. ' Michael P. Lawrence [ISB No. 7288] Jack W. Relf [ISB No. 9762] GIVENS PURSLEY LLP 601 West Bannock Street P.O. Box 2720 Boise, Idaho 83701-2720 Office: (208) 388-1200 Fax: (208) 388-1300 www .givenspursley.com Attorneys for Gordon Sylte, Susan Goodrich, John Sylte, and Sylte Ranch Limited Liability Company BEFORE THE DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES OF THE STATE OF IDAHO IN THE MATTER OF SYLTE'S PETITION FOR DECLARATORY RULING RE DISTRIBUTION OF WATER TO WATER RIGHT NO. 95-0734 State of Idaho ) ) ss. County of Ada ) Docket No. P-DR-2017-001 SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL P. LA WREN CE RECEIVED AUG 2 2 2017 DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOUF.CC3 MICHAEL P. LAWRENCE , being first duly sworn upon oath, deposes and states: 1. I am over the age of eighteen and I make this Affidavit based upon my personal knowledge. 2. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the state of Idaho. 3. I am a partner in the firm of Givens Pursley LLP, which represents Gordon Sylte, Susan Goodrich, John Sylte, and Sylte Ranch Limited Liability Company in the above-captioned action. 4. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of an Idaho Department of Water Resources ("Department") adjudication recommended water right report for water right no. 95-0876, which was obtained from the Department's website. SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL P. LAWRENCE - 1 13461-4_13851487_4.doc
Transcript
. '
Michael P. Lawrence [ISB No. 7288] Jack W. Relf [ISB No. 9762] GIVENS PURSLEY LLP 601 West Bannock Street P.O. Box 2720 Boise, Idaho 83701-2720 Office: (208) 388-1200 Fax: (208) 388-1300 www .givenspursley.com Attorneys for Gordon Sylte, Susan Goodrich, John Sylte, and Sylte Ranch Limited Liability Company
BEFORE THE DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES
OF THE STATE OF IDAHO
IN THE MATTER OF SYLTE'S PETITION FOR DECLARATORY RULING RE DISTRIBUTION OF WATER TO WATER RIGHT NO. 95-0734
State of Idaho ) ) ss.
County of Ada )
Docket No. P-DR-2017-001
SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL P. LA WREN CE
RECEIVED
AUG 2 2 2017 DEPARTMENT OF
WATER RESOUF.CC3
MICHAEL P. LAWRENCE , being first duly sworn upon oath, deposes and states:
1. I am over the age of eighteen and I make this Affidavit based upon my personal
knowledge.
2. I am an attorney licensed to practice law in the state of Idaho.
3. I am a partner in the firm of Givens Pursley LLP, which represents Gordon Sylte,
Susan Goodrich, John Sylte, and Sylte Ranch Limited Liability Company in the above-captioned
action.
4. Attached hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of an Idaho Department of
Water Resources ("Department") adjudication recommended water right report for water right
no. 95-0876, which was obtained from the Department's website.
SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL P. LAWRENCE - 1 13461-4_13851487 _ 4.doc
5. Attached hereto as Exhibit Bis a true and correct copy of the November 5, 2013
Notice of Change in Water Right Ownership filed with the Department by Colby A. Clark and
Kathryne Clark, which was obtained from the Department's files.
6. Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of a Warranty Deed
executed July 13, 2017, and recorded on July 14, 2017 in the real property records of Kootenai
County, Idaho, as instrument no. 2602733000, conveying real property in Kootenai County from
Colby A. Clark and Kathryne Clark to Karin L. Walker and Martin R. Walker, as obtained from
the Kootenai County Recorder's Office.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Respectfully submitted this 22d day of August, 2017.
GIVENS PURSLEY LLP
Michael P. Lawrence Attorneys for Gordon Sy/le, Susan Goodrich, John Sy/te, and Sylte Ranch Limited Liability Company
Subscribed and sworn to before me this z;z,~fil.y of August, 2017.
~ -½~ NbtJ>ublic ti r Idahp Residing at: -h~~~~~------My Commission Expires: 4
SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL P. LAWRENCE - 2 13461-4_13851487 _ 4.doc
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on this 22d day of August, 2017, I caused to be filed and served a
true and correct copy of the foregoing by the method indicated below, and addressed to the following1:
DOCUMENT FILED:
Shelley Keen, Hearing Officer, D ~ D D ~
Idaho Department of Water Resources 322 East Front Street P.O. Box 83720 Boise, ID 83 720-0098
Norman M. Semanko Parsons Behle & Latimer 800 W. Main Street, Suite 1300 Boise, ID 83 702
Alice, Mary A. Anderson, Mary F Anderson, Mary F et al Andrews, Debra Andrews, John Bafus, Matthew A. Benage, Charles and Ruth Chetlain Jr., Arthur Clarence & Kurt Geiger Families Clark, Kathy Collins, Mary K./Bosch Properties Cozzetto, Sandra Crosby, Wes Curb, James
Freije, Joan Hatrock, Amber Herr, Barbara Hilliard, Wendy & James Hogan, Pat & Denise Holmes, Steven & Elizabeth Houkam, Leif Jayne, Donald Jayne, Douglas I & Bertha Mary Kiefer, Terry Knowles, Michael K.remin, Adam Kuhn, Robert Lacroix, Rene Lake-Ommen, Joan
U.S. Mail Hand Delivered Overnight Mail Facsimile E-mail
Nipp, David R. Nooney, John Rodgers, Steve & Pam Roth, Kimberli Schafer, David & Lori Schultz, Darwin R. Seaburg, Molly Sunday, Hal TCRVLLC Twin Echo Resort Twin Lakes Improvement Assoc. Upper Twin Lakes, LLC Van Zandt, Rick & Corrinne WeUer, Gerald J.
De Vitis, Maureen Ellis, Don
Larry D & Janice A Faris Living Trust LaLiberte, Terry
Wilson, Bruce & Jamie Ziuchkovski, Dave
Ellis, Susan Erickson, Scott
Miller, Patrick E. Minatre, William H Murray, Angela
1 The certificate of service is taken from the Order Regarding Certificate of Service, issued July 20, 2017, by the Hearing Officer. Mr. Semanko's address and information has been updated to reflect his Notice of Firm Name and Address Change dated August 16, 2017. Also, as requested by Mr. Michael C. Dempsey and as indicated on his June 22, 2017 Form Required by May 26, 20 I 7, Order, email is included as a method of service for Estate of Carmela G. Dempsey and Curran D. Dempsey Disclaimer Trust.
SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL P. LAWRENCE - 3 l 346 l-4 _ 13851487 _ 4.doc
Clark, Colby 30701 N. Clagstone Road Athol, ID 8380 I
Estate of Carmela G. Dempsey and Curran D. Dempsey Disclaimer Trust 3224 S. Whipple Road Spokane Valley, WA 99206-6310 [email protected][email protected]
SECOND AFFIDAVIT OF MICHAEL P. LAWRENCE - 4 I 346 l-4_13851487 _ 4.doc
8/22/2017
I Close I IDAHO DEPARTMENT OF WATER RESOURCES Adjudication Recommended Right Report
8/22/2017
WATER RIGHT NO. 95-876
Owner lype Name and Address Current Owner COLBY A CLARK Current Owner KATHRYNE CLARK
9836 W TWIN LAKES RD RATHDRUM, ID 83858 2082776822
Original Owner CAROLEE KELLY 9836 W TWIMLAKES RD RATHDRUM, ID 83858 2086873526
Original Owner WILLIAM KELLY 9836 W TWIN LAKES RD RATHDRUM, ID 83858 2086873526
Priority Date: 05/01/1890 Basis: Decreed Status: Active
Source I Tributary TWIN LAKES RATHDRUM CREEK
Beneficial Use From To Diversion Rate Volume DOMESTIC 01/01 12/31 0.04 CFS 1.2 AFA Total Diversion 0.04 CFS
Location of Point(s) of Diversion:
Water Right Report
TWIN LAKES jNESW Lt 31sec. 36!Township 53N!Range 05W!KOOTENAI County
EXHIBIT
I A http://www.idwr.idaho.gov/apps/ExtSearch/RightReportAJ.asp?BasinNumber=95&SequenceNumber=876&SplitSuffix=%20o/o20&TypewrAdjudicationR. .. 1/2
8/22/2017 Water Right Report
Place(s) of use:
Place of Use Legal Description: DOMESTIC KOOTENAI County
Conditions of Approval:
This partial decree is subject to such general provisions necessary for the definition of the rights or for 1. C 18 the efficient administration of the water rights as may be ultimately determined by the Court at a point in
time no later than the entry of a final unified decree. Section 42-1412(6), Idaho Code. 2. N13 The quantity of water under this right shall not exceed 13,000 gallons per day. 3. XOI Domestic use is for 1 home. 4. PIN Parcel No. 045400000020 5. JOI Property is also known as Lot 2, Lake Park.
This right originated as all or part of Right No. 95-0876 in the Final Decree, In the Matter of the General 6. TLI Determination of the Rights to the Use of the Surface Waters of Twin Lakes, Including Tributaries and
Outlets, Case No. 32572 (1st Jud. Dist. Ct. April 20, 1989).
Dates:
Other Information: State or Federal: Owner Name Connector: Water District Number: Generic Max Rate per Acre: Generic Max Volume per Acre: Swan Falls Trust or Nontrust: Swan Falls Dismissed: OLE Act Number: Cary Act Number: Mitigation Plan: False I Close I
1. List the numbers of all water rights and/or adjudication claim records to be changed. If you only acquired a portion of the water right or adjudication claim, check "Yes" in the "Split?" column.
Water Right/Claim No. Split? Water Right/Claim No. Split? Water Right/Claim No. Split?
lf->-fs7~ Yes D Yes D Yes D
Yes D Yes D Yes D
Yes D Yes D Yes D
Yes D Yes D Yes D
Yes D Yes D Yes 0
2. Previous Owner's Name: Name of current water right holder/claimant
3. New Owner(s)/Claimant(s):
New owner continued Name connector D and D or D and/or N ~~ 9~3Co w.,vJ10 LAKe..s "S<. 1
Stale ZIP
Telephone \'( o.± 'Fhc K.e..C' 1@ eJY'o.,, L , li;crJ
Email ,,
4. If the water rights and/or adjudication claims were split, how did the division occur?
D The water rights or claims were divided as specifically identified in a deed, contract, or other conveyance document. D The water rights or claims were divided proportionately based on the portion of their place(s) of use acquired by the
new owner.
5. Date you acquired the water rights and/or claims listed above: IO - 3.l - .) D \3
6. This form must be signed and submitted with the following REQUIRED items:
• A copy of the conveyance document - warranty deed, quitclaim deed, court decree, contract of sale, etc. The conveyance document must include a legal description of the property or description of the water right(s) if no land is conveyed.
• Plat map, survey map or aerial photograph which clearly shows the place of use and point of diversion for each water right and/or claim listed above (if necessary to clarify division of water rights or complex property descriptions).
• Filing fee (see instructions for further explanation):
e $25 per undivided water right. o $100 per split water right. o No fee is required for pending adjudication claims.
I , 7. Signature:
Signature:
For IDWR Office Use Only:
Receipted by N8t£ud t ,.o 01 Date 11 -05 -t?, Approved by CU ~ Processed by W
~nrm 41-1411/41-14n<ar,:;1 R"u n7/1n
Title, if applicable
Title, if applicable
\lo~J Receipt No. ::::Nf>;'.'>020\
Date II/~ /i 3
\ \ ..... S- .:>OI) Date
\ 1. - s;-- d -ol) Date
\/oil Receipt AmlJ" 2[ i .(1)
EXHIBIT
6
· Full Screen Image Viewer
Rl;"CO~IUNG ltEQU1!$TW IV F1r5t Arl1Qllf(1KJ Tittii CJmpamf
AJm WJf!lt R!.CORD!D ,U,Jl.. TO: l'lrJt" ArliertGn 11tle Co,npiM!f 1 &(i6 rtu11h ~l'J!h'O:ld L>rlWt l"M:&Jr (tMH11~, ID 8lll14
THIS IS CERTIFIED TO BE A rnu!: AND EXACT COPY OF
-:-HE ORIGj!)IAL 7,_ &,,t,·1-__
WARRANTY DEED
Rn Va\ll! Rl!Cet~ci:l, WP~1m l, 1{4il'( ancl-~Nllae J, K911r, 'husband ,,mat wife, h!t~nRM c;illod u,11 Gr~r#.r, hllfQbf granli, ba1geh11, i$ ;llfl!f CWIV'fl "~ Colby A. Clarlc and' Kathryne Chlrk,, hus~d and wtfD,, herol.n.lfuir tetecJ \tie G111ntee, wt~" ~t Dlklrmis li 11136 w~ l'Vdn Laka Road, R11tttlfrum, ID 8311&, tlio ,O,ltw1fng dl!tcr~ 11remli1:t, ,1Uinl114 In l(Qcminal County, Id41t10, l1r'/lll.:
LOT 2, LliJCI! P41'1f(, .ACtORlJtNG·TO THI! "PLAT Rf!COROl!C> flt 800K C 01' PLATS, PAGt! 9;1. rtF.OOm>S Of KOOTI:NAJ COUNTY, lOAHO.
SUIOl!.CT TO i!!ll ea.sm:ents1 '1J1hl or wavs, t!Mlllllrlfli, Mtrlcttom,, N!Sl!rvauom,. appliGnl)le l>ui1(1¥J~ oill'KJ mioing l!ll'lllna~ 111111 UH nio~ ond resi:11ctfflrll~ or n:wrd. i11.ld .pgyimnt of awuillg ptl!Sl!f'it ~"11:tr t.,i,es and BSG!UlffllP.tds ~ i,g,.i ID by p;11ts aboYe.
TO H/o.llE I.NO TO tl(llb thi sMl p1eirilsl!!, i,lth fl,; .iPJJuirtllfllr!QtS', UtlW llll!I !lelu GtQl'A\<I, RAIi W UlCI G1,1~'s lwlr, or-4 U!ISfgn~ f~. /lrrJ. !he said: GrnitQr lliii!~ l~rot1r 0'tliVliJflt tc;, 11ml' wllJ1 thit ,a,tl Gtlln"\Qa, lt4t. tho Grantor Is the ot1~ In fett. smp'lct or Did preri~; l"8t HIii pri:ml,;m: aro rroe !mm-all en@~~r11:is ~\It airrtrd yua,s ~. ~ GM a.:niessmentt. .ind ,eiu:ief'A t,.,. P.:iwnt rOfil!rvatlllnr.,. restt~lalli, t:Milml:!'1~ af 111axd and eo~~ vllllta upon tho pramlse,. 111'1Ci tllnr <inln11!1i· wlll warreinl and cleter111 \hi!, $l!m0 rrom iii! dams vAwta!;~~.
On Uris. __ 3..Q. day or Octoll«i 2QU,. lltf1)U! 1n~ i; l'fOUuy l?~llc Ill 111d rw uskl !itllll"., pi>J:W~lt, ilW'lorod ~m 1. ICCIIV and Ca,rolM 1. Kelty, kl\1l1~n or liloot'lllro to fl1(I to be th~!IDA(S) ...nose :MIO(&} 't)•.bliOiblld fo the wllhll:1 lnstrurnGtJt, ;:ioo 1Kkrlal1li:1:lpod iD m1r tl~t hclsh•e_':!Jixneoo!d the .\'lmC,
- -- ~ --
C -a -a m ;o -I ~ z r )> A m
'NERl31-U. 531JVlf!JJVNI ID:! A.1118\Jll ON 53WnSSV ANVdWOJ 311.ll NVJI'S'-lV 1S111::1 OIIV 53SIW311d OIVS ~Nil VJOl NI ~NllSISSV :10 350dald 31-U. ID:! A 1370S ~11VHJ lnOHlIM CB-lSIN11n:I SJ HJ.L3)15 S11-U.
vvo-uv+u 0298Ac -
008-005-0 263,30'
0.307 Ac
271 10· :s 1------0._n_o_A_c _oi ___ .....J& §
2es11r :s z 0331 Ac --.J !! s;:
----t:;0----------1 ;,;; 0.G82 Ac 292 10· Cl g rn 008-008-A 0> , al
-------- ---- --------~- - el
220.00'
§ !! 000-018-A
0 758A c
:!20 .00'
...... ex,
29~ 40' Qi I!;
ID ~ !! . g 000-019-A co
"' 295 10'
0 -~ ___ o,:o_: ~c ____ _
008-011-A
... 0333Ac O
283 10·
0.625Ac
...... ... 210 20· - ~-- - --g 265 oo· "' !!
008-013-8 ...... 008-013-A !!1 0.193Ac (270S0')(.,J O 115Ac l;i
O 319Ac 000-001-0
220.00·
g 000-020-A 0 3 Q253Ac
220 00'
§ !! 000-021-0
0.505Ac 220 co·
I!; 135 00'
!! 001-001-A 0.310 Ac
.. 0
"' ...
135 00'
#5651 21' 00' ~- ~ - g :S 001-002-A ,
0316Ac 000-002-0 N ~ 8 0619A )--------......:.~--'· I ~ _!!_ - lJS_OO~ : _ ": _; #5649 !
274 00' ~ I q ! . :s ' ' < /-0_.3_1_9A_c_0_00_·_00_3_-0 __ (.,J ____ c...J. !:j 13500' - I
m oo- "' ~ :s s· :s 001-004-0 #6569 0.328Ac 000-004-0 l"I, g ' ._. ,8 0.155 Ac .i,. '. , 6000 O 1SS A
f-----~-::-:---~~=----·{, L.....J, ' 135.00' ' • C 290 00' -----:J
0, :i:· "' ' ,!!I 001-005-A I #5540 !S 1 240Ac 000-005-A rt) ~ . I lo' . g 0.JI 0 Ac o, -~ !! _ .. _________ _ _______ _ . • J-t I ' · 135.00' ~
287 50' ~ :s I 1-t ':s 001-006-A o, ~~ o C) ig· 0.310Ac Ol ~ " ·~ #23335 -
13500
- -------285.0D- --__;-~-8;_ @ii_· -- - -1---1-- f 000-007-8 ~ f'' 0 --.J { _· __ ' 0 3099 Ac
RECORDING REQUESTED BY First American Title Company
AND WHEN RECORDED MAIL TO: Karin and Martin Walker 9836 W Twin Lake Rd Rathdrum, ID 83858
File No.: 642408-C (smc)
JIM BRANNON 2 P 2602733000 KOOTENAI COUNTY RECORDER CMK 7/14/20171:54 PM REQ OF FIRST AMERICAN TITLE -
KOOTENAI RECORDING FEE: $15.00 DD
Electronically Recorded
N»ie ms Line for Rec:orcler's Use On
WARRANTY DEED
Date: July 12, 2017
For Value Received, Colby A. Clartc and Kathryne Clark, husband and wife, hereinafter called the Grantor, hereby grants, bargains, sells and conveys unto Karin L. Walker and M•rtln R. Walker, wife and husband, hereinafter called the Grantee, whose airrent address is 9836 W. Twin Lakes Road, Ratlldnam, ID 83858, the following described premises, situated in Kootenill County, Idaho, to-wit:
LOT 2, LAKE PARK, ACCORDING TO THE PLAT RECORDED IN BOOK C OF PLATS, PAGE 92, RECORDS OF KOOTENAI COUNTY, IDAHO.
SUBJECT TO all easements, right <:J ways, covenants, resbictlons, reservations, applicable building and zoning ordinances and use regulations and restrictions of record, and payment of accruing present year taxes and assessments as agreed to by parties above.
TO HAVE AND TO HOLD the said premises, With Its appurtenances, unto the said Grantee, and to the Grantee's heirs and assigns forever. And the said Grantor does hereby covenant to and with the said Grantee, that the Grantor Is the owner in fee simple of said premises; that said premises are free from all encumbrances except wrrent years taxes, levies, and assessments, and except U.S. Patent reservations, restrictions, easements <:J reoord and easements visible upon the premises, and that Grantor will warrant and defend the same from all claims whatsoever.
EXHIBIT
Date: 07/12/'llJ17
STATE OF Idaho ) ss.
COUN"TY OF Kootenai )
Warranty Deed - continued
File No.: 642408-C (1111c)
On this /,3 day of July, 2017, before me, a Notary Public In and for said State, personally appeared COiby A. Clark and Kathryne aark, known or Identified to me to be the person(s) whose name(s) ls/are subscribed to the within instrument, and acknowledged to me that he/she/they executed the same.
/!/v~:UYl/ ~ ~Publ~ofldaho
Residing at: , daho My Commisslo pires:.e;.n:~~-2,..,urT.dr- O !:,710/o11J~?...
