of 83
The Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP)
J. Nirdosh Reddy Asha Reddy Anaar Company Bloomfield Hills, MI USA
Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Creating Our Future Introduction Business scenario Business performance to date Constraint analysis on each goal Strategy trees - one for each goal Subapproaches matrices - one for each process on the global process chart Finalization of goals for next fiscal year
Anaar, 2006
2
Expected Outcome
A comprehensive, clearly defined one year goals with: time-bound action plan of projects sponsors and team leaders measurements
Anaar, 2006
3
Creating Our Future If we dont take the time to create our future, who will create our future?
Anaar, 2006
4
Creating Our Future If we dont take the time to create our future, who will create our future? Competition
Anaar, 2006
5
Creating Our Future If we dont take the time to create our future, who will create our future? Competition What will that future be like?
Anaar, 2006
6
Creating Our Future If we dont take the time to create our future, who will create our future? Competition What will that future be like? Chaotic Reacting to winds of change Fire-fighting
Anaar, 2006
7
Creating Our Future If we do this year what we did last year, we will get less this year than what we got last year
Anaar, 2006
8
Creating Our Future If we do this year what we did last year, we will get less this year than what we got last year We must improve our systems and processes The fundamental question is: what do we need to differently?
Anaar, 2006
9
Creating Our Future If we do this year what we did last year, we will get less this year than what we got last year We must improve our systems and processes The fundamental question is: what do we need to differently? Senior management needs to spend about 50% of their time in creating the future of the organization - identifying, sponsoring and ensuring completion of improvement projects
Anaar, 2006
10
Ground rules Think about the business as a whole (not in compartments, not in departments)
Anaar, 2006
11
Ground rules Think about the business as a whole (not in compartments, not in departments) One meeting at a time No side conversations Cell phones in OFF mode
Anaar, 2006
12
Ground rules Think about the business as a whole (not in compartments, not in departments) One meeting at a time No side conversations Cell phones in OFF mode Focus on solutions, not on excuses
Anaar, 2006
13
Ground rules Think about the business as a whole (not in compartments, not in departments) One meeting at a time No side conversations Cell phones in OFF mode Focus on solutions, not on excuses Let go of excess baggage Dont let the past come in the way of creating a better future
Anaar, 2006
14
Ground rules Think about the business as a whole (not in compartments, not in departments) One meeting at a time No side conversations Cell phones in OFF mode Focus on solutions, not on excuses Let go of excess baggage Dont let the past come in the way of creating a better future Leave negative thoughts outside the conference room Anaar, 2006
15
Ground rules Think about the business as a whole (not in compartments, not in departments) One meeting at a time No side conversations Cell phones in OFF mode Focus on solutions, not on excuses Let go of excess baggage Dont let the past come in the way of creating a better future Leave negative thoughts outside the conference room Build on other peoples ideas Anaar, 2006
16
RecapLets start with a recap of overview of TQM / Anaar Roadmap
Anaar, 2006
17
Total Quality Management1950s Japanese implement Total Quality Control (TQC) based on teachings of Dr. W. Edwards Deming Establish Deming Prize 1980 NBC White Paper If Japan Can, Why Cant We? Ford re-discovers Demings teachings as Total Quality Excellence (TQE) Present Widely implemented (in many western businesses) as Total Quality Management (TQM)
Shift from just working harder to working smarter Anaar, 2006
18
Why TQM ? Whats the need? Profitability - is it acceptable? Is it at intrinsic capability? Customer satisfaction - is it what it should be? Quality - is it at world class levels? Employee motivation Is it consistently high? Is there pride in work for all employees? Is it an exciting place to work, not merely a place to earn a salary?
After hard work, are the results satisfactory? Is cooperation between departments high all the time? (Or only when there is a crisis?)
Anaar, 2006
19
Goals of a TQM Program Enhance customer focus Bring in long term perspective Encourage people to take pride in work Enable team work Foster a harmonious environment Achieve global competitiveness
TQM is a means of unleashing the potential of people Anaar, 2006
20
The Anaar Roadmap Module 1: New Mindsets and New Practices Dr. Demings 14 points for management, Maslows hierarchy of human needs, Anaar model of an enterprise, transformation process
Module 2: Anaar Process Review System (APRS) From only managing people to managing people and processes Bringing in ownership of processes and pride in improvement
Module 3: Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Breaking down barriers between departments Aligning the thinking of various departments
Module 4: Continuous Improvement Process Involving everyone to improve their processes
Anaar, 2006
21
Module on Anaar Process Review System (APRS) APRS helps define the entire enterprise as a network of processes, both primary and enabling Helps optimize the enterprise, not departments For each process, APRS helps Create ownership of processes and pride in their improvement Identify customers expectations; establish measurements Provides the foundation to prevent recurrence of problems Enables organizational learning and seamless functioning Since processes produce output, our job is to manage and improve processes Anaar, 2006
22
Global Process Chart of an Enterprise
Primary processes:Sponsor
Customer
P1
P2Pr. Leader
P3 PnCustomer
Enabling processes:Sponsor
E1
E2Pr. Leader Anaar, 2006
E3
En
Revision: Effective Date: File: Prepared by: Approved by: Title:
23
First-Level Macro ProcessProcess Owners ResponsibilitySequential Processes: Independent Processes:
Suppliers Customers Revision: Effective Date: File: Prepared by: Approved by: Title:
Interfacing Processes:
Anaar, 2006
24
Customer-Related DataProcess: ___________ Subprocess: ________Process Internal Customers What is expected Expectations Parameter Expected Value Actuals Actual Value
Management
External Customers
Note: Collect similar data for suppliers and interfacing processes
Anaar, 2006
25
Business Planning Scenario Many business plans remain on paper Many top managers are not satisfied with the way their strategies are implemented by all employees the results being delivered Middle managers are not satisfied with the way the goals are established interdepartmental barriers the level of cooperation from employees
Anaar, 2006
26
Module on Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP)
Since our salaries come from satisfied customers, our goal is to maximize customer satisfaction ASIP helps develop and integrate strategies to optimize the entire business unit (system) instead of the traditional sub-optimization align the thinking of various departments break down barriers between departments ASIP enables identification and removal of constraints existing in the current way of doing things to achieve superior results
Anaar, 2006
27
ASIP ASIP is a systematic team-oriented thought process Translates organizations vision and goals into process-oriented, manageable, actionable and monitorable approaches Is a process of ... Translating strategic issues into key processes Integrating and communicating goals throughout the enterprise
Anaar, 2006
28
Different ways of establishing direction for a company
Winds of Change Chaos
Anaar, 2006
29
Departmental focus
Establish departments Manage people Better profits However, barriers between departments are created Inhibiting teamwork Leading to sub-optimization Less than maximum profits
Anaar, 2006
30
Departmental focus
Anaar, 2006
31
Sub-optimization
Anaar, 2006
32
Different ways of establishing direction for a company
Winds of Change Chaos
Departmental focus Sub-optimization
Anaar, 2006
33
Process Focus
Break down barriers between departments through - Systems thinking - Process-oriented practices
Anaar, 2006
34
System optimization
Anaar, 2006
35
Different ways of establishing direction for a company
Winds of Change Chaos
Departmental focus Sub-optimization
Process focus System optimization
Anaar, 2006
36
Organizational Performance
Some progress No progressTIME
Some deterioration
Significant progress
TIME Anaar, 2006
37
Strategic Issue: Cost CompetitivenessStyle of ManagementTraditional Approach Cut costs Everybody in the organization tries to reduce cost at their individual level (Cost reduction objective delegated down the chimney)
Organizations ResponseProduct or Service at what cost?
Emerging Approach
Reduce cost per unit Identify key processes Identify processes requiring improvement Quantify the level of improvement
Product or Service at lower cost
Anaar, 2006
38
Anaar Strategy Integration ProcessSTRATEGY TREESA-20 A-1 A-2
StrategyGoals Approaches Sponsors and Process leaders
GOALS G1 -
QNTY
G10 Quantification Is this process in place? Degree of improvement required By when? GOALS G1 QNTY
SUBAPPROACHESSA-10 SA-1 G10 Quantification Is this process in place? Degree of improvement required By when? SA-2
TacticsGoals Subapproaches Process leaders
ImplementationSubapproach leaders, project leaders, all levels
Pursue the seven stages of Continuous Improvement (Module 4)
Anaar, 2006
39
Module on Anaar Continuous Improvement Process
Everything we do at work is part of some process Processes left unattended tend to deteriorate over time How well we satisfy the customers depends on how well our processes are behaving Process capability depends on how well we are utilizing the creativity of our employees and suppliers to meet and exceed the customers expectations 7 questions and steps on the next slide become part of the management system Many projects can be completed in 2 to 3 months
Anaar, 2006
40
7 Questions and StagesQ1: Are the processes defined? - Micro-level detail & employee training Q2: Are customers expectations identified? Q3: Managing with facts: Are data collected? Q4: Are data analyzed? Problems identified? Q5: Are the root causes of problems identified? Q6: Are the root causes removed? - Processes modified? employees re-trained? Q7: Are the customers satisfied? Are capability indices CPK > 2? (Six sigma)
Anaar, 2006
41
Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Creating Our Future Introduction Business scenario Business performance to date Constraint analysis on each goal Strategy trees - one for each goal Subapproaches matrices - one for each process on the global process chart Finalization of goals for next fiscal year
Anaar, 2006
42
Business Scenario What business are we in? What business do we want to be in? By business segments, and by worlds regions What is the size of the market and our market share in the business we want to be in? (by segment, and by region) Environmental scan and top 5 competitors
Anaar, 2006
43
Business Scenario
Presentation by ..
Anaar, 2006
44
Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Creating Our Future Introduction Business scenario Business performance to date Constraint analysis on each goal Strategy trees - one for each goal Subapproaches matrices - one for each process on the global process chart Finalization of goals for next fiscal year
Anaar, 2006
45
Business Performance
Business performance parameters (Goals) for the organization Measurement methods for each goal Unambiguous Measurable
Anaar, 2006
46
Business PerformancePrior Year actual & Current Year estimate Goal G1 - Revenue G2 - Profits (PBT or any other accepted measure) G3 - Customer satisfaction G4 - Employee motivation G5 - Other 1 G6 - Other 2 Anaar, 2006
2004 - 05 (Actual)
2005 - 06 (Estimate)
47
Business Performance
Presentation by ..
Anaar, 2006
48
Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Creating Our Future Introduction Business scenario Business performance to date Constraint analysis on each goal Strategy trees - one for each goal Subapproaches matrices - one for each process on the global process chart Finalization of goals for next fiscal year
Anaar, 2006
49
Constraint Analysis What is / are constraining our results, our performance? What are blocking us, not allowing us to proceed? such as competitors actions What are choking us, not allowing us to breathe? such as excessive regulation, taxes What are limiting us, putting chains on our actions? such as lack of technology such as managerial practices Lets introspect Anaar, 2006
50
Individual Assignment
Connect the 9 dots with 4 straight lines without lifting your penTime limit: 2 minutes Anaar, 2006
51
Constraint Analysis We are prisoners of our paradigms, our mindsets Many constraints are figments of our imaginations We imagine constraints that are not there, that are NOT REAL We have been conditioned by our past experiences In order to Create our future, we need to Open our minds, and Break away from these shackles
Anaar, 2006
52
Constraint AnalysisAs senior managers: No matter what the level of our performance is, we need to be dissatisfied with it While being proud of what we have achieved, we need to have the desire to do better in order to survive in this highly competitive environment Aim so high that we will never be bored We need to empower our people to challenge status quo and make a contribution to the organization
Anaar, 2006
53
Constraint AnalysisAs senior managers: No matter what the level of our performance is, we need to be dissatisfied with it While being proud of what we have achieved, we need to have the desire to do better in order to survive in this highly competitive environment Aim so high that we will never be bored We need to empower our people to challenge status quo and make a contribution to the organization
The future can be no better than what the senior management envisions Anaar, 2006
54
Constraint AnalysisLet us examine what are constraining us in our: Ability to generate revenue, which comes from Ability to market Ability to produce Ability to procure Ability to make profits Ability to satisfy our customers Ability to motivate our people Ability to achieve other goals
Anaar, 2006
55
Constraint AnalysisFor each goal, we need to: Form a cross-functional team; select a coordinator Review the performance parameter, actual values achieved in 2004 - 05 and estimates for 2005 - 06 Establish a baseline performance - either full year or last quarter or best months performance - something you have already achieved. We need to improve beyond this level Brainstorm on potential causes for this low level of performance, no matter how good performance is Prepare a CED; identify likely causes; collect available data on likely causes and identify the root causes Anaar, 2006
56
Constraint AnalysisFor each goal (continued): Fill in ONLY the left side of Constraint Analysis sheet List the constraints (the root causes are the constraints) Identify the processes in which these root causes are Identify what actions can be taken to remove these root causes - remember that actions may need to be taken in processes other than where the constraint is felt Identify gains that can be expected over a 12-month period after the constraint is removed (This is NOT same as for the next FY) Calculate cumulative performance that is possible Anaar, 2006
57
Constraint AnalysisFor each goal (continued): Continue to identify constraints and actions to remove the constraints until you have reached over 50% of market share OR until you have exhausted the available space in your campus Dont let investment requirements hinder your vision Dont stop until you have reached world-class levels of performance in quality, productivity and competitiveness
The future can be no better than what the senior management envisions Anaar, 2006
58
Constraint Analysis on Goal: _______________________Performance parameter:_______________________ 2004 - 05 actual:__________; 2005 - 06 estimate:___________ Baseline: _______________________ 2006 - 07 projection:_____________
What can be done to remove the constraint What is the constraint and in which process Actions
Cum = Potential Baseline + gain (1) potential gain In which process (2)
Gains in 2006 - 07 from Strategy Yr end TreeDo-able by
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
Tot (3)
run rate (4)
Anaar, 2006
Gain for the quarter Baseline for the quarter Projection for the quarter
1. Potential gain for a 12-month period after removing the constraint 2. Cumulative performance for a 12-month period after removing the constraint 3. If the performance parameter is an index or %, don't fill this column 4. With the improvements made by Q4 end, what would be achieved for the following year
Anaar, 2006
59
Constraint Analysis on Goal: _______________________Performance parameter:_______________________ 2004 - 05 actual:__________; 2005 - 06 estimate:___________ Baseline: _______________________ 2006 - 07 projection:_____________
What can be done to remove the constraint What is the constraint and in which process Actions
Cum = Potential Baseline + gain (1) potential gain In which process (2)
Gains in 2006 - 07 from Strategy Yr end TreeDo-able by
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
Tot (3)
run rate (4)
Anaar, 2006
Gain for the quarter Baseline for the quarter Projection for the quarter
1. Potential gain for a 12-month period after removing the constraint 2. Cumulative performance for a 12-month period after removing the constraint 3. If the performance parameter is an index or %, don't fill this column 4. With the improvements made by Q4 end, what would be achieved for the following year
Anaar, 2006
60
Constraint AnalysisAssignmentPrepare to present Constraint Analysis for each goal (either via transparency or PC): Performance parameter, past data and baseline Cause and effect diagram and root causes Constraints Possible actions to remove the constraints Potential gains for a 12-month period Cumulative performance, after each constraint is removed Time: 1 hour - 30 minutes Anaar, 2006
61
Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Creating Our Future Introduction Business scenario Business performance to date Constraint analysis on each goal Strategy trees - one for each goal Subapproaches matrices - one for each process on the global process chart Finalization of goals for next fiscal year
Anaar, 2006
62
Strategy Tree The cumulative performance figures on CA indicate what is possible by doing things differently The things we need to do differently are of three types: IPO - Improve the Process Of .. (A process already exists but needs to be improved) CPO - Create a Process Of .. (A required process does not exist) Task - A one time task needs to be undertaken (Describe the task starting with a verb)
Anaar, 2006
63
Strategy Tree We need make the ideas identified on the CA sheets actionable Clarify what needs to be done This may require that some of the ideas be expanded and broken down Identify measurement parameters that are applicable to this action and specify values Identify which process on the global process chart needs to lead each identified effort Identify time-frames
Anaar, 2006
64
Strategy Tree For each goal: Continue with the same cross-functional team Prepare a Strategy Tree to achieve the maximum cumulative performance Approach is opposite of the Constraint listed on CA Subapproaches are actionable projects Expand the ideas from CA, as necessary Identify measurement parameters and values Identify which process on the global process chart needs to lead each identified effort Identify time-frames, as applicable
Anaar, 2006
65
Strategy Tree For each goal (continued): Fill in ONLY the left side One subapproach can have more than one measures; list the most important measures
Anaar, 2006
66
Strategy Tree for Goal:__________ Performance parameter Cumulative maximum Projection for 2006 - 07Things we need to do differently to achieve the goal (Approaches, subapproaches and processes)ApproachA1
From SA matricesGlobal Pr # Leader Doable Resourc by es reqd
SA #1 2 3 4 5 6
IPO/CP O/Task
Subapproach (SA)
Desired result Parameter From
To
A2
1 2 3 4 5 6
A3
1 2 3 4 5
A4
1 2 3 4 5
Anaar, 2004
Note: One IPO / CPO / Task can have more than one measureable parameters. List the most importan
Anaar, 2006
67
Strategy Tree for Goal:__________ Performance parameter Cumulative maximum Projection for 2006 - 07Things we need to do differently to achieve the goal (Approaches, subapproaches and processes)ApproachA1
From SA matricesGlobal Pr # Leader Doable Resourc by es reqd
SA #1 2 3 4 5 6
IPO/CP O/Task
Subapproach (SA)
Desired result Parameter From
To
A2
1 2 3 4 5 6
A3
1 2 3 4 5
A4
1 2 3 4 5
Anaar, 2004
Note: One IPO / CPO / Task can have more than one measureable parameters. List the most importan
Anaar, 2006
68
Strategy TreeAssignmentPrepare to present a strategy tree for each goal (either via transparency or PC): Make sure Approaches are opposite of Constraints List the approaches in the same sequence as constraints Clarify whether a subapproach is an IPO / CPO / Task Include measurement parameters and values Identify applicable process on Global process chart
Time: 1 hour
Anaar, 2006
69
Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Creating Our Future Introduction Business scenario Business performance to date Constraint analysis on each goal Strategy trees - one for each goal Subapproaches matrices - one for each process on the global process chart Finalization of goals for next fiscal year
Anaar, 2006
70
Subapproach Matrices How do we communicate and prioritize all these strategic initiatives By mapping all these actions into appropriate processes on the global process chart Subapproach matrices are intended to contain all the planned projects that apply to that process box There should be one subapproach matrix for each process box Projects come from two sources Strategy trees Improvement plans driven by gap between customers expectations and actual process performance (Tab 9 of process binders) Anaar, 2006
71
Subapproach MatricesAssignment for each Process LeaderPrepare to present a Subapproach Matrix for each process box (either via transparency or PC): Review all strategy trees and pick out all subapproaches where your process is called out Fill in subapproaches in the top 1/4 of the sheet Enter measurement value across from Desired result Identify project leaders for each subapproach Fill in estimated dates for start and finish for each subapproach Indicate if cross-functional team is required Indicate if any resources are required Anaar, 2006
72
Subapproach MatricesAssignment (continued): Add projects that are to be taken from customer related data from the process binders (Tab 8 and 9) Adjust priorities of projects if there are conflicts in scheduling Once completed, provide the following information to the appropriate strategy tree coordinators: Names of subapproach leaders Estimated project completion dates Estimate of resources required, if any
Anaar, 2006
73
Subapproaches Matrix FY xxxx :Process : Sponsor: Process Leader:
Goals G1 G2 G3 G4 G5 G6 G7 -
Projection
Subapproaches x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
x-y-z
Priority Benchmark - Best in class value Breakthrough Required? Resources required? Crossfunctional team? Is there an M3? SA / Project leader
* Y Y
By w hen? Anaar Legend:
S = Start
Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Revision level: Date:
Desired result
Anaar, 2006= Breakthrough required F = Finish *
74
Anaar Strategy Integration Process (ASIP) Creating Our Future Introduction Business scenario Business performance to date Constraint analysis on each goal Strategy trees - one for each goal Subapproaches matrices - one for each process on the global process chart Finalization of goals for next fiscal year
Anaar, 2006
75
Finalization of values for Goals Based on the actions planned on Subapproaches Matrices, we need to revisit the strategy trees and capture when the things we need to do differently can be done Then we need to revisit the constraint analysis to estimate the size of gains quarter-wise With this we will be ready to project what we can expect to achieve for the next FY, IF WE REMOVE THE IDENTIFIED CONSTRAINTS AS PLANNED.
Anaar, 2006
76
Strategy Tree RevisitedAssignment Prepare to present a strategy tree for each goal (either via transparency or PC): Update the right side of strategy tree with the information received from subapproaches matrices Names of leaders for each subapproach Doable dates (finish dates) Value of resources needed, if any Time: 30 minutes
Anaar, 2006
77
Strategy Tree for Goal:__________ Performance parameter Cumulative maximum Projection for 2006 - 07Things we need to do differently to achieve the goal (Approaches, subapproaches and processes)ApproachA1
From SA matricesGlobal Pr # Leader Doable Resourc by es reqd
SA #1 2 3 4 5 6
IPO/CP O/Task
Subapproach (SA)
Desired result Parameter From
To
A2
1 2 3 4 5 6
A3
1 2 3 4 5
A4
1 2 3 4 5
Anaar, 2004
Note: One IPO / CPO / Task can have more than one measureable parameters. List the most importan
Anaar, 2006
78
Constraint Analysis RevisitedAssignment Prepare to present Constraint Analysis for each goal (either via transparency or PC): Update right side for each constraint (from strategy tree) By when column - last date for the group of actions Based on this date, estimated benefits quarter-wise Year-end run rate Total gains by quarter Fill in baseline numbers by quarter Total projections by quarter, and for the year Time: 1 hour Anaar, 2006
79
Constraint Analysis on Goal: _______________________Performance parameter:_______________________ 2004 - 05 actual:__________; 2005 - 06 estimate:___________ Baseline: _______________________ 2006 - 07 projection:_____________
What can be done to remove the constraint What is the constraint and in which process Actions
Cum = Potential Baseline + gain (1) potential gain In which process (2)
Gains in 2006 - 07 from Strategy Yr end TreeDo-able by
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
Tot (3)
run rate (4)
Anaar, 2006
Gain for the quarter Baseline for the quarter Projection for the quarter
1. Potential gain for a 12-month period after removing the constraint 2. Cumulative performance for a 12-month period after removing the constraint 3. If the performance parameter is an index or %, don't fill this column 4. With the improvements made by Q4 end, what would be achieved for the following year
Anaar, 2006
80
Business Performance Projections
Summarize projected performance for all the goals
Anaar, 2006
81
Business Performance ProjectionsGoal 2004 - 05 2005 - 06 (Actual) (Estimate) 2006 - 07 (Projections) Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Total
G1 - Revenue G2 - Profits (PBT or any other accepted measure) G3 - Customer satisfaction G4 - Employee motivation G5 - Other 1 G6 - Other 282
Anaar, 2006
Creating Our Future If we do this year what we did last year, we will get less this year than what we got last year We must improve our systems and processes The fundamental question is: what do we need to differently? Senior management needs to spend about 50% of their time in creating the future of the organization - identifying, sponsoring and ensuring completion of improvement projects83
Anaar, 2006