Audited Project Financial Statements
The audited project financial statements are documents owned by the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB’s Board of Directors, Management, or staff. These documents are made publicly available in accordance with ADB’s Public Communications Policy (2011) and as agreed between ADB and the Ministry of Public Works and Housing.
Project Number: 49141-001 Period covered: 1 January 2017 to 31 December 2017
INO: Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery through Better Engineering Services Project
Prepared by the Audit Board of the Republic of Indonesia
For the Asian Development Bank Date received by ADB: 29 June 2018
AUDIT BOARD OF
THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA
AUDIT REPORT ON
THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF ADB LOAN NO. 3455-INO
IN THE ACCELERATING INFRASTRUCTURE DELIVERY THROUGH BETTER
ENGINEERING SERVICES PROJECT OF
THE SECRETARIAT GENERAL OF THE MINISTRY OF PUBLIC WORKS
AND PUBLIC HOUSING YEAR 2017
Number : 20.A/LHP/XVII/06/2018 Date : 04 June 2018
AUDIT BOARD OF THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA Jl. Gatot Subroto No.31, Central Jakarta 10210
Telephone/Facsimile: (021) 5738770
BPK Audit Report – Financial Statement of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO Year 2017 i
TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ...................................................................................................... i
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS ............................................................................................... ii
SYSTEMATICS OF AUDIT RESULTS ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF ADB LOAN NO. 3455-INO IN AIDBES/ESP YEAR 2017 ................................................ iii
AUDIT REPORT ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ................................................. 1
SUMMARY OF THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS .......................................................... 4
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF ADB LOAN NO. 3455 IN AIDBES/ESP ........................................................................................................................ 6
OVERVIEW OF AUDIT ...................................................................................................... 34
Audit Legal Basis ................................................................................................................. 34
Audit Objectives ................................................................................................................... 34
Audit Target .......................................................................................................................... 34
Audit Standards ..................................................................................................................... 35
Audit Method ........................................................................................................................ 35
Audit Term ............................................................................................................................ 35
Audit Objects ........................................................................................................................ 35
Audit Limitations ......................................................................................................... 35
BPK Audit Report – Financial Statement of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO Year 2017 ii
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS 1. ADB : Asian Development Bank 2. APBN : State Revenues and Expenditures Budget 3. AIDBES : Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery through Better
Engineering Services 4. CaLK : Notes to Financial Statements 5. DED : Detailed Engineering Design 6. DIPA : Budget Implementation Form 7. DGHS : Directorate General of Human Settlements, otherwise
known as the Direktorat Jenderal Cipta Karya 8. DJBM : Direktorat Jenderal Bina Marga
9. DGH : Directorate General of Highways, otherwise known as Direktorat Jenderal Bina Marga
10. Dirjen : Director General 11. Ditjen : Directorate General 12. EoI : Expression of Interest 13. ESP : Engineering Services Project (This Loan in addition
to be abbreviated into AIDBES is also well known with the acronym ESP)
14. KDP : Construction in Progress 15. LARAP : Land Acquisition and Resettlement Action Plan 16. LKPP : Government Procurement of Goods and Services Policy
Board 17. LRA : Budget Realization Report 18. LO : Operational Report 19. MPWH : Ministry of Public Work and Housing 20. PDB : Gross Domestic Product 21. PMO : Project Management Office 22. PIU : Project Implementation Unit 23. PUPR : Public Works and Public Housing 24. SAI : Accounting System for Line Ministry 25. SAIBA : Accrual-Based Accounting System for Line Ministry 26. SIMAK : Management and Accounting Information System 27. SDA : Water Resources 28. Sekjen : Secretariat General 29. Setjen : Secretary General 30. SPI : Internal Control System 31. SPKN : State Finance Auditing Standard 32. SPSE : Electronic Procurement System 33. TOR : Term of Reference 34. TP/TGR : Treasury Demand/Compensation Demand
BPK Audit Report – Financial Statement of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO Year 2017 iii
SYSTEMATICS OF AUDIT RESULTS ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF ADB LOAN No. 3455-INO in AIDBES/ESP
YEAR 2017
The audit report on the Financial Statements of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO in the
Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery through Better Engineering Services Project (AIDBES)
Year 2017 comprises of three reports as follows:
1. Audit Report on the Financial Statements
This report contains: (a) Audit report containing opinion of the Audit Board on the fairness
of the Financial Statements of 2017; (b) Financial Statements in the form of Budget
Realization Report, Balance Sheets, Operational Report, Statement of Changes in Equity
and Notes to Financial Statements, and (c) Overview of Audit containing the legal basis of
the audit, objectives of the audit, target of the audit, audit standards, audit method, audit
term, audit objects, and audit limitations.
2. Audit Report on the Internal Control System
This report contains: (a) Summary of the Report on the Internal Control System, (SPI); (b)
Results of the Audit on SPI; and (c) Follow-up to the Findings of Previous Audit.
3. Audit Report on the Compliance with the Statutory Regulations
This report contains: (a) Summary of the Report on Compliance with the Statutory
Regulations; (b) Results of the Audit on Compliance with the Statutory Regulations; and (c)
Follow-up to the Findings of Previous Audit.
BP
A
B
D
En
(E
R
Fi
Pu
fin
le
da
T
Se
fin
A
th
BP
B
B
Th
PK Audit Repor
Based
Accountabilit
oard (BPK)
ecember 3
ngineering
ESP), which
eport, State
inancial Sta
ublic Work
nancial repo
etter (a) of
ated Novem
he Govern
ecretariat G
nancial stat
Administratio
hat are free o
PK’s Resp
PK’s respo
PK’s audit
hose standa
rt on Opinion -
AUDIT RE
on Law Nu
ty Audit an
) has audited
31, 2017 i
Services Pr
h consists
ement of C
atements ha
ks and Pub
orting claus
the Loan A
mber 28, 201
ment's Res
General of t
tements in a
on Manual,
of material m
onsibility
onsibility is
s. BPK per
ards require
Financial State
A
THE RE
EPORT ON
umber 15 o
nd Law Num
d the Conso
in the Acc
roject or al
of Budget
Changes in
ave been pre
blic Housing
se as contai
Agreement o
16 between
sponsibility
the Ministr
accordance
, and adequ
misstateme
s to expres
rforms the
e that BPK
ements of ADB
AUDIT BOA
EPUBLIC O
N THE FIN
of 2004 reg
mber 15 of 2
olidated Fin
celerating
lso well kn
t Realizatio
Equity a
epared by t
g (PUPR)
ined in Arti
of Asian D
the Republi
y for the Fin
ry of PUPR
with the Go
uate interna
nt, either ca
s an opinio
audit unde
K complies
Loan No. 3455
ARD OF
F INDONE
NANCIAL
garding Sta
2006 regard
nancial State
Infrastructu
own as the
on Report,
and Notes
the Secretar
as the Exe
icle IV Part
Developmen
ic of Indone
nancial Sta
R is respons
overnment
al control to
aused by fra
on on the f
er the State
with BPK’
5-INO Year 20
SIA
STATEME
ate Financia
ding the Aud
ements for t
ure Deliver
e Engineerin
Balance S
to Financia
riat General
ecuting Ag
ticular Cove
nt Bank (AD
esia and AD
atements
sible for the
Accounting
o prepare f
aud or error
financial st
Finance A
s code of c
17
ENTS
al Managem
dit Board, th
the year end
ry Through
ng Services
Sheets, Ope
al Statemen
l of the Min
ency based
enants Sect
DB) No. 34
DB.
e preparatio
g Standards
financial sta
.
tatements b
Auditing Sta
conduct, as
1
ment and
he Audit
ded as of
h Better
s Project
erational
nts. The
nistry of
d on the
tion 4.05
455-INO
on of the
, Project
atements
based on
andards.
well as
BPK Audit Report on Opinion - Financial Statements of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO Year 2017 2
plans and performs the audit to obtain reasonable assurance that the financial
statements are free of material misstatement.
An audit includes implementing procedures to obtain audit evidences supporting the amounts
and disclosures in the financial statements. The selected procedure shall be based on the
professional judgment of the auditors, including an assessment of the risk of material
misstatement in the financial statements, either caused by fraud or error. In assessing the risk,
the Auditors consider the internal controls relevant to the preparation of the entity’s financial
statements to design an appropriate audit procedure in accordance with the existing conditions,
but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the entity's internal
control. An audit also includes evaluating the accuracy of the accounting policies applied and
the fairness of the accounting estimates established by the Secretariat General of the Ministry of
PUPR, as well as evaluating the overall financial statements presentation.
BPK believes that the audit evidences obtained have provided adequate and reasonable basis to
state an opinion of BPK.
Opinion
According to BPK’s opinion, the aforementioned financial statements were presented fairly, in
all material respects, the financial position of the ADB Loan No. 3455-INO in Accelerating
Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Project (ESP) as of December 31,
2017 in conformity with the Government Accounting Standards and Project Administration
Manual.
Basis of Accounting and Restrictions on the Distribution and Use
Without modifying the opinion, BPK emphasizes on the Notes to the Financial Statements to
describe the basis of accounting. The Financial Statements are prepared to assist the Secretariat
General of the Ministry of PUPR to comply with the financial reporting clause set forth in
Article IV Particular Covenants Section 4.05 letter (a) of the Loan Agreement. As a
consequence thereof, the financial statements may not be appropriate for other purposes. BPK
report is only intended for ADB and the Ministry of PUPR, and is not allowed to be distributed
to/or used by any party other than ADB and the Ministry of PUPR.
4
SUMMARY OF FINANCIAL STATEMENT
The financial statements of the Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better
Engineering Services Project (AIDBES or better known as ESP) of 2017 have been prepared
and presented in accordance with Government Regulation No. 71 of 2010 on Government
Accounting Standards (SAP), Minister of Finance Regulation No. 222/PMK.05/2016 on Manual
for the Preparation and Submission of Financial Statement for Government Ministry/Agency,
and other accounting principles. This Financial Statement consists of:
I Budget Realization Report
The Budget Realization Report describes the comparison between the budget and its
realization, which includes LRA-Revenue and Expenditure elements during the period of
January 1st through December 31st, 2017.
Realization of State Revenues in Fiscal Year 2017 are as much as Rp14,009,342,920.00
or 47.33% of a budget allocation of Rp29,597,189,000.00.
Realization of Financing Acquisition are in the form of Acquisition from International
Loan to finance the Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering
Services Project as much as Rp14,009,342,920.00 or 47.33% of the estimated budget of
Rp29,597,189,000.00.
II Balance Sheet
The balance sheet describes the entity's financial position on Assets, Liabilities and
Equity as of December 31st, 2017.
Asset Value per December 31st, 2017 is recorded and presented in the amount of
Rp14,009,342,920.00 which consists of: Current Assets of Rp12,701,110,800.00 and
Intangible Asset of Rp1,308,232,120.00.
The Value of Equity is Rp14,009,342,920.00, meanwhile the Total Value of Liabilities
and Equity combined amounted to Rp14,009,342,920.00.
III Operational Report
The Operational Report (LO) presents various elements of LO's income, expenses,
surplus/deficit from operations, surplus/deficit from nonoperational activities,
surplus/deficit before extraordinary items, extraordinary items, and surplus/deficit-LO.
5
The LO-income, expense and Surplus/Deficit for Activities for the period up to December
31st, 2017 amounted to Rp0.00.
IV Statement of Changes in Equity
The Statement of Changes in Equity provides information on the increase or decrease in
the equity of the reporting year compared to the previous year. Equity as of January 1st,
2017 amounted to Rp0.00 meanwhile Equity as of December 31st, 2017 amounted to
Rp14,009,342,920.00, which was due to the traction between entities that was worth
Rp14,009,342,920.00.
V Notes to the Financial Statements
The Notes to the Financial Statements (CaLK) provide information on explanations or
detailed lists or an analysis of the value of a post presented in the Budget Realization
Report, Balance Sheet, Operations Report and Statement of Changes in Equity. Further
included in the CaLK is the presentation of information required and recommended by
the Government Accounting Standards.
According to Minister of Finance Regulation No. 222/PMK.05/2016 on Manual for the
Preparation and Submission of Financial Statement for Government Ministry/Agency, the
Budget Realization Report for the period ending on December 31st, 2017 is prepared and
presented on a cash basis, meanwhile the Balance Sheet, Operational Report and Statement of
Changes in Equity for the Year 2017 are prepared and presented on an accrual basis.
6
CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF ADB LOAN NO. 3455 IN AIDBES/ESP
I. BUDGET REALIZATION REPORT Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Project (ESP)
Budget Realization Report for Year Book Ended on December 31st 2017
Description Notes
FY 2017 % of
Budget
FY2016
Budget (Rp)
Realization (Rp)
Realization (Rp)
REVENUE
Non-tax State Revenue
Other Non-tax State Revenue
Total Revenue
EXPENDITURE
Operational Expenditure B.1
Goods and Service Expenditure B.1.1 13,547,189,000.00 6,628,644,620.00 48.93
Total Operational Expenditure 13,547,189,000.00 6,628,644,620.00 48.93
Capital Expenditure B.2
Machinery Equipment Expenditure B.2.1 8,000,000,000.00 3,572,466,180.00 44.65
Irrigation Roads and Bridges Expenditure
B.2.2 7,550,000,000.00 3,808,232,120.00 50.44
Other Capital Expenditures B.2.3 500,000,000.00
Total Capital Expenditures 16,050,000,000.00 7,380,698,300.00 45.98
Total Expenditure 29,597,189,000.00 14,009,342,920.00 47.33
Financing
Acquisition of International Financing
B.3
Acquisition of International Loan from ADB 3455-INO
29,597,189,000.00 14,009,342,920.00 47.33
Total Acquisition of Financing 29,597,189,000.00 14,009,342,920.00 47.33
Notes to the Financial Statement are an inseparable component to the Financial Statement
itself.
7
II. BALANCE SHEET Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Project (ESP)
ESP Balance Sheet For Year Book Ended on December 31st 2017
Description Note Realization in FY 2017
ASSETS
CURRENT ASSETS C.1
Advance Payment (Prepaid) C.1.1 12,701,110,800.00
Total Current Assets 12,701,110,800.00
FIXED ASSETS C.2 0
Equipment and Machinery C.2.1 0
Buildings C.2.2 0
Roads, Irrigation and Network C.2.3 0
Construction In Progress C.2.4 0
Accumulated Depreciation on Fixed Assets C.2.5 0
Total Fixed Assets
OTHER FIXED ASSETS C.3
Intangible Assets C.3.1 0
Intangible Assets in Progress C.3.2 1,308,232,120.00
Accumulated Depreciation & Amortization of Intangible Assets C.3.3 0
Total Other Fixed Assets 1,308,232,120.00
TOTAL ASSETS 14,009,342,920.00
LIABILITIES
Short Term Liabilities C.4
Total Short term Liabilities
EQUITY
Equity C.5 14,009,342,920.00
Total Equity 14,009,342,920.00
LIABILITIES & EQUITY TOTAL 14,009,342,920.00
Notes to the Financial Statement are an inseparable component to the Financial Statement
itself.
8
III. OPERATIONAL REPORT Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Project (ESP)
Operational Report For Year Book Ended on December 31st 2017
Description Notes Amount
OPERATIONAL ACTIVITIES
REVENUE
Revenue-LO D.1 -
TOTAL REVENUE -
EXPENDITURE
Labor Expenditure D.2
Inventory Expenditure D.3 -
Depreciation & Amortization D.4 -
TOTAL EXPENDITURE -
Notes to the Financial Statement are an inseparable component to the Financial Statement itself.
9
IV. STATEMENT OF CHANGES OF EQUITY Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Project (ESP)
ESP Statement of Changes of Equity For Year Book Ended December 31st 2017
Description Notes 2017 2016
Initial Equity E.1 -
Transactions Between Entities E.2 14,009,342,920.00
LO Surplus/Deficit, Revised Increase/Decrease in Equity E.3 -
Final Amount of Equity E.4 14,009,342,920.00
Notes to the Financial Statement are an inseparable component to the Financial Statement
itself.
10
V. NOTES ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENT
A. GENERAL DESCRIPTION
Improving infrastructure is critical to stimulating inclusive growth in Indonesia.
Inadequate infrastructure has hampered growth and poverty reduction, and poses significant
obstacles to doing business in Indonesia. Poor road infrastructure contributes to logistics cost in
Indonesia up to 24% of GDP. Food security is affected by poor irrigation infrastructure. Since
2005, irrigated land with decent infrastructure has declined from 78% to less than 50% today.
Access to basic urban water and sanitation services lags far behind other middle-income
countries. In 2014, just 80.7% of the urban population had access to improved water sources,
while 61.06% had access to improved sanitation facilities. Such gaps in basic infrastructure
provision are the result of both low government infrastructure investment and underutilization
of the capital budget.
The reform of fuel subsidies in January 2015 has enabled the government’s
infrastructure budget to increase from Rp144.4 trillion in 2014 to Rp280.3 trillion in 2015 and
further to Rp302.6 trillion in 2016. The line-ministries are responsible for the delivery of more
than 50% of the government’s infrastructure budget. The increase in infrastructure spending has
been accompanied by institutional reforms to enable the ministries to deliver their public
investment programs in an accelerated manner. In 2014–2015, the government, in line with
institutional reforms, had: (i) established a dedicated office for land acquisition at the Ministry
of Agrarian and Spatial Planning/National Land Agency (NLA), (ii) improved legal and
technical frameworks on land acquisition, (iii) strengthened the procurement units of
government agencies and rolled out a national e-procurement system (LKPP SPSE), (iv)
increased the use of advance procurement and multi-year contracts for infrastructure projects,
and (v) set up a budget realization evaluation and monitoring team to address implementation
constraints at the central and sub-national levels.
The Ministry of Public Works and Housing (MPWH) leads the government’s effort to
meet RPJMN, 2015–2019 basic infrastructure targets to build 3,650 kilometers of new
highways, improve the irrigation network covering 1 million hectares, build 49 dams, attain
100% access to drinking water, reduce slum areas to 0%, and achieve 100% access to improved
sanitation, all of which are targeted to be achieved by 2019. During 2015–2019, the MPWH’s
infrastructure program is estimated to be Rp660 trillion or 47% of the government’s
infrastructure program. In 2015–2016, about 37% of the government’s infrastructure budget was
allocated to the MPWH.
Delivery of the MPWH’s infrastructure programs has been constrained by complex land
acquisition processes, procurement delays, and inadequate preparation of infrastructure projects.
11
With the implementation of the new land acquisition law and continuous efforts to strengthen
public procurement systems, it is now the latter that critically limits the ministry’s ability to
deliver infrastructure of good quality and timely manner. Weak project implementation
preparation is largely due to lack of resources to complete the required assessments, surveys,
master plans, feasibility studies, designs, and environmental and land acquisition clearances.
Addressing the project preparation issue will be, therefore, important for the MPWH to meet its
infrastructure development targets.
By incorporating these lessons learned, the proposed Accelerating Infrastructure
Delivery through Better Engineering Services Project (ESP) has been designed to target the
MPWH’s critical constraints by: (i) enabling financing of the preparation of infrastructure
projects as a separate project; and (ii) strengthening MPWH systems to improve the quality and
timeliness of the preparation of master plans, feasibility studies, detailed engineering designs
(DEDs), land acquisition and resettlement plans, environmental impact assessments, bidding
documents, and construction supervision. The project will be coordinated with development
partners to ensure complementarity.
The outcome that is expected of ESP is the strengthening of capacity of DGWH, DGH
and DGHS so that the design and implementation of public investment program in MPWH can
be done as efficient as possible. The outputs of ESP are given as follows:
Output 1: Quality and timely start-up of infrastructure projects improved. This output
will support the preparation based on new analytical methods and design standards of: (i)
irrigation, flood management, and bulk water projects of the MPWH’s Directorate General of
Water Resources (DGWR), (ii) water supply and sanitation projects of the Directorate General
of Human Settlements (DGHS), and (iii) national road projects of the Directorate General of
Highways (DGH). All infrastructure projects are from the MPWH’s 2015-2019 Strategic Plan,
and are to be mainly financed from the government budget. This output will support preparation
of: (i) master plans and feasibility studies; (ii) detailed engineering designs, including
geotechnical, topographical and other surveys; (iii) environmental impact assessments and land
acquisition documents as per government requirements; and (iv) advance contracting for civil
works. This output will also support construction supervision (for selected projects of DGHS
and DGH), and technical and financial assessment (for selected DGH projects).
Output 2: Capacity in public investment management strengthened. This output will
support the DGWR, DGHS, and DGH of the MPWH in: (i) improving master planning and
public investment management systems; (ii) on-the-job capacity development of project staff,
especially at local level, in such areas as design-and-build contracts, design standards,
construction supervision, enforcement of civil works contractor performance via technical and
12
financial assessment during construction, multi-year contracting, etc.; (iii) strengthening of the
ministry’s safeguards and procurement systems, (iv) strengthening value engineering during
preparation of infrastructure projects, and (v) implementation of the ESP, including monitoring
and evaluation of project preparation activities.
The project is expected to be implemented from December 1st 2016 to December 31st
2019. Most activities related to preparation and bidding of projects are planned to be completed
by the end of 2018 and mid-2019 respectively. A significant share of ESP prepared projects is
expected to be at various phases of civil works by the end 2019. The period between mid-2018
to the end of 2019 would be used for construction supervision as well as technical and financial
assessment of selected infrastructure projects prepared under the ESP.
The DGWR, DGHS, and DGH of the MPWH (implementing agencies under the ESP)
will undertake: (i) project preparation work for their infrastructure projects, and (ii) institutional
and capacity strengthening in public investment management. The list of ESP-supported
projects may change based the government priorities and agreement with the ADB.
A.1 Funding of ESP (RRP INO 49141) FY 2017
The financing of the Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering
Services Project (ESP) is derived from ADB Loan No. L3455-INO. The financing mechanisms
are carried out through DIPA with Direct Payment Procedure from ADB, based on the payment
request of the: (i) Directorate General of Water Resources (DGWR), (ii) water supply and
sanitation projects of the Directorate General of Human Settlements (DGHS), and (iii) national
road projects of the Directorate General of Highways (DGH). The Data on Budget and Actual
Expenditures are listed in the following Table 1.
Table 1. Budget and Actual Expenditure for Fiscal Year 2017
Work Unit
Output
Budget (USD) Budget (IDR) Actual
Expenditure (USD)
Actual Expenditure (IDR)
Loan Loan Loan Loan
Directorate Irrigation and Lowland (PIU on DGWR)
Output 1 ‐ Improved quality and timely start‐up of MPWH’s infrastructure projects
37,313.00 500,000,000.00 ‐ ‐
Directorate River and Coastal (PIU on DGWR) ‐ ‐ ‐ ‐
Directorate Center for Ground Water and Bulk Water (PIU on DGWR)
253,731.00 3,400,000,000.00 ‐ ‐
Centre Of Dams (PIU on DGWR) 597,015.00 8,000,000,000.00 359,518.00 4,880,698,300.00
Directorate Water Resource Development (PMO on
Output 2 ‐Strengthening
387,538.00 5,193,004,000.00 ‐ ‐
13
Work Unit
Output
Budget (USD) Budget (IDR) Actual
Expenditure (USD)
Actual Expenditure (IDR)
Loan Loan Loan Loan DGWR) capacity of MPWH in
public investment management
Directorate of Road Construction (PIU on DGH)
Output 1 ‐ Improved quality and timely start‐up of MPWH’s infrastructure projects
‐ ‐ ‐ ‐
Directorate of Bridges (PIU of DGH) 92,284.00 1,250,000.000.00 ‐ ‐
Administration Establishment and International Loan and Grant Monitoring, Directorate of Road Network Development (PMO on DGH)
Output 2 ‐Strengthening capacity of MPWH in public investment management
186,517.00 2,500,000,000.00 184,054.00 2,500,000,000.00
Directorate for Water Supply System Development (PIU on DGHS)
Output 1 ‐ Improved quality and timely start‐up of MPWH’s infrastructure projects
‐ ‐ ‐
Directorate of Environmental Sanitation Development (PIU on DGHS)
‐ ‐ ‐
Directorate of Integration of Settlement Infrastructure (PMO on DGHS)
Output 2 ‐Strengthening capacity of MPWH in public investment management
502,138.00 6,728,645,000.00 488,370.00 6,628,644,620.00
Total 2,056,536.00 27,571,649,000.00 1,031,942.00 14,009,342,920.00
A.2 Profile of Loan
The general profile of the loan is as follows:
Project Name : Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Project
Executing Agency : Ministry of Public Works and Housing
ADB Loan Number and Register Number
: 3455-INO (Project No.49141-001)
Date of Signing : November 28th 2016
Effective Date of Loan : December 24th 2016
Closing Date of Loan : June 30th 2020
Total Loan : USD 148,20 million
14
A.3 Loan Allocation per Category
Table 2. ESP Loan Allocation by Funding Source
Description
ADB Portion (USD)
% Government Amount (USD) %
A Investment Costs
1 Consultants :
a. Infrastructure project preparation. 123,700,000.00 100 ‐ ‐
b. ESP Management and MPWH Institutional Strengthening 8,600,000.00 100 ‐ ‐
c. Trainings &Workshops 200,000.00 100 ‐ ‐
2 Office Equipment& Furniture 600,000.00 100 ‐ ‐
Subtotal (A) 133,100,000.00 100 ‐ ‐
B Contingencies
Sub Total (B) 15,100,000.00 100 ‐ ‐
C Taxes
Sub Total (C) ‐ ‐ 14,800,000.00 100
D Implementation Fees
Interest During Implementation ‐ ‐ 4,600,000.00 100
Sub Total (D) ‐ ‐ 4,600,000.00 100
Total Project Cost (A+B+C+D) 148,200,000.00 88.42 19,400,000.00 11.58
Table 3. Loan Allocation in Each Directorate General No. Organization Unit Loan Portion (USD)
A DG Water Resources (DGWR) 51,625,000.00
B DG Highway (DGH) 45,000,000.00
C DG Human Settlement (DGHS) 51,575,000.00
Total 148,200,000.00
A.4 Organizational Structure of ESP
A.4.1 Project Implementation Organization-Roles and Responsibilities
The Steering Committee (SC) was established through a Decree of the Minister of
Public Works and Housing and chaired by Secretary General of the Ministry Public Works and
Housing. Other members of the ESP Steering Committee will include Director General for
Highways, Director General for Human Settlements, and Director General for Construction
Development. This Committee has some duties, that is: (i) to provide overall coordination and
guidance during the implementation of the ESP; (ii) Monitor status of preparation of individual
infrastructure projects and ensures that ESP-supported projects receive the required capital
budget; (iii) Monitor status of institutional strengthening and capacity building activities; and
(iv) Ensure alignment of the ESP with MPWH SDP targets and time-lines. The steering
committee will meet regularly and ad-hoc meetings may also take place at the request of the
Chairperson.
15
A.4.2 The Project Coordination Office (PCO), Secretary General’s Office
The ESP Project implementation is coordinated by Secretary General’s Office (Setjen)
assigned through the PCO. Consultants are also called in involvement to support PCO through
APBN and ADB cluster technical assistance on sustainable infrastructure assistance program
(C-TA0013-INO). The roles and responsibility PCO will include the following :
• Serve as secretariat in ESP Steering Committee;
• Ensure follow-up on issues discussed in Steering Committee meetings;
• Execute the monitoring, evaluation and coordination of the implementation of ESP activities;
• Prepare a consolidated implementation report on ESP which will be submitted to the Minister of MPWH along with other respectful agencies;
• Give instruction and guidance to each Project Management Office;
• Facilitate annual financial audit; and
• Prepare a public pocket book that contains information of the implementation of ESP activities that are updated annually and/or a webpage containing information on the implementation of ESP.
A.4.3 Project Management Office (PMOs) at DGWR, DGHS, and DGH
DGWR, DGHS and DGH are the implementing agencies for the project to be prepared
for implementation under ESP. These DGs will be represented by their PMOs. The PMO for
each of the DG headed by Director of relevant directorate for planning and programming and
will include necessary staffs to cover procurement ad financial management areas. The roles
and responsibilities of PMO’s include the following overall :
• Coordination and reporting of ESP to PCO and ADB;
• Coordinate and give guidance to PIU;
• Facilitate whatever funding is needed for activities that are supported through ESP;
• Manage financial reporting and accountability aspects (withdrawal applications, financial reports, audits, bank account statements, etc.) in accordance to the ADB Loan Disbursement Handbook and the respectful Government of Indonesia’s Regulations;
• Review and process payments to consultants; and
• Manage loans and state-owned goods.
16
A.4.4 Project Implementation Units (PIUs) at DGWR, DGHS, and DGH
The PIU for each of the DG headed by a Director and include necessary staffs to cover
procurement, financial management, and technical areas. The management roles and
responsibilities of each of the PIUs will include the following:
• Coordination and reporting to PMO;
• Monitoring and evaluation of the implementation of ESP activities within the PIU;
• Assist PMO in facilitating annual financial audit;
• Manage loans and state-owned goods;
• Review and process payments to consultants; and
• Report the monitoring results on the contract implementation status to PMO and ensure
the timeliness of project implementation.
A.4.5 Project Team (PIU – Balai/Satker)
Established by the concerned PIU with participation of local Balai or Satker. Tasks
carried out by the team are to :
• Review the results of project preparation done by consultants;
• Submit consultant outputs to PIU for approval and endorsement of payment to the project preparation consultant firms.
A.5 Approach to Preparation of Financial Statements
This 2017 Financial Report is a report covering all financial aspects of the ESP. This
Financial Statement is generated through Institution Accounting System (SAI) which is a series
of manual and computerized procedures starting from data collection, recording and
summarization up to reporting of financial status and financial operation at State
Ministry/Agencies.
SAI consists of Accounting System of Accrual Based Institution (SAIBA) and
Management Information System and Accounting of State Property (SIMAK-BMN). SAI is
designed to generate a Unit Working Financial Statement consisting of Budget Realization
Reports, Balance Sheet, Operations Report, and Statement of Changes in Equity. While
SIMAK-BMN is a system that produces information of fixed assets, inventories, and other
assets for the preparation of balance sheets and reports of state property and other managerial
reports
Preparations of Financial Reports of the Project for Accelerating the Provision of
Infrastructure through Better Technical Service (PPT) and as a reference for Financial
17
Administration Reporting are:
• Director General of treasury’s Regulation No. Per-14/PB/2014
• Law Number 17 of 2003 on State Finance
• Law Number 1 of 2004 on State Treasury
• Government Regulation (PP) Number 71 of 2010 of the Governmental Standard Accounting
• Minister of Finance’s Regulation Number 171/PMK.05/2007 as amended to Minister of Finance’s Decree Number 233/PMK.05/2011 on Central Government’s Financial Accounting and Reporting System.
• Minister of Finance Regulation No. 222/PMK.05/2016. on Guidelines for the Preparation and Submission of Financial Statements of State Ministries/Agencies
• Presidential Regulation (PerPres) Number 54 of 2010 concerning Procurement of Goods/Services as amended a number of times and the last amendment was Presidential Regulation Number 70 of 2012
• ADB Guidelines on Goods and Services Procurement
• Loan Agreement between ADB and the Government of Indonesia
• General Unit Price and Basic Unit Price for Activities (HSU & HSPK).
A.6 Base of Accounting
ESP adopts an accrual basis in preparing and presenting the Balance Sheet, Operations
Report and Statement of Changes in Equity and cash basis for the preparation and presentation
of the Budget Realization Report. The accrual basis is an accounting basis that acknowledges
the effect of transactions and other events at the time the transactions and events occur,
regardless of when cash or cash equivalents are received or paid. While the cash basis is the
basis of accounting that recognizes the effects of transactions or other events when cash or cash
equivalents are received or paid. This is in accordance with Government Accounting Standards
(SAP) that has been established with Government Regulation No. 71 of 2010 on Government
Accounting Standards on Accrual Basis.
A.7 Basic Measurement
Measurement is the process of determining the value of money to recognize and include
each component in the financial statements. The measurement basis adopted by Accelerating
Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Projecting preparing and
presenting the Financial Statement is to use historical value.
18
Assets are recorded at the expense / use of economic resources or at fair value of the
benefits provided for acquiring the asset. Liabilities are recorded at the fair value of economic
resources used by the government to meet the obligations concerned.
The measurement of financial statement items uses Rupiah currency. Transactions using
foreign currencies are converted first and denominated in rupiah.
A.8 Accounting Policies
The preparation and presentation of the 2017 Financial Statements has been referred to
Government Accounting Standards (SAP) on Accrual Basis. The accounting policies are the
principles, basics, conventions, rules and specific practices chosen by a reporting entity in the
preparation and presentation of financial statements. The accounting policies adopted in these
financial statements is the policies established by the Accounting and Financial Reporting
Board, which are reporting entities of the Jayapura Special Accounting Office. In addition, in
the preparation has been an applied rule of sound financial management within the government
environment.
The significant accounting policies used in the preparation of the Financial Statements
of the Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery Through Better Engineering Services Projecting as
follows:
A.8.1 Revenue-LRA
• Revenue-LRA is recognized when the cash is received in the State Treasury (KUN).
• Revenue-LRA accounting is executed on gross basis, by posting gross receipts, and not
recording the net amount (after being offset).
• Revenue-LRA is presented according to the classification of revenue sources.
A.8.2 Revenue-LO
• LO revenues are recognized when the right to revenue and / or income is realized, is the
flow of economic resources.
• Revenues that are used to fund operational activities are not used for neither the capital
expenditure of goods nor fixed assets.
• Revenue from Building Rentals is recognized proportionally between the value and
period of rent.
• Revenue from Fines is recognized the moment when the fine verdict is published or
respectful documents.
19
• LO revenue accounting is based on gross principle, by posting gross receipts, and not
recording the net amount (after being compensated by expenditures).
• Revenue is presented according to the classification of sources of income.
A.8.3 Expenditure
• Expenditures are recognized when a cash outflow is made from KUN.
• Specifically for expenditures through the expenditure treasurer, expenditure recognition
occurs when the accountability of such expenditures is authorized by the State Treasury
Office (KPPN).
• Expenditures are presented by economic classification / type of expenditure and
subsequent classifications by organization and function will be disclosed in the Notes to
the Financial Statements.
A.8.4 Expenses• Expenses states the decline in economic benefits or potential services in the reporting
period that decrease the equity, which may be the expenditure or consumption of assets
or the incurrence of liabilities.
• Expenses are recognized when an obligation is incurred; asset consumption occurring;
the decline in economic benefits or potential services.
• Expenses are presented under the economic classification / type of expenditure and
subsequent classifications by organization and function are disclosed in the Notes to the
Financial Statements.
A.8.5 Assets
Assets are classified into Current Assets, Fixed Assets, Long-Term Receivables and Other
Assets.
a. Current assets
• Cash is presented on the balance sheet using nominal value. Cash in foreign currencies
are presented on the balance sheet using the middle rate of BI at the balance sheet date.
• BLU’s Short-term Investment in securities is stated at cost, while investments in time
deposits are recorded at nominal value.
• Receivables are recognized if they meet the following criteria:
i. Receivables arising from the Treasury / Indemnification Demand if there a rise
rights that are backed by an Absolute Liability Statement and / or have been issued
a decree which has permanent legal force.
20
ii. Accounts receivable arising from receivables are recognized in the event of a
claiming event and are endorsed by a treaty which expresses rights and obligations
clearly and the amount can be measured reliably
• Receivables are presented on the balance sheet at a realizable value. This is realized by
establishing an allowance for doubtful accounts. The allowance is based on the quality
of receivables determined on the basis of maturity and collection efforts by the
government. The allowance is as follows:
Table 4. Allowance According to Quality of Receivables Quality of Receivables Description Allowance
Current Unpaid until due date 0.5%
Substandard Unpaid until one month commencing from the date of the First Billing Letter 10%
Doubtful Unpaid until one month from the date of the Second Billing Letter 50%
Loss
Unpaid until one month from the date of Third Billing Letter 100% Receivables have been submitted to the State Receivables
Management Committee/DJKN
• Claims on Installment Sales (TPA) and Compensation / Compensation Claims
(TP/TGR) which will mature 12 (twelve) months after the balance sheet date are
presented as Current Section TP/TGR or Current Section of TPA.
• Inventory Value is recorded based on the results of the physical inventory at the balance
sheet date multiplied by:
o the latest purchase price, if obtained by purchase;
o standard price if obtained by self-production;
o fair price or estimated sales value if obtained by other means.
b. Fixed assets
• Fixed assets include all tangible assets utilized by the government as well as for the
public interest which has a useful life of more than 1 year.
• The value of Property and Equipment is presented at cost or fair value.
• The recognition of fixed assets is based on the value of the minimum unit of
capitalization as follows:
i. Expenditures per unit of equipment and machinery and exercise equipment equal
to or more than Rp300.000,00 (three hundred thousand rupiahs);
ii. Expenditures on buildings and buildings of value equal to or more than
Rp10.000.000,00 (ten million rupiahs);
21
iii. Expenditures not covered by the minimum capitalization limits mentioned
above, are treated as expenses except land, road / irrigation / network
expenditures, and other fixed assets in the form of library and artwork
collections.
• Fixed Assets not used in government operations due to, among other things, being worn
out, out of date, not in accordance with the needs of the growing organization, severely
damaged, incompatible with the general spatial plan (RUTR), or the useful life has
ended up reclassified to Other Assets on Other Assets item.
• Fixed assets that are permanently discontinued are removed from the balance sheet at
the time of any proposed removal from the entity in accordance with the provisions of
legislation in the management of BMN / BMD.
c. Depreciation of asset
• Depreciation of property and equipment is a value adjustment in relation to the decrease
in the capacity and benefits of a fixed asset.
• Depreciation of property and equipment is not carried out against:
i. Soil
ii. Construction in Progress
iii. Fixed Assets declared to be lost on the basis of valid source documents or in
conditions of serious damage and / or obsolescence that have been proposed to
the Goods Manager for removal
• Calculation and recording of Depreciation of Fixed Assets shall be done at the end of
each semester without taking into account the residual value.
• Depreciation of Property and Equipment is carried out using the straight-line method by
allocating depreciable value from fixed assets equally each semester during the Benefit
Period.
• The Period of Benefit of Property Assets is determined based on Decree of the Minister
of Finance Number: 59 / KMK.06 / 2013 concerning Table of Benefit Period in the
Framework of Depreciation of State Property in the form of Fixed Assets in Central
Government Entities. In general, the useful life table is as follows:
Table 5. Classification Fixed Assets based on its Useful Life
Group of Fixed Assets Useful Life/Benefits Age
Equipment and Machines 2 until 20 years
Building 10 until 50 years
Road, Network and Irrigation 5 until 40 years
Other Fixed Assets 4 years
22
d. Long Term Receivables
• Long-term Receivables are expected/scheduled receivables within a period of more than
12 (twelve) months after the date of reporting.
• Claims on Installment Sales (TPA), Claim for Treasury/Compensation Claims
(TP/TGR) are valued at face value and presented at the realizable value.
e. Other Assets
• Other assets are government assets other than current assets, fixed assets, and long-term
receivables. Included in Other Assets are intangible assets, installment sales receipts
with maturities of more than 12 (twelve) months, assets of cooperation with third parties
(partnership), and restricted cash.
• Intangible Assets (ATB) are presented at their net carrying amount at cost less the
accumulated amortization.
• Amortization of ATB with limited useful life is done on a straight-line method and
residual value of nil. While on ATB with unlimited period of service is not made
amortization.
• The Period of Benefit of Intangible Assets is determined by the Decree of the Minister
of Finance No. 620/KM.6/2015 on the Period of Benefit for the Amortization of State
Assets in the form of Intangible Assets in Central Government Entities. In general, the
useful life table is as follows:
Table 6. Classification of Intangible Assets based on its Useful Life Intangible Assets Group Useful Life (years)
Computer Software 4
Francize 5
License, Simple Patent, Brand, Industrial Design, Trade Secret, Layout Design of Integrated Circuit.
10
Economic Rights of Broadcasting Institutions, Patent Ordinary, Variety Protection of Annual Plants.
20
Copyright of Applied Art Works, Annual Plant Variety Protection 25
Copyright on Creation Gol.II, Economic Rights Performer Performance, Economic Rights of Producer Phonogram. 50
Copyright on Creation Gol.I 70
• Other Assets in the form of government fixed assets are presented at book value that
is cost subtracted by accumulated depreciation.
23
A.8.6 Liabilities
Liability is debt arising from past events whose settlement resulted in a flow of
government economic resources. Government obligations are classified into short-term
liabilities and long-term liabilities.
• Short-term Liabilities
An obligation is classified as a short-term liability if they are expected to be paid or due
within twelve months after the date of reporting.
Short-term obligations include Debt to Third Parties, Expenditures that are Paid, Revenue
Received Advance, Current Section of Long-Term Debts, and Other Short-Term Debts.
• Long-term obligation
A liability is classified as long-term liabilities if they are expected to be paid or is due for
more than twelve months after the date of reporting.
Liabilities are recorded at nominal value, which is the value of government liabilities at the
first transaction.
A.8.7 Equity Equity represents the difference between assets and liabilities in a period. Further
disclosures of equity are presented in the Statement of Changes in Equity.
24
B. EXPLANATION ON POST BUDGET REALIZATION REPORT
The 2017 DIPA for ESP based on the source of income and type of expenditure is given
below:
2017 Budget Description Budget (Rp)
Acquisition of Financing:
Government of Indonesia
ADB Loan no.3455 INO: 29,597,189,000.00
a) DGWR 14,461,404,000.00
b) DGH 5,007,140,000.00
c) DGHS 10,128,645,000.00
Total Amount of Acquisition of Financing 29,597,189,000.00
EXPENDITURES:
Goods and Services Expenditure 13,547,189,000.00
a) DGWR 5,561,404,000.00
b) DGH 1,257,140,000.00
c) DGHS 6,728,645,000.00
Capital Expenditure 16,050,000,000.00
a) DGWR 8,900,000,000.00
b) DGH 3,750,000,000.00
c) DGHS 3,400,000,000.00
Social Expenditure
Total Expenditure 29,597,189,000.00
B.1 Operational Expenditure
The realization of ESP expenditures in 2017 is Rp14,009,342,920.00 or 47.33% of the
budget of Rp29,597,189,000.00. The details of the budget and the realization of expenditures in
2017 are as follows:
Details of Expenditure Estimation and Realization in 2017
Description
FY 2017 % of Budget
FY 2016
Budget (Rp) Realization (Rp) Realization (Rp)
Goods and Services Expenditure 13,547,189,000.00 6,628,644,620.00 48.93
a) DGWR 5,561,404,000.00 -
b) DGH 1,257,140,000.00 -
c) DGHS 6,728,645,000.00 6,628,644,620.00 98.51
Capital Expenditure 16,050,000,000.00 7,380,698,300.00 45.99
a) DGWR 8,900,000,000.00 4,880,698,300.00 54.84
25
Description
FY 2017 % of Budget
FY 2016
Budget (Rp) Realization (Rp) Realization (Rp)
b) DGH 3,750,000,000.00 2,500,000,000.00 66.67
c) DGHS 3,400,000,000.00
Total Expenditures 29,597,189,000.00 14,009,342,920.00 47.33
The realization in FY 2017 Expenditures increased by 100% compared to actual
expenditure in the previous year.
B.1.1 Goods and Services Expenditure
The goods and services expenditure is used for the shopping/expenditure of Project
Management Consultants (PMC). According to the loan agreement of ADB No. 3455-INO there
is a separate expenditure category for consultant services, whereas this is used for PMC. The
amount of Goods and Services Expenditure for 2017 is Rp6,628,644,620.00.
�
B.2 Capital Expenditure
Actual capital expenditures for FY 2017 and FY 2016 are Rp1,308,232,120.00 and
Rp0.00, respectively. Capital expenditures represent budgetary expenditures for Consultant
Expenditure whose costs should be capitalized into the intangible assets because the consultant
work that is preparation of DED, LARAP, and FS can be categorized as intangible assets as
they can be used for more than one year after completion.
Capital expenditure realization in FY 2017 is increased by 100% compared to FY 2016
due to the start of procurement consultants in 2017.
Comparison of the Capital Expenditures of 2017 and 2016:
• Payment for Capital Expenditure for Machinery Equipment with a total or
Rp7,380,698,300.00 which is comprised of:
a. A payment total of Rp1,308,232,120.00 for Milestone 1 for Project
Preparation of the consultants for DED, LARAP, Feasibility Study and
Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA or better known as AMDAL) for
Jragung Multi-purpose Dam awarded to PT Indra Karya Persero, for the
payment of the Inception Report and cost of consultant for preparation of
making DED, FS, LARAP and AMDAL must be capitalized to Intangible
Assets in Progress. The comparison of Capital Expenditures for Intangible
Assets for FY 2017 and 2016 is given as follows.
26
Description Realization FY 2017 Realization FY2016 Increase/ (Decrease)
Capital Expenditure (Intangible Assets in Progress) 1,308,232,120.00 0 100%
Amount 1,308,232,120.00 0 100%
b. A payment total of Rp3,572,466,180.00 as advance payment for activities in
PIU 3 Center of Dams, DGWR, MPWH.
c. A payment total of Rp2,500,000,000.00 as advance payment for
Administration Assistance and Implementation of the Management of
International Loan and Grant, DGH, MPWH.
B.2.1 Capital Expenditures on Equipment and Machinery
Capital Expenditures on Office Equipment and Machinery for 2017 is as much as
Rp4,880,698,300.00. The Realization of Capital Expenditures for Machinery is
Rp1,308,232,120.00. Derived from the payment of consultants for the preparation and
establishment of DED, AMDAL, FS, and LARAP for Jragung Multipurpose Dam Project which
is won by Indra Karya Persero. The expenditures for preparation of DED, AMDAL, FS, and
LARAP will all be capitalized as Intangible Assets in Progress and the amortization will be
accounted for after the completion of each document.
As much as Rp3,572,466,180.00 is still in the form of advance payment, and is not
categorized as fixed assets. In the first term, the value of advance payment will decrease and
acquired as assets in progress. The comparison of the Realization of Capital Expenditures on
Equipment and Machinery for 2017 and 2016 is given in the following table.
Comparison of Equipment and Machine Realization in year 2017 and 2016
Description Realization in 2017
Realization in 2016
Increase/ (Decrease)
Advance Payment for Capital Expenditures of Office Equipment and Furniture
3,572,466,180.00 - 100%
Payment For Other Capital Expenditure 1,308,232,120.00
Capital Expenditures of Office Equipment and Furniture
4,880,698,300.00 - 100%
Return of Equipment and Furniture expenditure - - -
Total Expenditure 4,880,698,300.00 - 100%
27
B.2.2 Capital Expenditure on Roads, Irrigation and NetworksRealization Capital Expenditure for Road, Irrigation and Network Expenditures of FY
2017 and FY 2016 amounted to Rp2,500,000,000.00 and Rp0,00 respectively. The funds from
the loan can only be used for the procurement of consultants to establish DED, FS, LARAP, and
AMDAL. In the first term, the value of the advance payment will decrease and acquired as
assets in progress.
Comparison of Capital Expenditure of Irrigation and Network Roads Realization in year 2017 and 2016
Description Realization in 2017
Realization in 2016
Increase/ (Decrease)
Capital Expenditures of Office Equipment and Furniture
2,500,000.000.00 - 100%
Total Gross Capital Expenditure 2,500,000,000.00 - 100%
Return of Equipment and Furniture expenditure
- - -
Total Expenditure 2,500,000,000.00 - 100%
B.2.3 Other Capital Expenditures
Other Capital Expenditures are the expenditures that are not classified within the criteria
of capital expenditures for Land, Equipment and Machinery, Buildings, and Networks (Roads,
Irrigation, etc.). In the FY 2017, other capital expenditures according to the DIPA is
Rp500,000,000.00.
B.3 Acquisition of Financing
Realization of Acquisition of Financing for ESP for the period ending on December
31st 2017 is Rp14,009,342,920.00 or 47.33% of the total DIPA that is Rp29,597,189,000.00.
This realization is derived from the ADB loan for the PMC component in DGH and DGHS, and
the Project Preparation Consultant (PT Indra Karya) for the establishment of FS, DED,
AMDAL, and LARAP for the Jragung Multi-purpose Dam Project.
28
C. EXPLANATION OF BALANCE SHEETS
C.1 Current Assets
C.1.1 Advance Payment
Advance Payment Expenditures as of December 31, 2017 and 2016 amounted to
Rp12,701,110,800.00 and Rp 0.00 respectively. Advance Payment are rights that must still be
received after the balance sheet date as a result of the goods/services that have already been paid
in full but not yet received entirely. The details of Advance Payment are as follows:
Advance Payment Details on FY 2017 and 2016
Description 2017 2016
PT Smec International (PMC on Bina Marga/DGH) 2,500,000,000.00 -
PT. Indra Karya (Persero) DED Consultant for Jragung Multipurpose Dam Project on DGWR
3,572,466,180.00
-
PT Ciria Jasa (PMC on Cipta Karya/DGHS) 6,628,644,620.00 -
Total 12,701,110,800.00
C.2 Fixed Assets
C.2.1 Office Equipment and Furniture
The balance of office equipment and furniture as of December 31st, 2017 and 2016 is
Rp0.00 and Rp0.00. This is because the PMC have yet to establish any spending on the
procurement of office equipment nor furniture, although it has already been allocated in the
advance payment.
C.2.2 Buildings
Building values as of December 31st, 2017 and 2016 are Rp0.00 and Rp0.00. Within
ADB Loan No. 3455 INO, there is no allocation for the procurement of buildings.
C.2.3 Roads, Irrigation, and NetworksThe balance for Road, Irrigation and Networks as of December 31st, 2017 and 2016
amounted to Rp0.00 and Rp0.00 respectively, due to the fact that ADB loan no. 3455 did not
allocate any funds for physical procurement of road construction, irrigation and its network.
C.2.4 On-going Construction (KDP)
The balance for on-going construction as of December 31st, 2017 and 2016 amounted
to Rp0.00 and Rp0.00 respectively. Absence of On-going Construction is because there is no
allocation of funds for procurement of categories for physical procurement in building,
irrigation, dam and network in ADB Loan No. 3455 INO.
29
C.2.5 Accumulated Depreciation of Fixed Assets
The accumulated depreciation balance of fixed assets as of December 31st, 2017 and
2016 amounted to Rp0.00 and Rp0.00 respectively. Accumulated Depreciation of Fixed Assets
is a systematic allocation of the value of a fixed asset depreciated over the useful life of the
asset except for Land and On-going Construction. Details of the Accumulated Depreciation of
Fixed Assets as of December 31st, 2017 are as follows:
Details of Accumulated Depreciation of Fixed Assets FY 2017 and 2016
No Fixed Assets Acquisition Value Accumulated Depreciation Book Value
1 Equipment and Machinery - - -
2 Building - - -
3 Road, Irrigation & Network - - -
4 Other fixed assets - - -
Accumulated Depreciation - - -
C.3 Other Fixed Assets
C.3.1 Intangible Assets
Intangible assets are identifiable and owned assets, but have no physical form. The
balance of Intangible Assets (ATB) as of December 31st, 2017 and December 31st, 2016 are
both Rp0.00.
C.3.2 Intangible Assets in Progress
Intangible Assets in Progress within ESP are attained from implementation progress by
PT Indra Karya (Persero) Consultants that is the establishment of DED, FS,AMDAL, and
LARAP of Jragung Multipurpose Dam Project. The transactions and cash flow on Intangible
Assets at the reporting date is as follows:
Balance Acquisition Price per December 31st, 2016 0
Added Mutation :
Purchasing Rp1,308,232,120.00
Decreasing Mutation :
Balance per December 31st, 2017 Rp1,308,232,120.00
Accumulated Depreciation until December 31st, 2017 0
Book Value per December 31, 2017 Rp1,308,232,120.00
Mutation added: Payment of Milestone 1 for Inception Report of PT Indra Karya
(Persero) Consultant firm for Preparation of Jragung Multipurpose Dam Project worth
Rp1,308,232,120.00.
30
C.3.3 Accumulated Depreciation and Amortization of Intangible Assets
The accumulated balance of other asset depreciation as of December 31st, 2017 and
2016 is Rp0.00 and Rp0.00 respectively. The intangible assets that are derived from the
procurement process of DED, AMDAL, LARAP, Feasibility Study for the development of
Multipurpose Dam has not been amortized because it is still under progress and will be
amortized only after the completion of the contract. Accumulated Depreciation of Other Assets
is the counter of other Asset Accounts which are presented based on the accumulated value
adjustment in relation to the decrease in capacity and benefits of Other Assets. Details of
Accumulated Depreciation of Intangible Assets as of December 31, 2017 are as follows:
Details of Accumulated Depreciation and Amortization of Other Intangible Asset
Fixed Assets
Price Acquisition
Accumulated Depreciation/ Amortization
Book Value
Other Assets:
DED, LARAP, FS, AMDAL Rp1,308,232,120.00 0 Rp1,308,232,120.00
Total Rp1,308,232,120.00 0 Rp1,308,232,120.00
The amortization of ATB with a limited useful life is done using the straight-line
method and the residual value of zero. While for ATB with unlimited period of service,
amortization is not needed.
C.4 Short-term Liabilities
The Value of Debt to Third Parties as of December 31st, 2017 and 2016 amounts to
Rp0.00 and Rp0.00respectively. Debt to Third Parties is an outstanding liability and will be
settled to other third parties in less than 12 (twelve months) from the date of reporting.
C.5 Equity
Equity as of December 31st, 2017 and 2016 amounted to Rp14,009,342,920.00 and
Rp0.00 respectively. Equity is the net worth of an entity which is the difference between assets
and liabilities. More details on equity are presented in the Statement of Changes in Equity.
31
D. CEXPLANATION OF OPERATIONAL REPORT POST
D.1 Non-Tax State Revenue
Revenues as of December 31st, 2017 and 2016 amounted to Rp0.00 and Rp0.00. No
operational expense has been incurred since it is still an advance payment for the PMC
consultant and for the payment for PT Indra Karya (Persero) for milestone 1 which is the
implementation of the AMDAL, DED and LARAP preparations for Jragung Multipurpose Dam
Project which are now up to the Inception Reports phase, which will be capitalized as intangible
assets in progress.
D.2 Employee Expenses
Total Employee Expenses in 2017 and 2016 amounted to Rp0.00 and Rp0.00
respectively. Employee Expenses are the expense of compensation, in the form of money or
goods stipulated under the laws and regulations granted to state officials, Civil Servants (PNS),
and Non Civil Servant employees. There is no salary expense for civil servants because no part
of this ADB loan nor are there counterpart funding from the Indonesian government for civil
servant salary payments within ESP.
D.3 Inventory Expenses
Total Inventories Expense in 2017 and 2016 amounted to Rp0.00 and Rp0.00
respectively. Inventory Expense is used to record consumption of consumables, including both
marketed and non-marketed products. No amount of fund from this ADB loan is allocated for
the purchase of inventory, since loan funds are allocated only for consultancy of DED, LARAP,
AMDAL Feasibility study, purchasing office equipment and furniture and related expenses to
conduct training by the Project Management Consultant.
D.4 Depreciation and Amortization Expense
Total Depreciation and Amortization Expenses for the years 2017 and 2016 amounted
to Rp0.00 and Rp0.00 respectively. Depreciation Expense is an expense to record the systematic
allocation of the value of a depreciable asset over the useful life of the asset. Meanwhile
Amortization Expense is used to record the allocation of decreased economic benefits for
Intangible Assets. For 2017, the ADB loan gives no allocation of funds for the physical
procurement of buildings, roads, bridges and dams so there is no depreciation cost for such
tangible fixed assets. Amortization of intangible assets has not been made since it is still in the
32
process of making DED, FS, AMDAL, and LARAP analysis by consultant and not yet
completed in terms of the contract by both time and result.
33
E. EXPLANATION OF STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN EQUITY
E.1 Initial Equity
The value of shareholders' equity, that is the Government of Indonesia, as of January 1st
2017 is Rp0.00, even though the effective date of the ADB loan no. 3455-INO is December
24th, 2016.
E.2 Transactions between Entities
The value of transactions between entities correlates to the disbursement of ADB loan
no. 3455-INO, that is Rp14,009,342,920.00.
E.3 Surplus (Deficit) LO
Total Surplus as of December 31st 2017 is Rp0.00.
E.4 Final Equity
Value of Equity as of December 31st 2017 is Rp14,009,342,920.00.
BPK Audit Report on Opinion - Financial Statements of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO Year 2017 34
OVERVIEW OF THE AUDIT
1. Audit Legal Basis
a. Law Number 15 of 2004 regarding State Financial Management and Accountability Audit;
b. Law Number 15 of 2006 regarding Audit Board;
c. Loan Agreement of Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery through Better Engineering Services Project (AIDBES) Project between Republic of Indonesia and Asian Development Bank (ADB) No. 3455-INO Article IV (Particular Covenants) section 4.05 (a).
2. Audit Objectives
The Audit on the Financial Statements of AIDBES/ESP is conducted to express opinion on the Consolidated Financial Statements of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO as of December 31, 2017. In accordance with the Loan Agreement of Accelerating Infrastructure Delivery through Better Engineering Services Project (AIDBES/ESP) between the Republic of Indonesia and ADB Section 4.05.(a), which states, among other things, that the audit to express an opinion shall be performed by taking into account the following matters:
a. Assessment of the internal control system and its compliance with the government accounting standards in relation to the expenditures and other transactions;
b. Assessment of the adequacy of evidences supporting the implementation of funds disbursement procedures; and
c. Assessment of the compliance of project implementation with the loan agreement and the provisions set forth in the Loan Agreement and other applicable regulations.
3. Audit Target
Target of the audit is the Financial Statements of AIDBES/ESP ended as of December 31, 2017, including the overall implementation of AIDBES activities, such as the source and use of funds by the Secretariat General of the Ministry of Public Works and Public Housing as Executing Agency (EA), supported by the following implementing organizations:
a. Steering Committee, chaired by the Secretary General, with the committee members comprising of the Director General of Water Resources, Director General of Highways, Director General of Human Settlements, and Director General of Construction Development;
b. Project Coordination Office (PCO) is a coordination team under the Secretariat General;
c. Project Management Office (PMO) comprising of Directorate General of Water Resources (SDA), Directorate General of Highways, and Directorate General of Human Settlements; and
d. Project Implementation Unit (PIU) comprising of the relevant technical/central directorates.
BPK Audit Report on Opinion - Financial Statements of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO Year 2017 35
4. Audit Standards
Regulation of BPK RI Number 1 of 2007 regarding State Finance Auditing Standards (SPKN).
5. Audit Method
The audit on the Financial Statements of AIDBES/ESP as of December 31, 2017 has been performed with the following approaches:
a. Risk Approach
The methodology applied in the performance of the audit on the Financial Statements of AIDBES/ESP Year 2017 is the risk approach, based on comprehension and testing of the effectiveness of internal control system for the preparation of Financial Statements.
The results of such a comprehension and testing will determine the reliability level of management assertion and implementation of the applicable policies, plans and procedures.
The audit risk that is determined simultaneously with the reliability level of risk control (control risk) and the inherency level (inherent risk) of the entity to be audited can be used as a reference in determining the expected detection risk and number of tests to be conducted as well as in determining the focus of the audit.
b. Materiality
The materiality level in the overall financial statements is determined at 3.13% of the FY 2017 expenditure realization. The aforementioned materiality standard shall not applicable to any deviations containing the elements of collusion, corruption and nepotism (KKN) as well as any violations of law.
c. Audit Sampling
This audit is conducted by means of sample testing on the transactions within the population to be tested. The conclusions of the audit will be obtained based on the sampling results to be used as the basis for describing the conditions of the population. In this audit, the auditors determine the extent of samples based on the results of risk assessment which has been performed with due observance of the adequacy of number of samples selected both in terms of rupiah amount and the transaction type.
6. Audit Period
The audit was conducted for 20 days as from April 24, 2018 up to May 22, 2018 based on the Assignment Letter from BPK RI Number 25/ST/VI/04/2018 dated April 6, 2018.
7. Audit Objects
The audit was conducted on the Financial Statements of AIDBES/ESP Year 2017 in the form of Consolidated Financial Statements for the year ended as of December 31, 2017.
8. Audit Limitations
All information presented in the financial statements is the responsibility of the management. Therefore, BPK is not responsible for misinterpretation and possible effects of the omission of information either intentionally or unintentionally by the management.
BPK Audit Report on Opinion - Financial Statements of ADB Loan No. 3455-INO Year 2017 36
An audit by BPK includes procedures designed for providing reasonable assurance in detecting any errors and misrepresentations that materially affect the financial statements. An audit by BPK is not aimed at finding errors and irregularities. However, if any irregularities are found in the audit, they will be disclosed.
In conducting the audit, BPK also recognizes the possible existence of any unlawful acts. However, the audit by BPK provides no assurance that all unlawful acts will be detected and gives only reasonable assurance that the unlawful acts, which directly and materially affect the amounts stated in the financial statements, will be detected. BPK will inform about any possible unlawful acts or material errors/deviations found during the course of the audit.
In carrying out a testing of compliance with statutory regulations, BPK only tests compliance of the agency with the statutory regulations directly related to the preparation of the financial statements. This does not rule out the possibility that there is still unidentified non-compliance with the regulations.
AUDIT BOARD OF
THE REPUBLIC OF INDONESIA