IPC Irvine 2010
BGA Fanout Patterns
Charles Pfeil
Engineering Director
Systems Design Division
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Charles Pfeil Background
1966-1987 PCB Designer
1978-1987 Founder of Computer Circuits Inc., Fairfax VA, PCB Design Service Bureau
Marketing and/or engineering management at these software vendors, specializing in automatic and interactive routing:
1983-1985 Racal Redac
1988-1991 ASI/Cadence
1991-1999 Intergraph/VeriBest
1999-2010 Mentor Graphics
Original product architect for Expedition PCB
An inventor of XtremePCB & XtremeAR
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Abstract
Choosing the appropriate fanout patterns for routing BGAs can enable fewer layers and better signal integrity
When using HDI, many options are available for fanout patterns
This session demonstrates different fanout patterns in the context of HDI stackups and how they can be successfully applied on large dense BGAs
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Definition of “Breakouts”
The combination of fanouts and escape traces, having a purpose of routing out of the BGA pin array
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Why Care About Fanouts?
If the BGA device has too many pins in a dense array, the only way to minimize the number of layers is to utilize all the available space inside the component area with a pattern of fanouts and escape traces
24-36% improvement in route density using effective fanouts
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Why Care About Fanouts?
With good fanout patterns, you can effectively reduce the size of the array for routing
With HDI, 1760 pins effectively reduced 41% to 1024
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Overview
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Overview - Scope
Routing of multiple 1mm pitch BGAs >1500 pins, are the primary influence on layer count
A few large BGAs on a board can be routed without impact on layers
Emulation, network and server boards with many large BGAs are difficult to route with minimal layers
Usually an HDI approach will enable fewer signal layers
Effective fanouts will also contribute to fewer layers
Netlines Display
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Overview - Challenge
Future will bring >2000 pins, .8mm pitch
HDI and efficient fanouts will be required
Each board has many variables with different priorities
Understanding the principles for via models, fanouts and escapes will allow you to succeed on a variety of conditions
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Overview – In Theory…
Theoretical solutions have limited application
Simply calculating the number of route channels ignores the impact of signal and power integrity, design rules, and available via models
Some common methods
Reassign and align pwr/gnd & unused pins to open channels
Ignore diff pairs
Ignore netline direction
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Overview – Practical Side
Red = Difficult
Green = Easy
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Overview – Practical Side
Finding an effective fanout pattern within the context of the stackup and via models will have a significant impact on route-ability
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Overview – Practical Side
Alignment of vias increases space
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Overview – Practical Side
For large designs with numerous BGAs, layer-biased breakouts may be most effective
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Design Rules – 1mm Pitch BGA
Rules used for various breakout methods
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Design Rules – Notes
Diff Pairs
If there isn’t adequate room to get proper spacing between compliments in a diff pair, a compromise must be made
o Space them 0.1mm (4th) inside the BGA with a rule area and spread them once the breakout is completed
o Split the diff pairs
o Change the via pattern and maybe add more layers to allow greater spacing
Rule Areas
It is common to see smaller widths and spacing for all signals inside the BGA perimeter
o Will case an impedance discontinuity, but each engineer has to decide if it will be significant
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Signal Integrity
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Diff Pair Via-Via Crosstalk
When diff pairs are routed on the laminated core layers the buried-vias show insignificant crosstalk
o At 5Ghz, the via-to-via crosstalk between the diff pairs (vias spaced 1mm/4th) is around -35db. This is only 15db greater than if the vias were spaced 24th apart.
o In the context of the whole circuit, thisnoise should not be significant
The via stubs affect the diff pairs less than the single-ended nets
Remove unused pads on the blind-vias to minimize noise
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns - Signal Integrity
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Single-ended Via-Via Crosstalk
Micro-vias reduce potential for crosstalk – try to route single-ended nets on the buildup layers
o Buried-vias if spaced too close together will cause significant crosstalk between the single-ended nets
o Buried-vias can also become noisy via stubs
Remove unused pads on all buried-vias
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Overview
The effectiveness of a fanout pattern on large BGAs contributes significantly to the route-ability of a design which impacts the layer count, which in turn affects the cost of the board fabrication
Since there are many variables involved in determining fanout patterns, such as layer stackup, via models, via spans and design rules, we will explore fanout patterns BGAs in the context of large dense boards where minimizing layer count is important
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Goals
The goal is to use a fanout pattern that increases route density and reduce the effective size of the ball pad array.
Eliminate the BGA as the most significant contributor to layer count
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
1760 pins effectively reduced
41% to 1024
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Alignment
When aligning fanout vias, the relationship between diff pairs may be shifted and spread apart
Pin swapping (within restrictions) can help
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
When using through vias, there are not too many options due to the large 0.5mm via pad relative to the 1mm ball pitch
Either a “Quadrant Dog-Bone” or “Via-in-Pad” method is appropriate
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Qu
ad
ran
t D
og
-Bo
ne
Via
-in
-Pa
d
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Quadrant Dog-Bone
Advantages (Over Via-in-Pad) Opens up additional routing channels in
the center row and column
o However, there is room for only two or three more routes
On the side of the board opposite the BGA mount, the column and row channel is a convenient place to add capacitors and pull-up resistors
Lower cost and less risk of soldering problems related to the via-in-pad
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Quadrant Dog-Bone
Disadvantages (Compared to Via-in-Pad) If you have a ground or power plane on the BGA
mount side, the fanout via pads prevent a continuous plane fill under the BGA
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Qu
ad
ran
t D
og
-Bo
ne
Via
-in
-Pa
d
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Via-in-Pad
Advantages (Over Quadrant Dog-Bone)
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
If you do not use the mount layer for a plane, then you have an additional routing layer for the BGA - albeit a surface layer which is not recommended for high-speed nets
If you have a ground or power plane on the BGA mount side, the via-in-pads allow a continuous plane fill under the BGA
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Via-in-Pad
Disadvantages (Compared to Quadrant Dog-Bone)
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
No additional route channels in the center column and row
Less room for capacitors and resistors on the opposite side under the BGA since the fanout via array is full
If you have unused pins and you do not add fanout vias for them; you will have some room in those locations for components
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Via-in-Pad
Disadvantages (Compared to Quadrant Dog-Bone)
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
There will be a slightly higher cost for filling the vias and ensuring a smooth surface for the soldering of the ball pads
There is some risk of BGA soldering problems (de-lamination or pop-corning) with via-in-pad while using lead-free solder
An experienced assembly company should be able to manage this risk and make it a non-issue
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Combine methods using both via-in-pad and quadrant dog-bone
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC 2009
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Power, Ground and Unused Pins
One method proposed to increase route channels on inner layers is to not use fanout vias when possible for power, ground and unused pins
When using through-vias there is very little benefit
The power and ground pins will be assigned to the center of the device and distributed among the other pins; and it is highly unlikely they will be distributed in nice columns and rows
Unused pins will not likely be in convenient rows and columns either
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Power, Ground and Unused Pins
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Virtex-4 with power (orange) & ground (green) vias
Virtex-4 with power & ground vias removed
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Shifting Vias
If you have a set of design rules that will not allow diff pairs to be routed together, it may be helpful to shift the fanout vias
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Through-Vias
Pushing Vias
You can push the vias at the perimeter to increase the first signal layer route density to include two additional rows.
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
Using drilled blind & buried-vias may be a viable alternative, positioned between through-via laminated boards and micro-via HDI boards
Route density is increased in two ways:
Smaller Via Sizes – Since the layer span is only one to three layers, the drilled blind-via can be only 8th hole with a 18th pad
Additional Route Space - Connections routed on blind-via layers eliminate vias on the buried-via layers
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
Smaller Via Size
In the context of high pin-count BGAs, layer reduction and higher density routing can be achieved due to the smaller via sizes compared to through-vias
However, these gains are not as significant as can be achieved with micro-via HDI methods. The gains are dependent on the size of the blind-via.
Since a minimum drilled hole size of 0.2mm (8th) applies to these blind-vias, the pad size should be 0.45mm (18th)
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
mm milsBlind-Via Pad 0.45 18Buried-Via Pad 0.50 20Through-Via Pad 0.50 20Ball Pad 0.60 24
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
Additional Route Space
Whenever a blind-via is used to complete a route, then the buried-via is not required on the inner core
If blind-vias are arranged in patterns, significant additional routing space can be attained on the blind-via layers
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
Multiple Fanout Patterns
Using a number of different patterns works well in this context
1 – Aligned 1:2
2 – Aligned 1:3
3 – Transition 1:3
4 – Dog-Bone
Diagonal
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
A blind-via pattern around the perimeter of the BGA in which the vias are shifted into columns and rows (4-6)
Results in 24% greater route density per layer
This methodology is key to success with HDI micro-vias as well
If ball pads are smaller, the vias couldn’t be shifted into a tighter column since the blind-vias are already spaced at a minimum of 0.1mm (4th)
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
1,2 - Aligned
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
The pins between the pins using the dog-bone via patterns and the shifted vias lack space for the fanouts
I recommend using a row around the perimeter for the transition
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
3 - Short dog-bone in the transition area
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
4 - Quadrant dog-bone in the center
The layer 1-2 blind-via uses a quadrant dog-bone pattern and then transitions to a buried-via
o The pins that would need to run to the bottom of the board to connect to bypass capacitors pull-up resistors, would have another blind-via between layers n & n-1
One alternative to using the blind/buried/blind vias in the center would be to just put in a through-via either in a quadrant dog-bone pattern or via-in-pad configuration
o This will simplify the fanout and since most of the pins in the center area are power & ground, it will not impact the route density in a significant manner
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
The corners of the BGA are always the easiest to breakout because there are half as many pins to route to the edge, split along the diagonal
If there is a need for extremely dense routing at the corners to bring out routes from the center pins, a pattern can be used to spread the fanouts away from the diagonal
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Diagonal
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – Blind & Buried-Vias
Advantages (Compared to through-hole) 24% increased route density per layer over through-
vias and un-shifted blind-vias
More room for a ground plane on the mount layer compared to quadrant dog-bone through-vias
If you route the high-speed single-ended nets on the layers using blind-vias, via stubs are eliminated and via-via crosstalk is minimized
Any signal routed on the blind-via layers, will not need to have a buried via, thus opening up route space on the buried via layers as well
Disadvantages Does not provide as much route-density as HDI
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
Compared to through-hole and blind & buried-vias, the variety of stackups with HDI and smaller via sizes provide for tighter shifted column and row patterns, improved route density and greater flexibility
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
When using HDI, the blind micro-vias give greater route density and fewer total layers required for routing
The fanout patterns herein use these types of HDI construction:
1+N+1 = Type II (layer 1-2 micro-vias with buried vias in laminated core)
2+N+2 = Type III (layer 1-2, 2-3 micro-vias with buried vias in laminated core)
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
1+N+1 Type II 2+N+2 Type III
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
Layer 1-2 micro-vias (1+N+1)
Layer 1 is assumed to be used for a GND plane
The fanouts need to be patterned to maximize layer 2 route density
The same patterns described for the blind-vias can be used for micro-vias
However, since the micro-vias are smaller, you can compact them more
Micro-vias aligned to improve route density 12% over shifted blind-vias 36% over quadrant dog-bone through-vias
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Fanout Via Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
Many possible via patterns
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Fanout Via Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
Many possible via patterns
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
Via-in-pad micro-vias
If via-in-pad is used with micro-vias, it still makes sense to shift the vias
o Often you will lose space for one trace in one channel while gaining space for two in the other
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
Advantages Smaller via size allows for greater route density
Potential for 12% increased route density per layer over blind-vias, 36% over through-vias
Dependent on the effectiveness of the fanout pattern
More flexibility for via models and patterns
Skip vias & stacked vias
More room for a ground plane on the mount layer
Routing on buildup layers eliminates via stubs
Any signal routed on the micro-via layers, will not need to have a buried via, thus opening up route space on the buried-via layers as well
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Fanout Patterns – HDI Micro-Vias
Disadvantages Potentially more expensive than laminated through-via
or blind & buried-via; however, if you consider the increased yield and reliability with fewer layers, the overall cost may be lower for a very dense board
Learning curve is greater; however, once patterns are developed for a given set of stackups of design rules, the benefits are easily justified
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
0.8mm Pin Pitch BGA - HDI
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
0.8mm BGA
Modified a Virtex-5 1mm package into 0.8mm pitch just to see the impact on fanout patterns
0.8mm Pitch
1mm Pitch
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Design Rules – 0.8mm Pitch BGA
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Fanout Patterns – 0.8mm Pitch BGA
Layer 1
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Fanout Patterns – 0.8mm Pitch BGA
Signal 1
1-2 uVia Thru-Via
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Fanout Patterns – 0.8mm Pitch BGA
Signal 2
1-3 Skip-Via
Thru-Via
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Fanout Patterns – 0.8mm Pitch BGA
Signal 3 & 4 using through-vias in center
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Fanout Patterns – 0.8mm Pitch BGA
Signal 5 using through-vias in center
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
Breakouts – 0.8mm Pitch BGA
Conclusion
Applying NSEW breakouts with good fanout patterns enables breakouts on large BGAs in 5-6 signal layers
With increased spacing for diff pairs, it probably could be done with 8-10 signal layers
Can maintain normal trace widths and clearances
If over 2000 pins, may have to compromise trace widths and clearances
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
Interactive Demos
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
BGA Breakout Solutions
IPC Irvine 2010
BGA Fanouts Patterns
Conclusion
An effective set of fanout patterns developed to match the stackup significantly improve the route-ability
HDI should be considered now because in the future it will become a requirement with fine-pitch and high pin-count
Copyright © 2010
Mentor Graphics
PDF from Mentor:
http://iconnect007.com/ads/mentor/regform.php
Book from Amazon.com:
just search on Amazon for “BGA Breakouts”
BGA Breakout Solutions IPC Irvine
2010