Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
NanoBio Spectroscopy Group and ETSF Scientific Development CentreDpto. Física de Materiales, Universidad del País Vasco,
Centro Física de Materiales CSIC-UPV/EHU San Sebastián, Spainand FHI Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, Berlin, Germany
http://nanobio.ehu.es Email: [email protected]
Angel Rubio
Time dependent DFT
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
OUTLINE
Introduction: Framing the lecture:Excitations; response concepts
Applications:
Optical properties of nanostructures and biomolecules Chlorophylls: photosynthesis (excite state dynamics and energy store/harvesting)
Optimal Control Theory: quantum information High-harmonic generation
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Physical Processes: Spectroscopies
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time-dependent phenomena!
Photoexcitation and relaxation
Time required for building up of screening?
Introduding a negative bare charge q=-1 in a nanostructure: monitorise the time evolution of the electronic
density (TDDFT calculation)
q=-1
‘Bare particles get dressed’Huber et al.,
Nature 414, 286 (2001)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Quantum control
R. J. Levis et al, Science 292, 709 (2001)
Time resolved pump-probe techniques
Zewail et al (2005)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Excitations in bio-systems: encouraging results!!Green fluorescent protein and their mutants (2008, Nobel prize in Chemistry)
(Aequorea victoria: jellyfish)
M.A.L Marques, X. Lopez, D. Varsano, A. Castro, and A. R. Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 158101 (2003)
Some biophysical processes
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Theoretical Framework
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Density Functional versus Manybody perturbation theory
groundstate
What about excited-state properties: electron-ion dynamics, spectroscopies
E [R ions]=min ⟨∣He∣ ⟩ Hohenberg-Kohn (1964)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
What is a spectrum?
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Vinduced
= δ n v + fxc
δ n
Hartree
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Many Body Perturbation Theory (MPBT)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time Dependent Density Functional Theory (Runge and Gross 1984):
All observables are functionals of the TD density
?
One-to-one correspondence between the time-dependent density and the external potential, v(r,t) <------> (r,t)
Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory, Lecture Notes in Physics, Vol. 706 (Springer, Berlin, 2006)
Same time-dependent
density n(r,t)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time Dependent Density Functional Theory (Runge and Gross 1984):
All observables are functionals of the TD density
i ℏ ddt=H i ℏ d
dti=H KS [ { j} ]i , i=1,⋯N ?
H KS=ℏ
2
2mi∇−
ecℏ
AAxc2
V externalV hartreeV exchangeV correlation
One-to-one correspondence between the time-dependent density and the external potential, v(r,t) <------> (r,t)
Linear and non linear phenomena accessible
Octopus Code http://www.tddft.org
Time-Dependent Density Functional Theory, Lecture Notes in Physics, Vol. 706 (Springer, Berlin, 2006)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
By the Runge-Gross theorem ALL observables are functionals of the TD density
Absorption spectra: from the power spectrum of the TD dipole moment
d(t) = < r n(r,t) > ------ d(w)=FT[d(t)]
........... and current response
Ionisation yields:
Excited state densities and transition probabilities
....................... and many more observables!!!!!!
PES p =∑i ∣i p , t∞∣2=5eV
I=1.3 1011 W cm2
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
potential
t (R)| g>
|e>
|ψ(t)>=C1(t)|e>+C2(t)|g> ????
beyond BO Hψ = Eψ
F = mα
Electron dynamics
MD
within BO
i∂
∂ t=H
Ehrenfest's dynamics (non-adiabatic)
Femtosecond dynamics: test photodissociation of a dimer (Na2
+).
80fs
A. Castro, M.L. Marques. J.A. Alonso, G.F. Bertsch and AR (2003)
ω=3.2eV
ω=2.5eV
Time resolved Vibrational Spectroscopy: Raman
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
TDDFT Lagrangian formulation for BO-MD dynamics: fictitious dynamics as in Car-Parrinello dynamics
L=∑ii∣i
∂∂ t−
12m
pecA
2
−V ion∣i−EHxcV
8 c2
d Adt
2
12∑i
M I R I Ri
The equation of motion without external field for simplicity
i∂
∂ ti=[−ℏ
2
2m∇
2V ionV HV xc]i
J.L. Alonso, X. Andrade, P. Echenique, F. Falceto, D. Prada, AR PRL (2008)
MI R I=−∇ I E [ ,R]
Advantages of this modified Ehrenfest-dynamics:● Time reversibility build in; exact total physical energy conserved● Good scaling: no need to orthogonalise the states during evolution● intrinsicaly parallel, benefit from many developments in CP dynamics ● limits µ=0; exact BO dynamics, µ=1, Ehrenfest, larger µ>>1 desirable for fast simulation ( the ionic ∆t is basicaly µ times the electronic ∆t)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
TDDFT Lagrangian formulation for BO-MD dynamics: fictitious dynamics: performance
Linear response
),( tr
),( t′′r
tickle the systemobserve how thesystem respondsat a later time
( ) ( )tVtttddtn ′′′′′′= ∫∫ ,,,,),( 11 rrrrr χdensity
responseperturbationdensity-density
response function
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
TDDFT does the job for you!!!
Vext
however the KS system V
eff
=00v f xc
0 r ,r ' ,w=∑ij f j− f i
icr jr i r ' j
cr '
i− j−wf xcr , r ' ,=
V xcr ,
n r ,
Linear Response
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
How to solve the linear response equations
(1) Sum over states: 0 r ,r ' , w=∑ij f j− f i
icr jr i r ' j
cr '
i− j−w
=00v f xc
Cassida's approach
[1−v f xc0]=0
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
How to solve the linear response equations
(2) Time propagation
Propagation Scheme:●Apply a perturbation of the form δvext (r,t) = −κ zδ(t) to the ground state of the system●At t = 0+ the Kohn-Sham orbitals are φ
ι (r,t=0+)= eikz φ
ι (r )
●Propagate these KS wave-functions for a (in)finite time.●The dynamical polarizability can be obtained from α(ω)= − k-1 Σ
ι <φ
ι | z | φ
ι >
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
How to solve the linear response equations
(3) Density Functional Perturbation Theory
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Problems with extended systems in finite fields?
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Macroscopic Polarisation Theory and real-time simulation
E=−1c
d A t d t
i ℏ∂
∂ ti=[ 1
2m p
ecA
2
V ionV HV xc]i
14
d 2 A
dt 2=−e2 n
mA−c
eV∑i
i∣pm∣i =c2 jmac t =−c2 d P t
dt
G.F. Bertsch, J.I. Iwata, AR, K. Yabana, PRB62, 7998 (2000)
A(t) = Aext
(t) + Aind
(t) Emac
= 4 π P(t)
H= H + H
em P=polarisation
What is the link to the “modern theory of polarisation”? (see the recent review by Vanderbilt, Resta)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Macroscopic Polarisation Theory <-->real-time A(t)
Berry Phase
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
H2 molecular chains (infinite long case)
D. Varsano, A. Marini, AR PRL (2008)
Dimerised
equidistant
Metallic
versus
semiconducting
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Illustration: Some applications
Optical properties of nanostructures and biomolecules Chlorophylls: photosynthesis (excite state dynamics and energy store/harvesting)
Optimal control theory: High-harmonic generation
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Towards the color of plants: e.g. Spinach
Fleming et al Nature (2005),.... (Berkeley)
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Journal of Chemical Physics 131, 84101 (2009)
Free standing porphyrins
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Towards the color of plants: The real Chlorophyll molecule
Exp.Gas
phase
LDA
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Charge Transfer excitations
Photovoltaic Hybrids: Grätzell cells
Road to Improving Efficiency: Controlling position of the frontier orbitals
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Photo-excitation of the light-harvesting carotenoid-porphyrin-C60
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Photo-excitation of the light-harvesting carotenoid-porphyrin-C60
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Clamped ions
Carotenoid-porphyrin-C60 photodynamics
Charge on the C60
Dynamical ionsClamped ions
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Optimal control theory
Key question: What is the laser pulse that drives the system intoa predefined goal?
Procedure: Define a target operator Ô and at the end of thelaser interaction (t = T) maximize the functional
W. Zhu, J. Botina, H. Rabitz, JCP 108, 1953 (1998)
Ô = |Φ ><Φ |F F target state
Example: High harmonic generation
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
What makes experimental “control” possible
●Existence of laser sources, since the 1960’s.●Femto-second laser sources, which allow for fast processes (avoiding decoherence), and extending the band-width.●High-intensities.●Laser shapers.●Learning-loops algorithms.
Interrogating Molecules?Science, Nov. 2008
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Tailoring HHGHHG consists of the emission of integer multiples of the carrier frequency of a driving laser, due to its highly non-linear interaction with matter. It can be explained with the so-called 3-steps model:
Typically, the HH spectrum (emission intensity vs. photon frequency) consists of a rapid intensity decrease, a plateau, and a cut-off.
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Tailoring HHG
7th 13th
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
The combination of MBPT and (TD)DFT is a powerful tool to “predictive” describe the combined
dynamics of electron/ion in response to external electromagnetic fields of large scale nanostructures, biological molecules and extended systems spanning
very different time scales
ETSF
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Acknowledgements
X. Andrade, M. Wanko, A. Akbarim L. Espinosa,N, Helbig, S. Kurth, I. Tokatly, J. Fuks, J. Alberdi, M. A. L. Marques
ETSF , Department of Material Physics, Centro Mixto CSIC-UPV, University of the Basque Country, Donostia, Spain
E. K. U. Gross Halle
A. Castro, J.L. Alonso, P. Echenique Zaragoza
D. Varsano, C. Rozzi, N. Spallazani Modena
K. Thygessen S. Bronsted Nielsen Denmark
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Than
k yo
u!!!!
For more details see:http://nano-bio.ehu.eshttp://etsf.eu
Time dependent DFT
Hands-on workshop on EXC!TiNG code, CECAM Lausanne, Switzerland, 15th Noveber 2010
Workshop “Non adiabati
c dynamic
s at surfaces
”, Schloss Reisens
burg October
2007
12th Density Functional Theory Conference, Amsterdam, August 2007
Time and size scales
Some Pathologies of the KS-DFT functional
Band-gap problemis discontinuous by a constant when an electron is added to the system(Sham, Schlüter and Perdew, Levy (1983)
Widely separated open-shell atomsAlmbladh and von Barth 1985
Exchange correlation electric field in insulators
Godby and Sham 1984, Gonze, Ghosez and Godby 1995
Some Pathologies of the KS-DFT functionalSome Pathologies of the KS-DFT functionalBan-gap problem(Sham, Schlüter and Perdew, Levy
(1983)
Egap=N1KS
−NKSN1
KSN1−N1
KS≡Egap
KSxc
Egap=I−A=LUMO−HOMO
xc=[Exc[n]
n r ]N1
−[Exc [n]
nr ]N O1/N xc-discontinuity
Some Pathologies of the KS-DFT functional
Band-gap problemis discontinuous by a constant when an electron is added to the system(Sham, Schlüter and Perdew, Levy (1983)
Widely separated open-shell atomsAlmbladh and von Barth 1985
Exchange correlation electric field in insulators
Godby and Sham 1984, Gonze, Ghosez and Godby 1995
Some Pathologies of the KS-DFT functionalSome Pathologies of the KS-DFT functionalWidely separated open-shell
atomsAlmbladh and von Barth 1985
The KS-effective potential takes a positive value IB-I
A
around atom B
Some Pathologies of the KS-DFT functional
Band-gap problemis discontinuous by a constant when an electron is added to the system(Sham, Schlüter and Perdew, Levy (1983)
Widely separated open-shell atomsAlmbladh and von Barth 1985
Exchange correlation electric field in insulators
Godby and Sham 1984, Gonze, Ghosez and Godby 1995
Some Pathologies of the KS-DFT functionalSome Pathologies of the KS-DFT functional