Business Manager – Knees, Invibio Ltd
Ian Revie
MedTech BESTManaging R&D projects
Victrex Confidential
Session
Managing the team
…………….and the risks
…………….as well as the technology.
Victrex Confidential
…to transform Total Knee Arthroplasty within the next 10 years and become a leading player within the market,
offering a thin shell cartilage replacement device which optimises PEEK function for strength, ingrowth and wear
to support minimally invasive surgery.
We will do this by initially developing a partnership implant business (IKL) ………will establish a unique best in
class offering to orthopaedic companies ………... The advanced knowledge created in IKL will then be used to
……develop and supply their company specific derivative devices.
Vision setting
Initial offering – simple entry – Femur - Equivalence – technically, functionally, surgically
Variants introducing material capability – eg, bearing conformity? on-growth?
Tibia changes, exploring thin surfaces
Superiority - technically & functionally, Expanding on material capability
Thin shell bearings, MI procedures, custom devices?
Ingrowth and Regenerative options
Yea
r 1
Yea
r
10
Low cost manufacture option – metal free
knee - focus market India
High performance option –
target market USA
What does a product development look like?
Design
Process development
Process Validation
Clinical evaluation
Product launch
Prototype testingDesign specs
Process specs
Ist size completed
DHF completedClinical submissions
Last size completed
DHF completedRegulatory approvals
Design & regscompletion
Product SpecDrawings
Risk analysis
FemurPackaging
LabelsIFU
MPSProcess flowRisk analysis
FemurPackaging
LabelsIFU
Install or procure new processesMeasuring
Clean and pack
Manufacture Cell
Full manufacture specsFull inspection specs
VMPManufacture records
Inspection reports & CofC
IQOQ
PQ
Major process changes -5 -1 0 iterations
Minor process changes 2-3 runs
No process changes
G0 G1 G2 G3 G4 G5
Design Validation
PL
Design Validation
Production scale-up
Planning PMP
Knee
Customer Projects
Maxx Project (AA)
Product Dev and Val (WS1) AB
Critical Work Package (CWP1.1)
Imaging MB
Process Dev and Val (WS2)
Critical Work Package (CWP2.5)
Condyle Bruise MH
Critical Work Package (CWP2.6)
Shear at Gate NW
Critical Work Package (CWP2.7) 2ndry Operations MW
Clinical Trials (WS3) SS
Mathys (MB)
Concept de-risk (WS10) MB
Product Dev and Val (WS11) AB
Process Dev and Val (WS12) PC
Clinical Trials (WS13) SO
Platform
Business Development
Science (WS4) AB
Marketing (WS5) IR
Intellectual Property (WS6) NT
Commercial Pipeline (WS7) IR
Operational Structure
Operational Development (WSA)
MH
Quality System Development (WSB)
CV
Product Design Services Dev (WSC)
NW
Organisational Development (WSD)
VM
Business Systems Dev(WSE) IR
Planning WBSPart of wider
medical business
platform work streams
Planning
Planning
Planning
Reporting
•Why do we report• Progress
• Track and agree changes
• Prioritise
•Who do we report to• Team
• External parties
• PSC
• Management
Victrex Confidential
Commentary
• Documentation is awaiting technology completion and
handover to Maxx. Process started and expected to
complete Jan 2017
• Change of management engagement to complete design
transfer • Maxx size C remedy in review – expect earliest
completion Dec 2016. potential to extend till Q1 2017
• Change of Validation process – verify 100%
• Maxx Product completed full process PQ – 1 of 32 (6
started)
IP Claims • EU prior art challenge submission via consultant
• Patent Drafts• Second Rib Patent in draft,
• Review of potential revisability patent
• Residual Risks review• Management review planned mid Nov
• DHF completed
• Mathys contracts reviews by both external counsel
Reporting high level
Victrex Confidential
Reporting PSC
Managing scope change
• Negative change• EMAT
• £400,000 2 year development
• £25M 5 years development
• Positive change• Invibio
• 1 project – 5 years
• 4 programs for 20 plus projects – 20 years
Victrex Confidential
…to transform Total Knee Arthroplasty within the next 10 years and become a leading player within the market,
offering a thin shell cartilage replacement device which optimises PEEK function for strength, ingrowth and wear
to support minimally invasive surgery.
We will do this by initially developing a partnership implant business (IKL) ………will establish a unique best in
class offering to orthopaedic companies ………... The advanced knowledge created in IKL will then be used to
……develop and supply their company specific derivative devices.
Scope change
Cementless – Prog 2
Tibia – Prog 3
Thin shell, Custom, Regenerative – Prog 4
Year
1
Year
10
Budget – Prog 1a Premium – Prog 1b
Maxx
Femur Company 4
femur
Company 3
femur
Company 2
femur
Mathys
femur?Maxx
Knee Company 4
femur
Company 3
femur
Company 2 femur
Mathys
knee?
Mathys
Knee? Company 4
femur
Company 3
femur
Company 2 femur
Maxx
knee
Max
Tibia Company 4
femur
Company 3
femur
Company 2 femur
Company 1
Tibia
Stryker
Next Gen Company 2 Company 1
Victrex Confidential
2015 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2023
£3M Revenue£1M Revenue
First commercial product sale
Second Medium Co. commits to JDA
Tibia Development MAXX ???
Start Clinical Trial
Large 4 Co. commits to LOI
Mathys commits to development
Surgeons promotions at Ortho Congress
Prog 1Cemented femur
Maxx Femur
Prog 2Cementless Femur
Prog 3Tibia
Mathys femur?Company 2 Femur
Stryker Femur?Company 3 Femur?
Mathys Femur?Maxx femur
Company 2 FemurCompany 3
Maxx TibiaCompany 1 Tibia
Company 2 Tibia
Tibia Development MAXX
Company 3
Prog 4Regen/Custom
Stryker femurCompany 1 Femur
Company 2 FemurCompany 3
Scope change
The Design Process
The Design Dossier
The Design Dossier
Managing design change
• Quality system• Procedures – change control, deviation control
• Roles and responsibility (RASCI)
• Competence
• Continuous improvement (CAPA)
• The specification• Design
• Manufacture
• Inspection
Project Risk management
• Product risk• Required by ISO 13485 and MDD 93/42/ECC
• ISO 14971 – Risk management – includes FMEA
• Project risk• Product is great but the business is dead
Risk management
Product Risk management
Project Risk management
Business Manager – Knees, Invibio Ltd
Ian Revie
Q&AManaging R&D projects