+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes,...

Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes,...

Date post: 29-May-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 7 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
8
Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy William F. Schmalstieg, MD Brian G. Weinshenker, MD Neurology ® Clinical Practice 2010;75(Suppl 1):S2–S8 I mproved understanding of the differential diagnosis and improved investigative tech- niques, particularly neuroimaging and sero- logic testing, have facilitated the diagnosis of patients with acute and subacute myelopathy and reduced the proportion of patients who are labeled as having “idiopathic transverse myelitis.” Addi- tionally, these advances have identified subgroups of patients in whom progression of deficit or fu- ture relapses are anticipated, allowing intervention and prophylaxis as appropriate. However, early management remains empiric and consists of high- dose corticosteroids for most patients. In the event of an inadequate response to corticosteroids or a subsequent atypical course, further investigations to detect diagnoses other than “transverse myelitis” should be considered and additional treatments, such as plasmapheresis, may be appropriate. Indi- vidualized diagnosis and treatment is more feasible now than in the past. IS IT AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY? Localizing an acute neurologic process to the spinal cord is often, but not always, straightforward (table 1). The as- cending sensory symptoms of acute inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (AIDP) may confuse the diagnosis, as this complaint is also highly associated with acute myelopathy. Un- equivocal upper motor neuron signs exclude AIDP, but are often not apparent in the early stages of a spinal cord insult. Although not invariably present, an unequivocal sensory level on the torso, sensory loss indicating involvement of spinal tracts (e.g., spinothalamic modality impairment contralateral to motor findings), or urinary retention localize to the spinal cord. Myopathy or neuromuscular junction disor- ders may be mistaken for myelopathy, particularly if the lower limbs are predominantly affected, but the absence of any sensory abnormality should suggest the correct localization. Bilateral mesial frontal lobe lesions (e.g., bilateral anterior cerebral artery distribution infarcts) could mimic a myelopathy, although abulia or other signs of frontal lobe dysfunction typically coexist. Autoimmune or paraneoplastic muscle stiffness syn- dromes, such as stiff-person syndrome associated with glutamic acid decarboxylase or amphiphysin autoanti- bodies, may be confused with spasticity and erroneously lead one to suspect myelopathy. Occasionally patients with chronic myelopathy may present a history that mistakenly suggests an acute process. For example, patients with primary progressive multiple sclerosis (MS) may experience acute, transient worsening (pseudoexacerbation) in the setting of an underlying infection or heat exposure. In such cases, careful history will uncover symptoms that have been insidiously progressive over a longer interval than first From the Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, Rochester, MN. Disclosure: Author disclosures are provided at the end of the article. Illustration by Amy P. Collins Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr. Brian G. Weinshenker, Department of Neurology, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, 200 1st Street SW, Rochester, MN 55905 [email protected] S2 Copyright © 2010 by AAN Enterprises, Inc.
Transcript
Page 1: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy

William F SchmalstiegMD

Brian G WeinshenkerMD

Neurologyreg Clinical Practice201075(Suppl 1)S2ndashS8

Improved understanding of the differentialdiagnosis and improved investigative tech-niques particularly neuroimaging and sero-

logic testing have facilitated the diagnosis ofpatients with acute and subacute myelopathy andreduced the proportion of patients who are labeledas having ldquoidiopathic transverse myelitisrdquo Addi-tionally these advances have identified subgroupsof patients in whom progression of deficit or fu-ture relapses are anticipated allowing interventionand prophylaxis as appropriate However earlymanagement remains empiric and consists of high-dose corticosteroids for most patients In the eventof an inadequate response to corticosteroids or asubsequent atypical course further investigationsto detect diagnoses other than ldquotransverse myelitisrdquoshould be considered and additional treatmentssuch as plasmapheresis may be appropriate Indi-vidualized diagnosis and treatment is more feasiblenow than in the past

IS IT AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY Localizing anacute neurologic process to the spinal cord is oftenbut not always straightforward (table 1) The as-cending sensory symptoms of acute inflammatorydemyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (AIDP)may confuse the diagnosis as this complaint is alsohighly associated with acute myelopathy Un-equivocal upper motor neuron signs excludeAIDP but are often not apparent in the early

stages of a spinal cord insult Although not invariably present an unequivocal sensory level on the torsosensory loss indicating involvement of spinal tracts (eg spinothalamic modality impairment contralateral tomotor findings) or urinary retention localize to the spinal cord Myopathy or neuromuscular junction disor-ders may be mistaken for myelopathy particularly if the lower limbs are predominantly affected but theabsence of any sensory abnormality should suggest the correct localization Bilateral mesial frontal lobe lesions(eg bilateral anterior cerebral artery distribution infarcts) could mimic a myelopathy although abulia orother signs of frontal lobe dysfunction typically coexist Autoimmune or paraneoplastic muscle stiffness syn-dromes such as stiff-person syndrome associated with glutamic acid decarboxylase or amphiphysin autoanti-bodies may be confused with spasticity and erroneously lead one to suspect myelopathy

Occasionally patients with chronic myelopathy may present a history that mistakenly suggests an acuteprocess For example patients with primary progressive multiple sclerosis (MS) may experience acute transientworsening (pseudoexacerbation) in the setting of an underlying infection or heat exposure In such casescareful history will uncover symptoms that have been insidiously progressive over a longer interval than first

From the Department of Neurology Mayo Clinic College of Medicine Rochester MN

Disclosure Author disclosures are provided at the end of the article

Illustration by Amy P Collins

Address correspondence andreprint requests to Dr Brian GWeinshenker Department ofNeurology Mayo Clinic Collegeof Medicine 200 1st Street SWRochester MN 55905weinbmayoedu

S2 Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc

suspected Patients with myelopathy who have noclear lesion on spinal MRI or multiple chronic-appearing lesions should be questioned to uncoversubtle previous symptoms of chronic myelopathyand examined to detect cognitive or bulbar impair-ment localizing elsewhere in the nervous system

WHEN IT IS AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY WHATCAUSES SHOULD BE CONSIDERED In pa-tients with recent onset symptoms particularly onesthat evolve rapidly the initial priority is to exclude asurgical emergency such as epidural metastasis or ab-scess When the index of suspicion for an acute com-pressive lesion is high immediate imaging isrequired ideally with MRI of the entire spine If im-aging demonstrates spinal cord compression due toan acute lesion such as epidural metastasis definitivemanagement (ie surgery) should be pursued with-out delay to prevent rapid and irreversible worsening

Often the cause of an acute or subacute myelopa-thy is inapparent after an initial evaluation In a re-cent French series of patients presenting with acutenoncompressive myelopathy 101170 (594) wereof uncertain cause initially although 55101(544) patients were ultimately diagnosed with ademyelinating or inflammatory disorder After aver-age follow-up of 732 months 49170 (288) had afinal diagnosis of myelopathy of uncertain etiologyThe most commonly identified causes were demyeli-nating disorders (MS and neuromyelitis optica) spi-nal cord infarction parainfectious myelitis and

systemic inflammatory disorders (eg Sjogren syn-drome and lupus)1

Transverse myelitis is the default diagnosis for anunexplained myelopathy evolving over the course ofdays to 3 weeks with subsequent stabilization or im-provement In practice there are no satisfactory waysto distinguish among idiopathic transverse myelitisparainfectious myelitis and postvaccinial myelitisWhen a viral illness occurs in close temporal associa-tion parainfectious myelitis is often diagnosed butthe causal role of the associated infection is difficultto determine for an individual patient One can con-fidently link the two only when myelitis occurs con-currently or within days of an infection known to beassociated with myelitis (eg zoster) or when investi-gation such as CSF PCR demonstrates unequivocalevidence of CNS infection

Nevertheless serologic evidence of recent infectionwith pathogens known to be associated with myelopa-thy (eg enteroviruses Chlamydia Mycoplasma) maylimit the need for further diagnostic investigations in anotherwise unexplained myelopathy Features suggestingan infectious etiology include fever rash (zoster entero-virus Lyme disease) meningismus a history of recenttravel (tuberculosis parasitic infections such as schisto-somiasis with travel to endemic regions) suspected ra-bies exposure or immunosuppression (herpes zostercytomegalovirus) It is particularly important to con-sider treatable infections such as syphilis HIV tubercu-losis Lyme disease and herpesviruses

Occasionally patients withchronic myelopathy maypresent a history thatmistakenly suggests an acuteprocess

Other diagnoses that may be made confidently inmost instances include cord compression vasculardisorders toxicmetabolic syndromes neoplasmparaneoplastic syndromes and sarcoidosis Althoughcompression is often obvious as the cause of myelop-athy on MRI spinal stenosis may cause impressiveand occasionally longitudinally extensive T2 signalabnormalities (3 vertebral segments) on spinalMRI that may lead one to suspect an inflammatorymyelopathy Circumscribed gadolinium enhance-ment at the point of maximal stenosis and a historyof progressive symptoms over many weeks to monthsare consistent findings in such cases (figure 1 A andB)2 Vascular myelopathies include those due to in-farction resulting from arterial embolism or hypo-perfusion hemorrhage or vascular malformationsassociated with venous hypertension Dural arterio-

Table 1 Distinguishing acute myelopathyfrom mimics

Signs strongly indicating myelopathy

Sensory level on torso

Spinal tract crossed findings (eg unilateral pyramidal signswith contralateral spinothalamic findings)

Spinal tract-specific sensory findings (eg selectivespinothalamic findings with preserved dorsal columnfindings suspended band of spinothalamic sensory loss)

Urinary retention

Signs consistent with but not diagnostic of myelopathy

Glove-and-stocking sensory loss (consider peripheralneuropathy)

Hyporeflexiahypotonia (consider peripheral neuropathy)

Unilateral or bilateral upper motor neuron signs (considerbrain or brainstem disorders)

Signs suggesting alternative diagnosis

Spasms rather than spasticity (consider stiff-personsyndrome)

Paratonic rigidity (consider frontal lobe disorder)

Cognitive impairment (consider frontal lobe or diffuse braindisorder)

Dysarthria and dysphagia (consider brainstem disorder suchas motor neuron disease)

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S3

Figure 1 MRI of representative cases of acute and subacute myelopathies

(A B) Sagittal T2 and gadolinium-enhanced T1 MRI showing longitudinally extensive cord signal change (A) and focal signet ringgadolinium enhancement (B) due to severe spinal stenosis (C) Sagittal T2 and axial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI demon-strating longitudinally extensive tract-specific lateral column enhancement due to paraneoplastic disorder in a patient withrenal cell carcinoma (D) Sagittal gadolinium-enhanced T1 and axial T2 (inset) MRI demonstrating focal enhancement and T2signal change in the periphery of the cord in a patient with partial transverse myelitis due to multiple sclerosis (E) Sagittal T2 andaxial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI showing longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis extending rostrally into the me-dulla and central cord enhancement due to neuromyelitis opticandashassociated myelitis (F) Sagittal and axial T2 (inset) MRI showinganterior cord signal change due to anterior spinal artery infarct (G) Sagittal and axial T2 (inset) MRI longitudinally extensivesignal change extending to the conus and flow voids (eccentric to the left side of the cord) characteristic of dural arteriovenous fistula(H) Sagittal and axial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI demonstrating nodular and subpial enhancement due to sarcoidosis

S4 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

venous fistula (DAVF)ndashassociated myelopathies maybe distinguished by the distinctive history of stepwiseprogression or transient worsening precipitated bywalking or prolonged standing This myelopathy canbe successfully treated by obliteration of the fistulaand should not be missed Toxic myelopathy due tonitrous oxide abuse is a consideration in younger pa-tients and medical professionals patients with under-lying vitamin B12 deficiency are particularlyvulnerable Vitamin and trace metal deficiencies usu-ally cause chronic myelopathies but as these etiolo-gies are readily treatable vitamin B12 and copperlevels should be tested in unexplained steroid nonre-sponsive myelopathy Spinal cord tumors maypresent subacutely or with apoplectic onset in thecase of hemorrhage into tumor and are usuallyreadily identifiable on MRI although rarely theymay be mistaken radiologically for myelitis Screen-ing for serum paraneoplastic autoantibodies includ-ing collapsin response mediator protein-5 (CRMP-5)antibody3 should be considered in patients withknown cancer constitutional symptoms smokinghistory or suggestive neuroradiology with isolated

tract-specific involvement Sarcoidosis may presentas isolated myelopathy Definitive diagnosis requiresbiopsy evidence of noncaseating granulomatous inflam-mation either from the nervous system or other in-volved organs A high serum angiotensin-convertingenzyme level is suggestive but nonspecific A diagnosisof isolated CNS sarcoidosis should be suspected whensubacute myelopathy is accompanied by patchy asym-metric slowly evolving and persistently enhancing gad-olinium cord lesions A satisfactory therapeutic responseto empiric long-term (months to years) corticosteroidtreatment provides a reasonable basis for a tentative butusually correct diagnosis

WHAT CLINICAL FEATURES SUGGEST A PAR-TICULAR DIAGNOSIS The time course (figure2) specific spinal cord syndrome and symptomsother than those referable to the spinal cord may pro-vide useful clues as to the diagnosis Apoplectic onsetsuggests a cord infarct or spinal hemorrhage both ofwhich may worsen over hours to days Parainfectiousor idiopathic myelitis myelitis related to inflamma-tory demyelinating diseases and some paraneoplastic

Figure 2 Differential diagnosis of acute myelopathy Time course and MRI findings

Relapses upon withdrawal of corticosteroidsimmunosuppression MRI may be normal ADEM acute disseminated en-cephalomyelitis DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula HTLV human T-lymphotropic virus MS multiple sclerosis NMO

neuromyelitis optica SCD subacute combined degeneration SD systemic disease TM transverse myelitis

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S5

syndromes evolve over days to weeks but generallyreach a nadir within 3 weeks after which there iseither improvement or stability4 When a myelopa-thy develops insidiously or continues to progress af-ter 3 weeks transverse myelitis becomes unlikely andthe differential diagnosis includes an intrinsic cordtumor compressive lesion DAVF metabolic de-rangement sarcoidosis or a degenerative process

The clinical syndrome of spinal cord involvementmay suggest a particular etiology although none arespecific Incomplete Brown-Sequard syndrome (lossof pain and temperature sensation contralateral toweakness) may be associated with either compressionor an intrinsic cord lesion such as demyelination Ananterior spinal cord syndrome with bilateral cortico-spinal and spinothalamic involvement sparing dorsalcolumn function is typical of anterior spinal arterydistribution infarction but may also occur in MS Acomplete spinal cord syndrome with bilateral in-volvement of all spinal tracts is rarely caused by anMS relapse or infarct but may occur in idiopathic orneuromyelitis optica (NMO)ndashassociated transversemyelitis or cord compression NMO-associated my-elitis more commonly presents with clinical and im-

aging signs of central cord involvement than doesMS-associated myelitis which more commonly af-fects the periphery of the cord Highly selective tractinvolvement (eg pure corticospinal tract involve-ment) especially when confirmed by MRI evidenceof highly localized enhancing tractopathy is charac-teristic of a paraneoplastic disorder (figure 1C)

Neurologic or constitutional symptoms not refer-able to the spinal cord focus the differential diagno-sis but may be irrelevant and distract one from the truediagnosis Optic neuritis or a prior diagnosis of inter-mediate uveitis may suggest MS Severe optic neuri-tis and an episode of unexplained intractable nauseaor hiccoughs are characteristic of NMO5 Coexist-ing peripheral neuropathy can occur in sarcoidSjogren syndrome lupus metabolic disorders(eg subacute combined degeneration) and para-neoplastic syndromes

WHAT INVESTIGATIONS SHOULD BE PER-FORMED MRI scan of the spinal cord with andwithout gadolinium contrast is the initial investiga-tion of choice in the evaluation of acute myelopathyContraindications are limited to MRI-incompatibleferromagnetic medical devices or foreign bodies andincompatibility with the scanner due to habitusWith careful coordination between cardiologists andradiologists MRI can be performed in selected pa-tients with cardiac pacemakers who are not entirelypacemaker-dependent For patients unable to un-dergo MRI CT myelography may be consideredwhen cord compression is suspected CSF evaluationincluding cell count glucose protein oligoclonalbands immunoglobulin G (IgG) index and cytologyis appropriate unless imaging history and examina-tion already suggest a clear diagnosis The results ofspinal MRI and clinical suspicion should guide theselection of additional investigations (table 2)

For noncompressive myelopathy the results ofMRI can be broadly subdivided into 3 categories

1 Short T2 hyperintensity (3 vertebral segmentsin length)

Focal discrete lesions that do not occupy the en-tire cord in axial cross-section are highly sugges-tive of MS (figure 1D) although remotesometimes forgotten trauma can occasionally pro-duce such lesions MRI scan of the brain may helpto clarify the cause detection of 1 or more brainlesions typical of MS (discrete periventricularjuxtacortical or infratentorial T2 hyperintensefoci) correlates with at least an 85ndash90 futurerisk of developing MS6 Oligoclonal bands andelevated CSF IgG index help to confirm a sus-pected MS diagnosis but CSF analysis may be

Table 2 Utility of diagnostic tests in evaluation of myelopathy

Test used to evaluate for Sensitivitya Specificitya

Imaging studies

Spinal MRI Rule out compressiondefine etiology

Brain MRI MS

CT myelogram Cord compression

Spinal angiogram DAVF

CSF studies

Oligoclonal bands MS

IgG index MS

PCR for herpesviruses CNS herpesvirus infection

Cytology Intramedullary neoplasm

Serologic and other bloodtests

NMO IgG NMO

Antinuclear SSanticardiolipin antibodies

Systemic inflammatorydisease NMO

Angiotensin convertingenzyme

Sarcoidosis

Serologies for infectiousagents

Parainfectious or infectiousmyelopathy

Electrodiagnostic studies

EMG Myelopathy associated withperipheral neuropathy (egsarcoid Sjoumlgrenparaneoplastic)

Abbreviations DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula IgG immunoglobulin G MS multiplesclerosis NMO neuromyelitis optica SS Sjoumlgren syndromea The symbols and indicate low intermediate and high sensitivityspecificityrespectively

S6 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

superfluous if other clinical and radiographic fea-tures are highly suggestive

2 Longitudinally extensive T2 hyperintensity (3vertebral segments in length)

Longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis oc-curs in idiopathic transverse myelitis NMO (fig-ure 1E) acute disseminated encephalomyelitiscord infarction and myelitis associated with sys-temic diseases such as systemic lupus erythemato-sus Serum NMO IgG testing is indicated beforeassigning a diagnosis of idiopathic transverse my-elitis7 Brain lesions on MRI eventually occur inthe majority of patients with NMO but usuallyNMO does not lead to the discrete Dawson fingerpattern of periventricular lesions characteristic ofMS However confluent and linear lesions encir-cling the ventricles may occur in NMO CSF oligo-clonal bands are usually absent in NMOCertain patterns of signal abnormality on MRIpredict a vascular disorder Anterior and centralcord signal change and swelling with sparing ofthe posterior columns suggest infarct particularlyin patients with a suggestive history (figure 1F)Posterior flow voids on spinal MRI representingdilation of the epidural venous plexus are a fairlyspecific but less sensitive indicator of DAVFwhereas longitudinally extensive gadolinium en-hancement and T2 hyperintensity often extend-ing to the conus are typical but nonspecificfindings (figure 1G) Magnetic resonance angiog-raphy may help to visualize a DAVF but spinalangiography is required for definitive diagnosisand treatment

If symptoms suggestive of recent infection or CSFpleocytosis (50 leukocytesL) are presentCSF PCR testing for herpesviruses (eg herpessimplex cytomegalovirus varicella zoster) and se-rologic testing for HIV syphilis and Lyme dis-ease should be considered Prominent CSFpleocytosis and occasionally neutrophilic pleocy-tosis may occur in myelitis associated with NMOSymptoms and signs of systemic inflammatorydisease such as polyarthritis should prompt auto-immune serologic testing (ie antinuclear anti-bodies SS-A SS-B antibodies) In the absence ofclinical indications of these diseases positive sero-logic tests may be unimportant although they mayindicate NMO a quarter of NMO spectrum disor-der patients have nonspecific serologic evidence ofautoimmunity usually in the absence of clinicalsigns of other autoimmune disorders8 Indiscrimi-nate use of autoantibody testing in all patientswith myelitis is not recommended MRI find-ings including nodular and persisting (2

months) gadolinium enhancement or menin-geal and nerve root enhancement suggest sar-coidosis (figure 1H) or rarely lymphoma

3 Normal MRI

Patients with suspected myelopathy and appar-ently normal MRI should undergo careful reviewof the images for subtle findings of cord signalchange atrophy or extrinsic compression by un-common causes (eg epidural lipomatosis) If ex-amination demonstrates unequivocal evidence ofa spinal cord process and the MRI is normal con-sider and test for degenerative infectious andmetabolic causes of myelopathy EMG and nerveconduction studies occasionally help to identify aprimary peripheral process (eg AIDP) or my-elopathy associated with concomitant peripheralneuropathy as can be seen in sarcoidosis and sub-acute combined degeneration

HOW SHOULD AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY BETREATED Controlled studies of treatment of acutemyelitis are lacking In myelitis due to demyelinat-ing inflammatory or undetermined cause expertconsensus favors high-dose IV corticosteroids typi-cally 1 gram of IV methylprednisolone daily for 5days This treatment should not be withheld in thecase of suspected recent viral infection the role of ste-roid treatment in patients with definitive evidence fordirect viral infection of the cord (eg myelitis occurringsimultaneously with or within days of a zoster eruption)is unclear Plasmapheresis should be considered in pa-tients who continue to have significant impairment af-ter high-dose corticosteroids In a sham-controlled trialof plasma exchange in patients with an acute relapse ofdemyelinating disease unresponsive to corticosteroidtreatment many of whom had acute myelitis 8 of 19(421) treated patients experienced moderate tomarked improvement vs 1 of 17 (59) who receivedsham treatment9 There are no established treatmentsfor patients with cord infarction

Long-term treatment to reduce recurrent attacks orprogression of deficit is required for patients withNMO neurosarcoidosis and systemic inflammatorydisorders Options to be considered for NMO includeazathioprine mycophenolate mofetil mitoxantroneand rituximab Sarcoidosis is usually treated with pro-longed high-dose oral corticosteroids (eg prednisone 1mgkgday for 6ndash12 months) Oral steroids andsteroid-sparing immunosuppressive agents are also typi-cally prescribed when systemic inflammatory processesinvolve the nervous system Immunomodulatory treat-ment should be considered in patients who are at highrisk for developing relapsing-remitting MS by virtue ofhaving additional lesions on MRI of the head

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S7

Ongoing clinical observation is an important partof the care of patients with an unexplained myelopa-thy Subsequent appearance of new neurologic orsystemic symptoms may reveal a demyelinating orsystemic inflammatory disorder Patients with relent-lessly progressive symptoms despite appropriate em-piric treatment may require spinal cord biopsy fordefinitive diagnosis particularly when follow-up im-aging demonstrates worsening

DISCUSSION Acute and subacute myelopathies re-quire urgent medical evaluation Imaging preferablyby MRI should be performed without delay to ex-clude a compressive lesion Subsequently history andphysical examination should guide subsequent inves-tigations to reach a definitive diagnosis As the etiol-ogy is often unclear at initial presentation empirictreatment should be provided while conducting fur-ther investigations to determine the etiology of my-elopathy A thorough evaluation often revealsevidence of a treatable disorder or one that may re-lapse without preventive treatment

DISCLOSURE

Dr Schmalstieg reports no disclosures Dr Weinshenker has served on

data safety monitoring boards for Novartis and Biogen Idec serves on the

editorial boards of Multiple Sclerosis the Canadian Journal of Neurological

Sciences and the Turkish Journal of Neurology receives research support

from the Guthy-Jackson Charitable Foundation and receives license roy-

alties from RSR Ltd and may receive royalties from Mayo Medical Ven-

tures for a patentintellectual property re Aquaporin-4 associated

antibodies for diagnosis of neuromyelitis optica

Received July 14 2010 Accepted in final form September 2 2010

REFERENCES1 Debette S de Seze J Pruvo JP et al Long-term outcome

of acute and subacute myelopathies J Neurol 2009256980ndash988

2 Kelley BJ Erickson BJ Weinshenker BG Compressivemyelopathy mimicking transverse myelitis Neurologist201016120ndash122

3 Keegan BM Pittock SJ Lennon VA Autoimmune my-elopathy associated with collapsin response-mediatorprotein-5 immunoglobulin G Ann Neurol 200863531ndash534

4 Proposed diagnostic criteria and nosology of acute trans-verse myelitis Neurology 200259499ndash505

5 Takahashi T Miyazawa I Misu T et al Intractable hiccupand nausea in neuromyelitis optica with anti-aquaporin-4antibody a herald of acute exacerbations J Neurol Neuro-surg Psychiatry 2008791075ndash1078

6 Brex PA Ciccarelli O OrsquoRiordan JI Sailer M ThompsonAJ Miller DH A longitudinal study of abnormalities onMRI and disability from multiple sclerosis N Engl J Med2002346158ndash164

7 Weinshenker BG Wingerchuk DM Vukusic S et alNeuromyelitis optica IgG predicts relapse after longitudi-nally extensive transverse myelitis Ann Neurol 200659566ndash569

8 Pittock SJ Lennon VA de Seze J et al Neuromyelitisoptica and non organ-specific autoimmunity Arch Neurol20086578ndash83

9 Weinshenker BG OrsquoBrien PC Petterson TM et alA randomized trial of plasma exchange in acute centralnervous system inflammatory demyelinating disease AnnNeurol 199946878ndash886

If you liked this article you may be interested in

Continuum

Spinal Cord Root and Plexus Disorders June 2008 wwwaancomgoelibrarycontinuum

Neurology

Nathan P Staff et al Hypertrophic nerves producing myelopathy in fulminant CIDP August 242010 wwwneurologyorg

Jeremy D Isaacs et al Noncompressive myelopathy associated with violent axial tics of Tourettesyndrome February 23 2010 wwwneurologyorg

David Roshal et al Pearls amp Oy-sters Fibrocartilaginous embolism myelopathy February 162010 wwwneurologyorg

N Duggal et al Brain reorganization in patients with spinal cord compression evaluated usingfMRI March 30 2010 wwwneurologyorg

S8 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 2: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

suspected Patients with myelopathy who have noclear lesion on spinal MRI or multiple chronic-appearing lesions should be questioned to uncoversubtle previous symptoms of chronic myelopathyand examined to detect cognitive or bulbar impair-ment localizing elsewhere in the nervous system

WHEN IT IS AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY WHATCAUSES SHOULD BE CONSIDERED In pa-tients with recent onset symptoms particularly onesthat evolve rapidly the initial priority is to exclude asurgical emergency such as epidural metastasis or ab-scess When the index of suspicion for an acute com-pressive lesion is high immediate imaging isrequired ideally with MRI of the entire spine If im-aging demonstrates spinal cord compression due toan acute lesion such as epidural metastasis definitivemanagement (ie surgery) should be pursued with-out delay to prevent rapid and irreversible worsening

Often the cause of an acute or subacute myelopa-thy is inapparent after an initial evaluation In a re-cent French series of patients presenting with acutenoncompressive myelopathy 101170 (594) wereof uncertain cause initially although 55101(544) patients were ultimately diagnosed with ademyelinating or inflammatory disorder After aver-age follow-up of 732 months 49170 (288) had afinal diagnosis of myelopathy of uncertain etiologyThe most commonly identified causes were demyeli-nating disorders (MS and neuromyelitis optica) spi-nal cord infarction parainfectious myelitis and

systemic inflammatory disorders (eg Sjogren syn-drome and lupus)1

Transverse myelitis is the default diagnosis for anunexplained myelopathy evolving over the course ofdays to 3 weeks with subsequent stabilization or im-provement In practice there are no satisfactory waysto distinguish among idiopathic transverse myelitisparainfectious myelitis and postvaccinial myelitisWhen a viral illness occurs in close temporal associa-tion parainfectious myelitis is often diagnosed butthe causal role of the associated infection is difficultto determine for an individual patient One can con-fidently link the two only when myelitis occurs con-currently or within days of an infection known to beassociated with myelitis (eg zoster) or when investi-gation such as CSF PCR demonstrates unequivocalevidence of CNS infection

Nevertheless serologic evidence of recent infectionwith pathogens known to be associated with myelopa-thy (eg enteroviruses Chlamydia Mycoplasma) maylimit the need for further diagnostic investigations in anotherwise unexplained myelopathy Features suggestingan infectious etiology include fever rash (zoster entero-virus Lyme disease) meningismus a history of recenttravel (tuberculosis parasitic infections such as schisto-somiasis with travel to endemic regions) suspected ra-bies exposure or immunosuppression (herpes zostercytomegalovirus) It is particularly important to con-sider treatable infections such as syphilis HIV tubercu-losis Lyme disease and herpesviruses

Occasionally patients withchronic myelopathy maypresent a history thatmistakenly suggests an acuteprocess

Other diagnoses that may be made confidently inmost instances include cord compression vasculardisorders toxicmetabolic syndromes neoplasmparaneoplastic syndromes and sarcoidosis Althoughcompression is often obvious as the cause of myelop-athy on MRI spinal stenosis may cause impressiveand occasionally longitudinally extensive T2 signalabnormalities (3 vertebral segments) on spinalMRI that may lead one to suspect an inflammatorymyelopathy Circumscribed gadolinium enhance-ment at the point of maximal stenosis and a historyof progressive symptoms over many weeks to monthsare consistent findings in such cases (figure 1 A andB)2 Vascular myelopathies include those due to in-farction resulting from arterial embolism or hypo-perfusion hemorrhage or vascular malformationsassociated with venous hypertension Dural arterio-

Table 1 Distinguishing acute myelopathyfrom mimics

Signs strongly indicating myelopathy

Sensory level on torso

Spinal tract crossed findings (eg unilateral pyramidal signswith contralateral spinothalamic findings)

Spinal tract-specific sensory findings (eg selectivespinothalamic findings with preserved dorsal columnfindings suspended band of spinothalamic sensory loss)

Urinary retention

Signs consistent with but not diagnostic of myelopathy

Glove-and-stocking sensory loss (consider peripheralneuropathy)

Hyporeflexiahypotonia (consider peripheral neuropathy)

Unilateral or bilateral upper motor neuron signs (considerbrain or brainstem disorders)

Signs suggesting alternative diagnosis

Spasms rather than spasticity (consider stiff-personsyndrome)

Paratonic rigidity (consider frontal lobe disorder)

Cognitive impairment (consider frontal lobe or diffuse braindisorder)

Dysarthria and dysphagia (consider brainstem disorder suchas motor neuron disease)

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S3

Figure 1 MRI of representative cases of acute and subacute myelopathies

(A B) Sagittal T2 and gadolinium-enhanced T1 MRI showing longitudinally extensive cord signal change (A) and focal signet ringgadolinium enhancement (B) due to severe spinal stenosis (C) Sagittal T2 and axial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI demon-strating longitudinally extensive tract-specific lateral column enhancement due to paraneoplastic disorder in a patient withrenal cell carcinoma (D) Sagittal gadolinium-enhanced T1 and axial T2 (inset) MRI demonstrating focal enhancement and T2signal change in the periphery of the cord in a patient with partial transverse myelitis due to multiple sclerosis (E) Sagittal T2 andaxial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI showing longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis extending rostrally into the me-dulla and central cord enhancement due to neuromyelitis opticandashassociated myelitis (F) Sagittal and axial T2 (inset) MRI showinganterior cord signal change due to anterior spinal artery infarct (G) Sagittal and axial T2 (inset) MRI longitudinally extensivesignal change extending to the conus and flow voids (eccentric to the left side of the cord) characteristic of dural arteriovenous fistula(H) Sagittal and axial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI demonstrating nodular and subpial enhancement due to sarcoidosis

S4 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

venous fistula (DAVF)ndashassociated myelopathies maybe distinguished by the distinctive history of stepwiseprogression or transient worsening precipitated bywalking or prolonged standing This myelopathy canbe successfully treated by obliteration of the fistulaand should not be missed Toxic myelopathy due tonitrous oxide abuse is a consideration in younger pa-tients and medical professionals patients with under-lying vitamin B12 deficiency are particularlyvulnerable Vitamin and trace metal deficiencies usu-ally cause chronic myelopathies but as these etiolo-gies are readily treatable vitamin B12 and copperlevels should be tested in unexplained steroid nonre-sponsive myelopathy Spinal cord tumors maypresent subacutely or with apoplectic onset in thecase of hemorrhage into tumor and are usuallyreadily identifiable on MRI although rarely theymay be mistaken radiologically for myelitis Screen-ing for serum paraneoplastic autoantibodies includ-ing collapsin response mediator protein-5 (CRMP-5)antibody3 should be considered in patients withknown cancer constitutional symptoms smokinghistory or suggestive neuroradiology with isolated

tract-specific involvement Sarcoidosis may presentas isolated myelopathy Definitive diagnosis requiresbiopsy evidence of noncaseating granulomatous inflam-mation either from the nervous system or other in-volved organs A high serum angiotensin-convertingenzyme level is suggestive but nonspecific A diagnosisof isolated CNS sarcoidosis should be suspected whensubacute myelopathy is accompanied by patchy asym-metric slowly evolving and persistently enhancing gad-olinium cord lesions A satisfactory therapeutic responseto empiric long-term (months to years) corticosteroidtreatment provides a reasonable basis for a tentative butusually correct diagnosis

WHAT CLINICAL FEATURES SUGGEST A PAR-TICULAR DIAGNOSIS The time course (figure2) specific spinal cord syndrome and symptomsother than those referable to the spinal cord may pro-vide useful clues as to the diagnosis Apoplectic onsetsuggests a cord infarct or spinal hemorrhage both ofwhich may worsen over hours to days Parainfectiousor idiopathic myelitis myelitis related to inflamma-tory demyelinating diseases and some paraneoplastic

Figure 2 Differential diagnosis of acute myelopathy Time course and MRI findings

Relapses upon withdrawal of corticosteroidsimmunosuppression MRI may be normal ADEM acute disseminated en-cephalomyelitis DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula HTLV human T-lymphotropic virus MS multiple sclerosis NMO

neuromyelitis optica SCD subacute combined degeneration SD systemic disease TM transverse myelitis

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S5

syndromes evolve over days to weeks but generallyreach a nadir within 3 weeks after which there iseither improvement or stability4 When a myelopa-thy develops insidiously or continues to progress af-ter 3 weeks transverse myelitis becomes unlikely andthe differential diagnosis includes an intrinsic cordtumor compressive lesion DAVF metabolic de-rangement sarcoidosis or a degenerative process

The clinical syndrome of spinal cord involvementmay suggest a particular etiology although none arespecific Incomplete Brown-Sequard syndrome (lossof pain and temperature sensation contralateral toweakness) may be associated with either compressionor an intrinsic cord lesion such as demyelination Ananterior spinal cord syndrome with bilateral cortico-spinal and spinothalamic involvement sparing dorsalcolumn function is typical of anterior spinal arterydistribution infarction but may also occur in MS Acomplete spinal cord syndrome with bilateral in-volvement of all spinal tracts is rarely caused by anMS relapse or infarct but may occur in idiopathic orneuromyelitis optica (NMO)ndashassociated transversemyelitis or cord compression NMO-associated my-elitis more commonly presents with clinical and im-

aging signs of central cord involvement than doesMS-associated myelitis which more commonly af-fects the periphery of the cord Highly selective tractinvolvement (eg pure corticospinal tract involve-ment) especially when confirmed by MRI evidenceof highly localized enhancing tractopathy is charac-teristic of a paraneoplastic disorder (figure 1C)

Neurologic or constitutional symptoms not refer-able to the spinal cord focus the differential diagno-sis but may be irrelevant and distract one from the truediagnosis Optic neuritis or a prior diagnosis of inter-mediate uveitis may suggest MS Severe optic neuri-tis and an episode of unexplained intractable nauseaor hiccoughs are characteristic of NMO5 Coexist-ing peripheral neuropathy can occur in sarcoidSjogren syndrome lupus metabolic disorders(eg subacute combined degeneration) and para-neoplastic syndromes

WHAT INVESTIGATIONS SHOULD BE PER-FORMED MRI scan of the spinal cord with andwithout gadolinium contrast is the initial investiga-tion of choice in the evaluation of acute myelopathyContraindications are limited to MRI-incompatibleferromagnetic medical devices or foreign bodies andincompatibility with the scanner due to habitusWith careful coordination between cardiologists andradiologists MRI can be performed in selected pa-tients with cardiac pacemakers who are not entirelypacemaker-dependent For patients unable to un-dergo MRI CT myelography may be consideredwhen cord compression is suspected CSF evaluationincluding cell count glucose protein oligoclonalbands immunoglobulin G (IgG) index and cytologyis appropriate unless imaging history and examina-tion already suggest a clear diagnosis The results ofspinal MRI and clinical suspicion should guide theselection of additional investigations (table 2)

For noncompressive myelopathy the results ofMRI can be broadly subdivided into 3 categories

1 Short T2 hyperintensity (3 vertebral segmentsin length)

Focal discrete lesions that do not occupy the en-tire cord in axial cross-section are highly sugges-tive of MS (figure 1D) although remotesometimes forgotten trauma can occasionally pro-duce such lesions MRI scan of the brain may helpto clarify the cause detection of 1 or more brainlesions typical of MS (discrete periventricularjuxtacortical or infratentorial T2 hyperintensefoci) correlates with at least an 85ndash90 futurerisk of developing MS6 Oligoclonal bands andelevated CSF IgG index help to confirm a sus-pected MS diagnosis but CSF analysis may be

Table 2 Utility of diagnostic tests in evaluation of myelopathy

Test used to evaluate for Sensitivitya Specificitya

Imaging studies

Spinal MRI Rule out compressiondefine etiology

Brain MRI MS

CT myelogram Cord compression

Spinal angiogram DAVF

CSF studies

Oligoclonal bands MS

IgG index MS

PCR for herpesviruses CNS herpesvirus infection

Cytology Intramedullary neoplasm

Serologic and other bloodtests

NMO IgG NMO

Antinuclear SSanticardiolipin antibodies

Systemic inflammatorydisease NMO

Angiotensin convertingenzyme

Sarcoidosis

Serologies for infectiousagents

Parainfectious or infectiousmyelopathy

Electrodiagnostic studies

EMG Myelopathy associated withperipheral neuropathy (egsarcoid Sjoumlgrenparaneoplastic)

Abbreviations DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula IgG immunoglobulin G MS multiplesclerosis NMO neuromyelitis optica SS Sjoumlgren syndromea The symbols and indicate low intermediate and high sensitivityspecificityrespectively

S6 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

superfluous if other clinical and radiographic fea-tures are highly suggestive

2 Longitudinally extensive T2 hyperintensity (3vertebral segments in length)

Longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis oc-curs in idiopathic transverse myelitis NMO (fig-ure 1E) acute disseminated encephalomyelitiscord infarction and myelitis associated with sys-temic diseases such as systemic lupus erythemato-sus Serum NMO IgG testing is indicated beforeassigning a diagnosis of idiopathic transverse my-elitis7 Brain lesions on MRI eventually occur inthe majority of patients with NMO but usuallyNMO does not lead to the discrete Dawson fingerpattern of periventricular lesions characteristic ofMS However confluent and linear lesions encir-cling the ventricles may occur in NMO CSF oligo-clonal bands are usually absent in NMOCertain patterns of signal abnormality on MRIpredict a vascular disorder Anterior and centralcord signal change and swelling with sparing ofthe posterior columns suggest infarct particularlyin patients with a suggestive history (figure 1F)Posterior flow voids on spinal MRI representingdilation of the epidural venous plexus are a fairlyspecific but less sensitive indicator of DAVFwhereas longitudinally extensive gadolinium en-hancement and T2 hyperintensity often extend-ing to the conus are typical but nonspecificfindings (figure 1G) Magnetic resonance angiog-raphy may help to visualize a DAVF but spinalangiography is required for definitive diagnosisand treatment

If symptoms suggestive of recent infection or CSFpleocytosis (50 leukocytesL) are presentCSF PCR testing for herpesviruses (eg herpessimplex cytomegalovirus varicella zoster) and se-rologic testing for HIV syphilis and Lyme dis-ease should be considered Prominent CSFpleocytosis and occasionally neutrophilic pleocy-tosis may occur in myelitis associated with NMOSymptoms and signs of systemic inflammatorydisease such as polyarthritis should prompt auto-immune serologic testing (ie antinuclear anti-bodies SS-A SS-B antibodies) In the absence ofclinical indications of these diseases positive sero-logic tests may be unimportant although they mayindicate NMO a quarter of NMO spectrum disor-der patients have nonspecific serologic evidence ofautoimmunity usually in the absence of clinicalsigns of other autoimmune disorders8 Indiscrimi-nate use of autoantibody testing in all patientswith myelitis is not recommended MRI find-ings including nodular and persisting (2

months) gadolinium enhancement or menin-geal and nerve root enhancement suggest sar-coidosis (figure 1H) or rarely lymphoma

3 Normal MRI

Patients with suspected myelopathy and appar-ently normal MRI should undergo careful reviewof the images for subtle findings of cord signalchange atrophy or extrinsic compression by un-common causes (eg epidural lipomatosis) If ex-amination demonstrates unequivocal evidence ofa spinal cord process and the MRI is normal con-sider and test for degenerative infectious andmetabolic causes of myelopathy EMG and nerveconduction studies occasionally help to identify aprimary peripheral process (eg AIDP) or my-elopathy associated with concomitant peripheralneuropathy as can be seen in sarcoidosis and sub-acute combined degeneration

HOW SHOULD AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY BETREATED Controlled studies of treatment of acutemyelitis are lacking In myelitis due to demyelinat-ing inflammatory or undetermined cause expertconsensus favors high-dose IV corticosteroids typi-cally 1 gram of IV methylprednisolone daily for 5days This treatment should not be withheld in thecase of suspected recent viral infection the role of ste-roid treatment in patients with definitive evidence fordirect viral infection of the cord (eg myelitis occurringsimultaneously with or within days of a zoster eruption)is unclear Plasmapheresis should be considered in pa-tients who continue to have significant impairment af-ter high-dose corticosteroids In a sham-controlled trialof plasma exchange in patients with an acute relapse ofdemyelinating disease unresponsive to corticosteroidtreatment many of whom had acute myelitis 8 of 19(421) treated patients experienced moderate tomarked improvement vs 1 of 17 (59) who receivedsham treatment9 There are no established treatmentsfor patients with cord infarction

Long-term treatment to reduce recurrent attacks orprogression of deficit is required for patients withNMO neurosarcoidosis and systemic inflammatorydisorders Options to be considered for NMO includeazathioprine mycophenolate mofetil mitoxantroneand rituximab Sarcoidosis is usually treated with pro-longed high-dose oral corticosteroids (eg prednisone 1mgkgday for 6ndash12 months) Oral steroids andsteroid-sparing immunosuppressive agents are also typi-cally prescribed when systemic inflammatory processesinvolve the nervous system Immunomodulatory treat-ment should be considered in patients who are at highrisk for developing relapsing-remitting MS by virtue ofhaving additional lesions on MRI of the head

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S7

Ongoing clinical observation is an important partof the care of patients with an unexplained myelopa-thy Subsequent appearance of new neurologic orsystemic symptoms may reveal a demyelinating orsystemic inflammatory disorder Patients with relent-lessly progressive symptoms despite appropriate em-piric treatment may require spinal cord biopsy fordefinitive diagnosis particularly when follow-up im-aging demonstrates worsening

DISCUSSION Acute and subacute myelopathies re-quire urgent medical evaluation Imaging preferablyby MRI should be performed without delay to ex-clude a compressive lesion Subsequently history andphysical examination should guide subsequent inves-tigations to reach a definitive diagnosis As the etiol-ogy is often unclear at initial presentation empirictreatment should be provided while conducting fur-ther investigations to determine the etiology of my-elopathy A thorough evaluation often revealsevidence of a treatable disorder or one that may re-lapse without preventive treatment

DISCLOSURE

Dr Schmalstieg reports no disclosures Dr Weinshenker has served on

data safety monitoring boards for Novartis and Biogen Idec serves on the

editorial boards of Multiple Sclerosis the Canadian Journal of Neurological

Sciences and the Turkish Journal of Neurology receives research support

from the Guthy-Jackson Charitable Foundation and receives license roy-

alties from RSR Ltd and may receive royalties from Mayo Medical Ven-

tures for a patentintellectual property re Aquaporin-4 associated

antibodies for diagnosis of neuromyelitis optica

Received July 14 2010 Accepted in final form September 2 2010

REFERENCES1 Debette S de Seze J Pruvo JP et al Long-term outcome

of acute and subacute myelopathies J Neurol 2009256980ndash988

2 Kelley BJ Erickson BJ Weinshenker BG Compressivemyelopathy mimicking transverse myelitis Neurologist201016120ndash122

3 Keegan BM Pittock SJ Lennon VA Autoimmune my-elopathy associated with collapsin response-mediatorprotein-5 immunoglobulin G Ann Neurol 200863531ndash534

4 Proposed diagnostic criteria and nosology of acute trans-verse myelitis Neurology 200259499ndash505

5 Takahashi T Miyazawa I Misu T et al Intractable hiccupand nausea in neuromyelitis optica with anti-aquaporin-4antibody a herald of acute exacerbations J Neurol Neuro-surg Psychiatry 2008791075ndash1078

6 Brex PA Ciccarelli O OrsquoRiordan JI Sailer M ThompsonAJ Miller DH A longitudinal study of abnormalities onMRI and disability from multiple sclerosis N Engl J Med2002346158ndash164

7 Weinshenker BG Wingerchuk DM Vukusic S et alNeuromyelitis optica IgG predicts relapse after longitudi-nally extensive transverse myelitis Ann Neurol 200659566ndash569

8 Pittock SJ Lennon VA de Seze J et al Neuromyelitisoptica and non organ-specific autoimmunity Arch Neurol20086578ndash83

9 Weinshenker BG OrsquoBrien PC Petterson TM et alA randomized trial of plasma exchange in acute centralnervous system inflammatory demyelinating disease AnnNeurol 199946878ndash886

If you liked this article you may be interested in

Continuum

Spinal Cord Root and Plexus Disorders June 2008 wwwaancomgoelibrarycontinuum

Neurology

Nathan P Staff et al Hypertrophic nerves producing myelopathy in fulminant CIDP August 242010 wwwneurologyorg

Jeremy D Isaacs et al Noncompressive myelopathy associated with violent axial tics of Tourettesyndrome February 23 2010 wwwneurologyorg

David Roshal et al Pearls amp Oy-sters Fibrocartilaginous embolism myelopathy February 162010 wwwneurologyorg

N Duggal et al Brain reorganization in patients with spinal cord compression evaluated usingfMRI March 30 2010 wwwneurologyorg

S8 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 3: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

Figure 1 MRI of representative cases of acute and subacute myelopathies

(A B) Sagittal T2 and gadolinium-enhanced T1 MRI showing longitudinally extensive cord signal change (A) and focal signet ringgadolinium enhancement (B) due to severe spinal stenosis (C) Sagittal T2 and axial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI demon-strating longitudinally extensive tract-specific lateral column enhancement due to paraneoplastic disorder in a patient withrenal cell carcinoma (D) Sagittal gadolinium-enhanced T1 and axial T2 (inset) MRI demonstrating focal enhancement and T2signal change in the periphery of the cord in a patient with partial transverse myelitis due to multiple sclerosis (E) Sagittal T2 andaxial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI showing longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis extending rostrally into the me-dulla and central cord enhancement due to neuromyelitis opticandashassociated myelitis (F) Sagittal and axial T2 (inset) MRI showinganterior cord signal change due to anterior spinal artery infarct (G) Sagittal and axial T2 (inset) MRI longitudinally extensivesignal change extending to the conus and flow voids (eccentric to the left side of the cord) characteristic of dural arteriovenous fistula(H) Sagittal and axial gadolinium-enhanced T1 (inset) MRI demonstrating nodular and subpial enhancement due to sarcoidosis

S4 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

venous fistula (DAVF)ndashassociated myelopathies maybe distinguished by the distinctive history of stepwiseprogression or transient worsening precipitated bywalking or prolonged standing This myelopathy canbe successfully treated by obliteration of the fistulaand should not be missed Toxic myelopathy due tonitrous oxide abuse is a consideration in younger pa-tients and medical professionals patients with under-lying vitamin B12 deficiency are particularlyvulnerable Vitamin and trace metal deficiencies usu-ally cause chronic myelopathies but as these etiolo-gies are readily treatable vitamin B12 and copperlevels should be tested in unexplained steroid nonre-sponsive myelopathy Spinal cord tumors maypresent subacutely or with apoplectic onset in thecase of hemorrhage into tumor and are usuallyreadily identifiable on MRI although rarely theymay be mistaken radiologically for myelitis Screen-ing for serum paraneoplastic autoantibodies includ-ing collapsin response mediator protein-5 (CRMP-5)antibody3 should be considered in patients withknown cancer constitutional symptoms smokinghistory or suggestive neuroradiology with isolated

tract-specific involvement Sarcoidosis may presentas isolated myelopathy Definitive diagnosis requiresbiopsy evidence of noncaseating granulomatous inflam-mation either from the nervous system or other in-volved organs A high serum angiotensin-convertingenzyme level is suggestive but nonspecific A diagnosisof isolated CNS sarcoidosis should be suspected whensubacute myelopathy is accompanied by patchy asym-metric slowly evolving and persistently enhancing gad-olinium cord lesions A satisfactory therapeutic responseto empiric long-term (months to years) corticosteroidtreatment provides a reasonable basis for a tentative butusually correct diagnosis

WHAT CLINICAL FEATURES SUGGEST A PAR-TICULAR DIAGNOSIS The time course (figure2) specific spinal cord syndrome and symptomsother than those referable to the spinal cord may pro-vide useful clues as to the diagnosis Apoplectic onsetsuggests a cord infarct or spinal hemorrhage both ofwhich may worsen over hours to days Parainfectiousor idiopathic myelitis myelitis related to inflamma-tory demyelinating diseases and some paraneoplastic

Figure 2 Differential diagnosis of acute myelopathy Time course and MRI findings

Relapses upon withdrawal of corticosteroidsimmunosuppression MRI may be normal ADEM acute disseminated en-cephalomyelitis DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula HTLV human T-lymphotropic virus MS multiple sclerosis NMO

neuromyelitis optica SCD subacute combined degeneration SD systemic disease TM transverse myelitis

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S5

syndromes evolve over days to weeks but generallyreach a nadir within 3 weeks after which there iseither improvement or stability4 When a myelopa-thy develops insidiously or continues to progress af-ter 3 weeks transverse myelitis becomes unlikely andthe differential diagnosis includes an intrinsic cordtumor compressive lesion DAVF metabolic de-rangement sarcoidosis or a degenerative process

The clinical syndrome of spinal cord involvementmay suggest a particular etiology although none arespecific Incomplete Brown-Sequard syndrome (lossof pain and temperature sensation contralateral toweakness) may be associated with either compressionor an intrinsic cord lesion such as demyelination Ananterior spinal cord syndrome with bilateral cortico-spinal and spinothalamic involvement sparing dorsalcolumn function is typical of anterior spinal arterydistribution infarction but may also occur in MS Acomplete spinal cord syndrome with bilateral in-volvement of all spinal tracts is rarely caused by anMS relapse or infarct but may occur in idiopathic orneuromyelitis optica (NMO)ndashassociated transversemyelitis or cord compression NMO-associated my-elitis more commonly presents with clinical and im-

aging signs of central cord involvement than doesMS-associated myelitis which more commonly af-fects the periphery of the cord Highly selective tractinvolvement (eg pure corticospinal tract involve-ment) especially when confirmed by MRI evidenceof highly localized enhancing tractopathy is charac-teristic of a paraneoplastic disorder (figure 1C)

Neurologic or constitutional symptoms not refer-able to the spinal cord focus the differential diagno-sis but may be irrelevant and distract one from the truediagnosis Optic neuritis or a prior diagnosis of inter-mediate uveitis may suggest MS Severe optic neuri-tis and an episode of unexplained intractable nauseaor hiccoughs are characteristic of NMO5 Coexist-ing peripheral neuropathy can occur in sarcoidSjogren syndrome lupus metabolic disorders(eg subacute combined degeneration) and para-neoplastic syndromes

WHAT INVESTIGATIONS SHOULD BE PER-FORMED MRI scan of the spinal cord with andwithout gadolinium contrast is the initial investiga-tion of choice in the evaluation of acute myelopathyContraindications are limited to MRI-incompatibleferromagnetic medical devices or foreign bodies andincompatibility with the scanner due to habitusWith careful coordination between cardiologists andradiologists MRI can be performed in selected pa-tients with cardiac pacemakers who are not entirelypacemaker-dependent For patients unable to un-dergo MRI CT myelography may be consideredwhen cord compression is suspected CSF evaluationincluding cell count glucose protein oligoclonalbands immunoglobulin G (IgG) index and cytologyis appropriate unless imaging history and examina-tion already suggest a clear diagnosis The results ofspinal MRI and clinical suspicion should guide theselection of additional investigations (table 2)

For noncompressive myelopathy the results ofMRI can be broadly subdivided into 3 categories

1 Short T2 hyperintensity (3 vertebral segmentsin length)

Focal discrete lesions that do not occupy the en-tire cord in axial cross-section are highly sugges-tive of MS (figure 1D) although remotesometimes forgotten trauma can occasionally pro-duce such lesions MRI scan of the brain may helpto clarify the cause detection of 1 or more brainlesions typical of MS (discrete periventricularjuxtacortical or infratentorial T2 hyperintensefoci) correlates with at least an 85ndash90 futurerisk of developing MS6 Oligoclonal bands andelevated CSF IgG index help to confirm a sus-pected MS diagnosis but CSF analysis may be

Table 2 Utility of diagnostic tests in evaluation of myelopathy

Test used to evaluate for Sensitivitya Specificitya

Imaging studies

Spinal MRI Rule out compressiondefine etiology

Brain MRI MS

CT myelogram Cord compression

Spinal angiogram DAVF

CSF studies

Oligoclonal bands MS

IgG index MS

PCR for herpesviruses CNS herpesvirus infection

Cytology Intramedullary neoplasm

Serologic and other bloodtests

NMO IgG NMO

Antinuclear SSanticardiolipin antibodies

Systemic inflammatorydisease NMO

Angiotensin convertingenzyme

Sarcoidosis

Serologies for infectiousagents

Parainfectious or infectiousmyelopathy

Electrodiagnostic studies

EMG Myelopathy associated withperipheral neuropathy (egsarcoid Sjoumlgrenparaneoplastic)

Abbreviations DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula IgG immunoglobulin G MS multiplesclerosis NMO neuromyelitis optica SS Sjoumlgren syndromea The symbols and indicate low intermediate and high sensitivityspecificityrespectively

S6 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

superfluous if other clinical and radiographic fea-tures are highly suggestive

2 Longitudinally extensive T2 hyperintensity (3vertebral segments in length)

Longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis oc-curs in idiopathic transverse myelitis NMO (fig-ure 1E) acute disseminated encephalomyelitiscord infarction and myelitis associated with sys-temic diseases such as systemic lupus erythemato-sus Serum NMO IgG testing is indicated beforeassigning a diagnosis of idiopathic transverse my-elitis7 Brain lesions on MRI eventually occur inthe majority of patients with NMO but usuallyNMO does not lead to the discrete Dawson fingerpattern of periventricular lesions characteristic ofMS However confluent and linear lesions encir-cling the ventricles may occur in NMO CSF oligo-clonal bands are usually absent in NMOCertain patterns of signal abnormality on MRIpredict a vascular disorder Anterior and centralcord signal change and swelling with sparing ofthe posterior columns suggest infarct particularlyin patients with a suggestive history (figure 1F)Posterior flow voids on spinal MRI representingdilation of the epidural venous plexus are a fairlyspecific but less sensitive indicator of DAVFwhereas longitudinally extensive gadolinium en-hancement and T2 hyperintensity often extend-ing to the conus are typical but nonspecificfindings (figure 1G) Magnetic resonance angiog-raphy may help to visualize a DAVF but spinalangiography is required for definitive diagnosisand treatment

If symptoms suggestive of recent infection or CSFpleocytosis (50 leukocytesL) are presentCSF PCR testing for herpesviruses (eg herpessimplex cytomegalovirus varicella zoster) and se-rologic testing for HIV syphilis and Lyme dis-ease should be considered Prominent CSFpleocytosis and occasionally neutrophilic pleocy-tosis may occur in myelitis associated with NMOSymptoms and signs of systemic inflammatorydisease such as polyarthritis should prompt auto-immune serologic testing (ie antinuclear anti-bodies SS-A SS-B antibodies) In the absence ofclinical indications of these diseases positive sero-logic tests may be unimportant although they mayindicate NMO a quarter of NMO spectrum disor-der patients have nonspecific serologic evidence ofautoimmunity usually in the absence of clinicalsigns of other autoimmune disorders8 Indiscrimi-nate use of autoantibody testing in all patientswith myelitis is not recommended MRI find-ings including nodular and persisting (2

months) gadolinium enhancement or menin-geal and nerve root enhancement suggest sar-coidosis (figure 1H) or rarely lymphoma

3 Normal MRI

Patients with suspected myelopathy and appar-ently normal MRI should undergo careful reviewof the images for subtle findings of cord signalchange atrophy or extrinsic compression by un-common causes (eg epidural lipomatosis) If ex-amination demonstrates unequivocal evidence ofa spinal cord process and the MRI is normal con-sider and test for degenerative infectious andmetabolic causes of myelopathy EMG and nerveconduction studies occasionally help to identify aprimary peripheral process (eg AIDP) or my-elopathy associated with concomitant peripheralneuropathy as can be seen in sarcoidosis and sub-acute combined degeneration

HOW SHOULD AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY BETREATED Controlled studies of treatment of acutemyelitis are lacking In myelitis due to demyelinat-ing inflammatory or undetermined cause expertconsensus favors high-dose IV corticosteroids typi-cally 1 gram of IV methylprednisolone daily for 5days This treatment should not be withheld in thecase of suspected recent viral infection the role of ste-roid treatment in patients with definitive evidence fordirect viral infection of the cord (eg myelitis occurringsimultaneously with or within days of a zoster eruption)is unclear Plasmapheresis should be considered in pa-tients who continue to have significant impairment af-ter high-dose corticosteroids In a sham-controlled trialof plasma exchange in patients with an acute relapse ofdemyelinating disease unresponsive to corticosteroidtreatment many of whom had acute myelitis 8 of 19(421) treated patients experienced moderate tomarked improvement vs 1 of 17 (59) who receivedsham treatment9 There are no established treatmentsfor patients with cord infarction

Long-term treatment to reduce recurrent attacks orprogression of deficit is required for patients withNMO neurosarcoidosis and systemic inflammatorydisorders Options to be considered for NMO includeazathioprine mycophenolate mofetil mitoxantroneand rituximab Sarcoidosis is usually treated with pro-longed high-dose oral corticosteroids (eg prednisone 1mgkgday for 6ndash12 months) Oral steroids andsteroid-sparing immunosuppressive agents are also typi-cally prescribed when systemic inflammatory processesinvolve the nervous system Immunomodulatory treat-ment should be considered in patients who are at highrisk for developing relapsing-remitting MS by virtue ofhaving additional lesions on MRI of the head

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S7

Ongoing clinical observation is an important partof the care of patients with an unexplained myelopa-thy Subsequent appearance of new neurologic orsystemic symptoms may reveal a demyelinating orsystemic inflammatory disorder Patients with relent-lessly progressive symptoms despite appropriate em-piric treatment may require spinal cord biopsy fordefinitive diagnosis particularly when follow-up im-aging demonstrates worsening

DISCUSSION Acute and subacute myelopathies re-quire urgent medical evaluation Imaging preferablyby MRI should be performed without delay to ex-clude a compressive lesion Subsequently history andphysical examination should guide subsequent inves-tigations to reach a definitive diagnosis As the etiol-ogy is often unclear at initial presentation empirictreatment should be provided while conducting fur-ther investigations to determine the etiology of my-elopathy A thorough evaluation often revealsevidence of a treatable disorder or one that may re-lapse without preventive treatment

DISCLOSURE

Dr Schmalstieg reports no disclosures Dr Weinshenker has served on

data safety monitoring boards for Novartis and Biogen Idec serves on the

editorial boards of Multiple Sclerosis the Canadian Journal of Neurological

Sciences and the Turkish Journal of Neurology receives research support

from the Guthy-Jackson Charitable Foundation and receives license roy-

alties from RSR Ltd and may receive royalties from Mayo Medical Ven-

tures for a patentintellectual property re Aquaporin-4 associated

antibodies for diagnosis of neuromyelitis optica

Received July 14 2010 Accepted in final form September 2 2010

REFERENCES1 Debette S de Seze J Pruvo JP et al Long-term outcome

of acute and subacute myelopathies J Neurol 2009256980ndash988

2 Kelley BJ Erickson BJ Weinshenker BG Compressivemyelopathy mimicking transverse myelitis Neurologist201016120ndash122

3 Keegan BM Pittock SJ Lennon VA Autoimmune my-elopathy associated with collapsin response-mediatorprotein-5 immunoglobulin G Ann Neurol 200863531ndash534

4 Proposed diagnostic criteria and nosology of acute trans-verse myelitis Neurology 200259499ndash505

5 Takahashi T Miyazawa I Misu T et al Intractable hiccupand nausea in neuromyelitis optica with anti-aquaporin-4antibody a herald of acute exacerbations J Neurol Neuro-surg Psychiatry 2008791075ndash1078

6 Brex PA Ciccarelli O OrsquoRiordan JI Sailer M ThompsonAJ Miller DH A longitudinal study of abnormalities onMRI and disability from multiple sclerosis N Engl J Med2002346158ndash164

7 Weinshenker BG Wingerchuk DM Vukusic S et alNeuromyelitis optica IgG predicts relapse after longitudi-nally extensive transverse myelitis Ann Neurol 200659566ndash569

8 Pittock SJ Lennon VA de Seze J et al Neuromyelitisoptica and non organ-specific autoimmunity Arch Neurol20086578ndash83

9 Weinshenker BG OrsquoBrien PC Petterson TM et alA randomized trial of plasma exchange in acute centralnervous system inflammatory demyelinating disease AnnNeurol 199946878ndash886

If you liked this article you may be interested in

Continuum

Spinal Cord Root and Plexus Disorders June 2008 wwwaancomgoelibrarycontinuum

Neurology

Nathan P Staff et al Hypertrophic nerves producing myelopathy in fulminant CIDP August 242010 wwwneurologyorg

Jeremy D Isaacs et al Noncompressive myelopathy associated with violent axial tics of Tourettesyndrome February 23 2010 wwwneurologyorg

David Roshal et al Pearls amp Oy-sters Fibrocartilaginous embolism myelopathy February 162010 wwwneurologyorg

N Duggal et al Brain reorganization in patients with spinal cord compression evaluated usingfMRI March 30 2010 wwwneurologyorg

S8 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 4: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

venous fistula (DAVF)ndashassociated myelopathies maybe distinguished by the distinctive history of stepwiseprogression or transient worsening precipitated bywalking or prolonged standing This myelopathy canbe successfully treated by obliteration of the fistulaand should not be missed Toxic myelopathy due tonitrous oxide abuse is a consideration in younger pa-tients and medical professionals patients with under-lying vitamin B12 deficiency are particularlyvulnerable Vitamin and trace metal deficiencies usu-ally cause chronic myelopathies but as these etiolo-gies are readily treatable vitamin B12 and copperlevels should be tested in unexplained steroid nonre-sponsive myelopathy Spinal cord tumors maypresent subacutely or with apoplectic onset in thecase of hemorrhage into tumor and are usuallyreadily identifiable on MRI although rarely theymay be mistaken radiologically for myelitis Screen-ing for serum paraneoplastic autoantibodies includ-ing collapsin response mediator protein-5 (CRMP-5)antibody3 should be considered in patients withknown cancer constitutional symptoms smokinghistory or suggestive neuroradiology with isolated

tract-specific involvement Sarcoidosis may presentas isolated myelopathy Definitive diagnosis requiresbiopsy evidence of noncaseating granulomatous inflam-mation either from the nervous system or other in-volved organs A high serum angiotensin-convertingenzyme level is suggestive but nonspecific A diagnosisof isolated CNS sarcoidosis should be suspected whensubacute myelopathy is accompanied by patchy asym-metric slowly evolving and persistently enhancing gad-olinium cord lesions A satisfactory therapeutic responseto empiric long-term (months to years) corticosteroidtreatment provides a reasonable basis for a tentative butusually correct diagnosis

WHAT CLINICAL FEATURES SUGGEST A PAR-TICULAR DIAGNOSIS The time course (figure2) specific spinal cord syndrome and symptomsother than those referable to the spinal cord may pro-vide useful clues as to the diagnosis Apoplectic onsetsuggests a cord infarct or spinal hemorrhage both ofwhich may worsen over hours to days Parainfectiousor idiopathic myelitis myelitis related to inflamma-tory demyelinating diseases and some paraneoplastic

Figure 2 Differential diagnosis of acute myelopathy Time course and MRI findings

Relapses upon withdrawal of corticosteroidsimmunosuppression MRI may be normal ADEM acute disseminated en-cephalomyelitis DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula HTLV human T-lymphotropic virus MS multiple sclerosis NMO

neuromyelitis optica SCD subacute combined degeneration SD systemic disease TM transverse myelitis

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S5

syndromes evolve over days to weeks but generallyreach a nadir within 3 weeks after which there iseither improvement or stability4 When a myelopa-thy develops insidiously or continues to progress af-ter 3 weeks transverse myelitis becomes unlikely andthe differential diagnosis includes an intrinsic cordtumor compressive lesion DAVF metabolic de-rangement sarcoidosis or a degenerative process

The clinical syndrome of spinal cord involvementmay suggest a particular etiology although none arespecific Incomplete Brown-Sequard syndrome (lossof pain and temperature sensation contralateral toweakness) may be associated with either compressionor an intrinsic cord lesion such as demyelination Ananterior spinal cord syndrome with bilateral cortico-spinal and spinothalamic involvement sparing dorsalcolumn function is typical of anterior spinal arterydistribution infarction but may also occur in MS Acomplete spinal cord syndrome with bilateral in-volvement of all spinal tracts is rarely caused by anMS relapse or infarct but may occur in idiopathic orneuromyelitis optica (NMO)ndashassociated transversemyelitis or cord compression NMO-associated my-elitis more commonly presents with clinical and im-

aging signs of central cord involvement than doesMS-associated myelitis which more commonly af-fects the periphery of the cord Highly selective tractinvolvement (eg pure corticospinal tract involve-ment) especially when confirmed by MRI evidenceof highly localized enhancing tractopathy is charac-teristic of a paraneoplastic disorder (figure 1C)

Neurologic or constitutional symptoms not refer-able to the spinal cord focus the differential diagno-sis but may be irrelevant and distract one from the truediagnosis Optic neuritis or a prior diagnosis of inter-mediate uveitis may suggest MS Severe optic neuri-tis and an episode of unexplained intractable nauseaor hiccoughs are characteristic of NMO5 Coexist-ing peripheral neuropathy can occur in sarcoidSjogren syndrome lupus metabolic disorders(eg subacute combined degeneration) and para-neoplastic syndromes

WHAT INVESTIGATIONS SHOULD BE PER-FORMED MRI scan of the spinal cord with andwithout gadolinium contrast is the initial investiga-tion of choice in the evaluation of acute myelopathyContraindications are limited to MRI-incompatibleferromagnetic medical devices or foreign bodies andincompatibility with the scanner due to habitusWith careful coordination between cardiologists andradiologists MRI can be performed in selected pa-tients with cardiac pacemakers who are not entirelypacemaker-dependent For patients unable to un-dergo MRI CT myelography may be consideredwhen cord compression is suspected CSF evaluationincluding cell count glucose protein oligoclonalbands immunoglobulin G (IgG) index and cytologyis appropriate unless imaging history and examina-tion already suggest a clear diagnosis The results ofspinal MRI and clinical suspicion should guide theselection of additional investigations (table 2)

For noncompressive myelopathy the results ofMRI can be broadly subdivided into 3 categories

1 Short T2 hyperintensity (3 vertebral segmentsin length)

Focal discrete lesions that do not occupy the en-tire cord in axial cross-section are highly sugges-tive of MS (figure 1D) although remotesometimes forgotten trauma can occasionally pro-duce such lesions MRI scan of the brain may helpto clarify the cause detection of 1 or more brainlesions typical of MS (discrete periventricularjuxtacortical or infratentorial T2 hyperintensefoci) correlates with at least an 85ndash90 futurerisk of developing MS6 Oligoclonal bands andelevated CSF IgG index help to confirm a sus-pected MS diagnosis but CSF analysis may be

Table 2 Utility of diagnostic tests in evaluation of myelopathy

Test used to evaluate for Sensitivitya Specificitya

Imaging studies

Spinal MRI Rule out compressiondefine etiology

Brain MRI MS

CT myelogram Cord compression

Spinal angiogram DAVF

CSF studies

Oligoclonal bands MS

IgG index MS

PCR for herpesviruses CNS herpesvirus infection

Cytology Intramedullary neoplasm

Serologic and other bloodtests

NMO IgG NMO

Antinuclear SSanticardiolipin antibodies

Systemic inflammatorydisease NMO

Angiotensin convertingenzyme

Sarcoidosis

Serologies for infectiousagents

Parainfectious or infectiousmyelopathy

Electrodiagnostic studies

EMG Myelopathy associated withperipheral neuropathy (egsarcoid Sjoumlgrenparaneoplastic)

Abbreviations DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula IgG immunoglobulin G MS multiplesclerosis NMO neuromyelitis optica SS Sjoumlgren syndromea The symbols and indicate low intermediate and high sensitivityspecificityrespectively

S6 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

superfluous if other clinical and radiographic fea-tures are highly suggestive

2 Longitudinally extensive T2 hyperintensity (3vertebral segments in length)

Longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis oc-curs in idiopathic transverse myelitis NMO (fig-ure 1E) acute disseminated encephalomyelitiscord infarction and myelitis associated with sys-temic diseases such as systemic lupus erythemato-sus Serum NMO IgG testing is indicated beforeassigning a diagnosis of idiopathic transverse my-elitis7 Brain lesions on MRI eventually occur inthe majority of patients with NMO but usuallyNMO does not lead to the discrete Dawson fingerpattern of periventricular lesions characteristic ofMS However confluent and linear lesions encir-cling the ventricles may occur in NMO CSF oligo-clonal bands are usually absent in NMOCertain patterns of signal abnormality on MRIpredict a vascular disorder Anterior and centralcord signal change and swelling with sparing ofthe posterior columns suggest infarct particularlyin patients with a suggestive history (figure 1F)Posterior flow voids on spinal MRI representingdilation of the epidural venous plexus are a fairlyspecific but less sensitive indicator of DAVFwhereas longitudinally extensive gadolinium en-hancement and T2 hyperintensity often extend-ing to the conus are typical but nonspecificfindings (figure 1G) Magnetic resonance angiog-raphy may help to visualize a DAVF but spinalangiography is required for definitive diagnosisand treatment

If symptoms suggestive of recent infection or CSFpleocytosis (50 leukocytesL) are presentCSF PCR testing for herpesviruses (eg herpessimplex cytomegalovirus varicella zoster) and se-rologic testing for HIV syphilis and Lyme dis-ease should be considered Prominent CSFpleocytosis and occasionally neutrophilic pleocy-tosis may occur in myelitis associated with NMOSymptoms and signs of systemic inflammatorydisease such as polyarthritis should prompt auto-immune serologic testing (ie antinuclear anti-bodies SS-A SS-B antibodies) In the absence ofclinical indications of these diseases positive sero-logic tests may be unimportant although they mayindicate NMO a quarter of NMO spectrum disor-der patients have nonspecific serologic evidence ofautoimmunity usually in the absence of clinicalsigns of other autoimmune disorders8 Indiscrimi-nate use of autoantibody testing in all patientswith myelitis is not recommended MRI find-ings including nodular and persisting (2

months) gadolinium enhancement or menin-geal and nerve root enhancement suggest sar-coidosis (figure 1H) or rarely lymphoma

3 Normal MRI

Patients with suspected myelopathy and appar-ently normal MRI should undergo careful reviewof the images for subtle findings of cord signalchange atrophy or extrinsic compression by un-common causes (eg epidural lipomatosis) If ex-amination demonstrates unequivocal evidence ofa spinal cord process and the MRI is normal con-sider and test for degenerative infectious andmetabolic causes of myelopathy EMG and nerveconduction studies occasionally help to identify aprimary peripheral process (eg AIDP) or my-elopathy associated with concomitant peripheralneuropathy as can be seen in sarcoidosis and sub-acute combined degeneration

HOW SHOULD AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY BETREATED Controlled studies of treatment of acutemyelitis are lacking In myelitis due to demyelinat-ing inflammatory or undetermined cause expertconsensus favors high-dose IV corticosteroids typi-cally 1 gram of IV methylprednisolone daily for 5days This treatment should not be withheld in thecase of suspected recent viral infection the role of ste-roid treatment in patients with definitive evidence fordirect viral infection of the cord (eg myelitis occurringsimultaneously with or within days of a zoster eruption)is unclear Plasmapheresis should be considered in pa-tients who continue to have significant impairment af-ter high-dose corticosteroids In a sham-controlled trialof plasma exchange in patients with an acute relapse ofdemyelinating disease unresponsive to corticosteroidtreatment many of whom had acute myelitis 8 of 19(421) treated patients experienced moderate tomarked improvement vs 1 of 17 (59) who receivedsham treatment9 There are no established treatmentsfor patients with cord infarction

Long-term treatment to reduce recurrent attacks orprogression of deficit is required for patients withNMO neurosarcoidosis and systemic inflammatorydisorders Options to be considered for NMO includeazathioprine mycophenolate mofetil mitoxantroneand rituximab Sarcoidosis is usually treated with pro-longed high-dose oral corticosteroids (eg prednisone 1mgkgday for 6ndash12 months) Oral steroids andsteroid-sparing immunosuppressive agents are also typi-cally prescribed when systemic inflammatory processesinvolve the nervous system Immunomodulatory treat-ment should be considered in patients who are at highrisk for developing relapsing-remitting MS by virtue ofhaving additional lesions on MRI of the head

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S7

Ongoing clinical observation is an important partof the care of patients with an unexplained myelopa-thy Subsequent appearance of new neurologic orsystemic symptoms may reveal a demyelinating orsystemic inflammatory disorder Patients with relent-lessly progressive symptoms despite appropriate em-piric treatment may require spinal cord biopsy fordefinitive diagnosis particularly when follow-up im-aging demonstrates worsening

DISCUSSION Acute and subacute myelopathies re-quire urgent medical evaluation Imaging preferablyby MRI should be performed without delay to ex-clude a compressive lesion Subsequently history andphysical examination should guide subsequent inves-tigations to reach a definitive diagnosis As the etiol-ogy is often unclear at initial presentation empirictreatment should be provided while conducting fur-ther investigations to determine the etiology of my-elopathy A thorough evaluation often revealsevidence of a treatable disorder or one that may re-lapse without preventive treatment

DISCLOSURE

Dr Schmalstieg reports no disclosures Dr Weinshenker has served on

data safety monitoring boards for Novartis and Biogen Idec serves on the

editorial boards of Multiple Sclerosis the Canadian Journal of Neurological

Sciences and the Turkish Journal of Neurology receives research support

from the Guthy-Jackson Charitable Foundation and receives license roy-

alties from RSR Ltd and may receive royalties from Mayo Medical Ven-

tures for a patentintellectual property re Aquaporin-4 associated

antibodies for diagnosis of neuromyelitis optica

Received July 14 2010 Accepted in final form September 2 2010

REFERENCES1 Debette S de Seze J Pruvo JP et al Long-term outcome

of acute and subacute myelopathies J Neurol 2009256980ndash988

2 Kelley BJ Erickson BJ Weinshenker BG Compressivemyelopathy mimicking transverse myelitis Neurologist201016120ndash122

3 Keegan BM Pittock SJ Lennon VA Autoimmune my-elopathy associated with collapsin response-mediatorprotein-5 immunoglobulin G Ann Neurol 200863531ndash534

4 Proposed diagnostic criteria and nosology of acute trans-verse myelitis Neurology 200259499ndash505

5 Takahashi T Miyazawa I Misu T et al Intractable hiccupand nausea in neuromyelitis optica with anti-aquaporin-4antibody a herald of acute exacerbations J Neurol Neuro-surg Psychiatry 2008791075ndash1078

6 Brex PA Ciccarelli O OrsquoRiordan JI Sailer M ThompsonAJ Miller DH A longitudinal study of abnormalities onMRI and disability from multiple sclerosis N Engl J Med2002346158ndash164

7 Weinshenker BG Wingerchuk DM Vukusic S et alNeuromyelitis optica IgG predicts relapse after longitudi-nally extensive transverse myelitis Ann Neurol 200659566ndash569

8 Pittock SJ Lennon VA de Seze J et al Neuromyelitisoptica and non organ-specific autoimmunity Arch Neurol20086578ndash83

9 Weinshenker BG OrsquoBrien PC Petterson TM et alA randomized trial of plasma exchange in acute centralnervous system inflammatory demyelinating disease AnnNeurol 199946878ndash886

If you liked this article you may be interested in

Continuum

Spinal Cord Root and Plexus Disorders June 2008 wwwaancomgoelibrarycontinuum

Neurology

Nathan P Staff et al Hypertrophic nerves producing myelopathy in fulminant CIDP August 242010 wwwneurologyorg

Jeremy D Isaacs et al Noncompressive myelopathy associated with violent axial tics of Tourettesyndrome February 23 2010 wwwneurologyorg

David Roshal et al Pearls amp Oy-sters Fibrocartilaginous embolism myelopathy February 162010 wwwneurologyorg

N Duggal et al Brain reorganization in patients with spinal cord compression evaluated usingfMRI March 30 2010 wwwneurologyorg

S8 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 5: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

syndromes evolve over days to weeks but generallyreach a nadir within 3 weeks after which there iseither improvement or stability4 When a myelopa-thy develops insidiously or continues to progress af-ter 3 weeks transverse myelitis becomes unlikely andthe differential diagnosis includes an intrinsic cordtumor compressive lesion DAVF metabolic de-rangement sarcoidosis or a degenerative process

The clinical syndrome of spinal cord involvementmay suggest a particular etiology although none arespecific Incomplete Brown-Sequard syndrome (lossof pain and temperature sensation contralateral toweakness) may be associated with either compressionor an intrinsic cord lesion such as demyelination Ananterior spinal cord syndrome with bilateral cortico-spinal and spinothalamic involvement sparing dorsalcolumn function is typical of anterior spinal arterydistribution infarction but may also occur in MS Acomplete spinal cord syndrome with bilateral in-volvement of all spinal tracts is rarely caused by anMS relapse or infarct but may occur in idiopathic orneuromyelitis optica (NMO)ndashassociated transversemyelitis or cord compression NMO-associated my-elitis more commonly presents with clinical and im-

aging signs of central cord involvement than doesMS-associated myelitis which more commonly af-fects the periphery of the cord Highly selective tractinvolvement (eg pure corticospinal tract involve-ment) especially when confirmed by MRI evidenceof highly localized enhancing tractopathy is charac-teristic of a paraneoplastic disorder (figure 1C)

Neurologic or constitutional symptoms not refer-able to the spinal cord focus the differential diagno-sis but may be irrelevant and distract one from the truediagnosis Optic neuritis or a prior diagnosis of inter-mediate uveitis may suggest MS Severe optic neuri-tis and an episode of unexplained intractable nauseaor hiccoughs are characteristic of NMO5 Coexist-ing peripheral neuropathy can occur in sarcoidSjogren syndrome lupus metabolic disorders(eg subacute combined degeneration) and para-neoplastic syndromes

WHAT INVESTIGATIONS SHOULD BE PER-FORMED MRI scan of the spinal cord with andwithout gadolinium contrast is the initial investiga-tion of choice in the evaluation of acute myelopathyContraindications are limited to MRI-incompatibleferromagnetic medical devices or foreign bodies andincompatibility with the scanner due to habitusWith careful coordination between cardiologists andradiologists MRI can be performed in selected pa-tients with cardiac pacemakers who are not entirelypacemaker-dependent For patients unable to un-dergo MRI CT myelography may be consideredwhen cord compression is suspected CSF evaluationincluding cell count glucose protein oligoclonalbands immunoglobulin G (IgG) index and cytologyis appropriate unless imaging history and examina-tion already suggest a clear diagnosis The results ofspinal MRI and clinical suspicion should guide theselection of additional investigations (table 2)

For noncompressive myelopathy the results ofMRI can be broadly subdivided into 3 categories

1 Short T2 hyperintensity (3 vertebral segmentsin length)

Focal discrete lesions that do not occupy the en-tire cord in axial cross-section are highly sugges-tive of MS (figure 1D) although remotesometimes forgotten trauma can occasionally pro-duce such lesions MRI scan of the brain may helpto clarify the cause detection of 1 or more brainlesions typical of MS (discrete periventricularjuxtacortical or infratentorial T2 hyperintensefoci) correlates with at least an 85ndash90 futurerisk of developing MS6 Oligoclonal bands andelevated CSF IgG index help to confirm a sus-pected MS diagnosis but CSF analysis may be

Table 2 Utility of diagnostic tests in evaluation of myelopathy

Test used to evaluate for Sensitivitya Specificitya

Imaging studies

Spinal MRI Rule out compressiondefine etiology

Brain MRI MS

CT myelogram Cord compression

Spinal angiogram DAVF

CSF studies

Oligoclonal bands MS

IgG index MS

PCR for herpesviruses CNS herpesvirus infection

Cytology Intramedullary neoplasm

Serologic and other bloodtests

NMO IgG NMO

Antinuclear SSanticardiolipin antibodies

Systemic inflammatorydisease NMO

Angiotensin convertingenzyme

Sarcoidosis

Serologies for infectiousagents

Parainfectious or infectiousmyelopathy

Electrodiagnostic studies

EMG Myelopathy associated withperipheral neuropathy (egsarcoid Sjoumlgrenparaneoplastic)

Abbreviations DAVF dural arteriovenous fistula IgG immunoglobulin G MS multiplesclerosis NMO neuromyelitis optica SS Sjoumlgren syndromea The symbols and indicate low intermediate and high sensitivityspecificityrespectively

S6 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

superfluous if other clinical and radiographic fea-tures are highly suggestive

2 Longitudinally extensive T2 hyperintensity (3vertebral segments in length)

Longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis oc-curs in idiopathic transverse myelitis NMO (fig-ure 1E) acute disseminated encephalomyelitiscord infarction and myelitis associated with sys-temic diseases such as systemic lupus erythemato-sus Serum NMO IgG testing is indicated beforeassigning a diagnosis of idiopathic transverse my-elitis7 Brain lesions on MRI eventually occur inthe majority of patients with NMO but usuallyNMO does not lead to the discrete Dawson fingerpattern of periventricular lesions characteristic ofMS However confluent and linear lesions encir-cling the ventricles may occur in NMO CSF oligo-clonal bands are usually absent in NMOCertain patterns of signal abnormality on MRIpredict a vascular disorder Anterior and centralcord signal change and swelling with sparing ofthe posterior columns suggest infarct particularlyin patients with a suggestive history (figure 1F)Posterior flow voids on spinal MRI representingdilation of the epidural venous plexus are a fairlyspecific but less sensitive indicator of DAVFwhereas longitudinally extensive gadolinium en-hancement and T2 hyperintensity often extend-ing to the conus are typical but nonspecificfindings (figure 1G) Magnetic resonance angiog-raphy may help to visualize a DAVF but spinalangiography is required for definitive diagnosisand treatment

If symptoms suggestive of recent infection or CSFpleocytosis (50 leukocytesL) are presentCSF PCR testing for herpesviruses (eg herpessimplex cytomegalovirus varicella zoster) and se-rologic testing for HIV syphilis and Lyme dis-ease should be considered Prominent CSFpleocytosis and occasionally neutrophilic pleocy-tosis may occur in myelitis associated with NMOSymptoms and signs of systemic inflammatorydisease such as polyarthritis should prompt auto-immune serologic testing (ie antinuclear anti-bodies SS-A SS-B antibodies) In the absence ofclinical indications of these diseases positive sero-logic tests may be unimportant although they mayindicate NMO a quarter of NMO spectrum disor-der patients have nonspecific serologic evidence ofautoimmunity usually in the absence of clinicalsigns of other autoimmune disorders8 Indiscrimi-nate use of autoantibody testing in all patientswith myelitis is not recommended MRI find-ings including nodular and persisting (2

months) gadolinium enhancement or menin-geal and nerve root enhancement suggest sar-coidosis (figure 1H) or rarely lymphoma

3 Normal MRI

Patients with suspected myelopathy and appar-ently normal MRI should undergo careful reviewof the images for subtle findings of cord signalchange atrophy or extrinsic compression by un-common causes (eg epidural lipomatosis) If ex-amination demonstrates unequivocal evidence ofa spinal cord process and the MRI is normal con-sider and test for degenerative infectious andmetabolic causes of myelopathy EMG and nerveconduction studies occasionally help to identify aprimary peripheral process (eg AIDP) or my-elopathy associated with concomitant peripheralneuropathy as can be seen in sarcoidosis and sub-acute combined degeneration

HOW SHOULD AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY BETREATED Controlled studies of treatment of acutemyelitis are lacking In myelitis due to demyelinat-ing inflammatory or undetermined cause expertconsensus favors high-dose IV corticosteroids typi-cally 1 gram of IV methylprednisolone daily for 5days This treatment should not be withheld in thecase of suspected recent viral infection the role of ste-roid treatment in patients with definitive evidence fordirect viral infection of the cord (eg myelitis occurringsimultaneously with or within days of a zoster eruption)is unclear Plasmapheresis should be considered in pa-tients who continue to have significant impairment af-ter high-dose corticosteroids In a sham-controlled trialof plasma exchange in patients with an acute relapse ofdemyelinating disease unresponsive to corticosteroidtreatment many of whom had acute myelitis 8 of 19(421) treated patients experienced moderate tomarked improvement vs 1 of 17 (59) who receivedsham treatment9 There are no established treatmentsfor patients with cord infarction

Long-term treatment to reduce recurrent attacks orprogression of deficit is required for patients withNMO neurosarcoidosis and systemic inflammatorydisorders Options to be considered for NMO includeazathioprine mycophenolate mofetil mitoxantroneand rituximab Sarcoidosis is usually treated with pro-longed high-dose oral corticosteroids (eg prednisone 1mgkgday for 6ndash12 months) Oral steroids andsteroid-sparing immunosuppressive agents are also typi-cally prescribed when systemic inflammatory processesinvolve the nervous system Immunomodulatory treat-ment should be considered in patients who are at highrisk for developing relapsing-remitting MS by virtue ofhaving additional lesions on MRI of the head

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S7

Ongoing clinical observation is an important partof the care of patients with an unexplained myelopa-thy Subsequent appearance of new neurologic orsystemic symptoms may reveal a demyelinating orsystemic inflammatory disorder Patients with relent-lessly progressive symptoms despite appropriate em-piric treatment may require spinal cord biopsy fordefinitive diagnosis particularly when follow-up im-aging demonstrates worsening

DISCUSSION Acute and subacute myelopathies re-quire urgent medical evaluation Imaging preferablyby MRI should be performed without delay to ex-clude a compressive lesion Subsequently history andphysical examination should guide subsequent inves-tigations to reach a definitive diagnosis As the etiol-ogy is often unclear at initial presentation empirictreatment should be provided while conducting fur-ther investigations to determine the etiology of my-elopathy A thorough evaluation often revealsevidence of a treatable disorder or one that may re-lapse without preventive treatment

DISCLOSURE

Dr Schmalstieg reports no disclosures Dr Weinshenker has served on

data safety monitoring boards for Novartis and Biogen Idec serves on the

editorial boards of Multiple Sclerosis the Canadian Journal of Neurological

Sciences and the Turkish Journal of Neurology receives research support

from the Guthy-Jackson Charitable Foundation and receives license roy-

alties from RSR Ltd and may receive royalties from Mayo Medical Ven-

tures for a patentintellectual property re Aquaporin-4 associated

antibodies for diagnosis of neuromyelitis optica

Received July 14 2010 Accepted in final form September 2 2010

REFERENCES1 Debette S de Seze J Pruvo JP et al Long-term outcome

of acute and subacute myelopathies J Neurol 2009256980ndash988

2 Kelley BJ Erickson BJ Weinshenker BG Compressivemyelopathy mimicking transverse myelitis Neurologist201016120ndash122

3 Keegan BM Pittock SJ Lennon VA Autoimmune my-elopathy associated with collapsin response-mediatorprotein-5 immunoglobulin G Ann Neurol 200863531ndash534

4 Proposed diagnostic criteria and nosology of acute trans-verse myelitis Neurology 200259499ndash505

5 Takahashi T Miyazawa I Misu T et al Intractable hiccupand nausea in neuromyelitis optica with anti-aquaporin-4antibody a herald of acute exacerbations J Neurol Neuro-surg Psychiatry 2008791075ndash1078

6 Brex PA Ciccarelli O OrsquoRiordan JI Sailer M ThompsonAJ Miller DH A longitudinal study of abnormalities onMRI and disability from multiple sclerosis N Engl J Med2002346158ndash164

7 Weinshenker BG Wingerchuk DM Vukusic S et alNeuromyelitis optica IgG predicts relapse after longitudi-nally extensive transverse myelitis Ann Neurol 200659566ndash569

8 Pittock SJ Lennon VA de Seze J et al Neuromyelitisoptica and non organ-specific autoimmunity Arch Neurol20086578ndash83

9 Weinshenker BG OrsquoBrien PC Petterson TM et alA randomized trial of plasma exchange in acute centralnervous system inflammatory demyelinating disease AnnNeurol 199946878ndash886

If you liked this article you may be interested in

Continuum

Spinal Cord Root and Plexus Disorders June 2008 wwwaancomgoelibrarycontinuum

Neurology

Nathan P Staff et al Hypertrophic nerves producing myelopathy in fulminant CIDP August 242010 wwwneurologyorg

Jeremy D Isaacs et al Noncompressive myelopathy associated with violent axial tics of Tourettesyndrome February 23 2010 wwwneurologyorg

David Roshal et al Pearls amp Oy-sters Fibrocartilaginous embolism myelopathy February 162010 wwwneurologyorg

N Duggal et al Brain reorganization in patients with spinal cord compression evaluated usingfMRI March 30 2010 wwwneurologyorg

S8 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 6: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

superfluous if other clinical and radiographic fea-tures are highly suggestive

2 Longitudinally extensive T2 hyperintensity (3vertebral segments in length)

Longitudinally extensive transverse myelitis oc-curs in idiopathic transverse myelitis NMO (fig-ure 1E) acute disseminated encephalomyelitiscord infarction and myelitis associated with sys-temic diseases such as systemic lupus erythemato-sus Serum NMO IgG testing is indicated beforeassigning a diagnosis of idiopathic transverse my-elitis7 Brain lesions on MRI eventually occur inthe majority of patients with NMO but usuallyNMO does not lead to the discrete Dawson fingerpattern of periventricular lesions characteristic ofMS However confluent and linear lesions encir-cling the ventricles may occur in NMO CSF oligo-clonal bands are usually absent in NMOCertain patterns of signal abnormality on MRIpredict a vascular disorder Anterior and centralcord signal change and swelling with sparing ofthe posterior columns suggest infarct particularlyin patients with a suggestive history (figure 1F)Posterior flow voids on spinal MRI representingdilation of the epidural venous plexus are a fairlyspecific but less sensitive indicator of DAVFwhereas longitudinally extensive gadolinium en-hancement and T2 hyperintensity often extend-ing to the conus are typical but nonspecificfindings (figure 1G) Magnetic resonance angiog-raphy may help to visualize a DAVF but spinalangiography is required for definitive diagnosisand treatment

If symptoms suggestive of recent infection or CSFpleocytosis (50 leukocytesL) are presentCSF PCR testing for herpesviruses (eg herpessimplex cytomegalovirus varicella zoster) and se-rologic testing for HIV syphilis and Lyme dis-ease should be considered Prominent CSFpleocytosis and occasionally neutrophilic pleocy-tosis may occur in myelitis associated with NMOSymptoms and signs of systemic inflammatorydisease such as polyarthritis should prompt auto-immune serologic testing (ie antinuclear anti-bodies SS-A SS-B antibodies) In the absence ofclinical indications of these diseases positive sero-logic tests may be unimportant although they mayindicate NMO a quarter of NMO spectrum disor-der patients have nonspecific serologic evidence ofautoimmunity usually in the absence of clinicalsigns of other autoimmune disorders8 Indiscrimi-nate use of autoantibody testing in all patientswith myelitis is not recommended MRI find-ings including nodular and persisting (2

months) gadolinium enhancement or menin-geal and nerve root enhancement suggest sar-coidosis (figure 1H) or rarely lymphoma

3 Normal MRI

Patients with suspected myelopathy and appar-ently normal MRI should undergo careful reviewof the images for subtle findings of cord signalchange atrophy or extrinsic compression by un-common causes (eg epidural lipomatosis) If ex-amination demonstrates unequivocal evidence ofa spinal cord process and the MRI is normal con-sider and test for degenerative infectious andmetabolic causes of myelopathy EMG and nerveconduction studies occasionally help to identify aprimary peripheral process (eg AIDP) or my-elopathy associated with concomitant peripheralneuropathy as can be seen in sarcoidosis and sub-acute combined degeneration

HOW SHOULD AN ACUTE MYELOPATHY BETREATED Controlled studies of treatment of acutemyelitis are lacking In myelitis due to demyelinat-ing inflammatory or undetermined cause expertconsensus favors high-dose IV corticosteroids typi-cally 1 gram of IV methylprednisolone daily for 5days This treatment should not be withheld in thecase of suspected recent viral infection the role of ste-roid treatment in patients with definitive evidence fordirect viral infection of the cord (eg myelitis occurringsimultaneously with or within days of a zoster eruption)is unclear Plasmapheresis should be considered in pa-tients who continue to have significant impairment af-ter high-dose corticosteroids In a sham-controlled trialof plasma exchange in patients with an acute relapse ofdemyelinating disease unresponsive to corticosteroidtreatment many of whom had acute myelitis 8 of 19(421) treated patients experienced moderate tomarked improvement vs 1 of 17 (59) who receivedsham treatment9 There are no established treatmentsfor patients with cord infarction

Long-term treatment to reduce recurrent attacks orprogression of deficit is required for patients withNMO neurosarcoidosis and systemic inflammatorydisorders Options to be considered for NMO includeazathioprine mycophenolate mofetil mitoxantroneand rituximab Sarcoidosis is usually treated with pro-longed high-dose oral corticosteroids (eg prednisone 1mgkgday for 6ndash12 months) Oral steroids andsteroid-sparing immunosuppressive agents are also typi-cally prescribed when systemic inflammatory processesinvolve the nervous system Immunomodulatory treat-ment should be considered in patients who are at highrisk for developing relapsing-remitting MS by virtue ofhaving additional lesions on MRI of the head

Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010 S7

Ongoing clinical observation is an important partof the care of patients with an unexplained myelopa-thy Subsequent appearance of new neurologic orsystemic symptoms may reveal a demyelinating orsystemic inflammatory disorder Patients with relent-lessly progressive symptoms despite appropriate em-piric treatment may require spinal cord biopsy fordefinitive diagnosis particularly when follow-up im-aging demonstrates worsening

DISCUSSION Acute and subacute myelopathies re-quire urgent medical evaluation Imaging preferablyby MRI should be performed without delay to ex-clude a compressive lesion Subsequently history andphysical examination should guide subsequent inves-tigations to reach a definitive diagnosis As the etiol-ogy is often unclear at initial presentation empirictreatment should be provided while conducting fur-ther investigations to determine the etiology of my-elopathy A thorough evaluation often revealsevidence of a treatable disorder or one that may re-lapse without preventive treatment

DISCLOSURE

Dr Schmalstieg reports no disclosures Dr Weinshenker has served on

data safety monitoring boards for Novartis and Biogen Idec serves on the

editorial boards of Multiple Sclerosis the Canadian Journal of Neurological

Sciences and the Turkish Journal of Neurology receives research support

from the Guthy-Jackson Charitable Foundation and receives license roy-

alties from RSR Ltd and may receive royalties from Mayo Medical Ven-

tures for a patentintellectual property re Aquaporin-4 associated

antibodies for diagnosis of neuromyelitis optica

Received July 14 2010 Accepted in final form September 2 2010

REFERENCES1 Debette S de Seze J Pruvo JP et al Long-term outcome

of acute and subacute myelopathies J Neurol 2009256980ndash988

2 Kelley BJ Erickson BJ Weinshenker BG Compressivemyelopathy mimicking transverse myelitis Neurologist201016120ndash122

3 Keegan BM Pittock SJ Lennon VA Autoimmune my-elopathy associated with collapsin response-mediatorprotein-5 immunoglobulin G Ann Neurol 200863531ndash534

4 Proposed diagnostic criteria and nosology of acute trans-verse myelitis Neurology 200259499ndash505

5 Takahashi T Miyazawa I Misu T et al Intractable hiccupand nausea in neuromyelitis optica with anti-aquaporin-4antibody a herald of acute exacerbations J Neurol Neuro-surg Psychiatry 2008791075ndash1078

6 Brex PA Ciccarelli O OrsquoRiordan JI Sailer M ThompsonAJ Miller DH A longitudinal study of abnormalities onMRI and disability from multiple sclerosis N Engl J Med2002346158ndash164

7 Weinshenker BG Wingerchuk DM Vukusic S et alNeuromyelitis optica IgG predicts relapse after longitudi-nally extensive transverse myelitis Ann Neurol 200659566ndash569

8 Pittock SJ Lennon VA de Seze J et al Neuromyelitisoptica and non organ-specific autoimmunity Arch Neurol20086578ndash83

9 Weinshenker BG OrsquoBrien PC Petterson TM et alA randomized trial of plasma exchange in acute centralnervous system inflammatory demyelinating disease AnnNeurol 199946878ndash886

If you liked this article you may be interested in

Continuum

Spinal Cord Root and Plexus Disorders June 2008 wwwaancomgoelibrarycontinuum

Neurology

Nathan P Staff et al Hypertrophic nerves producing myelopathy in fulminant CIDP August 242010 wwwneurologyorg

Jeremy D Isaacs et al Noncompressive myelopathy associated with violent axial tics of Tourettesyndrome February 23 2010 wwwneurologyorg

David Roshal et al Pearls amp Oy-sters Fibrocartilaginous embolism myelopathy February 162010 wwwneurologyorg

N Duggal et al Brain reorganization in patients with spinal cord compression evaluated usingfMRI March 30 2010 wwwneurologyorg

S8 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 7: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

Ongoing clinical observation is an important partof the care of patients with an unexplained myelopa-thy Subsequent appearance of new neurologic orsystemic symptoms may reveal a demyelinating orsystemic inflammatory disorder Patients with relent-lessly progressive symptoms despite appropriate em-piric treatment may require spinal cord biopsy fordefinitive diagnosis particularly when follow-up im-aging demonstrates worsening

DISCUSSION Acute and subacute myelopathies re-quire urgent medical evaluation Imaging preferablyby MRI should be performed without delay to ex-clude a compressive lesion Subsequently history andphysical examination should guide subsequent inves-tigations to reach a definitive diagnosis As the etiol-ogy is often unclear at initial presentation empirictreatment should be provided while conducting fur-ther investigations to determine the etiology of my-elopathy A thorough evaluation often revealsevidence of a treatable disorder or one that may re-lapse without preventive treatment

DISCLOSURE

Dr Schmalstieg reports no disclosures Dr Weinshenker has served on

data safety monitoring boards for Novartis and Biogen Idec serves on the

editorial boards of Multiple Sclerosis the Canadian Journal of Neurological

Sciences and the Turkish Journal of Neurology receives research support

from the Guthy-Jackson Charitable Foundation and receives license roy-

alties from RSR Ltd and may receive royalties from Mayo Medical Ven-

tures for a patentintellectual property re Aquaporin-4 associated

antibodies for diagnosis of neuromyelitis optica

Received July 14 2010 Accepted in final form September 2 2010

REFERENCES1 Debette S de Seze J Pruvo JP et al Long-term outcome

of acute and subacute myelopathies J Neurol 2009256980ndash988

2 Kelley BJ Erickson BJ Weinshenker BG Compressivemyelopathy mimicking transverse myelitis Neurologist201016120ndash122

3 Keegan BM Pittock SJ Lennon VA Autoimmune my-elopathy associated with collapsin response-mediatorprotein-5 immunoglobulin G Ann Neurol 200863531ndash534

4 Proposed diagnostic criteria and nosology of acute trans-verse myelitis Neurology 200259499ndash505

5 Takahashi T Miyazawa I Misu T et al Intractable hiccupand nausea in neuromyelitis optica with anti-aquaporin-4antibody a herald of acute exacerbations J Neurol Neuro-surg Psychiatry 2008791075ndash1078

6 Brex PA Ciccarelli O OrsquoRiordan JI Sailer M ThompsonAJ Miller DH A longitudinal study of abnormalities onMRI and disability from multiple sclerosis N Engl J Med2002346158ndash164

7 Weinshenker BG Wingerchuk DM Vukusic S et alNeuromyelitis optica IgG predicts relapse after longitudi-nally extensive transverse myelitis Ann Neurol 200659566ndash569

8 Pittock SJ Lennon VA de Seze J et al Neuromyelitisoptica and non organ-specific autoimmunity Arch Neurol20086578ndash83

9 Weinshenker BG OrsquoBrien PC Petterson TM et alA randomized trial of plasma exchange in acute centralnervous system inflammatory demyelinating disease AnnNeurol 199946878ndash886

If you liked this article you may be interested in

Continuum

Spinal Cord Root and Plexus Disorders June 2008 wwwaancomgoelibrarycontinuum

Neurology

Nathan P Staff et al Hypertrophic nerves producing myelopathy in fulminant CIDP August 242010 wwwneurologyorg

Jeremy D Isaacs et al Noncompressive myelopathy associated with violent axial tics of Tourettesyndrome February 23 2010 wwwneurologyorg

David Roshal et al Pearls amp Oy-sters Fibrocartilaginous embolism myelopathy February 162010 wwwneurologyorg

N Duggal et al Brain reorganization in patients with spinal cord compression evaluated usingfMRI March 30 2010 wwwneurologyorg

S8 Neurology Clinical Practice 75(Suppl 1) November 2 2010

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology

Page 8: Approach to acute or subacute myelopathy - Neurology · disorders, toxic/metabolic syndromes, neoplasm, paraneoplastic syndromes, and sarcoidosis. Although compression is often obvious

DOI 101212WNL0b013e3181fb3638201075S2-S8 Neurology

William F Schmalstieg and Brian G WeinshenkerApproach to acute or subacute myelopathy

This information is current as of November 1 2010

ServicesUpdated Information amp

httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at

References httpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullref-list-1

This article cites 9 articles 2 of which you can access for free at

Citations

leshttpnneurologyorgcontent7518_Supplement_1S2fullotherarticThis article has been cited by 4 HighWire-hosted articles

Subspecialty Collections

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectiontransverse_myelitisTransverse myelitis

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_spinal_cordAll Spinal Cord

httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_demyelinating_disease_cnsAll Demyelinating disease (CNS)following collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the

Permissions amp Licensing

httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in

Reprints

httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online

rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright Copyright copy 2010 by AAN Enterprises Inc All

reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology


Recommended