Mission Housing | Habitat for Humanity | Pacific Union Development Corporation
AvalonBay Communities + BRIDGE Housing
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 2
CAC Workshop #3 Agenda
• Recap of discussion from 12/11/17 CAC meeting
• Housing types and updates on housing program
• Distribution of housing types
• Housing scale and character
• Next steps
Fall 2018Fall 2014 Fall 2017 – Winter 2018 Spring/Summer2018
• CAC Development of Parameters• RFP Development
1
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT• Monthly CAC Meetings • Other Activities
• Developer Selection• Begin Masterplan / Community
Engagement Design Process
2
• Initiate / Receive Technical Feedback3
• Develop and Refine Masterplan4
• Draft Masterplan Based on Technical and Community Feedback
5
1 2
Master Planning Timeline
3 4 5
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 3
1. Introductions (Oct 2)
2. Public Open Spaces (Nov 13)
3. Walking Tour (Dec 2)
4. Transportation, Circulation & Parking (Dec 11)
5. Affordable Housing, Types & Character (Tonight)
6. Preview of Fiscal Feasibility Legislative Package (Feb 12)
7. Master Plan Updates (March)
8. Open House (March)
CAC Workshop Schedule Through March 2018
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 4
9. Public Open Space, Programming & Design
10. On-Site Transportation, Walking, Biking & Autos
11. Affordable Housing, Types & Character
12. Off-Site Transportation (Coordinate with MTA)
13. Sustainability
CAC Workshop ScheduleApril through August 2018
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 5
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 6
Overview of 12/11/17 CAC Discussion
Transportation • Last Mile connection to BART is critical,
need to improve all transit modes
• Need to study other alternatives for accessing BART including a shuttle
• Provide pick-up and drop-off for ride share
• Traffic impacts on Sunnyside Neighborhood
• Traffic study needs to be accurate and address seasonal variations
• Provide adequate emergency access
• Careful design of Lee Avenue Access
• Reduce the number of City College students and staff driving into neighborhood
Community Feedback from 12/11/17 CAC
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 7
Parking • Provide more detail on parking need and
how unbundled parking works
• Concern that residents and visitors will park on streets in Westwood Park
• Too much shared parking could lead to more auto use and more traffic
• Provide more examples of buildings with 0.5 parking ratio
• Provide shared parking in each phase, not just in Phase 2?
• Plan needs to address the future of auto use and parking, not just current use
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 8
Community Feedback from 12/11/17 CAC
General Comments • Critical for Developer and City College to
work together on transportation solutions
• One way to reduce traffic is to reduce the number of new units
• Clarify whether local residents will have preference in leasing or purchase of units
• We all need to come together to find long-term transportation solutions - Supervisor Yee
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 9
Community Feedback from 12/11/17 CAC
QUESTIONS &COMMENTS
Master Planning ProcessOverview of 12/11/17 CAC Meeting
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 10
HOUSING
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 11
PRINCIPLE #1: Build new Housing for people at a range of incomes
PRINCIPLE #2: Create Housing that can serve a diverse group of household types
PRINCIPLE #3: Help alleviate City’s undersupply of Housing
CAC Principles
BRIDGE Housing MASTER DEVELOPERMission Housing Habitat for Humanity 50% of all units
affordable Potential for educator
housing with City College
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 12
Who will Build Affordable Housing?
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 13
Range of Housing Types
AMI = Area Median Income Household pays 30% or
less of their income for housing costs Units will be affordable
in perpetuity Serving a variety of
household incomes
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 14
What is Affordable Housing?
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 15
Who Lives in Affordable Housing?
Non-profit developers build and operate housing
Public subsidies (grants, loans, land, operating subsidies)
Maintenance and operations
Non-profits and residents
Tenant placement
Community facilities –community room and childcare
Community services
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 16
How Does Affordable Housing get Built?
QUESTIONS &COMMENTS Affordable Housing
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 17
SITE PLAN UPDATES
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 18
End of Slides
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 19
Original Site Plan
End of Slides
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 20
Original Distribution of Housing Types
Moderate-Income
Market-Rate
Low-Income
Habitat for
Humanity
For-Sale Townhomes
Market-Rate
Market-Rate
For-Sale Townhomes
Park
Phase 1 Phase 2
Low-Income
Moderate-Income
End of Slides
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 21
Adjustments to Site Plan
Increase Townhomes
Increase Townhomes
Park
Phase 1 Phase 2
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 22
Updated Distribution of Housing Types
Moderate-Income
Market-Rate
Low-IncomePark
Market-Rate
Market-Rate
Habitat for
Humanity
For-Sale Townhomes
Phase 1 Phase 2
Low-Income
Moderate-Income
For-Sale Townhomes
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 23
Building Heights
Park
Phase 1 Phase 2
3 Stories3 Stories
6-7 Stories5-6 Stories
6 Stories6-7 Stories
5 Stories 4-5Stories
4-5 Stories
Site Overview
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 24
Building Heights
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 25
Streets and Courtyards
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 26
Building Character
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 27
Unit Entries on Street
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 28
SEATTLE,WA
Unit Entries on Greenways
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 29
MISSION BAY, SF
Building Entries, Views to Courtyards
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 30
HAYES VALLEY,SF
Ground Floor Community Space
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 31
Sunny, Sheltered Courtyards
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 32
BELMAR APTS.LA
Sunny, Sheltered Courtyards
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 33
MACARTHUR VILLAGE,OAKLAND
Buildings Framing Park
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 34
WARM SPRINGS,FREMONT
Bays and Balconies
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 35
HAYES VALLEY,SF
Variety of Roof Shapes
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 36
PARADISE CREEKSAN DIEGO
Step Backs at Top Floor
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 37
CANDLESTICK POINT,SF
QUESTIONS &COMMENTS
Building ScaleBuilding Character
Townhome Options
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 38
1. Neighborhood Group Meetings
2. Walking Tours
3. Site Activities
4. Community Open House
5. Email & Website Feedback• [email protected]• Additional resources TBD
Next Steps & How To Engage
Balboa Reservoir CAC Presentation | 1/22/18 39