1
HCCA Delaware ValleyJune 6, 2014
Robert F. Bacon, MHA
AVP & Billing Compliance Officer
Audits, Appeals &
Other Emerging Compliance Risks
Disclaimer
• Opinions expressed are my own and do
not represent any guarantees,
warranties or endorsements by the
University of Pennsylvania or its
Trustees
o Emerging issues in the field of
Billing Compliance
oGovernment Audits
oConsumer awareness & media
o 2 Midnight Rule
Course Objectives
2
• Penn Medicine offers comprehensive clinical services throughout the greater Philadelphia region
• Practice Plans
– Clinical Practices of the University of Pennsylvania
– Clinical Care Associates
• Hospitals
– Chester County Hospital
– Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania (the nation's first teaching hospital)
– PENN Presbyterian Medical Center
– Pennsylvania Hospital (the nation's first hospital)
– Penn Medicine at Rittenhouse
• Home Care & Hospice Services
– PENN Care at Home / PENN Home Infusion Therapy
– Wissahickon Hospice
From the beginning…Medicare 1965
And how things have changed…… Medicare 2014
3
7777
Regulatory Environment
� Federal & State Authorities
� Office of the Inspector General
� Department of Justice
� Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
� Office of the State Attorney General
� Federal False Claims Act
� Pennsylvania False Claims Act
� Anti-Kickback Statute
� Beneficiary Inducement Law
� “Stark” law: Physician self-referral law
� UPHS Policy #03-03 “Fraud, Waste and Abuse”
Pace of Change with Post Payment
Audits Continues to Accelerate
Who What
RAs Recovery Auditors
MACs Medicare Administrative Contractors
PSCs Program Safeguard Contractors
ZPICs Zone Program Integrity Contractors
CERT Comprehensive Error Rate Testing
MIP Medicaid Integrity Plan
MIG CMS Medicaid Integrity Group
MICs Medicaid Integrity Contractors
MIGs Medicaid Inspector Generals
PERM Payment Error Rate Measurement
OIG Office of Inspector General
DOJ Department of Justice
FBI Federal Bureau of Investigation
9999
Who can access the Medical Record
Medical Record
Physicians & Other Medical
Staff
Internal Auditing
Government Payers
Legal Personnel
Patients & Families
4
10101010
Proposed RA Transition
Current Contractors
Performant
Recovery
CGI Federal, Inc.
Connolly, Inc.
Health Data Insights, Inc.
Pennsylvania New Jersey DE, MD, DC
Skewed Audit Sampling
by Recovery Auditors
• Effective 8/5/13, record limit revised
– 70% of claim types such as inpatient
• Medical record limitation of 2% remains
– 160,000 x 2% = 3,200/year (max records)
– 2,240 limit per claim type (e.g. 70% Acute I/P)
– Inpatient fee-for-service admissions of
8,000/year (5.5% of total claims population)
28% of annual admissions in audit
Electronic Medical Record
• All rules apply
– No different than
paper
• Integrity
– Do not share sign-
on and password
• Complete, accurate,
timely
– Audit trail
5
Health Care Fraud Prevention &
Enforcement Action Team (HEAT)
• Joint Medicare Fraud Strike Force
– Department of Justice, HHS/OIG & CMS
• Mission
– Help prevent waste, fraud & abuse
– Reduce cost & improve quality of care
Source of Improper Payments
• Medically Unnecessary Services
• Incorrectly Coded Services
• Duplicate Payments
• No Documentation
• Outdated Fee Schedules
• Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP)
Defense Strategies
• Ability to mange medical record request is
vital
• Ability to manage and track audit and
related appeals
– Timely filing
• Unfavorable findings attributable to medical
necessity
– InterQual guideline (for discharges prior to
10/1/13)
– Literature to support
6
"Your board of directors locked themselves in rehab with
compliance fatigue."
17171717
Medicare Appeal Process – 5 Levels
� Redetermination – Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC)
• 120 days to file
• 60 days for decision
� Reconsideration – QIC (Qualified Independent Contractors)
• 180 days to file
• 60 days for decision
� Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) hearing
• 60 days to file – minimum $ amount in controversy
• 90 days for decision
� Department Appeals Board
� Federal District Court – Judicial review
Preparing for Audits
• Assume ALJ hearings for all appeals and prepare files accordingly
• Submit copies of supporting documentation beyond medical records
– Coding clinics
– Applicable Federal or local regulations
– Professional literature to include morbidity & mortality data
7
View from the Trenches
• Providers must have aggressive appeal
strategies
• Prepare appeals with expectation of ALJ
hearings
• Consider external assistance with appeal
expertise & proven success rates
– Executive Health Resources (EHR)
Emerging Compliance Risk Considerations
• Implications of data mining
– “Pay and chase” is yesterday’s news
– Common work file
– Government audits predicated upon results of
data mining
– Requirement for providers to self audit with
presumption that all reported data is incorrect
OIG Audits -
Material Change In Approach
• Former Secretary Sebelius – Review and
enforce current policies (e.g. credits for
devices)
• Audit sample based upon data mining
• Significant increase in sample size with
presumption of error
• Requirement to “self audit” and complete
work sheets provided by the OIG
8
Emerging Compliance Risk Considerations
• CMS approved Region C Recovery Auditor (RA)
Connolly to begin conducting audits of coding for
E&M services in physician offices
– Specifically, CPT code 99215
• Permitted to extrapolate findings based on a statistical
sample of such claims
• Likely to be approved in other Medicare regions in the
near future
Public Awareness
• Consumer
awareness &
media attention
•Reputational risk
•Justification of
charges
•Accurate CDM
View from the Trenches
• Substantial increase in operating costs to manage
audits and related appeals
• Hospitals must incorporate monitoring activity
with benchmarking data
– Risk avoidance
– Identification of opportunities
• Consider in your annual audit plan
9
Time for a change?
• Has audit program become “same old; same old”?
• Have audit results stagnated?
• Does audit program demonstrate value added to
the organization?
• Do audit results change behavior?
It may be time to assess your program!
Value Added Auditing
• Audit sample
– Is audit population timely & reflective of current operations?
• Accurate & timely communications
• Audit findings
– Report unfavorable findings & opportunities
– Explain why in addition to what
– Management must recognize service orientation
Value Added Auditing
• Recommendations
– Results must be timely
– Use audit results to make a difference
– Improve performance & efficiency
– Identify causation (I.e. go beyond identification of discrepant data)
– Offer management a “road map” to correct issues
10
Implement Monitoring, Auditing & Reporting
Systems
• Cost vs. Benefits
– 80/20 rule
• Select appropriate data to monitor
– Organizational risk
– Establishment of benchmarks
– Ability to change based upon identified
discrepancies
Implement Monitoring, Auditing & Reporting
Systems
� Concurrent vs. Retrospective Reviews
– Ability to access data (e.g. dictated notes & reports)
– Time requirement to complete audit to include holding claims
– Correct claims prior to submission
– Auditees ability to over-ride findings
– Refund policy for retrospective reviews
Audit Sampling
• Regular & periodic compliance reviews
– Sample size & tolerable error rate
• Types of testing
– Trend analysis
– Transaction testing
• Documentation and related billing
• Requisition forms
– Interviews
11
View from the Trenches
Hospital Audit Programs
� Inpatient programs must consider:
– High Risk DRGs
• MCC & CC’s supported by only 1 diagnosis
– One Day Stays
– Post Acute Care Transfers
– Clinical coding denials – loss of cc or mcc
� Use of claim editor systems
DRG Audit Program
• Minimize risk to organization
• Review of OIG targeted DRG’s/DRG Pairs
• Discharge disposition status
Practical Considerations & Key Decision
Points
• Are the findings related to coding or medical
necessity?
• File an appeal?
– Stop recoupment?
• Financial risk associated with interest
(10.875%)
– Probability of favorable outcome?
• File appeals with expectation of ALJ hearing
12
Practical Considerations & Key Decision
Points
• Extrapolations
– Integrity & validity of statistical sample
– What is the population subject to the
extrapolation?
– Need for external consultant?
AMC Audit Challenges
• “Cutting Edge” of medicine
– Introduction of new procedures &/or techniques that do not agree with CPT code descriptions (e.g. approach using arthroscopy versus open fashion as described in CPT)
– Use of unlisted codes
• Technological advances in medicine
– Extended timeframe for development of new codes
AMC Audit Challenges
• Tertiary/quaternary care institutes
– Patient acuity
• Teaching Physician New Rules (TPNR)
– Required attestation & tethering language
– Service fully documented by resident but
insufficient documentation by teaching
physician (e.g. demonstrate participation &
management)
13
Development of Hospital Appeal Departments
• Predict appeals departments equal in size to
compliance departments
• Require expertise of coders and clinical
staff/utilization management with access to
physicians
Use of Appeal Templates
• Required data elements
• Allegations
• Medicare requirements
• Clinical summary
• Rebuttal of each allegation
– Page references
Timely Data/Reporting
• Trending analysis
• Implications for financial reporting
• Establishing sufficient reserves
14
Practical Considerations & Key Decision
Points
• Are the findings related to coding or medical
necessity?
• File an appeal?
– Stop recoupment?
• Financial risk associated with interest
(~11%)
– Probability of favorable outcome?
• File appeals with expectation of ALJ hearing
To Pay or Not to Pay – Stop Recoupment
Dollars
($)High Medium Low
High Yes ? No
Medium Yes ? No
Low Yes ? No
← Probability of Recovery on Appeal →
Practical Considerations & Key Decision
Points
• Extrapolations
– Integrity & validity of statistical sample
– What is the population subject to the
extrapolation?
– Need for external consultant?
15
AMC Audit Challenges
• “Cutting Edge” of medicine
– Introduction of new procedures &/or techniques that do not agree with CPT code descriptions (e.g. approach using arthroscopy versus open fashion as described in CPT)
– Use of unlisted codes
• Technological advances in medicine
– Extended timeframe for development of new codes
AMC Audit Challenges
• Tertiary/quaternary care institutes
– Patient acuity
• Teaching Physician New Rules (TPNR)
– Required attestation & tethering language
– Service fully documented by resident but
insufficient documentation by teaching
physician (e.g. demonstrate participation &
management)
Development of Hospital Appeal Departments
• Predict appeals departments equal in size to
compliance departments
• Require expertise of coders and clinical
staff/utilization management with access to
physicians
16
2014 IPPS Final Rule
2 Midnight Rule
NEW
Material Changes in Admission Criteria
� Changes effective October 1, 2013
� 24 hour benchmark no longer applies
� Level of care and patient risk factors to include
comorbidities does not determine cause for admission
� Newly created time based admission guideline
� Generally appropriate for inpatient Part A stay if
patient-beneficiary crosses 2 midnights
� MAC ‘Probe’ audits currently being performed
2 Midnight Rule
� Physician expects patient-beneficiary to remain in the hospital
crossing at least 2 midnights
� Transfers: time spent in the sending hospital counts towards the
2 MN rule
� Outpatient if less than 2 midnights
� Exceptions
� Procedures listed as OPPS inpatient only;
� Patient expires; or,
� Patient transferred to another acute facility
� New guideline is consistent with CMS’s application of Medicare
utilization days
� Based upon number of midnights crossed
17
IPPS: Inpatient Prospective Payment System
2 Midnight Rule
� Admission order must be present in the medical record
� Order must be placed at or before time of admission
� Order must be evaluated in the context of the evidence in the medical record
o Supported by admission & subsequent progress notes
� Physician must certify need for inpatient stay
� Must be signed and documented in medical record prior to discharge
� Guidelines regarding content forthcoming
� Recertify as of day 12 of admission, day 30, and every 30 days thereafter
Actual clinical notes on patient charts:
10. Patient complains of chest pain if she
lies on her left side for over a year
9. On the second day, the knee was better on
the third day it completely disappeared
8. The patient has no history of suicides
7. Patient has two teenage children, but no
other abnormalities
Actual clinical notes on patient charts:
6. Discharge status: alive but without permission
5. Rectal exam revealed a normal size thyroid
4. Patient states she had been constipated for
most of her life, until she got a divorce
3. The patient was in his usual state of geed health
until his airplane ran out of gas and crashed
2. Patient expired on the floor uneventfully