Jesús García, Susana Tostón, Carlos Jiménez, Fabiola Martínez, Rafael Camarillo, Isaac Asencio and Jesusa Rincón
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Castilla-La Mancha
Faculty of Environmental Sciences and Biochemistry Avda. Carlos III, s/n, 45071, Toledo, Spain
E-mail: [email protected]
“Electrocatalytic conversion of CO2
into energy compounds”
Toledo, 22nd of November 2013
-Sustainability and waste treatment-
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
INDEX OF CONTENTS
1. Introduction. 2. Objetive of this work.
3. Metodology. 4. Results.
5. Conclusions.
1. Introduction: Global warming, CO2...
The latest IPCC reports (3rd, 4th y 5th)
[CO2]
Use
fossil fuels
Therefore:
Earth temperature
In the last 40 years, GHG
emissions have been
doubled (major
contributor: CO2, 75%)
Use fossil fuels
(main source of energy)
In recent decades
Technologies that avoid
these emissions
Renewable
energy
In this Century
Fossil fuels will remain the mainstay
of world energy production
Capture and Storage* of CO2
GLOBAL WARMING
Global warming
-CLIMATE CHANGE-
INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY
Recycling of CO2
(Complementary technology to storage)
1
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
Awareness GHG
emissions (especially CO2)
1. Introduction: Technologies of CO2 recycling.
Objetive: CO2 conversion to fuels and chemicals consumption or can be used
as raw material in the chemical industry.
Main CATALYTIC METHODS
of CO2 conversion:
1) Photocatalytic reduction of CO2.
2) Electrocatalytic reduction of CO2.
Chemical transformation of CO2
at ambient conditions requires a
high energy input
POSSIBLE SOLUTION:
Addressing
CO2 conversion reaction by
CATALYTIC METHODS
2
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
CHEMICAL REDUCTION OF CO2
USE FUELS:
-Electricity production -Industry, etc…
Fuels
Other products
CO2
CO2
Photocatalytic reduction of CO2 Electrocatalytic reduction of CO2
PhotoElectroCatalytic reduction of CO2
- Involve the use of semiconductors (photocatalysts),
substances that cause chemical reactions (redox) under
light.
- By the time the conversions achieved aren’t very high.
- Involve the use of electrocatalyst, substances that
promote chemical reactions (redox) in the presence of
electric power.
MAIN LIMITATION: low solubility of CO2 in water
when using aqueous solutions of CO2.
- The conversions achieved are higher than those
obtained in the photocatalytic process.
Scheme of a PEC reactor for reducing CO2 using sunlight
RESEARCH
SOLUTIONS:
Adapted from (Centi et al., 2007)
1) increasing the pressure and the CO2 concentration
in the system, but limit the effectiveness of the process.
2) performing the Photocatalytic or Electrocatalytic
conversion of CO2 in gas phase.
3) PhotoElectroCatalytic conversion of CO2 in gas phase
(alternative and complementary procedure).
3
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
1. Introduction: Technologies of CO2 recycling.
PHOTO-catalysts ELECTRO-catalyst
sunlight
2. Objetive.
The objective of this work is to develop an
electrocatalytic system that allows, through the use of
electrocatalysts, the conversion of CO2 in gas phase to
hydrocarbons (liquid fuels easy to store and transport)
using electrical current to activate them.
4
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
3. Metodology.
Electrochemical cell used
It has been carried out the assembly and
tuning up of an installation for
electrochemical reduction of CO2 to
hydrocarbons through the use of an
electrochemical cell.
5
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
Connections and operation of
the electrochemical cell
H2O
INLET
ANODIC ZONE CATHODIC ZONE
H2O
OUTLET
Heater cartridge
Thermocouple
CO2
INLET
CO2 + REACTION PRODUCTS
OUTLET
Electrical connection (RE+CE)
Electrical connection (WE)
Electrooxidation of H2O for generate H+ and e-
Electroreduction of CO2 to hydrocarbons using H+ and e-
generated in the electrooxidation
Main component of this cell
Membrane Electrode Assembly
(MEA)
TO ACHIEVE THIS OBJETIVE…
Flow diagrams of the experimental installation of electrocatalysis
(continuous operation)
CO2 BOTTLE
6
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
3. Metodology.
POTENCIOSTAT-GALVANOSTAT
TEMPERATURE CONTROLLER
PUMP - aquous solution of KHCO3 -
ELECTROCHEMICALCELL HUMIDIFIER
TANK - aquous solution of KHCO3 -
Thermocouple
Heater
cartridge
WE
CE + RE
CO2
FLOWMETER
to GC-FID-TCD
CO2 +
REACTION
PRODUCTS
OUTLET
Configuration to channel reaction products leaving the cell and to analyze them
by gas chromatography
7
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
3. Metodology.
GC-FID-TCD
decane
in
Liquid products trapped in decane
are preconcentrated and injected in GC
Gaseous products released from decane
are injected in GC
Cooling bath (-5 °C)
Solids filter
CO2 +
REACTION
PRODUCTS
OUTLET Heater cord temperature (130 - 140 °C)
1) Reaction products trapped
in liquid absorbent (decane)
2) Gaseous products released
from the liquid absorbent
Identification
with GC-FID-TCD
(* pA: picoamps; μV: microvolts; min: minutes)
Identification
8
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
“Configuration to channel reaction products leaving the cell“
1) Reaction products trapped in
decane
Preconcentrated and injected
in GC-FID-TCD
(* pA: picoamps; min: minutes)
- Methanol and acetone have been identified.
- The peak whose retention time is 26.3 min.
can be isopropanol or methyl acetate.
It’s necessary to study new temperature ramps.
- There are peaks without identification.
Conditions experiment 12:
-CO2 flow= 250cm3 min-1
-KHCO3 concentration= 0.025 mol/l
-Current intensity= 0.54 A (Galvanostatic mode)
-Cell temperature= 60 °C
-Cell pressure= 1 atm
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
“Configuration to channel reaction products leaving the cell“
It’s necessary to inject other patterns.
Comments:
9
2) Gaseous products released from
liquid absorbent (decane) Injected in GC-FID-TCD
(* pA: picoamps; min: minutes)
- Carbon monoxide (CO) has been identified.
- In the 5 minute there are a peak without identification.
(* μV: microvolts; min: minutes)
- Hydrogen (H2) has been identified.
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
“Configuration to channel reaction products leaving the cell“
It’s necessary to inject other patterns.
10
Through the use of an electrochemical cell similar to PEM fuel cells is possible to
obtain fuel products from CO2 reduction.
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
5. Conclusions.
The configuration to channel reaction products which consisted in the absorption
of the reactions products in a cold trap, with decane as absorbing liquid, and their
preconcentration and subsequent injection into GC-FID-TCD has allowed to
identify compounds liquid fuels such as methanol and acetone, and gaseous
compounds such as carbon monoxide and hydrogen.
Upcoming work includes:
Deposition of metals on carbon nanotubes in supercritical media to create
advanced electrocatalysts.
Identification and quantification of all products attained.
11
Thanks for your attention!
Presented by: Jesús García García
E-mail: [email protected]
“Electrocatalytic conversion of CO2
into energy compounds”
Toledo, 22nd of November 2013
1. Introduction: Technologies of CO2 capture and storage.
Objetivo: evitar que las emisiones antropogénicas de CO2 alcancen la atmósfera.
Captura Almacenamiento Transporte
Absorción en disoluciones
no acuosas de aminas.
En formaciones geológicas:
- Minas subterráneas.
- Sumideros terrestres
(depósitos agotados de
carbón, petróleo,…).
- Océanos.
Implica: gasto adicional de
energía Emisiones
de CO2.
PROBLEMÁTICA CCS:
- Necesario acondicionar los
lugares de almacenamiento
definitivo
- ¿Seguridad a largo plazo?
Actualmente
Reciclaje de CO2
(Tecnologías complementarias a
la de almacenamiento)
Contracorriente: flujo de
gas cargado de CO2 y la
disolución no acuosa de
aminas.
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
A FAVOR de estas tecnologías:
1) Grandes cantidades de CO2
puro y a bajo coste.
2) Numerosas emisiones para
las que no es apropiada la
captura y almacenamiento
(distancia,…).
3) Buena imagen de la
empresa por adoptar política
de reducción de emisiones.
EN CONTRA de estas tecnologías:
1) Gasto adicional de energía Emisiones
de CO2
Solución: el aporte adicional de energía a de
proceder de una fuente renovable, como es la
solar.
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
1. Introduction: Technologies of CO2 recycling.
3. Metodology. Celda
electroquímica
Componentes
principales de la
celda electroquímica
EME
*
MEMBRANA PROTÓNICA
SOPORTES CARBONOSOS PARA LOS ELECTRODOS
JUNTA SELLANTE
JUNTA SELLANTE
PLACA BIPOLAR DEL
ÁNODO
PLACA BIPOLAR DEL
CÁTODO
*
Proceso preparación EME:
1) Preparar electrodos.
2) Ensamblar electrodo-membrana-electrodo.
3) Montaje en celda.
Montaje final de la celda electroquímica
PLACA COLECTORA
PLACA DEL ÁNODO
PLACA DEL CÁTODO
JUNTA AISLANTE
JUNTA AISLANTE
PLACA COLECTORA
Adaptado de (Linares, 2009)
Se ha llevado a cabo el montaje y puesta a
punto de una instalación de reducción
electroquímica de CO2 a hidrocarburos
mediante el empleo de una celda
electroquímica.
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
3. Metodology.
Conexiones y funcionamiento
de la celda electroquímica
ENTRADA H2O
COMPARTIMENTO ANÓDICO
COMPARTIMENTO CATÓDICO
SALIDA H2O
Cartucho calefactor
Termopar
ENTRADA CO2
SALIDA CO2 +
PRODUCTOS REACCIÓN
Conexión eléctrica (RE+CE)
Conexión eléctrica (WE)
Electrooxidación de H2O para generar H+ y e-
Electrorredución de CO2 a hidrocarburos empleando los H+ y e-
generados en la electrooxidación
Disposición de las conexiones eléctricas en la celda electroquímica
WE en cátodo
CE-RE en ánodo
y viceversa
WE en cátodo
CE en ánodo
RE en cable (EME)
EME
COMPARTIMENTO ANÓDICO
COMPARTIMENTO CATÓDICO
COMPARTIMENTO ANÓDICO
COMPARTIMENTO CATÓDICO
WE
RE
WE CE
Permite controlar el voltaje de la celda
- Permite controlar el voltaje catódico – Descartada problemas RE-cable EME
CE-RE
1 2
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
Flow diagrams experimental installation of electrocatalysis
(continuous operation)
POTENCIOSTAT-GALVANOSTAT
TEMPERATURE CONTROLLER
PUMP - aquous solution of KHCO3 -
ELECTROCHEMICALCELL HUMIDIFIER
CO2 BOTTLE
TANK - aquous solution of KHCO3 -
Thermocouple
Cartridge
heater
WE
CE + RE
CO2
FLOWMETER
6
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
3. Metodology.
CO2 +
REACTION
PRODUCTS
OUTLET
Configurations for canalize reaction products leaving the cell, and so be able to
perform the same analysis by gas chromatography
7
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
3. Metodology.
4. Results.
“Experimentos con el objeto de
seleccionar la metodología más
adecuada para analizar la corriente
producto”
Configuración 1
Configuración 2
“Experimentos para el estudio
del comportamiento electroquímico
de los electrodos”
Método
Voltametría Cíclica Potenciostática
(VCP)
Configuración 3
9
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
ESTUDIO DEL COMPORTAMIENTO ELECTROQUÍMICO DE LOS
ELECTRODOS
VCP entre +4V y -4V
Voltaje negativo (catódico): picos de reducción.
Voltaje positivo (anódico): picos de oxidación.
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
4. Results.
“ESTUDIO DEL COMPORTAMIENTO ELECTROQUÍMICO DE LOS ELECTRODOS”
WE en cátodo
CE en ánodo
RE en cable (EME)
Voltajes negativos
(catódicos):
Condiciones experimento 2:
-Flujo CO2= 432cm3 min-1
-Concentración KHCO3= 0,5 mol/l
-VCP= entre -0,4 V y 0 V
-Tª en celda= 25 °C
-Presión en celda= 1 atm
VCP: barrido de voltaje para
analizar los cambios en la
intensidad de corriente como
consecuencia de las reacciones
redox que ocurren en la celda.
Reducción de H2O
-0,2V
Reducción de CO2
-0,38V
Picos reacciones de
reducción
- Pico de reducción de
CO2 a -0,2V.
- Pico de reducción de
H2O a -0,38V.
Conclusiones:
1) La aplicación del método VCP a una celda electroquímica permite determinar la existencia de
reacciones redox.
2) Los picos de las reacciones de reducción aparecen cuando los voltajes son negativos.
10
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
“Experiments with the aim of selecting the most appropriate
methodology to analyze the product stream”
Configuration 1 Configuration 2 Configuration 3
9
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
Configuration 1
“STUDY OF THE MOST APPROPRIATE METHODOLOGY TO ANALYZE THE PRODUCT STREAM“
1-pentanol absorption Decane absorption
Conditions in experiment 3:
-CO2 flow= 540cm3 min-1
-KHCO3 concentration= 0.5 mol/l
-Voltage= -2.8 V (Potenciostatic mode)
-Cell temperature= 60 °C
-Cell pressure= 1 atm
Conditions in experiment 4:
-CO2 flow= 540cm3 min-1
-KHCO3 concentration= 0.5 mol/l
-Voltage= -0.2 V (Potenciostatic mode)
-Cell temperatura= 60 °C
-Cell pressure= 1 atm
25%
Acetone
1.690
83%
1- pentanol
3.520 – 9.840
4%
CO2
1.494
1- pentanol absorption (GC-MSD)
30%
Acetone
1.489
94%
Decane
8.326 – 12.228
4%
CO2
1.320 Decane
absorption (GC-MSD)
Configuration 1 conclusions:
1) The probability with which the MSD identifies the acetone in both chromatograms isn’t high
enough for us to say that acetone is formed in the reaction CO2 conversion.
2) Other reaction products (overlapped with the peak of absorbing liquid or its concentration is
below DL).
Configuración 2 is proposed…
11
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
Configuration 2
Conditions experiment 5: Conditions experiment 7:
-CO2 flow= 540cm3 min-1
-KHCO3 concentration= 0.5 mol/l
-Voltage= -0.2 V (Potenciostatic mode)
-Cell temperature= 60 °C
-Cell pressure= 1 atm
-CO2 flow= 540cm3 min-1
-KHCO3 concentration= 0.5 mol/l
-Current intensity= 0.54 A (Galvanostatic mode)
-Cell temperature= 60 °C
-Cell pressure= 1 atm
Ethylene oxide 4%
Acetaldehyde 3%
CO2 2%
2,426 – 3,766
Injection at 2 hours (GC-MSD)
Formaldehyde
2%
2,366 – 3,478
Methanol 1%
7,621 – 8,549
12
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
“STUDY OF THE MOST APPROPRIATE METHODOLOGY TO ANALYZE THE PRODUCT STREAM“
Configuration 2 conclusions:
1) The probability with which the MSD identifies the products isn’t high enough for us to say
that are those products which are formed from the reaction of CO2 conversion.
2) Obstruction problems occur in the heated pipe.
Configuration 3 is proposed…
Injection at 45 minutes
(GC-MSD)
Uso H2SO4 como electrolito:
1) evita problemas de obstrucción,
2) no mejora los resultados respecto al uso de KHCO3 y
3) podría afectar negativamente a los electrocatalizadores
Se retoma el uso de KHCO3 como electrolito pero en concentraciones inferiores a las usadas inicialmente.
Configuración 2
Condiciones experimento 9:
WE en cátodo
CE-RE en ánodo
Óxido de etileno 3%
Acetaldehído 3%
CO2 2%
2,556 – 3,834
Inyección a las 2 horas (GC-MSD)
-Flujo CO2= 250 cm3 min-1
-Concentración H2SO4= 1 mmol/l
-Intensidad de corriente= 0,54 amperios (Modo galvanostático)
-Tª en celda= 60 °C
-Presión en celda= 1 atm
13
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.
“STUDY OF THE MOST APPROPRIATE METHODOLOGY TO ANALYZE THE PRODUCT STREAM“ Conclusiones Configuración 2:
1)La probabilidad con la que el MSD identifica los productos no es lo suficientemente alta como
para que podamos afirmar que son esos productos los que se forman a partir de la reacción de
conversión de CO2.
2)Surgen problemas de obstrucción en la tubería calefactada.
Se plantea la Configuración 3
CONFIGURACIÓN 1: Disoluciones de 1 y 5 ppm de metanol, etanol, acetona e
isopropanol (enrase decano)… En GC-MSD
Acetona 86%
4,232
Decano 97%
7,841 – 16,412
1ppm
Acetona 90%
3,683
Decano 95%
6,523 – 16,430
5ppm
“Solvent delay”
Energy and Environment Knowledge Week – E2KW 2013 -
4. Results.