Date post: | 08-Jul-2015 |
Category: |
Technology |
Upload: | biomap-systems |
View: | 6,739 times |
Download: | 2 times |
Bridging the Gap From In Vitro to In Vivo
Novel Chemoproteomics (KinobeadsTM) and Phenotypic (BioMAP®)
Discovery Platforms for the Development of Novel and Safer Kinase
Inhibitors for Inflammatory Diseases
1
Ellen L. BergInflammation Research Association Conference
Bolton Landing NY 10 September, 2012
Challenges of Kinase Drug Discovery
Difficulty of obtaining selective inhibitors
Kinase gene family members (> 500 members) are highly related
Conserved active sites
Biochemical ≠ cellular efficacy
Challenge of defining optimal target selectivity
Limited knowledge about target biology
Individual kinases can play a role in multiple pathways - complex signaling
Unclear significance of secondary activities
There will be secondary targets at a high enough concentration
Are secondary targets affecting safety and/or efficacy?
2
Technologies
Advanced chemoproteomics tools
KinobeadsTM platform
Human phenotypic screening models
BioMAP® platform
3
KinobeadsTM PlatformA chemoproteomics approach to drug discovery
Works exclusively with native proteins directly in cell
or tissue lysate under close to physiological settings
Protein targets are in their “natural“ environment, with
right
Modifications
Protein complexes
Provides comprehensive profile of targets and off-
targets of drugs in tissue of relevance
One assay plaform can be used throughout entire drug
discovery process and across different species
4
Kinobeads™ Concept
Kinobeads™
(empty)
Kinobeads™
(loaded)
1 2
3
NBroad spectrum kinase inhibitors(ATP mimetics)
Immobilized on solid support
Incubate beads with cell or tissue lysate
Capture tissue kinome on matrix
Identify captured proteinsby mass spectrometry
5
Kinobeads™ competition binding assays
for mass spec profiling
Kinobeads™
(loaded)
1 2
3
N
Kinobeads™
(empty)
Cell lysate
Competition experiment:Compounds compete for kinase binding to beads
Capture kinases in a compound-dose dependent manner
PI-Kinobeads™
Elution
MASS SPECTROMETRY BASED PROFILING
Detection by quantitative mass spectrometry:Most potent compounds are profiled against 100+ kinases
Compound
200 400 600 800 1000 1200m/z0
100
%
6Bantscheff et al, Nat Biotechnol 25, 2007
TMT =Tandem Mass Tags
3. Add Kinobeads™1. Add inhibitor to lysate at different concentrations
4. Elute beads, digest & labelwith stable isotope
Inh
ibit
or
con
cen
trat
ion
10 µM
0.625 µM
0.16 µM
0.0 µM(DMSO,Control)
0.04 µM
2.5 µM
TMT 126
TMT 128
TMT 129
TMT 131
TMT 130
TMT 127
5. Mix all 6 samples,run single LC-MS/MS& quantify in MS/MSspectrum
Protein does not bind to drug
2. Incubate - inhibitor binds to targets
Protein binds to drug:
Chemoproteomics Platform: Mass Spec Detection
7
Multiplexing:Spotting of low volumes of eluate allows preparation of multiple arrays for detection
Kinobeads™ and Episphere™-
based competition binding assays
8
Immuno-detection on Arrays:Cell lysate
Compound
Kinobeads™
Episphere™
(loaded)
1 2
3
N
Kinobeads™
Episphere™
(empty)
Competition experiment:Compounds compete for kinase/epi-target bindingto beads
Capture kinases/epi-targets in a compound-dose dependent manner
Kinobeads™
Episphere ™
Elution
NEGATIVECONTROL
POSITIVECONTROL
HITS
Immunodetection on affinity protein arrays
– high throughput (50,000 cmpds/wk)
– low protein coverage (>10 proteins quantified per sample)
A chemoproteomic approach to drug discovery:
PI3Kg
9
Late LO/clinical
Lead Optimization(LO)
Hit ID
Target
Clinical Candidate
Kinobeads™
LO/clinical: broad kinase profiling/cross species comparison
Hit ID: library screening
Compounds/Library
Human blood
Tissue lysate
Cell lysate
LO: primary assayPI3Kg PI3Ka
PI3Kb
mTor
DNAPK PI3Kd
[cp
d]
PI3Kg
PI3Ka
PI3Kb
TPI3Kd
DNAPK
mTor
PI3
Kg
PI3
Ka
PI3
Kb
PI3
Kd
DN
AP
K
mTo
r
From multiplexed screening to selective probes:
PI3Kg inhibitors
10
mTor DNAPK PI3Kd PI3Kg
Co
mp
ou
nd
s
Library screening
Bergamini et al, NatChemBiol, June 2012
Identification of a selective PI3Kg inhibitor
11Bergamini et al, NatChemBiol, June 2012
CZC24832 shows efficacy in mouse arthritis model
(CIA)
12
Mixed species KinobeadsTM
profiling:
Potency drop for PI3Kg,b of 2-5 fold in rodents
Selectivity unchanged5,0
*
**
**
**
* * * * * * * *
Disease control
CZC24832 10 mg/kg
Dex0.01mg/kg
CZC24832 3 mg/kg
Collagen induced arthritis model
CZC24832
0,0
0,5
1,0
1,5
2,0
2,5
3,0
3,5
4,0
4,5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
Arthritis Day
Mea
n±S
E C
linic
al A
rth
irit
s Sc
ore
(Sco
red
0-5
)
Bergamini et al, NatChemBiol, June 2012
Dose-dependent efficacy mouse CIA model
Reduction in severity of arthritis is comparable to PI3Kg-/- mice
Selectivity translates from chemoproteomic profiles to primary
cell phenotypes: a new role of PI3Kg in TH17cell biology
BioMAP® profile
13
PI3Kg
Bergamini et al, NatChemBiol, June 2012
14
BioMAP® Technology Platform
BioMAP
Assay Systems
Reference
Profile Database
Predictive
Informatics Tools
Human primary cells
Disease-models
30+ systems
Biomarker responses to drugs
are stored in the database
>3000 drugs
Specialized informatics tools are
used to predict clinical outcomes
Human Biology Integrated into a Robust, Scalable Platform
Human primary cell-based assays Engineered to model complex human disease biology
BioMAP® Systems
15
Physiologically relevant assay conditions
Mixtures of stimulation factors, co-cultures of cells
Signaling networks that reflect in vivo tissue states
Clinically validated disease biomarkers
Quantitative and reproducible
Robust readouts (proteins, mediators); standardized assays, QMP, SOPs
Donor variation is managed
Validated with known drugs
BioMAP® Systems – Cell Types & Co-cultures
16
BioMAP Systems
B cells
Endothelial Cells
Bronchial Epithelial Cells
Keratinocytes
Smooth Muscle Cells
Dermal Fibroblasts
Lung Fibroblasts
Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cells
Macrophages
10 primary human cell types
12 assay systems
• Different cell types, co-culture combinations
• Different activation conditions – disease models
BioMAP® Systems – Biology Covered
17
BioMAP Systems
Vascular Biology
Wound Healing
Th1 Inflammation
Skin Biology
Th2 Responses
Immune Biology
Th17 Biology
Lung Biology
BioMAP Profile of CZC24832
18
95% significance envelope
Control (no drug)
Readout Parameters (Protein Biomarkers)
Cytotoxicity Readouts
BioMAP Systems
Log expression ratio(Drug/DMSO control)
DoseResponse
BioMAP Profile of CZC24832
19
Key activities of CZC24832
• Selective inhibition of T-cell-dependent B cell activation (BT system)
• Reduction in IL-17A, IL-6, TNFa; modest inhibition of B cell proliferation (grey
arrow)
• Consistent with reduced progression and and severity of arthritis in a
mouse model of CIA
AS-605240: first published PI3Kg inhibitor with efficacy
in models of inflammation
Williams, Chemistry and Biology (supplement), 2010
Camps, Nat. Med., 2005Kinobeads AS-605240 DNA-PK
PI3Kg
20
PI3Kg
Kinobeads CZC24832 Bergamini et al, NatChemBiol, June 2012
Comparison of CZC24832 and AS605240
21
Overlay of CZC24832 (PI3Kg)and AS605240 (less selective PI3Kginhibitor)
CZC24832 is selectively active in the BT system
BioMAP profile of AS605240 is dominated by activities in other systems
Compounds show cell-type selectivity in anti-proliferative effects (thick grey arrows)
Minor shared activities are indicated by thin black arrows
Kinase Inhibitors in Development
Tofacitinib (CP-690,550)
Jak 3 kinase inhibitor – FDA review for rheumatoid arthritis
Fostamatinib (R788)
Syk kinase inhibitor – Phase III for rheumatoid arthritis
What can BioMAP profiling tell us?
22
Case Study: Kinase Inhibitors in RA
TofacitinibCP-690,550
Jak 3 kinase selective inhibitor Kinase activity: EC50s: Jak3 (1 nM); Jak2 (20 nM); Jak1 (112 nM); Rock-II (3.4 mM) and Lck
(3.8 mM) (Changelian, Science 2003, 302:875). Binding: JAK3 (2.2 nM) and Jak2 (5 nM)
(Karaman, Nat Biotech 2008, 26:127).
Safe and effective in rheumatoid arthritis Kremer, Arthr & Rheum 2012, 60:1895; Fleischmann, Arth & Rheum 2012, 64:619
In review at the FDA for rheumatoid arthritis (Pfizer)23
BioMAP Profile of Tofacitinib (≤ 370 nM)
Key activities of Tofacitinib (CP-690,550 ) ≤ 370 nM
• Inhibition of IL-4 dependent signaling in endothelial cells (4H system)
• Selective inhibition of T-cell-dependent B cell activation (BT system)
• Several activities consistent with clinical efficacy biomarkers (in red)
Eotaxin-3
IgG
TNFa
IL-2
IL-6
24
IgG
TNFaIL-6
De Paz, 2010Lin, 2010
Kutukculer, 1998
BioMAP Profile of Tofacitinib (≥ 370 nM)
Many additional activities at higher doses (≥ 370 nM):• Most are clinical efficacy biomarkers for RA (Kuan, 2010; Klimiuk, 2002; Kutukcular,
1998; Dolhain, 1998; Metawi, 2011) (in red)
Activities are consistent with clinical effects and dosing• Van Gurp, Transpl. 2009, 87:79
• Cmax in one clinical study was ~1 microM (Cohen, BJCP 2010, 69:143)
Higher dose (less selective) profile is more “efficacious” in BioMAP
and in the clinic
Eotaxin-3
IgG
TNFa
IL-2
MIGHLA-DR
VCAM CD38
MIG
CD40IL-17A, F
MIG
HLA-DRMIG
HLA-DRICAM
IP-10
MIGIP-10IP-10
VCAMIL-6
CD69
25
IgG
TNFa
MIG
VCAM CD38
MIG IL-17A, FMIG
MIGIP-10IP-10
VCAMIL-6 ICAM
IP-10MIG
Fostamatinib (R788)
Syk kinase inhibitor
Kinase activity: IC50= 41 nM (active form). Braselmann, JPET 2006, 319:998
Well tolerated in Phase II studies for rheumatoid arthritis
Genovese, Arth & Rheum 2011, 63:337
Currently in Phase III clinical trials for RA (Rigel/AstraZeneca)
R788Fostamatinib
26
BioMAP Profile of Fostamatinib
Key activities of Fostamatinib (R788) • Broadly active in endothelial cells, leukocytes, epithelial cells and SMC
• Inhibition of monocyte activation, T cell activation, and T-dependent B cell activation
• Many activities (in red) consistent with clinical efficacy biomarkers (Szekanecz, 1997;
Klimiuk, 2002, 2005; Kutukculer, 1998; Kaun, 2010)
Consistent with Clinical effects• Peak serum concentrations of > 800 ng/ml (1.4 mM) reported in clinical studies
(Podolanczuk, Blood 2009, 113:154)
Eotaxin-3 TNFa
TFuPAR
MIG
uPAR
IL-6
IL1auPAR
MCP-1
MIP1auPAIL-8IL-1a
27
MMP3
TNFa
uPAR
MIG
uPAR
IL-6
uPAR
MCP-1
IL-8 MMP3
Expression of Syk Kinase mRNA in BioMAP Systems
Expression of Syk mRNA in BioMAP Systems (AU units)
Fostamatinib is active in systems where syk kinase mRNA is not detected
Fostamatinib may not be a selective syk inhibitor at clinically relevant doses
3C 4H LPS SAg BT BF4T BE3C CASM3C HDF3CGF KF3CT MyoF
/Mphg
100.4 98.5 133 137.3 550 251.3 165.3 179.1 108.3 87 108.1 733.7
28
Clinical Standards of Care
E-sel
IgG
TNFaIL-8
E-sel
IL-17
IL-2
TNFa
IP-10IL-8
MMP-9IL-6
MCP-1 VCAM
IL-8
MCP-1VCAM
E-sel
IL-8
SAA
Rheumatoid Arthritis - Clinical Standards of Care• Methotrexate – inhibitor of DHFR
• Selective inhibitor of T cell dependent B cell activation
• Prednisolone – corticosteroid
• Inhibition of macrophage > monocyte activation; T cell activation
• Remicade – TNF antagonist
• Inhibition of monocyte > macrophage activation; myofibroblast activation
29
How do we apply BioMAP systems for
investigating side effect mechanisms?
Are there BioMAP profile features that are associated with
particular side effects?
Hypertension
A side effect of NSAIDS and fostamatinib but not tofacitinib
What about side effects?
BioMAP Profile of Fostamatinib
Vascular Effects
• Strong activities in endothelial cell- and smooth muscle cell-containing
systems (brackets) – non syk dependent??
• Inhibition of endothelial and smooth muscle cell proliferation (grey arrows)
• Effect on prostaglandins (black arrow)
31
Prostacyclin (PGI2)
Vasodilator with anti-thrombotic and anti-proliferative
effects
Produced by vascular cells, platelets
Regulated by inflammatory settings
In several BioMAP systems, PGI2 levels (6-keto-PGF1a) is
increased by inflammatory stimuli
Effects of selective Cox-2 inhibitors on PGI2 has been
proposed as one potential mechanism underlying the
cardiovascular side effects of these drugs
Yu, Sci Transl Med., 2012, 4:132 (PMID: 22553252)
32
Fostamatinib Inhibits Prostacyclin Production BioMAP LPS System
33
Tofacitinib
Jak
Fostamatinib
Syk
Prednisolone
GR
Rofecoxib
Cox-2
Control
Rel
ativ
e [6
-ket
o-P
GF
1a]
(sta
ble
met
abol
ite o
f PG
I 2)
Possible relationship to fostamatinib hypertension side effect
P < 0.01
P < 0.01
10 10 1 10
Rosiglitazone increases Prostacyclin Production BioMAP LPS System
34
Rel
ativ
e [6
-ket
o-P
GF
1a]
(sta
ble
met
abol
ite o
f PG
I 2)
Tofacitinib
Jak
Fostamatinib
Syk
Prednisolone
GR
Rofecoxib
Cox-2
Rosiglitazone
PPARg
Control
10 10 1 10 100
Possible relationship to blood pressure lowering effect of rosiglitazone
P < 0.01
Summary
New target-based discovery platform, KinobeadsTM
enabled the discovery of a highly selective PI3Kg
inhibitor, CZC24832
CZC24832 is selectively active in inhibiting T cell dependent B cell
activation responses, including decreasing IL-17A
BioMAP systems of primary human cell based assays
can be useful for characterizing novel kinase inhibitors
Discovery new biology or confirm known biology
Comparison to standards of care
Testing combination therapies
Investigation of side effect mechanisms
35
Summary
Current clinical stage kinase inhibitors for rheumatoid
arthritis are not selective
Tofacitinib and fostamatinib are broadly acting agents
Opportunity for next generation compounds
Further study of the control of blood pressure by
inflammatory mechanisms may help identify new drugs
with reduced hypertension side effects
36
Acknowledgements
BioSeek
Alison O’Mahony
Mark A. Polokoff
Dat Nguyen
Jennifer Melrose
Andrew Melton
Cellzome
Oliver Rausch
Giovanna Bergamini
Gitte Neubauer
37
Bridging the Gap From In Vitro to In Vivo
Contacts
BioSeek, LLC310 Utah, #100South San Francisco, CA 94080
BioSeek, LLC
T: +1-650-416-7600
F: +1-650-416-7625
www.biomapsystems.com
www.bioseekinc.com
Ellen L. Berg, PhD
T: +1-650-416-7621
F: +1-650-416-7625
www.biomapsystems.com
39