14
Benchmarking Waste Forum Mark Shergold - FTA
Benchmarking
Waste ForumMark Shergold - FTA
• Waste Benchmarking for January – June 2010• 12 Companies participated• Number of ‘O’ License vehicles in sample is
4,754• Results refer to 45% of the total fleet in the
sample• This equates to 2,138 vehicles tested• On average 8.6% of tests in period resulted in
PRS, initially recorded as failure• Failure rate was 7.4% of all tests in the period
Introduction
Initial Test Pass Rates
% Pass Rate Internal vs External maintenance providers
21
93 94
8087
9690
78.471
61
73
83
36
9792
100
82 80.387 87
71
85.9
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
May Jun July Aug Sep Nov-08 Jan-Mar2009
Apr-June2009
2009 Jan-Jun2010
Internal ≥90% External ≥90% Combination %
Final Test Pass Rates
% Pass Rate Internal vs External maintenance providers
96
10099
86
97 97 96
91.8
100 100
8990 91
98100 100
94
89.1
92
97.5
93 93.8
70
75
80
85
90
95
100
May Jun July Aug Sep Nov-08 Jan-Mar2009
Apr-June2009
2009 Jan-Jun2010
Internal ≥90% External ≥90% Combination %
Comparison Test Pass Rates with Headlamp Aim
96 95 97
89
96 9794
9895
91.588
6469
56
6561
46
6066
33.9
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
May Jun July Aug Sep Nov-08 Jan-Mar2009
Apr-June2009
2009 Jan-Jun2010
Final Pass Rate Overall % Rate of headlamp aim as defect %
Headlamp aim failure rate by company
Company Jan - Jun 2010
1 33.3
2 32.6
3 0.0
4 23.6
5 35.3
6 100.0
7 11.1
8 25.0
9 33.3
10 36.4
11 40.0
12 36.4
Average 33.9
Sifts per region
Total Average Median Minimum Maximum
North Eastern 17 8.5 8.5 7 10
North Western 18 4.5 4 1 9
West Midland 5 1.7 1 1 3
Welsh 6 3 3 1 5
Eastern 5 2.5 2.5 1 4
Western 13 4.3 5 2 6
South East/Metropolitan 19 3.8 2 1 11
Scottish 22 7.3 7 1 14
Total 105
SIFT % of all checks 35.20%
% Sifts by region
TAO Sifts %
North Eastern 39.53%
North Western 39.13%
West Midland 16.67%
Welsh 60.00%
Eastern 17.24%
Western 34.21%
South East/Metropolitan 31.15%
Scottish 53.66%
Roadside encounters by region
Total Average Median Minimum Maximum
North Eastern 26 8.7 9 6 11
North Western 28 7 6 2 14
West Midland 25 6.3 3.5 2 16
Welsh 4 4 4 4 4
Eastern 24 4.8 3 1 11
Western 25 6.3 6 1 12
South East/Metropolitan 42 7 5 1 17
Scottish 19 4.8 3 1 12
Total 193
Roadside encounters
1.08 0.9 0.5 1 1 1 1.7 0.72.7 3.2
1.7
6.6 6.1
14.3 15
36
41
25
5.6
26
39
20.7
26.4
39.7
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Feb Mar Apr May Jun July Aug Sep Nov-08 Jan-Mar2009
Apr-June2009
2009 Jan-Jun2010
Rate of roadside encounter as % of no vehicles in fleet Prohibition rate as % of total number of roadside checks
OCRS by Traffic AreaAverages for sample Jan – Jun 2010
North East
North West
West Mids Welsh Eastern Western
South East/Met Scottish
Roadworthiness 2.3 1.9 1.8 2.0 2.3 3.2 2.0 2.2
TrafficEnforcement 2.8 1.3 1.2 2.5 2.4 0.8 1.9 2.0
Next Benchmark
• July 2010 – December 2010• To be sent out in March
FTA Research Service
• Bespoke research and information related to your operation
– Diesel trends and graphs– OCRS– Published statistics and trends– Carbon calculator– Fuel surcharge calculator– Cost information
• Average driver’s wage• Cost of fuel duty increases• Cost of legislation changes
FTA Research Team
• Mark Shergold – Research Analyst [email protected] 01892 552218
– Logistics Buyer– Benchmarking– Fuel Price information– Logistics Carbon Reduction Scheme
• Bruce Goodhart – Research Analyst [email protected] 01892 552242
– Manager’s Guide to Distribution Costs– Quarterly Transport Activity Survey– Fuel Price Information– Cost information
• Joan Cooper – Subscription Administrator [email protected] 01892 552365
• Sharon Ryan – Head of Research [email protected] 01892 552286
– Bespoke Research– All products and services
