Before The Ju# 2 11 30 f’fl ‘00 POSTAL RATE COMMISSION ...Secure Site Raymond to questions posed...

Before The POSTAL RATE COMMISSION

Ju# 2 11 30 f’fl ‘00

WASHINGTON, DC. 20268-0001 p&c,T;.: ;‘L.T:: C?‘i”lC .ix ‘i OFF,CL .9;: ill; SLCk; !;,~i‘r

Postal Rate and Fee Changes, 2000 Docket No. R2000-1

RESPONSE OF THE UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE WITNESS RAYMOND TO QUESTIONS POSED AT HEARING

BY COMMISSIONERS GOLDWAY AND LEBLANC (June 2,200O)

The United States Postal Service hereby provides the response of witness

Raymond to questions posed at hearing by Commissioners Goldway (Tr. 19/8101-02)

and LeBlanc (Tr. 19/8089-90). Each question is restated and is followed by the

response.

Respectfully submitted,

UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE

By its attorneys:

Daniel J. Foucheaux, Jr. Chief Counsel, Ratemaking

475 L’Enfant Plaza West, S.W. (202) 268-2993; Fax: -6402 Washington, DC. 20260-I 137 June 2,200O

RESPONSE OF UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE WITNESS RAYMOND TO QUESTIONS POSED AT HEARING

At Tr. 19/8101-8102 Commissioner Goldway asked for the average daily hours a city carrier worked and what proportion of time was spent in the office and on the street from the Engineered Study. She also requested variability information on the percentage of time carriers spent in the office and on the street.

RESPONSE:

The average daily hours spent on a route from the Engineered Study was

8 hours and 22 minutes. Our focus was to collect route data and not carrier-

specific data. Therefore, the observed time on a route may include assistance

from other carriers on the route in instances in which it was possible for us to

study the activities of these other carriers.

The following percentage Office and Street breakdown was developed

from the various groupings of the routes:

ES Random ES USPS LR-I-163 Sites Picked Sites Routes

I office 1 Street oftice I Street office 1 Street

Percentage I 37.6 1 62.2 39.5 I 60.5 39.3 1 60.7

The following graphs and table illustrate the variability of Office and Street

percentages based on LR-I-163.

. .

05/25/2000 In ResponsetoTr.Vol.19page 8104lines57

Office Percentages

400

350

il

300

s 250 K % 200

i 150 3

* 100

50

0

10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

16 of Time in Office

Street Percentages

300

III e!

250

a K 200 z

jj 150

5 z 100

50

10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

% Of Time on the Street

Page1

In Response to Tr. Vol. 19 page 8104 lines 3-7 Page 1

7 iSO% I 1071 551 6- -,. 95 41; 54 43.2%: 70: 29: --i---- 49: YjGEa-

30: 66: ---e .I_

104,

75: 32t- is :;L;~~+-~~:.;

! 80' 34; 48; 42.5%: 57.59 -- !I) 74: 25; An .Kxr, cc -,a

I I 84. 3oi

:* 3% “A% -4 :P “56

-, I .I... g5i I=:-

7& --2L."-

70; 30' _^".^ r, -39;

--a: Tf.

;;mL.-;;y

32' g7---~", . ,_

75: 33 42;- 44.0%: s;gY

---__ ---... 27~ ‘Ye q.7 co,

0, ,370 .____ -.- .___-.-.

83 39; 53.0% -.___--,_ ____~ i4106 : 99.

_I- --SST-- .".L?!!-- 61.8%

i I 27; 31.4%: 88.8% - ---.-- --_._- .--

.-frrJ 84 30: ,"~ 45 48.4%~ 53.8% -- __._-__. -- .,.. - --- "---- I 12189 ! 78: 2 18~ 501 84.1% -"A"-

‘84. g-- 35.9%: _

-3

-. .“e "104 : 2 58 31 .O%: 89.0%

-5 --,--

514 _I_. 1

-%

3: - .L---.----

k- 58 33.3%; 68.7% __-_l~ ,..--- -.--

708 ; 38.8% 83.4% -Izt7; .~~~Lz..L+~~~-. 52; __-_._.- ,CYlO 82155 :

---~-~----;%;~- 59.3%

i4817 i 851 _---. "

41; a-x-pfq--- ."."," 51.8% --, ----d----.-z :4921 j 84 L-.-- 35; -s^s"- 41.7%' 5".. ____. --_.-_------

iCYO5 leaI $140: 3 i 88! 40; 48 45.5%~ 5" ' -- -1-‘--

--m% ^^^’ :YJUL : 78: 34 -----44- -_.--_,-.

b4*14 w------ 43.8%, 5.x. I

ICY11 -'-I-I-‘---

31: 63: - 33.0%: .- .._.._^-..-- 6i-n~

L---- _--.-~ __- -.. ,.rl.

& -.p~ ;LZ

'%Jl / 101, 31' 7n 30~7%' 6 ._ .,~~_-

:4/19 / y -

I,CA -:r;Yll _”

91: o,, ao."ml _,_. ---- '/'65 ; 09: 37: 52, Gva.~~/v

r"% ; 91; 3z-- 41.8% ,---'Ly.--.

58 ,.- ,..,_-__ ~,-=~

38.5%' --i

B i 85! T' r------ am nn,'---

B : 01: 5, 7". t I.T,V~ i 711 271 44i

.-- 6 : 71: 19: --'

L I lPP8 I 1011 31; CYO2 $1560

?jiGj---y 55: 7

!CYl4 93: SQL '-''"3 11233 : 77; 3%

3 :2934 / 03: 331 j 11237 I 79; 28:

'CYO3 :4111 : 85~ 33, 53; fz."y~ 52 i-.--e -- ---,---- --,-

9 id-e-6 ! p-..““.--3+ 83': 53: J&M~_~ -___. --- ,-,-- _. 52 --j

81: 28: 53: 34.8%: ~---__--. ---_._-- ! 4.80 85: 40: 45. 47.14L. -- ~1081 81: 34 47, 42.0%~ -- __--- _-,.-.----

5 '1024 99 35' ---- 84 35.4%' -"5 '

----?- 86

_-___ -._- .,-- ,-- 22, d---..--

79: 24:

. .,““...” -. . _---.

)6.WA _--.-

05/25/2000 In Response lo Tr. Vol. 19 page 8104 lines 3-7 Page 2

A ) B I C I u 1 t I I- I 0 I H I I 1 Date I Stat&ode: UnitCode I Route _ ~_~-..,----d 1 Total Tallies : lnskte TallleslOutsMe Tallle~i lnsidePerc& OUtSMe Pe!CeId

60 12/04/96:PR :cy34 :3104 : 02: 36: 46 43.9%: 56.1% _ ~~,-.-_-___ 61 12105196IN yY36 km0 i -E.- 30: 5% 34.9%’ --- 65.1% _.. _-i-.--- 62 Q/05/96 PR ; CY34 ‘3141 98: 30. 68, 30.6%: 69.4%

_ -. ,......... -‘.~~~~-..-.~G.-o+------ 63 12106/9WlN 80’ 27.5%! ----72.5% __-_.--_-- 64 12109/9SMA I-.-- 30.9%: 69.1% _ .-.-.-.-~~1..._ -. 65 Q/09/96 MI kY37 45.3%: sl.7% __-.__-- 66 12/09/9qx jCY35 ,-. -- / .--: - .I 69; 31.0m; --d 69.0%

67 12/l O/96; MA ;cy33;ifirr, . . ..- A4 :.-

24: -. 65; 27.h 73.0% _-- 68 12/10/96!MI ICY37 /“..... / --/ L-i 65.3% --%?71 : 79, ..z: 2!i iii 34.7461 -----~..- 69 12/10/9STX :cy35 16703 ) 92: 32 60: 34.8%’ -*5?!? .,.. -_- _ _ _-- ._^.._ 70 12l1119SMA ICY33 ilGT8 / 03: 12; 71: 14.5%; --85.5% 71 .-“-I- 12111/96:MI <CY37 !nqQA . 70 31.6%: 68.4%

72 -~~~~gjjTjgg~y~~ 16739 ’ RA 26 ARI 42~9% 57.1%

73 12l13lW:MI icy40 :tii 74 12/l 31961 PAyCY36 93OG vc .“,.lrnC’YP ‘Pv-0 ~nnG

-"-----ho .._-,--._-...- i ~_..~...__

-kvnn ______-_.---. I-~

18044 ! 68, 27! .~- ,.-.._. -- --.----- - R9A9

+. 91, -?FzL-...- 5? 93; 31: 62 .-.- _l__--a-...--J.

; 8ic 33 ___. ----_.,~ 50. 39.096: 96 24:

i~y-~5~~-g -- -____..-,._- ..,--..

2 81: 46 35: 56.8%: ..I-- -.-._- .~.‘-.-----~~ --.. ~51’~~-1- ,,Ld----- --d.- 70, 25,

L-.-l -7, ._._..

i -91: _LL_II_-;--.

64' 29~7%' -L----zi3 i -i--15T ----z--

28: :1430 : Sl, 28, -

i4$iij1 -.-.~___ f3 *'I

L-

&-----

-

I’- 74: --.--

-EL- 00: 84,

---- -4*

2.

i : 94i ’ I 711 -I- 65:

--... I 65' .I 84: 34: 5

03: 28: J- - . :a I 76; 25:

‘n7 : 70: L. 2 511 43: 38.1

v , I ei$ 31; xc---.---

54, r...~-, _ -____-- “.A 53, -__ : 17; 36 32.1%: ~---__--=r?-

6% 22 73.6%: --. -: _ 58; 27; 531 ‘“-~i$-----~~

36 42*--- _.._ k:-

_--I_^--x 5* 3o.t

------KY ‘L, --- 104, 46,- --.+---..---~ 68 --‘i-- 83: Z$

-3z .35, 93: 37;

- *“~ 99,


_.. .- .-. .” ” “. _.: __.” I”, 3lQ7;c.A 3jr 54, -An 70/L

71,

8197~MO CY40 ~0105 ~EF~411 , z- .!:I---id..d

07; WA : CY46 :1133 : 9197: Al i CY49 10711 I

: ,:v.sn :a717 : jo105 I

'1411 : -----m9 / ;1133 ;

(0711 1 10717

----%%r I

L- 771 18; 91: 35; 73: 7S! 85: 76f 87; ; 78: L

z; ---+

82!

-. 41.6%

------------i---- q ~.=~..~,..-~-.l-.,~l:=_l_ 21; 53' pn 4% 1 05/12/97~OH ,-----$v i 101: 40: 6,$-F

----c----rTlZL-

I*, “.,,I.,,-, “I, 158 05/16/97iAl icy49 10102 I :;I ;'ol 159 05/16/97,GA icv$Yil :07-- 391 39: 50; 43.8561 56.2% 17 I I 160 O5ll6lQ7iMO~~~i~~ 74i 311 431 43~9%' 5.~1% -'37 ! ; _ .,..... -____ 161 05ll6l97~NV _. .-.-..-._4I : CY47 :I411 : 84; 2ij

.._._ $0: '-- pls%: -KY ."." ," I%

' CYrx? '1579 / 75' SA' -...--~.'~~

167. 05/16/97!0H ,66.9% _ _.~_.___ _ _- 03; "" 30.1%! 163 05/16/97;WA ;cvii 33: 44.6%; ill33 : 74; iii 55.4% --- 164 05/17/97:AL :cy49 .-. 25: 30: 1 h-*02 : 55: 45.5%: 54.5% -..,. 165

_,._.. ---______- 7.- WW~~~ GA :R? 31; 46

-_l__-.---- ICY50 ,". 17 ! 79, 39.2%i 60.8%

166 05/I 7197, +w ( rwA7 36: . . . ~". ~..I !I411 100, _ ~-._-_-._ ?OH

-A.-- 64 ---------*~ 36.0%: 167 05/17/97,-.. _.__ ai 53: 29.3%: 70.7% 8 llvtw I 11579 i 75; -

- 168 05/19/971CA FCY51 /"I"" "I, 39: $991 44.3%1 55.7% 'Rlr;C a*' -.. -_--~-,~._.-- 169 ~+9/97iGA KtY54 lot- ,I1 I Mi 191 65' ; 12.6%! 77.4% I_-.- -__. -7 _-.-_ --._-" 170 05/19l97~w 30: 62 --6E p47 iI411 92: 32.6% ----. 171 05/19/97:OH j CYO2 !I579 / 90; 28- 62 31.1%' 68.9% -_-_-~__.-._--_ 172 05/19/97~WA icy46 47; 49: ~~ ,i 96: 49.0%: 51.0% _ 051'2OfQ7,CA~~l /g;-----.* 48: 24: 241 50.0%: ..---.'I--.-~d:o% -_-..-. ,.._ 173

-.-__-_l.. __.- "__ -_..-,-- ..-. 174 175

05L'Ol97~GA__1CY64 3 62 27.1% 72.9% 05lZOl971 OH ; &?jyjy

;0411 ; 85! ;I59 : 91; 3lJ 61: ----A- ---_-

- 33.0%, 67.0% ---

176 _-____.l_-_.-__-.

05/20/97iWA $Y46 11133 03: 29; 54 34.9%; 65.1% / I_ --.---. ~177 05/21197,CA : ci%i :6156 : 66 30: --&-.-----L 44.1%: 55.9%

. .

05/25/2000 In Response to Tr. Vol. 19 page 8104 lines 3-7 Page 4

1 1 A i B I C I D I E I F I G I I.4 I I I 1 Date i StateCode / Unit&e I Route I Total Tallies / Inside TalllesiOutside Tallies InsidePercent: Outskkpe~~nt

170 05121197;GA : CY54 :0411 : IiS 70: 20.5%: 79.5% 179 05lzll97:OH I CY”3

--‘-- llS7Q ._.” I QQ! --, 79! --, lx”! -.. 32.6%: - ._ ~~..~._~ _.. - _- !c 67.4%

180 05/21/97:WA 84j 56: 33.3%: -.--.__._

: CY46 81133 28 66.7% a..* nC-I,.-hm. IP..,cl t^lrq -^t .“a: A-, -;--i---.--=-:-y:;

““. ._ ““._ CY50 :07;17 :

-._...-

iOA2A ! Z-1 43.3%: !ia 1’

31: Al SXt

_“.. ._ --.- 40.9%: SQXI

29; I

33: _“._,”

05/30/97,WA ; CY46 :1133 ; 75: 0513ll97’GA j ------@777 43 cvso / : -35 8’ 18.6%:

llQ7’GA CYSA ‘M7A 75’ ,A’ 511 -------~~~~Y

-. .- . .-- --.v ,“, --__- -- ---.___

! 74i 361 381 48.6%! 11101

L._-.^__- : 85; 321 53:

II-W374 I *,! 24: 37.J

571 29.Lr.. -- --

ii 82; 311

Ii 40;

ji 1--L- ‘1

lo;! 191

11581 --.------

t 06;05/97;WA-; 36i 65: 35.6%! SA A’

CY46 2x40 : 74: 301 36, 51.4%: $YSO !0701 i 83: 30;- 45’ 45.8%: .-- __-d.-~_-_

s $Y55 ;0611 : 83. 16: 67: 19.3%: ‘CYIi~ ii581 06: 33: -5s .- ---7---

37.5%: k :llAA r---

--.-- 75: RA

:: - . - . --. ! CY4:7 j ;$+-+--- ii: 35’

--__-.. 63: 35.: ,I, --

I _“. “T. --.- ,“, -_I_--- ‘ISRI RA RI1’

In Response to Tr. Vol. IQ page 8104 lines 3-7 Page 5

I A I I C I 0 I E I F I G I l-l I I I

-.-----_ILLI- .-,

'= $8701 101: 53: 47... j1605 j 79! 36: 43; 45.6% ,",

84; 30; 54 35.7% -4 i 70: 255: 43! 55

-_. -.. -.__ 11m7: MS ;CYS!=.

/16/97,0H

,LY'A 7197;CA

_ - /17/97, GA

12219 I ---X57 :

I f 90: 36 54: 40.0%:

.$no;ij97. 6-i __-..

l20197; WA

Rl197:FL R1197.GA _-.-~- I21197 ml t21197iOH R1197~ WA

,- ..-

18701 i -3-of: 42: 64 39.6%:

76' 36! !jBl __- ____ - ._._ -

5o.ow 50.0% j CYOL it581 : - 79: 35: 46

-___-- 44.3%. 55.7%

ICY46 '1148 ! -I 7li 25: ~-----g,>$-- 64.8% _-i-__-,-^- 38 a:, I--__- 52.8%: 47.2% .-_.~,.-----~-.._- ,.-. 29: 43.3%' 56.7%

s2: 28:

30; ~__.,.___ -.-^--

32' 40.4%s 51.6% ___I_~_, I CY47

--...___ '1508 ;

--- -__l___-ll_ll-..~--_ 70: 19' 51: 27.1%; 72.9%

ICY02 11581 i so 30: 52 42.2%! 57.0% __--, CYAfi sllA8 74: TiA .~ All 45~9%; sAl%

. .

In Response to Tr. Vol. IQ page 6164 lines 3-7 Page 6

” ” ” - . ” ./ -“, _“.“,“. “V.” --- ICY56 10405 L Elk 341 471 42.0%; .-_ 563 .--.-_ ---_

-. -. . sCY50 88701 44: ..-., I- _.. -._

91: ^._.i.._-.B-. 47: 40.4%% 51.6’ vQ7:Nv ! CY47 / 1xK-y 93: 28j 6Q.C .-

I1 : 99, 43; ill40 I L9: 30, 39: 43.5961 --_-

.-.’ ---. --.z 14 I 39: ;;I 46.1. w ,vvJ%- : 89; 54: ‘--

__, f 35: 39.3%:

-io 8701 icy47

! j 05: 37: 40: t-.- ;15p3 91;

43.5%: ___ -- 30; 61’ 33.0%; 67.0’

: CYO2 :I581 101: 42: 59; 41.6%: ---z-z - --

I 89' 39 5oi :2215--r is”

43:! 43:

‘CY56 --A 43: 48.!

‘1049 ___i___~~ -_-- 72; 241 48: 33.3%;

i870L_LP__~ 84 37;

--_-L.-&Z ” ..“._ --zzL---.-.~-.~~~~‘-

07: 341 531 39.1%’ R” cl’ -3~ 34

1 24!

T----------- 10: 70.6%

!_o ;a735 : 95: , ,:.:z,:;-:.LL;L~.Y - -;7 I !3716 84

1~ ~/30!2!!!NV ‘CY47 7/97,OH -----%%ii

:1c75 ; 101: i4243 sli- -- i

l7:Tx ICY& 1’ !!E.~A : 85: 46 St?------“----I- 47.9%:

: CY46- :1145& 76. -- ‘c%---+-- i0735 I 94 --~_i_-_---. ,“.“. 13716 : 5J

26 721 2r ^^’ _ ---.-_

.-.-, -.- -197:WA CY46 :1m : 37: 48.6%:

: a735 / 83: 35: 48’ 42.: :cy57 ;3716 I 76: 2q 48; --c I^._^. I .T.” __/ .-5 ~4&---.-

77; ;;. -- --.---- 35.1%; 64.9%

“I,““,~, UA !CVSO e----------b3! -~--_-----_

92: 39; 57.6%; 42.4% .--_..-- -.- ---..- 07/05/97: MD : CY57 ;3709 ; 84; 35: _- .__ -- 49. -.--__ 41.7%’ 56.3%

REV L!zEL+. ‘1475 : 102: 35: 67: 34.3%‘ 65.7% xwmi-

-_-_----___-.- --_-.--.~ __.-~_.._-. ,CYo4 (4243 I 105: 53, 52: 50.5%: 49.5%

07lo5l97:Tx / CY60 :1913 : --__--_ ___-.,_~_--

a8 31. 35.2%, 64.8% , C’?26

57, .-. ;I145 , 83i 36! 47; 43.4% 66.6% ..-.

‘197. GA : CYSO :0735 I 104 49; 55: ---: 47.1%, 52.9%

05/25l2000 In Response to Tr. Vol. 19 page 8104 lines 3-7 Page 7

I I I I s* I

/ Total Tallies j In&k T~iOutsMe Talli$ InsktePm~&tl Outside Percent -..- .,.-. e-P 10’ 76.8%: 63.2%

ffibi 62.5% 45.2%: ?F%L

??E!i 75.8%

1. _i _“I II

/ CY47 61475 t 08! 33i 5s 37.59 13 t 93, 42t

I 91’ 22j 69: L-f.GIO, ” 11145 : 06 35; I., -mL

/ _--_ ) I 93: 47;

ICY57 / 3707 84; 29; 551 1 34.5%; .~.

365 “,,“O,~,~YY~ 366 07/09/97$ GA 367 07/09/97’MD 31r 368 07/09/97: NV _ 369

..-._. .._ ~-.----qG 07/09/97: OH e!c ;44 _,

370 371

07/09/97! .,.,----$S$! TX 07/09/97; WA

372 07/10/97, GA !C 373 07/l O/97, MD YCY57 ‘3704 ---I- 374 07/10/97: NV 1 CY4 375 07/10197~0H :cyo.l I-IL? 376 07/10/971TX ; CY6” 377 07/10/97:WA CY;iS : :1145 376 07/l 1197’ GA ‘cYsr--E3~ -7”

_. .._ -. _. __.. ._ ;CYO4 14243 ; 76; 361 40: 47.4%, 1 CY60 11901 I 90: 21: 691 23.3%:

n~,,.m,,,~~..,” I CY46 I1345 1 -cm 29; 5.i icy50 ;a735 ; ggi 42: 43: 33.3%!- 49.4%

--=y57 ! 3707 I 601 24: 56: 30.0%: Y47 (1475 : 99; ;;;* I’?43

32: 67: 3 ,. ..I,.

/ 85: 36; 49: 4L.m; 0 ;1901 I 89; 23; 66 2

cc;146 :1145 ; 84 36: as: 4 Y50 10735 -__,.- I 841 39i 45; 4

07; 331 54 j7 L.- 9%: 7 I1475 I 2s 71; 26.1 ;--~~~~~- : 34: -7~ 1 ” a ,187 *1i 25; 5rT *

I 82~ 31, 51: 37.1 36’ 46: 43x _.~ 20; 3fi%1 29:

-.-,-___ 34.9%: ,_ _---I .

36 47 ~L---43.4%~ 22: -“-ig 31.0%7

-..- ..-

-1_-.- i-‘-L,;---~z..Li

Y57 :3704 : aii - Y47 11475 I 92i “?43 : 71:

‘GTO” 76’ -_-..- :1d17 j - i.-- :1145 ‘CY46 : 77:

(A.-- ~O?----+~. ‘0735 ! 73: 7 ,1475 ; 102;

ii; ‘-’ _l- ..z-‘:z_j---.-

58 2 I.-- __I-.. 35i 57: 3o.wm: 36 351 ,...--

50.7%, -.“_--_- 31’ /

4540.8%-. 34; 43: 44.2%: 321

_-lll- 41; 43.8%: l_.-

3$

..-. .---, !8.4%: 71.69 _- .^,. -.. -_- ,I I,., 62.E

49.3! -_-.--_ 59.2: 55.w -- 56.2:

-- 63: 38.2%: 61.8: is.?%: _,--*--

IYI 37.2%; 12.4%:

F-I J&l%!

90: 42: 40: 4 YO4 ;4243 :~~g-----+f45

70; 29: 4- - -.~-I-.---...-.i -.----& _._.. -.--.i”, ---I 85: 4

1 84 1

i 84 24 , e-t i-i

1.2 “,z e-n 3

!I1 7.l 9%. L-n. 1. SC

,-- -- ---?50 / 145’---; A-- ;C

$735 / 00;

42: 46: 47.7%:

:c 53 :0212 97; 20: 69: ?” on y47 11475 91; I 23. 68; 2

‘bYo4 14243 81: 35: 46. 4J.L-y (CY61 14271 I 73; 271 46 f-- ’ CV& I 1-. .- , . ., , 84 ‘IIF; 26 58: 5 ..-., --- --- ._,-^l_

!97iGA I CY5fi -_-_“- ,197, MD -.__--_ ! E ‘197: OH ‘/97:Tx

!CYo4 ‘CY6’ .+--A--

‘l97iWA : CY4ti U97,GA

--Y---I’- ,CY50

1197, MD : CYSS .-.-- 1197: NV -A--- ll97:OH .w,..

s ;_.__ ‘8217 : 75, .-. 3;: 40, =+----x7%.---- . -. - . -,

--.---.--- “-‘-I I 62i 33, 49) 4- -“’ A--

‘1 ;u,! I 81: 23: 58: 20.4-m __ 1 9% 487 47: -50.s-~~

-ST-- ----

41; 43; 48.P”” ‘6 Elir- 35’ -----a, 70 --

ICY47 11475 ; * 32: 51;

---SW _A___ 55i r--

~4243 : 61. 34 ----w- L.-..

. .

05/25/2000 In Response to Tr. Vol. 1s page 8104 lines 3-7 Page 8

A 1 B I C I D 1 E I F I G I H I I 1 _D_; I Stat&ode j UnltCcde !

414 07ml97:Tx iCY61 Route I Total Tallies j lnskte Talk.@ Outslde Tallies: InsidePercent; Outskle Percent

:2717 : 75: 21: 54: 26.0%: 72.0% 415 07119197:GA ICY50 18735 I 84: 41; 416 07119/97:MD d5a t8217 s 60: 30: 30:

~~------- si? SQ/&

417 07/19/97!uV ‘CY4 - ,.-..-_-I- - . . % 410 07it9197.DH ! CYO ..54* 419 07/10/9 66.7% --__

__ ._._._ --.-, ,7 11475 j 88j $$-----,I 3i;by fii-li --,--____

45.3%’ --t---- . ..-71Tx 33.3%:

27.w 72.6: 32.3%:

----._ 67.7’

07/21107~0!4 .-.__

ICYM 14243 I 99; 461 53 46.5%! 52 !T l~____.-.-.-L. :4275 I 87: 32: 55: 36.l.“” IllAS : 1l-n 211 54i snc

WJ

07l21/97~Tx :&ii; . ..-- 07l21197i WA i CY46 I..._ -- 07l22l97, MD :CYSR

-.-- :0218 : 07l22l9TiiT--$Y47 1147 ‘5 j ~.,~ ..-- .- .-_ 07ml97; OH : CYo4 :424 13 : 07ml97;Tx !CYBl /427 ‘5 !

‘1 07t22l971 WA__, CY46 ~~___-~-.+_- ili45 ; 07123197gMD I CY50 18210 : ~---.. 07l23197: NV 8 CY47 07lZ3197: OH-

! 1475 I ~_ _~_~-_--_ ..~. .-~.----i- :cypl 14243 : 07l23l97: TX ICY61 14275 i 07l23197:WA : CY46 :1145 07R4

~7Zr---xisj I8735 I __-__--_-.-____

07l24 ,197. MD iCY58 48221 -__. 107: on ‘CYtiiiA243 07/24...I_.. / ;-__. ,.=.-

07l24197: TX ..,. -.--._i_,_ ‘CY61 j -_ 14273 ; :11;15 / 07124l97: WA ; CY46

07l25l97: GA iifFY ;a735 / 07/25/97. MD :CY58 $8221 , 07l25l97~ NV ICY47 I_~_ / I1475 07l25197,OH XYO4 ‘4243 : L.-- 07l25l97;I-x !CYRl id971 I

,_.I. .-_,-

07l26l97~ MD ICY5 8 :8221 : ..,. ~.~.., .___,. -, CY47 1147 ‘57 07l26197: NV -.-.---,_ _-

07l26l97:OH :cyo4 14243 : 07l26l97: WA : CY46 ill45 j 07/28/97’AR . ..~~.---A-.. 1 CY62 ; 0406 I 07lZ3197:DC icy59 :0320 :

~_~ ..,... ._...~ .__._ icy50 18759 07/28l97! GA I 07l20l97 NV icy47 Z1586 2 07nai97iOH !CYoA IA23

VV.” k ----- 63.2%

.--j -./ _.,

;;; I”.. 50.0%

- 05: 20: 571 32.L ,I jcr---- a7 I% 1,. . 9oi 24’ 66: 26.; I%! 73.3% 76: 37: 39: 48.; rOLi------ I”, 51.3% - 09: 30: 59: 33.7%: 66.3% 99; 40; 51; % 031 25: 5s:

4R.K 30.1%:

-.-.FL5! 69.9%

89; 23i 66: 25.8%~ 74.2% 46 01: 35: 43.2%: 568%

37.296: .L--

86 32i 54 62~8% _-._. _.-- .---~-^..-..~ ,__.., 81: 30: 51: 37.0%; 63.0! K a$! 371 .---.

46 445% 5s 1’ .-. . % -- 47. 24:

.-.-~--.-.1--- 23; 51.1%, 4

aA - ., 37: !@%

ii

a A& ii$-----7 :. . .._,_~ .ie.O% __,A_ 63; 821 431

54; 34.9%, 6511% 39f 52:i%: 47.6%

801 371 -3‘13~-.-.~.-.-.-----~

46.3% 53.0% 48: 2F

---_.- .._. 248 50.0%, 50.0% .-.--

86 34 86 34:

52, 39.5% 60.5% 46

L------2-~-,------ 57.5%

m: , “.

?-a! ““2

-~-~~Ara~~~ ---.- -I -.,.“I” 58.2%

ig: 25: 24: -- .--

51.0%. i9.00 !4 gg 66’ ..--.----.-

30: 31.: 1%’ 60.0% -___ --..-_____~ 62’ 71%

39; 43, 47.6% 52.4%

961 211 50: 29.6%, 70.4% - .,_._ -.--,.- 33; ! 631 34.4%; 65.6% -.&-.--,-_--

90, 29; 61: 32.2%: 67.8% -~-.. -,.-.._-_ q 39 58; 40.2%i 59.8% --- aA 32’ 52, 38.1%’ 61.0%

,-.-. ,._ A ; __, ~.LLL_

64 35: 49i 07l2al97;wA : csi6

--GG :1132 : 94 4% 50;

- 2 I -

10406 94 31’ 631 33.0%’ 67.e. - 07/29/07’ DC CY59 :0320 84 20: 56! 33.3% 66~7’

4 !CYSO ! 0759 I 95j __

53; --_ 44.2%; 8P.Y.T IALa, .,....I ,_. .--- 23; 63, 2-.7:‘.: 42.7Od -.-, :cyo‘l : 02:

-- i4234 351 47; 57.5

i CY46 ill32 I w 37, 52; 41.60~1 58.4! CY62 ~0406 46: 29: 17: 63.0%: 3i.oc

851 2 j CY59 3 F”A7

11132 ; 761 26 50: 34.: .-.-

“,,-“,” ,/... *“.T. “1 .I6 : 6@ I CYo4 14234 I 85! _,- -_--.,- :cy46 ,,- ICY62 $415 ! 101;

76: 87’;

% -.::- ,____ -. I.

4w “,,Jl,Y,IN” ,c;14/ !,OMo ._- I eq----- -_l_---i 470 07l31197~OH ; CYo4 34234 791 60.896 ___.-

- 471 07131197;WA , CY46 +iZi I 761 29: 471 38.2%: 61.8% --_ 472 05/01197,AR I CY62 10415 : 97; 23: 74: 23.7%: 76.3%

. .


‘L.-.-- .‘; --.- ,_

9 1 ae- 45!-------- 48.9O4.i 6 --.3_ 83' 23, 43!-- ___--.-.._ -..-. :

4 I 831 z- ;I132 I 73; 20; 45: I_.__ --. ^^/

_.-_ -._. ICY59 $417 ' 'CY47 p6 : %---- 23. 61: 27a --_ SYO4 :4234 / 92: 40' 52; 4ci-5%~---?5&. .

!I132 / 731 45: z- I 931

3.s; ._~._ 35: 50:

38.4%; -....-. I_- 37.6%, -.- ~-

,---__-. y/“OIYI “” 32, --I_ ~--

311 52' 37.: WA _.~l-~_-------.

CY46 11132 1 63' CY62 ;0424: 33

..- 26, 57, 31.:

CY59 !2417 : cv-.".---A~-~~ 81' 31n-- 36.: oq--F7'~ cc -i-i

08105/97i WA !( 08/66/97~AR I, 08/06/97;DC jl 08/06/97~ GA _ .- ~~_- .-----c_;_- Om6l97~ NV -_ ,~~~~T~~T~~--~~~~ ,... ..~.. .-...-.__ _ -.-._..-- OWO6197 WA ICY46 _~- ._._ ~-._- -- 08/07/97:AR / cv62 08m7i97: DC 08/07/97iGA /( tlA11171!a7~ F.N

L...--.-

fl132 -..- / M26

‘L. -._ __

“JL 39; 49: 44.2, .- --=x3 / m 52, 29.7%!

ii / 73 30. 45: 45.1 II_-~..--

~3:~~-- 11132 I 7,: 261

---'-'Tcg ; 73: 221 jqr- 30.' n / f"! 24i

z ",,

67; 61; 74: ._. .-. ._ ,.._ -

---

1971 GA i 87sF se; 591 40.; -- - - . - 4 /

-'- ~1401 : 01: 21:

521 08l11197~NV j CY47 !1386 I 85i 261 5% 30.6%; ---- 69.4% .-.- .._. 522 0811 llQ7,QH I CYO4 :42MT 99; 43. 56; 43.4% 56.6% _ ~. -..----- 523 988~~7i WA I cY46 11132 I 63i 3i'i 52;

~---?---- 37.3%: 62.7%

524 08/12/97~----- t CY50 +39 : 95, 44: 51: 463%~ 53.7%

525 !??!!!!X ;- __- I CY63 ioet!s , _ 85~-- 3$----I----- -.-- --' 54 36.5%: 63.5% ---...I__ --,

526 08/12/97:NE ! CY64 22; -pw----.--t--.--- .._-- 61: 73.5% _-,-.- -- ~-.---

527 08112l97iNV icy47 21: +..-..A~~?~;

25.6%: 74.4% ---.- 526 08IlUQ7:~

;c;vo4 __-_- 39:

--.slL 45: -----&nF 53.6% _ ~.-.~.-...-._-__

529 08/12/97~WA -ZS6 *5:-- --. 30~ - .~ .._. ----_l--_--l .~-+-----s 35.3% 64.7% - ,-- 530 08/13/97~GA .~ .._.. ~2~~. lCY50 16759 ) 92: 43.5%: -.~~-. --’

401 52:-.--.- _62% 531 08/13/97: NC I CY63 10025 : 85 35: 50: 41.2% 58.8%


/ .-- .- 0 42; 41.7q--- --.-,

!I3759 ! 391 5s 7”

--:

47i 32.L s-1

$- 57j 3o.L I” I4 i2 /

99; 39; 60; 39.r--- 76j 34! 42! 44.;

- _ _.. / cv?z3~~3~----=

--. . . -- . 5 29: 59' 3z _.-.-- --881 --

._. .._ CY64- I1457T 81: 3iT 50: 38.: _ _. J/97’ OH /CYo4 -izG-y- 107: 44: 63: 41: -- “wlQlQ7’WA 11132 82’ 27;

-.-- 70: 47: _L- 32 9%~

:1132 : ----A!$ 321 53: 37.6%: ---_.,_._- 18759 I 9oi 351 551 38.9%:

cq------- 39.lL -- 23: 63: 26.7%? 73.3’

,_. .___ __. .._._ __._. ---

_I 08Rll97iOH .~.- . -. ! CYo4 14234 i 84: 33i 4i 39.3%i---’ 60.7: 16

.-. ..i;dr : CY46 :1132 : 831 32: 51: -ygc----- . ._. 61.4’ _ k

7--.- ‘197tGA 1 CYSO 18759 I 681 31! 371 4ci 3961 541% ._ _ ., ” 9 L-w63 - _ 10827 : 82: 20: 62: 24.4%, 7s 61 .” .-.- ib

b cw =.A j2411 j 77/ 23! 54; Liz_ Fu? ,^-- 70.1%

;1586 ; 55; 15; 40) 27.3%: 72.7% i4234 : 89: 31: 58: 34.8%: 65.2% “,~~~..~_.__ _.--

,.-~~ ~_ / ;;;f E 60.0% --.- LOA *+ CQL

a :2411 : 84 31: 53: 36.1 .._

!2 ! 89: 28: 6li 31.! --_

11132 x7-@-- -_-- ‘082 - ~~~~~~

z7 ‘4234

.$w- ; 8744 -- 10822 -- s ,cn7

I 281 34

44 52: --

91: 103!

32; 40: .---

59; _.--a-- s3:--.-

50; --4--- 59: ---.-

/ 92: 93:

42; 34; _+-- --

i 8: n7

32i 511 38.t I”“, 30- 57: 34.:,..


I I A I n I c I n I F I F I G I H I I I Total Tallies i In&k

AA ““: ““/

2 I 73; 3$--- .“.A j 682 38. -- --

85; 7 / 77; 26 4 I 104 27:

__) -4. Yli

SII,

-. .” :.

~CYliR ml31 104; 45: 59; 43.i --.- 17 I 91: 29: 62 --, 31~9%’ _ _ _ 68~19

pi ; 83’ 32; 5% 38.6%’ .--+-.---~.--- Aa * ,2 : 77: 32: 45: 41.6%,

891 33) li6; 37 I%5 ““. “...I” 84 u;---

-I__ 83’ ---

__._ -_. . . 09/03/97 GA -., A__ ~- CYSO / 8744 : 45: 102:

A”.?” 33; 62: .Tv.,m, 47; I m. ,.,--- 45: I%!

,c1740 :1142 : 85: 41: -rcvso--~7~- -..-- 93: .-. 38: ---

^.,^_ ‘0807 I 11-507 !

84; 36

‘4254 j 87: 43; 44; 45.4-m O”.O: I-,

,-----kz 97; 39; .?a:

IIt% r-a!=.

1”1”“,“. ..I.

)9/M/97: GA

:“#T-. _i- *-.(; 7”: --__.

17 : 83; 33’ .._I_ 36 -_- I”&

:I142 : ---- 87; 48; 18744 1 831 371 -- .“‘37 : 82: 27:

17 / 39: IS; - :. * 0.’ 07’

; CYM 8”--- ;;;;

I i/97! WA CY46 ill:

/

_“. D9lUOIY I UM D9/08/97,NC _ ----.L..

.-. ._ ,... -

1;;: I &I.

I 441 Jc_vsO !87w i 91) 35; - .7”.” ro:

96: 26: -97,

27.1%~ __.i_^ q 63; 35.1%:

84 44 40: 52.4%: .I .V 36’ ..__?_ - .--- 94; 581 ,^- 38.3%1 -6i~i’, - __.--

96. 41; 57: 41.8x- 58.2% !083jf 977 35: 62 _._l__-.____---.,-- 36.1%: 63.9% i---.-

57: 37; 60.6%: 39.4% _~____ ._..._ 38:___--.-..-m.---_- --,...-. 50; 43.2%: 56.8% 41; 45.1%. 50: 54.9% 25’

___,____. --- 67; 27.2%~ 72.8% -.__----_

L15p7 ! 85: 28; 57L.-&?EL-----~. 67.1% ‘d,!u 102L----- 43: . . 59: 42.2%: 57.8%

39: 46: 55:

. ,

05l25l2000 In Response to Tr. Vol. 19 page 8104 lines 3-7 Page $2

I I A I R I c I ” I I= I I I? I Ll I I

95 411 54: 43.: I 97; 42; %-----: 437;

--, 56: 3.L

H ICY04 14254 1 78: 29: 49! 37.7%: -7i -_. CY48 :I142 : 98: 42: 56: 42.L ._~ c%o 18744 1 75: 39; xi ---- _ - .-‘3 :0824

: 79:

52_.px: 26 53; 32.L ._

! CY47 11567 I 92; 28j 64, -----gjy~T1 OQ/i3/97~OH ’ CYnA ‘12%

744 ; ;oci20

88; ;CY63 : 85:

36; 52: -.-2!!!?.%-.~~5~i!!

I CY46 31 :r-------’ 54 36.2-c+ 63.5’

----$50 11142 I 94 35; __ 59; 37.2%: 62.8’ ..-.- i--_-- i8744 : 100. ___ 48: 52;

F~~~~~~~~ ~~~ .--.- ~_~

LCYSO

ill42 d-i----.z+---.lz-

.- @ 40; 44 .~~~7---g-zj

__.-- 18744 ; 90: 39; 5l: -A.- 43.3%: 56.71

I CYE6c. :0811 : 66 25 , ---_i____

611 29.1%’ 70.9:

..- .._... i;;.: 1CY46 ,114T / ,g,g71 GA-‘-‘-----

------ion -. ._.__

&Q; - 4; .-. . %

:%?L, 58744 ! .g 36 51:

Em!C-iCY63. ---l-l_l

iO811 I 821 54 82

28~ 34.1% 19197: WA

-i,--- _.__ ~~,-.-.-- f 15.9% : CY46 34 __-.- llci2 : __I 7

- ---_-_ 11971 GA ICY50 i8744 ! 67i 37i

48: 2!E& 30;

II : 84: 39: 45: 46.4%; 53.6% --1_ -.___-.-- 12 641

--,~---~- ~-,-, 19; 45. 29.; 35; 67’ 34.:. I”,

’ CYM 14931 / 73: 29: 44 -+-39;7%ii--?iE ““.“% g ; 100: 37; 63.

-“--T &---.-?7~?!?L

69; 46. 33.-i ?97iOH 36 30’

-=gl-- 34.L .-,

;cYsn ;0726 ;

14 ;-- .-- 4928 I 87i 41.4%;

- ,O LB736 : 87; 36: 51: 41.4%: A IAQIS I rwi 431 -- ‘- 59: 42.2%:

36: 56nTz - -. - -. ,-.i $ios j 86, 36 -“pdiFzp 50: -i 27197~ CA _ ~-~.. ;cr53 /2201 ; 88 57;

ICY50 “’ 31; 64.8%

1001 41: ~_

27197: GA i8727 1 59. 41.0%’ : cYscF---- 12202

-- ,__.,,. -.--..-___ 7.r.A I 88; 391 49; 44.3%:

t%iF--- - 8748 89 45, -L..-.-6~6-~~-‘-- 44

!3 60; 38; 421 47.! rn ‘(5’ r-47. ,* ni;

.-“.V, ---

58.1’ 35.2’ -.- 59.0’ 55.71 _-.- 49.4:

05R5/2000 in ResponsetoTr.Voi. 19 page 8104 iines3-7 Page13

I I A I I I n I F I I G I H I I I

90; 40; 5q 44.4%! i3 12211 : 833 43: 40; 51.1

i8711 : 96 491 471 SiTO%i

-.__ ,-.. --_ .CY50 18717 I 90; ;CYSR 77 3-r---

I - - - -. 96: 52; ;2i14 : 8% 43: 44: i8735 ! a31 42: 511 45.2%: 1

, .,.j; I

-- 83’ -“3 _

84: ------35-

- _ _ _ _ _ _~_i_-- z-1------.--z.L- 17.Nl-z aCY63 ~0803 : 98 32:

! CYE lti5 i -_

57; 32 2:. _L~_. ‘l-l,34 i!i 19:

! 104 ;;: 571 -.

45.2%: 7--- --- --.,__

--.. ’ I_ i 79: 30; 70:

4p: 38.0%’ -.-- 19: 51: 27.1%:

/ ,,‘I- cTF----~~~

92 2 01 I 93: 40: 531 a.04

U13lQ7;CA ( CY00 !F

.__ .-FE6

,_151 ii%lQ7: CA : 0249 --_

: CYn.l

I I-r “8,

80; 34; 122: 48i-

i4940 I 120, 67; 4244 f 81: 38: 4 10370 ; 911 291

::nn74 --_ 6-

: 67; 25; 42: 82 i 93i 32i 61: 34.4%:

27 : 31, 51; 37.6% r----%58,, ! ;+-- 201 .- - 64 23.8%:

93: -%7- 55: -.-._~--

40.9%’

g7 3 / : 78: 26’ __~~~~-~~~~~_.~_~

-,. 52’ --_ 33.3% 85; 35, 50’ 41.2%, -..-__.

L__*-‘-. 14 ; 59: 18: 43: 27.1%. dM,!j I 7q--- 18:- 52;-’

: . . ..T “m-’ e-B -----d

. .


’ 1 A 1 B I C I n I F I F I G I II I I I . . 1 Date

I ) State&de i UnitCode i Route i Total Talll~>sbde TalliesiOutslde Talllesi InsidePercent! Outside Percent

766 W30l97~CA T- -.-

CYGr; -.- 6

in114 ! .-... RR --. a-: --I !a?;: --, !aA 9%~ “7.. 65.1% 769 01102/98iCAic.vn 10116 ! 86 35! 511 40.7 ?%Li ,“, 59.3% - .__-~--_._ -__.-

$Y66 -

770 01/02/98~CA '0373 2 771 01/03/98jCA lC-& in9.G

102: 44: 58, 43.1%: I *Gi ?L! dOi’------- ““_%_

'"4%' 57.6% 772 OllO5198;CA 6i2% -.- ICY66 1024 -,-- ^I,“r.me~^. l^.,^- 8”:: L?i “_ -_.

“__., “I 7”. -.a.- 78; ii; 54; 30.1 86; 35: 511 4OT;IR

._. 5Y.33 -_ -_.

1; _-._.

I 38.1%' 615 1198,CA $Y68 $376 : 69% 36; 33 Si2%, 47 I(” 1198 CA -&c\iss io117 ! m . -. - , -,

cvmi 1,X=%,8 ; E. 33: 58; 3j.W! - -- - “, ‘8 ; 89: 35; 54: 39.1.“. --._-

--.- .- . ..-?a *l-l fs% 59.4d

. ,“. 62.9! WA

-.--

-.-.-. ---. CY66 :0101 : 78: 44: 43.f

- 1: 27' 571 32Ti .c__- CY66 '0281 ’ 68: 24; 44 -~~, 35.3%,

---- - J:

--=- 43.9%:

CY66 -‘-----

:0128 :~ ‘02. 5z -- 43: 576%: 42.24 10254 I

.L.eI--p- !CY86 f3E 371 281 56.9%; --

_. - .__ .-._

_ ..-J98.Ol-l iCYO4 7233 I g@ 24: ---..-_I’ 66j -. 23 ._, ,'"95 : 71: 22: ,/n. “1 ““l.

:,9R, CA ! cvrw *!T -“I

dn’ --I

AS _“I

A7 4%’ -, . I”, 52.-.

79: 31; 48: ..-.

39.2%; 80.84 6 1024 10 I 85; 37!

(~^-------- 401

*^ ““, 4J.oYc; 5

R 09, AR k +nr;oA ” . . 7”. 7”) ““.“,” ---

4 I 88 61 42i /-

52.:

I---- I CY66 :0113 : 84 36: 48;

-i/9$ OH ._~

-_ ICY04 14229 i _--.

811 24: 57i 29.6%: ?i%. 02/05/98:OH xii04 ;4237 84

i”,OR---+--X 26; 58: 31.0%, imd

;igT*.A-p>-&?g RA. 511: !iii&c--- ,_.__ ,_.__ -- -- -- __,_._ : CVRR ‘rllln TiF

i-_-.-i 32 5s !%%A%’ __. _- __.__, _, .

+ ,_. .- 4213-= 77i

--. 44j

__.-._ _-._.- ,CYO4t-- 33)

_._Ic_____- ..___- J 822 02lO8l98:OH 42.9%: 57.1% 823 02/07/9&CA ; CY66

I_- ,011l iii- 2s; 5q 30.6ik

-.-- / 69.4%

824 02/07/98.CA : c-Y86 :0130 ; 66; 25: 41: 37.9%: 62.1% 825 02/07/98:OH ~.~ ,...__ --- poll L4230 ! 78i _ 371 41, 826 02/09/98:CA :cy66 :0104 85: : 48' 37;

. :

05/25f-2000 In ResponsetoTr.Vol. 19pqe 8104 lines3-7 Page 15

A 1. B I C I D 1 E I F I G I H I I 1 Date I StateCodei UnitCode ! Ret _ ~-...---l-_“_, Jotal Tallies ! lnskte Talllss~Outsh3e Tallies InsidePercent: Outsiie Pe

827 02/09/98.CA : CY66 10116 ' 83, --- 22; --.--~-. -,.__ ~_-.--.----,-_.~-

ICY04 .-_j_ 38:

61' _ 26~5% -_ _ 828 02/09/98:OH !4221 i ------& - 54 41.3%: -- _ .~..._.^ .~..--._.- --- 829 02/10198:OH ICY04 !43n7 ! 11e”. AA:

-TATrv-g$ 43: _-. Afi; .-. 47 7% ,- . ---_,..-

830 02l11198.OH ICY04 .:= --g$ 54: 37.2%: , -_-_-- --. .--- 831 02/12/98OH tJ8: 43: 832 02/18/98'0H 95i 43' 633 02/20/98:OH ,,I - a' _ .._ -.- i..--. ws.4 nlnrroa'nu

j EE;s;! iv,“-. /Y&“-r i 15: 2: 13: --F"fi" ---

"=-=- 69: ; 427 47:

8z I 472%

35: 47, 42.7O% A--.-_. CYO4 14224 I 861 3?i w 37.:

84; 39; 45, 46.4% --ia

-- m-a: C,I 2-l noL:

:4225 : --_. 14236 I .-~II_-- 84257 ; 14258 j

Yli I”. .,I,

94: 44 50. -:I?----- 791 33: -6 37; ST--

", ."I".

-90: 81'

43; -.’ ii: 47. 34; 47, 42:.-m

/ 58: 17; 41: 29.3%*--' _."_ I__.. i 121 0: 12; o.o-%; ii -_

'M43 84: ; 34; 50: 40;& ?-.-.. 11 I 741 291 45 39.2%i 60.8% 7? / 49: 24: 25:- 49.0%: 51.0%

. .


At Tr. 19/8089,8090 Commissioner LeBlanc asked for the percentage of mail volume by accountables, flats, letters, parcels from the Engineered Study and a comparison of this information to the results of the city carrier cost system samples to determine consistency. He also requested variability information on the percentage of mail volume.

RESPONSE:

The following is the aggregate percentage data by mail type from the

Engineered Study:

Mail Types

ES Random ES USPS LR-I-163 Sites Picked Sites Routes

Ave # Percentages Ave # Percentages Ave # Percentages Pieced Pieces/ Pieces/ Route Route Route

.-.- DPS 1092.00 45.45 1188.00 47.81 1157.00 48.87

Accountables 8.25 0.28 4.00 0.18 4.20 0.17

Parcels 32.40 1.35 25.30 1 .Ol 28.10 1.08

Total 2402.85 100.00 2495.30 100.00 2488.30 100.00

The following CCS data was supplied to me by the United States Postal Service

and the data compares very closely to the above ES data.

PIECES PER POSSIBLE DELIVERY AND PIECES PER ROUTE DAY FROM FY 1997 CCS

I I Aw # I I Avg # I I

Mail Types

Letters (including

Pieces/Route Percentages Pieces/Possible Percentages Day Delivery

1,819.O 73.74% 3.286 73.72%

- DPS) Flats 544.4 24.80% 1.100 24.84%

DPS N/A N/A

Accountables 4.4 0.20% ,008 0.18%

Parcels 27.7 1.28% ,055 1.25% Total 2,195.4 100.00% 4.430 100.00%


PIECES PER POSSIBLE DELIVERY AND PIECE: S PER ROUTE DAY FROM

Avn f I FY 1998 CCS

Avg # ..w .. Pieces/Route Percentages Pieces/Possible Percentages

Day Delivery 1,708.4 73.39% 3.433 73.38%

586.2 25.21% 1.180 25.23%

N/A N/A

Mail Types

Letters (including DPS) Flats I-IPS

&ountables 4.4 fi1.19% ,008 0.17%

Parcels 28.3 1.22% 0.057 1.22% .- Total 2,325.3 ,i JO.OO% 4.679 100.00%

The following are examples showing the variation in piece volume and

percentage change in mail mix from multiple day studies of the same route:



Following is a summary of the above route days by route:

Minimum Parcel % 0.04 ) Tuesday, July 08,1997 1.07 Thursday. August 14,1997 Maximum Parcel % 1.84 1 Friday, July 18,1997 3.52 Tuesday, August 05,1997 Average Parcel % 0.72 1 2.15


The following is a view of multiple route days that will assist in seeing the

variability of pieces per possible delivery point from day to day on the same

CYM IA243 -._. .-._ CY04 4243 CY04 4243 CY04 4243 CY04 4243 CY04 4243 CY04 424: CY04 424b CYO4, 4243 CY04 42, CY04 42-4

July “L, Saturday, July 05, IS Monday, Julv 07~

Tues+-’ Wednesaay, my utl,

Ibarumay, July I‘,

roure:


-_ _.. _.- 2828 7.802151 2982 7.982366

=0Dp 5.973118 5DP 8.216031

L- . - - . , -. . - 634 1

m-m ^ _

634 1343 2.11 834 1859 , *!a

Low *=--” a Ave,. - High #Pcs/ur I s.l31M11

I hA7

-.-. 11 A75

-7,” 848 3696 4.358491 CY47 1475 848 2571 3.03184 CY47 1475 .--, 1997 848 3457 4.076851 CY47 1475 397 848 4150 4.893868 CY47 1475 a7 848 3235 3.814858 CY47 1475 J97 848 2343 2.782972 CY47 1475 -, 1997 848 3321 3.918274


-.-. . ..- --.-.- I,( “I. .-, .” CY47 1475 Monday, July 14,19( CY47 1475 Tuesday, July 15. 19 CY47 1475 Wednesday, July 18. CY47 1475 Friday, July 18, lBB7 --.. CY47 1415 Saturday, July 19, IQ CY47 1475 Monday, July 21,19$ CY47 1475 Tuesday, July 22,19 CY47 1475 Wednesday, July CY47 1475 Friday, July 25.1 S97

4.476 ra

I I

351 ,-.--, .-7 351 2: - -, . - -. lh7ll.d 97 1M7 351

2831997 351 1 , . .- --. - - , 1997 351 -

--_. _., I !F., I

--. ---. .-

,.““-A “I

I Ir;ll 9A

r

DECLARATION

I, Lloyd B. Raymond, declare under penalty of pejuty that the foregoing answers are

true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief.

/ H

Date: 6 - 2 - 0 c,

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing document upon all

participants of record in this proceeding in accordance with section 12 of the Rules of

Practice.

Richard T.‘Cooper /

475 L’Enfant Plaza West, S.W. Washington, DC. 20260-l 137 June 2,200O

Date post:	02-Nov-2020
Category:	Documents
Upload:	others
View:	0 times
Download:	0 times

Before The Ju# 2 11 30 f’fl ‘00 POSTAL RATE COMMISSION ...Secure Site Raymond to questions posed...

Documents