+ All Categories
Home > Documents > André Strydom Physics Department, University...

André Strydom Physics Department, University...

Date post: 25-Feb-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 1 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
35
YFe 2 Al 10 …unravelling the origin of quantum criticality André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg
Transcript
Page 1: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10

…unravelling the origin of quantum criticality

André Strydom

Physics Department, University of Johannesburg

Page 2: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Acknowledgements

Frank Steglich (MPI‐CPfS, Dresden)

Michael Baenitz and co‐workers (MPI‐CPfS, Dresden)

Meigan Aronson (BNL & Stony Brook Univ., USA)

Devashibhai Adroja and Adrian Hillier (ISIS, UK) 

Pararajasingham Peratheepan (Eastern Univ., Sri Lanka)

Page 3: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Overview of properties of the 1:2:10 series

Data on YFe2Al10 : a candidate for criticality of T=0 ferromagnetism?

Page 4: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Ferromagnetic quantum criticality: an enigmatic rarity

Examples of itinerant ferromagnets tuned into quantum criticality …

by doping (UNi1xCoxSi2, Ca1xSrxRuO3, CeRu1xFexPO,… )

or pressure (ZrZn2, MnSi, UGe2)– role of superconductivity?– is the end‐point continuous or not?

quantum critical fluctuations above TC = 3K in UCoGe…

…but magnetic field always seems malevolent to ferromagnetic quantum criticality!

Page 5: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Ferromagnetic quantum criticality: an enigmatic rarity

Case of NbFe2:

…proximity to ferrimagnetism

…proposed mechanism of vanishing carrier velocity

…competing q=0 and q ≠ 0 instabili es producing non‐Fermi    liquid critical exponents

…and the key role of chemical doping

Haynes et al., PRB 85 (2012) 115137 Neal et al., PRB 84 (2011) 085133Tompsett et al., PRB 82 (2010) 155137Alam and Johnson, PRL 107 (2011) 206401

Page 6: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Ferromagnetic quantum criticality: a rarity

Tuning of a ferromagnet turns out to be more complex…

FM‐QCP reached through a tricritical point…

Belitz, Kirkpatrick, Rollbühler

PRL 94 (2005) 247205

YFe2Al10 : a candidate for accidental criticality of T=0 ferromagnetism?

Page 7: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

RT2Al10: (R=Y, La, Ce,…Yb, Lu;   T=Fe, Ru, Os)  [1]

CeRu2Al10: a collection of very unusual properties [2] 

Orthorhombic Cmcm,Al unique sites for Ce, Ru

Ce – Ce: 5.2 ÅCe

Ru

1. Thiede, Ebel, Jeitschko, J Mater Chem 8 (1998) 2. Strydom, Physica B 404 (2009) 2981

Page 8: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Two different anisotropic Kondo insulators…

CeRu2Al10

TN = 27 K… ;  ord = 0.34 B ;  k=(1,0,0)  [3]8 meV spin gap [4] with strong c–f hybridization; depletion of 

magnetic  moment and low electrical conductivity along b–axiseasy magnetization along a–axisyet ordered moment and high conductivity along c–axisfavours description in terms in terms of ac–plane dimensionality

CeFe2Al10

Strong and highly anisotropic c–f  hybridization, pseudogap from NMR 11 meV  [5] or from neutrons 12‐15meV [6] 

3. Khalyavin et al, Phys Rev B 82 (2010) 100405 4. Robert et al, Phys Rev B 82 (2010) 100404 5. Chen & Lue, Phys Rev B 81 (2010) 0751136. Adroja et al., unpublished

Page 9: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

CeRu2Al10

A phase transition with a commonthread in resistivity, specific heat, and susceptibility…

Strydom, Physica B 404 (2009) 2981

Page 10: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

CeRu2Al10

Characteristic Kondo Insulator (or Heavy‐Fermion semiconducting)susceptibility…

Nishioka et al., J. Phys. Soc. Japan 78 (2009) 123705

Page 11: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10

Exploratory susceptibility [1] and Mössbauer [7] reported absence of  magnetic ordering above 2K

Our studies exposed T– and B– dependencies in various properties below  5 K…

Sample quality : elemental purity > 99.99 wt.‐%

homogeneity and composition using WDX:Y : Fe : Al = 1.00(1) : 2.00(1) : 9.55(3)a=8.97 Å, b=10.15 Å, c=9.02 Å

powder‐XRD profile refinement 

Mössbauer to check for single species of Fe  

7. Waerenborgh et al, J. Alloys Comp. 323‐324 (2001) 78

Page 12: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10

Sample quality (continued)

nearest‐neighbour FeFe : 4.48 Å

Fe in octahedral site                          symmetry 

Page 13: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10

Sample quality (continued) : recent single‐crystal analysis [8]reported no significant deviation from ideal Fe and Al site compositions through refinement of site occupations  

Y environment… Fe environment…  

8. Kerkau et al., Z. Kristallogr. NCS 227 (2012) 289

Page 14: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: Thermal behaviour

Susceptibility

Curie‐Weiss at high T (> 120 K), eff ≈ 0.4 Bac shows no frequency dependence (1 – 1000 Hz)…

Strydom & Peratheepan, PSS‐RRL 4 (2010) 356

Page 15: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: Thermal behaviour

Susceptibility

Park et al., PRB 84 (2011) 094425  Strydom & Peratheepan, PSS‐RRL 4 (2010) 356 

Page 16: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: Thermal behaviour

Susceptibility

Park et al., PRB 84 (2011) 094425

(T )  T 1.28(T )  T 1.28

Page 17: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: Thermal behaviour

Susceptibility

Key results of Park et al.: YFe2Al10 can be tuned into a Fermi liquidusing magnetic field,

(T )  T 1.28

Susceptibility scaling exponents are not reconcilable with either mean‐field nor with disorder or impurity models                                              

Park et al., PRB 84 (2011) 094425

Page 18: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: Thermal behaviour

Magnetization

Continuous curvature towards T=0…

yet   / | → is still finite at 0.5 K

Strydom & Peratheepan, PSS‐RRL 4 (2010) 356

Page 19: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: Thermal behaviour

Magnetization

Strydom et al., J. Phys. Soc. Japan 80 (2011) SA043

T=0.78 K

Page 20: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: Thermal behaviour

Magnetization

Strydom et al., J. Phys. Soc. Japan 80 (2011) SA043

26Al‐NMR : suppression of spin fluctuations commences from B 1T… 

T=0.78 K

Page 21: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10 physical properties: Magnetism 

Inelastic neutron scattering

T = 4 K T = 100K

Ei = 25 meV

Ei = 6 meV

Adroja & Strydom (25 – 30 Oct 2012, ISIS, UK)

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

|Q| (Å-1)

Ene

rgy

(meV

)

mar17975.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=25 meV0<|Q|<7, 0<Energy<22

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

|Q| (Å-1)

Ene

rgy

(meV

)

mar17978.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=25 meV0<|Q|<7, 0<Energy<22

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.50

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

|Q| (Å-1)

Ene

rgy

(meV

)

mar17976.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=6 meV0<|Q|<3.5, 0<Energy<5

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.50

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

|Q| (Å-1)E

nerg

y (m

eV)

mar17977.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=6 meV0<|Q|<3.5, 0<Energy<5

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Page 22: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10 physical properties: Magnetism 

Inelastic neutron scattering

T = 4 K T = 100K

Ei = 25 meV

Ei = 6 meV

Adroja & Strydom (25 – 30 Oct 2012, ISIS, UK)

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

|Q| (Å-1)

Ene

rgy

(meV

)

mar17975.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=25 meV0<|Q|<7, 0<Energy<22

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 70

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

|Q| (Å-1)

Ene

rgy

(meV

)

mar17978.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=25 meV0<|Q|<7, 0<Energy<22

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.50

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

|Q| (Å-1)

Ene

rgy

(meV

)

mar17976.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=6 meV0<|Q|<3.5, 0<Energy<5

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.50

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

|Q| (Å-1)E

nerg

y (m

eV)

mar17977.spe, symd(1,2,3), s=4, Ei=6 meV0<|Q|<3.5, 0<Energy<5

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Further experiments:  lower T,  E,  Q… 

Page 23: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10 physical properties: Magnetism 

26Al NMR:

Baenitz et al., 2012

0.1 10

Page 24: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10 physical properties: Magnetism 

Muon spin resonance

Adroja, Hillier, Strydom, (27 – 28 Oct 2012, ISIS, UK)

T = 0.05 K

BL = 2500 G2000G1500G1000 G500 G50 G0 G

Page 25: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10 physical properties: Magnetism 

Muon spin resonance 

absence of cooperative magnetic effects confirmed down to 0.05 K

Complete absence of small‐field induced effects

Are spin fluctuations at 50 mK still too short‐lived for the ISIS SR time window…?

Adroja, Hillier, Strydom, (27 – 28 Oct 2012, ISIS, UK)

Page 26: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: ThermalSpecific heat : low T

Below 2K, Cp(T )/T = 0.0382(2) ∙ T 0.31(1)

Page 27: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: ThermalSpecific heat : the role of Fe stoichiometry 

Page 28: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: ThermalSpecific heat : the role of Fe stoichiometry 

Far from stoichiometric Fe… Fermi liquid

Page 29: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: ThermalSpecific heat : the role of Fe stoichiometry 

Far from stoichiometric Fe… Fermi liquid

At stoichiometric Fe… non‐Fermi liquid

Page 30: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: ThermalSpecific heat : the role of Fe stoichiometry

CP(T )/T =  + bT 2 + [dT 2 . ln(T/Tsf)] ,  Tsf = 15(2) K 

Far from stoichiometric Fe… Fermi liquid

At stoichiometric Fe… non‐Fermi liquid

Near stoichiometric Fe… spin fluctuating

Page 31: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: ThermalSpecific heat : the role of Fe stoichiometry

non‐Fermi liquid behaviour does not scale with Fe concentration…

Far from stoichiometric Fe… Fermi liquid

At stoichiometric Fe… non‐Fermi liquid

Near stoichiometric Fe… spin fluctuating

Page 32: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

YFe2Al10: physical properties: ThermalElectrical resistivity

0 ≈ 100 .cm, RRR ≈ 3  (polycrystal) 0 ≈  75 .cm, RRR ≈ 2  (single crystal) [Aronson et al.]

TK ≈ 20 K

Page 33: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Conclusions

YFe2Al10 is a good metal, paramagnetic at room temperature 

No magnetic ordering found down to 0.05K

Correlated phenomena develop below 2K in electronic specific heat, or below 20K in electrical resistivity

Notions of itinerant FM quantum criticality:Specific heat  : Cp(T )/T T 0.33 (2D clean FM1)Susceptibility :      (T )  T 4/3 (3D clean FM2)  

1. Moriya & Takimoto, JPSJ 64 (1995) 960, Lonzarich, The Electron (1997) Cambridge2. Hertz PRB 14 (1976) 1165, Millis PRB 48 (1991) 7183 

Page 34: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

Questions

How to reconcile the dimensionality issue?

Is there magnetic ordering below T = 50 mK?

…or is the observed nFL scaling merely a spectator segment en route to a very lowT Fermi liquid? 

Current work

(T) and (T) under pressure

(T) at low temperatures

Page 35: André Strydom Physics Department, University …hf.iphy.ac.cn/workshop/HF2012Nov/Andre_M_Strydom_files...André Strydom Physics Department, University of Johannesburg Acknowledgements

THANK YOU !!


Recommended