7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 1/31
WP2: Homecare & Independent
Living
Final review template
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 2/31
WP2 Objective
The objective of the WP2 experiment is to:
– Evaluate different SME’s Homecare and Independent Living services inanother country
– Provide a “lessons learned” in transferring or setting-up cross borderHomecare and Independent Living Living Lab projects
– Assess• what kind of ecosystem, value network and common approach needs to be in place to
conduct cross-border pilots (in the domain of H&IL)
• to what extent it helps to do cross-border experiments faster, easier and moreefficiently
This has to result in – specific information results related to the impact of remote gateway andsensor-based systems on the daily practices of people
– a set of requirements and guidelines for setting up such cross-borderprojects.
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 3/31
WP2 Expected results
The expected results from the Homecare and IndependentLiving (H&IL) experiment are:
1. Overview of the different contextual factors related to
the Homecare and Independent Living domain2. A common approach for setting up experiments within a
cross-border network of H&IL LL including:1. a transfer strategy and protocol
2. Validated methods and tools for a cross-border eHealth network3. Evaluation of the benefits of a cross-border network in
exploring new and emerging markets
4. Addressing the needs/questions of the SMEs involved
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 4/31
WP2 Structure
Assess a common eco-system for a cross-border network of LL in eHealth
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 5/31
WP2 Resources
Schedule: M1-M30 Resources: Total 113 PMs over 30 months
Partners and contact persons:
• AALTO: Hendrik Hielkema (Task Lead 2.4)
• FV: Marianne Dannbom (Task lead 2.1)
• IBBT: Bram Lievens (Task Lead 2.5)
• IAV: Bidatzi Marin (Task Lead 2.2)
• AIM: Daan Velthausz (Task Lead 2.3)• TLV: Saar De Zutter, Henk Van Steenkiste
• INN: Tim Van den Dool
• LOGICA: Gohar Sargsyan, Chris Bannink
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 6/31
WP2 Deliverables
Nr. Title Lead PM M.
2.1 Identification of requirements FHV 7 M3
AVAILABLE
2.2 Common Living Lab approach IAV 10 M9SUBMITTED M15
2.3 Set-up the local experiment in the remote Living Lab AIM 33 M12
FORESEEN M16
2.4
Evaluation and recommendations report on the cross
border experiment HSE 42 M29
2.5Strategy for setting up cross border pilots in Homecare and
Independent Living domainIBBT 21 M29
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 7/31
WP2 Set-up
• Cluster four Living Labs that focus on H&IL applications,
services and technologies within this field
• Transfer two types of IDS from one Living Lab to another
– Homecare platform XtramiraTM From Belgium to Finland – ADL sensor network From the Netherlands to Spain
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 8/31
WP2 Specific Focus
• Project-specific focus
– Investigate feasibility and value of a common EcosystemApproach for cross-border piloting
– Identifying the homecare and independent Living specificelements crucial in cross-border collaboration
– Facilitate SMEs to explore new market opportunities by
performing cross-border pilots
– Challenging the current role of Living Labs
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 9/31
Pilot 1: Videophony for extramural care
and independent living
• Original Set-up:
– Belgian Living Lab: IBBT
– Belgian SME: Televic - Xtramira™ is a videophony solutioncompatible with existing personal alarm systems to
facilitate extramural care & independent living
– Finnish Living Lab: Forum Virium Helsinki
– Finnish Research Institute: Aalto University
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 10/31
LocaL eco-system
Pilot 1 Development
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 11/31
LocaL eco-system
Pilot 1 Development
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 12/31
LocaL eco-system
Pilot 1 Development
Setting-up common
eco-system
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 13/31
LocaL eco-system
Pilot 1 Development
• New local projects
• Business opportunities for local
actors
Setting-up common
eco-system
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 14/31
LocaL eco-system
Pilot 1 Development
• New international projects
• Business adjustments
• New local projects
• Business opportunities for local
actors
Setting-up common
eco-system
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 15/31
Pilot 1: Partners, Roles and Outcomes
Partners Role in the common eco-
system
Outcome
A P O L L O N P a r t n e r s
B
e l g i u m
IBBT Connect local SME
Provide research insights to
partners
New collaborations wit local SME and
remote Living Lab
Televic Transferring new market Insights in new market
Specific business leads
Impact on organisation
F i n
l a n
d Forum Virium Setting up comon eco-system
in Finland
New project with additional partners
Aalto University Perform user research Increased knowledge
E
x t e n
d e
d D o m a i n
E c o s y s t e m
L i v i n g L a
b
D o m a i n
c o n t a c t s
Palmia Integration and evaluatingserrvice
Assessment of videophone service intheir organisation
Terveykeskus Supporting the experiment,
providing the necessary
environment
Added value of new technologie in the
wlefare of people
D o m
a i n
S M
ETunstall Providing alternative solution
for local partner needs
Assessment of their product
Real business opportunity and lead
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 16/31
Pilot 2: ADL
• The ADL sensor network is an
intelligent service for the informal
care.
• Set of sensors (motion-detection,
connections…) that detects &monitor activities within the home.
• Alarms can be defined and triggered
by different rules.
• Rules for alarm can be defined onsensor level, quite flexible
• The alarms are being send via e-mail
and SMS
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 17/31
Pilot 2 Development
LocaL eco-system
• Service sold
• Take-over of INN activities
• New local projects
• Strengthen internal position
Setting-up common
eco-system
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 18/31
Pilot 2: Partners, Roles and Outcomes
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 19/31
Pilot 3: I Can Help
• I Can Help is a location based social emergencyservice
– iOS application
– Central webbased management platform
• Objective:
– Test and validate the service – Entering a new market
• New country
• New segment
• Partners involved
– From Netherlands: Logica, AIM and CM(subcontracting)
– From Belgium: IBBT, city of Turnhout/socialpublic welfare organisations
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 20/31
Pilot 3 Development
LocaL eco-system
• New projects
• Strategic collaboration for LL
• New market opportunities
• Commercialization track of the
service
Setting-up common
eco-system
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 21/31
Pilot 3: Partners, Roles and Outcomes
Partners Role in the common eco-
system
Outcome
A P O L L O N
P a r t n e r s
B e
l g i u m
IBBT Setting up a common eco-
system
Connect local actor
Performing the user research
New and sustainable collaborations wit
local actor and remote Living Lab
N e t h e r l a n
d s Logica Setting up comon eco-systemin Finland
Market insightsInput for further commercialization
path
AIM Supporting the local partner in
the Living Lab process
New collaborations with partner
E x t e n
d e
d D o m a i n
E c o s y s t e m
L i v i n g L a
b
D o m a i n c o n
t a c t s City of Turnhout &
public social welfare
organisation
Integration and evaluating the
serrvice
Assessment of videophone service in
their organisation
? ? ?
D o
m a i n
S M E
CM2 Providing alternative features
(in subcontracting)
Learning process of offering services in
another country
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 22/31
WP2 Results: Pilot Level
• Videophony for extramural care and independent living• Finding the right eco-system
• Identifying a clear business opportunity for experimenting
• Contextualizing the Xtramira services
• Alternative pilot – with new eco-system partners service providers
• Activity daily Living system
• Repositioning of the ADL system business model
• Adjusting the service for a global deployment
• Testing and validating the service in an iterative way (different cycles)
• Spin-out the service
• I Can Help App
• Assessment of the application and service
• Adjusted for a new market• New country, new segment
• Piloted with a user group of ca. 20 users• Capturing feedback
• Lessons learned on• Technological issues
• Business model
• User behavior
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 23/31
WP2 Results: Common Ecosystem
Approach
Home care
organization
Government
Developer
Service provider
Operator
Informal care
giver
Care receiver
Insurance
Living
Lab
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 24/31
WP2 Results: Project Level
• For SMEs
• Insights in new markets
• Clear business opportunities
• Assessment of their service
• Entry point to new eco-systems
• Commercialization of the product
• For Living Labs
• New methods and tools that can be offered
• Insights in homecare and independent Living specific cross-border Living Lab issues
• New collaborations
• Connection with new eco-systems
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 25/31
Homecare & Independent Living Domain
Network
• Dissemination & exploitation
– ICT2010
• Organization of (local) workshops
– Barcelona workshop (March 19th
, 2010) – Joint workshop with ENoLL on thematic cross border
(December 13th, 2010)
• SME promotion and stimulation
– Additional partners
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 26/31
Key Lessons learned
• With regard to the eco-system: – a common eco-system isn’t feasible for a number of
reasons• the domain of Health the eco-system is too specific for each
country.
• the eco-system comprehends more then only a network of partners – contextual factors such as rules and regulations, business
structures…
• necessary to find a good match between the variousstakeholders
– eco-system is a necessary condition in setting-up cross-border pilots
• built around roles and responsibilities
• involvement of these partners driven by a clear need and fit
• Preferably a bottom-up process on all levels
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 27/31
Key Lessons learned
• With regard to the cross-border aspect
• Working in a cross-border network do facilitate SMEs
to enter foreign markets
• The local Living Lab acts as a broker
• Need for a good and thorough feasibility
• Technological
• Market
• In homecare and independent Living there are some
critical elements
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 28/31
Critical elements
Critical
elements in
cross-border
pilots in Health
Privacy
Liability
Ethics
Local
assessment
Safety
Maturity
Cost
Trust
Rulesandregulatio
ns
Access toend-
users
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 29/31
Success stories
• For INNOVITING• Changes in the services
• New sensors vendor
• Redesigned the web application
• Changed the business case from consumers to home care organizations
• The ADL system is a sold spin-off from INNOVITING to Livind (Adesys andBureauvijftig)
• LOGICA
• No leads in other markets
• Now investigating other business models for their service
• Preparing the commercialization of the
• For ArteConnect & TUNSTALL• Additionally involved in the pilot
• Match different players
• Integrated service now commercially offered
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 30/31
WP2 Sustainability
• Providing the strategy and structure for a thematic
domain network
• Addressing specific topics
• All partners are part of the thematic domain network on
Health and Well-being
• Methods and tools integrated in the knowledge center
• Services for cross-border piloting available in the market
place
7/31/2019 APOLLON Final Review WP2 v2
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/apollon-final-review-wp2-v2 31/31
Thanks
• Questions
Bram Lievens
IBBT-SMIT
Pleinlaan 2 – 1050 Brussel
[email protected] - +32 478720154