Aragon Appeal and Exhibits

8/10/2019 Aragon Appeal and Exhibits

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/aragon-appeal-and-exhibits 1/24

!"#$%&' )* +,-. /0112//30445

/0678992:

-,;);-. < =>-? @A7A

@BCBD#EF& 2E"GHIJK

-+?L /BFD&# 6JMKA

4$D @FC&J&D* 1@ N,,+)

4$D @FC&J&D 1E#O @'&I PJIFFEFC 1$QQEDDE$F

";$ 1E#O $R 4$D @FC&J&D PJIFFEFC :&S#A

3ECB&'$I PJITI !RRE"&+,- UA 3ECB&'$I /#A* .#G 3J$$'

4$D @FC&J&D* 1@ N,,-+

V2> 1ID& U$A W&D#EFC 9&F#I#EM& 9'I"# 7IS U$A X+??LY1U

1P1Y+,-LYLL-NY:6Y/PV2UWY+,-LYLL+,Y7U:YV&"-

@KK'&DD> --=?Y-+.X Z /BFD&# 6JMKA IFK N-X UA 2M&'&## /#A

@SS&IJ $R> @KMED$'O @C&F"O[D :&#&'QEFI#E$F 4&##&' KI#&K /&S#A +)* +,-.

@KK&FKBQ #$ 2UWY+,-LYLL+,Y7U:

2UWY+,-LYLL+,Y7U:

!F /&S#&Q%&' +?* +,-.* #G& @KMED$'O @C&F"O S'&SI'&K IF @KK&FKBQ #$ #G& 8FE#EIJ

/#BKO;7E#ECI#&K U&CI#EM& :&"JI'I#E$F \8/;7U:] R$' HGI# E# "GI'I"#&'ET&D ID ^QEF$'_

"GIFC&D #$ #G& K&M&J$SQ&F# S'$`&"# J$"I#&K I# #G& IKK'&DD JED#&K I%$M&* G&'&EFIR#&''&R&''&K #$ ID ̂ P'$`&"#A_ 9GED ED I QEDYD#I#&Q&F# $R #G& RI"#DA 9G& IKKE#E$F $R Q$'&

#GIF L*?,, DaBI'& R&&# $R "$QQ&'"EIJ DSI"& ED IF EF"'&ID& $R .+b* aBIJEROEFC E# ID I

F&H IFK KERR&'&F# S'$`&"#A 9G& 8/;7U: IFIJOT&K "$QQ&'"EIJ DaBI'& R$$#IC& I#=*.,) DRA* #G& "#$ %&'(#)* `BD# '&M&IJ&K JID# H&&c GID --*N,) DRA $R '&#IEJ I'&IA 9GED

EF#&FDERE&K BD& GID DECFERE"IF# EQSI"#D $F MI'E$BD &FME'$FQ&F#IJ RI"#$'D IFK'&aBE'&D #GI# #G& 7U: %& '&Y"E'"BJI#&K IFK BSC'IK&K #$ IF 2FME'$FQ&F#IJ 8QSI"#

V&S$'# \28V]A

+' '%%'&*,"-*. /'& %,01-) &#2-#$ '/ "#$ 3&'(#)*

dE#G $FJO -, KIOD %&#H&&F #G& BFM&EJEFC $R #G& ^F&H_ S'$`&"#* IFK #G& #EQEFC $R E#DISS&IJ K&IKJEF&* #G& SB%JE" GID F$# GIK IF $SS$'#BFE#O #$ "$QQ&F# $F #G& F&H

S'$`&"# $' G&I' E# S'&D&F#&K EF I SB%JE" R$'BQA 12e@ \1IJER$'FEI 2FME'$FQ&F#IJ

eBIJE#O @"#] '&aBE'&D #GI# #G&'& %& IF I""B'I#& IFK D#I%J& S'$`&"# K&D"'ES#E$FA @

REFE#& S'$`&"# ED "'B"EIJ R$' IFIJODED %O %$#G #G& SB%JE" IFK #G& K&"EDE$F QIc&'DA



456 3783896: ;<3 =9 =+>8+9=946+4 ?=45 456 <33@=><A@6 B8+=+C

9G& S'$S$D&K P'$`&"# D&&cD I :&FDE#O 6$FBD* %B# '&JE&D $F !RRY7&FB EF"&F#EM&D #$

I""$QQ$KI#& E#D '&#IEJ "$QS$F&F#* HGE"G ED F$# EF "$QSJEIF"& HE#G #G& /#I#&

!'KEFIF"&A

:#"D-*. A'",D -")#"*-2#D EF. "'* 0# F0,D#G *' /,&*H#& *H# &#*F-1 %&'/-*F0-1-*.'/ F E-I#GJ,D# %&'(#)*K #2#" -/ *H# )'EE,"-*. D,%%'D#G1. FDLD /'& -*M

@""$'KEFC #$ #G& @KK&FKBQ IFK #G& 8/;7U: #G& ISSJE"IF# D&&cD #$ S&'QE# #H$ ?YD#$'O QEf&KYBD& %BEJKEFCD EF JE&B $R LYD#$'O* I X+ R$$# QIfEQBQ G&ECG# EF I \1+Y-W4]

.? R$$# T$F&* IFK EF"'&ID&K RJ$$' I'&I 'I#E$A 9G& ISSJE"IF# ED %BFKJEFC #$C&#G&'#G&D& EF"&F#EM&D IFK "JIEQEFC #G&Q IJJ ID SI'# $R #G& :&FDE#O 6$FBD S'$C'IQA 8F

'&IJE#O* #G& EF"'&ID&K G&ECG# ID '&aB&D#&K IFK IKKE#E$FIJ D#$'E&D I'& EF ME$JI#E$F $R

#G& !'KEFIF"&A :&FDE#O 6$FBD EF"&F#EM&D I'& KED"'&#E$FI'O IFK $FJO IJJ$H&K #$ #G&&f#&F# #GI# #G&O I'& F&"&DDI'O #$ $RRYD&# #G& &"$F$QE" EQSI"#D '&JI#&K #$ #G&

S'$MEDE$F $R #G$D& Xb $R BFE#DA 9G&'& &fED#D F$ "$'$JJI'O %&#H&&F #G& &"$F$QE"R&IDE%EJE#O $R Xb J$HYEF"$Q& BFE#D IFK #G& &f"&DDEM& '&aB&D#D R$' X+[ R#A QIfEQBQ

G&ECG# IFK #G& IKKE#E$FIJ RJ$$'DA 9G& #'B#G ED '&M&IJ&K EF #G& #&f# $R #G& 7U:* SIC&

+.N>

!"# %&'(#)* +,- '&./.0,112 3#-./0#3 ,- , 4.5#6-*'&2 ,11 &#-.3#0*.,1 3#5#1'78#0* *",*

7&'7'-#3 *' 9*.1.:# , -#)'03 ;06<#09 =0)#0*.5# *' ,11'+ 4'& ,0 ,33.*.'0,1 -*'&2 ,03 >>

4##* .0 "#./"*? @'+#5#&A .0 &#-7'0-# *' *"# )'8890.*2A *"# %&'(#)* ,33#3 , -./0.4.),0*

)'88#&).,1 )'87'0#0* ,1'0/ B90-#* C'91#5,&3 ,03 >D -9&719- /9#-* &#-.3#0*.,1

7,&E.0/ -7,)#- +".)" &#-91*#3 .0 '0# ,33.*.'0,1 1#5#1 .0 '&3#& *' 8,.0*,.0 *"# 3#-.&#3

&#-.3#0*.,1 3#0-.*2? F.*" *"# ,33.*.'0,1 -*'&2A *"# %&'(#)* 0' 1'0/#& G9,1.4.#- 4'& *"#

;06<#09 "#./"* .0)#0*.5#?

9G& ISSJE"IF# '&M&IJD #GI# #G& EF"&F#EM&D I'& F&&K&K #$ I""$QQ$KI#& #G& '&#IEJ* IFK

#G&F QEDJ&IKD #G& '&IK&' %O "JIEQEFC #GI# #G& $'ECEFIJ S'$`&"# HID ? D#$'E&DA 9G&$'ECEFIJ S'$`&"# HID L D#$'E&D \2M&'&## S$'#E$F] IFK . D#$'E&D \/BFD&# S$'#E$F]* IFK

IF IJJY'&DEK&F#EIJ :&FDE#O 6$FBD S'$`&"# "$FDED#EFC $R +,- '&DEK&F"&D IFK ++-

SI'cEFC D#IJJDA



9G& SG$#$ IFK I'#E"J& SB%JEDG&K $F #G& 2ID#DEK&' 4@ %J$C \HHHA&ID#DEK&'JIA"$Q]

K&D"'E%&D I S'$RE#I%J& :&FDE#O 6$FBD S'$`&"# BDEFC #G& I%$M& "$FRECB'I#E$FA :&FDE#O

6$FBD S'$`&"#D I'& IJJ$H&K EF"&F#EM&D \HIEM&'D] $FJO #$ #G& &f#&F# #G&O I'&

F&"&DDI'O #$ &FDB'& #G& J$HYEF"$Q& G$BDEFC S$'#E$F $R I S'$`&"#A g$H #G&F "IF #G&

ISSJE"IF# "JIEQ #GI# #G& FBQ&'$BD !F IFK !RRY7&FB EF"&F#EM&D I'& DBKK&FJO

F&"&DDI'O D$J&JO #$ &FDB'& #G& R&IDE%EJE#O $R X b J$H EF"$Q& BFE#D $R +-, '&DEK&F#EIJ

BFE#D IFK +)X '&DEK&F#EIJ SI'cEFC D#IJJDh 9G& +,- BFE# $'ECEFIJ S'$`&"# HID $FJO

IDcEFC R$' I 3@V IK`BD#Q&F# IFK QIEF#IEF&K S'$RE#I%EJE#O HE#G #GI# $F& EF"&F#EM&A

9G& S'$R$'QI IFK E#D IFIJODED HID S'&SI'&K %O #G& ISSJE"IF# IFK K$&D F$# ISS&I' #$

GIM& %&&F '&ME&H&K %O IF $%`&"#EM&* $B#DEK& I""$BF#EFC "$FDBJ#IF#* "IJJEFC EF#$

aB&D#E$F #G& MIJEKE#O $R #G& &F#E'& K$"BQ&F#A @D DB"G* #G& S'$R$'QI R$' #G& P'$`&"# ED

EF"$F"JBDEM& EF E#D I%EJE#O #$ S'$M& #GI# #G& &f"&DDEM& EF"&F#EM&D I'& #E&K $FJO #$ #G&

R&IDE%EJE#O $R #G& J$HYEF"$Q& KH&JJEFCDA 9G& 1E#O QBD# REFK #GI# #GED S'$`&"#* HE#G E#D

"B''&F# JED# $R '&aB&D#D* K$&D F$# aBIJERO BFK&' #G& :&FDE#O 6$FBD !'KEFIF"&A

9G& S'$S$D&K ^#'I"# QIS ISS'$MIJ ED "$F#EFC&F# BS$F #G& ISS'$MIJ $R #G& :&FDE#O6$FBDi_ \SA LN* :&"EDE$F 4&##&']A 9G& @KMED$'O @C&F"O RIEJD #$ '&"$CFET& #GI# #G&

S'$`&"# ED EF ME$JI#E$F $R #G& "B''&F# T$FEFC #G'&DG$JKD R$' G&ECG#* 3@V IFK SI'cEFC*

IFK HE#G$B# #G& :&FDE#O 6$FBD EF"&F#EM&D #G& P'$`&"# H$BJK F&M&' %& S&'QE##&KA 8R#G& DIQ& '&aB&D#D H&'& QIK& ID KED"'&#E$FI'O j$FEFC WI'EIF"&D #G&'& H$BJK %& F$

%IDED R$' ISS'$MIJA



456 :69=C+ 87 =;378N6;6+4 8O 456 3783896: 9PA:=N=9=8+ =9 +84

>8+9=946+4 ?=45 456 <33@=><A@6 C6+67<@ 3@<+

@D K&DECF&K* #G& P'$`&"# ED EF"$FDED#&F# HE#G #G& D#I#&K $%`&"#EM&D $R #G& /EJM&' 4Ic&

k 2"G$ PI'c k 2JODEIF WIJJ&O 1$QQBFE#O PJIFA 1$QQBFE#O PJIFD I'& QIFKI#&K %O

#G& /#I#& IFK QBD# %& "$FDEK&'&K HE#GEF #G& SJIFFEFC GE&'I'"GO ID DB"GA 8# HEJJ"IBD& IKM&'D& &FME'$FQ&F#IJ EQSI"#D #$ #G& DB''$BFKEFC F&ECG%$'G$$KD #GI# I'&

DECFERE"IF#* S&'QIF&F# IFK HE#G$B# QE#ECI#E$FA

4&F//-) F"G *&-% )',"*D F&# -"F)),&F*#1. )F1),1F*#G

@SSJE"IF# &''$F&$BDJO '&JE&D $F 892 \8FD#E#B#& $R 9'IRRE" 2FCEF&&'D] JIFK BD& #'ES"$K& l=+, R$' #G& F&H --*N,) DRA '&#IEJ S'$`&"#A 892 "$K& l=+, ED R$' /G$SSEFC

1&F#&'D* DB"G ID $F& QECG# &F"$BF#&' EF I DB%B'%IF F&ECG%$'G$$K* F$# EF I 7Ef&KY

0D& B'%IF EFREJJ S'$`&"#A 9G& 892 K&REF&D "$K& l=+, ID>

HI B"'77.0/ )#0*#& .- ,0 .0*#/&,*#3 /&'97 '4 )'88#&).,1 #-*,J1.-"8#0*- *",* .- 71,00#3A 3#5#1'7#3A '+0#3 ,03 8,0,/#3 ,- , 90.*? I -"'77.0/ )#0*#&K- )'87'-.*.'0 .-

&#1,*#3 *' .*- 8,&E#* ,&#, .0 *#&8- '4 -.:#A 1'),*.'0 ,03 *27# '4 -*'&#? I -"'77.0/

)#0*#& ,1-' 7&'5.3#- '06-.*# 7,&E.0/ 4,).1.*.#- -944.).#0* *' -#&5# .*- '+0 7,&E.0/

3#8,03-?L

9G& ISSJE"IF# ED F$# $S&'I#EFC I /G$SSEFC 1&F#&' ID K&REF&K %O 892 4IFK 0D& 1$K&

=+,A 9G& ISSJE"IF# K&D"'E%&D #G& '&#IEJ DSI"& ID "$QQ&'"EIJ "$FK$QEFEBQD R$' DIJ&AU$ EF#&C'I#E$F $' '&#IEJ SJIFFEFC GID %&&F $RR&'&K %O #G& ISSJE"IF#* IFK #G& SI'cEFC

'&aBE'&Q&F# GID F$# %&&F Q&#A 8F RI"#* #G& ISSJE"IF# RIEJD #$ K&DECFI#& JIFK BD&

"$K&D #$ #G& "$QQ&'"EIJ BFE#D ID '&aBE'&K* IFK EFD#&IK '&JE&D $F #G& 892 =+, ID I

"I#"GYIJJ R$' E#D '&#IEJ "$QS$F&F#A 0DEFC #GED $F&YDET&YRE#DYIJJ ISS'$I"G #$ E#D O&#YBFK&#&'QEF&K '&#IEJ "$QS$DE#E$F '&FK&'D EFI""B'I#& IFK I'#ERE"EIJJO J$H #'ES "$BF#D#GI# K$ F$# '&RJ&"# I"#BIJ F&ECG%$'G$$K '&#IEJ SI##&'FDA 12e@ '&aBE'&D #GI#

&FME'$FQ&F#IJ D#BKE&D BD& #G& Q$D# "$FD&'MI#EM& &D#EQI#&D IFK H$'D# "ID& D"&FI'E$

IFIJOD&D D$ #GI# K&"EDE$FYQIc&'D I'& BFJEc&JO #$ &''$' EF `BKCQ&F#A 9G& ISSJE"IF#[D

#'IRRE" &FCEF&&' GID ME$JI#&K 12e@ %O BDEFC #G& Q$D# "$FM&FE&F# 892 "$K& #GI#

S'$KB"&D I RIM$'I%JO J$H #'ES C&F&'I#E$F "$BF#* HE#G$B# #IcEFC EF#$ I""$BF# #G&

&fED#EFC SI##&'FD $R BD& HE#GEF #G& EQQ&KEI#& I'&I #GI# I'& JEc&JO #$ '&S&I# HE#GEF

#G& F&H S'$`&"#A

3$' EFD#IF"&* 892 lNL- ED BD&K R$' I F&ECG%$'G$$K '&D#IB'IF# DB"G ID I PETTI PI'J$'*

6ED#'$ $' 7&fE"IF 3$$KA 9G& S&Ic P7 G$B' #'ES 'I#& R$' 892 lNL- ED XA.N* HG&'&ID#G& l=+, /G$SSEFC 1&F#&' GID I S&Ic P7 #'ES R$'&"ID# $R $FJO LAX-A @""B'I#&JO'&RJ&"#EFC #G& S'$%I%J& EF#&FK&K BD& $R I '&#IEJ DSI"& HEJJ '&DBJ# EF #'ES "IJ"BJI#E$FD

#GI# "IF %& #HE"& ID QIFO \$' Q$'&] #GIF HGI# GID %&&F $RR&'&K EF #G&&FME'$FQ&F#IJ K$"BQ&F#A 892 "$K&D I##I"G&K ID 2mg8689 -A

@ DIQSJ& $R #G& F&H --*N,) DR '&#IEJ "$QS$F&F# ED I##I"G&K ID 2mg8689 + DG$HEFCSJIBDE%J& RB#B'& BD&D $R #G& '&#IEJ DSI"& R$JJ$HEFC #G& &fED#EFC SI##&'F $R



F&ECG%$'G$$K BD&DA dG&F I "$QSI'ED$F ED QIK& BDEFC I"#BIJ 892 4IFK 0D& 1$K&D

R$' F&ECG%$'G$$K D&'MEFC '&#IEJ BD&D DB"G ID I 5$CI /#BKE$* 6Ic&'O;:&JE* :'O

1J&IF&'D* W&CIF V&D#IB'IF#* gIE' /IJ$F IFK nID#'$ PB% HE#GEF #G& F&H --*N,) DRA

'&#IEJ DSI"&* E# ED "J&I' #GI# #G& "I#"GYIJJ 892 l=+, RIJJD DG$'#A 0DEFC IF IM&'IC& C'$BS

$R F&ECG%$'G$$K BD&D EF #G& 2mg8689 + DIQSJ&* E# ED DG$HF #GI# @7 P&Ic g$B' #'ESD

EF"'&ID& %O .Xb IFK P7 P&Ic g$B' #'ESD EF"'&ID& %O ..b $M&' #G& C&F&'E"/G$SSEFC 1&F#&' \892 =+,] K&D"'ES#E$F JED#&K EF #G& &FME'$FQ&F#IJ K$"BQ&F#A 9G&

ISSJE"IF# QBD# %& IDc&K #$ '&Y"E'"BJI#& #G& 7U: #$ I""$BF# R$' EQS'$M&K #'ES

C&F&'I#E$F "$BF#D #GI# R$JJ$H 12e@ CBEK&JEF&D BDEFC #G& Q$D# "$FD&'MI#EM&

&D#EQI#&D R$' I"#BIJ IFK JEc&JO SI##&'FD $R BD&A @D #G& DIQSJ& DG$HD* '&IJYJER& #'ESC&F&'I#E$F ED JEc&JO #$ S'$KB"& ISS'$fEQI#&JO .?b Q$'& #'ESD #GIF GIM& %&&F

&D#EQI#&K EF #G& @KK&FKBQA

8# ED H$'#G F$#EFC #GI# 9I%J& .A+ $F SIC& L) $R #G& 9'IRRE" /#BKO DG$HD RB#B'& 4&M&J

!R /&'ME"& HE#G S'$`&"# "$FKE#E$FD KB'EFC #G& P&Ic @7 G$B' I# /BFD&# 6JMKA IFK7I'E$F @M&A \#G& K'EM&HIO] #$ '&I"G 4!/ 1 HE#G I W;1 VI#E$ $R ,A,LNA @ DECFERE"IF#

EQSI"# H$BJK GIM& %&&F R$BFK ER #G& W;1 VI#E$ '&I"G&K ,A,.,* -Y$F& GBFK'&K#G $R IK&"EQIJ C'&I#&'A /&& 2mg8689 LA 8R #G& F&ECG%$'G$$K '&#IEJ HID I""B'I#&JO

I""$BF#&K R$' HE#G S'$S&' 892 "$K&D* EFD#&IK $R #G& =+, "I#"G IJJ* #G& P&Ic @7 W;1

VI#E$ H$BJK "&'#IEFJO K&Q$FD#'I#& I #G'&DG$JK EQSI"#A

7#)-&),1F*-'" '/ ;+: &#Q,-&#G /'& &#*F-1 %F&L-"R E-D)F1),1F*-'"

9G& 8/;7U: @KK&FKBQ IFK #G& @KMED$'O @C&F"O K&#&'QEFI#E$F '&JO $F #G& F$HY

K&RBF"# 2ID# 4$D @FC&J&D /#I#& 2F#&'S'ED& j$F& \/2j] R$' #G& ISSJE"IF#[D '&JE&R R'$Q

SI'cEFC '&aBE'&Q&F#D D&# %O JIHA @J#G$BCG j87@/ "$F#EFB&D #$ JED# #G& /#I#&

2F#&'S'ED& j$F& EF E#D DOD#&Q* /2j[D H&'& '&S&IJ&K EF oBJO +,-L HG&F #G& /#I#&

J&CEDJI#B'& SIDD&K @A6A NL IFK #G&'& ED F$ '&"$'K $R `B'EDKE"#E$F R$' #G& "$F#EFB&K BD&$R #G& /2jA 0FK&' #G& '&S&IJ&K @"# SI'cEFC '&aBE'&Q&F#D H&'& '&KB"&K #$ + DSI"&D

S&' -,,, DR $R F&H '&#IEJ K&M&J$SQ&F#A /EF"& #G& /2j S'$C'IQ GID %&&F &JEQEFI#&K*

#G& ISSJE"IF# QBD# '&M&'# #$ .;-,,, DRA $' ?;-,,, DRA* K&S&FKEFC BS$F #G& JIFK BD&K&DECFI#E$FA /&& 4@:6/ %BJJ&#EF P;j1 +,,+Y,-- I##I"G&K ID 2mg8689 .A

>F*FD*&'%H-) +#-RH0'&H''G 4&F//-) ="*&,D-'"

7I'E$F @M&A ED #G& P'$`&"#[D S'EF"ESIJ K'EM&HIOA @JJ "I'D &F#&'EFC #G& S'$`&"# G&IKY

$F R'$Q #G& d&D# HEJJ aB&B& $F 7I'E$F @M&A @JJ "I'D &fE#EFC #G& P'$`&"# #$ I""&DD #G&

-,- RHO U$'#G IFK /$B#G HEJJ &fE# #G& S'$`&"#* K'EMEFC $F 7I'E$F IFK 6&JJ&MB&

@M&FB&D* HGE"G I'& &F#E'&JO '&DEK&F#EIJ D#'&&#DA

7I'E$F @M&A ED #G& 2ID#&'JO CI#&HIO #$ #G& @FC&JEF$ g&ECG#D gP!jp #G& RE'D# gP!j EF

#G& 1E#OA 8# ED I BFEaB& '&DEK&F#EIJ F&ECG%$'G$$K HE#G S'$#&"#&K T$FEFC #$ S'&D&'M&

GED#$'E" DEFCJ& IFK QBJ#EYRIQEJO S'$S&'#E&DA

@FC&JEF$ g&ECG#D GID I FBQ%&' $R BFEaB& "GI'I"#&'ED#E"D #GI# IRR&"# J$"IJ #'IRRE"A 8# ED

G$Q& #$ I MI'E&#O $R '"R'-"R /-1E-"R %&'(#)*D EF"JBKEFC #&J&MEDE$F D&'E&D IFK QBJ#EY



SI'# 7$#E$F PE"#B'& R'IF"GED&D DB"G ID ^3ID# IFK 3B'E$BDA_ 3EJQ S'$`&"#D "J$D& K$HF

$' DB%D#IF#EIJJO %J$"c D&"#E$FD $R 7I'E$F IFK 6&JJ&MB& R$' REJQEFC BD& I# J&ID# ? KIOD

S&' Q$F#GA 4Ec&HED&* :$KC&' #'IRRE" aB&B&D $F J$"IJ D#'&&#D %&R$'& IFK IR#&' CIQ&D

I# J&ID# =- KIOD $R #G& O&I'A

@FC&JEF$ g&ECG#D GID I%BFKIF# S&K&D#'EIF I"#EME#O IFK F$ DECFIJET&K EF#&'D&"#E$FDA@ "GB'"G* DQIJJ SI'c* "$FM&FE&F"& D#$'& IFK #G& &F#'IF"& #$ 2"G$ PI'c 4Ic&* I'& IJJ

R$BFK $F 7I'E$F IFK 6&JJ&MB& %&#H&&F #G& P'$`&"# IFK -,- R'&&HIO I""&DDA 9G&'&

I'& ? D#$S DECFD #GI# P'$`&"# '&DEK&F#D QBD# G&&K ID #G&O "$Q& IFK C$ %&#H&&F #G&

P'$`&"# I# #G& 7I'E$F K'EM&HIO IFK #G& -,- U$'#GA 9G&'& I'& L D#$SD DECFD IFK I#B'F $F#$ I 4$"IJ V&DEK&F#EIJ D#'&&# F&"&DDI'O #$ "$Q& IFK C$ %&#H&&F #G& P'$`&"#

IFK #G& -,- U$'#GA

9G& #'ES C&F&'I#E$F "$BF# R$' #G& F&HJO BFM&EJ&K S'$`&"# HE#G --*N,) DRA $R '&#IEJ HEJJ

F$H '&I"G I# J&ID# L*L?N K'EM&HIO #'ESD* ID EFKE"I#&K EF #G& @KK&FKBQA :'EM&HIOIFIJOD&D I'& F$# DB%`&"# #$ SIDDY%O K&KB"#E$FD* I""$'KEFC #$ %$#G 4@:!9 IFK 892A

9G& ISSJE"IF#[D #'IRRE" D#BKO K&D"'E%&D #G& #'ES KED#'E%B#E$F $F SIC& LX>

Y +,b $R #G& #'ESD #$HI'KD #G& F$'#G

Y L,b $R #G& #'ESD #$HI'KD #G& D$B#G

Y +?b $R #G& #'ESD #$HI'KD #G& &ID#

Y +?b $R #G& #'ESD #$HI'KD #G& H&D#

@D #G& QIS %&J$H EFKE"I#&D* #G& 7I'E$F @M&A K'EM&HIO \+] '&S'&D&F#D IJJ K'EM&HIO

#'ESD &ID# IFK H&D#* $' ?,b $R #G& I%$M& KIEJO S'$`&"# #'ES C&F&'I#E$F>

L*L?N ; + q -)=, #'ESDA

@""$'KEFC #$ 892 'BJ&D R$JJ$H&K %O 4@:!9* #G&'& ED F$ #'ES '&KB"#E$F I# S'$`&"#



K'EM&HIOD* D$ #G& &F#E'& -*)=, &ID# IFK H&D# #'ESD H$BJK %& $F 7I'E$F @M&A* I

'&DEK&F#EIJ D#'&&# EF IF gP!jA 9GED '&S'&D&F#D I DECFERE"IF# EF#'BDE$F HE#GEF I

S'$#&"#&K F&ECG%$'G$$K !M&'JIOA V&DEK&F#D JEMEFC $F 7I'E$F GIM& QIFBIJJO

"$BF#&K "B''&F# #$#IJ KIEJO #'ESD I# ISS'$fEQI#&JO -,+?A 4H# -"*&'G,)*-'" '/ SKTUV"#$ *&-%D F* *H# ;F&-'" <2#M G&-2#$F. )'"D*-*,*#D F" -")&#FD# -" *&F//-)

2'1,E# 0. '2#& STWXM 9G& #'IRRE" D#BKO RIEJ&K #$ "$BF# &fED#EFC KIEJO #'ESD $F7I'E$F S'&"ED&JO %&"IBD& E# H$BJK '&M&IJ I F&ECG%$'G$$K EF#'BDE$F $R &SE"

S'$S$'#E$FD* DB"G #GI# EQSI"#D #$ #G& &FME'$FQ&F#* SB%JE" DIR&#O IFK aBIJE#O $R JER&

H$BJK %& "I#ID#'$SGE" IFK BFQE#ECI%J&A

4H&#DH'1G '/ D-R"-/-)F")# #I)##G#G '" 1')F1 &#D-G#"*-F1 D*&##*

3B'#G&'Q$'&* #G& ISSJE"IF#[D #'IRRE" D#BKO RIEJ&K #$ I""$BF# R$' EF#'BDE$FD $F#$ #G&

J$"IJ '&DEK&F#EIJ D#'&&# 2A 2KC&HI'& VKA I# 7I'E$F @M&A @""$'KEFC #$ SIC& -X $R #G&

@BCBD# +,-. 4@:!9 S$JE"E&D IFK S'$"&KB'&D GIFK%$$c* #G& #G'&DG$JK R$' DECFERE"IF#&FME'$FQ&F#IJ EQSI"#D $F I J$"IJ '&DEK&F#EIJ D#'&&# ED -+, #'ESDA dE#G -*)=, F&H

#'ESD SJIFF&K #$ #'IM&J $F 7I'E$F @M&A* $FJO -+, $R #G&Q H$BJK GIM& #$ #B'F $F 2A2KC&HI'& VKA #$ '&I"G #G& #G'&DG$JKA P'$`&"# '&DEK&F#D HEJJ "$Q& IFK C$ R'$Q #G&

-,- /$B#G MEI #GED J$"IJ D#'&&#A 1&'#IEFJO* QIFO Q$'& #GIF -+, $R #G& -*)=, HEJJ

#'IM&J $F #G& -,- /$B#G MEI 2A 2KC&HI'&* 9&QSJ& IFK 0FE$FA 9GED ED #G& RID#&D# IFK

Q$D#Y$R#&F #'IM&JJ&K '$B#&* O&# #G& 9'IRRE" /#BKE&D* #G& 7U:* IFK E#D @KK&FKBQ RIEJ

#$ IKK'&DD P'$`&"# #'IRRE" I""&DDEFC #GED QI`$' gECGHIOA

>'EE,"-*. 31F" 3'1-). SYJYMS :'GR#& 4&F//-) 01')LD %&'(#)*

@# F$ S$EF# EF #G& &FME'$FQ&F#IJ K$"BQ&F#D $' #G& 9'IRRE" /#BKE&D ED :$KC&' #'IRRE"

Q&F#E$F&KA 9G$BDIFKD $R "I'D aB&B& IJ$FC /BFD&# 6JMKA I# J&ID# =- KIOD S&' O&I'*

DE##EFC I# I D#IFKYD#EJJ KE'&"#JO EF R'$F# $R #G& =+LYR$$# J$FC P'$`&"#A 9GED #'IRRE" JID#DR$' ISS'$fEQI#&JO #H$ G$B'D %&R$'& &I"G CIQ&* IFK R$' I%$B# .? QEFB#&D IR#&' &I"G

CIQ&A

:$KC&' #'IRRE" ED F$# IF IF$QIJOp E# ED CBI'IF#&&K #$ GISS&FA 9$ K&JE%&'I#&JO IFK

Q&#G$KE"IJJO $QE# #G& ^?,, J%A n$'EJJI_ #GI# ED :$KC&' 9'IRRE" R'$Q IJJ P'$`&"# '&S$'#DED 'I#G&' aB&D#E$FI%J&A 9G& 7U: K&JE%&'I#&JO &MIK&D 12e@ QIFKI#&D R$' ̂ RBJJ

KED"J$DB'&_ $R &FME'$FQ&F#IJ RI"#$'DA 3B'#G&' E# %JI#IF#JO ECF$'&D 1$QQBFE#O PJIF

P$JE"O -+Y+A- #GI# K&QIFKD ^DS&"EIJ #'IRRE" $S&'I#E$FD S'$"&KB'&D_ IFK ^#B'F JIF&

$S&'I#E$FD '&D#'E"#E$FD #$ QIFIC& #'IRRE" EF #G& ME"EFE#O $R :$KC&' D#IKEBQ #$ GIFKJ&

CIQ& KIO #'IRRE" M$JBQ&DA_

8F IKK'&DDEFC #G& I%$M& P'$C'IQ -+Y+A- #G& ISSJE"IF# RJESSIF#JO '&DS$FKD #GI# #G&

K&M&J$S&' GID IC'&&K #$ '&YD#'ES& #G& EF#&'D&"#E$F I# /BFD&#;6&IBK'O* %B# RIEJD #$

IKQE# #GI# #G& S'$`&"#[D #G'&& K'EM&HIOD I'& J$"I#&K $F #G& K&KE"I#&K :$KC&' /GB##J&

6BD JIF&* IFK #GI# #G&O QBD# S'$MEK& QE#ECI#E$F EF I""$'KIF"& HE#G #G& P'$C'IQA ="

/F)*K 0,-1G-"R &#D-G#"*D $-11 HF2# *' Z-11#RF11.[ )&'DD *H# AP9J8+@\ 1F"# G,&-"RUS RFE# GF.D *' F))#DD *H#-& H'E#DM



9G& EDDB& $R :$KC&' #'IRRE" IFK I SJIF R$' IKK'&DDEFC '&DEK&F# I""&DD #$ IFK R'$Q

K'EM&HIOD IFK #B'F JIF&D QBD# %& IKK'&DD&K EF IF 28VA :$KC&' #'IRRE" IJ'&IKO

'&FK&'D /BFD&# 6JMKA I 4!/ 3 R$' G$B'D $F CIQ& KIODA 9G& IKKE#E$F $R )), '&DEK&F#D

IFK GBFK'&KD $R '&#IEJ SI#'$FD I##&QS#EFC #$ I""&DD #G& P'$`&"# "IFF$# %& ECF$'&KA

456 9=46 =9 +84 35\9=><@@\ 9P=4<A@6 O87 456 3783896: 4\36 8O:6N6@83;6+4

dEJD$F n&$D"E&F"&D S'&SI'&K I '&S$'# \2mg8689 ?] #GI# "$F"&'FD I%B##EFC

F&ECG%$'D $F IJJ DEK&D $R #G& P'$`&"#A 9G& '&S$'# R$BFK S'$%J&QI#E" DJ$S& D#I%EJE#O&fED#D I# #G& DE#& IFK "$F"JBK&K #GI# IKKE#E$FIJ K&DECF Q&IDB'&D H&'& '&"$QQ&FK&K

#$ &FDB'& #GI# #G& P'$`&"# ED R&IDE%J& I# #G& DE#&A n&$9&"GF$J$CE&D "JIEQD #$ GIM&IKK'&DD&K #G&D& K&DECF Q&IDB'&D* %B# F$#GEFC DB%D#IF#EM& ED D&&F EF E#D '&S$'# #$

CBI'IF#&& #GI# #G& P'$`&"# HEJJ F$# BSD&# R'I"#B'&D QISS&K EF +,,) IFK +,-LA

^9G& K&M&J$SQ&F# SJIF EF"JBK&D D#&&S \D#&&S&' #GIF +>-] QIFBRI"#B'&K "B# DJ$S&DA

/J$S&D D#&&S&' #GIF +>- I'& DBD"&S#E%J& #$ J$FC #&'Q DB'RE"EIJ EFD#I%EJE#O KB& #$H&I#G&'EFC IFK &'$DE$F* IFK '&aBE'& Q$'& D#'EFC&F# QIEF#&FIF"&A_ \dEJD$F

n&$D"E&F"&D J&##&' #$ F&ECG%$' g$$M&' 9IFC* KI#&K @BCBD# .* +,-.]*

dG&F HEJJ #G& SB%JE"* IFK Q$'& DS&"ERE"IJJO @'IC$F[D S$#&F#EIJ F&ECG%$'D* J&I'F

I%$B# #G& QE#ECI#E$F IFK QIEF#&FIF"& SJIF @'IC$F HEJJ K&M&J$S #$ S'$#&"# IKÌ"&F#

S'$S&'#E&D R'$Q S$#&F#EIJ JIFKDJEK&Dh 12e@ K&QIFKD #GI# H& GIM& #G& 'ECG# #$

cF$H 623!V2 #G& S'$`&"# ED ISS'$M&K* F$# IR#&' #G& RI"#A

9G& 7U: K&FE&D #G& S$#&F#EIJ R$' JIFKDJEK&D &fED# I# #G& DE#&A @ S'$R&DDE$FIJ

n&$J$CED# GE'&K %O I "$F"&'F&K F&ECG%$' KEDIC'&&D HE#G #G& "$F"JBDE$FD EF #G& 7U:

IFK DBCC&D#D #GI# #G&'& ED I '&IJ "$F"&'F DEF"& n&$#&"GF$J$CE&D $FJO ^S&'R$'Q&KDB'RE"EIJ DJ$S& D#I%EJE#O $R "B# DJ$S&D I# +X K&C'&&D C'IKE&F#A_ \2mg8689 ?] 9G&

S'$`&"# HEJJ I"#BIJJO %& QIcEFC QB"G D#&&S&' "B#D \.? K&C'&&D] EF #G& %&K'$"c #GIF

#G& +X K&C'&&D #&D#&KA dGO EDF[# #G& "$FDBJ#IF# %&EFC IDc&K #$ S&'R$'Q DB'RE"EIJDJ$S& D#I%EJE#O #&D#EFC $R .? K&C'&& "B#D* HG&F #G$D& I'& #G& Q$D# "'E#E"IJ "B#D #$ #G&

%&K'$"ch 9GED ED I C'IM& "$F"&'F R$' I%B##EFC F&ECG%$'DA 8# ED #G& 1E#O[D KB#O BFK&'12e@ #$ RBJJOY&fSJ$'& #G& S$#&F#EIJ KIFC&'D IFK &FME'$FQ&F#IJ EQSI"#D #GI# GIM&

%&&F %'$BCG# #$ E#D I##&F#E$FA

dEJD$F n&$D"E&F"&D RB'#G&' "JI'ERE&D #G& S$#&F#EIJ KIFC&'] Z?H#" D1'%# F"R1#D

D*##%#& *HF" Y^ G#R&##D F&# )'"D-G#&#GK 1'$#& /F)*'&D '/ DF/#*. F&# '0*F-"#GM[

9G& 4$D @FC&J&D :&SI'#Q&F# $R 6BEJKEFC IFK /IR&#O D&&QD #$ IC'&& HE#G #G& dEJD$F

n&$D"E&F"&D '&S$'#A P'$`&"# "$FKE#E$FD $F SIC& +) $R #G& 9'I"# 7IS K&"EDE$F J&##&'

D#I#& #GI# ^#G& S'$S$D&K "B# DGIJJ %& EF"JEF&K ID D#&&S ID L? K&C'&&DA /EF"& #G& DJ$S&

&f"&&KD IFK EF"JEFI#E$F $R +) K&C'&&D* I Q$KERE"I#E$F #$ #G& 1E#O $R 4$D @FC&J&D

6BEJKEFC 1$K& DGIJJ %& F&"&DDI'OA_

8R "B#D D#&&S&' #GIF +X K&C'&&D I'& Q$'& KIFC&'$BD IFK &fS$D& #G& P'$`&"# IFK E#D



F&ECG%$'D #$ ^J$H&' RI"#$'D $R DIR&#O*_ HGO ED #G& 1E#O ISS'$MEFC #GED "B#h 9G& SJIFD

"IJJ R$' I .? K&C'&& "B#* O&# #G& 1E#O $FJO KED"BDD&D #G& L? K&C'&& "B# EF E#D

:&#&'QEFI#E$F 4&##&' IFK '&"$QQ&FKD Q$KEROEFC #G& 6BEJKEFC 1$K& #$

I""$QQ$KI#& #G& :&M&J$S&'* 'I#G&' #GIF S'$#&"#EFC F&ECG%$'DA 9G& 6BEJKEFC 1$K&

ED EF SJI"& HE#G C$$K '&ID$FA 9$ K&QIFK #GI# E# %& "GIFC&K #$ I""$QQ$KI#& #GED

P'$`&"# ED E''&DS$FDE%J&A

6=7 "#)#DDF&. *' #2F1,F*# D1'%# D*F0-1-*. F"G DF/#*. '/ %&'%'D#G ),*D

9H$ S'$R&DDE$FIJ n&$J$CED#D GIM& K&Q$FD#'I#&K KERR&'EFC $SEFE$FD $F #GED QI##&'A0FK&' 12e@* IFK I""$'KEFC #$ #G& '&"&F# 'BJEFC C#&E#1#2 @.11-.3# %&#-#&5,*.'0 5? M.*2

'4 C#&E#1#2A @-L-+?. \3E'D# @SS&JJI#& :ED#'E"#* 3&%'BI'O -?* +,-+] IF 2FME'$FQ&F#IJ8QSI"# V&S$'# ED F&"&DDI'OA 9G& "$B'# R$BFK #GI# #G& &fED#&F"& $R KERR&'EFC &fS&'#

$SEFE$FD HID IJ$F& DBRRE"E&F# #$ Q&&# #G& RIE' I'CBQ&F# &f"&S#E$F IFK #'ECC&' IF

28VA

456 9=46 =9 +84 35\9=><@@\ 9P=4<A@6 O87 456 3783896: :6+9=4\ 8O 456:6N6@83;6+4

O<7 A'",D /'& ;-I#GJPD# "'* D,%%'&*#G 0. *H# >'EE,"-*. 31F"

3ECB'& ? $R #G& /EJM&' 4Ic&;2"G$ PI'c;2JODEIF WIJJ&O "$QQBFE#O SJIF \1P] DG$HD I

QIS $R #G& ^J$"I#E$FD $R KED"'&#E$FI'O 7Ef&KY0D& RJ$$' I'&I %$FBD_ I##I"G&K ID

2mg8689 )A 9GED QIS '&RJ&"#D #G& I'&ID HG&'& 7Ef&KY0D& %BEJKEFCD I'& &F"$B'IC&KIFK IJJ$H&K #G& IKKE#E$FIJ 3@VA 9G& QIS "J&I'JO DG$HD* IFK #G& #&f# $R 1P $%`&"#EM&

+Y.AL D#I#&D* #GI# /BFD&# 6JMK ED JEQE#&K #$ -A?>- 3@V &f"&S# $F #G& SI'"&JD EK&F#ERE&KEF 3ECB'& -A P&' #G& QIS* #G& P'$`&"# DE#& ED U!9 8U140:2: ID IF I'&I K&DECFI#&K

R$' KED"'&#E$FI'O 7Ef&KY0D& %$FBD&DA @SS'$MIJ $R EF"'&ID&K 3@V ED F$# DBSS$'#&K%O #G& 1$QQBFE#O PJIF* HGE"G ED #G& CBEKEFC K$"BQ&F# R$' KED"'&#E$FI'O I"#E$FDA

3&'(#)* -D -")'"D-D*#"* $-*H C'F1DK 3'1-)-#D _ 80(#)*-2#D '/ *H# >'EE,"-*. 31F"

9G& 7U: IFK E#D @KK&FKBQ "JIEQ #GI# #G& P'$`&"# ED "$FDED#&F# HE#G 1$QQBFE#O

PJIF !%`&"#EM& -A-* ^#$ I"GE&M& IFK QIEF#IEF I G$BDEFC DBSSJO DBRRE"E&F# #$ Q&&# #G&

KEM&'D& &"$F$QE" IFK D$"E$&"$F$QE" F&&KD $R #G& "B''&F# IFK S'$`&"#&K S$SBJI#E$F

#$ #G& O&I' +,-,*_ %&"IBD& E# S'$MEK&D F&H G$BDEFC IFK I JEQE#&K FBQ%&' $R

IRR$'KI%J& BFE#DA g$H&M&'* #G& BFK&'JOEFC S$JE"E&D %&GEFK !%`&"#EM& -A- "$FRJE"# HE#G

#G& P'$`&"#[D FI#B'& IFK "GI'I"#&' HE#G #G& R$JJ$HEFC>

-Y-A- 7IEF#IEF IF IK&aBI#& DBSSJO IFK KED#'E%B#E$F $R QBJ#ESJ& RIQEJO* J$H

EF"$Q& IFK DS&"EIJ F&&KD G$BDEFC $SS$'#BFE#E&D EF #G& 1$QQBFE#O

PJIF @'&IA-Y-AL P'$#&"# &fED#EFC DEFCJ& RIQEJO '&DEK&F#EIJ F&ECG%$'G$$KD R'$Q F&H

$B#Y$RYD"IJ& K&M&J$SQ&F#A

-Y-A. 2F"$B'IC& F&H EFREJJ '&DEK&F#EIJ K&M&J$SQ&F# #GI# "$QSJ&Q&F#D

&fED#EFC K&M&J$SQ&F# IFK I'"GE#&"#B'IJ D#OJ&A



-Y-A? P'$#&"# &fED#EFC D#I%J& DEFCJ& RIQEJO IFK J$HYK&FDE#O QBJ#ESJ& RIQEJO

'&DEK&F#EIJ F&ECG%$'G$$KD R'$Q &F"'$I"GQ&F# %O GECG&' K&FDE#O

'&DEK&F#EIJ IFK $#G&' EF"$QSI#E%J& BD&DA

-Y-A) P'$Q$#& #G& S'&D&'MI#E$F $R &fED#EFC DEFCJ& IFK QBJ#ESJ& RIQEJO

F&ECG%$'G$$KDA

9G& P'$`&"# ED K&D"'E%&K ID #H$ ?YD#$'O %BEJKEFCD HE#G I QIfEQBQ G&ECG# X+YR&&#

I%$M& C'IK&* J$"I#&K $F I D&'E&D $R -X J$#D R'$F#EFC /BFD&# 6JMKA #$#IJEFC

ISS'$fEQI#&JO =+L R&&# HE#G I #$#IJ -NX*=?= DRA 9G& GED#$'E" K&#I"G&K DEFCJ& RIQEJO

%BFCIJ$HD KE'&"#JO #$ #G& F$'#G $R #G& P'$`&"# I'& ISS'$fEQI#&JO ??, DRA HE#G IG&ECG# $R -L R#A 9G& QBJ#EYRIQEJO %BEJKEFCD #$ #G& &ID# %&GEFK #G& P'$`&"# IM&'IC& L=

R#A #IJJ IFK ISS'$fEQI#&JO )*.,, DRA

4H# 3&'(#)* -D #"'&E',D1. ',*J'/JD)F1# $-*H "#-RH0'&-"R %&'%#&*-#DM =* -D TJ

4=;69 *F11#& F"G ̀ TYJ4=;69 0-RR#& *HF" *H# H'E#D *' *H# "'&*Ha F"G YJ4=;69*F11#& F"G `SJ4=;69 0-RR#& *HF" *H# F2#&FR# &#D-G#")#D *' *H# #FD*M 9GED ED F$#

I GECG K&C'&& $R "$QSI#E%EJE#O IFK K$&D F$# S'$#&"# #G& "GI'I"#&' IFK D"IJ& $RF&I'%O F&ECG%$'G$$KD* EF"JBKEFC #G& GED#$'E" gP!j HGE"G %&CEFD I# /BFD&# 6JMKA*

KE'&"#JO I"'$DD #G& D#'&&# R'$Q #G& P'$`&"#A @ P'$`&"# $R #G& G&ECG#* DET&* IFK D"IJ&

D$BCG# %O #G& ISSJE"IF# K$&D F$# S'$Q$#& S'&D&'MI#E$F $R F&ECG%$'G$$K "GI'I"#&'

$' #G& !M&'JIO j$F&A

@ P'$`&"# #GI# #$H&'D $M&' F&ECG%$'EFC D#'B"#B'&D* K&S'EMEFC #G&Q $R JECG#* IE' IFK

S'EMI"O %O "'&I#EFC F&H "$FK$ BFE#D #GI# S&&S EF#$ %I"cOI'KD* IFK $%D"B'& HEFK$HD

#GI# R$'Q&'JO R'IQ&K B'%IF DBFD&#D* BFK&'QEF&D #G& aBIJE#O $R JER& R$' IJJ HG$ JEM&

F&I'%OA @ P'$`&"# #GI# "'&I#&D DECFERE"IF# BFQE#ECI%J& #'IRRE" EQSI"#D #$ I S'EQI'O

EFC'&DD;&C'&DD R$' IF &F#E'& "$QQBFE#O* K$&D F$# S'$#&"# #GI# F&ECG%$'G$$KA

VI#G&'* E# S'$Q$#&D K&C'IKI#E$F $R #GI# F&ECG%$'G$$KA

4H# 3&'(#)* /,#1D C#"*&-/-)F*-'" 0. %&'2-G-"R 2#&. /#$ 1'$J-")'E# ,"-*D

dGEJ& #G& S'$`&"# QIO IKK '&DEK&F#EIJ BFE#D* #G$D& BFE#D I'& F$# &M&FJO I""&DDE%J&

IQ$FC #G& &fED#EFC H$'cEFCY"JIDD S$SBJI#E$F EF #G& I'&I* IFK #G$D& Q$D# $R#&FKEDSJI"&K %O F&H K&M&J$SQ&F#A 9G& J$#D #GI# "$QS'ED& #G& P'$`&"# R$'Q&'JO G$BD&K

R$B' S&'QE##&K* '&F#Y"$F#'$JJ&K BFE#D* IFK #H$ BFS&'QE##&K IKKY$F KH&JJEFCDA 9G&

F&H S'$`&"# HEJJ $FJO '&FK&' N F&H IRR$'KI%J& BFE#D* HGE"G GI'KJO IKK'&DD&D #G&

EQQ&KEI#&* &Q&'C&F"O D$"E$&"$F$QE" F&&K R$' Q$'& J$HYEF"$Q& G$BDEFCA

1$F#'I'O #$ D#I#&Q&F#D EF #G& 7U: IFK E#D @KK&FKBQ* #G& P'$`&"# RIEJD #$ Q&&# #G&Q$D# RBFKIQ&F#IJ !%`&"#EM& $R #G& 1$QQBFE#O PJIFA 8# ED $B#Y$RYD"IJ& HE#G IKÌ"&F#

G$Q&D IFK $B#Y$RY"GI'I"#&' HE#G #G& DB''$BFKEFC GED#$'E" F&ECG%$'G$$KA 8# "IBD&D

K&#'EQ&F#IJ #'IRRE" IFK SI'cEFC EQSI"#D #GI# "IFF$# %& QE#ECI#&KA 8# RIEJD EF

S'$MEKEFC #G& G$BDEFC #GI# #G& 1$QQBFE#O PJIF O&I'FD R$'A 8FD#&IK* E# "I#&'D #$

BSHI'KJO Q$%EJ& C&F#'EROEFC &JE#&* HGEJ& '&JB"#IF#JO S'$MEKEFC I F&# EF"'&ID& $R $FJON IRR$'KI%J& KH&JJEFCDA



456 :69=C+ 8O 456 9PA:=N=9=8+ =9 @=b6@\ 48 >76<46 9PA94<+4=<@

6+N=78+;6+4<@ =;3<>49 <+: <OO6>4 3PA@=> 56<@45

9G& n&$#&"GF$J$CE&D '&S$'# IFK #G& @28 SGID& 88 '&S$'# %$#G "IJJ R$' IKKE#E$FIJ

#&D#EFC #$ M&'ERO "&'#IEF S$#&F#EIJJO #$fE" "$FKE#E$FD S'E$' #$ #G& D#I'# $R

"$FD#'B"#E$FA 9G& @KMED$'O @C&F"O K&#&'QEFI#E$F J&##&' EK&F#ERE&D I D&'E&D $RS$#&F#EIJ GITI'KD %&JE&M&K #$ &fED# $F #G& S'$S&'#O KB& #$ E#D IC& IFK '&"$'K $R

R$'Q&' BD&DA 9G& KED#B'%EFC RI"# #GI# QBD# %& IKK'&DD&K ED> HGO #G& K&M&J$S&' ED

IJJ$H&K #$ HIE# BF#EJ #G& SB%JE" "$QQ&F# S&'E$K ED $M&' #$ #&D# R$' #G& S'&D&F"& IFK

J&M&JD $R #$fE" DB%D#IF"&Dh

12e@ '&aBE'&D I ^C$$K RIE#G &RR$'# I# RBJJ KED"J$DB'&A_ dE#GG$JKEFC "'E#E"IJ*S$#&F#EIJJO JER&Y#G'&I#&FEFC EFR$'QI#E$F R'$Q #G& SB%JE" I%$B# S$DDE%J& EQSI"#D $F

G&IJ#G ED EJJ&CIJA 9G& 7U: IFK #G& :&#&'QEFI#E$F 4&##&' JE%&'IJJO KED"BDD #G&

S'$%I%EJE#O $R #$fE" DB%D#IF"&D cF$HF #$ "IBD& "IF"&'* %'IEF KIQIC& IFK JBFCKED&ID& DB"G ID ID%&D#$D* J&IK* Q&'"B'O IFK Q&#GIF&A 9G& K$"BQ&F#D K&Q$FD#'I#&

I GECG S'$%I%EJE#O R$' #G&D& DB%D#IF"&D* IFK #G& 1E#O GID IDc&K R$' "$FDBJ#I#E$FD IFKIDD&DDQ&F#D R'$Q S'$R&DDE$FIJ I%I#&Q&F# "$F#'I"#$'D J#4'&# *"# -*,&* '4

)'0-*&9)*.'0* HGE"G ED &F#E'&JO $B#DEK& $R SB%JE" ME&HA P'$R&DDE$FIJD QBD# %&

"$FDBJ#&K EQQ&KEI#&JO IFK #G&E' REFKEFCD IFK '&"$QQ&FKI#E$FD QIK& cF$HF #$

J$"IJ '&DEK&F#D HE#GEF ?,, R&&#A

OF-1,&# *' -G#"*-/. 1')F1 D)H''1D F"G D#"D-*-2# &#)#%*'&D

9G& &FME'$FQ&F#IJ K$"BQ&F# IDcD #G& ISSJE"IF# ER #G&O HEJJ &QE# GITI'K$BD

&QEDDE$FD HE#GEF $F&YaBI'#&' QEJ& $R I D"G$$J* \SIC& -=)]A 9G& ISSJE"IF# '&DS$FKD

#GI# #G& P'$`&"# ED F$# EF "J$D& S'$fEQE#O #$ IFO 79J1.) D"G$$JDA g$H&M&'* $F& %J$"c

#$ #G& D$B#G #G&'& ED I S'EMI#& D"G$$J Û&H 1$M&FIF# @"IK&QO*_ %B# #G& ISSJE"IF#KEDQEDD&D #G& DECFERE"IF"& $R #G& D"G$$J %&"IBD& -] E#[D I S'EMI#& D"G$$J* IFK +] E#D

IKÌ"&F# #$ IF @B#$ V&SIE' DG$S "IJJ&K /&FC[D>

9G& IDDBQS#E$FD QIK& %O #G& ISSJE"IF# I'& F$#GEFC DG$'# $R ID#$FEDGEFCA 12e@ ED

"$F"&'F&K I%$B# EQSI"#D #$ D&FDE#EM& '&"&S#$'D* F$# HG&#G&' #G&O I##&FK SB%JE" $'

S'EMI#& D"G$$JD F&f# #$ IF IB#$ '&SIE'A 9G& I%DB'K IFK K&JE%&'I#&JO &MIDEM&



'&DS$FD& %O #G& ISSJE"IF# DG$BJK %& I '&KYRJIC #$ 1E#O /#IRRA 1&'#IEFJO #G& S'$`&"# HEJJ

&QE# GITI'KD HE#GEF r QEJ& $R #GED D"G$$JA 8# ED I /8nU8381@U9 EQSI"#A

?HF* F0',* *H# 1'$J-")'E# 5#FGD*F&* 3&#J9)H''1 S 01')L F$F.c

9G& ISSJE"IF# RIEJ&K #$ J$"I#& IFK EK&F#ERO I /#I#& g&IKD#I'# S'&YD"G$$J R$' J$HYEF"$Q& "GEJK'&F J$"I#&K I# X,X 2A s&FDEFC#$F VKA HG&'& E# "'$DD&D 7I'E$F @M&A

^4E##J& 3'E&FKD_ S'&YD"G$$J D&'M&D "GEJK'&F + k ? O&I'D $JK #GI# JEM& HE#GEF #G&

EQQ&KEI#& F&ECG%$'G$$KA 9G& S'$`&"# HEJJ &QE# RBCE#EM& KBD# IFK #$fE" SI'#E"J&D

HE#GEF r QEJ& $R I P'&Y/"G$$JA 9GED '&S'&D&F#D I /8nU8381@U9 EQSI"#A

/EQEJI'JO* #G&'& I'& X "GEJK'&F IFK L #$KKJ&'D JEMEFC EQQ&KEI#&JO #$ #G& F$'#G* J&DD#GIF ?, R&&# IHIO* HG$ HEJJ %& &fS$D&K #$ GECG "$F"&F#'I#E$FD $R RBCE#EM& KBD#

"$F#IEFEFC BF#$JK aBIF#E#E&D $R #$fE" SI'#E"J&DA 9G&'& I'& F$ QE#ECI#E$F Q&IDB'&D

#GI# "IF S$DDE%JO RBJJOYS'$#&"# '&DEK&F#D JEMEFC EF DB"G "J$D& S'$fEQE#O #$ #G& P'$`&"#*%B# #GI# DG$BJKF[# %& #G& ISSJE"IF#[D 'I#E$FIJ& R$' "$QSJ&#&JO RIEJEFC #$ IKK'&DD #G&

G&IJ#G "$F"&'FD $R '&DEK&F#D JEMEFC F&f# K$$'A

4H# FG(F)#"* &#D-G#"*D &#Q,#D* *HF* E'"-*'&-"R G#2-)#D 0# -"D*F11#G /'& *H#

G,&F*-'" '/ *H# )'"D*&,)*-'" %#&-'G *' )'"*-",',D1. E#FD,&# /,R-*-2# G,D*#1#E#"*D F"G *'I-) #E-DD-'"D 1#2#1DM

9G& ISSJE"IF# GID F$# IK&aBI#&JO IKK'&DD&K F$ED& IFK &QEDDE$FD J&M&JD C&F&'I#&K

%O #'B"c EKJEFC* #'B"c D#ICEFC* K&Q$JE#E$F IFK GIBJEFCA 9G&'& ED EFIK&aBI#&

KED"BDDE$F $R #G& BD& $R %E$ RB&JD IFK J$H &QEDDE$F G&IMO &aBESQ&F# DB"G ID

&f"IMI#$'D IFK %BJJ K$T&'DA 6&"IBD& #G& 1E#O GID F$# '&aBE'&K #G& ISSJE"IF# #$

"$FKB"# #&D#EFC R$' #G& GITI'KD EF IKMIF"& $R #G& G&I'EFC S'$"&DD* #G& ISSJE"IF# GID

F$# IC'&&K #$ "$F#'I"# "&'#ERE&K #$fE" I%I#&Q&F# DS&"EIJED#D IFK ED "B''&F#JO $FJO'&aBE'&K #$ "$FDBJ# HE#G #G&QA 9GED ED BFI""&S#I%J& IFK I ME$JI#E$F $R 12e@

S'$"&DD&DA

>8+>@P9=8+

9G&'& I'& QO'EIK S'$%J&QD HE#G #G& ISS'$MIJ $R #G& 9'I"# 7IS IFK #G& @KK&FKBQ

#$ #G& 7U:A

Y 9G& P'$`&"# GID BFK&'C$F& DECFERE"IF# "GIFC&D DEF"& #G& 8/;7U: IFK

F&&KD #$ %& '&"E'"BJI#&K

Y 9G& P'$`&"# K$&D F$# "$FR$'Q #$ EQS$'#IF# &J&Q&F#D HE#GEF #G&

1$QQBFE#O PJIFAY 9G& ISSJE"IF# QIFESBJI#&D #G& :&FDE#O 6$FBD S'$C'IQ #$ REFIF"& E#D '&#IEJ

$S&'I#E$FDA

Y 8# '&JE&D $F /2j SI'cEFC '&KB"#E$FD #GI# GIM& %&&F '&S&IJ&KA

Y 9G& S'$`&"# GID EFI""B'I#&JO I""$BF#&K R$' 9'ESD IFK 9'IRRE" EQSI"#D EF IJJ

IFIJOD&D* EF"JBKEFC #G& @KK&FKBQAY 9G& P'$`&"# #'IQSJ&D $F #G& J$"IJ F&ECG%$'G$$K HE#G E#D &f"&DDEM& G&ECG#

IFK QIDDEFCp E#D EFIK&aBI#& SI'cEFCp E#D EF"&DDIF# #'IRRE"p IFK E#D #$fE"



&QEDDE$FD EF "J$D& S'$fEQE#O #$ %I%E&D* #$KKJ&'D IFK D"G$$J "GEJK'&FA

9G& P'$`&"#[D 7U: IFK @KK&FKBQ K$&D F$# '&S'&D&F# I ^C$$K RIE#G &RR$'# I# RBJJ

KED"J$DB'&*_ EF ME$JI#E$F $R 12e@A 9G& &FME'$FQ&F#IJ K$"BQ&F#D $QE# c&O IFIJOD&D

#GI# DG$BJK GIM& %&&F S&'R$'Q&K* IFK E# ED D#EJ#&K #$ IM$EK REFKEFCD $R $%ME$BD

DECFERE"IF# &FME'$FQ&F#IJ EQSI"#DA

9G& PJIFFEFC 1$QQEDDE$F DG$BJK '&"$QQ&FK #GI# #G& S'$`&"# F$# C$ R$'HI'K BF#EJ

IJJ #G& &FME'$FQ&F#IJ "$F"&'FD GIM& %&&F RBJJO IFK S'$S&'JO IKK'&DD&K EF IF 28V*

IFK EF I""$'KIF"& HE#G #G& JIHA

8 '&D&'M& #G& 'ECG# #$ DB%QE# IKKE#E$FIJ "$QQ&F#D IFK $%`&"#E$FD '&CI'KEFC #G&:&FDE#O 6$FBD* #G& @KMED$'O @C&F"O[D ISS'$MIJ $R #G& W&D#EFC 9&F#I#EM& 9'I"# 7IS*

#G& 7U:* IFK E#D @KK&FKBQ IFK #G&E' '&DS&"#EM& 2FME'$FQ&F#IJ 3EFKEFCD #G'$BCG

#G& "J$D& $R #G& IKQEFED#'I#EM& S'$"&&KEFCD '&JI#&K #$ #G& P'$`&"#A

V&DS&"#RBJJO DB%QE##&K %O>

tttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttttt

7'A @BCBD#EF& 2E"GHIJK

-+?L /BFD&# 6JMKA

4$D @FC&J&D* 1@ N,,+)























Date post:	02-Jun-2018
Category:	Documents
Upload:	weareechopark
View:	217 times
Download:	0 times

Aragon Appeal and Exhibits

Documents