1
Assimilating Satellite Sea-Surface Salinity in NOAA
Eric Bayler, NESDIS/STARDave Behringer, NWS/NCEP/EMCAvichal Mehra, NWS/NCEP/EMC
Sudhir Nadiga, IMSG @ NWS/NCEP/EMC
5/21/2014 12th JCSDA Science Workshop
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 2
Sea-Surface Salinity (SSS) DataSatellite:• ESA Soil Moisture – Ocean Salinity (SMOS) mission
– Barcelona Expert Centre (SMOS-BEC) Level-3 gridded SSS fields for 2012 – 2013• Uses ECMWF modeled winds for the retrieval
– 0.25-degree resolution– 3-day average (global coverage), updated every 3 days– Interpolated to model grid
• NASA Aquarius mission (AQRS)– Jet Propulsion Lab (JPL) Physical Oceanography Distributed Active Archive Center (PO.DAAC)– Version 2 (V2) Level-3 gridded SSS fields for 2012 – 2013
• Uses NOAA modeled winds for the retrieval – 1.0-degree resolution– 7-day average (global coverage), updated every 7 days– Interpolated to model grid
In Situ:• World Ocean Atlas (WOA) 2009 climatology
– NOAA’s National Oceanographic Data Center (NODC)– 1.0-degree resolution– Interpolated to model grid
• Argo profiling floats– Near-surface observations (~ 5m depth) – Monthly-mean SSS – 1.0-degree resolution– Interpolated to model grid
5/21/2014
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 3
SSS Data: RMS difference of monthly means
5/21/2014
Salinity RMS difference (psu)
SMOS - WOA AQRS - WOA
SMOS - AQRS
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 45/21/2014
Equatorial Pacific (2°S – 2°N) SSS: MeanWOA2009 Argo AQRS SMOS
Salinity (psu)
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 55/21/2014
Equatorial Pacific (2°S – 2°N) SSS Mean: DifferencesAQRS -WOA SMOS-WOA SMOS -AQRS
Salinity Difference (psu)
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 6
Model• Modular Ocean Model v.4 (MOM4)
– NOAA National Weather Service / Environmental Modeling Center (EMC)• Operational Global Ocean Data Assimilation System (GODAS)• Ocean component of NOAA’s operational Coupled Forecast System (CFS)
– Near-global 1.0-degree resolution• Increased resolution (1/3-degree) between 10°S – 10°N
– Forcing: NCEP Climate Forecast System Reanalysis (CFSR)• Saha et al., 2010• Daily fluxes
– Model runs are for 2012-2013 only• Period of overlapping Aquarius and SMOS data• All runs were initiated from the same initial conditions• Relaxed to daily satellite sea-surface temperature (SST) fields.
5/21/2014
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 7
Modeled CasesCONTROL
– CTRL30: NODC World Ocean Atlas (WOA) monthly climatological SSS, relaxation = 30 days• Current operational configuration
– CTRL10: NODC World Ocean Atlas (WOA) monthly climatological SSS, relaxation = 10 days
SMOS– SMOS30: SMOS SSS, 1/4° resolution, 3-day averages (SMOS-BEC), relaxation = 30 days– SMOS10: SMOS SSS, 1/4° resolution, 3-day averages (SMOS-BEC), relaxation = 10 days
Aquarius– AQ30: Aquarius V.2 daily SSS, 1° resolution (NASA/JPL PO.DAAC), relaxation = 30 days– AQ10: Aquarius V.2 daily SSS, 1° resolution (NASA/JPL PO.DAAC), relaxation = 10 days
• Satellite data gaps, e.g., radio frequency interference (RFI) areas, are filled with World Ocean Atlas (WOA) 2009 monthly mean values.
• All runs began from the same initial conditions.
• Model forcing: CFSR daily fluxes
5/21/2014
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 9
ValidationReference = Satellite Salinity Observations
5/21/2014
Salinity RMSE (psu)(a)
AQ10 RMSE; reference = AQRS
(b)
SMOS10 RMSE; reference = SMOS
Model seems to better assimilate the Aquarius data.
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 10
ImprovementNear-real-time Observations versus Climatology
5/21/2014
AQ10 – CTRL10; ref = AQRS obs SMOS10 – CTRL10; ref = SMOS obs
Salinity RMSE (psu)(a) (b)
Blue = Reduction in RMS errors
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 11
Validation: Altimetry
5/21/2014
Normalized RMSE difference (%); reference = satellite sea-surface height anomalies
RMSE difference (cm); reference = satellite sea-surface height anomalies
SMOS10 – CTRL10 AQRS10 – CTRL10 AQRS10 – SMOS10
SMOS10 – CTRL10 AQRS10 – CTRL10 AQRS10 – SMOS10
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 12
Satellite SSS vs Climatology: 30-day RelaxationAverage and RMS Temperature Differences
5/21/2014
Temperature Difference
(°C)
AQ30 – CTRL30 SMOS30 – CTRL30Average Difference Average Difference
RMS Difference RMS Difference
Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 13
Satellite SSS vs Climatology: 30-day RelaxationAverage and RMS Salinity Differences
5/21/2014
Salinity Difference
(psu)
AQ30 – CTRL30 SMOS30 – CTRL30Average Difference Average Difference
RMS Difference RMS Difference
Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 14
SSS Constraint: 10-day vs 30-day RelaxationAverage and RMS Temperature Differences
5/21/2014
Temperature Difference
(°C)
AQ10 – CTRL30 SMOS10 – CTRL30Average Difference Average Difference
RMS Difference RMS Difference
Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 15
SSS Constraint: 10-day vs 30-day Relaxation Average and RMS Salinity Difference
5/21/2014
Salinity Difference
(psu)
AQ10 – CTRL30 SMOS10 – CTRL30Average Difference Average Difference
RMS Difference RMS Difference
Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 16
SSS Data vs Relaxation PeriodAverage and RMS Temperature Differences
5/21/2014
Temperature Difference
(°C)
AQ10 – CTRL10 SMOS10 – CTRL10Average Difference Average Difference
RMS Difference RMS Difference
Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 17
SSS Data vs Relaxation Period Average and RMS Salinity Differences
5/21/2014
Salinity Difference
(psu)
AQ10 – CTRL10 SMOS10 – CTRL10Average Difference Average Difference
RMS Difference RMS Difference
Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 18
Aquarius SSS vs SMOS SSS(AQ10 – SMOS10)
5/21/2014
Temperature Difference Salinity DifferenceAverage Difference Average Difference
RMS Difference RMS Difference
Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 19
Latitudinal Differences 5-degree-wide Longitudinal Slice at 120° W: Temperature
5/21/2014
AQ10 – CTRL10: Avg Difference
AQ10 – CTRL10: RMS Difference SMOS10 – CTRL10: RMS Difference
SMOS10 – CTRL10: Avg Difference
Temperature Difference (°C)Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 20
Latitudinal Differences5-degree-wide Longitudinal Slice at 120° W: Salinity
5/21/2014
AQ10 – CTRL10: Avg Difference
AQ10 – CTRL10: RMS Difference SMOS10 – CTRL10: RMS Difference
SMOS10 – CTRL10: Avg Difference
Salinity Difference (psu)Red line indicates the average depth of the 20C isotherm
12th JCSDA Science Workshop 21
Summary• Assimilating satellite SSS fields improve the simulated ocean state, thus will provide better initialization
of coupled seasonal and tropical cyclone forecast systems. – Significant commonalities in results when using two independent satellite SSS data sets
demonstrate the robustness of the results– Improvements accrue from using satellite SSS data, as well as shortening the salinity relaxation
period
• Most temperature and salinity differences at or above the 20° isotherm
• Generally more intense impact with respect to the current operational configuration (SSS monthly climatology) when using Aquarius data.
• Results indicate largest differences/improvements in the tropical Pacific Ocean.– Possible improvement in countering the model’s tendency toward mirroring the ITCZ in the
Southern Hemisphere.
• Validation– Sea-surface height error reduction indicates some improvement in this region– No obvious impact on ocean heat content other than a very faint indication of improvement in the
tropical Pacific (figure not shown)
• Next:– Examination of model response in the Atlantic and Indian Oceans– Assimilation of SSS Level-2 data
5/21/2014