BART Adaptation Strategy for Sea-Level Rise in the San Francisco
Bay Area FTA Project CA-26-6006-00
with support of
National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration
San Francisco Bay Conservation &
Development Commission
Metropolitan Transportation Commission
March 22, 2012 Arlington, VA
Tian Feng, FAIA, FCSI District Architect
San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District
50 year – 16 inch
& 100 year
– 55 inch
BART pilot is building on the findings but adding “heavy down pour and flood”
BART Adaptation Strategy for Sea-Level
Rise in the San Francisco Bay Area
FTA Project CA-26-6006-00
Scope &
Methodology
A component(s) of each type of SYSTEMS and ASSET (a location specific facility) will be studied against sea level, heavy down pouring, and flooding in scenarios of 50/100 years for 4 aspects: hazard, risk, adaptation strategies, and implementation strategies
Infrared thermogr a section of dir
aphy depicting the pattern of water presence at ect fixation track in a concrete liner tunnel.
Infrared Thermography Survey
of Water Intrusion along Trackway
BART pilot is following the model for BART Water Intrusion Remediation Program:
Study – Strategy – Program – Implementation
C2
C1 CX
Total Reports = 1,617
A – Line: Total 791 B – Line: Total 194 C – Line: Total 437 D – Line: Total 195
Legend
Track
Vents Stations
INTENSITY
Color Code # reports
0-10
11-25
26-50
51-75
76-100
>=101
1.27 C
D20
Station 1
DV 25
DV 21 0.35 C
0.53C
0.440
DV 11
C - Line
DV 17
A10
Station 4
A - Line 0.57 A
0.2600.040 0.220
A2
A1
C1
C2
0.230 B1
BX
0.200
0.40 B
BX B2
1.48 B
B - Line
B2
B1 0.67
D10 Station 2
Station 3
Water intrusion related maintenance reports color coded water by intensity, superimposed over the transit operating system diagram.
0.70 C
0.62
1.080
BART Water Intrusion Program mainstreamed into design, construction, maintenance, and operations
BART’ Facilities Standards guide design and construction of assets against natural hazards, such as water intrusions: for example, street level vent is not permitted (10 ft riser is required)
BART Facilities Standards
Figu re 4· 1 Station Area Access Priorities
On·&cr.•! P.rloi~1 '° s..,........c....- ~1>or••ta11
Vtll~~-of·W'a')· for
llil<W."lodC..-t lon•
Figu re 4· 2 Faregate Area Access Priorities
DinKt.~......"'d hodtttr~ Sc~: Croulnn
l'<aocimi~~c ... b s.-. Around$tatioft
p.,;i,;,,,~......~ ....... ......p.e,,. wlithA u;... \J,..
~... o ..~c.... i..-., ~ l"cdtSt'l..n arlil kif 11.oirln
C:on«!l'llnlt~ Hl1:~ ll;hJ~p S111"fic~tCfoMn c. $i;id91tln
ober, 2011
Appendices
BART's policies, programs and technical publications al
construction, operations, and maintenance of District f and industry standards that are referenced by the Stan
DISTRICT POLICIES
DISTRICT PROGRAMS & GUIDELINES
DISTRICT TECHNICAL MANUALS
GOVERNMENT CODES• REGULATIONS
INDUSTRY CODES• STANDARDS
Editor-In-Chief: Tian Feng, FAIA, FCSI, District Architect, San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Tram
r BART Bicycle Access and Parking Plat
BART Station Access Guidelines
DART Transit-Oriented Development C
Public Art Performance Standards
Sample Artist Assignment Agreement
Wayfinding and Signage Design Video~
CHAPTER 13- RULES COMPLIANCE/ PROCEDURES REVIEW ......... 13-1
1301 Overview........ .......... ........................................ .... ... .... 13-1 1302 Review and Revision of Rules and Procedures .. .. .. ..... ... .. lr-··~------------------------------. 1303 ProcesstorEnsuringRulescompliance .................... ....... BART Facilities Standards ~ 1304 Train Operator Evaluations Program..................... .... ... ... .. 1305 Operations Safety Compliance Program..........................
1501 Systems and Facilities Subject to Maintenance Program...... 1502 Resolution of Audit/inspection Findings................ ......... .... 1503 Checklists................................... ................... ...........•
OISfl!llT POLICIES
CHAPTER 16 -TRAINING AND CERTIFICATION REVIEW/ AUDIT.. ......
1601 Overview.................. ..... .............. .. ... ......... . ........ ... .... OISTlllCT1602 Employee Safety..... .. ......... ....... ....... ....... ... ........... ..... .. PROGRAMS1603 Contractor Safety....... ........... ...... ........ ........... ............... .! lrGUIDRINH
1604 Record Keeping.. ....... ................. ....... ......... .. ...... .... ..... a;.. ...1605 Compliance with Training Requirements.......... .. .... ......... .. "C ~ DISTlllCTu
l TKH..CAL CHAPTER 17 - CONFIGURATION MANAGEMENT........... ....... ... ........ c MANUALS
al ... 01701 Overview... ....... ........ ..... .. ...... .. ..... .. ... . ... .. ....... ... .. .......J i <iOVERNMENTQ 'U1702 Process for Changes. ... ....... ... ....................•.. ............... !!I ... CODES &
1703 Authority for Change.................. .. ..................... ............ REGULATIONS~ 'U "' c1 CHAPTER 18- COMPLIANCE WITH LOCAL,STATE AND............. ..... 1: i:i .- INDUSTRYt1. "' FEDERAL REQUIREMENTS . - CODES a"' STANDARDS
1801 Employee Safety Program............ ..... ........... ...... .. ....... .. 1802 Working on or near Rail. ........................... .......... ......... ..
Transit Controlled Property 1803 Compliance with Required Safety Programs ................ ......
CHAPTER 14 - FACILITIES and EQUIPMENT INSPECTIONS..............
1401 Facilities and Equipment Subject to inspection.... ........ ....... 1402. Regular Inspection and Testing.............. ...... . ................. Appendices 1403 Checklists .... ...................... ........ ...... ...... ........ ... .......... 1404 Coordination with Hazard Management Process.... .. .......... BART's policies, programs and technical publication!
construction,operations, and maintenance o f Distri<CHAPTER 15 - MAINTENANCE AUDITS / INSPECTIONS........ ............
and Industry standards that are referenced by the St
Access Mana£emen: & lmprovemerr t:AK I l-'ol1 : y ~rumcwo~< tor ::iystcm F.ART Shcl.,ui:: Plw1
Financial Stabilir/ P~licy
Fol cy Framework fo · S:alionArea P Sustain<bilitv Poli : y Systerr Safety r'rcgram r lan S~slf"rr · R~-icl "\';.tlin·1S;.iff"l y lrisp~: :li1
I rurs1t-Or cn:cd Ucvclcpmcn: ( IOU Welfare to Work tc Gareer Policy Fr·
$100 ISSUE-0 Uctooer, l 011
iii System Safety Program Plan, Revision 8, February 1, 2008
DJ BART Facilities Standards CRITERIA CIVIL
DRAINAGE
CONT ENTS Facility Design Criteria
Principles and recommendations for desig
practices and BART's experience. Mandator
attributes required for facility safety, usabili
I ARCHITECTURE Basic Design Policies
Drainage
Miscellaneous Standards CIVIL
Streets and Surface Par
Trackway
Utilities ELECTRICAL
ELECTRONICS
MECHANICAL
I STRUCTURAL
1. GENERAL 1.1 Basic Design Policies 1.2 Design Responsibilities
2. HYDROLOGY 2.1 Storm Frequency 2.2 Intensity-Duration 2.3 Runoff
3. HYDRAULIC DESIGN 3.1 Open Channels and Culverts 3.2 Storm Drains and Closed Conduits 3.3 Curbs, Gutter s, and Inlets 3.4 Debris Control 3.5 Permissible Velocities 3.6 E nergy Dissipation
4. PUMPING STATIONS 4.1 Justification 4.2 Available Natural Storage 4.3 Constructed Storage 4.4 Runoff Diversion 4.5 Pumps
Release 2.1.2 Version - Issued October, 2011 Editor-In-Chief: Tian Feng, FAIA, FCSI, District Ar .....~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
HOME I ABOUT I THE TEA.Mi I GLOSSARY I FA•Q5i I
PHASES
TIMELINE
BUSINESS
AREAS
Home> ft.bout > Business AJeas >Maintenance
Maintenance
The. J.Iaximo and Optram suite of modules will be implemented to the following busines~
areas as n1apped out helow:
Business Area F&n:ttonal Area Modules to be Implemented
l Rolling Stade 4 Sh
l Maxiftlo &at• pi ism
M4E Maintenance
M&E rad< 4 Structu
