Date post: | 27-Mar-2015 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | danielle-flores |
View: | 214 times |
Download: | 0 times |
Animal detection Systems
•Effectiveness•Types•Design Issues•Implementation•Applications•Costs•Operation &Maintenance
Effectivness
System Types
Break the Beam
Area Coverage Detection
Designing for Success
Implementation
Pros:•Safe crossing•Less restrictive to wildlife movement•No major Road Construction•Less Expensive
Cons:•Only large Animals•Some Only at night•Ten years as compared to 20-30•Equipment in RofW•Still some AVC
Applications
Costs
$65,000/mile *–stand alone
$20,000 *for a gap in a fence
•excluding installation and signage and wildlife fencing
, Problems and Experience with operations.
Area cover systems
Break-the-beam system
Geo-phone system
Radio-collar system
False positives
High, moving or wet vegetation
√ √
Flying birds, nesting birds, rabbits
√ √
Wind, rain, water, fog, snow spray, falling leaves
√ √ √
Snow and ice accumulation on sensors or ground
(√) √
Microwave radio signal reflection off guard rail
√
Sun, heat, unstable sensors √ √ √
Insufficient ventilation in box (fog on lens)
(√) √
Problems and Experience with operations
Area cover systems
Break-the-beam system
Geo-phone system
Radio-collar system
False positives
Frost, low temperatures √ √Lightning (√) √ √ (√)Long distance between transmitter and receiver
√
Traffic on road √ √ (√)Traffic on driveways or side road (√) √Passing trains √Signals from other transmitters √ √
Problems and Experience with operations
False negatives Area Coverage
Break the beam
Geo- phone
Radio collar
Curves, slopes not covered by sensors
(√) √
Loitering animals in right-of-way not detected
(√) √ (√)
None of the individuals that cross have collars
√
Not feasible for non-gregarious species/migrants
√
Insufficient warning time (√) (√) (√)
Some systems are only active during the night
√ √
Problems and Experience with operations
Maintenance Area Coverage
Break the beam
Geo phone
Radio collar
Maintenance costs (e.g., mowing, power, fences)
(√) √ (√) (√)
Shade/snow on solar panels (√) √ (√) (√)
Vandalism and theft of e.g. solar panels
(√) √ (√) (√)
Safety (cars of road) (√) √ (√) (√)
Broken sensors, warning lights or other material
√ √ (√) √
Period required to solve technical difficulties
√ √ √ √
Signs (standardization, liability) √ √ √ √
No remote access to data (poor cell phone coverage)
(√) √ √ (√)
Problems and Experience with operations
Landscape, ecology, animals
Area Coverage
Break the Beam
Geo phone
Radio Collars
Landscape aesthetics (√) √ (√) (√)
Animals crossing areas may change overtime
(√) √ (√) (√)
Animals may wander between fences (if present)
√ (√) (√) (√)
Small animals are not detected
√ √ √ √
Continuous effort to capture animals
√
Stress for the animals involved
√
Not in habitat linkage zones (light disturbance)
√1