Appendix A. Meta-analysis of biochemical recurrence data from SWOG 8794, EORTC
22911, and ARO 96-02
Appendix B. Outcomes from Randomized Controlled Trials
SWOG 8794 EORTC 22911 ARO 96-02
RP + RT RP only RP + RT RP only RP + RT RP only
Biochemical recurrence Biochemical recurrence-free survival
60/172 (34.9%)
recurrence
5y bRFS:
71.0%
10y bRFS: 53.0%
112/175 (64%)
recurrence
5y bRFS:
44.0%
10y bRFS: 26.0%
198/502
(39.4%)
recurrence
5y bRFS: 74.0%
10y bRFS: 60.6%
311/503 (61.8%)
recurrence
5y bRFS: 54.0%
10y bRFS: 41.1%
38/148
(25.7%)
recurrence
5y bRFS:
72% 10y bRFS: 56%
67/159 (42.1%)
recurrence
5y bRFS:
54%
10y bRFS: 35%
Comparison: HR=0.43 (95% CI= Comparison: HR=0.49 (95% CI= Comparison: HR=0.51 (95% CI=
CU CI+CI:
0.31-0.58; p<0.001) 0.41-0.59; p<0.001) 0.37-0.70; p<0.001)
Local Recurrence Cumulative local relapse
15/190 (8%)
local
recurrence at
median 10.6y
40/184 (22%) 42/502 (8.4%)
with locoregional
failure
10y cumulative local relapse rate: 7.3% (95% CI=4.9-9.8%)
87/503 (17.3%)
locoregional
failure
10y cumulative local relapse rate: 16.6% (95% CI=13.1- 20.1%)
NR NR
local
recurrence at
median 10.6y
Comparison: no HR reported; Comparison: HR=0.45 (95% CI= NR
p<0.01 0.32–0.68; p<0.0001)
Hormone therapy- free survival
5y hTFS:
90.0%
10y hTFS: 84.0%
5y hTFS:
79.0%
10y hTFS: 66.0%
NR NR NR NR
Comparison: HR=0.45 (95% CI= NR NR
0.29 –0.68; p<0.001)
Metastases Metastatic rate Metastases- free survival cumulative
93/214 (43.5%)
had metastases or died of any cause
20/214 (9.3%)
had metastases
5y mRFS: 88%
10y mRFS: 71%
114/211 (54%)
had metastases or died of any cause
37/211 (17.5%)
had metastases
5y mRFS: 84%
10y mRFS:61%
55/502 (11.0%)
had distant metastases
10y cumulative metastatic rate:
10.1% (95% CI=
7.2-13.0%)
57/503 (11.3%)
had distant metastases
10y cumulative metastatic rate:
11% (95% CI=
8.0-14.0%)
4/148 (2.7%)
had distant metastases at median 4.5y 25/148 (16.9%) had distant metastases at median 9.3y
5/159 (3.1%)
had distant metastases at median 4.5y 22/159 (14.9%) had distant metastases at median 9.3y
Comparison: HR=0.71 (95% CI= Comparison: HR=0.99 (95% CI=0.67-
1.44;
0.67 – 1.44; p=0.94)
NR
0.54–0.94; p=0.016) 1 1.44; p=0.94)
Clinical progression and clinical progression- free survival
84/214 (39.3%)
clinical progression or death at median 10.6y
10y cPFS: 70%
111/211
(52.6%) clinical progression or death at median 10.6y
10y cPFS: 49%
157/502
(31.3%) clinical progression or death at median 10.6y
10y cPFS: 70.3%
181/503 (36.0%)
clinical progression or death at median 10.6y
10y cPFS: 64.8%
NR NR
Comparison: HR=0.62 (95% CI=
0.46–0.82; p=0.001)
Comparison: HR=0.81 (95% CI=0.65 –
1.01; p=0.054)
0.65 – 1.01; p=0.054)
NR
Deaths from
cancer
Cancer-
specific
survival
NR NR 25/502 (5.0%)
deaths from
prostate cancer
10y cumulative prostate cancer
mortality rate:
3.9% (95% CI=
2.0-5.7%)
34/503 (6.8%)
deaths from
prostate cancer
10y cumulative prostate cancer
mortality rate:
5.4% (95% CI=
3.2-7.5%)
NR NR
NR Comparison: HR=0.78 (95% CI=
0.46–1.33; p=0.34)
NR
Overall Survival
88/214 (41.1%) deaths at median 12.7y
10y OS estimate: 74.0%
110/211 (52.1%) deaths at median 12.5y 10y OS estimate: 66.0%
130/502 (25.9%) deaths at median 10.6y 10y OS estimate: 76.9%
115/503 (22.9%) deaths at median 10.6y
10y OS estimate: 80.7%
5/148 (3.4%) deaths at median 4.5y
23/148 (15.5%) deaths at 14y
8/159 (5.0%) deaths at median 4.5y
20/159 (12.6%) deaths at 14y
Comparison: HR=0.72 (95%
CI=0.55–0.96; p=0.023)
Comparison: HR=1.18 (95% CI=
0.91–1.53; p=0.20)
Appendix C. Risk factor subgroup findings from RCTs
SWOG 8794 EORTC 22911 ARO 96-02
Gleason 2-6 Met RFS:
Obs. = RT**
(HR approx. 0.90, CI 0.55-1.50)
Biochem RFS:
Obs < RT****
(HR approx. 0.44; CI 0.26-0.82)
Biochem RFS:
Obs < RT†
(HR 0.42, CI 0.20-0.89)
Obs < RT#
(HR 0.47, CI 0.26-0.83)
Gleason 7-10 Met RFS:
Obs. < RT**
(HR approx. 0.58, CI 0.35-0.92)
Biochem RFS:
Gleason 7: Obs < RT****
but dif n.s. (HR approx.
0.63; CI 0.38-1.00)
-Gleason 8-10: Obs <
RT****
but dif n.s. (HR
approx. 0.52; CI 0.26-
1.20)
Biochem RFS:
Obs < RT†
(HR 0.59, CI 0.37-0.95)
Obs < RT#
(HR 0.52, CI 0.36-0.77)
No SVI Not reported Biochem RFS:
Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.43, CI 0.35-
0.54)
Clin RFS: Obs. =
RT***
(HR 0.8; CI 0.61-1.04)
Overall survival: Obs. =
RT***
(HR 1.30, CI 0.95-
1.77)
Not reported
SVI Biochem RFS:
Obs < RT*
(HR 0.23, CI 0.06 to 0.84)
Met RFS: Obs. < RT**
but dif ns (HR approx. 0.68, CI 0.42-1.07)
Clin RFS: Obs = RT*
(HR 0.76, CI 0.33 to 1.74)
Biochem RFS:
Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.60, CI 0.44-
0.82)
Clin RFS: Obs. = RT***
(HR 0.82; CI 0.58-1.16)
Overall survival: Obs. =
RT***
(HR 1.00, CI 0.66-
1.52)
Biochem RFS:
Obs = RT†
but dif n.s. (pT3c: HR 0.77, CI 0.42-1.40)
SWOG 8794 EORTC 22911 ARO 96-02
Negative margins Not reported Biochem RFS:
Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.61, CI 0.45-
0.81)
Clin RFS:
Obs. = RT***
(HR 1.08;
CI 0.78-1.55)
Overall survival:
Obs. > RT***
(HR 1.68, CI
1.10- 2.56)
Biochem RFS:
Obs = RT†
(HR 0.95, CI 0.47-1.93)
Obs = RT#
(HR 0.80, CI 0.45-1.43)
Positive margins Biochem RFS:
Obs. < RT*
(HR 0.44, CI 0.3 to
0.65))
Clin RFS:
Obs < RT*
(HR 0.64, CI 0.45 to 0.93)
Biochem RFS:
Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.44, CI 0.35-
0.75)
Clin RFS:
Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.69; CI 0.53-0.91)
Overall survival:
Obs. = RT***
(HR 0.98,
CI 0.72-
1.34)
Biochem RFS:
Obs < RT†
(HR 0.41, CI 0.25-0.66)
Obs < RT#
(HR 0.39, CI 0.27-0.57)
No EPE Not reported Biochem RFS: Obs. <
RT***
(HR 0.51, CI 0.35-
0.75)
Clin RFS: Obs. = RT***
(HR 0.78; CI 0.49-1.24)
Overall survival: Obs. =
RT***
(HR= 1.21, 95%
CI=0.70-2.08)
1.21, CI 0.70-
2.08)
Not reported
EPE Not reported Biochem RFS: Obs. <
RT***
(HR 0.49, CI 0.40-
0.60)
Clin RFS: Obs. = RT***
(HR 0.83; CI 0.65-1.05)
Overall survival: Obs. =
RT***
(HR 1.16, CI 0.88-
1.54)
Biochem RFS:
Obs < RT†
(pT3a/b: HR 0.34, CI 0.19-0.64)
Obs < RT#
(pT3a/b: HR 0.37, CI 0.24-0.58)
SWOG 8794 EORTC 22911 ARO 96-02
EPE or Positive margins Met RFS: Obs. < RT**
but dif n.s. (HR approx. 0.73, CI 0.52-1.08)
Not reported Not reported
SVI and Positive margins
Biochem RFS: Obs < RT*
(HR 0.40, CI 0.20-0.77)
Clin RFS: Obs < RT*
(HR
0.47, CI 0.27-0.81)
Not reported Not reported
Age Not reported Biochem RFS:
-<65 y: Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.43, CI 0.33-0.56)
-65-69 y: Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.46, CI 0.34-0.61)
-≥70 y: Obs. < RT***
but dif n.s. (HR 0.75, CI 0.52-1.08)
Clin RFS:
-<65 y: Obs. < RT***
(HR 0.57, CI 0.40-0.79)
-65-69 y: Obs. = RT***
(HR 0.81, CI 0.57-1.15)
-≥70 y: Obs. > RT***
(HR 1.78, CI 1.14-2.78) Overall survival:
-<65 y: Obs. = RT***
(HR 0.91, CI 0.60-1.39)
-65-69 y: Obs. = RT***
(HR 0.97, CI 0.65-1.44)
-≥70 y: Obs. < RT***
(HR 2.94, CI 1.75-4.93)
Not reported
* Thompson23 median 10.6 years follow-up; all bRFS analyses conducted in patient subset of 348 who
had post-RP PSA </= 0.4 ng/ml **
Thompson24 median 12.7 years follow-up for RT group; median 12.5 years follow-up for Observ group; all bRFS analyses conducted in patient subset of 348 who had post-RP PSA </= 0.4 ng/ml ***
Bolla25 median 10.6 years follow-up ****
Van der Kwast322 patient subset (n=552) of total eligible sample (n=972) who had central pathology review; included here are data from Fig. 2 which consists of only patient with post-RP PSA ≤ 0.2 ng/ml †
Wiegel26 median 4.5 years follow-up; 1992 AJCC – pT3a/b – EPE; pT3c – SVI #
Wiegel27 median 9.3 years follow-up
Appendix D. Hormone therapy RCT data
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Country France North America (USA/Canada)
Funding source French Ministry of Health, Astra
Zeneca and La Ligue Contre le
Cancer
National Cancer Institute and Astra
Zeneca
Study period 2006 - 2010 1998 – 2003
Overall sample
size
743 760
Inclusion criteria - men aged 18y or older
- pathological T2-T4a prostate
adenocarcinoma with N0/NX
disease
- had undergone radical
prostatectomy
- must have PSA level < 0.1
ng/ ml for at least 6 months
after surgery and then rose to
0.2 to less than 2.0 ng/ml,
confirmed by two consecutive
tests without evidence of
clinical disease
- Eastern Cooperative Oncology
Group performance status of
0 to 1
- Have adequate cardiac
function including controlled
hypertension
- life expectancy of 10 years or
more
- men who had undergone
radical prostatectomy +
lymphadenectomy
- pathological T2 or T3 disease
without nodal involvement
(N0)
- detectable PSA at least 8
weeks after surgery ranging
from 0.2-4.0 ng/ml
- Karnofsky performance status
score of ≥80
- no previous use of hormone
therapy unless for short-term
pre-operative indication; 2-6
months prior to surgery (6.4%
of enrollees)
- life expectancy of more than
10 years
Exclusion criteria - have pituitary adenoma
- history of receiving previous
androgen deprivation therapy
or pelvic radiation therapy
- history of invasive cancer in
the past 5 years
- receiving other cancer
treatment at the time of
enrollment
- had evidence of distant
metastasis
- had evidence of liver disease
- had history of previous
chemotherapy or radiation for
prostate cancer
- had persistent urinary
extravasation after
prostatectomy
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Intervention arm SRT + goserelin (n=369)
Hormone therapy protocol:
Goserelin acetate 10.8 mg was
given by subcutaneous injection
on the first day of radiation.
Another subcutaneous injection
of goserelin acetate 10.8 mg was
given 3 months later (duration of
hormone therapy: 6 months)
SRT protocol:
- All received 3D conformal
radiotherapy (3D-CRT) or
intensity modulated
radiotherapy (IMRT)
- Total dose: 66 Gy in 33
fractions, 5 days a week (SRT
duration = 7 weeks)
- Seminal vesicles received up
to 50 Gy for T3b disease only
- Those who did not have node
dissection and at least 15%
risk of nodal involvement
received pelvic irradiation, up
to a dose of 46 Gy (2
Gy/fraction)
SRT + bicalutamide (n=376)
Hormone therapy protocol:
- Oral bicalutamide 150mg OD
- First dose at initiation of
radiotherapy and then
provided daily for the next 24
months
SRT protocol:
- Radiation initiated within 12
weeks after randomization;
targeted toward original
prostatic site, tumor bed and
membranous urethra
- Total dose: 64.8 Gy in 36 daily
fractions of 1.8 Gy at five
sessions per week (SRT
duration = 7.2 weeks)
- No one received pelvic
irradiation
Control arm SRT alone (n=373)
SRT protocol:
- Same as above
SRT + placebo (n=384)
Placebo protocol:
One placebo tablet given daily
from day one of radiation and
for the next 24 months (same
as hormone therapy protocol
above)
SRT protocol:
Same as above
Type of hormone
therapy
Goserelin is a GnRH agonist Bicalutamide is an anti-androgen
Median follow-up
duration
5.3y 13y
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Follow-up
protocol
Initial staging for baseline
information included
measurement of PSA
concentration and clinical exam.
PSA measured every 6 months
for five years and every year
thereafter.
Radiographical assessment was
only performed where evidence
of clinical or biochemical
progression was present.
Definition of biochemical
recurrence: confirmed by 2
consecutive tests at 2-month
intervals; PSA above nadir of
more than 0.5 ng/ml or clinical
evidence of disease
Quality of life and functional
dependence evaluated at
randomization, 1 year and 5
years follow up after end of
radiotherapy using QLQ-C30 and
QLQ-PR25 questionnaires.
At initiation and end of
radiotherapy, every 3 months
after radiotherapy for fist 2 years
and every 6 months for 3 years,
then yearly: clinical history,
physical exam, Karnofsky
performance-status score, CBC,
PSA level, serum ALT, serum
bilirubin, adverse effects were
measured.
At subsequent biochemical
recurrence after randomization,
bone and CT scans were
performed.
Definition of biochemical
recurrence: second recurrence
was defined as an increase of at
least 0.3 ng/ml above the lowest
detectable PSA after protocol
treatment. The lowest detectable
PSA decreased from 0.5 ng/ml to
0.2 ng/ml during the years of
enrollment. Third biochemical
recurrence occurred when PSA
reached 0.5 ng/ml or higher or
when there was disease
progression after the start of
salvage hormone therapy.
If metastatic disease was
discovered or if serum PSA >4.0
ng/ml, maximum androgen
blockade was instituted.
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Outcomes
measured and
definitions
Primary outcome: Progression-
free survival defined as time from
randomization to documented
biochemical or clinical
progression, or both; death from
any cause, or censoring at date
of last follow-up.
Secondary outcomes:
Overall survival
Acute and late toxicities
Metastasis-free survival
Time from randomization to
nadir PSA
Changes in quality of life
Changes in functional
dependence among men older
than 75y
Primary outcome: Overall survival
Secondary outcomes:
Disease-specific death: all
death from prostate cancer or
treatment complications, or
unknown cause in a patient
with active prostate cancer
Non-disease-specific death:
death from any other cause
but the above
Distant metastasis: requires
radiographic confirmation from
bone or CT scans
Local disease progression:
development of palpable mass
in prostatic fossa, determined
by clinical exam
Any disease progression
including biochemical
recurrence
Acute and late toxicities
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Baseline
characteristics
Median age = 67y
Race & ethnicity: NR
Disease stage T3a/3b = 342
(46.0%); N0 = 547 (74%)
ECOG performance status 0 =
674 (90.8%)
Gleason score ≥8 = 81 (11%)
Positive surgical margins = 371
(50%)
No seminal vesicle involvement =
630 (85%)
Median PSA at randomization =
0.3 ng/ ml
Median interval between surgery
and recurrence = 2.5y (control) -
2.8y (intervention)
Median age = 65y
Race & ethnicity: White = 668
(87.9%); Black = 68 (8.9%);
Hispanic = 9 (1.2%); Other = 15
(2.0%)
Disease stage: T2 = 248 (32.6%)
and T3 = 512 (67.4%)
Karnofsky performance status
score of 100 = 576 (75.8%)
Gleason score: 2-6 = 214
(28.2%); 7 = 413 (54.5%); 8-10
= 131 (17.3%)
Positive surgical margin = 569
(74.9%)
Neoadjuvant hormone use = 49
(6.4%)
Median PSA at trial entry = 0.6
ng/ml
PSA nadir after surgery of <0.5
ng/ml = 670 (88.2%)
Median interval between surgery
and first detectable PSA = 1.4y
Median interval between surgery
and trial entry = 2.1y
BMI = NR
Comorbidities = NR
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Primary outcome Progression-free survival
At median follow up of 63 months
(5.3 years):
Number with disease progression:
SRT + Goserelin = 66/369 (18%)
SRT alone = 124/373 (33%)
Median duration between
randomization and disease
progression:
SRT+Goserelin = 32 months
(IQR=26-44)
SRT alone = 22 months (IQR=14-
38)
5-year progression-free survival:
SRT+Goserelin = 80% (95%
CI=75-84)
SRT alone = 62% (95% CI=57-67)
HR for progression = 0.50, 95% CI
= 0.38-0.66; P<0.0001 – favoring
SRT + Goserelin
Overall survival
At 12 years follow-up:
Bicalutamide = 76.3%
Placebo = 71.3%
Overall survival at 12 years by
subgroups (bicalutamide vs.
placebo):
a) Gleason 2-6 = 79.5% vs. 79.2%
b) Gleason 7 = 78.5% vs. 70.9%
c) Gleason 8-10 = 63.9% vs. 58.4%
d) PSA of <0.7 ng/ml at trial entry =
76.8% vs. 80.7%
e) PSA of 0.7-1.5 ng/ml at trial entry
= 77.0% vs. 67.5%
f) PSA of >1.5 ng/ml at trial entry =
73.5% vs. 48.9%
g) Negative surgical margin = 73.5%
vs. 72.9%
h) Positive surgical margin = 77.3%
vs. 70.7%
HR for death for all patients = 0.77;
95% CI = 0.59 – 0.99; P=0.04)
HR for death in each of these
subgroups:
a) Gleason 2-6 = 0.95; 95% CI =
0.57 - 1.59; P=0.84
b) Gleason 7 = 0.69; 95% CI = 0.49
– 0.98; P=0.04
c) Gleason 8-10 = 0.76; 95% CI =
0.44 – 1.30; P=0.32
d) PSA of <0.7 ng/ml at trial entry =
1.13; 95% CI = 0.77 – 1.65; P=0.53
e) PSA of 0.7-1.5 ng/ml at trial entry
= 0.61; 95% CI = 0.39 – 0.95;
P=0.03
f) PSA of >1.5 ng/ml at trial entry =
0.45; 95% CI = 0.25 – 0.81;
P=0.007
g) Negative surgical margin = 0.87;
95% CI = 0.53 – 1.41; P=0.56)
h) Positive surgical margin = 0.73;
95% CI = 0.54 – 0.98; P=0.04
On multivariable analysis (Cox),
significant negative prognostic
factors were: being assigned to
placebo, age ≥65 years,
PSA>1.5ng/ml at trial entry, Gleason
score of 8-10, and Karnofsky performance status score of 80-90.
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Other outcomes Median duration from randomization to nadir PSA was 3.0 months (IQR=2.3-7.6) in
intervention arm and 9.4 months (IQR=7.3-17.5) in the control arm
Total number died at 5 years:
SRT+Goserelin = 17/369 (5%) SRT alone = 26/374 (7%)
5-year OS SRT+Goserelin = 96% (93-98) SRT alone = 95% (92-97)
HR = 0.70; 95% CI 0.40-1.2; P=0.18
Quality of life scores
Number of respondents at baseline=615 (83%) Number of respondents at 1 year=403 (55%) Number of respondents at 5
years=163 (22%) QLQ-C30 global QoL score (at 5y compared to baseline) SRT+Goserelin: improved = 18%; worsened = 31%
SRT alone: improved = 20%;
worsened = 30%
Changes in functional dependence among men older than 75 years of age Number of men >75 years = 71;
only 44 (62%) returned IADL questionnaire at inclusion, 16 (23%) at 1 year, and 13 (18%) at 5 years, not allowing for analysis
*No data for metastasis-free survival was available
12-year disease-specific death: Bicalutamide = 5.8% Placebo = 13.4%
HR for death = 0.49 (95% CI = 0.32 – 0.74); P<0.001 12-year non-disease-specific
death: Bicalutamide = 17.9% Placebo = 15.3%
HR for death = 1.10 (95% CI = 0.79 – 1.53); P=0.53 12-year cumulative incidence of
metastatic disease: Bicalutamide = 14.5%
Placebo = 23.0% HR for metastases = 0.63 (95% CI = 0.46 – 0.87); P=0.005 Subgroup analysis for incidence of metastases: a) Gleason 8-10: HR = 0.35 (95% CI =
0.18-0.67); P=0.001 b) PSA>1.5 ng/ml at trial entry: HR = 0.36 (95% CI = 0.15 – 0.84); P=0.01 c) Positive surgical margin: HR = 0.56 (95% CI = 0.38 – 0.84); P=0.005
12-year cumulative incidence of
second biochemical recurrence: Bicalutamide = 44.0% Placebo = 67.9% HR for second biochemical recurrence = 0.48 (95% CI = 0.40 – 0.58); P<0.001
12-year cumulative incidence of
third biochemical recurrence: Bicalutamide = 84.2% Placebo = 80.7% HR for third biochemical recurrence = 1.11 (95% CI = 0.85 – 1.46); P=0.43
12-year cumulative incidence of local progression:
Bicalutamide = 1.8% Placebo = 4.7% HR for local progression = 0.36 (95% CI = 0.15 – 0.85); P=0.02
12-year cumulative incidence of
any disease progression: Bicalutamide = 47.1% Placebo = 69.2% HR for any disease progression = 0.51
(95% CI = 0.42 -0.61); P<0.001
GETUG-AFU 16 (Carrie 2016) RTOG 9601 (Shipley 2017)
Early toxicity Grade 2 or worse genitourinary
toxicity: Goserelin = 13%; SRT
alone = 11%
Grade 2 or worse gastrointestinal
toxicity: Goserelin = 12%; SRT
alone = 14%
From text: no difference in rates of
early urinary, bowel, hematologic,
skin or other toxicities. Toxicities
were primarily Grade 1-2 toxicities.
Late toxicity Grade 3 or worse genitourinary
toxicity: Goserelin = 7%; SRT
alone = 8%
Grade 3 or worse gastrointestinal
toxicity: Goserelin = 2%; SRT
alone = 1%
Grade 3 or worse sexual disorder:
Goserelin = 8%; SRT alone = 5%
Grade 1-3 hot flashes: Goserelin
= 45%; SRT alone = 1%
Grade 1-3 sweating: 13%; SRT
alone = 0%
Genitourinary toxicity:-
Grade 3: Bicalutamide = 2.4%;
Placebo = 1.3%
Grade 4: Bicalutamide = 0.3%;
Placebo = 0.8%
Gastrointestinal toxicity:-
Grade 3: Bicalutamide = 7.0%;
Placebo = 6.0%
Grade 4: Bicalutamide = 0.3%;
Placebo = 0.3%
Liver toxicity:-
Grade 2: Bicalutamide = 1.6%;
Placebo = 0.8%
Grade 3: Bicalutamide = 0.8%;
Placebo = 0.3%
Hematologic toxicity:-
Grade 3: Bicalutamide = 1.6%;
Placebo = 0.5%
Grade 4: Bicalutamide = 0.0%;
Placebo = 0.5%
Gynecomastia:-
Grade 2: Bicalutamide = 24.1%;
Placebo = 2.1%
Grade 3: Bicalutamide = 3.7%;
Placebo = 0.0%
Cardiac:-
Grade 3: Bicalutamide = 2.7%;
Placebo = 0.3%
Grade 4: Bicalutamide = 1.3%;
Placebo = 1.3%
Appendix E. RTOG Acute and RTOG/EORTC Late Radiation Morbidity Scoring Criteria
Acute Late
Gastrointestinal Genitourinary Gastrointestinal Genitourinary
Grade 0 No change No change None None
Grade 1 Anorexia with ≤5% weight loss; nausea, abdominal discomfort, increased frequency or change in bowel habits,
rectal discomfort; no need for medications
urinary frequency or nocturia that is twice pre- treatment levels, dysuria, urgency; no need for medications
mild diarrhea, mild cramping, bowel movement 5/day, slight rectal discharge or
bleeding
slight bladder epithelial atrophy, minor telangiectasia (microscopic
hematuria)
Grade 2 anorexia with ≤15% weight loss, nausea and/or
vomiting or abdominal pain requiring medication, diarrhea requiring parasympatholytics, mucus discharge not requiring sanitary pads, rectal/abdominal pain
requiring analgesics
urinary frequency or nocturia that is <1/hour,
dysuria, urgency, bladder spasm requiring local anesthetic (e.g., Pyridium)
moderate diarrhea and colic, bowel
movement >5/day, excessive mucus or intermittent bleeding
moderate frequency,
generalized telangiectasia, intermittent macroscopic hematuria
Grade 3 anorexia with >15% weight loss or nausea/vomiting or diarrhea requiring nasogastric (NG) tube or
parenteral support; abdominal pain that is severe despite medications, hematemesis or melena, abdominal distension; severe
mucus/blood discharge requiring sanitary pads
urinary frequency with urgency and nocturia hourly or more frequently with dysuria, pelvis pain or bladder spasm
requiring regular frequent narcotics or gross hematuria with/without clot passage
Obstruction or bleeding requiring surgery
Severe frequency and dysuria, severe generalized telangiectasia
(often with petechiae), frequent hematuria, reduction in bladder capacity
(<150 cc)
Grade 4 ileus, subacute or acute obstruction, fistula,
perforation, GI bleeding requiring transfusion, abdominal pain requiring tube decompression or bowel diversion
hematuria requiring transfusion, acute bladder
obstruction not secondary to clot passage; ulceration or necrosis
Necrosis, perforation, fistula
Necrosis, contracted
bladder (capacity <100 cc), severe hemorrhage, cystitis
Appendix F: Acute Toxicity Effects of Radiotherapy After Prostatectomy
(Ranges based on RTOG or CTCAE Grading Systems)
Genitourinary Gastrointestinal
Study Arm Type Grade 1-2 Grade 3-4 Grade 1-2 Grade 3-4
Adjuvant 10.5 - 26% 2.0 - 8.0% 22.0 – 25.0% 0.0 – 2.0%
Salvage 3.0 - 82.0% 0.0 – 6.0% 2.9 – 96.0% 0.0 – 2.2%
Mixed 5.0 – 92.0% 0.0 – 3.0% 4.3 – 87.0% 0.0 – 1.3%
Appendix G. Late Toxicity Effects of Radiotherapy After Prostatectomy
(Ranges based on RTOG/EORTC or CTCAE Grading Systems)
Genitourinary Gastrointestinal
Study Arm Type Grade 1-2 Grade 3-4 Grade 1-2 Grade 3-4
Adjuvant 2.0 – 22.0% 0.0 - 10.6% 1.0 – 12.7% 0.0 – 6.7%
Salvage 1.0 – 49.0% 0.0 – 6.0% 0.0 – 66.0% 0.0 – 18.0%
Mixed 1.3 – 79.0% 0.0 – 17.0% 2.0 – 59.0% 0.0 – 4.3%