical
companies will improve the sales in non-performing territories
33
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Critical Business Questions To Explore?
What does the complete competitive landscape for my product look like?
How can we maximize the impact of our product launch tactics?
How effective are our sales reps in accessing, engaging, and promoting to targeted physicians?
How well does our detailing activity drive brand choice compared with competitors?
Which core messages are most effective?
Is it time to change our messaging strategy?
Are sampling volumes driving share—or supplanting written prescriptions?
Is our marketing campaign driving share from the targeted source of business?
How effective are our new sales strategies and tactics?
34
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
www.ampideainc.com
Questions
35
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Praveen Mathur is Vice President of Business Analytics at Amp Idea. He works with clients in establishing best practices in the area of sales optimization through combination of customer and market information, advanced analytical processes and software solutions. His areas of expertise include: maximizing ROI on marketing investment; customer segmentation; promotion response modeling; field force portfolio optimization; and market mix modeling using non-linear regression techniques.
Prior to joining Amp Idea, Praveen held various positions at inVentiv Health, leading cross-functional teams of business analysts and software engineers in the development of analytical tools to evaluate the effectiveness of sales and marketing initiatives.
Ram Bala is an Assistant Professor of Operations Management & Information Systems at the Leavey School of Business, Santa Clara University. He holds a Ph.D. in Management Science from the UCLA Anderson School of Management. His main research areas are product line design, promotional effort allocation, global product development and pricing and contracting strategies for services. His specific interest is the deployment of cutting edge technologies to increase the “intelligence” of business decisions.
Prior to joining academia, he has consulted for several firms in the area of pharmaceutical marketing analytics.
Author’s Bios
All information contained within is strictly confidential. Information cannot be copied, forwarded or transferred to another third-party without prior written consent from Amp Idea, Inc.
Contact
Praveen Mathur, Vice President - Analytics, Amp Idea, Inc. [email protected] www. ampideainc.com 732-619-3899
37