Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Interventions aiming to treat fetal growth restriction
and the EVERREST EU-project
14/01/2015
Karel Maršál Lund University
Sweden
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Fetal Growth Restriction
• Complicates ~8% of pregnancies (severe 1:500) • Major cause of perinatal mortality & morbidity • No effective treatment • Outcome dependent on gestational age • Early-onset severe IUGR associated with
reduced uterine blood flow
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Uteroplacental perfusion Uteroplacental blood flow is proportional
to fetal size Uteroplacental insufficiency
Sheep pregnancy
(Konje et al. 2003)
Ute
rine
bloo
d flo
w (m
l/m
in)
Gestational Age (Weeks)
Human pregnancy
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Baschat et al 2007
Neonatal outcome in fetal growth restriction
Gestational age at birth
%
total survival
survival without disability
Between 23 and 26 weeks of gestation, an increase in birthweight of 100g reduces the risk of dying by 40%.
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Very preterm IUGR – high survival: - Lund / Malmö 90% - TRUFFLE study 94 %
HOWEVER
- both the short-term and long-term morbidity is considerably high !
• cognitive impairment • behavioural disturbances • reduced lung function • changes in cardiovascular function
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Early-onset IUGR
Postnatal growth stimulation of IUGR infants difficult.
It is desirable to improve fetal growth and to prolong
pregnancy.
Need for intrauterine therapy.
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Therapies that do not work • Bedrest • Maternal oxygen supplementation • Maternal nutritional supplements • Low-dose aspirin • β-mimetics (RCTs show no effect) • Calcium channel blockers • Plasma volume expansion • Vitamin C
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Interventions aimed at increasing uterine blood flow
L-arginine (aminoacid, nitric oxide donor)
• Maternal intravenous infusions
• L-arginine readily available and safe in pregnant women, however, conflicting data on increase in birth weight
• Currently not recommended for treatment of IUGR
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Interventions aimed at increasing uterine blood flow
Sildenafil citrate (nitric oxide donor)
• Temporary smooth muscle relaxation in vessels • Works in animal models and tested in humans • In severe, early-onset IUGR thrice daily
maternal treatment with 25 mg sildenafil until delivery = ↑ AC growth velocity
• Randomized controlled trial data required
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Growth hormone treatment
• Animal models
• Maternal and fetal supplementation • Risk of adverse effects (hydranencephaly
in fetuses)
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Insulin-Like Growth Factor-1 (IGF-1)
• Implicated in regulation of normal placental function and of appropriate fetal and postnatal growth
• Anabolic effect, stimulates substrate
uptake and inhibits protein breakdown
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
IGF-1 treatment
Maternal Guinea pigs • Increased placental mass and functional
capacity of placenta = ↑ fetal growth • Significant effects on maternal physiology
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
IGF-1 treatment Fetal infusion Sheep and non-human primates • Increased aminoacid utilization and alteration
in fetal protein accretion • Adequate substrate supply necessary for
effective tissue growth • Organ specific increases in growth, however
no significant effect on body size and growth
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
IGF-1 treatment
Intra-amniotic
Sheep
• Increased total fetal growth rate and organ growth in growth restricted fetal sheep
• Up-regulates placental amino acid transporters
• Promising approach (?)
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Maternal uterine artery VEGF gene therapy ...and the EVERREST study
Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor (VEGF)
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
VEGF angiogenesis vasodilatation vascular protection
sFlt-1 ↑
Pre-eclampsia
VEGF ↓ PlGF ↓ endothelial dysfunction
IUGR
Reduced endothelial derived vasodilatation
VEGF implicated in trophoblast invasion
Over-expression of sFlt1 in pregnant mice using adenovirus causes PE-like syndrome & IUGR
Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
….uses genetic material as a drug delivery vehicle to facilitate the expression of
therapeutic proteins
Gene therapy……
Achieve targeted protein expression • Uteroplacental circulation
Short term protein expression • Adenovirus vectors
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
VEGF levels are reduced in fetal growth restriction
Sustained local levels of VEGF will treat fetal growth restriction
“Maternal growth factor gene therapy”
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Hypothesis Delivery of adenovirus containing VEGF gene to
uteroplacental circulation
Local over-expression of VEGF
Increase uterine blood flow Alter uterine artery vascular tone &
angiogenesis
Increase fetal growth in severe FGR
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Short-term changes in uterine artery volume flow 4 – 7 days after vector injection
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Long-term changes in uterine artery blood flow after vector injection
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Correcting growth restriction in animal models of IUGR
14/01/2015
IUGR guinea pig: maternal nutrient restriction model - fetal growth, vector dose and safety
IUGR sheep: adolescent overfed ewe, Rowett Institute, Aberdeen - efficacy, fetal growth, neonatal outcome and safety
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Fetal Growth Velocity - abdominal circumference
14/01/2015
Gestation (days)
Abd
omin
al c
ircum
fere
nce
(mm
)
***
***
***
***
A
B
140
160
180
200
220
240
260
280
300
80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120 125 130
Control (n=12)VEGF (n=18)Saline (n=13)LacZ (n=14)
Mean surgery day
*** p=<0.001
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Proportion of very small sheep fetuses >2SD below control mean
0
5
10
15
20
VEGF Saline+LacZ
YesNo
p = 0.033 (Fisher’s exact test)
(Control mean = 5084g , SD = 431g, -2SD cut-off = 4222g)
Severe FGR >2SD
Mild FGR <2SD
Saline+LacZ VEGF
Num
ber o
f fet
uses
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
No significant changes in:
Maternal heart rate, blood pressure
Fetal heart rate, blood pressure
No vector spread
No fetal abnormalities 60
70
80
90
100
110
120
130
140
12/0
2/20
08
13/0
2/20
08
14/0
2/20
08
15/0
2/20
08
16/0
2/20
08
17/0
2/20
08
18/0
2/20
08
19/0
2/20
08
20/0
2/20
08
21/0
2/20
08
22/0
2/20
08
23/0
2/20
08
24/0
2/20
08
25/0
2/20
08
26/0
2/20
08
27/0
2/20
08
28/0
2/20
08
29/0
2/20
08
01/0
3/20
08
02/0
3/20
08
03/0
3/20
08
04/0
3/20
08
05/0
3/20
08
Daily
BP
at 9
am
SystolicDiastolicMean
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23
Day after flow probe placement
vector injection
Total n = 4
Pre
ssur
e (m
m H
g)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
04/07/200809:00
05/07/200809:00
06/07/200809:00
07/07/200809:00
08/07/200809:00
11/07/200809:00
12/07/200809:00
13/07/200809:00
14/07/200809:00
15/07/200809:00
16/07/200809:00
17/07/200809:00
Systolic
Diastolic
Mean Arterial Pressure
Vector Injection
Day 1
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
Day 6
Day 7
Day 10
Day 8
Day 9
Day 11
Day 12
Safety
Abi-Nader et al, Lab Animals, 2011
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
EVERREST
• Does vascular endothelial growth factor gene therapy safely improve outcome in severe early-onset fetal growth restriction?
Our aim • To translate a novel gene medicine delivered to
mothers, into the clinic, so as to improve fetal growth in severe early-onset fetal growth restriction
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
EVERREST
• Reproductive toxicology • Bioethics study • First-in-woman phase I/IIa safety/efficacy study
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Human placenta toxicology studies
14/01/2015
After regeneration of syncytiotrophoblast, placental villous explants are exposed to high dose adenovirus vector
Perfusion experiments in normal and IUGR human placentae with high dose adenovirus vector
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
First-in-woman trial
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
First-in-woman trial • 4 EU recruiting centres
(London, Hamburg, Lund, Barcelona)
• Inclusion criteria:
• Severe early-onset IUGR
• ≥22 weeks of gestation
• Uteroplacental insufficiency (abnormal blood flow)
• Other causes of IUGR excluded
• Vector delivered via interventional radiology
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Treatment
• Vector instilled into uterine artery for 2 minutes using interventional radiology approach
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
EVERREST outcome measures Primary outcome
• Assessment of patient safety and tolerability Secondary outcomes
• Uterine artery volume blood flow • Abdominal and head circumference (ultrasound) • Gestational age at delivery • Birth centile • Maternal blood pressure and proteinuria • Composite clinical outcomes • Myometrial artery contractility and placental
phenotype
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Summary • Local expression of VEGF in the uterine arteries
• increases uterine blood flow • alters vascular reactivity • increases angiogenesis • improves fetal growth in IUGR pregnancies • without apparent maternal or fetal harm
• VEGF gene therapy promising as a therapy for
severe early-onset IUGR
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
original idea
bioethics
ethical & regulatory approval
Phase I/IIa safety/efficacy
study
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Thank you !
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
www.everrest-fp7.eu
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
14/01/2015
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
original idea
University College London, UK A David et al, Gene Therapy 2008 V Mehta et al, Gene Therapy 2011
Increase uterine artery blood flow short and long term Relax uterine arteries Increase endothelial nitric oxide synthase Increase endothelial cell proliferation in uterine artery adventitia No vector spread to fetus No acute haemodynamic changes
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
Supported by the EC under the FP7 Programme
Copyright © 2013 EVER
REST Consortium
– All rights reserved
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
original idea
University College London, UK D Carr et al, Hum Gene Ther 2014 V Mehta et al, PLoS One 2014
Increase fetal growth velocity Mitigate “brain sparing” No adverse events at delivery or up to 3 months postnatally Planned clinical vector has similar effects