Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 1 of 33
Before the
MAHARASHTRA ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION
World Trade Centre, Centre No.1, 13th Floor, Cuffe Parade, Mumbai – 400 005
Tel. 022 22163964/ 65/ 69 Fax 022 22163976
Email: [email protected]
Website: www.mercindia.org.in / www.merc.gov.in
Case No. 112 of 2014
In the matter of
Application of Tata Power Company Limited for grant of Transmission Licence
Smt. Chandra Iyengar, Chairperson
Shri Vijay L. Sonavane, Member
Shri Azeez M. Khan, Member
The TaTa Power Company Limited,
Bombay House,
24, Homi Mody Street,
Mumbai – 400 001 ……..Applicant
ORDER
Dated: 14 August, 2014
1. Introduction
1.1. The Tata Power Company Limited (TPC) is a Company incorporated on 18
September, 1919 and registered under the Indian Companies Act, VII of 1913.
1.2. TPC owns and operates around 1140 ckt.km. of Transmission Lines at 220 kV / 110
kV with 20 Receiving Stations spread across Mumbai having a transformation
capacity of around 8873 MVA as on 31 March, 2014.
1.3. Since TPC’s existing Licence expires on 15 August, 2014, TPC submitted an
Application for grant of a Transmission Licence on 23 May, 2014 in accordance
with Sections 14 and 15 of the Electricity Act, 2003 (EA 2003) read with
Regulations 4 and 13 of MERC (Transmission Licence Conditions) Regulations,
2004 along with its Amendment in 2006 (“Transmission Licence Conditions
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 2 of 33
Regulations”)for a period of 25 years commencing from 16 August, 2014, for the
transmission of electricity as follows:
a. Area of transmission covering Mumbai city, Mumbai suburban area and Mira
Bhayandar Municipal Corporation (together called ‘Mumbai Transmission
Area’);
b. All existing Transmission Receiving Stations (including those outside the
Mumbai Area) forming part of the Intra-State Transmission System of
Maharashtra;
c. All existing Transmission Lines of TPC entering Mumbai, forming a part of the
Intra-State Transmission System of Maharashtra; and
d. All proposed Transmission Lines and Transmission Receiving Stations as
mentioned at Annexures 8 and 9 of its Application.
1.4. TPC has made the following prayers in its Application:
“
a. Admit the present Application along with the attached documents, submitted by
Tata Power for the grant of Transmission Licence under Section 14 and 15 read
with Section 86(1)(d) of the Electricity Act 2003, and in pursuance of MERC
(Transmission Licence Conditions)Regulations, 2004 including amendments
thereof;
b. Grant Transmission Licence to Tata Power for a period of 25 years with effect
from 16th August, 2014, in accordance with the provision of Section 14 read and
15 of Electricity Act, 2003, read with MERC (Transmission Licence
Conditions)Regulations, 2004 including amendments thereof, for the
Transmission in Mumbai City , the Mumbai Suburban Area, Mira Bhayandar
Municipal Corporation (viz. Mumbai Transmission Area), all existing
Transmission Receiving Stations, all Transmission Lines of Tata Power entering
Mumbai forming a part of intra-State transmission system (InSTS) of
Maharashtra and all proposed Transmission Lines and Transmission Receiving
Stations by Tata Power.
c. Condone any inadvertent omissions/ errors/ shortcomings and permit Tata Power
to add/ change/ modify/ alter this filing and make further submissions as may be
required at a future date; and
d. Any other relief that Hon’ble Commission may deem fit.”
1.5. TPC also forwarded a copy of its Application to the State Transmission Utility
(STU) vide letter dated 27 May, 2014.
2. Regulatory Proceedings:
2.1. Based on preliminary scrutiny of the Application in accordance with Regulation 5.1
of the MERC (Transmission Licence Conditions) Regulations, 2004 as amended in
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 3 of 33
2006, the Commission conveyed the following data gaps and sought the following
information, documents and clarifications from TPC vide e-mails dated 31 May and
2 June, 2014:
a. Inconsistency observed in the data on transformation capacity and length of the
Transmission Lines.
b. An undertaking, as per the format provided by the Commission, in accordance
with Transmission Licence Regulations.
c. Specification of the Transmission Lines that originate from and terminate at
Receiving Stations of other Transmission Licensees, and the voltage ratings of
existing Receiving Stations.
d. Details of TPC’s Receiving Stations located outside Mumbai, along with their
year of commissioning.
e. Capacity of Transmission Lines used for transmitting power from outside
Mumbai to Mumbai, and the capacity addition planned for these lines in the next
5 financial years.
f. The names of the promoters, along with their respective ownership percentage,
with appropriate modification in Schedule 1 or revising the date in Schedule 1 in
accordance with TPC’s submission.
g. Management information with respect to the Information Technology (IT)
functions.
h. Clarification on the inconsistency in the number of Receiving Stations
considering that in Annexure 7B of the Application. TPC has furnished details of
20 Receiving Stations, whereas Annexure 7C pertaining to the number of bays at
each Receiving Stations, provides details of 24 Receiving Stations. Moreover, the
Commission noted that it had not approved the “Dehrand-Nagothane
Transmission Line” which TPC has included in the list of proposed Transmission
Lines so approved.
i. Resubmission of the Single Line Diagram (SLD) for the proposed Transmission
Lines and existing Transmission Lines, clearly differentiating the proposed from
the existing Transmission Lines.
j. List of streets or parts of streets for which TPC has obtained authorisation to
undertake transmission work in the proposed area.
k. Data pertaining to existing and proposed systems in the following format:
i. Existing System – Transmission Lines with voltage levels, line name,
originating and receiving point, layout and ckt.km length;
ii. Existing System – List of EHV Substation Bays with Receiving Station
name, voltage level and number of bays;
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 4 of 33
iii. Proposed System – Transmission Lines with voltage levels, line name,
originating and receiving point, layout, ckt.km length with STU and the
Commission’s approval;
iv. Proposed System – List of EHV Substation Bays with Receiving Station
name, voltage level, number of bays with STU and the Commission’s
approval; and
v. Transmission Systems submitted to the Commission and STU for
approval.
l. Commission’s approval letter date and number (pertaining to capital
investments), and dates of submission of Capex proposals for schemes which are
not yet approved by the Commission.
2.2. The Commission held the Technical Validation Session (TVS) on 3 June, 2014,
when TPC made a presentation on its competencies, technological best practices
adopted by it, current transmission assets and plan for future Transmission Lines.
2.3. TPC also elaborated the provisions of EA 2003 and the MERC Transmission
Licence Regulations to support its contention that an Area Specific Licence can be
granted by the Commission. TPC requested the Commission to grant it an Area
Specific Licence for Mumbai Area and a Line Specific Licence for Transmission
Lines which are proposed to bring power from outside to the Mumbai area.
2.4. On 4 June, 2014, TPC submitted its response in respect of the data gaps identified
by the Commission, as follows:
a. Details of length of Transmission Lines and the transformation capacity were
provided.
b. TPC would submit the undertaking sought by the Commission shortly and
requested the Commission to admit its Application in the meantime.
c. Details of Transmission Lines originating from or terminating at Receiving
Stations of other Transmission Licensees, and the voltage rating of existing
Receiving Stations were submitted.
d. Details of year of commissioning and purpose of Receiving Stations at IXORA,
Panvel and Ambernath, which are located outside the Mumbai Area.
e. The current capacity of the tie lines for import of power to Mumbai was stated to
be around 1710 MW without any security margin. TPC also submitted details of
the additional schemes planned for enhancing import capacity.
f. Details of the share holding pattern as on 31 March, 2014. TPC also mentioned
that its website is yet to be updated and only the shareholding pattern as on 31
December 2013 has been uploaded.
g. The management information pertaining to IT functions.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 5 of 33
h. TPC clarified that the Grant Road Sub-Station has no transformer but only bays.
Accordingly, it has not been considered in the list of existing Receiving Stations
under TPC. The Receiving Stations at Davdi and Central Railway (Wadala) are
consumer funded schemes and have not been considered in the list of existing
Receiving Stations. Further, the bays in the Maharashtra State Electricity
Transmission Company Limited’s (MSETCL) Receiving Stations which are
maintained by TPC have been included (along with the Receiving Stations) in the
list of bays pertaining to Receiving Stations maintained by TPC.
i. The Commission had given in-principle approval to the Dehrand-Nagothane
Transmission Line vide letter No. MERC/CAPEX/20112012/01103 dated 27
July, 2011. It was resubmitted to the Commission only for approval of the revised
capital cost. Accordingly, the Transmission Line has been listed in both the
categories, viz., “Approved by MERC” and “To be approved by MERC”.
j. TPC submitted the revised Single Line Diagram (SLD), and stated that not all the
Receiving Stations proposed had been shown in the revised SLD as the incoming
lines for some of the Receiving Stations are still to be identified.
k. The streets which are required to be repaired/ dug up for the purpose of laying
cables or lines are under the purview of the Local Authorities. TPC submitted a
list of authorities from whom permissions have been sought for laying
Transmission Lines and cables.
l. Data on the existing and proposed transmission system has been submitted in the
format specified. TPC also submitted details of STU and Commission approvals
pertaining to various Transmission Systems.
2.5. TPC also submitted that certain submissions that had been made by it were
erroneous. Accordingly, it submitted a revised Application for grant of
Transmission Licence fulfilling the data gaps identified by the Commission, on 5
June, 2014.
2.6. After verification, the Commission found the revised Application to be complete
and accompanied with the requisite information, particulars and documents.
2.7. The Commission accordingly admitted TPC’s revised Application for grant of
Transmission Licence on 11 June, 2014 vide letter no. MERC/Case No. 112 of
2014/20142015/00500. The Commission directed TPC to furnish an undertaking as
per the Transmission Licence Regulations and to issue a Public Notice in
accordance with Section 15(2) of EA 2003 read with Regulation 6 of the
Transmission Licence Regulations. TPC was also directed to serve a copy of its
Application to the Chief Engineer, STU in accordance with Section 15(3) of EA
2003.
2.8. TPC submitted the undertaking on 14 July, 2014. TPC also published a Notice of its
Application in two English language (DNA and Financial Express) and two Marathi
language (Loksatta and Prahar) newspapers on 13 June, 2014. A copy of the
Application along with enclosures was made available on TPC’s website.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 6 of 33
2.9. In reply to TPC’s letter to STU dated 27 May, 2014, STU provided its
recommendation for the grant of Transmission Licence vide letter no.
MSETCL/CO/C.E-STU/007519 dated 27 June, 2014.
2.10. Section 15(2)(ii) of EA 2003 provides that if an Application for a Licence is
received for an area including the whole or any part of any cantonment, aerodrome,
fortress, arsenal, dockyard or camp or of any building or place in the occupation of
the Central Government for defence purposes, no objection to the grant of the
Licence on the part of the Central Government needs to be ascertained.
2.11. Accordingly, the Commission issued letter no. MERC/Case No. 112 of
2014/00701/11072014 dated 11July, 2014 to the Ministry of Defence, Ministry of
Shipping and Ministry of Civil Aviation inviting objection(s), if any, with reference
to TPC’s Application. The Commission did not receive any objections in this
respect within two weeks as had been stipulated.
2.12. After evaluating the Application submitted by TPC and considering the
recommendations of the STU, the Commission published a Public Notice on 17
July, 2014 in two English (DNA and The Times of India) and two Marathi
(Loksatta and Maharashtra Times) newspapers stating the details of the proposed
Transmission Licence Application as submitted by TPC in accordance with Section
15(5)(a) of the EA 2003. The Notice specified that the Commission is proposing to
grant a Transmission Licence to TPC under Alternative 2 of its Transmission
Licence Regulations. Suggestions or objections were invited by 7 August, 2014,
and it was stated that the Public Hearing would be held on 12 August, 2014 at the
office of the Commission (World Trade Centre, Centre 1, 13th Floor, Cuffe Parade,
Mumbai 400 005).
2.13. The Public Hearing was held accordingly on 12 August, 2014. TPC and STU were
represented by their respective officials. The list of persons who were present is at
Annexure II.
2.14. During the hearing, TPC made a presentation on TPC’s history in the transmission
business and steps taken to improve the quality and efficiency of transmission. TPC
reiterated its claim for a combination of (i) Licence for Mumbai Transmission Area
and (ii) Licence for Receiving Stations (or Transmission Receiving Stations) and
Transmission Lines which are situated outside Mumbai Area but are owned by it or
proposed to be constructed and owned by it in future and which would form a part
of the Intra-State Transmission System (InSTS) of Maharashtra.
2.15. At the Public Hearing, the representative of STU reiterated its recommendations
dated 27 June, 2014.
3. Objections/ Suggestions
3.1. In response to the Public Notice on the grant of Transmission Licence to TPC, the
Commission received no objections from the Central Government.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 7 of 33
3.2. The Commission received two objections/ suggestions, as set out below along with
TPC’s response and the Commission’s view.
Objection/Suggestion of Shri Ulhas Chaudhari (Received within time)
3.3. While supporting the grant of Transmission Licence to TPC, Shri Ulhas Chaudhari
enquired whether TPC had, in past, provided transmission connections to the
consumers of R-Infra Ltd and BEST as required, or it planned to do so. Otherwise,
the Commission should make TPC responsible for making unwarranted
investments.
3.4. He suggested that consumers having consumption of more than 1 MW should be
kept under the ambit of the transmission tariff instead of distribution tariff. Such
consumers may also be declared as ones purchasing power under Open Access as
they have made investments. Further, earlier concession given to BEST on the
electricity provided through High Tension (110 kV) connections may be resumed.
This Concession should be provided through the transmission fund to BEST.
3.5. The investment proposed by TPC in its Transmission Business Plan for the period
from FY 2014-15 to FY 2019-20 is unwarranted. Approval should be given only to
those schemes that are necessary for capacity building and to meet the rise in
demand.
3.6. Shri Chaudhari also submitted that,
a. As per the report of Maharashtra Energy Development Agency (MEDA), 70%
electricity can be saved. No specific measures have been undertaken so far in
this regard;
b. ‘Green Buildings’ can save up to 10% electricity. Additionally, a minimum of
10% of the electricity requirements can be generated through solar rooftop
generation in buildings.
c. Energy audit of consumption of power in buildings has not been done since long;
d. The Commission should make efforts to ensure completion of projects like the
Green Liquefied Gas Line project. Approval to the projects proposed by TPC will
harm the environment; and
3.7. There is no longer any excavation and back-filling potential in Mumbai and
whatever land is available should be utilized judiciously.
TPC’s Reply
3.8. Vide letter dated 7 August, 2014, TPC responded that the transmission outlets
requested by R-Infra and BEST from TPC’s transmission system have been given
after approval from STU. Further, any capital investment is taken up after due
approvals from STU.
3.9. Any consumer can avail of Open Access on the Transmission System by following
the procedure specified in MERC (Transmission Open Access) Regulations, 2014,
and TPC would play the role of non-discriminatory Open Access provider.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 8 of 33
3.10. All capital investments related to the transmission network are made as per the STU
Plan, and only after approval of the Commission as well as STU.
Commission’s view
3.11. As regards the objections set out at paras 3.3 and 3.5 above, the Commission has
noted TPC’s reply. All capital expenditures undertaken by TPC are to be carried out
as per the approvals of the Commission and STU. The Commission undertakes
appropriate scrutiny of the proposed schemes prior to granting such approvals.
3.12. As regards the objections set out at para 3.4, any consumer can avail of Open
Access on the Transmission System by following the procedure specified in the
MERC (Transmission Open Access) Regulations, 2014. The issue of tariff for
consumers connected to High Tension Line (110 KV) is not relevant to grant of
Transmission Licence to TPC and may be raised in the proceedings relating to the
Tariff Petition of Distribution Licensee.
Objection/Suggestion of Shri Prashant K Zaveri (Received after the due date)
3.13. Shri Prashant K Zaveri has stated that the Supreme Court has passed recent Orders
to grant the Licence. He stated that the monopoly of BEST must end and healthy
competition must be promoted in light of the reforms in the power sector and global
investments. Since TPC is supplying directly, its per unit cost will be less than that
of BEST. TPC has been providing better service than BEST for the last several
years. With this consideration, TPC should be granted the Transmission Licence.
TPC’s Reply
3.14. TPC has stated that it understood that Shri. Zaveri is in favour of grant of
Transmission Licence to TPC. The other suggestions/objections made pertain to
Distribution Licence, which is not the subject matter of the current Application of
TPC.
Commission’s View
3.15. The objection/suggestions of Shri. Zaveri relate to competition in distribution of
electricity and are not the subject matter of the present Application for grant of
Transmission Licence.
4. Submissions of the Applicant
4.1. TPC had submitted that the following four Licences had been issued to its
predecessors under the erstwhile Indian Electricity Act, 1910 to supply electricity in
and around Mumbai, which have been amended from time to time by the Industries,
Energy and Labour Department, Government of Maharashtra:
a. The 1907 Licence: The Bombay (Hydro-Electric) Licence dated 7 March, 1907
was originally granted to Dorabji J. Tata and Ruttonji J Tata. This Licence was
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 9 of 33
assigned on 7 September, 1910 in favour of the Tata Hydro Electric Power
Supply Co. Ltd.;
b. The 1919 Licence: The Andhra Valley (Hydro-Electric) Licence dated 3 April,
1919 was issued in favour of the Tata Hydro-Electric Power Supply Co. Ltd.;
c. The 1921 Licence: The Nila Mula Valley (Hydro-Electric) Licence, 1921 dated
15 November, 1921 was issued in favour of Tata Power; and
d. The 1953 Licence: The Trombay Thermal Power Electric Licence, 1953 dated 19
November, 1953 in favour of Tata Hydro-Electric Supply Co. Ltd., The Andhra
Valley Power Co. Ltd. and Tata Power.
4.2. On 18 October, 2000, Bombay High Court passed a Judgment in Petition No. 828
of 2000 connected with Company Application No. 336 of 2000, amalgamating the
Tata Hydro-Electric Power Supply Co. Ltd. and the Andhra Valley Power
Supply Co. Ltd. with the Applicant. Pursuant to that Judgment, the transferor
Companies (i.e., Tata Hydro-Electric 'Power Supply Co. Ltd. and the Andhra
Valley Power Supply Co. Ltd.) stood dissolved and all the approvals, consents,
licences, registration, etc. connected with or related to the undertaking of the
transferor entities stood automatically transferred to TPC with effect from 1
April, 2000.
4.3. Upon sanction of the amalgamation by Bombay High Court by its Judgment dated
18 October 2000, the Government of Maharashtra, by its Resolution No.
lEA-2001/CR-10509/NRG-1 dated 12 July, 2001 gave its consent for the transfer
of the 1907 Licence, 1919 Licence and 1953 Licence to the Applicant. The
Government of Maharashtra, vide its Notification No. LTT. 6789/C.R.-
1459(iv)/NRG-2 dated 14 June, 1991, extended the validity period outlined under
Clause 14 of these Licences up to 15 August, 2014.
4.4. In the view of the above, TPC has submitted the Application in accordance with the
provisions of Sections 14, 15 and 81(1)(d) of the EA 2003 and its Amendments,
and as per the provisions of Transmission Licence Regulations. The Application
was made as per Schedule 1 under the Transmission Licence Regulations with the
requisite enclosures.
4.5. In accordance with Schedule 1 of Transmission Licence Regulations, TPC
submitted details of incorporation of the Company, address of the registered office,
technical information such as area of transmission, existing and proposed
transmission network, financial information, list of defence areas and streets, copy
of processing fees and an undertaking.
4.6. In its Application, TPC has sought a combination of (i) Licence for Mumbai
Transmission Area and (ii) Licence for Receiving Stations (or Transmission
Receiving Stations) and Transmission Lines which are situated outside the Mumbai
Area that are owned by it or proposed to be constructed and owned by it, in future
and which would form a part of the Intra-State Transmission system (InSTS) of
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 10 of 33
Maharashtra. TPC submitted the reasons for seeking a Transmission Licence for
such combination as below:
a. Its transmission system in and around Mumbai cannot be identified as a single
transmission project with agglomeration of Transmission Lines. The existing
transmission network comprises composite schemes of over 20 transmission
Receiving Stations with over 1100 Ckt. Km of transmission network of overhead
lines. It also includes underground cables (220 kV/110 kV/33 kV/22 kV) that
cater to the transmission requirement of entire Mumbai and its suburban areas.
Further, it connects Generating Stations at Trombay as well as Hydro Generating
Stations at Bhira, Bhivpuri and Khopoli.
b. As for improvement in the Transmission System, several schemes would be
undertaken. Such schemes may range from large schemes such as setting up of
Transmission Line or setting up of a Receiving Station, to a small scheme such as
replacement of equipment like transformers.
c. Any modification in the form of addition of small equipment would entail
amendment to the Transmission Licence under Sections 15 or 18 of the EA 2003.
Further, each time an approval is granted by the Commission (under the Capital
Investment approval procedure) for execution of the scheme, it would require the
amendment to the Transmission Licence. This would be extremely cumbersome
and time consuming. Hence a Transmission Licence for specific schemes
pertaining to Transmission Systems may not be sufficient.
d. TPC’s transmission network is not restricted to the Mumbai Area alone. In
addition to feeding the loads of all the three Distribution Licensees in Mumbai,
i.e., R-Infra, BEST and TPC(Distribution), it is feeding around 250 MW of the
Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company Limited (MSEDCL) load
outside Mumbai, i.e., at Ambernath, Kalyan, Kolshet (Thane District) and
Salsette (Bhandup), in addition to MSEDCL load in North West Mumbai from
Saki Station. TPC is also feeding MSEDCL load at Neral through its Bhivpuri –
Ambernath lines which are outside the Mumbai Area.
e. TPC has existing transmission assets outside Mumbai, and has proposed to
construct 400 kV lines from the State Transmission Grid /National Grid along
with a 400 kV ring system, which would bring power from outside Mumbai to
Mumbai. This would take care of the future load growth of all the four
Distribution Licensees in Mumbai city. Accordingly, the grant of a Transmission
Licence for the Mumbai Area alone would not be adequate to undertake the
schemes pertaining to the existing and proposed transmission business activity by
TPC.
4.7. Alternatively, the Commission could grant a Transmission Licence for the entire
State of Maharashtra.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 11 of 33
5. Compliance Evaluation and Analysis by the Commission
5.1. The Commission verified the submissions of the Applicant in relation to
compliance with the Schedule 1 of Transmission Licence Regulations as below:
Sr. No. Particulars Submission
1 General Information – Name, Primary Contact details Submitted
2 Information about the applicant – Registered office, date
of incorporation etc. Submitted
3 Enclosures – Incorporation documents Submitted
4 Enclosures – Technical Information Submitted
5 Description of the actual and proposed location of the
system of electric lines Submitted
6 Detailed map of the proposed area of transmission Submitted
7 List of defence areas Submitted
8 List of street(s) which are repairable Submitted
9 Financial Information Submitted
10 Copy of receipt of processing fees Submitted
5.2. During verification, the Commission noted that the undertaking envisaged in the
Transmission Licence Regulations had not been provided and directed TPC to
submit it. TPC submitted the undertaking on 14 July, 2014 in the format specified
by the Commission.
5.3. The Commission noted that the TPC’s submissions are in compliance with EA
2003 and its Transmission Licence Regulations.
5.4. The Commission evaluated the claims of TPC as per the provisions of EA 2003 and
Transmission Licence Regulations and has considered the recommendations
provided by the STU on the grant of Transmission Licence to TPC.
5.5. In its Application, TPC has referred to Section 14 of the EA 2003, and claimed that
the Commission can grant Licence to an Applicant in any area as specified in the
Licence. TPC also contended that Regulation 13 of the Transmission Licence
Regulations stipulate that the area of transmission of the Transmission Licensee
shall be the area as specified in the Licence.
5.6. The Commission notes that Para 3 – Part II – General Terms and Conditions in
Schedule II of its Transmission Licence Regulations provides for two alternatives
for the grant of Transmission Licence:
a. Alternative 1: The area of Transmission shall be the State of Maharashtra; and
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 12 of 33
b. Alternative 2: The Licence authorises the Transmission Licensee to establish and
operate certain specific Transmission Lines (i.e., Line Based Transmission
Licence)
5.7. In accordance with Alternative 1 set out above, the Transmission Licence can be
granted for the area which is the entire State of Maharashtra. Any area lesser than
this does not qualify under Alternative 1. Hence, the Commission rejects the claim
of TPC for grant of Transmission Licence for the Mumbai Transmission Area.
5.8. In its Application, TPC has sought a combination of (i) Licence for Mumbai
Transmission Area and (ii) Licence for Receiving Stations (or Transmission
Receiving Stations) and Transmission Lines situated outside Mumbai Area which
are owned by it or proposed to be constructed and owned by it in future and which
would form a part of the Intra-State Transmission System of Maharashtra. TPC has
submitted the rationale for seeking Transmission Licence for such combination, and
intimated the STU accordingly for its recommendation vide letter dated 27 May,
2014.
5.9. In response, the STU has recommended the grant of Transmission Licence for a
combination of (i) Licence for the Mumbai Transmission Area and (ii) Licence for
Receiving Stations (or Transmission Receiving Stations) and Transmission Lines
situated outside Mumbai Area that are owned by TPC or proposed to be constructed
and owned by TPC in future and forming part of the Intra-State Transmission
System (InSTS) of Maharashtra, and which are in the STU plan approved by the
Commission. In its letter of recommendation dated 27 June, 2014, for grant of
Transmission Licence, the STU has also stated that:
a. As per the clarification dated 9 October, 2010 issued by the Ministry of Power
(MoP) regarding Clause 5.1 and Clause 7.1 of Tariff Policy, excepting
transmission projects for which Bulk Power Transmission Agreements (BPTAs) /
Transmission Service Agreements (TSAs) have been signed on or before 5 May,
2011, Tariff based Competitive Bidding shall be applicable for the remaining
projects.
b. The present power scenario in Mumbai is critical and there is an urgent need for
transmission system strengthening of the Mumbai power system considering the severe
Right of Way (RoW) issues, environmental norms and load growth in the Mumbai
Metropolitan area. TPC is already operating a transmission network in the Mumbai
Power Transmission System and has enough experience of successful execution of
transmission projects in and around Mumbai, and possesses all the technical
capabilities, capital adequacy, and managerial and administrative capacity to fulfil
the requirements of Sections 14 and 15 of the EA 2003 and the Commission’s
Transmission Licence Regulations.
c. In view of the above, STU has recommended that TPC be granted the
Transmission Licence for a combination of
i. Licence for Mumbai Transmission Area; and
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 13 of 33
ii. Licence for Transmission Receiving Stations and Transmission Lines
situated outside Mumbai Area that are owned by TPC or proposed to be
constructed and owned by TPC in future and forming part of the Intra-
State Transmission System of Maharashtra, and which are in STU plan
approved by the Commission.
d. While granting the Transmission Licence, the Commission may specify all the
conditions or any other relevant condition, which the Commission deems fit, for
Competitive Bidding.
5.10. The Commission noted the recommendation made by the STU. With regard to the
combination of Mumbai Area and Line Specific Licence to TPC, the Commission
has rejects the Area Basis Licence for reasons specified elsewhere.
5.11. The Commission’s views on grant of Transmission Licence for the entire State of
Maharashtra are as follows:-
a. The clarification dated 9 December, 2010 of the Ministry of Power relating to
Clause No. 5.1 & 7.1 of the Tariff Policy, makes it clear that all transmission
projects except transmission projects of STUs/CTU for upgradation/strengthening
of existing lines and associated sub-stations and projects for which
BPTA(s)/TSA(s) have been signed on or before 5 January, 2011, should be
through Competitive Bidding.
b. Clause 7.1(6) of the Tariff Policy provides that:
“Investment by transmission developer other than CTU/STU would be invited
through competitive bids. The Central Government will issue guidelines in three
months for bidding process for developing transmission capacities. The tariff of
the projects to be developed by CTU/STU after the period of five years or when
the Regulatory Commission is satisfied that the situation is right to introduce such
competition (as referred to in para 5.1) would also be determined on the basis of
competitive bidding.”
c. The Tariff Policy was notified by Ministry of Power vide Resolution No.
23/2/2005- R&R (Vol. III) dated 6 January, 2006. While, the substantive
provisions of the Tariff Policy came into effect from that date, the procedural part
concerning the issue of guidelines within three months for the bidding process for
developing transmission capacities was effected when the Ministry took the
following actions:
“(i) Notified the “Guidelines for Encouraging Competition in Development of
Transmission Projects” notified vide Resolution No. 11/5/2005-PG(ii) dated 13th
April, 2006 and were amended on 7 July 2007, 10 October 2008 and 2 May 2012
under the provision of Electricity Act 2003 published in the Gazette of India, Part
I, Section 1;
(ii) Constituted the Empowered Committee on 14th June 2006 to give effect to and
implement the provisions of “Guidelines for Encouraging Competition in
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 14 of 33
Development of Transmission Projects”;
(iii)Notified the “Tariff based Competitive-bidding Guidelines for Transmission
Service” on 17th April, 2006 vide Resolution No. 11/5/2005-PG(i) published in
the Gazette of India, Part I, Section 1.”
d. The “Tariff based Competitive-Bidding Guidelines for Transmission Service”,
made under the provisions of section 63 of the EA 2003 state that (under Clause
2.2) the Guidelines shall apply for procurement of transmission services for
transmission of electricity through Tariff based Competitive Bidding through the
mechanisms described in the Notification, and to select transmission service
provider for a new Transmission Line and to Build, Own, Maintain and Operate
the specified transmission system elements.
e. Clause 2.4 of the Guidelines provides that procurement of transmission services
would include all activities related to survey, detailed project report formulation,
arranging finance, project management, obtaining Transmission Licence,
obtaining right of way, necessary clearances, site identification, land
compensation, design, engineering, equipment, material, construction, erection,
testing and commissioning, maintenance and operation of Transmission Lines
and/or substations and/or switching stations and/or HVDC links, including
terminal stations and HVDC Transmission Line.
f. Clause 3.2 provides that, for procurement of transmission services required for
any inter-State Transmission Project, the Central Government shall notify any
Central Government Organization/ Central Public Sector Undertaking or its
wholly owned subsidiary (Special Purpose Vehicle) to be the Bid Process
Coordinator (BPC). The Ministry of Power may review the nomination of BPC at
any time. The Empowered Committee constituted under the “Guidelines for
encouraging competition in development of Transmission Projects” would be the
BPC till any other organization is nominated by the Ministry of Power.
g. For intra-State transmission, the Guidelines provide that –
“3.3. For procurement of transmission services required for intra-state
transmission, the appropriate State Government may notify any Organization/
State Public Sector Undertaking especially engaged for this purpose by the
appropriate state government or BPC notified by the Central Government to be
the BPC for the State.”
h. The Guidelines also require that the bid documentation be approved by the
Appropriate Commission, or the BPC could use the standard bidding documents
notified by Ministry of Power. Approval of the Appropriate Commission would
be necessary if any material deviation is proposed.
i. On the requirement of Transmission Licence, the Guidelines state that:-
“5.1. The successful bidder shall be designated as the Transmission Service
Provider (TSP), hereinafter referred to as the TSP, after executing the TSA and
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 15 of 33
acquiring the SPV. The TSP shall seek transmission license from the appropriate
Regulatory Commission, if it is not a deemed licensee. The TSA shall be effective
from the date of grant of license from the appropriate Regulatory Commission.”
j. The Guidelines also have provisions relating to Transmission Charge Structure,
Time Table for Bid Process, etc. In the clause on “Contract award and
conclusion” they state as under:-
“12.2. The TSP shall make an Application for grant of transmission license to the
Appropriate Commission within ten days of issuance of LOI or signing of TSA,
whichever is later”
k. The Commission specified that MSETCL, as the STU has the key responsibility
of network planning and development based on the National Electricity Plan in
co-ordination with the concerned agencies as provided in the EA 2003. The STU
is responsible for planning and development of the Intra-State Transmission
System [Paragraph 5.3.10 of the National Electricity Policy (NEP)]. The role and
functions of STU under Section 39 EA 2003 and as a Transmission Licensee
under Section 40 are different. Paragraph 5.3.10 of the NEP provides that –
“Special mechanisms would be created to encourage private investment in
transmission sector so that sufficient investments are made for achieving the
objective of demand to be fully met by 2012.”
l. The “Guidelines for Encouraging Competition in Development of Transmission
Projects” and the “Tariff based Competitive-Bidding Guidelines for Transmission
Service” further these aforesaid objectives. The STU is required to undertake
network expansion and procurement of transmission services through a
transparent bidding process.
5.12. In view of the above, the Commission notes that TPC cannot be granted
Transmission Licence for the entire State of Maharashtra considering that
paragraph 5.1 read with 7.1(6) of the Tariff Policy requires tariff based Competitive
Bidding for Transmission Services for the projects identified from the STU’s 5 year
Plan.
5.13. The Commission also noted the submission made by TPC regarding the
requirement of amendment to Licence each time there is a modification in schemes
if it is granted a Line Specific Licence. The Commission specifies that such Licence
is issued for Ckt. Km. of Transmission Lines and a certain number of bays. The
Applicant needs to state only the Ckt. Km of Transmission Lines and the number of
bays envisaged in its Application for grant of Transmission Licence. Only
additions, modification, or upgradation to lines and bays would require amendment
to the Transmission Licence.
5.14. The Commission observes that, for any modification or addition to the
Transmission Lines and bays, an appropriate evaluation has to be necessarily done
in accordance with the provisions of EA 2003 and MERC (Transmission Licence
Conditions) Regulations, 2004 as amended in 2006 before the approval can be
granted to the Applicant.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 16 of 33
5.15. The Commission, having considered the submissions made and material placed on
record and the provisions of law, is of the view that TPC satisfies the requirements
for the grant of Transmission Licence under Alternative 2 of its Transmission
Licence Regulations.
5.16. The Commission has verified the existing and proposed transmission schemes
submitted by TPC. The Commission notes that the number of transmission schemes
claimed by TPC was in variance with the schemes mentioned in the STU Five Year
Transmission Plan for FY 2014-15 to FY 2018-19. The Commission also noted
discrepancy in the data submitted by the Applicant and the STU Plan pertaining to
various schemes.
5.17. The Commission held a meeting with representatives of TPC on 22 July, 2014 and
verified the details of existing and proposed transmission systems. TPC clarified
that the scope of the proposed schemes were curtailed and clubbed while including
them in the STU Plan. The Commission directed TPC to submit revised details of
all the transmission schemes in accordance with the STU Plan for FY 2014-15 to
FY 2018-19 and to write to the STU to verify and confirm if the proposed
transmission schemes are correct and in order.
5.18. TPC submitted revised details of the transmission schemes as per the STU Plan to
the Commission under letter dated 23 July, 2014 and also requested STU to verify
and confirm if the proposed transmission schemes were correct and in order.
5.19. STU replied to the Commission on 25 July, 2014 that the proposed transmission
system mapped with the STU plan have been found to be correct and in order and
could be included in the Licence.
5.20. A meeting was also held with the STU, TPC and the Commission’s representatives
on 5 August, 2014 for reconciliation of the proposed schemes with the STU plan.
After reconciliation, TPC submitted revised Annexure 9 (a) & (b) along with 3
schemes which were not a part of the STU Plan but were approved by the
Commission and requested that these be included in the Transmission Licence.
5.21. The Commission has validated the proposed transmission schemes submitted as
above. It has considered the Transmission Lines and bays pertaining to schemes
that are included in the STU Plan, and also the three schemes which were approved
by it but not listed in the STU Plan.
5.22. Further, 16 Transmission Schemes proposed by TPC which are neither approved by
the Commission and STU nor included in the STU Plan are rejected. The
Commission directs TPC to approach the Commission on case to case basis for
these 16 Transmission Schemes.
5.23. The Commission, vide letter dated 8 August, 2014 directed TPC to validate the
existing transmission system information as submitted in Annexure 7.
5.24. Accordingly, on 11 August, 2014, TPC submitted a copy of the letter from
Maharashtra State Load Despatch Centre (MSLDC) Kalwa to the Commission.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 17 of 33
5.25. In its letter no. MSLDC/Tech-SO/1463/08082014 dated 08 August, 2014,
MSEDCL submitted that it has validated the details of TPC’s existing transmission
system based on:
a. Transmission system data of TPC being submitted to MSLDC on monthly basis
for certification of the Transmission System Availability; and
b. Details of existing transmission system data as on 31 March, 2014 submitted by
TPC along with the request for validation.
5.26. MSLDC stated that the validation has been done without any physical verification
due to time constraints.
5.27. The Commission considered the details of the existing transmission system as
validated by MSLDC, and has accordingly considered the Transmission Lines and
bays for the existing transmission network.
5.28. The Transmission Lines and bays pertaining to the existing and proposed
transmission schemes have been listed in Annexure I.
6. Grant of Transmission Licence:
6.1. In exercise of the powers vested in the Commission under Section 14 of EA 2003,
the Commission grants a Transmission Licence to TPC as a Transmission Licensee,
under Alternative 2, in accordance with the MERC (Transmission Licence
Conditions) Regulations, 2004 as amended in 2006, for a period of 25 years from
16 August, 2014.
6.2. This Transmission Licence is granted for the Transmission Lines and the Receiving
Stations (or Transmission Receiving Stations) located in and outside the Mumbai
area, owned by TPC or proposed to be constructed and owned by TPC in future and
forming part of Intra-State Transmission System of Maharashtra. The Transmission
Lines and Receiving Stations under the Licence are listed in Annexure I.
6.3. The Commission directs that the Transmission Licence as above be issued by the
Secretary of the Commission. It also directs its Registry to forward a copy to the
Government of Maharashtra, all Electricity Transmission Licensees and
Distribution Licensees in the State of Maharashtra, the Central Electricity
Authority, the concerned Local Authorities/Self-Governments (Municipal bodies)
of the area through which the Transmission Lines pass, and to upload it on the
website of the Commission.
6.4. The grant of Licence shall be subject to TPC complying with the provisions of the
EA 2003, the Rules framed by the Appropriate Government, applicable Regulations
and all tariff parameters specified under the Tariff Regulations by the Commission,
the guidelines for in-principle clearance of proposed investment schemes, and all
applicable statutes.
6.5. The Commission directs TPC to submit its Tariff filings to the Commission in
accordance with the applicable Regulations.
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 18 of 33
7. Summary of Rulings
7.1. The Commission notes that TPC has applied for a Transmission Licence from
16 August, 2014 as its existing Transmission Licence is expiring on 15 August,
2014. The Commission is of the view that TPC satisfies the requirements to
qualify for grant of such Transmission Licence in accordance with the MERC
(Transmission Licence Conditions) Regulations, 2004 as amended in 2006.
7.2. The Commission observes that TPC has claimed that Transmission Licence
can be granted by the Commission for any area under Section 14 of the EA
2003. The Commission has rejected this claim, since a Transmission Licence
cannot be granted for any area other than the entire State of Maharashtra in
terms of the provisions in its Regulations.
7.3. The Commission also rejects, for reasons detailed elsewhere in this Order,
TPC’s alternative claim for grant of a Licence for the whole of the State of
Maharashtra.
7.4. The Commission notes that TPC has sought grant of Transmission Licence for
a combination of (i) Mumbai Transmission Area and (ii) Receiving Stations (or
Transmission Receiving Stations) and Transmission Lines which are situated
outside Mumbai Area which are owned by it or proposed to be constructed
and owned by it, in future, which would form a part of the Intra-State
Transmission System of Maharashtra. The Commission rejects TPC’s claim
for grant of a Transmission Licence for the Mumbai Area, and holds that TPC
can be granted a Transmission Licence under Alternative 2 (i.e. Line Specific),
in accordance with the Transmission Licence Regulations for a period of 25
years from 16 August, 2014.
7.5. For the purpose of this Transmission Licence, the Commission has included all
the existing Transmission Systems as proposed by TPC. The Commission has
also included the proposed schemes which are approved by it and included in
the STU Plan, and the three schemes which were approved by it but not listed
in the STU Plan for the period FY 2014-15 to FY 2018-19. The details of these
Transmission Lines and bays are at Annexure I.
7.6. 16 Transmission Schemes proposed by TPC which are neither approved by the
Commission and STU nor included in the STU Plan are rejected. The
Commission directs TPC to approach the Commission on case to case basis for
these 16 Transmission Schemes.
The Commission disposes of the Application of TPC in Case No. 112 of 2014
accordingly.
Sd/- Sd/- Sd/-
(Azeez M. Khan) (Vijay L. Sonavane) (Chandra Iyengar)
Member Member Chairperson
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 19 of 33
Annexure I Transmission schemes approved under the Licence
Existing Transmission Lines:
1. 220 kV Bhira-Dharavi 7 Transmission Line (106.90 km) from Bhira Receiving
Station to Dharavi Receiving Station
2. 220 kV Bhira-Dharavi 8 Transmission Line (106.90 km) from Bhira Receiving
Station to Dharavi Receiving Station
3. 220 kV Borivali-Aarey 1 Transmission Line (0.47 km) from Borivali Receiving
Station to R-Infra Aarey Receiving Station
4. 220 kV Borivali-Aarey 2 Transmission Line (0.51 km) from Borivali Receiving
Station to R-Infra Aarey Receiving Station
5. 220 kV Dharavi-Backbay Transmission Line (17.16 km) from Dharavi Receiving
Station to Backbay Receiving Station
6. 220 kV Kalwa-Salsette 3 Transmission Line (7.77 km) from Kalwa Receiving
Station to Salsette Receiving Station
7. 220 kV Kalwa-Salsette 4 Transmission Line (7.77 km) from Kalwa Receiving
Station to Salsette Receiving Station
8. 220 kV Salsette-Borivali 1 Transmission Line (11.07 km) from Salsette Receiving
Station to Borivali Receiving Station
9. 220 kV Salsette-Borivali 2 Transmission Line (11.07 km) from Salsette Receiving
Station to Boriavli Receiving Station
10. 220 kV Tata Borivali-MSETCL Borivali 4 Transmission Line (1.70 km) from
Borivali Receiving Station to MSETCL Borivali Receiving Station
11. 220 kV Tata Borivali-MSETCL Borivali 5 Transmission Line (1.57 km) from
Borivali Receiving Station to MSETCL Borivali Receiving Station
12. 220 kV Trombay-Carnac 5 Transmission Line (12.39 km) from Trombay Receiving
Station to Carnac Receiving Station
13. 220 kV Trombay-Carnac 6 Transmission Line (12.39 km) from Trombay Receiving
Station to Carnac Receiving Station
14. 220 kV Trombay-Dharavi 5 Transmission Line (11.00 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Dharavi Receiving Station
15. 220 kV Trombay-Dharavi 6 Transmission Line (11.00 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Dharavi Receiving Station
16. 220 kV Trombay-MSETCL Tie 1 Transmission Line (0.85 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to MSETCL-Trombay Receiving Station
17. 220 kV Trombay-MSETCL Tie 2 Transmission Line (0.85 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to MSETCL-Trombay Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 20 of 33
18. 220 kV, 3 terminal line Trombay Salsette 1 Backbay Transmission Line (39.45 km)
originating at Trombay Receiving Station and terminating at Salsette Receiving
Station and Backbay Receiving Station
19. 220 kV Trombay-Dharavi 9 Transmission Line (10.69 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Dharavi Receiving Station
20. 220 kV Saki-Sahar Transmission Line (2.60 km) from Saki Receiving Station to
Sahar Receiving Station
21. 220 kV Kalwa-Salsette 6 Transmission Line (8.93 km) from MSETCL Kalwa
Receiving Station to Salsette Receiving Station
22. Intermediate spare section of 220 kV Trombay Salsette#2 Transmission Line (14.23
km) from Pratiksha Nagar to Location 12 (Near Bhandup Village) kept charged
from the Trombay Receiving Station
23. 220 kV Saki-Narayan Industrial Estate-Sahar Transmission Line (4.77 km) from
Saki Receiving Station to Sahar Receiving Station
24. 110 kV Ambernath-Kalyan 1 Transmission Line (19.85 km) from Ambernath
Receiving Station to Kalyan Receiving Station
25. 110 kV Ambernath-Kalyan 2 Transmission Line (19.85 km) from Ambernath
Receiving Station to Kalyan Receiving Station
26. 110 kV BMC-Kolshet Transmission Line (18.97 km) from BMC Receiving Station
to Kolshet Receiving Station
27. 110 kV Bhira-Davdi Transmission Line (10.13 km) from Bhira Receiving Station to
Davdi Receiving Station
28. 110 kV Bhira-Khopoli 2 Transmission Line (50.96 km) from Bhira Receiving
Station to Khopoli Receiving Station
29. 110 kV Bhivpuri-Ambernath 1 Transmission Line (46.48 km) from Bhivpuri
Receiving Station to Ambernath Receiving Station
30. 110 kV Borivali-Malad 1 Transmission Line (7.40 km) from Borivali Receiving
Station to Malad Receiving Station
31. 110 kV Borivali-Malad 2 Transmission Line (7.40 km) from Borivali Receiving
Station to Malad Receiving Station
32. 110 kV Carnac-Backbay 1 Transmission Line (4.01 km) from Carnac Receiving
Station to Backbay Receiving Station
33. 110 kV Carnac-Backbay 2 Transmission Line (4.00 km) from Carnac Receiving
Station to Backbay Receiving Station
34. 110 kV Carnac-Grant Road Transmission Line (3.60 km) from Carnac Receiving
Station to Grant Road Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 21 of 33
35. 110 kV Chola-Kalyan 1 Transmission Line (2.50 km) from Chola Receiving Station
to Kalyan Receiving Station
36. 110 kV Chola-Kalyan 2 Transmission Line (2.50 km) from Chola Receiving Station
to Kalyan Receiving Station
37. 110 kV Dharavi-Mahalaxmi Transmission Line (6.40 km) from Dharavi Receiving
Station to Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
38. 110 kV Dharavi-Vikhroli Transmission Line (10.78 km) from Dharavi Receiving
Station to Vikhroli Receiving Station
39. 110 kV Kalwa-Kalyan Transmission Line (16.80 km) from MSETCL Kalwa
Receiving Station to Kalyan Receiving Station
40. 110 kV, 3 terminal line Kalyan-Kalwa-Salsette 1 Transmission Line (23.30 km)
originating at Kalyan Receiving Station and terminating at MSETCL Kalwa
Receiving Station and Salsette Receiving Station
41. 110 kV, 3 terminal line Kalyan-Kalwa-Salsette 2 Transmission Line (22.84 km)
originating at Kalyan Receiving Station and terminating at MSETCL Kalwa
Receiving Station and Salsette Receiving Station
42. 110 kV Khopoli-Bhivpuri Tie Transmission Line (28.67 km) from Khopoli
Receiving Station to Bhivpuri Receiving Station
43. 110 kV Khopoli-Davdi Transmission Line (39.84 km) from Khopoli Receiving
Station to Davdi Receiving Station
44. 110 kV, 3 terminal line Khopoli-Lodhivali-Chembur Transmission Line (64.60 km)
originating at Khopoli Receiving Station and terminating at Lodhivali Receiving
Station and Chembur Receiving Station
45. 110 kV Khopoli-Mankhurd Transmission Line (56.27 km) from Khopoli Receiving
Station to Mankhurd Receiving Station
46. 110 kV Malad-Versova 1 Transmission Line (6.85 km) from Malad Receiving
Station to Versova Receiving Station
47. 110 kV Malad-Versova 2 Transmission Line (6.85 km) from Malad Receiving
Station to Versova Receiving Station
48. 110 kV Parel-Carnac Transmission Line (5.41 km) from Parel Receiving Station to
Carnac Receiving Station
49. 110 kV Parel-Grant Road Transmission Line (5.20 km) from Parel Receiving
Station to Grant Road Receiving Station
50. 110 kV Parel-Mahalaxmi 1 Transmission Line (2.85 km) from Parel Receiving
Station to Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
51. 110 kV Parel-Mankhurd Transmission Line (11.10 km) from Parel Receiving
Station to Mankhurd Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 22 of 33
52. 110 kV Parel-Mahalaxmi 2 Transmission Line (3.61 km) from Parel Receiving
Station to Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
53. 110 kV Salsette-BMC Transmission Line (3.41 km) from Salsette Receiving Station
to BMC Receiving Station
54. 110 kV Salsette-Kolshet Transmission Line (10.91 km) from Salsette Receiving
Station to Kolshet Receiving Station
55. 110 kV Salsette-Saki 3 Transmission Line (7.80 km) from Salsette Receiving
Station to Saki Receiving Station
56. 110 kV Salsette-Saki 4 Transmission Line (7.80 km) from Salsette Receiving
Station to Saki Receiving Station
57. 110 kV Salsette-Vikhroli Transmission Line (7.19 km) from Salsette Receiving
Station to Vikhroli Receiving Station
58. 110 kV Tata Ambernath-MSETCL Neral Transmission Line (40.35 km) from
Ambernath Receiving Station to MSETCL Neral Receiving Station
59. 110 kV Tata Bhivpuri-MSETCL Neral Transmission Line (12.06 km) from Bhivpuri
Receiving Station to MSETCL Neral Receiving Station
60. 110 kV Tata Borivali-MSETCL Borivali 1 Transmission Line (2.05 km) from
Borivali Receiving Station to MSETCL Borivali Receiving Station
61. 110 kV Tata Borivali-MSETCL Borivali 2 Transmission Line (2.05 km) from
Borivali Receiving Station to MSETCL Borivali Receiving Station
62. 110 kV Trombay-Carnac 1/3 Transmission Line (12.47 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Carnac Receiving Station
63. 110 kV Trombay-Chembur 1 Transmission Line (4.30 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Chembur Receiving Station
64. 110 kV Trombay-Chembur 2 Transmission Line (4.30 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Chembur Receiving Station
65. 110 kV Trombay-Chembur 3 Transmission Line (7.29 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Chembur Receiving Station
66. 110 kV Trombay-Dharavi 1 Transmission Line (10.36 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Dharavi Receiving Station
67. 110 kV Trombay-Dharavi 2 Transmission Line (10.36 km) from Trombay
Receiving Station to Dharavi Receiving Station
68. 110 kV Trombay-Parel 1 Transmission Line (9.10 km) from Trombay Receiving
Station to Parel Receiving Station
69. 110 kV Trombay-Parel 2 Transmission Line (8.69 km) from Trombay Receiving
Station to Parel Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 23 of 33
70. 110 kV, 3 terminal line Trombay-Parel 3/Carnac 2 Transmission Line (8.59 km)
originating at Trombay Receiving Station and terminating at Parel Receiving Station
and at Carnac Receiving Station
71. 110 kV Trombay-Parel 4 Transmission Line (10.12 km) from Trombay Receiving
Station to Parel Receiving Station
72. 110 kV Salsette-Powai Transmission Line (9.97 km) from Salsette Receiving
Station to Powai Receiving Station
73. 110 kV Dharavi-Powai Transmission Line (13.64 km) from Dharavi Receiving
Station to Powai Receiving Station
74. 110 kV Khopoli – CRSE 2 Transmission Line (1.02 km) from Khopoli Receiving
Station to Central Railway SE Receiving Station
75. Intermediate spare section of the 110 kV Bhira-Khopoli 2 Transmission Line (9.84
km) from Devnhave to Katkarwadi kept charged from Khopoli Receiving Station
76. 110 kV feeders to DISCOMS (4.18 km):
a. 110 kV Tata Backbay – BEST 1 feeder (0.14 km)
b. 110 kV Tata Backbay – BEST 2 feeder (0.13 km)
c. 110 kV Tata Backbay – BEST 3 feeder (0.12 km)
d. 110 kV Tata Backbay – Nariman Point 2 Sakharbhavan feeder (1.25 km)
e. 110 kV BEST Backbay – Nariman Point 1 Sakharbhavan feeder (1.20 km)
f. 110 kV Mahalaxmi – BEST 1 feeder (0.67 km)
g. 110 kV Mahalaxmi – BEST 2 feeder (0.67 km)
77. 110 kV feeders to Direct Consumers (10.91 km):
a. 110 kV Borivali – W Railway 1 feeder (2.70 km)
b. 110 kV Borivali – W Railway 2 feeder (2.70 km)
c. 110 kV Malad – W Railway 1 feeder (0.15 km)
d. 110 kV Malad – W Railway 2 feeder (0.15 km)
e. 110 kV Trombay – HPCL 1 feeder (1.90 km)
f. 110 kV Trombay – HPCL 2 feeder (1.90 km)
g. 110 kV Trombay – BARC 3 feeder (0.65 km)
h. 110 kV Trombay – BARC 4 feeder (0.65 km)
Existing bays at Sub-Stations
1. 7 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Backbay Receiving Station
2. 14 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Borivali Receiving Station
3. 6 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Carnac Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 24 of 33
4. 13 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Dharavi Receiving Station
5. 9 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Sahar Receiving Station
6. 9 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Saki Receiving Station
7. 15 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Salsette Receiving Station
8. 4 No. of 220 kV Bays at MSETCL Receiving Station
9. 12 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Ambernath Receiving Station
10. 12 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Backbay Receiving Station
11. 19 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Borivali Receiving Station
12. 14 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Carnac Receiving Station
13. 12 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Chembur Receiving Station
14. 25 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Dharavi Receiving Station
15. 3 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Grant Road Receiving Station
16. 18 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Kalyan Receiving Station
17. 7 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Kolshet Receiving Station
18. 7 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Davdi Receiving Station
19. 15 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
20. 13 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Malad Receiving Station
21. 9 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Mankhurd Receiving Station
22. 20 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Parel Receiving Station
23. 4 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Panvel Receiving Station
24. 9 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Powai Receiving Station
25. 10 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Saki Receiving Station
26. 21 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Salsette Receiving Station
27. 6 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Versova Receiving Station
28. 10 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
29. 8 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Ixora Receiving Station
30. 2 No. of 110 kV Bays at Central Railway (Wadala) Receiving Station
31. 11 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Backbay Receiving Station
32. 48 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Borivali Receiving Station
33. 47 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Carnac Receiving Station
34. 90 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Dharavi Receiving Station
35. 56 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Parel Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 25 of 33
36. 27 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Powai Receiving Station
37. 40 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Sahar Receiving Station
38. 71 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Saki Receiving Station
39. 20 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Versova Receiving Station
40. 27 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Ixora Receiving Station
41. 20 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Ambernath Receiving Station
42. 20 No. of 22 kV Bays at 220 kV Borivali Receiving Station
43. 25 No. of 22 kV Bays at 220 kV Carnac Receiving Station
44. 32 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Chembur Receiving Station
45. 39 No. of 22 kV Bays at 220 kV Dharavi Receiving Station
46. 21 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Kalyan Receiving Station
47. 16 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Kolshet Receiving Station
48. 30 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
49. 26 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Malad Receiving Station
50. 15 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Mankhurd Receiving Station
51. 12 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Parel Receiving Station
52. 10 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Panvel Receiving Station
53. 33 No. of 22 kV Bays at 220 kV Salsette Receiving Station
54. 46 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
55. 4 No. of 11 kV Bays at 110 kV Chembur Receiving Station
56. 23 No. of 11 kV Bays at 110 kV Parel Receiving Station
Proposed - List of Transmission Lines:
1. 400 kV Kharghar – Vikhroli Transmission Line (23.1 km) from MSETCL Kharghar
Receiving Station to Vikhroli Receiving Station
2. 400 kV Dehrand- Vikhroli Transmission Line (51.3 km) from Dehrand Receiving
Station to Vikhroli Receiving Station
3. 400 kV Dehrand-Nagothane Transmission Line (45.0 km) from Dehrand Receiving
Station to Nagothane Receiving Station
4. 400 kV Panvel-Vikhroli Transmission Line (34.4 km) from Panvel Receiving
Station to Vikhroli Receiving Station
5. 400 kV Dehrand-Sewri Transmission Line (57.0 km) from Dehrand Receiving
Station to Sewri Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 26 of 33
6. 400 kV Kudus-Marve Transmission Line (50 km) from Kudus Receiving Station to
Marve Receiving Station
7. 400 kV Sewri-Hajiali Transmission Line (10 km) from Sewri Receiving Station to
Hajiali Receiving Station
8. 220 kV Trombay-Dharavi Transmission Line (40.0 km) from Trombay to Dharavi to
Salsette Receiving Station
9. 220 kV Kalwa-Salsette Transmission Line (13.0 km) from Kalwa Receiving Station
to Salsette Receiving Station
10. LILO of one circuit of existing 220 kV Bhira-Dharavi Transmission Line (1.0 km) at
Chunabhatti Receiving Station
11. LILO of two circuits of existing 220 kV Trombay - Dharavi Transmission Line (3.0
km) at Antop Hill, Wadala Receiving Station
12. 220 kV R-Infra Versova – TPC Versova Transmission Line (3.0 km) from R-Infra
Versova Receiving Station to TPC Versova Receiving Station
13. LILO of one circuit of existing 220 kV Trombay - Chunabhatti Transmission Line
(5. 0 km) at Bombay Dyeing, Wadala Receiving Station
14. 220 kV Uran-Sewri Transmission Line (22.0 km) from Uran Receiving Station to
Sewri Receiving Station
15. 220 kV Sewri-Mahalaxmi Transmission Line (10.0 km) from Sewri Receiving
Station to Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
16. 220 kV Sewri-Parel Transmission Line (5.0 km) from Sewri Receiving Station to
Parel Receiving Station
17. 220 kV Sewri-Antop Hill Transmission Line (8.0 km) from Sewri Receiving Station
to Antop Hill Receiving Station
18. 220 kV Sewri-Versova Transmission Line (25.0 km) from Sewri Receiving Station
to Versova Receiving Station
19. LILO of existing 220 kV Trombay-Carnac 5 & 6 Transmission Line (1.0 km) at
Sewri Receiving Station
20. LILO of existing 220 kV Trombay-Backbay Transmission Line (1.0 km) at Sewri
Receiving Station
21. 220 kV Mira Road Transmission Line (4.0 km) from R-Infra Mira Road Receiving
Station to Tata Mira Road (West) Receiving Station.
22. 220 kV Vikhroli (East) – Vikhroli (West) Transmission Line (4.0 km) from Vikhroli
(East) Receiving Station to Vikhroli (West) Receiving Station
23. 220 kV R Infra Mira Road - Dahisar (East) Transmission Line (8.0 km) from R-
Infra Mira Road Receiving Station to Tata Dahisar (East) Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 27 of 33
24. 220 kV Vikhroli-Sahar Transmission Line (8.0 km) from Vikhroli Receiving Station
to Sahar Receiving Station.
25. 220 kV Marve-Versova Transmission Line (14 km) from Marve Receiving Station
to Versova Receiving Station
26. 220 kV Borivali (East) - Dahisar (East) Transmission Line (5 km) from Tata
Borivali (East) Receiving Station to Dahisar (East) Receiving Station
27. 220 kV Saki-Versova Transmission Line (10 km) from Saki Receiving Station to
Versova Receiving Station
28. LILO of existing 220 kV MSETCL Trombay-Tata Trombay Transmission Line (1
km) at Trombay Generating Station
29. LILO of existing 220 kV Dharavi-Backbay Transmission Line (6.0 km) at
Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
30. 110 kV Khopoli-Bhivpuri Transmission Line (28.0 km) from Khopoli Receiving
Station to Bhivpuri Receiving Station
31. 110 kV Saki-Powai Transmission Line (4 km) from Saki Receiving Station to Powai
Receiving Station
32. 110 kV Dharavi - Mithi River Transmission Line (2.5 km) from Dharavi Receiving
Station to Mithi River Receiving Station
33. 110 kV Mithi River-HDIL Kurla Transmission Line (4.0 km) from Mithi River
Receiving Station to HDIL Kurla Receiving Station
34. 110 kV Dharavi - BKC Transmission Line (2.0 km) from Dharavi Receiving Station
to BKC Receiving Station
35. 110 kV Dharavi-Worli Transmission Line (12.0 km) from Dharavi Receiving
Station to Worli Receiving Station
36. 110 kV Mahalaxmi-Worli Transmission Line (12.0 km) from Mahalaxmi Receiving
Station to Worli Receiving Station
37. LILO of existing 110 kV Lodhivali - Chembur Transmission Line (2. 0 km) at
Chembur Tapping Strucuture/ Trombay Colony Receiving Station
38. 110 kV Tata Chunabhatti – Wadala Truck Terminal Transmission Line (15.0 km)
from Tata Chunabhatti Receiving Station to Wadala Truck Terminal Receiving
Station
39. 110 kV Backbay - Carnac Transmission Line (5 km) from Backbay Receiving
Station to Carnac Receiving Station
Proposed List of Bays:
1. 15 No. of 400 kV Bays at 400 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
2. 8 No. of 400 kV Bays at 400 kV Marve Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 28 of 33
3. 1 No. of 400 kV Bay at 400 kV Panvel Receiving Station
4. 1 No. of 400 kV Bay at 400 kV MSETCL Kharghar Receiving Station
5. 1 No. of 400 kV Bay at 400 kV Vikhroli Station
6. 2 No. of 400 kV Bays at 400 kV Dehrand Receiving Station
7. 2 No. of 400 kV Bays at 400 kV Nagothane Receiving Station
8. 7 No. of 400 kV Bays at 400 kV Sewri Receiving Station
9. 22 No. of 220 kV Bays at 400 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
10. 10 No. of 220 kV Bays at 400 kV Marve Receiving Station
11. 9 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Chunabhatti Receiving Station
12. 6 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Antop Hill, Wadala Receiving Station
13. 7 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Versova Receiving Station
14. 5 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Mahalaxmi Receiving Station
15. 1 No. of 220 kV Bay at 220 kV Dharavi Receiving Station
16. 2 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Salsette Receiving Station
17. 3 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Trombay Receiving Station
18. 1 No. of 220 kV Bay at 220 kV Kalwa Receiving Station
19. 1 No. of 220 kV Bay at 220 kV Salsette Receiving Station
20. 17 No. of 220 kV Bays at 400 kV Sewri Receiving Station
21. 7 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Parel Receiving Station
22. 7 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Bombay Dyeing, Wadala Receiving Station
23. 7 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Mira Road (West) Receiving Station
24. 7 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Vikhroli (West) Receiving Station
25. 7 No. of 220 kV Bays at 220 kV Dahisar (East) Receiving Station
26. 10 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Chunabhatti Receiving Station
27. 5 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV HDIL Kurla Receiving Station
28. 8 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV BKC Receiving Station
29. 7 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Worli Receiving Station
30. 7 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Chembur Tapping Structure/ Trombay Colony
Receiving Station
31. 11 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Mankhurd Receiving Station
32. 41 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Dharavi Receiving Station
33. 11 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Carnac Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 29 of 33
34. 19 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
35. 11 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Versova Receiving Station
36. 1 No. of 110 kV Bay at 110 kV Khopoli Receiving Station
37. 1 No. of 110 kV Bay at 110 kV Bhivpuri Receiving Station
38. 1 No. of 110 kV Bay at 110 kV Powai Receiving Station
39. 7 No. of 110 kV Bays at 400 kV Sewri Receiving Station
40. 18 No. of 110 kV Bays at 220 kV Parel Receiving Station
41. 7 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Wadala Truck Terminal Receiving Station
42. 20 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Saki Receiving Station
43. 11 No. of 110 kV Bays at 110 kV Malad Receiving Station
44. 1 No. of 110 kV Bay at110 kV Parel Receiving Station
45. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 400 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
46. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 400 kV Marve Receiving Station
47. 17 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Chunabhatti Receiving Station
48. 17 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Antop Hill, Wadala Receiving Station
49. 21 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Versova Receiving Station
50. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Bombay Dyeing, Wadala Receiving Station
51. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV HDIL Kurla Receiving Station
52. 25 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV BKC Receiving Station
53. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Worli Receiving Station
54. 24 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Chembur Tapping Structure/ Trombay Colony
Receiving Station
55. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Mankhurd Receiving Station.
56. 14 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Versova Receiving Station
57. 50 No. of 36 kV Bays at 110 kV Dharavi Receiving Station
58. 34 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
59. 11 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Powai Receiving Station
60. 12 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Malad Receiving Station
61. 12 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Backbay Receiving Station
62. 10 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Borivali Receiving Station
63. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 400 kV Sewri Receiving Station
64. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Mira Road (West) Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 30 of 33
65. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Parel Receiving Station
66. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Vikhroli (West) Receiving Station
67. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 220 kV Dahisar (East) Receiving Station
68. 23 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Wadala Truck Terminal Receiving Station
69. 12 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Saki Receiving Station
70. 12 No. of 33 kV Bays at 110 kV Parel Receiving Station
71. 21 No. of 22 kV Bays at 110 kV Vikhroli Receiving Station
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 31 of 33
Annexure II
a) List of persons who attended the TVS on 3 June, 2014.
Sr. No. Name Company / Institution
1. Shri. V. H. Wagle Tata Power Company
2. Ms. Swati Mehendale Tata Power Company
3. Shri. Karthik Krishnan Tata Power Company
4. Shri. Vaibhav Jain Tata Power Company
5. Ms.Ambica Gupta Tata Power Company
6. Shri. Aditya Gupta Tata Power Company
7. Shri. S.R. Warrie Tata Power Company
8. Shri. V. K. Choudhary Tata Power Company
9. Shri. D. R. Kamath Tata Power Company
10. Shri. K. K. Rao Tata Power Company
11. Shri. S. Padmanabhan Tata Power Company
12. Shri. Ashok Sethi Tata Power Company
13. Shri. V. R. Shrikhande Tata Power Company
14. Shri. Balawant Joshi Tata Power Company
15. Ms. Shital Khairya Tata Power Company
16. Shri. B. P. Mehta Tata Power Company
17. Shri. A. S. Mhapsekar Tata Power Company
18. Shri. Rameshwaram Tata Power Company
19. Shri. Karthik Pillai Tata Power Company
20. Ms. Manasvi M Sharma Tata Power Company
21. Shri. Deepak Kabadi Tata Power Company
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 32 of 33
Sr. No. Name Company / Institution
22. Shri. Jayant Tiku Tata Power Company
23. Shri. Vidyesh Raje Tata Power Company
24. Shri. K. R. Cooper Tata Power Company
25. Shri. D. B. Rane Tata Power Company
26. Shri. Indradeep Das Tata Power Company
27. Shri. T.K. Bhaskaran Tata Power Company
b) List of Persons, who participated in the Public Hearing, held on 12 August, 2014
Sr. No Name of the person Individual / Organization
1 The G.M. Tata Power Tata Power Company
2 Dr. Ashok Pendse Thane Belapur Industries Association
3 The Chief Engineer, SLDC CE, SLDC
4 Dr. Sanjay Kulkarni CE, STU
5 Ms. Swati Mehendale Tata Power Company
6 Ms. Ambica Gupta Tata Power Company
7 Shri. Amey Mhapsekar Tata Power Company
8 Shri. Kartik Krishnan Tata Power Company
9 Shri. Rameshkumar PN Tata Power Company
10 Shri. Abror Khan Tata Power Company
11 Ms. Shital Khairaliya Tata Power Company
12 Shri. V.H.Wagle Tata Power Company
13 Shri.P.G.Phokmare R Infra T
14 Shri. Indradeep Das Idam Infra
15 Ms. Puja Gupta Idam Infra
16 Shri. Balwant Joshi Idam Infra
17 Shri. D.B. Rane Tata Power Company
18 Shri. D.R.Kamat Tata Power Company
19 Shri. V.K.Choudhary Tata Power Company
20 Shri. M.P.Shende Tata Power Company
Grant of Transmission Licence to Tata Power Company Limited
Case No. 112 of 2014 Page 33 of 33
Sr. No Name of the person Individual / Organization
21 Shri. S.G. Bhangaonkar Tata Power Company
22 Shri. Tushar Dhande Tata Power Company
23 Shri. P.S.Sawant Tata Power Company
24 Shri. S.S.Mane Tata Power Company
25 Shri. R.D Patsute BEST Undertaking
26 Shri. S.S.Jadhav BEST Undertaking
27 Shri. V.K.Rokade BEST Undertaking
28 Shri. V.M.Kamat BEST Undertaking
29 Shri. Sumedh M R Infra T
30 Shri. V. Raje Tata Power Company
31 Shri. Msharau Tata Power Company
32 Shri. Deepak Kabadi Tata Power Company
33 Shri.S.S.Gawde BEST Undertaking
34 Shri. M .M. Shaikh BEST Undertaking
35 Shri. Aditya Gupta Tata Power Company
36 Shri. H.D.Thakkar Tata Power Company
37 Shri. S.R.Wane Tata Power Company
38 Shri. Umesh Mahale Tata Power Company
39 Shri. Kiran Desale Tata Power Company
40 Shri. Prakash Gedam Tata Power Company
41 Shri. V.R.Shrikhande Tata Power Company
42 Shri K.N.Pandya Tata Power Company
43 Shri. T.K. Bhaskaran Tata Power Company
44 Shri. P.B.Aughad Tata Power Company