+ All Categories
Home > Documents > Branch and Bound

Branch and Bound

Date post: 11-Jan-2016
Category:
Upload: mhkhan1980
View: 2 times
Download: 1 times
Share this document with a friend
Description:
Branch and Bound
30
Transcript
Page 1: Branch and Bound

����������� ���

� � � � � � � � � � � � � �

������� �"!$#&%�'(%*)(��%,+-$./.1032426587:9�;/<=0&>@?BA=>C7EDF23?HGI7J2�KL<MGN<=5PORQ�GSK3TJGSKU7@7J9�GS.VK3>C7HDW9=K3X67JGNTY23Z[7J9=;\>@]^2_2&`aOb 23TJ7JA�<=KL7JGN./c&de?H2_>"7f2LZ�7:9�G1DF23<gDFGhX�7:>iA=>CGe5j;\<j7:9�;\>fDW9=K3X67JGNTi9gKlk3Gm]^GhGN<Y56GNk3GN./2&XgGe5n;/<YGNK3TJ.\;/GNT2&<�GN>NOpoq;\`3Gj]=K&DW`_7JTWK3DW`4;/<=0=d6]�TWKL<=DW9rK3<=5�]^23A�<=5,>CGeKLTWDW9�GN>pKs>J23.\A67:;/2&<r>CX=K&DFGn7:9=KU7t;\>$2LZu7JGN<2&TJ0_KL<�;\vhGe5jK3>fK$7JT:GhG3Ofw19�GpDF2&?H?@2&<j7:TJGNGx2&TJ0_KL<�;\vNKL7J;\23<=>yKLT:Gz7:9�G[>CA=]=>CGh7fK3<=5YXgGNTJ?YA67:KL7J;\23<7:TJGNGN>{;\<_7JT:245�A=DFGe5Y;\<I|x9=K3X67JGNTx}6~&Oi�[2U��Ghk&GhTedLA�<�.\;\`3Gp]=K&DW`&7:T:K&DW`4;/<�0gdU�p9�;VDW9s>CGeKLTWDW9�GN>y7:9�GN>JG7:TJGNG�2&TJ0_KL<�;\vNKL7J;\23<=>i;\<HK�56GNX67J9����=TW>C7z?HK3<�<�GNTNdL]=T:K3<=DW9@K3<=5@]g2&A�<=5@A=>JA=KL.\.\cB>CGeKLTWDW9�GN>i7:9�GN>JG7:TJGNGN>1;\<�Gh;/7J9�GNTtKH]�T:GNK&547J96���=TW>"7p2&T[./GeK3>C7C��DF2_>"7p?EKL<�<=GhTeOxw19�GjK3X�X�.\;\DNKU7J;\23<g>[DF2&<=>C;V56GNTJGe5�;\<7:9�;\>tDW9=KLX�7JGhTtKLT:Gn7J9�GY>JK3?@GYK3>17:9�2&>JGj2LZx|x9=K3X67JGNT�}�~3O$|x23<=>JGN�_A�GN<_7J.\c3d�;/7�>J9�23A=.\5�]^GBGeK3>JcZ�2&Tzc32&AH7J2B>JGhG$7J9�G$>J;\?@;\.VKLT:;�7:;/Ge>mKL<g5E56;��aGhT:Gh<gDFGN>m]gGh7"�xGNGh<E7:9�G$]gK3DW`_7JTWK3DW`4;\<�0nKL<=5H]�TWKL<gDW96�K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5I?@Gh7J9�265�>NO� ;\<=DFG�7:9�Gj>JX=K3DhGtT:GN�_A�;\TJGN?HGh<_7:>123Zi]�TWKL<=DW9���K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�K3./0&23T:;�7:9�?E>1KLT:G�23Zu7JGN<SDh23<=>J;\56�

GNT:K3]�./c8?H23T:Gs7:9=KL<M7J9�2_>CGS2LZ$7J9�GN;/TH]=K&DW`&7:T:K&DW`4;/<�0rDh23A�<_7:GhT:X=KLTJ7:>Nd{]=K3DW`_7:T:K&DW`_;\<�0�;V>@2LZu7JGN<?H23T:G�>CA=DNDFGe>J>CZ�A�.�KL7��g<=56;\<�0H7J9�GjK3<=>J�xGNT�;\<�?HGh?H23T:c_��.\;/?H;/7JGe5I>J;�7:A=KU7:;/2&<=>NO

�_� ~

Page 2: Branch and Bound

�e�e� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡¤p¤t¥J¦ §©¨ %«ª¬% §©¨ ­ �®B¯U°�±y²l³�°�±y´¶µx·g¸y±i´ ;V>tK3<�2L7:9�GhT���KlcS7:2I>Jc4>C7JGN?EKU7J;VDhK3./.\c�>CGeKLTWDW9rK�>J23.\A67J;\23<�>CX=K&DFG&O�¹�756;/�^GNT:>�Z�T:23?º]=K3DW`_7:T:K&DW`_;\<�0SX�T:;/?EKLT:;\./cr;\<�7J9�G���Klc,K3<R»{��<�2656GH;\>nGh¼6X=KL<=5�GN5PO�»xK3DW9�./;\k3G<�2656GB]^GNDh23?HGN>�KL<�»{��<�2656GjGF¼�K&D½7J.\cS23<=DhG3O$Q�9=Gh<�Ks<�2656GY]^GNDh23?HGN>tKL<,»z��<=245�G3daKL.\.i<�GN�<�2656GN>{7J9=KL7xDhK3<@]^G[T:GNK&DW9�GN5@A=>J;/<=0jKn>C;\<�03.\Gp?H2Uk3GpKLT:Gp03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5POf¾�Gh<�GNT:KL7JGe5Y<=245�GN>{7:9=KU7DhK3<�<�2L7jX^2&>:>J;/]�.\c,.\GNK&5�7J2,KR¿À23X67:;/?EKL.uÁ�Z�GeK3>J;/]�.\Gs>J23.\A67J;\23<RKLT:Gs56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5©¿�;�O G3O\di7:9�Gs<�2656G56;\GN>WÁ½O$w19�GBTJGN?HK3;/<=;/<�0�<�2656GN>tKLT:GjK35�56Ge5�7J2s7J9�GY./;V>"7t2LZz.\;/k&Gj<�2656GN>NdaKL<=5S7:9�Gh<r2&<�Gj<�2656GZ�TJ2&?Â7:9�;V>m.\;\>C7x;V>�>CGN./GeD½7JGe5@7J2Y]gGeDF23?HGp7:9�G$<=GF¼47�»z��<�2656G&Oyw19=Gt>JGh.\GND½7:GN5H<�2656Gt;\>xGF¼47:T:K&D½7JGe5Z�TJ2&?Ã7J9�G�.\;\>C7p2LZ�.\;/k&G$<�2656Ge>1KL<=5�GF¼6X=KL<g56GN5POzw19=;\>�GF¼6X=K3<=>J;/2&<sX�T:24DhGN>:>m;V>1DF2&<&7:;/<4A�Ge5sA�<_7:;/.Gh;/7J9�GNT17J9�GjK3<=>J�xGNT�;V>1Z�2&A�<=5S23T17:9�Gn./;V>C7123Zy.\;\k3G�<�2656GN>[]gGeDF23?HGe>1Gh?HX67"c3Ow19�GhT:G$KLT:Gp7"��2jDF2&?@?H2&<E��Klc6>f7:2B>CGN./GeD½7z7:9�G$<=GF¼47�»z��<�2656Gj¿�7J9�2&A�039E237J9�GNTmX^2&>:>C;\]�;/7J;\GN>

GF¼6;V>"7½Á½ÄÅ ÆpÇ ¯lÈNÉEÊF±xË ÆpÇ ¯UÈhÉsÌE¸iÉrÍ Æ Ê Æ Ì�Îw19�;V>j>:DW9�Gh?HGHGF¼47:T:K&D½7:>�<=245�GN>�Z�T:23?Ï7:9�GE.\;\>C7j2LZ�./;\k3GE<�2656Ge>�;/<�7:9�Gs>JK3?HG@2&T:5�GhTjK3>7:9�GhcSKLT:G�X=A67[;/<_7:2@;/7NOxw19�G�./;\k3Gn<�2656G�.\;\>C7[]^Gh9=Klk&GN>pK3>1KE�_A�GNA�G3OÅ ÐxÑ °=ÈhÉIÒY·^ÈhÉH·=¯IÓÔ°6Õ×Ö�¯U·gØiÉw19�;V>�>JDW9�GN?HG[K3>:>C26DF;VKU7:GN>zKnDh2&>C7m23TmX�TJ23��7m�p;/7J9sGeK3DW9H<�2656G&Oy¹�ZP��G$KLT:G[>JGNKLTWDW9�;\<�0�Z�23TKS>C2&./A�7J;\23<r�p;/7J9�./GeK3>C7�Dh2&>C7Nd^7J9�GN<,7:9�G@./;V>"7�2LZx./;\k3GY<�2656GN>�DhK3<,]^G@>JGF7�A�X�K3>�K�?H;\<9�GeKLXqOzw19=G�<=GF¼47[»{��<�2656Gt;V>�7J9=G�.\;\k3G�<�2656G��p;�7:9S.\GNK&>"7pDF2_>"7eOf¹�Zi��G��1KL<_7pKY>J23.\A67:;/2&<�p;/7J9R?EKU¼6;\?BA�?ÙX�TJ23��7Nd�7J9�G�./;\k3GH<�2656GE.\;\>C7BDhK3<�]^G�>JGF7nA�X�K&>nKI?EKL¼�9�GeKLXqOsw19�G<�Gh¼47$»{��<�2656G�;\>17:9�Gn.\;/k&G�<=245�G��p;/7J9�?EKU¼6;\?BA�? X�T:2L��7eO

Ú$Õq°=ÛRÜyÝ ÑrÞgÞqßÀà�áuâ^ãeä�å�æxã�ç@ãlèFéFê |x23<=>J;\5�GhTa7J9=GzT:KL7C��;/<���KL��?EKLvNGi;\<=>C7:K3<=DFG{23Z b ;\03A�T:Gm}6~&O ëg¿ÀK&ÁKL<=5n7J9�G1>C2&./A�7J;\23<Y>JX=K&DFGm2&TJ0_KL<�;\vNKL7J;\23<�2LZ b ;\03A=TJG1}6~3O\~3O�¹�<YK b ¹ bfì ]�TWKL<=DW9jK3<=5j]^23A�<g5PdU�xG]gGN03;\<H�p;�7:9r¿"~3d\~eÁyK&>f7J9�G[»z��<=245�G1K3<=5HKL<HGh?HX67"cY./;\k3Gp<=245�Gp./;V>"7eO{w19�Gp?EKLvhG1X^2&>J;�7:;/2&<�¿"~3d\~eÁ;\>$>CGh7[7J2�~�7:2EX�TJGNk3GN<&7$KHT:GF7:A�T:<�7:2E7J9�;V>pX^2&>J;�7:;/2&<qO�¿"~3d\~eÁ�;V>pGh¼4XgKL<=56Ge5Pd=K3<=5S;�7W>[<�GN;/0&9_]^23T<�2656GN>n¿C~3dí}3Á1K3<=5�¿�}6d\~eÁ1K3TJG�K35�5�GN5I7J2@7J9=Gj�&A=GhA�Gs¿À;�O G3O\d67J9=Gn./;V>"7[23Zi.\;/k&Gn<�2656GN>WÁ½Ozîf2_>C;/7J;\23<g>¿"~&d }&ÁmK3<=5,¿�}6d\~eÁxKLT:G�>JGF7�7J2�~�;/<�7J9�G�?EKLvNG$7:2YX�T:Ghk&Gh<_71?@2Uk4;\<�0j7:2@7J9�Ge>CG�Xg2_>C;/7J;\23<g>�K30&K3;/<qOw19�Gn?EKLvNG�<=2U�ï;V>pK3>p>J9�2U�p<I;\< b ;/0&A�TJGj}&}6O\~&¿ÀK_Á½d6KL<g5�7:9�Gj»{��<�2656GH¿"~&d/~lÁ�;\>p56;V>:DhKLTW56Ge5PO

~ ~ ð ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ð ð ð ð ð ð ~ ð ð¿ÀK&Á ¿�]gÁ ¿�DNÁ

ÆpÇÀñ ¸�¯ Ñ,Þ^ÞPß�à b ¹ byì ]=T:K3<=DW9SK3<=5I]g2&A�<=5S;/<�K@?EKLvNGò 2656G�¿"~&d }&Á$;V>�TJGN?H2Uk3GN5�Z�TJ2&?ó7J9�GE�_A�GNA�G@K3<=5�GF¼6X=KL<g56GN5POY¹�7:>t7J9=TJGNG@<=Gh;\0394]g2&T:>@¿À>JGhG

7J9�GI>C2&./A67:;/2&<R>CX=K&DFGE23Z b ;\03A�T:G�}6~&O/~lÁ�KLT:GEGF¼�KL?H;\<�GN5PO ì <�.\c׿C~3d ë&Á�T:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7W>nKSZ�GNK3>J;\]�./G?H2Uk3G8¿u7J9=G�TJGN?HK3;/<=;/<�0�7"��28<�2656GN>HT:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7H?H2Uk3GN>Y7:2�]=./26DW`3Ge5MX^2&>J;/7J;\23<=>WÁ½d1KL<=5×;/7s;\>

MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
MHKhan
Highlight
Page 3: Branch and Bound

ô �: :�"õö¢e�E�N�L÷öø$ùf�_�$ú@�J�"�_¢L¡û�l�hüK&5�56GN5,7J2S7:9�GE�&A=GhA�G&OHw19=;\>�?EKLvNGHXg2_>C;/7J;\23<�;\>n>JGF7�7:2�~&d�KL<g5r7:9�Gs>"7WKU7:A=>�2LZ�ýSþ4ÿ��H;\>nK&>>J9�2U�p<8;/< b ;\03A�T:GI}&}6O\~&¿�]^Á½O ò 2656G,¿C~3dí}3Á�;V>B5�;\>:DhK3T:56Ge5PO�w19�Gs<�Gh¼47@»{��<�2656GE;V>jGh¼_7:T:K&D½7:GN5Z�T:23? 7J9�GB�_A�GNA�G3O�¹�7$;V>j¿�}�d/~lÁ½O�Q�9�Gh<�7:9�;V>$»{��<�2656Gn;V>pGF¼6X=K3<=56Ge5Pd=<�2656Gs¿�ë�d\~eÁ1;V>[K&5�56GN5S7:27:9�Gj�_A�GhA�G&d6ýSþ4ÿ��4¿Àë � ~eÁm;\>$>CGh7p7J2�~3d=K3<=5I<�2656Gs¿�}�d/~lÁm;V>[56;V>:DhKLTW56Ge5POfýSþ4ÿ��n;\>pK&>p>C9=2U�p<I;\<b ;\03A�T:G[}3}6O\~&¿�DNÁFd&KL<g5B7:9�G[�_A�GhA=G[9=K3>y7:9�G[<�2656Ge>[¿"~&d ë_ÁfKL<=5�¿�ë�d\~eÁy23<H;/7NOp¿"~&d ë_Áy]gGeDF2&?@Ge>f7J9=G<�Gh¼47�»z��<�2656G&O � ;/<gDFGY7J9�;V>n»{��<�2656GY5�2_Ge>�<�2L7�03Gh7tA=>t7J2�KL<4c�<�GN�Â<�2656Ge>hda;/7�;V>�56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5K3<=5M¿�ë�d\~eÁt]gGeDF2&?@Ge>�7J9�GH<�GN�(»z��<�2656G&OY-�7�7J9=;\>�7:;/?HGH7J9=GH�_A�GNA�GH;\>�GN?HX67"c3O ò 2656G�¿Àë=d/~lÁ0&GF7:>zA=>f7J2B<�2656Gj¿Àë=d }&Á½d3�p9=;\DW9E;V>{<�2U��K35�5�GN5@7J2�7:9�G$�_A�GNA�G3d_KL<=5�¿�ë�d\~eÁy;V>z56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5PO1¿Àë=d }&Á;V>t7J9�GH<�Gh¼_7j»z��<�2656G&OB»{¼6X=K3<=56;\<�0I7J9�;V>�<�2656G3d��xG@TJGeK3DW9�7:9�GHGF¼6;/7E¿�ë�d ë&ÁFd�KL<=5r7J9�GE>JGNK3T:DW97:GhT:?@;\<=KL7JGN>NO- b ¹ byì >JGNK3T:DW9�23ZtK�?HK3vhGS9=K3>B7J9=G�5�GN>J;/TWKL]�.\G�X=TJ2&XgGNTC7"c87:9=KU7@7J9�G�X=KL7J9MZ�23A�<=5�¿�;/Z

K3<_c�Áy;V>mKn>J9�23TJ7JGe>"7zXgKU7J9HZ�T:23?(7J9=G[Gh<_7JTWKL<gDFG17J2�7:9�G$?EK3vhG3O ì ]=>JGhT:k3G�7J9gKU7z7:9�G[X=KL7J9HZ�23A=<=5]4c,]gK3DW`_7JTWK3DW`4;\<�0I?EKlc�<�2L7B]^G�K�>J9�23TJ7JGe>"7jXgKU7J9�OI¹�<_7JGNTJGe>"7:;/<=03.\c3dy�xGE9=Klk&GsKL.\TJGeK356c�>CGNGh<7:9�G�DF2656GHZ�2&TBK b ¹ byì ]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5�>JGNK3T:DW9�2LZ[K�?EKLvNG3OSw19�Gs�p;\TJGh��T:23A67:;/<=0�Dh2656G23Z1îmTJ2&03TWKL? ~Nð=O � �p9�GN<�T:A�<8�p;/7J987J9=Gs>"7WKLTJ7jXg2_>C;/7J;\23<�¿"~&d/~lÁ�KL<=5��=<�;V>J9RXg2_>C;/7J;\23<�¿�� � ��ÁX^GhTJZ�23T:?E>{K b ¹ bfì ]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5@>CGeKLTWDW9B23Zg7:9�G[?EKLvNG1K3<=5H56GF7:GhT:?H;/<�Ge>f7J9=G[>C9�2&TC7:GN>C7>C7:K3TC7J��7:2L���=<�;V>C9IX=KU7:9qO

ÚtÕq°�ÛRÜfÝ ÑrÞ^ÞPßuÞ�á������zæUã��� :ã����Fê Q�G��p;/.\.xDNKLT:TJcr2&A67j]^2L7J9�K b ¹ bfì K3<=5RK�?EKU¼4��X�TJ23��7]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5Y>CGeKLTWDW9Y2&<Y7:9�G[`4<=K3X=>JK&DW`n;/<g>"7WKL<=DhG����ïë�d������ }Lð=d=~���d�~�����d������ �&ð=d} �6d=}�����d�K3<=5"!#�Âë3ð=O{w19�G b ¹ byì k3GhTW>J;/2&<�A=>JGN>[KH�_A�GNA�G�7J2H`3GNGhXS7JTWK3DW`E23Zy.\;\k3Gn<�2656Ge>hd�K&>7:9�GN>JG�<�2656GN>pK3TJG�7J2H]^GnGF¼47JTWK3DF7JGe5�;\< b ¹ bfì 2&T:56GNTNOfw19�Gn?EKU¼4��X�T:2L��71k3GNT:>J;/2&<�A=>JGN>pK@?EKU¼9�GeKLXqdLK&>i»z��<=245�GN>yKLT:Gx>JGh.\GND½7:GN5jZ�TJ2&?ÔKL?H23<�0$7J9�G�.\;/k&Gx<�2656Ge>y;/<@56GNDhTJGeK3>J;/<�0$23TW56GhTy2LZ=X=TJ23��7GeKLT:<�GN5HKU7m7J9�Gt./;\k3G[<=245�G[23Tx;/<s56GeDFT:GNK&>C;\<�0n23TW56GNTz2LZqKL<EGe>"7:;/?EKL7JG$23Za7J9�Gt?HKL¼6;/?YA�?(X=TJ23��7GeKLT:<�GN5EKL71K3<_c@.\GNKUZi;/<�7J9�G�./;\k3Gt<�2656G�$ >�>CA�]�7JT:GhG3O{w19�G�;\<=>"7WKL<=DhG$��GtK3TJGtA=>C;\<�0Y;\>m7J9�G�>:KL?HGK&>�7J9=KL71Ag>CGe5I;\<�»{¼�KL?HX�.\Gj}6~&O }�d4K3<=5�7J9�Gj>J23.\A67J;\23<�>JX=K3DhGt7:TJGNGn;\>�7:9=KU7[23Z b ;\03A�T:Gj}6~3Oí}6Ow19�G b ¹ bfì ]=T:K3<=DW96��KL<=54��]^23A�<=5�>JGNK3T:DW9S]gGN03;\<=>[�p;/7J9r7J9�GYTJ242L7$-(K3>17:9�GY»z��<=245�G3O1-�7

7:9�;\>n7J;\?@GH7:9�GE.\;/k&G@<=245�Gs�&A=GhA�GE;V>nGh?HX67"c&OEQ�9�Gh<8<�2656Gs-Ã;V>nGh¼4XgKL<=56Ge5Pd�<=245�GN>#%ÂK3<=5|¶KLT:Gn03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5PO1-$>t]^2L7J9rK3TJGjZ�GNK3>J;\]�./G&d�7:9�Ghc�KLT:GBK35=56GN5S7:2E7J9�GB./;\k3Gj<=245�GB�_A�GhA�G&d^K3<=5<�2656Gt-�;\>�56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5qOiw19�Gt<�GF¼47x»z��<�2656G$;\>m<�2656G&%�O3¹�7�;\>mGF¼6X=KL<g56GN5@7:2j03Gh7m<�2656GN>('¶K3<=5»$O)'�;\>f;\<6Z�GeK3>J;/]�.\GpKL<=5H56;V>:DhKLTW56Ge5PdU�p9�;\./G[»�;V>{K35�56Ge5Y7J2�7J9�G[�_A�GNA�G3O ò Gh¼47�|8]^GNDF2&?HGN>y7J9=G»z��<�2656G&O�Q�9�GN<EGF¼6X=K3<=56GN5qd&;/7m.\GNK35=>f7J2n<�2656Ge> b KL<=5s¾@O�%x237J9EKLT:G1Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\G[KL<=5HK&5�56GN5@7:27:9�G$�_A�GhA=G3O{w19�G[<�Gh¼47x»{��<�2656G3d_»[dL0&GF7W>zA=>z7J2+*jK3<=5-,HO *B;\>m;/<�Z�GNK3>J;\]�./G[K3<=5E56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5qO.,;V>[K@Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\Gj.\GNKUZ{KL<g5IT:GhX=TJGe>CGN<&7W>[KHX^2&>:>C;\]�.\Gj>C2&./A67:;/2&<S7J2H7J9=Gj;/<g>"7WKL<=DhG3O�¹�7:>[X=TJ23��7[kUKL.\A�G;V>/�&ð=Ow19�GH<�Gh¼_7j»z��<�2656G@;V>�<�2656G b OP¹�7W>nDW9�;\.\56T:Gh<�o�KL<=510 K3TJG@03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5POYo×T:GhX=TJGe>CGN<&7W>

KHZ�GeK3>J;/]=./GYX=K3DW`4;\<�0E�p;�7:9,X�T:2L�=7$kUKL.\A�G2�3ð�d=�p9=;/.\G30 T:GhX=TJGe>CGN<&7W>$KHZ�GeK3>J;/]=./GYX=K3DW`4;\<�0E�p;�7:9kUKL.\A�GE~4�6Ox¾(;V>17J9�GB.\K&>"7[<�2656G�7:2s]^GNDF2&?HG�7J9�GB»z��<=245�G3Oz¹�7W>$DW9�;\.\5�TJGN< ò KL<=5 ì KLT:G�]^2L7:9Z�GeK3>J;/]�.\G3Ofw19�Gp>JGNKLTWDW9@<�2U��7:GhT:?@;\<=KL7JGN>f]^GNDNKLA=>JG�7J9�G$./;\k3G1<�2656G[�_A�GNA�G1;\>{GN?HX67"c3Ofw19�Gp]^GN>C7>J23.\A67J;\23<IZ�23A=<=5S9=K3>1kUKL.\A�G5�Lð=Oò 237J;VDFG�7:9=KU7tK b ¹ byì ]�TWKL<=DW9�KL<g5I]^23A=<=5S�x2&TJ`4;\<�0H23<�KH>C2&./A67:;/2&<�>CX=K&DFG�7JT:GhGn;V>pk&GhT:c

?YA=DW9�./;\`3G@KE]�T:GNK&547J96���=TW>"7�>CGeKLTWDW9�2LZ{7J9=Gj7JT:GhGY�p;�7:9�7J9=GBT:2_237�K&>p7J9=GY>C7:KLTJ7tk&GhTJ7JGh¼aOtw19�G

Page 4: Branch and Bound

�e��6 �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡?EK�7"23Tp56;/�aGhT:Gh<=DhG�;V>�7J9gKU7 b ¹ byì ]�T:K3<=DW9IK3<=5S]g2&A�<=5S5624GN>1<�237[>CGeKLTWDW9I>JA�]67JT:GhGe>12LZy;/<6Z�GeKU�>C;\]�.\G�<�2656GN>NOw19�G$?EKU¼4��X�T:2L��7z]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5@KL.\032&TJ;/7J9�?(]gGN03;\<=>z�p;/7J9�<�2656G$- 23Za7J9�G$>J23.\A67:;/2&<

>CXgK3DFGI7JT:GhG�K3>Y7:9�G�;/<=;�7:;\K3.[»{��<�2656G3OMw19=GS?EKL¼�9�GNK3X×23Z$./;\k3G�<�2656Ge>@;\>H;\<�;/7J;VKL.\./c�GN?HX67"c3O»{¼6X=K3<=56;\<�0E7J9=GB;\<�;�7:;\K3.{»{��<�2656Gjc4;/GN.\5=>[7:9�GB<�2656Ge>8% K3<=5�|tO9%x237J9,K3TJGjZ�GNK3>J;\]�./G@KL<=5,KLT:G;/<g>CGNTC7:GN5n;\<_7J2t7J9�G�9�GNK3XqOfw19�GmX�T:2L�=7yGeKLT:<�GN5jKL7y<=245�G(%8;V>:�_ðB¿�K3>:;9</�¶~x9=GhT:GeÁ½dU�p9=;/.\Gm7:9=KU7GNK3TJ<�Ge5HKU71|M;V>xð=Oy-�;V>m5�;\>:DhK3T:56Ge5Pd&K3<=5-%©]gGeDF2&?@Ge>f7J9=G$<�Gh¼_7�»{��<�2656G3d_K3>z;/7:>mX�T:2L��7mkUK3./A�G;\>�.VKLT:03GNT$7:9=KL<�7J9gKU7n2LZ[|tOPQ�9�Gh<=%�;V>�GF¼6X=KL<g56GN5Pdq7J9�GH<�2656Ge>#' KL<=5�»¶K3TJG@03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5PO' ;\>1;\<6Z�GeK3>J;/]�.\G�KL<=5S56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5PO{»×;\>1K&5�56GN5�7J2@7:9�G�9�GNK3XqO{»M]^GNDh23?HGN>�7:9�G�<�GF¼47[»{��<�2656G3dK3>B;�7W>jX�T:2L��7YklK3./A=Gs;\>+�&ð=di�p9�;\.\Gs7J9gKU7B23Z�|Ô;V>Bð=O�Q�9�Gh<×»�;\>BGF¼6X=K3<=56GN5qd�7:9�G�<�2656Ge>+*KL<=5-, K3TJGp0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGN5qO.*B;\>m;/<6Z�GeK3>J;/]=./G�KL<=5E56;V>:DhKLTW56Ge5PO.,�T:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7W>{K�Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\G$>C2&./A�7J;\23<qOw19�;V>$>J23.\A67J;\23<�;V>[T:GNDh23TW56GN5�K3>[7J9�GY]gGe>"7$Z�23A�<=5,>C2EZÀK3TNd^KL<=5�,Ã56;V>:DhKLTW56Ge5PO ì <�./cS23<=Gj./;\k3G<�2656G3dP<=245�GE|tdaT:Gh?EKL;\<=>NO�w19=;\>�.\;/k&GY<�2656G@]^GNDF2&?HGN>$7J9�GH<�GN�»{��<�2656G3O ò 245�GN> b KL<=5�¾KLT:GH03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5,K3<=5�;/<=>JGhTJ7JGe5�;/<_7J2S7:9�GE?EKU¼�9=GNKLX�O b 9=K&>nK�X�TJ23��7n2LZ[}��SKL<g5,]^GNDh23?HGN>7J9�GH<�Gh¼47n»z��<=245�G3O ò 245�GN>�o�KL<=5>0 K3TJGY03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5PO+%�2L7:9�K3TJGH56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5PdPK&>$7:9�Ghc�KLT:G./GeKUZ�<�2656GN>NOsw19�Gs>J23.\A67J;\23<8DF2&TJT:GN>JXg2&<=56;\<�0s7:2ro©;\>nT:GNDh23TW56GN5�K3>�7:9�GE]gGe>"7nZ�2&A�<=58>J2�ZÀK3TNOb ;/<=K3./.\c3d�¾Ô]gGeDF23?HGe>z7:9�Gn»{��<�2656G3d4KL<=5s7J9�G�<�2656Ge> ò K3<=5 ì 0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGN5qO?%�237J9IK3TJGt./GeKlk3Ge>KL<=5SKLT:G�56;\>:DhK3T:5�GN5PO ò GN;�7:9�GhTpT:GhX=TJGe>CGN<&7W>1K@>J23.\A67:;/2&<�7:9=KU7p;V>1]gGh7C7JGNTp7J9gKL<I7J9�Gn]^GN>C7pZ�23A�<g5>C2HZÀK3TNd^>C2�<�2s>C2&./A�7J;\23<�A�Xa5�KU7:Gn7:K3`3Ge>pX�.VK3DFG&Opw19�Gj9�GeKLX�;V>[Gh?HX67"c&dgK3<=5S7J9�GNTJGB;\>$<�2s<�Gh¼_7»{��<�2656G3O{w19�Gj>JGNK3T:DW9�7JGNTJ?H;\<=KU7:GN>1�p;/7J9�o8TJGNX�T:GN>JGh<_7J;\<�0Y7J9�Gn2&X67J;\?EKL.q>J23.\A67J;\23<qO-$>x;/<E7:9�G�DhK3>JGp2LZq]gK3DW`_7JTWK3DW`4;\<�0=dA@�BACEDFCHG)IKJLB8MFN)IEG)OPNLQR@TSVU-G�WRD�N�WYX@TSZN�OPJHG�O�[HC8DTQACHCH\�CH\[F]^X_D`SVO�a#G#[HN�XO9\�SVO_abMHXORJ�@cSZN)O=Ofw19�;V>qZ�A�<gD½7J;\23<BX�.\K&DFGe>�KL<BA�X�X^GhTy]g2&A�<=5n2&<n7J9�Gx?EKU¼6;/?YA�?

X�T:2L��7n7:9=KU7YDNKL<8X^2&>:>C;\]�.\c,]^Gs23]67WKL;\<�GN5�]4c,Gh¼6X=KL<=5�;/<�0rK�XgKLTJ7J;VDFA�.VKLTn<�2656G&O�¹�Z[K�<�2656G $ >]g2&A�<=5ï;\>J<d$ 7S.VKLT:03GNTE7J9=K3< 7:9�G�X=TJ23��7I23Zj7J9�G�]^GN>C7�>J23.\A67J;\23< Z�23A�<=5¶>C2�ZÀKLTed$;/7S?EKlc�]gG56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5��p;/7J9=23A67�GF¼6X=K3<=>J;/2&<qO b A�TJ7J9=GhTedt;\<ï7:9�GRDhK&>CG�2LZYK×?EKU¼4��X=TJ23��7S]=T:K3<=DW9ïKL<g5]g2&A�<=5Pdi<�2656GN>�?EKlc�]^GEGF¼47JTWK3DF7JGe5rZ�T:23?ó7:9�GH?EKU¼,9�GeKLX�;/<8<�2&<�;\<=DFT:GNK&>C;\<�0�2&T:5�GhT�2LZ�7J9�GX�T:2L��7z]^23A�<g5Pd&TWKU7:9�GhTf7:9=KL<E]4cB7J9�G$K&D½7:A=KL.�X=TJ23��7{Z�23T{7:9�G[<�2656G&O{w19�;\>m>"7:T:KL7JGh0&cn7J2BGF¼47JTWK3DF7<�2656GN>j03;\k3GN>�X=TJGhZ�GhT:Gh<=DhGY7:2�./;\k3GE<=245�GN>�7:9=KU7YK3TJGH.\;/`&Gh.\c�7J2,./GeK35,7J2�0324265�./GeKlk3Ge>hdqTWKU7:9�GhT7J9=K3<S7J2H<�2656GN>�7:9=KU7[9gKlk3GnKL.\TJGeK356cEGeKLT:<�GN5I.VKLT:03G�X�TJ23��7NO

Ú$Õq°=ÛRÜyÝ ÑrÞgÞqßfeÂá�g.hVã�ilé)j å�æ4kml6ã�j é� ��Lé)hn po�æeê |x2&<=>C;V56GNTx7:9�G�Z�23A=TC��DF;/7"cE7JTWKlk3GN./;\<�03��>:KL.\GN>JXgGNT:>J23<;/<g>"7WKL<=DhGj2LZ b ;\03A�T:GY}6~&O �gOpw19�GBDF2&TJT:GN>JX^23<=56;\<�0s>J23.\A67J;\23<r>JX=K&DFGj2&TJ0_KL<�;\vNKL7J;\23<S;\>[7J9�GYXgGNTC�?BA67WKU7:;/2&<s7JT:GhG�23Z b ;/0&A�TJGn}6~&O ��O{- b ¹ bfì ]�TWKL<=DW9SKL<=5�]g2&A�<=5I�x2&A�.\5�]gGN03;\<I�p;/7J9S<�2656G#%K3>17:9�GB;\<�;/7J;VKL.f»{��<�2656GjKL<g5�KL<�Gh?HX67"c��_A�GhA=GB2LZ{.\;/k&Gj<�2656Ge>hO1Q�9�GN<P%ï;V>[Gh¼6X=KL<=5�GN5Pdg7J9�G<�2656GN>�|tdq'BdgKL<=5�»�KLT:G�03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5POz-t>17J9�GNTJGn;V>[K3<SGe5603G�Z�T:23? k3GhTJ7JGh¼,~�7J2EGeK3DW9�2LZy7J9�Gk3GNTC7:;\DhGN>[}6d^ë�d=K3<=5"�=d=K3./.�7J9�T:GhGn23Zi7:9�GN>JGj<�2656Ge>[KLT:G�Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\GBKL<=5�K3./.P7:9�T:GhGjKLT:GjK35=56GN5I7J27J9�G��_A�GhA�G&O{w19�G$»{��<�2656G&%©;V>m56;V>:DhKLTW56Ge5Pd_K3<=5@7J9=G$<�Gh¼_71»{��<�2656G[;V>{7:9�G[�=TW>C7m./;\k3Gt<�2656G[2&<7J9�GY�&A=GhA�G&O ò 245�G@|ï;\>17:9�Gj<�Gh¼47t»{��<�2656G3O�Q�9�GN<�7J9�;V>[<�2656Gn;V>[Gh¼6X=KL<=5�GN5Pdg<�2656GN> b KL<g5¾�KLT:Gp03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5PO?%x237J9EKLT:G$K&5�56GN5Y7:2n7J9�G��_A�GhA�G$]gGeDhKLAg>CG17:9�G$0&T:K3X�9Y23Z b ;\03A=TJGt}�~3O �n9=K3>KL<SGN560&G�Z�TJ2&? k3GNTC7:GF¼S}B7J2H]^2L7:9Sk&GhTJ7JGh¼IëHKL<=5Ik3GNTC7:GF¼m�=O ò GF¼47&'�]^GNDh23?HGN>�7:9�Gj»{��<�2656G3dKL<=5�7:9�Gh<�»�]^GNDh23?HGN>n7J9�G�»z��<=245�G3O ò 2U�Â7:9�Gs.\;/k&GE<�2656G��_A�GNA�G�DF2&<_7:KL;\<=>�7:9�Gs<�2656Ge> b7J9�T:23A=039r,HO

Page 5: Branch and Bound

ô �: :�"õö¢e�E�N�L÷öø$ùf�_�$ú@�J�"�_¢L¡û�l�tsw19�Gj<=GF¼47$»{��<�2656Gn;V> b O�¹�7$;V>[Gh¼4XgKL<=56Ge5I7J2E23]�7:KL;\<�<�2656Gjomd=�p9�;VDW9�;\>tKH./GeKUZ"Ox-�7J23A=T

9=K&>H]gGNGh<�Z�2&A�<=5PO�¹�7:>sDh2&>C7s;\>"�)u=Oïw19�G�<�Gh¼_7S»{��<�2656G3dp¾@dm0&GF7:>sA=>H7J2M./GeKUZ#0Rdm�p9�;VDW956Gh�=<�Ge>EKr7:23A�TE�p9�2_>CG�DF2_>"7H;V>-v�v�O©Q�9�GN<×<�2656G�� ]^GNDF2&?HGN>@7J9=G�»z��<=245�G3dz7:9�G�./GeKUZ ò7:9=KU7@TJGNX�TJGe>CGN<_7:>jKr7J23A=TB2LZ$Dh2&>C7H} ��;\>YT:GNK3DW9=GN5POrw19�GS<�Gh¼_7H»{��<�2656Gs;V>B¹½Oy¹�7YT:GhX=TJGe>CGN<&7W>7:9�GHX=KLTJ7J;VKL.y7J2&A�TH~3d ë�d �I�p9=2&>JG@Dh2&>C7Nd�})v=dq;V>t?H2&TJGY7J9=K3<,7:9=KU7n23Zm7J9=G@]^GN>C7n7J2&A�T�Z�23A�<g5�>J2ZÀK3TNO � 2,¹n;\>Y<�2L7YGF¼6X=KL<g56GN5PO b ;\<=K3./.\c3dw*�KL<=5x, ]^GNDh23?HG�»{��<�2656Ge>BKL<g5803GF7@GF¼6X=K3<=56GN5qOb 23.\./2U�p;\<�0S7J9�;V>jGh¼6X=KL<=>J;\23<qd�7J9�G��_A�GNA�GE;V>nGh?HX67"c&dfK3<=5�7J9�GIKL.\0323T:;/7J9�?ó7:GhT:?H;/<=KL7JGe>n�p;�7:9<�2656G ò ;V56Gh<_7:;�Z�c4;\<�0H7J9�Gn]^GN>C7p7J2&A�TeO¹�<=>C7JGeK35I2LZy>JGNK3T:DW9=;/<�0B7J9�Gj>J23.\A67:;/2&<S>JX=K3DhG$7:TJGNG�;/<�K b ¹ bfì ?EKL<=<�GhTed4�xGnDF2&A�.V5I>JGNK3T:DW9

;\<,Ks.\GNK&>"7J��Dh2&>C7$?EKL<�<=GhTed^Ag>C;\<�0IK�?H;/<�9�GNK3X�7J2S>"7:23T:Gj7J9=GB.\;/k&GB<�2656Ge>hOnw19�;V>t>JGNK3T:DW9rK3.\>J2]^Gh0&;/<=>y�p;/7J9@<�2656G/%RK3>i7J9�Gp»z��<�2656G�KL<=5@KL<YGh?HX67"cn.\;/k&Gx<=245�Gx.\;\>C7NOyQ�9�GN<2%R;V>yGF¼6X=K3<=56GN5qd7:9�Gj<�2656Ge>�|tdy'YdgK3<=5�» K3TJGn0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGN5SKL<g5�K35�56Ge5S7J2E7:9�Gj?H;\<r9�GNK3XqO ì Zy7:9�GB<=245�GN>p;\<7:9�GE?H;/<89�GeKLXqdf»�9=K3>n.\GNK&>"7jDh2&>C7�¿u7J9=GEX=KLTJ7J;VKL.f7:23A�Ts~&d ��9=K&>nDF2_>"75�4Á�KL<=5�]^GNDF2&?HGN>�7J9=G<�GN� »z��<=245�G3O�»�;V>nGF¼6X=K3<=56GN5qdyK3<=5�7J9�GE<�2656Ge>5*rK3<=5=, K3TJGEK35=56GN5�7J2�7:9�GE?H;/<R9=GNKLX�Ow19�Ge>CG�<�2656Ge>19=Klk3GnKHDF2_>"7p23Z�~t�HK3<=5�}��=d6T:GN>JX^GND½7:;/k&Gh.\c3O{w19�Gn.\GNK&>"7J��Dh2&>C71<=245�G�;\<S7J9�Gn?H;\<9�GeKLX�;V>[<�2U�z'YOg¹�7t]gGeDF23?HGe>[7:9�GB»{��<�2656G&dgKL<g5r�ÔKL<g5�¹pKLT:Gn03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5PO[w19�Gj?H;\<r9�GeKLX<�2U��DF2&<_7:KL;\<=>f7:9�G$<=245�GN>�|td4�jd&¹½d�*gd&K3<=5-,HO ì Za7:9�GN>JG[<�2656Ge>hd4� 9=K&>{.\GNK3>C7xDh2&>C7NO{��;V>{7J9=G<�Gh¼47�»{��<�2656G&Oi¹�71;\>xGF¼6X=K3<=56Ge5Pd_K3<=5E7:9�G[7:23A�T�~3d ë�dí}6d �=d\~p2LZ�Dh2&>C71} ��;\>�DF2&?HX�./Gh7JGe5PO ò 2656G^*;V>z7:9�G�<�GF¼47p»{��<�2656G3OfQ�9�GN<�;/7�;V>�GF¼6X=KL<g56GN5Pd4��G$T:GNK&DW9s<�2656Gtîfd4�p9�;VDW9�T:GhX=TJGe>CGN<&7W>mKj7J23A=T23ZfDh2&>C7t}��6O ò 2656GN>&,(K3<=5S¹1K3TJG�7:9�Gj<�Gh¼_7p7"��2s»{��<�2656Ge>hOm-t>17J9=GBDF2_>"7[23Zy¹1GF¼�DhGhGN5=>�7J9=KL723Zi7:9�Gn]gGe>"7�>C2&./A67:;/2&<�Z�2&A�<=5�>J2@ZÀKLTed67J9�GY>CGeKLTWDW9s7JGNTJ?H;\<=KU7:GN>t{�<�2&<�Gn2LZy7J9�GBTJGN?HK3;/<=;/<�0H.\;/k&G<�2656Ge>pDhK3<I0&GF7[A=>�7:2sKY]^GF7J7JGNT$>C2&./A�7J;\23<qO-$>1;\<s7:9�GnDhK&>CGt2LZ�7:9�G�`_<gKLX=>:K3DW`HGF¼�K3?@X=./GH¿À»z¼6K3?HX�./Gn}3}�O }&Á½d_�xG�DhK3<�A=>JGnKB]^23A=<=56;\<�0

Z�A�<gD½7J;\23<r7J2sT:GN56AgDFGn7:9�GB<4A�?Y]gGNT$2LZ{<�2656Ge>$0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGe5SK3<=5�GF¼6X=K3<=56Ge5PO � A=DW9rKEZ�A�<=D½7:;/2&<�p;\./.f56Gh7JGhT:?H;/<=G@K�]g2&A�<=5r2&<r7:9�GY?H;\<�;\?BA�?@��DF2&>C7$7:23A�T�.\2U�xGNT[7J9gKL<�DNKL<rX^2&>:>J;/]�.\c�]gG@23]��7WKL;\<�GN58]4c�GF¼6X=KL<g56;/<=0,K�X=K3TC7:;\DhA�.\K3Tj<�2656G&O�¹�Z$K�<�2656G�$ >j]^23A=<=5R;V>C<d$ 7Y>J?EKL.\./GNTj7J9gKL<87J9=GDh2&>C7[2LZy7J9�Gj]^GN>C7$7:23A�T[Z�23A�<=5�>J2HZÀKLTed67:9=KU7$<=245�Gj?EKlc�]^GB56;V>JDNKLTW56GN5S�p;/7J9�2&A67$GF¼6X=K3<=>J;/2&<qOb A�TC7:9�GhTed3;\<E7:9�G$DhK&>CG$2LZqKn.\GNK3>C7C��DF2_>"7z]=T:K3<=DW9EKL<=5H]^23A�<g5Pd&<=245�GN>z?EKlc@]gG$GF¼47JTWK3DF7JGN5@Z�T:23?7:9�Gn?H;/<�9�GeKLXS;/<�<�2&<=56GNDhTJGeK3>J;/<=0Y2&T:56GNT12LZ�7:9�GjDF2_>"7p]^23A�<g5PO-$>I?HGh<_7J;\23<=GN5�;\<�7J9=G,X�T:GNDhGN56;\<�0MGh¼�KL?HX�.\GN>Ndp�xG,DNKL< Ag>CG�]g2&A�<=56;\<�0�Z�A=<=D½7:;/2&<=>s7:2

T:GN56AgDFG@7J9�GE<4A�?Y]gGNTj2LZ1<�2656Ge>n2LZ�7J9�Gs>J23.\A67:;/2&<�>JX=K3DhGH7JT:GhG@7J9gKU7BKLT:GH03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5POEQ�9�GN<56GNk3GN./2&X�;/<=0�K�]^23A=<=56;\<�0nZ�A�<=DF7J;\23<qd_��G[>C9�2&A�.V5Y`&GhGNX@;\<E?H;/<g5@7J9=KL7m23A�TmX�TJ;\?EKLT:cj23]A7"GND½7:;/k&G;V>17J2s>J23.\k3G�7:9�Gj;\<=>"7WKL<=DhGnA=>J;/<�0H7:9�Gn.\GNK3>C7$KL?H2&A�<_7[2LZy7J;\?@GYKL<=5SA=>J;/<=0E<�2E?H23T:G�?HGN?@2&TJc7:9=KL<s;V>1KlkUKL;\.\K3]�./G[7J2BAg>hO}|9N)WY~�SVO�a-@�BAC}QRIKN [FW�C�U�[�]#a C�ORC�IKG�@TSVO�a-@VBqCEW�CHG4D`@wOyXU�[HC�I^N�M^O9Nt\ C`DSnD�ORN)@&@�BAC^Q9I`SVU�G)I`]>N�[Z��CHJF@TSV~�CFO�-t>nKSTJGe>CA�./7Nd��xGH<�GNGN58KS]g2&A�<=56;\<�0SZ�A�<=DF7J;\23<�7J9=KL7jX=Klc6>Z�2&T�;/7:>�DF2&?@X=A67:KL7J;\23<�7:;/?HG�]_c�K×DF23T:T:GN>JXg2&<=56;\<�0�T:GN56A=DF7J;\23< ;\< 7:9�G,<4A�?Y]gGNTI23ZB<�2656Ge>0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGN5qO%1K3DW`_7JTWK3DW`4;\<�0s0&Gh<�GNT:K3./.\c�9=K3>�K�?HGN?@2&TJcrK&56kUKL<_7:K303GY2Uk3GhTt]�TWKL<=DW9�KL<=5,]g2&A�<=5PO@w19�G?HGh?H2&TJc�<�GNGN56Ge5,]4c�]=K&DW`&7:T:K&DW`4;/<�0E;V>5�H¿�.\Gh<=0L7J9�2LZx./2&<�03Ge>"7�X=KU7:9,;\<,7:9�GE>C2&./A�7J;\23<,>JX=K3DhG2&TJ0_KL<�;\vNKL7J;\23<gÁFdg�p9�;\.\GY7:9=KU7�<�GNGN56Ge5,]4c�]�TWKL<=DW9�KL<=5,]g2&A�<=5�;\>#�H¿�>C;\vhGH2LZ�>C2&./A67:;/2&<�>JX=K3DhG2&TJ0_KL<�;\vNKL7J;\23<gÁFO b 23T@K,>JA�]=>JGF7@>JX=K&DFGs]=K&DW`_7JTWK3DW`4;/<=0ST:GN�_A�;\T:GN>3�@¿Z��Án?HGh?H23T:c3df�p9�;\.\Gs7J9=G]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�?HGF7:9�265�>�DF2&<=>C;V56GNTJGe5�TJGe�&A=;/T:G2�H¿�})��Á$?@GN?H23T:c3O b 2&T�K�XgGNTJ?YA67:KL7J;\23<>JX=K3DhGE]=K3DW`_7:T:K&DW`_;\<�0�T:GN�_A�;\TJGe>3�@¿���Án?@GN?H23T:c3df�p9�;\./GI]�T:K3<=DW9�KL<g58]g2&A�<=5R<�GNGN5�>2�H¿��b�íÁ½O

Page 6: Branch and Bound

�e�t� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡-[./7J9�2&A�039�K�?EKU¼4��X=TJ23��7Y2&TE./GeK3>C7C��DF2&>C7Y]=T:K3<=DW9×K3<=5M]^23A=<=5©9=K3>@;\<&7:A�;/7J;\k3G�KLX�X^GNK3.p2Uk3GNT]=K3DW`_7:T:K&DW`_;\<�0sK3<=5r?H;\039_7�]^GHGF¼6X^GND½7:GN5r7J2SGF¼�KL?H;\<�GBZ�GN�xGNTt<=245�GN>�23<�?HK3<4cS;\<�X�A�7:>NdP7J9�G>CXgK3DFG�<�GNGN5�>f?H;\039_7zGF¼�DFGNGN5B�p9=KU7z;V>{KlkUKL;\.\K3]�./G1>J2_2&<�GhTy7:9=KL<Y7J9�G�7:;/?HGp<�GNGN5�>f23Zg]=K&DW`&7:T:K&DW`_�;/<=0@Gh¼�DFGhGe5s7:9�Gn.\Gh<�037J9�2LZy7J;\?HGn�xGnKLT:G��p;/.\.\;/<�0@7:2E��K3;�71Z�23T17:9�GjKL<g>C��GhTeO%1�Â%8�z�×�a!�%×!~3O1¹�<HK Ý�°�ÈhÉ�� Ç ±d�:Øi¯UÈNÉF�:·^¸iÉBÍ Ð Ê Æ Ì�Î ]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5n>JGNK3T:DW9qde7:9�G1./;V>"7f2LZg./;\k3Gx<�2656GN>]^Gh9=Klk&GN>[K&>[Ks>C7:K&DW`^O/'tGN>:DFT:;/]^Gn7J9=GjX�T:2303T:GN>:>�2LZz>JA=DW9rKH?HGF7J9=245r23<S7J9�GY`4<=KLX=>:K3DW`;\<=>C7:KL<gDFGr23Zn»z¼�KL?HX�.\G�}&}6Oí}6O��[2U�ó5624GN>so�¹ byì ]�TWKL<=DW9�KL<g5×]^23A=<=5�56;/�^GNTsZ�T:23?]=K&DW`_7JTWK3DW`4;/<=0��

}6O$|x2&<=>C;V56GNTx7:9�Gjð��6~$`4<=K3X=>JK&DW`H;/<=>C7:K3<=DFG��p;/7J9"�=�z�=d4�P��� �=d�ë�d�}�dP~F��d�z����~&d=}6d6ë�d����d=K3<=5"!#��v�O¿�K&Á�'$TWKl� 7:9�Gj>J23.\A67J;\23<�>CXgK3DFG�7:TJGNGtZ�2&T[KYZ�23A�TJ��2&]7"GNDF7p`_<gKLX=>:K3DW`E;\<=>C7:KL<gDFG3O¿À]gÁSw�TWK3DhG�7J9�T:23A=039�7J9=GB��23T:`_;\<�0H2LZzK b ¹ bfì ]=T:K3<=DW96��KL<=54��]^23A�<=5�>JGNK3T:DW9qdgK3>[�1K3>5623<=G�;\<�»{¼�KL?HX�.\Gj}3}�O }�O

¿�DNÁ"�$>JGp7J9=Gp?@Gh7J9�2652�q���_���¿ÀîzT:230&T:K3?Â}6~&O u_Áq7:2B56Gh7JGhT:?H;/<=G17J9�G[?EKL¼4;\?BA=?ÂX�T:2L��723]67WKL;\<=KL]=./G�KL7YKL<4c�./GeKUZp;/<�K,>CA�]�7JT:GhG3O��t>CG�7J9�;V>j]^23A�<g587J2&03GF7:9�GhTB�p;�7:9R7J9�GkUKL.\A�Gn2LZy7J9�GB]gGe>"7$>J23.\A67J;\23<�56Gh7JGNTJ?H;\<�GN5�>J2YZÀK3Tp7J2s5�GNDF;V56Gn�p9�Gh7J9�GNT[23Tp<=2L7p7J2K35�5�K@<�2656G�7:2Y7:9�Gn.\;/k&Gn<�2656G�./;V>"7eOzQ�9�;VDW9�<�2656GN>123Zi7:9�Gj>C2&./A�7J;\23<�>CX=K&DFG�7JT:GhGKLT:G�03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5s]4c�K b ¹ byì ]�TWKL<=DW9�KL<=5I]^23A�<=5I7:9=KU7[A=>JGN>�7:9�;V>p?HGNDW9=K3<�;\>J?m�

¿�5=ÁSw�TWK3DhG$7:9�T:23A�0&9�7:9�G��x2&TJ`4;\<�0Y23ZyK@?EKU¼4��X�TJ23��71]�T:K3<=DW96��KL<=56��]^23A�<g5�>JGNKLTWDW9qd6K3>��K&>p5623<=G�;\<�»{¼�KL?HX�.\Gj}3}�O }�O

¿ÀGeÁIQ�9�;VDW9@<=245�GN>f2LZ^7J9=G1>J23.\A67:;/2&<@>JX=K3DhG�7JT:GhGpKLT:G103Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5B56A=TJ;\<�0nK�?HKL¼4��X�T:2L�=7]�TWKL<=DW9�KL<=5I]^23A�<=5S�p9�GN<S7J9�Gn]^23A�<g56;/<=0HZ�A�<=D½7:;/2&<�2LZ�¿�DNÁ�;V>pA=>JGN5q�

¤p¤t¥�¤ ������� �9� �M§ � ­�� !�w�/�c���p� �1 ¢¡(£_¤b¥K¡§¦d¨ª©5 w¤b«8¥p¡§¬­#®4­#¯±°r² ³d´wµ_¶·³d´¢¸·°r¹:º(´w¸

»¼¾½ w19�G�DF2&<&7WKL;\<�GhTJ��./2_K356;\<�0rX�T:23]=./GN? 2LZ � GNDF7J;\23<©}�~3Oí}6O\~IGe>J>JGh<_7:;\K3./.\cRTJGe�_A�;/T:GN>YA=>@7:2��g<=5×K

?EKU¼6;/?YA�? .\2&K&56;/<=0�23Z$7:9�G��=TW>"7�>J9�;\XqO w19�;V>HX�TJ2&]�.\Gh? ;V>sK8>CA=]=>CGh7C��>CGN./GeD½7:;/2&<MX�T:23]�.\Gh?�dKL<=5I7:9�GY>J23.\A67J;\23<�>JX=K3DhGn23T:0&K3<�;/veKU7:;/2&<�;V>$KE>JA�]=>JGF7[7:TJGNG3O1w19�G b ¹ byì ]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5KL<=K3./2&0I23Z1îmTJ2&03TWKL?Ù}�~3O\~@;V>jîmTJ2&03TWKL?Ï}3}�O/~&Osoq;\`3GsîzT:230&T:K3?Ï}6~3O\~3dyîzT:230&T:K3?ó}&}6O\~@�=<=5�>23<�.\cE7:9�Gn�xGN;/0&9_7123ZfK@?EKU¼6;\?BA�? ./2_K356;\<�0=Ow19�G�?@Gh7J9�2652¿RÀ ÁÂ�_À �RÃ��ÄY5624Ge>�K b ¹ byì ]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5s>JGNK3T:DW9�2LZq7:9�G�>J23.\A67:;/2&<

>CXgK3DFG[7JT:GhG[A=>J;\<�0j7:9�Gt�_A�GNA�G^ÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇ[7:2B>C7J23T:Gp7:9�G$��Gh;\039_7xK&>J>J26DF;VKU7JGe5H�p;�7:9sGNK&DW9./;\k3G@<�2656G&OYw19�GE�_A�GhA=G@K3.\>J2S>C7J2&TJGe>[7:9�GH�xGN;/0&9_72Ên~Y7J2S?EKLT:`�7J9�GHGh<g5,23ZxKS./GNk3Gh.f23Zm./;\k3G<�2656GN>NOjw19�G@?HGF7J9=245=À��_��ÂRÃ4ÆAÇ È���Ç@;V>tAg>CGe5�7J2�K35=5r<�2656Ge>@¿À;�O G3O\da7J9=Gh;\T���Gh;\039_7W>:Á[7J2I7J9�G

Page 7: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �l�N�

Î �_�yÅAÃ�ÏÑÐ�ÒAÀ ÒRÃ�ÏÓÃ��Ò�¿9À Á_Â�_À��RÃt�ÄwÔtÃ��_ÒÖÕØ×ÑÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ¢ÛPÃt�Ò·Ï)À Î ÀqÏÃ�Ò_Ü9ÝÞ ß_ß Ð�Ç ÒzÏ Å�ÀqÐ�Ðà�_À ÒAÀá¿9Ç4¿q�AÇ âRÐ�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä_å_���ÒAÀyÃt�qÇ âyÐ>æÓÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Ò}çKÅ�Ç��_Ä_Ò�ÚÑè·éëê¿9À Á�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒí_� îAÀ â�æ�ïbêÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇÉ��qÇ��qÇ�æÓ�qÇ)Ù�ð�â_âAÀ ÜqÉ��qÇ��qÇ?Ô�ÝñêÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇÉ��qÇ��qÇ¢ç Î �ÒbÔ��AÇ�Ù�ò��ÒÇ ÄAÇ âwÔHèRé Ý_Ýñê ß_ß Ç��A�è���äAè_Å Ç ÆAÇÅ�¿9À â_óÇ âß_ß Ã��ëÃ4Ò9Ã�ÀÅqÃ�ôÇ�ä� âõÅ�Ç ÆAÇ_Åöé�÷qè)�A���ÇÃ��ÒõÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å�æøéëêÃ��ÒõÇ ÈA���_Ç�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒªæ�ïbêß_ß Ð�Ç_À âRÏ�ÚzÐ4�_�9Ð�Ç�ÒöÐ Î ÀqÏ�ǪÒ_âÇ_ÇÙ_ÚëÃ�Å ÇùÔpÒ_â��qÇyÝÞ ß_ß Ï�ÚqÇqÏ�ó�Å�Ç ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å ����äÓ÷qè)�A���ÇÃ�ä�ÔLÇ ÈA���Ç)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒàúÓÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Ò/Õ�Ç ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ Æ_ÇÅ ×�û æzÏ�À Î ÀAÏÃ4Ò_Ü9Ýß�ß Å�Ç ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å �À �_�_ÂRÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç.ÔHÇ ÈA����Ç�ìAÇqÃ4Ä ÚÒ�úÑÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ/Õ�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇ_Å ×bÛmÇ�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆAÇÅqÝdêß_ß âRÃ4Ä�ÚÒöÏ4Ú9Ã�Å �zÃ�ЪÀÅ)ÙqÀ ÜyÐ�äÇ_ÀqÐÃt�yÅ�ÇÀ��_�_ÂRÃ�ÆAÇ ÈA���_Ç?ÔHÇ ÈA� �_Ç�ìqÇAÃ4Ä Ú_Ò¢Û-Ç ÈA���Ç ÂÇ ÆAÇÅAÝñêß_ß ÄÇ ÒÑ�qÇ Á_ÒÓ÷qè)�A���ÇÇ ÈA���Ç)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒªæÖÔ_Ôtò��ÒÇ ÄAÇ â9ÝáÅqÃ4ÆAÇ È���ÇÉ)�AÇ��qÇ¢çØâÇ�¿9�)ÆAÇ.ÔtÝ�Ý:ç`Ã��Ò_üÀ_Å��qÇ?ÔFÝñêÃ�ä�ÔLÇ ÈA���Ç)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òàæ_æõèRé ÝÞ ß_ß Ç��A����äõÅ�Ç ÆAÇÅÃ4ä�Ô`ÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇÉ)�qÇ)�qÇ¢çHà Ð�÷�¿ Î Ò_ÜwÔFÝ_Ýß_ß �q��¿R� âAÇ�ÅqÃ4ÆAÇà�q� �ÇqÐâAÇ�Ò��â���¿9À�Á�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒAí_� îÀ â¢êÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇÉ)�qÇ)�qÇ¢ç Î ��ÒwÔ��AÇ�Ù�ò��ÒAÇ ÄÇ âwÔ`èRé�Ý_Ýñê ß_ß Ç��A�Aè�� äAè_Å�Ç ÆÇÅ>¿9À�â_óAÇ âß�ß ÄAÇ�ÒÓ�AÇ Á_ÒÓ÷qè)�q� �ÇÇ�ÈA���Ç�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒàæ�Ô�Ôtò��ÒAÇ�ÄAÇ â9Ý�ÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇÉ)�qÇ)�qÇ¢çØâ_Ç4¿R� ÆÇ.ÔtÝ Ý.ç`Ãt�_Ò�üAÀÅ4�qÇ.Ô�ÝdêÇ�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆAÇÅ ú�úwêýýý

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßÀà b ¹ byì ]�T:K3<=DW96��KL<=56��]^23A�<g5I>JGNK3T:DW9�Z�23T[DF2&<_7:KL;\<�GNT�.\2&K&56;\<�0�¿ÀDF2&<_7J;\<_A=GN>WÁ

Page 8: Branch and Bound

�e�N� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

Î âRÃ4ÆAÀ ÒAÇ�Ð4ÒAÀ Ò9Ã�ÏáÆ�yÃ���À��_�_ÂyÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �Ç?ÔtÃ��_Ò�Ò ÚqÇ�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ¢Û�Ã��Ò�Ò�ÚqÇ�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅqÝÞ Ã�äùÔKÒ�ÚAÇ�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å�æ_æÑ�_��¿q�qÇ�âqã ä_å�)�ÒAÀyÃ��AÇ�âRÐÝÞ ß_ß äÇ�ÀqÐÃ��yÅ ÇÑÅ�Ç_À�äÃ�äÖÔKÒ�ÚqÇ)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Ò�þ�¿RÀ Á�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒAí_��îAÀ â9Ý ß_ß �qÇ Ò�ÒAÇ â�Å�Ç_À äÓâÇ_ÀqÏ4ÚqÇ �¿9À Á�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒí_� îAÀ â�æÓÒ�ÚqÇ�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ¢êýÇÅAÐ)Ç ß_ß �q� Ò�ÀõÅ Ç_À�äÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇwç Î �Ò?Ôp�qÇ)Ù�ò��_ÒAÇ ÄAÇ âbÔKÒ�ÚqÇ�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒyÝ_ÝdêýÖ�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPß�à b ¹ bfì ]=T:K3<=DW96��KL<=54��]^23A�<=5I>CGeKLTWDW9sZ�2&T[DF23<_7WKL;\<�GhT1.\2&K35�;/<�0�¿�DF23<gDF.\A=56GN5gÁ

./;\k3Gn<=245�GB�_A�GhA�G&O�w19=;\>p?HGh7J9�265�]^Gh0&;/<=>[]_c�DW9�GeDW`_;\<�0H�p9�Gh7J9�GNT[7J9=Gj./GNk3GN.q2LZy7J9�GB<�2656Gn7J2]gGHK35=56GN5,GN�_A=KL.V>t7J9�G@<4A�?B]^GhT�23ZxDF2&<&7WKL;\<�GhTW>NO�¹�Z1>C2gda�xGHKLT:GYKL7�KI./GeKUZ"Ojo�GNKlk3Ge>tK3TJGY<�2L7K35�5�GN5�7:2�7:9�GH�&A=GhA�G&dqK3>t7J9�Ge>CG@<�2656Ge>�DNKL<�<=2L7�]gG@GF¼6X=K3<=56GN5qOjoqGNKlk&GN>$7J9=KL7�K3TJGYTJGeK3DW9�Ge556GF�g<�GBZ�GeK3>J;/]=./GH>C2&./A�7J;\23<=>NdPKL<=5�GeK3DW9r;V>�DW9�GNDW`&GN5�Z�2&Tt]^Gh;\<�0S]gGh7C7:GhT�7J9=K3<r7:9�GY]^GN>C7�Z�23A�<g5>C2@ZÀK3TNO{w19�Gn��Gh;\039_7p2LZfKY<=23<�.\GNKLZy<�2656G�;V>[K35=56GN5�7J2H7:9�Gj�_A�GhA�G&O

¿RÀ ÁÂ�_À �RÃ��ÄB]^Gh0&;/<=>1]4cE;\<�;/7J;VKL.\;/vN;/<�0mÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å+�Ã~H¿ÀDFA=TJT:Gh<_7p»{��<�2656Gt;V>x7J9�G�T:242L7WÁKL<=5�¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�â3�ÔðI¿ÀkUKL.\A�Gn2LZy]gGe>"7p.\2&K35�;/<�0YZ�23A=<=5�>C2YZÀKLT½Á½O{-�7p7J9=;\>�7:;/?HGn<�2@./;\k3G<�2656GN>$KLT:G�;\<�7J9=Gj�&A=GhA�G&Ox-ÿÊn~n;V>[K35�5�GN5I7J2H7:9�GB�_A�GhA=G�7J2E;\<=56;VDhKU7:G�7J9=KL7[�xGjK3TJGjKL7p7J9�GGh<=5�2LZ�.\Ghk&Gh.y~3Of¹�<s7:9�G8Ù�ÚëÃ�Å�Çj.\2423XI�xG$�=T:>C7p>CGNG$�p9�Gh7J9�GNTx7:9�G�./GhZu7pDW9=;/.V5s23Zq7J9�G�»{��<�2656Gt;\>Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\G3O�¹�Zm>C2gdyÀ����_ÂRÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇY;\>$;/<4k32&`3Ge5POxw19�GN<�7J9�GBTJ;\039_7$DW9�;\.\5�;V>$K&5�56Ge5POn¿Àw19�;V>$DW9�;\.V5;\>10&A=KLTWKL<_7:GhGN5s7J2E]^G�Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\G3OíÁQ�9�Gh<s]^2L7:9�DW9�;\.\5�TJGN<E2LZP7J9=Gt»{��<�2656Gp9=Klk&Gp]gGNGh<s0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGe5PdL7:9�Gt»z��<�2656Gt56;/Ge>mK3<=5H�xG

GF¼47JTWK3DF7p7J9�GB<�GF¼47t»z��<�2656GjZ�TJ2&? 7J9=GB�_A�GhA�G&Opw19�GB�_A�GhA=GBDhK3<�<�2L7[]^GBGN?HX67"cSKL7p7J9�;V>p7:;/?HG]gGeDhK3A=>CGt;�71?BAg>"71DF23<_7WKL;\<�KU7�./GeK3>C7m7J9=GtGN<=54��2LZu��./GNk3Gh.g?EKLT:`3GhT&Ên~3Of¹�Zq�xGt9=Klk3GtTJGeK3DW9�Ge5@7J9�GGh<=5�23ZzKE./GNk3GN.�d=7J9�GN<��xGB>JGhGn�p9=GF7J9=GhTtK3<4c�.\;/k&Gj<�2656GN>[Z�TJ2&? 7:9�GB<�Gh¼47$./GNk3GN.iKLT:GnX�T:GN>JGh<_7NOw19�GN>JG�<�2656GN>1KLT:G�X�TJGe>CGN<_7x;/��7J9�Gn�_A�GhA=Gt;V>1<�2L71Gh?HX67"c&O{Q�9�Gh<S.\;/k&Gt<�2656Ge>xZ�TJ2&?Ã7J9�G�<�Gh¼_7./GNk3GN.�KLT:G�X�TJGe>CGN<_7Nd���GnK35�5�KL<�GN<=54��2LZu��./GNk3Gh.P?EK3TJ`&GhT17J2H7:9�GB�_A�GNA�GjKL<=5S]^Gh0&;/<S7J2EX=TJ26DFGe>J>7J9�Gn.\;\k3G�<�2656GN>pKL7p7J9�Gn<=GF¼47[./GNk3GN.�Ow19�G�7J;\?HGjKL<=5�>JX=K3DhGtT:GN�_A�;\TJGN?HGh<_7:>123Z9¿9À Á_Â�_À��RÃt�ÄHKLT:G5�H¿�})��ÁFO

� ´·®����¢² ¹������y´��Q�G@?EKlcrKU7J7JGh?HX67�7:9�GYT:GF�g<�Gh?HGh<_7�A=>JGN5�;/<�îzT:2303TWKL?ó}6~&O }�O�¹�<r7J9=;\>�T:GF�=<=Gh?HGh<_7nK�T:;/0&9_7DW9�;\.\5×��K&>BX=A�T:>JA�Ge5M2&<�./cR;/Z$7:9�G��xGN;/0&9_7HK&>J>J26DF;VKU7JGe5R�p;/7J9�;�7EX�.\A=>�¿ZâÇ4¿9ÀyÃ��9Ã��Ä�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ�ÁGF¼�DFGNGN5�>§¿9À Á�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒAí�� îAÀ âaOt¹�<RîzT:230&T:K3? }&}6O\~E¿9À Á�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒAí�� îAÀ â�5624GN>J<d$ 7n03GF7nA�Xa5�KL7JGN5A�<_7J;\.(Ç ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇÅ�GN�_A=K3.\>^�_��¿q�qÇ�âqã ä_å�)�ÒAÀyÃ��AÇ�âRÐ_OYîzT:;/2&Tt7:2�7J9�;V>n7:;/?HGE7:9�GET:;/0&9&7J��DW9=;/.V57JGe>"7BK3./�1Klc6>t>JA=DhDhGhGe5�>hdiK3>§¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�âr� ð�KL<=5>âAÇ4¿RÀyÃ��ëÃ��_Ä�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ � ð�OHQ�9�Gh<Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ@Ge�&AgKL.V>§�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä_å_���ÒAÀyÃt�AÇ âRÐ_d4<�2I?@2&TJGY<�2656GN>�K3TJG@K35�56Ge5�7J2I7J9=G@�_A�GNA�G3O� 2@7J9�GnT:;\039_7C��DW9�;\.\5�7JGe>"7[;V>12LZf<�2HA=>JG�KL7p7J9�;V>17:;/?HG3O

Page 9: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �l���wi2s?EKL`3G�7:9�GjT:;/0&9_7C��DW9�;/.V5�7JGN>C7tGh�^GeD½7:;/k&G3d=��Gn<�GNGN5S7J2�A�X^5=KU7JG^¿RÀ Á�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒAí_��îAÀ âBGeKLTJ�

.\;/GNTNO�Q�GY`4<�2U� 7:9=KU7�7J9=GY��Gh;\039_7t23Z{7J9�GH]^GN>C7�.\2&K&56;\<�0s;V>$7:9�G@?HKL¼6;/?YA�?ó2LZ{7:9�GH�xGN;/0&9&7W>K&>J>J26DF;VKU7JGe5B�p;/7J9s7J9�GpZ�GeK3>J;/]=./G[<=245�GN>z;\<H7J9=Gt>JA�]=>JGF7z7:TJGNG3O � ;/<gDFG[7:9�GN>JG$K&>J>J26DF;VKU7JGe5@�xGN;/0&9&7W>;\<=DFT:GNK&>CG$23<�.\cY�p9=Gh<IKB?H2Uk3G[;V>m?EK&56G[7:2YKj.\GFZu7pDW9�;\.\5qd&��G$?EKlcHA�Xa5�KU7:G}¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�âKL7�KL.\.{>CAgDW9,?H2Uk3Ge>hOnw19�;V>�23]=>JGhT:kUKU7J;\23<�T:GN>JA�./7:>�;\<r7J9=G@Dh245�GY23ZxîzT:230&T:K3? }&}6Oí}6O�Q�9�Gh<8K.\;/k&Gs<�2656GS;\>@K35=56GN587:2r7:9�GI�_A�GNA�G3dbÒ�ÚqÇ�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒ,DhK3<�<�2L7@GF¼�DFGNGN5�¿9À Á�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒí_� îAÀ â�K3<=5>J2á¿RÀ Á�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒAí_��îAÀ â�;V>�<�2L7rA=X^5�KL7JGe5POÏ- >C;\<�0&./G�>C7:KL7JGh?HGN<&7ed�;/<=>JGhTJ7JGe5¶5�;/T:GNDF7J.\cï;\<&7:2¿9À ÁÂ_�_À��RÃ��_ÄadL<=2U�ïT:GhX�.VK3DhGN>x7J9�Gn?HGh7J9�265�À��_��ÂRÃ4ÆAÇ È���ÇgO­�� ´w¸�� ´�����¶���°��������bº��������wi2I]^GsKL]=./GY7J2S�=<=5�7:9�GH]gGe>"7B>JA�]=>JGF7edq�xGH<�GNGN5,7J2�>C7J23T:G@X=KU7:9=>�Z�TJ2&?ó7J9=G@.\;\k3GH<�2656GN>�7:27:9�GE7JT:GhG�TJ242L7eOSw19=Gh<��p9�GN<R�xG�9=Klk3GE56Gh7JGhT:?H;/<=GN5R�p9�;VDW9R.\GNKUZp0&;/k&GN>�7:9�Gs]^GN>C7Y.\2&K35�;/<�0gd��G,DhK3<�7JTWKlk3GNT:>JGS7J9�G�X=KU7:9�7J2R7:9�G,T:242L7I>JGF7J7J;\<�0R7:9�GPÁ©kUKL.\A�GN>NOÔQ�G,<�GNGN5©7J2©DW9=KL<=03G7:9�Gs5�KU7WKI7"c_X^GH2LZ�7J9�GEGN./GN?HGh<_7:>n;\<�7J9�Gs�_A�GNA�GE2LZ�./;\k3GE<�2656Ge>�Z�TJ2&? ò��ÒÇ ÄAÇ âS7J2>É�ÈA� �Çgd�p9�GNTJG#É�È���ÇB9=K3>m7J9�G�;\<=>"7WKL<=DhG�5=KU7:KB?HGh?B]^GhTW> Î À âAÇ��ÒS¿ÀXg2&;/<_7JGNT�7J2BXgKLT:Gh<_7x<�2656G�;\<s7J9=G>J23.\A67J;\23<8>JX=K3DhGH7JT:GhGeÁFdbÅ�Ç�ä�Òå�ÚëÃ�Å ��¿�7JT:A�Gs;/�×<�2656GE;V>�7:9�Gs.\GFZu7YDW9�;\.V5�23Z�;/7:>BX=KLT:Gh<_7½Á½diK3<=5ÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ�¿���Gh;\039_7t23ZzX=KLTJ7J;VKL.y./2_K356;\<�0�KL7$7:9�;\>�<�2656GlÁ½Onw19�GY<�Gh�Ô]=T:K3<=DW96��KL<=54��]^23A�<=5�Dh2656GK3X�XgGeKLTW>�;/<�îzT:230&T:K3? }3}6O ë�O��³! #"%$m²�¹'&���°r²�³d´¢µ�¶ø³d´w¸ø°"¹.º¢´¢¸¹�<8K�?EKL¼_��X�T:2L��7�]�TWKL<=DW9���K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5,>JGNK3T:DW9,2LZm7:9�Gs>JA�]=>JGF7�7JT:GhG&dP7J9�GH.\;\>C7n2LZ�./;\k3GH<�2656Ge>;V>BK�?EKL¼_��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c,�_A�GNA�G3O,»xK3DW98.\;/k&Gs<�2656G Á�;\<87J9�GS�&A=GhA�GI9=K3>YKL<RA�X�X^GhTY�xGN;/0&9_7I¿�2&T?EKU¼EX�T:2L�=7WÁxK3>:>C26DF;VKU7:GN5E�p;/7J9I;�7eOzw19�;V>xA=X�XgGNT1�xGN;/0&9&71;V>z7:9�G��xGN;/0&9&71K3>:>C26Dh;\KL7JGN5s�p;�7:9s7J9=G<�2656GEÁsX=./A=>�7:9�Gn��Gh;\039_7�23Z�7:9�GnTJGN?EKL;\<�;/<=0@Dh23<_7:K3;/<�GNT:>NOfoq;\k3G�<�2656GN>1]^GNDh23?HGn»{��<�2656GN>�;\<56GeDFT:GNK&>C;\<�0�23TW56GhTm2LZa7J9�GN;/TxA�X�X^GhT��xGN;/0&9_7NO ò 2L7:;\DhGp7J9gKU7x;/ZëÁY;V>mKj<�2656G[�p;/7J9sA�X=XgGNTm��Gh;\039_7Á}ç � Î�Î Ç â�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒadh7:9�Gh<s<=2B<�2656Gt;/<s;/7:>�>JA�]67JT:GhGt9=K3>m�xGN;/0&9_7x?H23T:Gp7J9gKL<mÁ}ç � Î�Î Ç â�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒaOb TJ2&?ó7J9�;V>j2&]=>JGhT:klKL7J;\23<8KL<=5�7:9�GE23]=>JGhT:kUKU7:;/2&<,7:9=KU7n7:9�Gs��Gh;\039_7jK3>:>C26DF;VKU7:GN5��p;�7:9�K�./GeKUZ<�2656G�Ge�&AgKL.V>1;�7W>1A�X�X^GhT[��Gh;\039_7Nd4��GnDF23<gDF.\A=56G�7J9gKU7p�p9�Gh<�K@.\GNKUZy]gGeDF2&?@Ge>�7J9�Gj»z��<=245�Gt;\<KY?EKU¼4��Dh2&>C7x]�TWKL<gDW9IKL<g5s]^23A�<=5qd6<�2HTJGN?HK3;/<=;/<�0Y./;\k3G�<�2656GnDhK3<�.\GNK&5E7J2EKY./GeKUZ��p;/7J9S?H23T:G��Gh;\039_7NO{w19�GNTJGhZ�23T:G3d4��G�?EKlcE7:GhT:?H;/<=KL7JG�7:9�Gj>CGeKLTWDW9sZ�2&T17J9�Gn]^GN>C7[./2_K356;\<�0gOw19�;V>Y>C7JTWKU7:Gh0&c�?EKlc�]gGI;/?HX�.\Gh?HGh<_7:GN5�;\<�2&<�Gs2LZp7"��2r�1Klc6>hOr¹�<�7J9�G��=T:>C7YGeK3DW9R.\;/k&G

<�2656GBTJGe>C;V56GN>[;/<�7:9�GB?EKU¼4��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c��_A�GhA=GBKL.\23<�G&Ox¹�<�7:9�;V>tDNK3>JGnGNK3DW9�<�2656GB?BA=>C7tDF2&<_7:KL;\<7:9�GpX=KU7:9HZ�TJ2&?Ô7:9�G[T:2_237z2LZ^7J9�Gt>CA�]g>CGh7z7JT:GhG17:2�7J9�G[<=245�G3O{w19�;V>{;/<�Z�23T:?HKL7J;\23<H;V>{<�GhGe56GN5@7:256Gh7JGNTJ?H;\<�G[7:9�G8ÁHkUKL.\A�Ge>m2&<=DFG[��G$9gKlk3G$;V56GN<&7:;��gGN5H7:9�Gt.\GNKLZP7J9=KL7�c4;\Gh.V5�>m7J9�G�]gGe>"71.\2&K35�;/<�0gO¹�<�7:9�GY>JGNDh23<=5�>C7JTWKU7:Gh0&c3d=;\<�K&5�56;/7J;\23<�7:2�X�.VK3Dh;/<�0�GNK3DW9�.\;\k3GB<=245�GB;\<&7:2s7:9�GB?EKU¼4��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c�_A�GNA�G3d37J9�G[<=245�G[;\>mGh<_7JGNTJGe5@;/<_7J2YKn>CGNX=KLTWKU7:G17JT:GhG[>C7JT:A=D½7:A�TJG17:9=KU7�TJGNX�T:GN>JGh<_7:>y7:9�G[X^23TJ7J;\23<23Zy7:9�GB>JA�]=>JGF7t7JT:GhGn03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5PO1Q�9�GN<�7J9=Gj]gGe>"7�./GeKUZ{;V>[;V56Gh<_7J;/�=Ge5Pd=7:9�GYDh23T:TJGe>CX^23<g56;/<=02ÁkUKL.\A�Ge>[KLT:Gn56GF7:GhT:?@;\<�Ge5�]_c�Z�23.\./2U�p;\<�0@7J9=GjX=KU7:9SZ�TJ2&? 7:9�Gn./GeKUZf7J2H7:9�GjT:242L7NOmQ�Gj�p;\.\.�A=>JG7:9�;\>p>JGNDh23<=5I;\?@X=./GN?@GN<_7:KU7:;/2&<�?@Gh7J9�265POx»{¼6GhTWDF;V>CG#�YGF¼6X�.\23T:GN>x7J9=G��=T:>C7p?HGF7J9=245qOw19�GS>C2&./A67:;/2&<M>JX=K3DhGE7JT:GhGs;V>YTJGNX�TJGe>CGN<_7JGN58Ag>C;\<�0r<�2656Ge>B23Zp7J9�G�7"c4XgG)(*(_�q���Ç=Or»xK3DW9

<�2656Gp23Zg7:9�;V>f7"c4XgG[9gK3>y7J9=Gp�=Gh.V5�> Î À âAÇ��_Òs¿ÀXg2&;/<_7:GhT{7:2nX=KLT:Gh<_7{<�2656G[;\<@7J9�G$>J23.\A67:;/2&<@>JX=K3DhG7:TJGNGeÁ�KL<=5�Å�Ç�ä�Ò_å ÚëÃ�Å �I¿�7JT:A�G�;��r7:9�Gn<�2656Gn;V>[K@./GhZu7$DW9�;\.\5S2LZy;�7W>pX=K3TJGN<&7½Á½O

Page 10: Branch and Bound

�N�,+ �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

Î ���yÅqÃ�ÏÑÐ�ÒÀ Ò9Ã�ÏÓÃ��_Òà¿RÀ ÁÂ�_À �RÃ��ÄwÔ�Ã��ÒùÕØ×ÓÙAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒwÛ>Ã��ÒzÏ�À Î ÀAÏÃ4Ò_Ü9ÝÞ ß_ß Ð�Ç Ò�Ï Å�ÀAÐ_Ð��À ÒAÀá¿9Ç�¿q�qÇ âRÐ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä�å���ÒAÀqÃ��AÇ âyÐ1æÑÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ}çKÅ Ç��Ä_Ò�ÚÑè�éëê¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�â�æõïbêÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇáæÑ�qÇ�Ù�ð_â_âAÀ�ÜqÉ)�qÇ��AÇ?ÔtÝñêÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇwç Î �ÒbÔ��qÇ�Ùõò��_ÒAÇ ÄAÇ âbÔ`èRé Ý_Ýdê ß_ß Ç)�A�Aè���äè_Å�Ç ÆAÇ_Å>¿9À â�óAÇ âß_ß Ã��ëÃ�Ò9Ã)ÀÅqÃ4ôÇàä� âõÅ�Ç�ÆAÇÅzéá÷Aè)�q���ÇÃ��Ò�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ�æ éëêÃ��Ò�Ç È���Ç�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒàæõïbêÃ��ÒÓâAÇ�¿9ÀyÃ��ëÃt�Ä�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ�æöïbêä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò.-�æ./bê0-õû æÑ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä�å���ÒAÀqÃ��qÇ�âyÐ:ê1-�ú_úRÝâAÇ4¿RÀyÃ��ëÃ��_Ä�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒàú�æÓÙqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ/Õ2-�×wêß_ß Ð�Ç_À�âRÏ4Ú�Ð4�_�9Ð)Ç ÒöÐ Î ÀqÏ)ÇàÒ_âAÇ_ÇÙ_ÚëÃ)Å�Ç�ÔKÒ_â��AÇyÝÞ ß_ß Ï4ÚqÇqÏ4óöÅ Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å��Ó��ä�÷Aè)�q���ÇÃ��ÒöÅ�Ç�ä Òå ÚëÃ�Å�� ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ�æõÇ È���Ç�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒàú�ÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ/Õ�Ç�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆÇÅ)×wêÃ�äÖÔ`Å�Ç�ä Òå ÚëÃ�Å�� ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒàû æ�Ï)À Î ÀqÏÃ�Ò_Ü9ÝÞ ß_ß äÇ_ÀAÐÃ��yÅ�ǪÅ�Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ)Å �Ã�äÖÔ`Å�Ç�ä�Ò_å ÚëÃ�Å ��ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òªþá¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�â9Ý¿9À Á�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒAí�� îAÀ â�æöÅ Ç�ä�Òå Ú9Ã�Å � ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ¢êß_ß À��_�ÑÒA��3 �qÇ��qÇà�_�qÅ�ÇqÐ_ÐàÅ�Ç�À�äÃ�äÖÔHÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Åàûà�_��¿q�qÇ�âqã ä_å�)�ÒAÀyÃ��AÇ âyÐÝÅqÃ4ÆAÇ È���ÇÉ)�AÇ��qÇ¢ç Î �_ÒwÔØ�qÇ�Ù�ò��ÒAÇ�ÄAÇ âwÔ`Å Ç�ä�Òå Ú9Ã�Å�� ìÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒRÝ_Ýëêýß_ß Ï4ÚqÇqÏ4ó�âRÃ4Ä�ÚÒöÏ4Ú9Ã�Å �Ã�äÖÔHÇ ÈA� �Ç�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒªúÓâAÇ4¿RÀyÃ��ëÃ��_Ä�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒàþ�¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�â454 Ç ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Åàûà�_��¿q�qÇ�âqã ä_å�)�ÒAÀyÃ��AÇ âyÐÝß_ß â9Ã4Ä�Ú_ÒöÏ4ÚëÃ�Å ��¿9À�ÜöÅ Ç_À��ÑÒA�ª�qÇ Ò_ÒAÇ�â�Å�Ç_À�äÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇwç Î �_ÒbÔ��qÇ�Ùõò��_ÒAÇ ÄAÇ âbÔHÇ ÈA���_Ç�ìqÇqÃ�Ä�Ú_Ò9Ý Ýñêß_ß ÄAÇ ÒÓ�qÇ Á_ÒÑ÷Aè)�q���ÇÇ ÈA� �Ç�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒªæ�Ô_Ôtò��_ÒAÇ ÄAÇ âRÝáÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇwçØâAÇ�¿R� ÆÇ?ÔFÝ_Ý.çLÃ��_Ò_ü_ÀÅ)�Ç?Ô�ÝñêÃ�äÖÔHÇ ÈA� �Ç�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒªæ�æöèRé�ÝÖ�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßuÞ ¹�?@X=TJ2Uk&GN5Ik3GhTW>J;/2&<�2LZfîzT:230&T:K3? }&}6O\~@¿�DF2&<&7:;/<4A�Ge>:Á

Page 11: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �e�Lø

Þ ß_ß Ç��A����äõÅ�Ç ÆAÇÅÃ4ä�Ô`ÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇÉ)�qÇ)�qÇ¢çHà Ð�÷�¿ Î Ò_ÜwÔFÝ_Ýß_ß �q��¿9� âAÇ�ÅqÃ4ÆǪ�A���ÇqÐâAÇ�Ò��â���¿9À�Á�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒAí_� îÀ â¢êÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇÉ)�qÇ)�qÇ¢ç Î ��ÒwÔ��AÇ�Ù�ò��ÒAÇ ÄÇ âwÔ`èRé�Ý_Ýñê ß_ß Ç��A�Aè ��äAè_Å�Ç�ÆAÇÅ>¿RÀ â_óAÇ âß�ß ÄAÇ�ÒÓ�AÇ Á_ÒÓ÷qè)�q� �ÇÇ�ÈA���Ç�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒàæ�Ô�Ôtò��ÒAÇ�ÄAÇ â9Ý�ÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇÉ)�qÇ)�qÇ¢çØâ_Ç4¿R� ÆÇ.ÔtÝ Ý.ç`Ãt�_Ò�üAÀÅ4�qÇ.Ô�ÝdêÇ�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆAÇÅ ú�úwêâÇ4¿9ÀyÃ��9Ã��Ä�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒàè æÑÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ/Õ�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇ_Å ×bêýýý

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßVÞ ¹�?HX�T:2Uk3GN5�k3GNT:>J;/2&<�23ZfîmTJ2&03TWKL? }3}�O/~H¿ÀDh23<=Dh./A=5�GN5=Á

w19�Gs?EKL¼_��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c,�_A�GNA�Gs?EKlc,]^G�T:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7:GN5�K3>BK�?EKL¼�9�GeKLXqO�w19�G�Gh.\Gh?HGh<_7:>B2LZ7:9�;\>x?EKU¼E9�GeKLXsKLT:G[23ZP7"c_X^G76Ç_À Î ÈA� �Ç��p9�GNTJGtGNK&DW9E;/<=>C7:K3<=DFGt2LZ86AÇ_À Î ÈA���Ç�9=K&>{7J9=G$�=GN.\5=>ÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���Çn¿ÀK$Xg2&;/<_7:GhTi7J2[7:9�G�<�2656G:�Y2LZ67:9�G�>J23.\A67:;/2&<B>CXgK3DFGm7JT:GhGxTJGNX�TJGe>CGN<_7JGN5�]4c�7J9=;\>y9�GeKLX<�2656GlÁ½d� Î_Î Ç â ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒS¿�A�X=XgGNT[]g2&A�<=5S23<I7J9=Gn�xGN;/0&9&7[KL7w�^Á½d�K3<=5�Å�Ç�ÆAÇÅI¿u7:9�Gj.\Ghk3GN.P2LZR�^Á½Ow19�GpDh.\K&>J>96AÇ_À Î ÈA���Ç[;\?HX�./GN?HGh<_7:>f7:9�G1;/<_7:GhTJZÀK3DFG�å�4¿ Î À âAÀ��yÅ Ç[]4cjA=>J;/<�0�;/7:>.� Î_Î Ç�â�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ�=GN.\5qOw19�G�?HGF7J9=245"À����_ÂRÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇH¿ÀîmTJ2&03TWKL? }&}6O �_ÁFd3�p9�;VDW9�;V>xKB?HGh?B]^GhT123ZP7J9�G�DF.VK3>:>�:AÀ Áqè

; âA��äyÃ4ÒÂ�_À �RÃ��ÄadfK&5�5�>IKR<�Gh� .\;/k&G�<�2656Gr7:2R7J9=G,>CA=]=>CGh7s7JT:GhG&dpA=>J;/<�0×K8<�2656Gr2LZ�7"c4X^G(5(_�q� �Çgd�KL<g5�KL.V>C2E;\<=>JGhTJ7:>$KEDh23T:TJGe>CX^23<g56;/<=0E<�2656Gj;\<&7:2E7J9=GB?EKU¼S9�GNK3XqdgAg>C;\<�0�KH<�2656GY2LZ7"c4X^G76AÇ_À Î È���ÇgOw19�G�?@Gh7J9�265�¿9À ÁÂ��À��RÃ��Ä�¿�îzT:230&T:K3? }3}�O �&Á@XgGNTCZ�2&TJ?E>IKR?EKU¼4��X=TJ23��7s]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54�]^23A�<g5×>JGNK3T:DW9×]gGN03;\<�<�;\<�0RKU7E7J9=GST:242L7E2LZt7J9�Gr>J23.\A67:;/2&<©>JX=K3DhG�7:TJGNG3O�w19�GrÙ_ÚëÃ�Å Ç�.\2423X0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGN>E7J9�G�./GhZu7�K3<=5�T:;/0&9&7SDW9�;/.V56T:Gh<�23Zn7J9�G�DFA�T:TJGN<_7S»{��<�2656G&OÔ¹�Zn7J9�G�./GhZu7�DW9=;/.V5�;V>Z�GeK3>J;/]�.\GB¿À;�O G3O\d6;�7W>m��Gh;\039_7x5�2_Ge>m<=2L7xGh¼�DFGhGe5H7J9=G�DNKLX=K&DF;/7"c6ÁFd&;/7x;V>�K35�56Ge5H7J2B7J9�G�>JA�]=>JGF7m7:TJGNGK3<=5�7:2I7:9�G@?HKL¼,9�GeKLX�K&>�K�.\Ghk&Gh.wÇ È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ úëé�<�2656G3O@w19�GHTJ;\039_7nDW9�;\.\5,2LZ�K�Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\G<�2656GS;V>B0&A=KLTWKL<_7JGNGN587:2,]^GSZ�GNK3>J;\]�./GSKL<=5×>C2�;\>HK3./�1Klc6>BK35=56GN5�7J2�7J9�G�>CGh7H>JA�]67:TJGNGSK3<=5?EKU¼×9�GNK3XqO b 2&./.\2U�p;/<=0,7:9�;\>�K35�56;/7J;\23<�dm7:9�G�<�GF¼47�»z��<�2656G�;V>EGF¼47:T:K&D½7JGe5�Z�T:23? 7J9�G�?EKU¼9�GeKLXqOt¹�Z{7J9�GY<�GF¼47n»{��<�2656Gj;V>tKs./GeKUZ"da;�7�T:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7:>p7J9�G@23X67:;/?EK3.�.\2&K35�;/<�0gOtw19�;V>t./2_K356;\<�0;V>p56GF7:GhT:?H;/<�Ge5S]_csZ�23.\./2U�p;\<�0@7J9�GnXgKU7J9IZ�T:23? 7:9�;V>p./GeKUZi7J2H7J9=GnTJ242L7eO< ¹9����R´��"¹.´z®�����=>�����y´��)³!�?�T¹:´'tGF�=<=Gr¿9À Á�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒí_� îAÀ â�7:2×]^G�7J9�G�?EKU¼6;/?YA�? ��Gh;\039_7SK&>J>J26DF;VKU7JGe5��p;/7J9¶K3<4c©23Zj7J9=GZ�GeK3>J;/]�.\G�<�2656GN>y03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5Y>C2tZÀKLTeOiw19�G1X�T:;\23T:;�7"cn�_A�GhA=G�23Zg.\;/k&Gx<=245�GN>y?EKlcjDF23<_7WKL;\<Y>JGhk3GNT:K3.<�2656Ge>B�p9=2&>JG-� Î�Î Ç â�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ�kUKL.\A�GI5624Ge>B<�237YGh¼6DhGhGe5P¿9À�Á�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒAí_� îÀ âaOIw19=GN>JG�<�2656Ge>DNKL<�<�237xX^2&>:>C;\]�.\cH./GeK35E7:2j7:9�Gt]^GN>C7p./GeKUZ"O{w19�GN;/T�X�T:GN>JGh<=DhG$;\<s7J9=GtX�T:;\23T:;�7"cE�_A�GhA=Gt;V>z7WKL`4;\<�0kUKL.\A=K3]�./Gr�_A�GNA�G,>JX=K3DhGrKL<=5�K3.\>J2�DF2&<&7:TJ;\]�A67:;/<=087J287J9=Gr7J;\?HGr<�GNGN56Ge5©7J2R;\<=>CGNTC7F�U56GN./Gh7JG&OQ�Gr>C9=23A�.V5�Gh.\;/?H;\<=KU7:G�7J9�GN?�O ì <�G�GN./;\?H;/<gKU7J;\23< >C7JTWKU7:Gh0&c�;\>E7J287JGe>"7 � Î_Î Ç â�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒ@�

Page 12: Branch and Bound

�N�l� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

Î ���yÅqÃ�ÏÑÐ�ÒÀ Ò9Ã�ÏÓÃ��_Òà¿RÀ ÁÂ�_À �RÃ��ÄwÔ�Ã��ÒùÕØ×ÓÙAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒwÛ>Ã��ÒzÏ�À Î ÀAÏÃ4Ò_Ü¢ÛÃt�Ò ÕØ×�Ò ÚqÇ?(qÇqÐ4ÒÂ�_À��yÃ��Ä9ÝÞ ß_ß Ð�Ç Ò�Ï Å�ÀAÐ_Ð��À ÒAÀá¿9Ç�¿q�qÇ âRÐ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä�å���ÒAÀqÃ��AÇ âyÐ1æÑÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ}çKÅ Ç��Ä_Ò�ÚÑè�éëê¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�â�æõïbêÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇáæÑ�qÇ�Ù�ð_â_âAÀ�ÜqÉ)�qÇ��AÇ?ÔtÝñêÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇwç Î �ÒbÔ��_�AÅ_ÅqÝdêß_ß Ç)�A�Aè���äè_Å�Ç ÆAÇ_Å>¿9À â�óAÇ âÉ�ÈA� �ÇÑÇ ÈA���_ÇÓæÑ�_�yÅ�Å?ê�qÇqÐ4Ò_÷_ÈA���_Ç_í_� îAÀ�â�æÓ�_�yÅ_Å.ê�qÇqÐ4ÒÂ�_À��yÃ��ĪæÓÒ�ÚqÇ�(qÇqÐ�ÒÂ_�_À��RÃ��_Ä¢êß_ß Ã��ëÃ�Ò9Ã)ÀÅqÃ4ôÇàä� âõÅ�Ç�ÆAÇÅzéá÷Aè)�q���ÇÃ��Ò�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ�æ éëêÃ��Ò�Ç È���Ç�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒàæõïbêÃ��ÒÓâAÇ�¿9ÀyÃ��ëÃt�Ä�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ�æöïbêä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò.-�æ./bê0-õû æÑ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä�å���ÒAÀqÃ��qÇ�âyÐ:ê1-�ú_úRÝâAÇ4¿RÀyÃ��ëÃ��_Ä�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒàú�æÓÙqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ/Õ2-�×wêß_ß Ð�Ç_À�âRÏ4Ú�Ð4�_�9Ð)Ç ÒöÐ Î ÀqÏ)ÇàÒ_âAÇ_ÇÙ_ÚëÃ)Å�Ç�ÔKÒ_â��AÇyÝÞ ß_ß Ï4ÚqÇqÏ4óöÅ Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å��Ó��ä�÷Aè)�q���ÇÃ��ÒöÅ�Ç�ä Òå ÚëÃ�Å�� ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ�æõÇ È���Ç�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒàú�ÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ/Õ�Ç�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆÇÅ)×wêÃ�äÖÔ`Å�Ç�ä Òå ÚëÃ�Å�� ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒàû æ�Ï)À Î ÀqÏÃ�Ò_Ü9ÝÞ ß_ß äÇ_ÀAÐÃ��yÅ�ǪÅ�Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ)Å �Ã�äÖÔ`Å�Ç�ä�Ò_å ÚëÃ�Å ��ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òªþá¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�â9Ý¿9À Á�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒAí�� îAÀ â�æöÅ Ç�ä�Òå Ú9Ã�Å � ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ¢êÀ��_�_ÂyÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �Ç?Ô`Å�Ç ä�Òå�Ú9Ã)Å �)ìqÇyÃ�Ä Ú_Ò¢Û-Ç ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇÅ?Û�Ç�ÈA���ÇbÛ�Ò�â��qÇyÝñêýß_ß Ï4ÚqÇqÏ4ó�âRÃ4Ä�ÚÒöÏ4Ú9Ã�Å �Ã�äÖÔHÇ ÈA� �Ç�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒªúÓâAÇ4¿RÀyÃ��ëÃ��_Ä�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒàþ�¿9À Á ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒAí_� îAÀ�â9ÝÀ��_�_ÂyÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �Ç?ÔHÇ È���Ç)ìAÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ¢Û-Ç ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å?Û�Ç È���ÇbÛ"äÀ_ÅAÐ�ÇyÝñê

Ç ÈA� �ÇÑæ�Ô`É)ÈA���ÇyÝ�ÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇÉ)�qÇ)�qÇ¢çØâAÇt¿9��ÆÇ?Ô�ÝñêÃ�äÖÔHÇ ÈA� �Ǫæ_æÑ�_�yÅ_ÅqÝÞ ß_ß Ç��A����äõÅ�Ç ÆÇÅÃ�äÖÔ`ÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇÉ��qÇ��qÇ¢çHà Ð�÷4¿ Î Ò�ÜbÔ�Ý_Ý��âAÇ�À ó¢ê ß_ß �q�á¿9� âÇ�ÅAÃ4ÆAÇà�q���ÇAÐÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇÉ��qÇ��qÇ¢ç Î �ÒbÔ����yÅ ÅqÝñêß_ß Ç��A�è���äAè_Å Ç ÆAÇÅ Î �yÃ��_ÒAÇ â

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßne %�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5�DF2656GB7J9=KL7�K3.\>J2IDh23?HX�A67:GN>t7J9�G@]^GN>C7n>JA�]=>JGF7H¿ÀDh23<6�7J;\<4A�GN>WÁ

Page 13: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �e�Nü

Ç�ÈA���Ǫæ�Ô`É�ÈA���_ÇyÝ�ÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç_É)�qÇ��qÇwçØâAÇ4¿y� ÆÇ?Ô�ÝdêÇ�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆAÇÅ ú�úwêâÇ4¿9ÀyÃ��9Ã��Ä�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒàè æÑÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ/Õ�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇ_Å ×bêýÇ ÈA���Ç)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òªæ�Ç ÈA���Çwç ÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ¢êýß_ß Ï����9Ð�Ò�â��9Ï�Òà�AÇqÐ�ÒÂ��À��RÃ��Ä}ÕØ×á�_Üõä�_Å_Å���ÙëÃt�Ä Î À Ò Úõä âA�4¿ß_ß �qÇqÐ�Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç_í�� îAÀ â�ÒA�ÑâA�_� Ò¢Û �AÇqÐ�ÒÂ��À��RÃ��Ä}ÕT�_��¿q�AÇ�âqã)ä_å_���_ÒÀyÃ��qÇ âyÐ�×ß_ß Ã�Ð�Ð)Ç ÒÑ�ÜöÀ �_�_ÂRÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Çä� â�ÔtÃ��Ò.-ÓæÓ����¿q�qÇ âAã ä_å���_ÒAÀyÃ��qÇ)âRÐ=è·é9êA-�þ�ï?êA-è�èqÝÞ �qÇqÐ�ÒÂ_�_À��RÃ��_Ä/ÕB-�×�æ�Ô��qÇqÐ�Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç_í�� îAÀ â}ç�Å�Ç�ä�Òå�ÚëÃ)Å��RÝDC�éFErïbê�qÇqÐ�Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç_í�� îAÀ â�æÓ�AÇqÐ�Ò_÷_È���Ç_í_��îAÀ â}ç Î À âAÇ��ÒwêýâAÇ Ò��_â���¿9À Á�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒí_� îAÀ âwêýßG5G À��_��À�ÅqÃ4ÆAÇà�q� �ÇÓÀ ÒzÅ Ç ÆAÇÅàÒ�ÚqÇ ÂÇ ÆAÇÅ�À��A�ªÚqÀ Æ9Ãt�ĪÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒÑÒ�ÚqÇ�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒG ÒA��ÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇÉ��qÇ��qÇÑÃ�äÑ�q� Ò�ÀõÅ Ç_À�äG Ã�ä�äÇ_ÀqÐ_Ã��yÅ�ÇÑÅ Ç_À�äwÛPÐ�Ç�Ò��qÇAÐ�ÒÂ�_À �RÃ��Ä/Õc�_��¿q�Ç âAã ä�å_����ÒAÀqÃ��AÇ�âRÐ4×�æøéG Ã�ä_ä�Å�Ç ä�Òå ÚëÃ)Å �õÃ�Ð�Ò_â��qÇGIH Î À�âAÀ4¿õÒ�ÚqÇ ; À âAÇ��_Ò Î À âAÇ)�Ò���äÑ�qÇ�ÙÓ�q���ÇGIH Î À�âAÀ4¿�Å�Ç�ä Òå ÚëÃ�Å��àÒ_â��qÇöÃ�ä�äÑ�AÇ�Ù��A���ÇõÃ�ÐÑÅ�Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4Ú9Ã�Å ����äÑÒ�ÚqÇ ; À âAÇ��Ò G

ßÎ â9Ã4ÆÀ ÒAÇ�Ð�ÒÀ Ò9Ã�ÏáÆA�qÃ���À��_�_ÂRÃ�ÆAÇ ÈA���_Ç?ÔtÃ��Ò�Ò�ÚqÇ)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Ò¢Û�Ã��_Ò�Ò ÚqÇ�ÂÇ ÆÇÅ?ÛÉ�ÈA� �ǪÒ�ÚqÇ ; À�âAÇ��Ò¢Û��q�_�Å Ç_À��õÅ�Ç�ä Òå ÚëÃ�Å��RÝÞ Ã�äÖÔKÒ�ÚqÇ�Â_Ç ÆAÇÅ�æ�æÓ�_�)¿q�qÇ âqã�ä_å���ÒÀyÃ��qÇ)âRÐ_ÝÞ ß_ß äÇ_ÀqÐ_Ã��yÅ�ÇÑÅ Ç_À�äÃ�ä�ÔpÒ�ÚqÇ�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒàæ_æà¿RÀ Á�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒAí_��îAÀ â9ÝÞ ß_ß �qÇqÐ�ÒõÅ�Ç�À�äöÐ���ä_À â�qÇAÐ�Ò_÷_ÈA� �Ç_í_� îÀ âàæÓÒ�ÚqÇ ; À âAÇ��_Ò¢ê�qÇAÐ�ÒÂ�_À �RÃ��Ä/Õc�_��¿q�qÇ)âqã�ä�å�)�Ò_ÀyÃ��Ç âyÐ)×áæÖÔ`Å�Ç�ä Òå ÚëÃ�Å��RÝJC�éKErïbêýâAÇ Ò��â �(êý ß_ß �q� Ò�ÀöÅ�Ç�À�äwÛrÀ��_�ÑÒA��3 �qÇ)�qÇÉ�ÈA���_Ǫ�õæÑ�qÇ�ÙzÉ�ÈA���Ç.ÔKÒ�ÚqÇ ; À âAÇ��ÒbÛ�Å Ç�ä�Òå Ú9Ã�Å �wÛ-Ò�ÚqÇ�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ9ÝdêÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���ÇÉ��qÇ��qÇ¢ç Î �ÒbÔ��9ÝñêýÖ�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^Þqßfe %�TWKL<=DW9���K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�DF2656GY7J9gKU7nKL.V>C2SDF23?HX�A�7JGN>t7:9�GY]^GN>C7n>CA�]g>CGh7H¿�DF23<��Dh./A=5�GN5=Á

Page 14: Branch and Bound

�N�t6 �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

ßG*G À �_�õÀª�qÇ�ÙöÅqÃ�ÆAÇà�q���ǪÒA�ÑÒ�ÚqÇ�ÅqÃ4ÆǪ�A���Çá¿9À ÁÑÚqÇ_À ÎG À_ÅAÐ��ÓÀ��_�ÓÒ�ÚqÇ�ÅqÃ4ÆǪ�A���ǪÒA�ªÒ�ÚqÇöÐ��Å)�_Ò9Ã)���öÐ Î ÀqÏ�ǪÒ_âAÇ�ÇGLH Î À âAÀ4¿õÒ ÚqÇ ; À âÇ��ÒöÃ�Ð�Ò�ÚqÇ Î À�âAÇ��Ò���äÓÒ�ÚqǪ�qÇ�ÙöÅqÃ�ÆAÇà�q���ÇGLH Î À âAÀ4¿�Å Ç�ä�Òå Ú9Ã�Å �õÃ�Ð�Ò_â��AÇzÃ4ä_äÑÒ�ÚqǪ�qÇ�ÙöÅqÃ4ÆAÇà�q� �ÇöÃ�ÐG Ò ÚqÇõÅ Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å��Ó��ä�Ò ÚqÇ ; À âÇ��Ò G

ßÎ âRÃ4ÆAÀ ÒAÇ�Ð4ÒAÀ Ò9Ã�ÏáÆ�yÃ���À��_�_ÂyÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �Ç?ÔtÃ��_Òá� Î_Î Ç â�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒwÛ�Ã��ÒõÅ�Ç�ÆAÇÅ?Û(5(��q���ÇàÒ�ÚAÇ ; À âAÇ)�Ò¢Û-�A�_�Å�Ç_À)�õÅ�Ç�ä�Òå�ÚëÃ�Å �RÝÞ ß_ß Ï�âAÇ�À ÒAǪÒ�ÚqÇà�qÇ�ÙÓ�q� �ÇÓ��ä�Ò ÚqÇõÐ��Å)�ÒRÃ)���zÐ Î ÀAÏ�ÇàÒ_âAÇ_Ç(5(_�A���Ç��õæÓ�qÇ)Ù(*(_�q���Ç.ÔKÒ�ÚqÇ ; À âAÇ��ÒwÛ Å Ç�ä�Òå Ú9Ã�Å �RÝñêß_ß Ï�âAÇ�À ÒAÇõÏ�� â_âÇqÐ Î ����RÃ��Äá�q���ÇÑä��âà¿RÀ ÁÑÚqÇ_À Î6AÇ_À Î ÈA���ÇáÚÈA���ǪæÓ�qÇ�Ù6AÇ_À Î ÈA���Ç.Ôp�(Û-� Î_Î Ç â�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒwÛ"Å�Ç ÆÇÅqÝñêß_ß

Î �Ò·Ã��Ò��¿RÀ ÁÑÚqÇ_À ÎÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç?:AÀ Á56AÇ�À Î ç Î �_ÒwÔØÚÈA� �_ÇqÝñêýÖ�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßNM 0rKU¼�îzT:2L�=7L%/%1oq2&K&56;\<�0=O K35�5=oq;\k3G ò 2656G

¿9À�Á�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒAí_� îÀ âS]gGhZ�23T:Gs;\<=>CGNTC7:;/<=0,K�<�2656GI;/<_7J2r7J9�GIX�TJ;\23T:;/7"c��_A�GNA�G3O,�$2U�xGNk3GNTNdy>C;\<=DFG¿9À�Á�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒAí_� îÀ â�;\<=DFT:GNK&>CGe>xK&>z7:9�GnKL.\0323T:;/7J9�? X�T:2303T:GN>:>JGN>Nd3<�2656Ge>m7:9=KU71X=K&>J>m7J9�;V>�7JGe>"7pKU77J9�G17:;/?HGp23Z^;\<=>JGhTJ7J;\23<@?HKlcjZÀKL;\.�;�7x.\KL7JGhT{2&<qOf-�?@2&TJGpK30303T:GN>:>J;/k&Gx>C7JTWKU7JGN03cn;V>f7J2jK3.\>J2�KLX�X�.\c7J9�Gt7JGe>"71�p9�GN<�Ghk&GhTb¿RÀ Á�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒAí_��îAÀ â�;/<gDFT:GNK3>JGN>xKL<=5I56Gh.\GF7:G$Z�T:23? 7:9�GtX=TJ;\23T:;�7"cE�_A�GNA�GtK3./.<�2656GN>j�p;�7:9>� Î_Î Ç â ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒDOõ¿9À Á�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒAí�� îAÀ âaOBw19�;V>j>"7:T:KL7JGN03c�T:GN�_A�;\TJGe>�A=>�7J2r5�Gh.\GF7JG<�2656GN>t�p;/7J9,.\GNK&>"78� Î�Î Ç â�ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒaO1�$Gh<=DhGB��GB<�GNGN5�KsX�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c��&A=GhA�GB7J9=KL7�>JA�X�X^23TJ7:>$7J9�G23X^GhTWKU7:;/2&<=>j;\<=>JGhTJ7Ndm56GN./Gh7JGS?EKU¼PdmKL<g5M56GN./Gh7JGS?@;\<qO � AgDW9×K�X�TJ;\23T:;/7"c��_A�GNA�GI;V>HDhK3./.\GN5�K´i·^¸iµyÝ Ñ � Ñ ±i´ Ñ ´ X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c��_A�GNA�G3O1'tKL7:K�>"7:TJA=DF7JA�T:GN>jZ�23TH5623A=]�./Gh��GN<=56Ge5RX�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c��_A�GNA�GN>KLX�X^GNK3Tp23<I7J9�GnQ�Gh]�>J;�7:G3O

�w�/�c���c� PRQ}�TS ¡&¤9U7V�¤#W�X �>¨A �Y7Z�¦'[

\]_^ - ?EKU¼4��X�TJ23��7j]�TWKL<=DW9���K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�KL.\0323T:;/7J9�?ÙZ�23Tn7:9�G�ð��6~E`4<=KLX=>:K3DW`,X�TJ2&]�.\Gh?Ù?EKlc�]gG

56Ghk&Gh.\23X^GN5�]_c�A=>C;\<�0@7J9=G�?HGh7J9�265 Î â��äRÃ4Ò*(A���_�A�n2LZfîzT:230&T:K3? }�~3O un7:2HDh23?HX�A67:G�Z�23TpGNK&DW9./;\k3GH<�2656G1` KL<�A�X�X^GhTjX=TJ23��7�¿9À Á ; �AÐ_ÐÃ��yÅ Ç ; âA��äyÃ4ÒRò��Aí)�_��Ò_âÇ_ÇH>CA=DW9�7J9gKU7n<�2�<�2656GE;\<7J9�G[>JA�]67:TJGNG1�p;�7:9@T:242L7�` 9=K3>fX�T:2L�=7fkUK3./A�G1?H23T:G�7J9=K3<5¿RÀ Á ; �qÐ�ÐÃ��yÅ�Ç ; âA��äqÃ4Ò9òt�Aí)�_��Ò_âAÇ�Ç=Ow19�G,?EKU¼4��X�T:2L��7�]=T:K3<=DW96��KL<=54��]^23A�<=5�Dh245�G,;V>�>J;/?H;\.\K3Ts7J2©îzT:230&T:K3? }3}�O ��O�Q�G�A=>CG

K,?EKL¼M9�GNK3X�Z�2&TH7J9�G�.\;/k&GS<=245�GN>HKL<=5©DF2&<=>C7JT:A=D½7HXg2&TC7:;/2&<=>H2LZ$7J9�Gr>J23.\A67J;\23<©>CXgK3DFGI7JT:GhGK3>�<�GNGN56Ge5POEw19�GEGh.\Gh?HGN<&7W>�;/<�7:9�GE?EKU¼,9�GeKLX8KLT:GH2LZm7"c4X^G16AÇ�À Î ÈA���_Ç��p9�GNTJGa6AÇ_À Î ÈA���Ç9=K3>[7J9�GY5�KU7WKE?HGh?B]^GhTW>�� Î_Î Ç â ; âA��äRÃ�Ò�¿�A=X�XgGNTt]^23A=<=5�23<�X�T:2L�=7tKU7tK3<4cI.\GNKLZf;\<r>JA�]67JT:GhG�p;�7:9�7J9=;\>$TJ242L7½Á½d Î âA��äRÃ4Ò,¿�X�T:2L�=7$2LZ{X=K3TC7:;\K3.�>C2&./A�7J;\23<rKU7$7J9�;V>$<=245�GeÁ½dyÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒr¿���Gh;\039_7$23Z

Page 15: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �e��s

Î �_�yÅAÃ�ÏÑÐ�ÒAÀ ÒRÃ�ÏÓÃ��Ò�¿9À Á_Â�_À��RÃt�ÄwÔtÃ��_ÒÖÕØ×ÑÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ¢ÛPÃt�Ò·Ï)À Î ÀqÏÃ�Ò_Ü¢ÛÃ��Ò ÕØ×Ñ�qÇqÐ4ÒÂ�_À��yÃ��Ä9ÝÞ ß_ß Ð�Ç ÒzÏ Å�ÀqÐ�Ðà�_À ÒAÀá¿9Ç4¿q�AÇ âÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���Çb:À Á56AÇ_À Î æÑ�qÇ�Ù:AÀ Á*6AÇ_À Î Ô�Ýñêß_ß Ã��ëÃ4Ò9Ã�ÀÅqÃ�ôÇ�ä� âõÅ�Ç ÆAÇ_Åöé�÷qè)�A���ÇÃ��ÒÓ�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä_å_���ÒAÀyÃt�AÇ âRÐ>æÑÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ}çKÅ�Ç)�Ä_Ò�ÚÑè·é9ê(5(_�q� �ÇÑÇ ÈA���_ÇÓæÑ�_�yÅ�Å?êÃ��ÒõÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å�æøéëêÃ��ÒõÇ ÈA���_Ç�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒªæ�ïbêß_ß âAÇ4¿9ÀyÃt�ëÃ��Ä�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒ}Õ2-�×=ÙëÃ�Å�Åà�AÇzÐ4�)¿·� äÓÙqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒ/Õ2-�úëé'E �×ß_ß �Ç�äÀ��qÅ�ÒzÃ��ëÃ4ÒRÃ)ÀÅ�ÆAÀ_Å)�qÇöÃ�ЪïÃ��Ò ÕØ×ÑâAÇ4¿9ÀqÃ��ëÃ��Ä ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒàæÑ�qÇ�Ù·Ã��Ò ÕT�_�)¿q�qÇ âqã�ä_å���ÒÀyÃt�qÇ�âyÐ>úÿé�×bêä� â�ÔtÃ��Ò.-ÓæÓ����¿q�qÇ âAã ä_å���_ÒAÀyÃ��qÇ)âRÐ=è·é9êA-�þ�ï?êA-è�èqÝâAÇ4¿9ÀyÃt�ëÃ��Ä�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒ}Õ2-�×áæÓâAÇ4¿9ÀyÃt�ëÃ��Ä�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒ}ÕB-xú é�×�úÑÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Ò/ÕB-àú é�×wêß_ß Ð�Ç_À âRÏ�ÚzÐ4�_�9Ð�Ç�ÒöÐ Î ÀqÏ�ǪÒ_âÇ_ÇÙ_ÚëÃ�Å ÇùÔLÇ ÈA���Ç ÂÇ ÆAÇÅFcØæÑ�_��¿q�qÇ�âqã ä_å�)�ÒAÀyÃ��Ç âRÐ>úøé ÝÞ ß_ß �q� Ò�À ÒõÀõÅ Ç_À�äß_ß Ï�ÚqÇqÏ�óöÏ4Ú9Ã�Å ��âAÇ)����äÑ÷qè)�q���_ÇÃ�ä�ÔLÇ ÈA���Ç)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒàúÓÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Ò/Õ�Ç ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ Æ_ÇÅ ×�û æzÏ�À Î ÀAÏÃ4Ò_Ü9Ýß�ß äÇ�ÀqÐÃ��yÅ ÇÑÅ�Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4Ú9Ã�Å �À �_�_ÂRÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç.ÔHÇ ÈA����Ç�ìAÇqÃ4Ä ÚÒ�úÑÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ/Õ�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇ_Å ×áúâAÇ4¿9ÀqÃ��ëÃ��Ä ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Ò/ÕØÇ È_���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇ_Å�×wÛ-Ç ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇÅ�ú éëÛÇ ÈA���_ÇbÛ�Ò_â��qÇqÝñêß_ß âRÃ4Ä�ÚÒöÏ4Ú9Ã�Å �zÃ�ЪÀÅ)ÙqÀ ÜyÐ�äÇ_ÀqÐÃt�yÅ�ÇÀ��_�_ÂRÃ�ÆAÇ ÈA���_Ç?ÔHÇ ÈA� �_Ç�ìqÇAÃ4Ä Ú_Ò�úÓâAÇ4¿RÀyÃ��ëÃ��_Ä�ìqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ/Õ�Ç)ÈA� �Ç Â_Ç Æ_ÇÅ ×bÛÇ ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇÅ�úøéëÛPÇ�ÈA���ÇbÛ"ä_ÀÅAÐ�ÇyÝdêß_ß ÄÇ ÒÑ�qÇ Á_ÒÓ÷qè)�A���ÇbÛ ÚqÇ�À Î Ï�À��_�q��Òª�qÇ�Ç�¿ Î Ò_Ü6AÇ_À Î È���Ç��qÇ�Á_Ò_÷_ÈA� �ÇàæÖÔd6AÇ_À Î ÈA���ÇyÝáÅqÃ4ÆAÇ È���Çb:AÀ�Á56AÇ_À Î ç âAÇt¿9� ÆÇ?:À ÁwÔFÝñêÇ ÈA���Ç ÂÇ ÆAÇÅ�æÓ�qÇ�Á_Ò_÷_ÈA� �Ç¢çKÅ�Ç�ÆAÇÅ?êÇ ÈA���ÇÑæÑ�qÇ Á_Ò�÷_ÈA���ÇwçKÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA� �Ç.êÇ ÈA���Ç)ìqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_ÒªæÑ�qÇ Á_Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç¢çT� Î_Î Ç â ìqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒèÑâAÇ�¿9ÀyÃ��ëÃt�Ä�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ/Õ�Ç)ÈA����Ç�Â_Ç ÆÇ_Åáè·ét×wêýÖ�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßfe 0rKL¼_��X�T:2L��7p]�TWKL<gDW9IKL<g5I]^23A=<=5IZ�23Tp.\2&K35�;/<�0@X�T:23]�.\Gh?º¿ÀDF2&<_7J;\<_A=GN>WÁ

Page 16: Branch and Bound

�N��� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

ß_ß Ï����RÐ�Ò_â��9Ï4Òà�qÇqÐ�Ò_Â�_À��RÃt�Ä/ÕØ×x�Ü�ä�Å_Å��)ÙëÃ��Ä Î À Ò�Úß_ß ä�âA��¿·Ç�ÈA���ǪÒA�ÑÒ�ÚqǪâA�_��Òä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò.-�æÑ�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä_å_���ÒAÀyÃt�qÇ âyÐñêg-�þÓïbêA-_è_èqÝÞ �qÇqÐ4ÒÂ�_À��yÃ��Ä/ÕB- ×�æÖÔHÇ ÈA� �Ç¢çKÅ�Ç ä�Òå ÚëÃ)Å �RÝDC·éhErïbêÇ ÈA� �ÇÑæõÇ È���Ç¢ç Î À âAÇ��ÒwêýâAÇ Ò �â���Ç ÈA� �Ç�ìqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒ¢êý

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßie 0rKU¼4��X�TJ23��7p]�TWKL<=DW9SKL<=5S]^23A�<=5IZ�2&Tp./2_K356;\<�0HX�T:23]�.\Gh?Ù¿�DF2&<=DF.\A=56Ge5=Á

X=KLTJ7J;VKL.q>J23.\A67:;/2&<SKL7p7J9�;V>[<�2656GlÁ½dRÅ�Ç ÆAÇÅS¿�.\Ghk3GN.q2LZy7J9=;\>p<=245�Gn;/<S7J9=Gj>C2&./A67:;/2&<�>CX=K&DFG�7JT:GhGlÁ½dKL<=5�ÅqÃ4ÆAÇ È���Ç8¿�X^23;\<_7JGNTj7J2rDh23T:TJGe>CX^23<g56;/<=0�<�2656Gs;\<�>C2&./A67:;/2&<R>CX=K&DFGE7:TJGNGeÁFO ò 2656GN>YKLT:GGF¼47JTWK3DF7JGe5RZ�T:23? 7J9=GS?EKL¼M9�GNK3XMA=>J;\<�0,7:9�Gh;\T�� Î_Î Ç â ; âA� äRÃ4ÒrkUKL.\A�G&O×w19�G�<�2656Ge>H;/<×7J9�G>C2&./A�7J;\23<s>JX=K3DhG[7JT:GhGtKLT:G[2LZP7"c4X^Gj(5(_�q� �Ç��p9=GhT:Gk(5(È���Ç�9=K&>z7:9�Gt5=KU7:KB?HGh?B]^GhTW> Î À âAÇ��_Ò¿�X^23;\<_7JGhTt7J2�X=KLT:Gh<_7t;\<�7:9�Gj7:TJGNGeÁ[K3<=5>Å�Ç�ä�Ò_å ÚëÃ�Å ��¿u7JT:A�GY;��8<�2656GB;V>$7J9�GY./GhZu7�DW9�;\.V5�2LZz;/7:>X=KLT:Gh<_7½Á½Ow19�GBDF2656Gn23ZfîmTJ2&03TWKL? }3}�O vHK&>J>JA�?HGN>�7:9=KU7[7:9�Gn`4<=KLXg>JK&DW`s23]7"GeD½7W>19=Klk3G�]^GhGh<r>J23TJ7JGe5

;/<_7:2ïK3>:DFGN<=56;\<�0 23TW56GNT,2LZ�5�Gh<=>J;�7"c&dBA=>J;\<�0�7J9=G×>:KL?HGR7JGeDW9�<�;V�_A�G×K&>r��GMA=>JGN5�;\<ÂîmTJ23�03TWKL?º}�~3O � O�w19=GE?@Gh7J9�265áÀ��_�_ÂyÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �ÇIK35�5=>jK�<�Gh� .\;/k&GE<�2656GE7J2�]^2L7:987J9�Gs>J23.\A67:;/2&<>CXgK3DFG[7JT:GhG3d_A=>J;/<=0YKj<=245�G$2LZP7"c4X^Gk(5(_�q� �Çgd3K3<=5H7J2B7J9�Gt?EKU¼E9�GNK3Xqd_A=>C;\<�0@Kj<�2656Gt2LZP7"c4XgG6AÇ�À Î ÈA���_ÇgO�w19�;\>$?HGF7J9=245r;\>tk3GNTJcS>C;\?H;/.VKLT$7J2E7:9�GYDh23T:TJGe>CX^23<=5�;/<�0@Z�A�<gD½7J;\23<,A=>CGe5�Z�23T$7J9�G./2_K356;\<�0@X�T:23]�.\Gh? ¿ÀîzT:230&T:K3? }3}6O �_ÁFO{w19�GhT:GFZ�2&TJG&d&7:9�GjDF2656G�;V>p23?H;/7C7:GN5POw19�G$?HGF7:9�2653¿9À Á ; âA��äRÃ4Òb(5(ml��qÀ Î Ð)ÀqÏ�ó�XgGNTCZ�2&TJ?E>z7J9�G�?EKU¼4��X=TJ23��7z]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5>CGeKLTWDW9r23<,7J9�GE>JA�]=>JGF7�7JT:GhG&OBw19�G2Ù_ÚëÃ)Å�ÇI.\2_2&X,;V>�;�7:GhTWKU7JGe5,A=<&7:;/.zKI.\GNKUZx]gGeDF23?HGe>�7J9�GE»{�

<�2656G3O � ;/<=DhGY<=2�<�2656G@TJGN?EKL;\<�;/<=0�;\<r7J9=GY?EKU¼r9=GNKLX,9=K3>�KL<,A�X�X^GhT�X�T:2L��7�7J9=KL7�;V>�?H23T:G7J9=K3<87J9�G�X�TJ23��7BKU7B7J9�;V>j.\GNKLZ"di7:9�;V>j.\GNKUZp56Gh�=<�GN>YKL<R2&X67J;\?EKL.zX=K&DW`4;/<�0gOSw19=;\>nXgK3DW`4;/<=0�;\>56GF7:GhT:?H;/<�Ge5S]_csZ�23.\./2U�p;\<�0@7J9�GnXgKU7J9IZ�T:23? 7:9�Gn./GeKUZy7J2@7J9=GnTJ242L7eOw19�GY>C7JT:A=D½7:A�T:GB2LZ{7:9�G5Ù_ÚëÃ�Å�ÇE.\2_2&X�2LZ:¿9À Á ; âA��äRÃ4Ò*l��qÀ Î Ð)ÀqÏ�óB;V>tk3GhT:c�>C;\?H;/.VKLT$7J2s7:9=KU72LZ�7J9�G�Ù_ÚëÃ�Å�ÇS./2423X�2LZpîzT:230&T:K3?Ï}3}6O �=O b ;\T:>C7j�xGsDW9=GNDW`�7:9�GHZ�GNK&>C;\]�.\;�7"cr23Zx7:9�GE.\GFZu7YDW9�;\.V5

2LZz7:9�GE»{��<�2656G3OB¹�Zm7J9=;\>�DW9�;\.\5�;V>$Z�GeK3>J;/]=./G&dP;�7n;V>�K&5�56Ge5r7:2�7:9�GE>CA�]g>CGh7t7:TJGNG@K&>t��Gh.\.{K3>t7J27J9�Gn.\;\k3Gn<�2656Gn.\;\>C7Y¿À;�O G3O\d67J9=Gj?EKU¼�9�GeKLXgÁFOxw19�GnT:;\039_7[DW9�;/.V5S;\>$K35�56Ge5S23<�.\c�;/Z{;�7W>¢¿9À�Á ; �qÐ èÐÃt�yÅ�Ç ; â��äRÃ4Ò9òt�qí��_��Ò_âÇ_Ç�klK3./A=Gn;/<=5�;\DNKU7JGe>�7J9=KL7[;�7[?H;\039_7[.\GNK35IA=>�7:2H7J9�Gn]^GN>C7[X=K3DW`4;\<�0=O�w�/�c���on p ¤�qº�DZK¥srRt§¦

uv_w w19�Gt>J23.\A67:;/2&<�>CXgK3DFG[7JT:GhG[Z�2&Tm7:9�GtDh./;V�_A�G$X=TJ2&]�./GN?ó¿ � GeD½7J;\23<S}6~3Oí}6O ë&Á{;\>�KL.V>C2YKB>JA�]=>JGF7m7:TJGNG3O

oqGh7�Ag>tAg>CGY7J9�GE>:KL?HG@?HKL¼4��X�T:2L�=7�]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�;\?HX�.\Gh?HGh<_7:KL7J;\23<�>"7:T:KL7JGh0&c�K3>��xGA=>JGN5�Z�23Tq7J9�Gz.\2&K&56;\<�0[KL<=5�`4<=K3X=>JK&DW`[X�T:23]�.\Gh?E>NO�w19�Gz<=245�GN>P;\<�7J9�GxXg2&TC7:;/2&<�2LZ_7J9�Gm>J23.\A67:;/2&<>CXgK3DFGB7JT:GhGHDF2&<=>"7:TJAgD½7JGe5,K3TJGY2LZz7"c4X^Gx(5(_�q� �Çgd^�p9�;/.\GY7J9�GH?EKU¼4��X�TJ;\23T:;/7"cS�_A�GNA�GYGN./GN?HGh<_7:>

Page 17: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �e�e�

Î â9Ã4ÆÀ ÒAÇ�Ð�ÒÀ Ò9Ã�Ï���)�_�yÅ�Çx¿9À�Á ; âA��äyÃ4Ò*(5(ml �qÀ Î Ð�ÀÏ�ówÔFÝÞ ß_ß Ã��ëÃ4Ò9Ã�ÀÅqÃ�ôÇ�ä� âõÅ�Ç ÆAÇ_ÅöéÓÐ�ÒAÀ�â_Ò(5(_�q� �ÇÑÇ ÈA���_ÇÓæÑ�_�yÅ�Å?êÃ��ÒõÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å�æøéëê����_�qÅ�Çx¿9À Á ; âA��äRÃ4Òí_� îAÀ â�æ�ï¢çpïbê����_�qÅ�Çx¿9À Á ; �qÐ_ÐÃ��qÅ�Ç ; âA� äRÃ4ÒRòt�qí)�_��Ò_âAÇ Çáæ Î âA� äRÃ4Ò*(q�)�_�A�bÔ4é�Ýñêß_ß Ð�Ç_À âRÏ�ÚzÐ4�_�9Ð�Ç�ÒöÐ Î ÀqÏ�ǪÒ_âÇ_ÇÙ_ÚëÃ�Å ÇùÔLÇ ÈA���Ç ÂÇ ÆAÇÅFcØæÑ�_��¿q�qÇ�âqã äAã)��-_ÇqÏ�ÒRÐ>úøé ÝÞ ß_ß �q� Ò�À ÒöÅ�Ç_À�äß_ß Ï�ÚqÇqÏ�ó�Å�Ç ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å �����_�yÅ Ç�ÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òqã ä_ÂÇ ä�Òå ÚëÃ)Å �áæÓÙqÇqÃ4Ä�ÚÒqã�ä_å �â_âÇ��Ò ; ÀqÏ4ó9Ãt�_ÄúÑÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ/Õ�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇ_Å ×bêÃ�ä�Ô�ÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òqã ä_ÂÇ ä�Òå ÚëÃ�Å ��û æzÏ�À Î ÀqÏ_Ã4Ò_Ü9ÝÞ ß_ß äÇ_ÀqÐ_Ã��yÅ�ÇÓÅ�Ç ä�ÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å �Ã4ä�Ô Î âA��äRÃ4Ò�î_âA�4¿Rå��â_âÇ)�Ò ; ÀÏ�ó9Ã��Ä�ú Î â��äRÃ4Ò/ÕØÇ ÈA���Ç ÂÇ ÆAÇ�Å ×þ�¿9À�Á ; âA��äyÃ4ÒAí_� îÀ â9Ý¿9À�Á ; âA��äyÃ4ÒAí_� îÀ â�æ Î âA� äRÃ4Ò_î_â�4¿Rå �â�âAÇ)�Ò ; ÀqÏ�ó9Ãt�Äú Î âA��äRÃ�Ò/Õ�Ç ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇ_Å ×?êÀ �_�_ÂRÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç.Ô ¿9À Á ; �qÐ�Ð_Ã��qÅ�Ç ; âA��äRÃ�Ò9ò��qí�� �Ò�âAÇ�Ç?ÛÎ âA��äyÃ4Ò_î_âA��¿Rå �â_âÇ��_Ò ; ÀqÏ�óyÃ��_Ä�ú Î âA��äRÃ4Ò}Õ�Ç ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ�Å ×bÛÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒqã ä_å��â_âAÇ��_Ò ; ÀqÏ�ó9Ã���Ä�úÓÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒ/Õ�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆÇÅ ×?ÛÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å�úÿé9Û�Ç�ÈA���ÇbÛ�Ò�â��qÇyÝñêý¿9À Á ; �AÐ_ÐÃ��yÅ Ç ; âA��äyÃ�Ò9ò��í����_Ò_âÇ_Çxæ Î âA��äyÃ4Ò*(q�����A�bÔHÇ È���_Ç�Â_Ç�ÆAÇ�Åáúøé Ýñêß_ß Ï�ÚqÇqÏ�óÑâ9Ã�Ä�ÚÒzÏ4ÚëÃ�Å��Ã�ä�ÔT¿9À Á ; �AÐ_ÐÃ��yÅ Ç ; âA��äqÃ4ÒRòt�qí)�_��Ò_âAÇ Ç�þ�æà¿9À�Á ; âA��äyÃ4ÒAí_� îÀ â9Ýß�ß â9Ã�Ä�ÚÒöÏ4ÚëÃ)Å �ªÚqÀqÐ Î âA�qÐ Î ÇqÏ�ÒRÐÀ �_�_ÂRÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç.Ô ¿9À Á ; �qÐ�Ð_Ã��qÅ�Ç ; âA��äRÃ�Ò9ò��qí�� �Ò�âAÇ�Ç?ÛÎ âA��äyÃ4Ò_î_âA��¿Rå �â_âÇ��_Ò ; ÀqÏ�óyÃ��_Ä¢ÛÙqÇyÃ4Ä ÚÒqã ä_å��â_âAÇ��_Ò ; ÀqÏ�ó9Ã���Ä¢ÛÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å�úÿé9Û�Ç�ÈA���ÇbÛ"ä_ÀÅAÐ�ÇyÝdêß_ß ÄÇ ÒÑ�qÇ Á_ÒÓ÷qè)�A���ÇbÛ ÚqÇ�À Î Ï�À��_�q��Òª�qÇ�Ç�¿ Î Ò_Ü6AÇ_À Î È���Ç��qÇ�Á_Ò_÷_ÈA� �ÇàæÖÔd6AÇ_À Î ÈA���ÇyÝáÅqÃ4ÆAÇ È���Çb:AÀ�Á56AÇ_À Î ç âAÇt¿9� ÆÇ?:À ÁwÔFÝñêÇ ÈA���ÇÑæÑ�qÇ Á_Ò�÷_ÈA���ÇwçKÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA� �Ç.êÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òqã ä_å �_â_âAÇ��Ò ; ÀqÏ�óyÃ��_Ä�æÑ�qÇ Á_Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç¢çTÙqÇyÃ4Ä�Ú_Òwê

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßNy 0,KU¼4��X=TJ23��7p]�T:K3<=DW9�KL<=5S]^23A�<g5SZ�23Tp7:9�GBð��6~�`_<gKLX=>:K3DW`sX=TJ2&]�./GN?º¿�DF23<��7:;/<4A�Ge>:Á

Page 18: Branch and Bound

�N�e� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

Î âA� äRÃ4Ò_î_â�4¿Rå �â�âAÇ��Ò ; ÀqÏ4óRÃt�Ä�æÑ�qÇ Á_Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç¢ç Î âA��äRÃ�Ò¢ê¿9À Á ; �qÐ_ÐÃt�yÅ�Ç ; â��äRÃ4Òyò��qí)���_Ò_â_Ç_ÇxæÓ�qÇ�Á_Ò_÷_ÈA� �Ç¢ç � Î�Î Ç â ; â_��äRÃtÒ¢êÇ ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇÅ�æÑ�qÇ Á_Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç¢çpÅ�Ç ÆAÇÅ.êýß_ß Ï����RÐ�Ò_â��9Ï4Òà�qÇqÐ�Ò ; ÀqÏ�ó9Ãt�ÄAí_� îÀ â/Õ ×=�Ü�ä�Å�Å���ÙëÃ��_Ä Î À Ò�Úß_ß ä�âA��¿·Ç�ÈA���ǪÒA�ÑÒ�ÚqǪâA�_��Òä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò.-�æÑ�_��¿q�AÇ âqã äAã���-_ÇqÏ�ÒyÐ:ê1-õþ�ïbê -è_èqÝÞ �qÇqÐ4Ò ; ÀqÏ�óRÃ��ÄAí_��îAÀ â/Õz-�×áæ�ÔHÇ�ÈA���Ç¢çpÅ�Ç�ä�Òå�ÚëÃ�Å �RÝDC�éFErïbêÇ ÈA� �ÇÑæõÇ È���Ç¢ç Î À âAÇ��ÒwêýâAÇ Ò �â�� Î âA� äRÃ4Ò_î_â�4¿Rå �â�âAÇ��_Ò ; ÀqÏ�ó9Ã��_Äwêý

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞqßNy 0rKL¼_��X�T:2L��7[]=T:K3<=DW9SK3<=5�]^23A�<=5SZ�2&Tp7J9=Gjð��4~n`4<=K3X=>:K3DW`EX�T:23]�.\Gh? ¿ÀDh23<6�DF.\A=56Ge5=Á

KLT:GI23Z$7"c4X^G{6AÇ_À Î È���ÇgOMw19�;V>@7J;\?HG3d�6Ç_À Î ÈA� �Ç,9=K3>Y7:9�Gr5�KU7WK,?HGN?B]^GhTW>"Ï�ÅqÃ�3 �qÇ�íyÃ�ôÇ¿�<4A�?Y]gGNT[2LZfk3GNTC7:;\DhGN>1;\<�7J9�GjDh./;V�_A�GnTJGNX�T:GN>JGh<_7JGe5�]4cs7:9�;V>[<�2656GlÁ½d� Î_Î Ç�âAíyÃ�ôÇI¿À?EKU¼6;/?YA�?Xg2_>J>J;\]�./GjDh./;V�_A�GB>J;/vNGnZ�23TtKL<4c�.\GNKLZf;\<�7J9=;\>$<�2656G�$ >[>JA�]67JT:GhGlÁ½ddÅ�Ç�ÆAÇÅS¿�.\Ghk&Gh.i2LZf7J9�GB<�2656Gj;\<7J9�G1>J23.\A67J;\23<j>JX=K3DhGz7:TJGNGeÁ½dLK3<=53ÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���Çn¿�X^23;\<_7JGNT�7:2tDF2&TJGe>CX^23<g56;/<=0[<�2656Gm;\<j7:9�Gx>J23.\A67:;/2&<>CXgK3DFGz7JT:GhGeÁFO b 23Td� Î_Î Ç âíyÃ�ôÇ��xGx>C;\?HX�./c�A=>JG{7:9�GmkUKL.\A�G&Ï�ÅqÃ�3 �qÇ�íyÃ�ôÇ�úÓ�zèõÅ�Ç�ÆAÇÅàúøé&O-$>zK�T:GN>JA�./7NdL��G[DhK3<YGN./;\?H;/<=KL7JGpGN;�7:9�GhTf7:9�GEÏ ÅAÃ�3 �qÇ_íqÃ�ôÇ$23Ty7J9�GEÅ Ç ÆAÇÅ[�=Gh.V5@]gGeDhKLAg>CG�Z�T:23?� Î�Î Ç âAíyÃ4ôÇnK3<=5sGN;�7:9�GhT8Ï ÅqÃ|3 �qÇ_íyÃ4ôÇ�2&T�Å�Ç ÆAÇÅ�d37J9�G�2L7:9�GhT1DhK3<s]^G�Dh23?HX�A67:GN5PO{Q�9�GN<IK3<Gh.\Gh?HGh<_7$;V>17:2s]gGBGF¼47JTWK3DF7JGN5IZ�T:23? 7J9�Gj?EKL¼_��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c��_A�GNA�G3dg�xGj>JGh.\GNDF7$KL<�Gh.\Gh?HGN<&7[�p;/7J9?EKU¼6;/?YA�?Ö� Î_Î Ç âAíqÃ�ôÇgO{¹�<r23A=T[;/?HX�.\Gh?HGN<&7WKU7:;/2&<�2LZ}6AÇ�À Î ÈA���_Çgd4��Gj;/<gDF.\A=56GBK3./.�7J9�T:GhGj23Z7J9�Gj�=Gh.V5�>#Ï ÅqÃ�3 �AÇ_íyÃ�ôÇ=d � Î_Î Ç âAíyÃ�ô_Çgd6KL<g5�Å�Ç ÆAÇÅ�O�w19�Gj;\<=DF.\A=>J;/2&<�2LZy7J9�Ge>CGj�=Gh.V5�>[?EK3`3GN>;�7[GeK3>J;/GNT�7J2EGF¼6X^GhT:;/?HGN<&7p�p;/7J9�KL./7JGNTJ<gKU7J;\k3Gn56Gh�=<�;/7J;\23<=>123Z:� Î_Î Ç âíyÃ�ôÇgOw19�G�?HGh7J9�265�À��_�_åÅqÃ�3 �qÇ�ÈA���Ç�K35�5�>SK�.\;\k3G,<=245�Gr7J2M7J9�G�>CA=]=>CGh7I7:TJGNGr]^Gh;\<�0©Dh23<6�>"7:TJAgD½7JGe5RKL<=58K3.\>J2�7J2�7:9�Gs?EKU¼�9�GNK3XqO�w19�G�Dh245�GE;\>Bk3GhT:c�>J;\?@;\.VKLTn7:2�7J9�GSDF2656GHZ�23TB7J9�GDF2&TJT:GN>JXg2&<=56;\<�0@?@Gh7J9�265IZ�23T17:9�Gn.\2&K35�;/<�0HKL<g5I`4<=K3X=>:K3DW`EX�T:23]�.\Gh?E>1KL<g5I;V>123?H;/7C7:GN5POîzT:2303TWKL?Â}&}6O � 0&;/k&GN>y7:9�G[?HGF7:9�265E¿9À Á ; â��äRÃ4Ò*(*(m:AÀ ÁåÅAÃ�3 �ÇgOgw19=;\>{?HGh7J9�265HX^GhTJZ�23T:?H>KE?EKU¼4��X�TJ23��7$]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�>JGNK3T:DW9�2LZ{7:9�GY>JA�]=>JGF7�>C2&./A�7J;\23<,>JX=K3DhGn7JT:GhG&Otw19�GYTJ24237

2LZt7J9�;V>H7JT:GhG�;V>H7J9=G�;/<�;/7J;VKL.t»{��<�2656G3O�w19�;V>H<�2656G�;V>H<�2L7sGh¼4X=./;VDF;/7J.\c�T:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7JGe5M;\<©7J9�GDF2&<=>"7:TJAgD½7JGe5�7:TJGNG3O b 2&Tt7:9�;V>n»{��<�2656G"Ð_Ã�ôÇã ä�åAÅqÃ�3 �AÇ ð_Ò_÷ ÈA���_Ç@;\>nðS]^GNDhK3A=>JGY<�2�k&GhTJ7J;VDFGN>9=Klk3Gm]gGNGh<B>JGh.\GNDF7JGN5nZ�23Ty;/<=Dh./Ag>C;\23<j;\<_7J2p7:9�G1DF.\;\�_A�G&Oiw19�Gx./GNk3Gh._2LZ67:9�Gx»z��<=245�Gm;V>i56Ge>C;\03<gKU7JGe5]4c�7J9�G�kUKLT:;\K3]�./G/Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ=O^w19=;\>y;\<�;�7:;\K3.4klK3./A=Gx23ZRÇ È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ�;V>m~�]^GNDhK3A=>JGz7J9=G�;\<�;/7J;VKL.»{��<�2656G�;\>�7:9�GnT:2_237p2LZy7J9�Gj>JA�]=>JGF717JT:GhG&O

Page 19: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �e�~�ßG5G ¿9À ÁAè Î âA��äyÃ4Ò��âÀ��9Ï4Úyè À��A�Aè)�A���_�A�ªÏ����_ÇÑÒ��äRÃt�A��À�¿9À�Á�Ï�ÅqÃ�3 �qÇGIH Î À�âAÀ4¿Ñ¿9À Á_åAÅqÃ�3 �AÇ=¿9À ÁåÅqÃ�3 �qÇ¢ÕHÃ�×�Ð)Ç ÒÓÒA�øéÑÃ�ä_äzÃ�Ã�Ð�Ã��Ñ¿RÀ ÁzÏ ÅqÃ�3 �AÇGIH âAÇ�Ò��â��zÐÃ4ôÇÓ��ä�¿9À Á�Ï ÅqÃ�3 �AÇ G

ßÎ �_�yÅAÃ�ÏÓÃ��Ò�¿9À Á ; âA��äRÃ�Ò*(5(m:AÀ�ÁåAÅAÃ|3 �AÇ?ÔFÃ��Ò�ÕØ×�¿9À Á_åAÅqÃ�3 �AÇyÝÞ ÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���Çb:À Á56AÇ_À Î æÑ�qÇ�Ù:AÀ Á*6AÇ_À Î Ô�Ýñêß_ß Ã��ëÃ4Ò9Ã�ÀÅqÃ�ôÇ�ä� âõÅ�Ç ÆAÇ_ÅöéÓÐ�ÒAÀ�â_Ò(5(_�q� �ÇÑÇ ÈA���_ÇÓæÑ�_�yÅ�Å?êÃ��ÒõÇ ÈA���_Ç�ÂÇ ÆAÇ_Å�æøéëêÃ��Ò�ÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä_åAÅqÃ|3 �qÇ ð_Ò�÷�ÈA����ÇxæöïbêÃ��Ò�ÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä*:AÀ Á_åAÅqÃ�3 �AÇ�í_� î_À â�æõï?êß_ß Ð�Ç_À âRÏ�ÚzÐ4�_�9Ð�Ç�ÒöÐ Î ÀqÏ�ǪÒ_âÇ_ÇÙ_ÚëÃ�Å ÇùÔLÇ ÈA���Ç ÂÇ ÆAÇÅFcØæÑ�öúøé ÝÞ ß_ß Ù_ÚëÃ�Å Ç��q� ÒõÀ ÒõÅ�Ç_À�äß_ß Ð)Ç_ÇöÃ�ä�ÆÇ â_ÒAÇ Á�Ç�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆAÇÅ�à Ð�Ï)���_�qÇqÏ4ÒAÇ��àÒA��ÀÅ_ÅàÆAÇ�â_Ò9Ã�Ï�ÇAÐß_ß Ãt�øÏ4�_â_âAÇ��Ò�Ï ÅqÃ�3 �AÇ�q�_�Å�Ç�À��zÏ����_�AÇqÏ�ÒAÇ��àæ�Ò_â �qÇbê(5(_�q���_Ç�Ï4�â_âAÇ)�Ò_ÈA���_Ç�æ�Ç ÈA���Ç?êä� âÖÔtÃ��Ò.-�æõÇ È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅàè�éëê0-õþÓïbêÏ4�â�âAÇ��Ò_È���Ç�æzÏ4�â�âAÇ��Ò_È���Ç¢ç Î À âAÇ���Ò¢Û1-è_èqÝÃ4ä�Ô�Ï��â_âAÇ��_Ò_ÈA���ÇwçKÅ�Ç ä Òå�ÚëÃ�Å � 454 c�À(Õ�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ ×}Õ2- ×RÝÞ ß_ß -�Ã�Ð�Ã���Ò�ÚqÇõÏ ÅqÃ|3 �qÇ��_�ÒÓ�q�ÓÇ���ÄǪ�AÇ Ò�ÙqÇ_Ç)��Ç ÈA���Ç ÂÇ ÆAÇÅ�À��A�-Ï��)�_�qÇqÏ�ÒÇ��àæ�äÀÅAÐ�Ç?ê�âÇ_À ó¢êý

Ã�ä�ÔFÏ����_�qÇAÏ�ÒAÇ��RÝÞ ß_ß Å�Ç�ä�ÒzÏ4Ú9Ã�Å �zÃ�ÐàäÇ_ÀqÐÃt�yÅ�ÇÃ4ä�Ô�Ð_Ã�ôÇã ä�åAÅqÃ�3 �AÇ ð_Ò�÷�ÈA� �ÇxúøéàþõÐÃ�ô_Çã ä*:AÀ�ÁåAÅqÃ�3��qÇ_í_�)îAÀ âRÝÐÃ4ôÇã ä*:À ÁåAÅqÃ|3 �qÇ�í�� îÀ â�æzÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä_åAÅqÃ|3 �qÇ ð_Ò�÷_È���_ÇáúøéëêÀ �_�_ÂRÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç.Ô�ÐÃ�ôÇ�ã ä�åÅqÃ|3 �Ç ð_Ò ÷_È����Ç�úÑ�zè�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ�úøéëÛÐÃ4ôÇã ä_åÅqÃ�3 �qÇ�ð_Ò_÷�È���_Çxúÿé9Û�Ç�ÈA���Ç�Â_Ç ÆAÇÅ�úøéëÛ�Ç ÈA���_ÇbÛ�Ò_â��qÇqÝñêýÃ�ä�ÔFÐÃ�ôÇã�ä_åAÅqÃ�3��qÇ ð_Ò_÷ ÈA� �_ÇáúÑ�·èÓÇ ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇÅàþ æzÐÃ�ô_Çã ä*:AÀ�ÁåAÅqÃ�3��qÇ_í���îÀ â9Ýß�ß â9Ã�Ä�ÚÒöÏ4ÚëÃ)Å �ªÚqÀqÐ Î âA�qÐ Î ÇqÏ�ÒRÐÀ �_�_ÂRÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç.Ô�ÐÃ�ôÇ�ã ä�åÅqÃ|3 �Ç ð_Ò ÷_È����Ç�úÑ�zè�Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ?ÛÐÃ4ôÇã ä_åÅqÃ�3 �qÇ�ð_Ò_÷�È���_ÇbÛ-Ç È���Ç�ÂÇ�ÆAÇÅ�ú éëÛ�Ç ÈA���_ÇbÛ"äÀÅAÐ)ÇyÝñê

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßf� 0rKL¼_��X�T:2L��7p]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�?HKL¼4��Dh./;V�_A�G�Dh2656Gs¿ÀDh23<_7J;\<4A�GN>WÁ

Page 20: Branch and Bound

�~�,+ �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

ß_ß ÄAÇ ÒÓ�qÇ Á_ÒÑ÷Aè)�q���Ç?Û ÚqÇ_À Î Ï�À����q� Òª�qÇ�Ç4¿ Î Ò�Ü6AÇ_À Î ÈA���Ç��AÇ Á_Ò_÷_È���ÇàæÖÔd6AÇ_À Î ÈA���ÇqÝáÅqÃ4ÆÇ ÈA���Ç?:AÀ Á56AÇ�À Î çØâ_Ç4¿R� Æ_Çb:AÀ)ÁwÔ�ÝñêÇ ÈA� �ÇÑæÓ�qÇ�Á_Ò_÷_ÈA� �Ç¢çKÅqÃ�ÆAÇ ÈA���ÇbêÐÃ�ô_Çã ä_åAÅAÃ�3 �qÇ ð�Ò_÷_ÈA���ÇxæÓ�qÇ�Á_Ò_÷_ÈA� �Ç¢çHÏ ÅAÃ�3 �qÇ_íAÃ�ô_Ç?êÇ ÈA� �Ç�ÂÇ ÆÇÅ�æÑ�qÇ Á_Ò_÷�ÈA���Ç¢çpÅ�Ç ÆAÇÅ.êýß_ß Ï����RÐ�Ò_â��9Ï4Òá¿9À ÁåÅqÃ�3 �qÇ¢ÕØ×��Ü�ä�Å�Å���ÙëÃ��_Ä Î À Ò�Ú�ä�â�4¿�Ç ÈA���ÇàÒ�ÓÒ�ÚAÇÑâ�_� Òä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò.-�æÑ�(ê0-õþÓïbê0-è_èqÝÞ ¿9À Á_åAÅqÃ�3 �AÇ(ÕB-�×�æ�ÔHÇ�ÈA���Ç¢çpÅ�Ç�ä�Òå�ÚëÃ�Å �RÝDC�éFErïbêÇ ÈA� �ÇÑæõÇ È���Ç¢ç Î À âAÇ��ÒwêýâAÇ Ò �â��zÐÃ�ô_Çã ä*:AÀ�ÁåAÅqÃ�3��qÇ_í���îÀ âbêý

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßi� 0rKU¼4��X�TJ23��7p]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5s?EKU¼4��DF.\;\�_A�GnDh245�GH¿�DF2&<=DF.\A=56Ge5=Á

¹�<×7:9�GrÙ_ÚëÃ)Å�Ç�.\2423X�»{��<�2656GN>EK3TJGSGF¼6X=K3<=56GN5©A�<_7:;/.$K�.\GNKLZ@¿�;�O G3O\d1K�.\Ghk&Gh./�Aúëé�<�2656GeÁ]gGeDF2&?@Ge>[7:9�GE»{��<�2656G3O b 23T�K�.\GNKLZm<�2656G3� Î_Î Ç âAíqÃ�ôÇ �ÖÐÃ�ôÇã�ä_åAÅqÃ�3��qÇ ð_Ò_÷ ÈA����ÇgO � ;\<=DFGKL.\.{TJGN?EKL;\<�;/<=0�<�2656Ge>�9=Klk3GHKL<>� Î�Î Ç âAíyÃ4ôÇsklK3./A=G{�Ô7J9=KL7�23Zm7:9�GEDFA�T:TJGN<_7n»z��<=245�G3da7J9=GhcDhK3<�<�2L7f.\GNK35j7J2nKt.\K3TJ0&GhTfDF.\;\�_A�G�7J9gKL<j7:9�G[DF.\;V�&A=GxT:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7:GN5j]4c�7:9�;\>{»z��<=245�G3Oiw19=GhT:GFZ�23T:G3d7J9�G�?EKU¼BDh./;V�_A�Gx9gK3>i]gGNGh<YZ�23A�<=5qOyw19�G1DF.\;V�&A=Gx;/7:>JGh./Z=;V>yDh23<=>C7JT:A=DF7JGN5B]4ctZ�2&./.\2U�p;\<�0[7:9�G1X=KU7:9Z�TJ2&? 7J9=Gj»{��<�2656G�./GeKUZ�7:2H7J9�GnT:242L7p2LZi7J9�GjDh23<=>C7JT:A=DF7JGN5S>JA�]=>JGF7p7JT:GhG&Ow�2sGh¼6X=KL<=5�KH<�2&<�.\GNKUZ{»{��<�2656G&d��xG��gT:>C7$DF2&<=>C;V56GNT[;�7W>p.\GFZu7tDW9�;\.V5PO�-�7$7J9�Gn.\GFZu7�DW9�;/.V5Pd=K

<�Gh�×k3GNTC7:GF¼x�n;V>f;/<gDF.\A=56GN5@;\<_7J2�7J9�G[Dh./;V�_A�G1]gGN;/<=0�Dh23<=>C7JT:A=DF7JGN5qOyw19�;V>f;\<=DF.\A=>J;/2&<Y;V>fXg2_>J>J;\]�./G23<�.\cE;/ZiKL<IGN560&GtGh¼4;V>C7:>�]gGh7"�xGNGh<Ik3GhTJ7JGh¼g�EKL<=5�GNK3DW9I2LZq7:9�G�k3GhTJ7J;VDFGe>1KL.\TJGeK356c@;/<gDF.\A=56GN5SKU77J9�GE»z��<�2656G&Ojw�2�56Gh7JGhT:?H;/<=GB7:9�G@Z�GNK3>J;\]�./;/7"c�2LZm7J9�GH.\GFZu7jDW9�;\.\5PdP��GYZ�23.\./2U� 7:9�GHX=KU7:9rZ�T:23?7J9�GY»{��<�2656G�7J2E7:9�GjT:242L7Ndg56GF7:GhT:?@;\<�;\<�0s�p9�;VDW9�k3GNTC7:;\DhGN>[K3TJG�;\<=DF.\A=56Ge5rKL<g5SK3.\>J2Ek3GNTJ;/Z�c4;/<=07J9=KL7nGNK3DW9�;/<gDF.\A=56GN5�k3GNTC7:GF¼r;V>nDF2&<�<�GNDF7JGe5�7J2�k&GhTJ7JGF¼0��]4crK3<�Ge5603G&Oj¹�Zx7:9�GH./GhZu7jDW9�;/.V5�;\>Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\G3d{��GIK35=5R;�7@7J2,7J9�GS?EKU¼4��X�TJ;\23T:;/7"c��_A�GhA=GSK&>j��Gh.\.1K&>n7:2,7:9�GI>JA�]=>JGF7@7JT:GhGI]gGN;/<�0DF2&<=>"7:TJAgD½7JGe5PO ò Gh¼47[�xGjK&5�5I7J9�GnT:;/0&9_7pDW9=;/.V5SX�TJ2Uk4;V56GN5�7J9gKU7[;/7:>[>JA�]67:TJGNGjDF23A=.\5SDF2&<&7WKL;\<SK./GeKUZi7J9=KL7[TJGNX�TJGe>CGN<_7:>1KH?EKU¼IDh./;V�_A�G3O� ;/<gDFGBGNk3GNTJcS03TWKLX�9�9=K&>tKs?HKL¼�Dh./;V�_A�G3da��GB562s<=2L7t<=GhGN5�7J2s7:GN>C7$Z�2&TtKL<�GN?HX67"c�9�GNK3X

�p9�Gh<�56GN./Gh7J;\<�0HZ�T:23? 7:9�Gn?EKU¼S9�GNK3XqOmw19�GEÙ_ÚëÃ�Å Ç@.\2423XS;\>[GF¼6;�7:GN5S23<=./cI�p9�Gh<���GnTJGeK3DW9IKZ�GNK&>C;\]�.\G�.\GNKLZ"O

Page 21: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �,�Lø�w���c�/��� �2¨A¤��¢¦'ZK¥p¡&¬F�}¤}Zp¦'V*U#¦d¨�V� ¢¡

��_� w19�GY7JTWKlk3GN./;\<�03��>:KL.\GN>JXgGNT:>J23<SX�T:23]�.\Gh? �1K3>t;/<_7:TJ2656A=DhGN5,;/< � GNDF7J;\23<8}6~3Oí}6O �=O�w19�GH>C2&./A�7J;\23<

>JX=K3DhG�Z�23Tz7:9�;V>{X�T:23]�.\Gh? ;\>mK�XgGNTJ?YA67:KL7J;\23<@7JT:GhG&Of-t>{;\<H7J9�G$DNK3>JGp2LZP?EKU¼4��X�TJ23��7zKL<=5@.\GNK&>"7J�Dh2&>C7�]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5r>JGNK3T:DW9=GN>t2LZ�>JA�]=>JGF7�7:TJGNGN>Nda7J9�GNTJGEKLT:Gj7"��2SXg2_>J>J;/]=;/.\;�7:;/Ge>�Z�23T�7J9=G;\?HX�./GN?HGh<_7:KL7J;\23<qOy¹�<H23<�G1��G�Ag>CGp2&<�./cYKtX=TJ;\23T:;�7"cj�_A�GNA�Gp;\<@�p9=;\DW9@GNK&DW9YGN./GN?@GN<_7mDF23<_7WKL;\<=>7:9�GpX=KU7:9@7J2�7J9�G$TJ242L7eO�¹�<@7J9=Gp2L7J9=GhT{��Gp?HK3;/<_7WKL;\<B7:9�GpXg2&TC7:;/2&<H2LZ=7:9�G$>J23.\A67J;\23<H>JX=K3DhGx7:TJGNG7:9=KU7[;V>p03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5�KL<g5SKHX=TJ;\23T:;�7"cI�&A=GhA�Gn23Zy.\;/k&Gn<�2656GN>NOm¹�<�7:9�Gj.VKU7J7JGhTtDhK3>JG�7J9�GBX�TJ;\23T:;/7"c�_A�GNA�GEGh.\Gh?HGh<_7W>n562�<�2L7BDh23<_7:K3;/<�7:9�GEX=KU7:9�7J2�7J9=GETJ242L7eO�w19�GE;\?HX�./GN?HGh<_7:KL7J;\23<8;/<�7:9�;\>>JGNDF7J;\23<SA=>CGe>�7J9�G�Z�2&TJ?HGNT[KLX�X�T:2&K&DW9qd&7J9�2&A�039S7J9=Gn.\KL7C7JGNT[DF2&A�.\5SKL.V>J2@9gKlk3G�]gGNGh<�A=>JGN5PO� ;\<=DFG���GnKLT:G$.\2_2&`4;/<�0YZ�23TpK@.\GNK3>C7C��DF2_>"7x7JTWKlk3GN./;\<�0L��>:KL.\GN>JXgGNT:>J23<HT:23A67:G3d6��Gt�p;\./.PGN?HX�./2Uc

KM./GeK3>C7C��DF2&>C7�]�TWKL<gDW9ïKL<=5 ]g2&A�<=5PO w19�G�;/?HX�.\Gh?HGN<&7WKU7:;/2&<ïA=>JGN>SK�?H;\<6��X=TJ;\23T:;�7"c��_A�GNA�G23Z@.\;/k&GR<�2656GN>NOºw19=G�<�2656GN>r;/<�7J9=;\>��&A=GhA�GMK3TJG823ZY7"c4X^GJ6AÇ�À Î ÈA���_ÇgOó»mK&DW9¶<=245�G�2LZ7:9�;\>s7"c4XgGr9gK3>H7:9�Gr�=GN.\5=> Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â�¿ÀKRX^GhT:?BA67WKU7:;/2&<©23Z�7J9�Gr<4A�?Y]gGNT:>,~�7J9�T:23A=039�8�p;�7:9 Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/Õ�ï�×I]^Gh;\<�0×~eÁ`{&ÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A����â8¿ÀK3<M;\<_7JGh0&GhT@>CA=DW9�7J9=KL7B7J9=GX=KL7J9©Z�T:23? 7:9�GrT:2_237E2LZ�7J9�G�X^GhT:?BA67WKU7:;/2&<×7:TJGNGS7J287J9=;\>E<=245�Gr56GF�=<=GN>H7:9�G�7J2&A�TEX�T:GF��¼Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/Õ�ï�ELÐ_Ã�ôÇ�ã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã4ÀÅ�����_â×�K3<=5�7:9�G8k3GNTC7:;\DhGN>Ic3GF7S7J2©]^G�k4;V>C;/7JGe5 ]4c�7J9=G7:23A�T@KLT:G Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A���â}ÕLÐÃ�ôÇ_ã�ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�À_Å?�_���â_ú9é8E �yèqé�×y{qKL.V>C2rGe�_A=KL.V>j<4A�?Y]gGNTB2LZpGe5603Ge>;\<�XgKLTJ7J;VKL.f7J2&A�T½Á`{wÏ��qÐ�Òqã�ä ; À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�âr¿�DF2&>C7n2LZx7J23A=TnX�TJGh��¼,T:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7:GN5r]4c�7:9�GEX=KL7J9Z�T:23?ó7:9�GE>C2&./A�7J;\23<8>CX=K&DFG@7JT:GhGHT:242L7�7J2S7J9=;\>n<=245�GeÁ`{wÅ���ÙAÇ âå�qÐ4Ò�¿�.\GNK&>"7jX^2&>:>C;\]�.\GEDF2&>C7n2LZK3<_cY./GeKUZP;\<H7J9�;V>z<�2656G $ >x>CA=]67JT:GhGlÁ`{4KL<=55¿:Ã��ð_�_�RÃ4Ò9Ã����qÀÅ å_�qÐ�ÒB¿�>CA�?Ã23ZPDh2&>C7:>{23ZP./GeK3>C7C��DF2&>C72&A67J]^23A�<g5�GN5�03GN>YZ�T:23? k3GNTC7:;\DhGN> Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â/ÕKÐÃ�ôÇã)ä ; À)â_ÒRÃ)À_Å��A���â�E �qèyé�×_ÁFOr»{¼47JTWK3DF�7:;/2&<=>yZ�TJ2&?Ô7:9�Gp?H;/<E9�GeKLXHKLT:Gp5623<�Gp]4c-Å ��ÙqÇ âå_�qÐ�Ò�klK3./A=G3Ofw19�Gp]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5YDh2656GK3X�XgGeKLTW>�;/<�îzT:230&T:K3? }3}6O � OîzT:230&T:K3?º}3}�O � ]gGN03;\<=>B]4c8DFT:GNKL7J;\<�0,Kr?H;\<�9�GeKLXR7:9=KU7@TJGNX�TJGe>CGN<_7:>n7:9�G�?H;\<6��X�TJ;\23T:;/7"c

�_A�GNA�G�2LZ�./;\k3G�<=245�GN>NO ò Gh¼47��xGrDh23?HX�A67:G�7J9=GrDF2&>C7s2LZ�7:9�GrDW9�GNK3XgGe>"7s2&A67J]^23A=<=5�GN560&GZ�T:23? GeK3DW9©k3GhTJ7JGh¼�;/<×7J9=Gr56;/0&T:K3X�9qO×¹�Z�>J23?HGSk3GhTJ7JGh¼�9=K3>H<=2�2&A67J]^23A=<=5MGe5603G&dz7:9�Gr56;/�0&T:K3X�9�9=K3>I<�2×7J2&A�TSK3<=5���G,7:GhT:?H;/<=KL7JG&O(¹�Z@GNK3DW9�k&GhTJ7JGh¼�9gK3>SKL<ï2&A67J]^23A=<=5 Ge5603G&d$K.\GNK&>"7J��Dh2&>C7m]�TWKL<=DW9�K3<=5E]^23A�<g5s;V>x;\<�;/7J;VKU7:GN5PO{Q�Gt]^Gh0&;/<I�p;�7:9s7:9�G�DW9=;/.V5s23ZP7J9�G�TJ24237�¿�<=245�G% ;\< b ;\03A�T:GE}6~3O��3ÁtK3>t7:9�G@�=T:>C7j»{��<�2656G3O@-�7�7J9�;V>�<�2656G@7J9�G@7:23A�T�X�T:GF��¼,Dh23<=>C7JT:A=DF7JGN5�;V>7"A=>C7�7J9�GE>J;/<=03.\G@k&GhTJ7JGh¼�~3OYw19=GhT:GFZ�23T:G3d?ÐÃ�ôÇã�ä ; À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�_â��Ãð=d Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â/ÕØï�× �~&dxKL<g5 Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?����â/ÕFé8E �yèRé�×�K3TJGI7J9=GST:Gh?EK3;/<�;\<�08k3GNTC7:;\DhGN>S¿�}�d�ë=dj���~�/d¢�=Á½O�w19�GS7J23A=TX�T:GF�=¼ ~�9=K3>�Dh2&>C7Sð�d�>C2�Ï��AÐ�Òqã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A����â�� ð=OÃ-$.\>J2=d/¿:Ãt�ð�_�RÃ�Ò9Ã)���qÀ_Å å�qÐ�Òx������� < Ï��qÐ4Òqã ä*:9Ãt�yã)�Ò_÷_��ÄAÇy� �T��Og¹�<�;/7J;VKL.\.\c3d6<�2B7J23A=T�9gK3>x]gGNGh<sZ�2&A�<=5Pd�>J2mÏ��qÐ�Òqã�äb(qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���âqèí_� îAÀ�âH;V>[>JGF717J2��_�yÅ_Å�Ow19�G8Ù_Ú9Ã�Å�Çn.\2423XsGh¼6X=KL<=5=>x»z��<�2656Ge>zA�<_7:;/.a��G$T:GNK3DW9E2&<�G[7:9=KU71;V>xKB./GeKUZ�2&Tm��G$T:A�<�2&A67

23Zg»{��<�2656GN>i7:2�Gh¼6X=KL<=5qOi-�.\GNKUZg;\>{56Gh7JGeD½7JGe5B]4cj<=2L7J;VDF;\<�0t7J9=KL7z�p9�Gh<�ÐÃ�ô_Çã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A�)�â���yèRé&d37:9�G�7J2&A�TxX=TJGh��¼s;\> Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/Õ�ï�ET�yèRét×y{e7:9�;\>�X�T:GF�=¼s;/<=Dh./Ag56GN>pK3./.R�sk3GNTC7:;\DhGN>x2LZ7:9�GY56;\03TWKLX=9qO$�[GN<=DFG@KE.\;/k&GB<�2656GY�p;�7:9xÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A���â��·�yèRéjT:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7W>[Ks.\GNKLZ"O%�c�7:9�G,<gKU7JA=TJGr23Z�7J9�G�KL.\0323T:;/7J9�?�dpK8./GeKUZn9=K&>�Ï��qÐ4Òqã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���_â�KL<g5�Å ��ÙqÇ âå_�qÐ�ÒGe�&AgKL.{7:2�7J9�G�Dh2&>C7j2LZ17J9=GE7J2&A�Tj;/7BTJGNX�T:GN>JGh<_7:>NO � ;\<=DhG�KL.\.zT:Gh?EKL;\<�;\<�0�./;\k3GE<=245�GN>j9gKlk3GEKÅ���ÙqÇ�âå�qÐ�ÒskUKL.\A�GEKU7�./GeK3>C7�K&>t?YA=DW9�K&>[7:9=KU7n23Zz7J9�G@�=TW>C7�.\GNKLZxGF¼47:T:K&D½7JGe5�Z�T:23? 7J9=G@?H;\<9�GeKLXqd&<�23<=G[2LZa7J9=GN>JG[TJGN?EKL;\<�;/<=0n<�2656GN>xDhKL<H.\GNK&5@7J2BK�]^GF7J7JGhT�.\GNKUZ"Ofw19�GNTJGhZ�23T:G3dL7:9�G$>JGNK3T:DW9Z�2&T�K3<�23X�7J;\?HK3.=7:23A�T1?EKlc@7JGNTJ?H;\<=KU7:G�K&>x>J2423<IK&>xKB./GeKUZ�]^GNDh23?HGN>x7:9�G�»z��<=245�G3Of¹�Z���GtT:A�<2&A67p2LZ{»{��<�2656GN>�]^GFZ�23T:GjK@./GeKUZy;\>pT:GNK&DW9�GN5qd&7:9�Gn03TWKLX=9I9=K&>1<�2@7J2&A�TNO

Page 22: Branch and Bound

�~�l� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

ßG*G Å Ç_ÀqÐ�ÒqèÏ��qÐ�Òà�_âAÀ��9Ï4Úqè�À��A�Aè��q���_�_�ÓÏ�� �ǪÒA�ÑäRÃ��A��ÀöÐ4Úq� â_ÒÇqÐ�ÒÑÒA���_âGLH Î À âAÀ4¿õÒ ÚqÇ5�_Ç â�ªôÇ âA�àÙqÇyÃ�Ä�ÚÒGLH Î À âAÀ4¿��AÇqÐ�Ò5�A�)�âª�qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���â/ÕLÃ�×�Ð�Ç�Ò�Ò��Ã'��Ò�Ú�ÆAÇ â_ÒAÇ�Á����øÐ�Úq� â_ÒAÇAÐ�ÒªÒA���_âGLH âAÇ Ò��â �zÏ��qÐ�Ò���äzÐ4Úq� â�ÒAÇqÐ�ÒªÒ���â G

ßÎ ���yÅqÃ�Ïàã)��-_ÇqÏ�Ò�Å�Ç�ÀqÐ�Òå�AÐ�Ò*(5(qí�ÀÅ�ÇqÐ Î Ç âyÐ)�)�¢ÔtÃ��Òx�qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���â/Õ ×wÛ"ã Î Ç âAÀ��yÅ Ç�Ò�ÚqÇ5��Ç âA�yÝÞ :9Ã��56AÇ_À Î ÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �Çb:9Ã��56AÇ_À Î æÓ�AÇ�Ù:9Ã��m6AÇ�À Î ÔtÝñêß_ß Ï��qÐ4Òqã ä*:9Ãt�yã)�Ò_÷_��ÄAÇ(ÕKÃ�×áæ�Ï��AÐ�Ò���äöÅ Ç_ÀqÐ�ÒqèÏ��qÐ�ÒªÇ���ÄAÇ�Å�Ç_À�Æ9Ã��ÄÑÆAÇ�â_ÒAÇ ÁzÃã Î Ç�âAÀ��yÅ�ÇùÕØ×�Ï)�qÐ�Òqã äb:9Ã��yã)�_Ò_÷��Ä_Ç�æÑ�qÇ�Ùöã Î Ç�âAÀ��yÅ�ÇùÕT�öúøé�×wê

ã Î Ç�âAÀ��yÅ�ÇÓÐ4��¿ëã äb:9Ã��Aå�AÐ�Òqã)�Ò�÷_��Ä_ÇqÐ>æ�Ô`ã Î Ç âAÀ��qÅ�ÇyÝ=Ò�ÚAÇ5�_Ç âA�wç�ôÇ âA�.ÔtÝñêß_ß �9Ð�ÇÓÀª�qÇ�Ù·Ï�� Î Ü���ä�ôÇ â�ä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò�Ãàæøéëê=ÃÑû æÑ�(ê=Ã�ú_úRÝÞ ß_ß Ï���¿ Î �ÒAÇ�Ï)�qÐ�Òqã äb:9Ã��yã)�_Ò_÷��Ä_Ç(ÕHÃ4×�À����Ð4�)¿ëã ä*:9Ãt�Aå�qÐ�ÒAã)�Ò_÷���ÄÇqÐã Î Ç�âAÀ��yÅ�Çx¿ñÃ��Aå�qÐ4ÒÑæ��_�qÅ_Å?êä� â�ÔtÃ��_Ò�-ÓæøéëêA-�û æÑ�(ê -�ú_úRÝÃ�äÖÔHÀ(ÕHÃ�×(ÕB-�×�cØæÑ�_�yÅ�Å 4*4 Ô ¿ñÃ��Aå�qÐ4ÒÑæ_æÑ�_�yÅ_Å��5�¿:Ã��Aå_�qÐ�Ò}çHÏ)�4¿ Î À âÇ?�A�:ÔHÀ(ÕLÃ4×(ÕB-�×qÝ1þ�ïyÝ_Ý¿:Ã��Aå�AÐ�ÒÓæ�ÔHã Î Ç âAÀ)�yÅ�ÇyÝ=À(ÕHÃ�×}Õ2-�×wê

Ã�äÖÔ ¿:Ã��å�qÐ�ÒÑæ�æÓ�_�qÅ_ÅqÝáâAÇ Ò��_â��Ñ�_�yÅ_Å.ê ß_ß �A�ÓâA�)�ÒAÇÏ��qÐ4Òqã ä*:9Ãt�yã)�Ò_÷_��ÄAÇ(ÕKÃ�×áæà¿:Ãt�Aå�qÐ�ÒwêÐ4��¿9ã ä*:9Ã��å�qÐ�Òqã��Ò_÷��ÄAÇqÐ.çHÃt�9Ï�âAÇ4¿RÇ)�_ÒwÔ ¿dÃ��å_�qÐ4Ò9Ýëêýß_ß Ã��ëÃ�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�÷qè��q���ÇõÃ�Ð�Ò_âAÇ�ÇÑâ�_� Ò6AÇ_À Î ÈA���ÇàÇ ÈA���ǪæÓ�qÇ�Ù6AÇ_À Î ÈA���Ç.ÔtÝñêÇ ÈA� �Ç¢ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A�)�â�æÑ�qÇ�ÙøÃ��Ò ÕT�A×bêä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò�Ãàæ�ïbê=ÃÑûà�(ê=Ã�ú_úRÝÇ ÈA� �Ç¢ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â(ÕHÃ�×áæ·Ã�úøéëêÇ ÈA� �Ç¢çHÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�À_Å?�_���â�æõï?ê ß_ßÎ À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�Ò���â�Ã�Ðß_ßÎ À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ¢ÕØï�Epï�×Ç ÈA� �Ç¢çHÏ��AÐ�Òqã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�À_Å?�_���â�æ�Ò ÚqÇ5�_Ç â�bê ß_ß Ã4ÒRÐÓÏ��AÐ�Ò�Ã�Ъô_Ç âA�Ç ÈA� �Ç¢çZ¿:Ãt�ð�_�RÃ�Ò9Ã����AÀ_Å å��qÐ�Ò�æ�Ð���¿ëã ä*:RÃ��Aå�qÐ4Òqã)�Ò_÷���ÄÇAÐ:êã Î Ç�âAÀ��yÅ�ÇÓÏ��qÐ�Òqã�äb(qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���âAí���îAÀ)âàæÑ�_�yÅ_Å.ê ß_ß �q�ªÒA���_â�ä_���_�A�öÐ��ÓäÀ âÃ��Ò ÕØ× Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?����âªæ�Ç ÈA� �Ç¢ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���_âwê

ß_ß Ð4Úq��â_Ò�ÚqÀ���àä� âß_ß Ç ÈA� �Ç¢ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A�)�âÖ�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßN� o�GNK3>C7C��DF2_>"7x]�T:K3<=DW9IK3<=5s]^23A=<=5EZ�2&Tx7:T:Klk&Gh.\;/<=0B>JK3./Ge>CX^GhTW>J23<,¿�DF23<_7:;/<4A�Ge>:Á

Page 23: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �,�Nü

ß_ß Ð�Ç_À âRÏ�Ú Î Ç â)¿q�_ÒAÀ Ò9Ã)�)�ªÒ_âAÇ�ÇÙ_ÚëÃ�Å ÇùÔLÇ ÈA���Ç�c æÓ�_�qÅ_Å 454 Ç ÈA���ÇwçHÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�ÀÅ������âªûª��è�é ÝÞ ß_ß �q� Ò�À ÒöÅ�Ç_À�äÎ À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���_âªæ�Ç ÈA���Çwç Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�âwêÃ�ä�ÔLÇ ÈA���ÇwçHÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â Ò9Ã�À_Å?�����âàæ�æÑ�zè./qÝÞ ß_ß Î À âAÇ)�Ò���ä�Å�Ç_À�äß�ß Ï���¿ Î Å�Ç ÒÇ�ÒA���âÑ�ÜõÀ��_�yÃ��ÄÑÒ�Ùq�ÓÇ�� ÄAÇqÐß�ß Ð�Ç�ǪÙ�ÚqÇ Ò�ÚqÇ�âª�qÇ�Ù�ÒA���â�Ã�Ð��qÇ Ò�ÒAÇ âÃ4ä�ÔHÀ¢Õ Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/Õc�Ñè�/�×_×}Õ Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A���â}Õc�ªè·ét×_×�c æÓ�_�qÅ_Å454 À¢Õ Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/ÕT�ªèøét×_×}ÕFé�×�c æÑ���yÅ_Å454 ÔFÏ��qÐ�Òqã�äb(qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���âAí � îAÀ)â�æ�æÓ�_�qÅ_Å��5�Ô�Ô`ã Î Ç âÀ��yÅ�ÇyÝöÔ_Ô`ã Î Ç âAÀ��yÅ ÇyÝxÇ È���Ç¢çHÏ)�qÐ�Òqã ä ; À â_ÒyÃ)ÀÅ���)�âçpÀ �_�bÔHÀ(Õ Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A����â/ÕT�ªè�/�×_×}Õ Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A���â}Õc�ªèøé�×�×RÝ_ÝçpÀ �_�bÔHÀ(Õ Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A����â/ÕT�ªè�é�×_×}ÕFét×RÝ_ÝçHÏ)�4¿ Î À âÇb�A�?Ô�Ï)�qÐ�Òqã ä�(qÇqÐ�Ò5�����âAí_�)îAÀ�â9Ý1ûÓïyÝ_ÝÞ ß_ß �qÇ Ò_ÒAÇ�âÑÒA���â�ä�����A�Ï��AÐ�Òqã äb(AÇqÐ�Ò5�A�)�âAí���îAÀ�â�æ ÔHã Î Ç âAÀ)�yÅ�ÇyÝöÔ_Ô_Ô`ã Î Ç âAÀ��yÅ ÇyÝxÇ È���ÇçHÏ)�qÐ�Òqã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���â(çpÀ��_�bÔKÀ(Õ Î À�â�Ò9Ã4ÀÅ��A�)�_â/ÕZ�Óè�/�×_×Õ Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/ÕT�Ñè·ét×_×RÝ_ÝçpÀ �_�bÔHÀ(Õ Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���â}ÕT�ªè�é�×_×}Õ`é�×RÝ_ÝñêÇ ÈA���ÇwçHÏ��qÐ�ÒAã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�ÀÅ��A����â�æzÏ��qÐ4Òqã äb(qÇAÐ�Ò5�A���_âAí_� î_À â¢êÇ ÈA���ÇwçKÅ���ÙqÇ�âå�qÐ�Ò�æzÏ��qÐ�Òqã�äb(qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���âAí���îAÀ)â¢êÇ ÈA���ÇwçHÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�ÀÅ��A����âú�úwêÅqÃ4ÆAÇ È���Çb:9Ãt�m6AÇ_À Î ç Î �Ò?ÔHÇ È_���_ÇyÝëêýýÇÅAÐ�ÇÞ ß_ß ÄAÇ��qÇ�âAÀ ÒAÇ�Ï4Ú9Ã�Å ��âAÇ)�ä_� âÖÔtÃ��Ò�Ã�æõÇ È���Ç¢çHÐ_Ã�ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã4ÀÅ?�_���_â�ú é9ê=ÃÑûª�¢êxÃ�ú�úRÝÃ�äùÔHÀ¢Õ Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/Õ�Ç È_���ÇbçHÐ_Ã�ô�Çã ä ; À�â_ÒRÃ�ÀÅ��A�)�â_×�×Õ Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���_â/ÕHÃ�×_×FcØæÑ�_�yÅ�ÅqÝÞ ß_ß äÇ_ÀAÐÃ��yÅ�ÇÓÏ4ÚëÃ�Å �bÛ"�A���_�A� Î À�Ò�Ú�Ï��qÐ�Òã Î Ç âAÀ��yÅ Ç�Ï��qÐ�Òqã�ä ; À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A���â�æ�ÔHã Î Ç âAÀ)�yÅ�ÇyÝáÇ�ÈA���ÇçHÏ)�qÐ�Òqã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���âçpÀ �_�bÔHÀ(Õ Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���â}Õ�Ç)ÈA����Ç¢çLÐÃ4ô_Çã)ä ; À â�ÒRÃ)À�Å?�A�)�_â_×_×Õ Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â/ÕLÃ�×_×RÝëê

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßN� oqGeK3>C7C��DF2_>"71]�TWKL<=DW9�KL<=5I]^23A�<=5IZ�2&T17JTWKlk3Gh.\;\<�0@>:KL.\GN>JX^GhTW>C2&<�¿ÀDh23<_7J;\<4A�GN>WÁ

Page 24: Branch and Bound

�~�t6 �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

ã Î Ç âAÀ��qÅ�Ç=¿:Ã��_ð�_�RÃ4ÒRÃ)���qÀÅ�å�qÐ4Ò�æÔ`ã Î Ç âÀ��yÅ�ÇyÝ=Ç ÈA���_Ç¢çZ¿:Ã��_ð�_�RÃ4ÒRÃ)���AÀ_Å å_�qÐ�Ò}çHÐt�_�_Ò_â_ÀqÏ�ÒÔ�Ï��qÐ�ÒAã ä*:9Ã��qã)�Ò_÷� ÄÇ(Õ Î À â�ÒRÃ)À_Å?�_���_âÕ�Ç ÈA� �Ç¢çHÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã4ÀÅ�����_â× ×RÝdêã Î Ç âAÀ��qÅ�ÇÑÅ�Ç_ÀAÐ�Òå�qÐ4Ò ; �qÐ_Ð_Ã��yÅ ÇáæÔ`ã Î Ç âAÀ��yÅ ÇyÝ�Ï��AÐ�Òqã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A���â¢çpÀ ���bÔT¿:Ã��ð� �RÃ�Ò9Ã4���qÀ�Å å_�qÐ4ÒRÝñêÃ4äÖÔFÏ��qÐ�Òqã�äb(qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���âAí���îAÀ â�æ_æÑ�_�yÅ�Å��5�Å�Ç_ÀqÐ4Òå�qÐ�Ò ; �qÐ_ÐÃt�yÅ�ÇwçLÏ)�4¿ Î À âÇ?�A�.Ô�Ï��qÐ4ÒAã ä?(qÇÐ�Ò5�_���_âAí � îAÀ)â9Ý1û�ïyÝÞ ß_ß Ð4�_�Ò_âÇ_Çx¿9À ÜÑÚqÀ ÆǪ�AÇ Ò_ÒAÇ â�Å Ç_À�äwÛ Î �ÒÓâA��� Ò�Ã��Ñ¿ñÃ��ÓÚqÇ_À Î6AÇ_À Î È���Ç�ÚÈ���ÇÑæÓ�AÇ�Ù6AÇ_À Î È���Ç?ÔtÝdêÚÈA���Çwç Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�_â�æÓ�qÇ)ÙøÃt�Ò ÕT�A×wêä� âÖÔtÃ��Ò.-Óæöïbê -õûª�(ê0-�ú_úyÝÚ_ÈA���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A����â/Õ2- ×�æ Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?����â/ÕB- ×wêÚÈA���Çwç Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�_â/Õ�Ç)ÈA� �_Ç¢çLÐÃ�ôÇ_ã�ä ; À â Ò9Ã)À�Å?�����âàúøé�×�æÎ À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â/ÕLÃ�×wêÚÈA���Çwç Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�_â/ÕHÃ�×áæ

Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/Õ�Ç È���_Ç¢çKÐÃ4ô_Çã�ä ; À â_ÒyÃ)À_Å?�_���â�úøé�×wêÚÈA���ÇwçHÏ��qÐ�ÒAã ä ; À â�ÒRÃ)ÀÅ��A�)�_â�æzÏ��qÐ4Òqã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���âbêÚÈA���ÇwçHÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â�ÒRÃ)ÀÅ��A�)�_â�æ�Ç ÈA� �Ç¢çHÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã4ÀÅ��A�)�_âúøéëêÚÈA���ÇwçKÅ���ÙqÇ�âå�qÐ�Ò�æöÅ�Ç_ÀqÐ�Ò_å�qÐ�Ò ; �qÐ_ÐÃ��AÅ�ÇbêÚÈA���ÇwçZ¿:Ã��ð_�_�RÃ4Ò9Ã��)�qÀÅ)å�AÐ4Ò�æ�¿:Ã��_ð�_�RÃ4ÒRÃ)���qÀÅ�å�qÐ�ÒbêÅqÃ4ÆAÇ È���Çb:9Ãt�m6AÇ_À Î ç Î �Ò?ÔpÚ_È���_ÇyÝëêýýýß_ß ÄAÇ ÒÓ�qÇ Á_ÒÑ÷Aè)�q���ÇÇ ÈA� �ÇÑæ�Ôd6Ç_À Î ÈA� �ÇyÝ�ÅqÃ�ÆAÇ ÈA���_Çb:9Ã��m6Ç_À Î ç âAÇ�¿9�)ÆAÇ?:RÃ��wÔtÝëêýÃ�äùÔ�Ï��AÐ�Òqã äb(AÇqÐ�Ò5�A�)�âAí_�)îAÀ â�æ_æª�_�yÅ_ÅAÝâAÇ Ò �â��Ó�_�yÅ_Å.ê ß_ß �A�ÓâA�)�ÒAÇß_ß Ï�� Î ÜÓ�AÇqÐ�ÒÓâA���ÒÇzÃt�ÒA�à�qÇqÐ�Ò*�A���â/Õ`é'E �A×ä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò�Ãàæ�ïbê=ÃÑûà�(ê=Ã�ú_úRÝ�qÇqÐ4Ò5�A���â}ÕHÃxúøé�×�æ Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?����â/ÕHÃ4×wêâAÇ Ò �â��zÏ��qÐ4Òqã äb(qÇAÐ�Ò5�A���_âAí_��îÀ�â¢êý

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßf� o�GNK3>C7C��DF2_>"71]�TWKL<=DW9IKL<=5I]g2&A�<=5�Z�23T�7JTWKlk3GN./;\<�0@>JK3./Ge>CX^GhTW>C2&<,¿ÀDh23<=Dh./Ag56GN5=Á

Page 25: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �,��sw19�Gt]g2656cE23ZP7J9�G8Ù_Ú9Ã�Å�Çn.\2423Xs;V>�>CX�.\;/7x;\<&7:2j7"��2YDNK3>JGN>NOyw19�G$�=TW>"7�;\>mZ�23T1»{��<�2656GN>m�p;�7:9ÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?��)�â8�à�yè*/gO�-�7{7J9�;V>y7J;\?HG17J9�G[»z��<=245�Gx;V>y7J9�G1X=K3TJGN<_7f23Z^K�>J;/<�0&./G�.\GNKUZ"Oy¹�Z

7:9�;\>x.\GNKUZ�5�GF�=<�Ge>1KnZ�GNK&>C;\]�.\G[7:23A�T�KL<=5E;/Zq7:9�G$7:23A�T1DF2_>"7�;\>x.\GN>:>z7:9=KL<E7:9=KU712LZP7:9�G$]^GN>C7�7J23A=TZ�2&A�<=5E>J2�ZÀKLTedL7J9=G$.\GNKUZP;V>z;\<=>JGhTJ7JGN5@;\<_7J2n7:9�G$?H;\<E9�GNK3XqO ì 7:9�GhT:�p;V>CG&dL7J9=G$.\GNKUZP;V>m56;V>:DhKLTW56Ge5PdK3<=5���G�?H2Uk3G�23<I7J2@7J9=Gn<�GF¼47$»{��<�2656G&O-[.\.3237J9�GNT�»{��<�2656Ge>^ZÀKL.\.3;\<&7:217J9�Gx>CGeDF23<g5�DNK3>JGf9=KL<=5�./Ge5�;/<�7:9�G{]g2656c�2LZ_7J9=GbÙ_Ú9Ã�Å�ÇgO ò 2U�

��G[03GN<�GhTWKU7:GpGNK&DW9sDW9�;/.V5E23ZP7J9�G�»{��<�2656G3O � ;\<=DFG$7J9�G�»{��<�2656G[T:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7W>f7J9�G$Z�GNK&>C;\]�.\G$X=KL7J9Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/Õ�ï�ELÐ_Ã�ôÇ�ã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã4ÀÅ�����_â×=d�7J9=G8Z�GNK3>J;\]�./GRDW9�;\.V56TJGN<�KLT:G,7:9�2&>JG8Z�23T��p9�;VDW9Ô Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?����â/ÕLÐ�×bÛ Î À)â_ÒRÃ�À_Å?�A���â}ÕLÃ�×yÝq;V>qKL<nGe5603Gf2LZ47:9�Gm56;\03TWKLX�9�KL<g5 Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���_â/ÕHÃ�×;V>@23<�GS2LZ Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A���â}ÕLÐÃ�ôÇ_ã�ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�À_Å?�_���â_ú9é8E �AèRé�×gO b 2&THGNK3DW9�Z�GNK3>J;\]�./G�DW9�;\.V5Pdm��GDh23?HX�A67:GY7:9�GEDF2_>"7�Ï��qÐ4Òqã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���_âE2LZm7:9�GEX�T:GF��¼M¿ Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â/ÕØï�EHÐÃ�ô�Çã ä ; À�âqèÒ9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â×gd Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?�A�)�â/ÕHÃ�×4ÁP]_cEK&5�56;\<�0n7J9=GtDF2_>"7x2LZP7J9=G$GN5�03G�Ô Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?����â/ÕLÐ_Ã�ô_Çèã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ��A���â×bÛ Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A���â}ÕHÃ�×RÝH7J2xÇ È���Ç¢çHÏ)�qÐ�Òqã ä ; À â_ÒyÃ)ÀÅ���)�âgO � ;/<gDFG�Ghk&GhT:c7:23A�T17:9=KU7$9gK3>�7J9=;\>$X�TJGh��¼�?YA=>"7�KL.V>C2EDF2&<_7:KL;\<�KL<�GN560&G�7J9=KL7[./GeKlk3Ge>1GNK3DW9S2LZy7J9=GjTJGN?EKL;\<6�;\<�0Hk3GNTC7:;\DhGN>Nd�<�2E.\GNKUZ{DhK3<I9gKlk3GnKEDF2_>"7[.\GN>:>�7J9=K3<=Ï��AÐ�ÒA��ä ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?�A�)�_âBX�./Ag>17J9�Gj>JA�? 2LZ7:9�GEDF2&>C7:>�23Zm7J9=GHDW9=GNKLX^GN>C7�GN560&GY7:9=KU7n.\GNKlk&GN>tGNK3DW9�2LZx7J9�GHT:Gh?EKL;\<�;\<�0Ik&GhTJ7J;VDFGe>hOYQ�GHA=>JG7:9�;\>m]g2&A�<=5EK&>{7J9=G[kUKL.\A�G[2LZ:Å���ÙqÇ�âå�qÐ�Òn2LZa7J9�GtDW9�;/.V5H03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5POyQ�G$K35�5@7:9�;V>z<�GN� DW9�;/.V57:2j7J9=G�.\;\k3G$<=245�Gt.\;\>C7n¿�;�O G&O/d47:9�Gt?H;\<�9�GeKLXgÁm;/Z�;�7W>&Å��)ÙqÇ âå�AÐ�Òj;V>x./Ge>J>x7J9gKL<s7:9�G�DF2&>C7x23Zq7J9=G]^GN>C7p7J2&A�T1Z�23A�<g5S>J2@ZÀKLTeO¹�Z�7:9�Gx56;\03TWKLX=9jDF23<_7WKL;\<=>q<�2$7J2&A�TNdUîmTJ2&03TWKL?¶}&}6O � TJGh7JA�T:<=>q7J9�G�kUKL.\A�Gw�_�yÅ_Å�O ì 7:9�GhT:�p;V>CG&d

;/7$T:GF7JA=TJ<=>[7J9�G@DF2_>"7$23Zf7J9�GY23X67:;/?EKL.�7J2&A�TNOpw19�GYk3GNTC7:GF¼S>JGN�_A�GN<=DFGYDF23T:T:GN>JXg2&<=56;\<�0@7J2E7:9�;\>7:23A�Tp;V>1TJGh7JA�T:<�Ge5�;\<S7J9�GjK3TJTWKlc2�AÇqÐ�Ò5�A�)�âaO�w���c�/�o� �  w¤?¨q« �r¦d¨�[�t§£¤:£A¥p ¢¡

� _¡ w19�G�>J23.\A67J;\23<M>JX=K&DFGIZ�23TY7J9�G�]^2&KLTW54��XgGNTJ?YA67:KL7J;\23<�X=TJ2&]�./GN? ¿ � GeD½7J;\23<�}6~&O }�O �&Á�;V>@K�X^GhTJ�

?YA67:KL7J;\23<�7JT:GhG3O@Q�GsDhKL<�X^GhTJZ�23T:?ÙKS./GeK3>C7C��DF2&>C7�]�T:K3<=DW96��KL<=56��]^23A�<g5r>CGeKLTWDW9,23Zm7J9=;\>�7:TJGNG7:2s�=<=5,Ks.\GNK3>C7C��56GN<=>C;/7"cS]g2_KLTW5�KLT:T:K3<�03GN?@GN<_7NO[Q�GBA=>JGYK�?H;/<6��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c��&A=GhA�G&d^GeK3DW9�GN./Gh�?HGh<_7p2LZf�p9�;VDW9IT:GhX=TJGe>CGN<&7W>1KY.\;\k3G�<�2656GjKL<g5�;V>p2LZi7"c4XgG¢6AÇ_À Î ÈA���ÇgO�»mK&DW9I2&]7"GNDF7123Z�7"c4X^G6AÇ_À Î ÈA���Çs9gK3>�7J9=GH�=Gh.V5�> Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ�¿ÀKS]^2&KLTW5�XgGNTJ?YA67:KL7J;\23<gÁF{¢ÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�¿�]^2&K3T:5=>Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ¢ÕFé8EHÐÃ�ôÇ_ã�ä ; À)â_ÒRÃ�À_Å ×sKLT:GY��¼6GN5�;/<RX^2&>J;/7J;\23<=>H~@7J9=TJ2&A�039àÐÃ�ô_Çã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�d=TJGh�>JXgGeD½7:;/k&Gh.\c6ÁF{ Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò_ÜE¿À5�Gh<=>J;�7"c�2LZ�7:9�G�]g2_KLTW5sKLT:TWKL<�0&Gh?HGh<_7 Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ¢ÕFé'ELÐÃ�ôÇèã ä ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�×^d&;/<=Dh./Ag56;/<=0E�p;/T:GN>10&23;\<�0@7J2H7J9=GnTJ;\039_7p2LZ Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅwÕLÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â Ò9Ã�À_Å ×4Á`{3K3<=5�q�_À â_�yÐò�� ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å�ìëÃ4Ò�ÚÈÇ�Òs¿��q��À â�yÐòt� ; À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ)ìRÃ4Ò�Ú_ÈÇ�Ò/ÕB-�×�;V>�7J9�Gn<4A�?Y]gGNTp2LZy]g2_KLTW5�>;\< Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ¢ÕFé8EHÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À�â_ÒRÃ)À�Å ×Y7J9=KL7jDF23<_7WKL;\<,<�Gh7�-4ÁFO ò 2656Ge>�KLT:GYT:Gh?H2Uk3Ge5�Z�T:23? 7J9=G?H;\<�9=GNKLX8;\<RK3>:DFGh<g56;/<=0S2&T:5�GhTn2LZ�7J9=Gh;\T Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò_ÜIklK3./A=G3O�îmTJ2&03TWKL?Ï}3}�O uS03;\k3Ge>7:9�Gn]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5�Dh245�G3OîzT:230&T:K3? }&}6O u,;\<�;/7J;VKL.\;/vNGN>@7:9�G�»{��<�2656G�7:28]gG�7:9�GS7JT:GhG�TJ24237NO ò 28]g2_KLTW5�9=K&>Y]^GhGN<

X�.VK3DhGN5YKU7y7J9�;V>f<�2656G3Ofw19�GNTJGhZ�23T:G3d�ÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å���ð�d Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?£Ç��9ÐÃ4Ò�Ü8��ð�d4�q�_À�â�yÐ èò�� ; À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�ìëÃ4Ò�ÚÈÇ�Ò/ÕHÃ�×E�ïðnZ�23T$~¢�öä�à����¿q�qÇ âAã äb(q�_À�â�yÐ6deK3<=5 Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ¢Õ`é'E �_��¿A�qÇ�âqèã äb(q��À â�yÐr;\>IKL<4cMX^GhT:?BA�7:KU7:;/2&<�2LZ�7J9=G,<4A�?B]^GhTW>�~�7:9�T:23A�0&9ª����¿q�qÇ âAã äb(q�_À�â�yÐ6O�w19�GK3TJTWKlcm�q�_À â_�yÐ4ìëÃ4Ò ÚÈAÇ ÒE;\>�;\<�;/7J;VKL.\;/vNGN5,>JA=DW9,7J9=KL78�q�_À â_�yÐ4ìëÃ4Ò ÚÈAÇ Ò/ÕLÃ�×@;V>$7:9�G@<_A=?B]^GhT�2LZ]^2&K3T:5�>n7J9=KL7@DF2&<_7:KL;\<8<�GF7"Ã4Orw19�G�]^GN>C7Y]^2&K3T:5�X^GhT:?BA67WKU7J;\23<�Z�23A�<=5R>J2�ZÀK3TB;V>B>:Klk3GN5�;\<7:9�GIK3TJTWKlc��qÇqÐ�Ò ; Ç â)¿q�_ÒAÀ Ò9Ã)�)�Aí_� î_À â^daK3<=587:9�GI56GN<=>J;�7"c8;V>Y>:Klk3Ge58;/<àÅ�Ç_ÀqÐ�Ò*£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò_ÜAí_�è

Page 26: Branch and Bound

�~��� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡

ßG*G Å Ç_ÀqÐ�ÒqèÏ��qÐ�Òà�_âAÀ��9Ï4Úqè�À��A�Aè��q���_�_�ÓÏ�� �ÇGLH Î À âAÀ4¿��A�_À â�/è?£Ñ�q��À â��À â_âAÀ�ÜGLH âAÇ Ò��â ���Ç��9ÐÃ�Ò_Ü���äª�qÇqÐ�Ò�À â�âAÀ��ÄAÇ�¿9Ç��Ò G

ßÎ ���yÅqÃ�ÏÑÐ�ÒÀ Ò9Ã�ÏÓÃ��_ÒöÅ Ç_ÀqÐ�Òå_�qÐ�Ò*(5(*(q�_À â�qÐdÔtÃ���Ò�ÕØ×}ÕØת�q�_À�â�wÛ>Ã��ÒÓ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä ÈAÇ ÒRÐ:ÛÃt�Ò ÕØ×Ó�AÇqÐ�Ò ; Ç�â)¿q�ÒAÀ�Ò9Ã)���ëÝÞ Ã��ÒÑ�_�)¿q�qÇ âqã�äb(q�_À â_�yÐ=æÑ�q�_À�â�(çKÅ�Ç)�Ä_Ò�ÚÓè·éëê:9Ã��56AÇ_À Î ÅAÃ4ÆAÇ ÈA� �Çb:9Ã��56AÇ_À Î æÓ�AÇ�Ù:9Ã��m6AÇ�À Î ÔtÝñêß_ß Ã��ëÃ�Ò9Ã)ÀÅqÃ4ôÇàäRÃ4âyÐ�ÒÑ÷qè)�q� �Ç�Ô Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?£Ç��9ÐÃ4Ò�Ü¢Ûß_ß �q�_À�â�yÐò�� ; À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ)ìëÃtÒ�ÚÈÇ�ÒwÛ�ÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?Û Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅqÝ6AÇ_À Î ÈA���ÇàÇ ÈA���ǪæÓ�qÇ�Ù6AÇ_À Î ÈA���Ç.ÔHïbÛ-�AÇ�Ù·Ã��Ò ÕT�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä�ÈÇ ÒRÐ1ú é�×bÛïbÛr�AÇ�Ù·Ã��Ò ÕT�_��¿q�AÇ âqã äb(A�_À â�yÐ>úøé�×RÝñêß_ß Ð�Ç ÒõÇ ÈA� �Ç¢ç �q��À â�yÐòt� ; À�â�ÒRÃ)À�Å)ìëÃ�Ò Ú_ÈAÇ Ò(ÕHÃ4×�æÑ�_��¿q�qÇ�â���äÓ�A�_À â�yÐß_ß Ã�� Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ¢ÕFé8EHÐ)×�Ù9Ã4Ò�ÚÓ�qÇ Ò�Ãß_ß Ð�Ç ÒõÇ ÈA� �Ç¢ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅwÕHÃ�×áæ·ÃdÛxÃ��9Ã4Ò9Ã)ÀÅ Î Ç â)¿q�_ÒAÀ Ò9Ã)�)�ß_ß Ð�Ç ÒõÇ ÈA� �Ç¢ç �q��À â�yÐ4ì9Ã4Ò�Ú_ÈÇ�Ò/ÕKÃ�×áæÓ�_�)¿q�qÇ â���äª�q�_À�â�yÐxÙëÃ4Ò Ú��AÇ ÒøÃÃ��Ò ÕØ×Ñ�q�_À�â�yÐ4ìëÃ�Ò�ÚÈAÇ Ò�æÑ�qÇ�Ù·Ã��Ò ÕT�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä ÈAÇ ÒRÐ1ú ét×wêä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò�Ãàæøéëê=ÃÑû æÑ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä?(q�_À â�qÐ:ê"Ã�ú_úRÝÞ Ç ÈA� �Ç¢ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅwÕHÃ�×áæøÃñêä� â�ÔtÃ��_Ò�-ÓæøéëêA-�û æÑ�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä�ÈÇ ÒRÐ:êg-�ú_úRÝ�q�_À â_�yÐ4ìëÃ4Ò ÚÈAÇ Ò/Õ2-�×áú_æÓ�A�_À â�}ÕLÃ�×}ÕB-�×bêý

Ã��ÒõÅ�Ç�ÀqÐ�Ò5£AÇ)�9ÐÃ4Ò_Üí_� îAÀ)âàæÑ�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä�ÈÇ ÒRÐ1úÿéëêÃ��Ò ÕØ×Ñ�qÇqÐ4Ò ; Ç â)¿A�ÒAÀ Ò9Ã����qí���îÀ â�æÑ�_�yÅ_Å?ê��Þ ß_ß Ç Á Î À��A�ª÷qè��q���ÇÃ�äÖÔHÇ ÈA� �Ç¢çHÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À â_ÒRÃ�À_Å=æ_æÑ�_��¿q�qÇ�âqã äb(q��À â�yÐxè·é�ÝÞ ß_ß ���qÇõÏ4Ú9Ã�Å �����yÅ�ÜÃ��ÒöÅ��qÏ�À_Å?£AÇ��9Ð_Ã4Ò_Ü_ð_Ò_Â_ÀqÐ�Ò*(q��À�â_��æõïbêä� â�ÔtÃ��Ò-�æ é9êA-�û æª�_��¿q�AÇ âqã ä�ÈÇ ÒRÐ:ê)-�ú_úRÝÅ��qÏ�ÀÅ�£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò_Ü_ð_ÒÂ_ÀAÐ�Ò?(q�_À�â_��ú�æ�q�_À�â�}Õ�Ç È���Ç¢ç Î À â_ÒRÃ�À_Å¢ÕT� ��¿A�AÇ âAã ä�(q��À�â�qÐ)× ×}ÕB-�×wê

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßf¥ oqGNK&>"7J��Dh2&>C7�]=T:K3<=DW9�K3<=5,]^23A=<=5rZ�2&T�7J9�GH]^2&K3T:54��X^GhT:?BA67WKU7J;\23<,X�TJ2&]�.\Gh?¿ÀDh23<_7J;\<4A�GN>WÁ

Page 27: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �,�e�

Ã4ä�Ô`Å �qÏ�ÀÅ?£Ç��9ÐÃ4Ò�Ü_ð_Ò_Â_ÀqÐ4Ò*(�_À â��àû�Å�Ç_ÀAÐ�Ò5£AÇ��RÐÃ4Ò_ÜAí�� îAÀ âyÝÞ ß_ß �qÇ Ò_ÒAÇ�â Î Ç â)¿q�_ÒAÀ Ò9Ã)�)��qÇAÐ�Ò ; Ç â�¿q�ÒAÀ ÒRÃ)���Aí�� îÀ â�æ�Ç ÈA���_Ç¢ç Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?êÅ�Ç�ÀqÐ�Ò5£AÇ)�9ÐÃ4Ò_Üí_� îÀ�â�æ�:AÀ Ò Ú/çZ¿9À ÁbÔ`Å��qÏ�À_Å?£AÇ��yÐÃ�Ò_Ü�ð�ÒÂ�ÀqÐ�Òb(A��À â�?ÛÇ�ÈA���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò�ÜRÝñêýýÇÅAÐ�ÇÞ ß_ß ÄAÇ��qÇ�âAÀ ÒAÇ�Ï4Ú9Ã�Å ��âAÇ)����äÓ÷qè)�q���_Çä_� âÖÔtÃ��Ò�Ã�æõÇ È���Ç¢çHÐ_Ã�ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã4ÀÅ=ú é9êÃÑû�æÓ�_�)¿q�qÇ âqã�äb(q�_À â_�yÐ:ê"Ã�ú_úRÝÞ 6AÇ�À Î ÈA���_Ç�ÚÈA���_Ǫæ��qÇ�Ù6AÇ�À Î ÈA���_Ç?ÔHïbÛ��qÇ�Ù·Ã��ÒÕT����¿q�qÇ âAã ä�ÈAÇ ÒyÐxúøé�×wÛ�ïbÛ"�qÇ�Ù·Ã��Ò ÕT�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä?(q�_À â�qÐ1úøé�×RÝdêä��â�Ô�Ã��Ò.-�æøéëê0-õû�æÓ�_�)¿q�qÇ âqã�ä�ÈAÇ ÒRÐñê)-�ú�úRÝß_ß ÀqÏ_Ï�Ï����_�Òªä� âÓ�qÇ ÒRÐ�Ã��Ó�qÇ�Ù��q�_À�â�ÚÈ���Ç¢ç �A�_À â�yÐ_ò�� ; À â Ò9Ã)À�Å)ì9Ã4Ò�ÚÈAÇ)Ò/Õ2-�×áæÇ�ÈA���Ç¢çT�q�_À â�qÐò�� ; À â�Ò9Ã�À_Å)ìRÃ4Ò�Ú_ÈÇ�Ò/ÕB-�×úÑ�q�_À�â�}Õ�Ç È���Ç¢ç Î À â�Ò9Ã�À_Å¢ÕKÃ�×_×(Õ2- ×wêÃ��_ÒöÅ �qÏ�ÀÅ?£Ç��9ÐÃ4Ò�Ü_ð_Ò_ÈAÇ�Ù5(q� À â_�áæöï?êä��â�Ô�Ã��Ò.-�æøéëê0-õû�æÓ�_�)¿q�qÇ âqã�ä�ÈAÇ ÒRÐñê)-�ú�úRÝÃ�äÖÔpÚÈ���Ç¢ç �A�_À â�yÐ_ò�� ; À)â_ÒRÃ)À�Å)ìëÃtÒ�Ú_ÈAÇ�Ò}ÕB-�×àþ�ï 4*4�q�_À â�qÐ4ìëÃ4Ò�Ú_ÈAÇ Ò/ÕB-�צc æÑÚ_ÈA���Ç¢çT�q�_À â�qÐò�� ; À�â�Ò9Ã4ÀÅ)ì9Ã�Ò ÚÈAÇ)Ò/Õ2- ×yÝÅ��qÏ)ÀÅ?£AÇ��RÐÃ4Ò_Ü_ð�Ò_ÈAÇ�Ùb(q��À â��_ú_ú?êÚÈ���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?£AÇ)�RÐÃ�Ò_Ü�æ�:AÀ Ò�Ú}çZ¿9À ÁwÔHÅ��qÏ�ÀÅ�£AÇ)�9Ð_Ã�Ò_Ü ð_Ò_ÈÇ)Ù*(q�_À)â�bÛÇ�ÈA���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?£AÇ��RÐ_Ã4Ò_ÜyÝñêÃ�äùÔpÚ_ÈA���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?£AÇ��yÐÃ4Ò Üªû�Å�Ç_ÀAÐ�Ò5£AÇ��RÐÃ4Ò_ÜAí�� îAÀ âyÝÞ ß�ß ¿RÀ ÜõÅ�Ç_À��ÑÒA�ª�qÇ Ò_ÒÇ â�Å�Ç_À�äÚÈ���Ç¢çHÐ_Ã�ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã4ÀÅ=æõÇ�ÈA���Ç¢çLÐÃ�ôÇã�ä ; À â_ÒRÃ�ÀÅ=úøéëêä��â ÔtÃt�Ò.-�æøéëê0-õû æÑ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä?(q�_À â�qÐ:ê1-�ú_úRÝÚÈA� �Ç¢ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅwÕB-�×áæõÇ�ÈA���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ¢ÕB-�×bêÚÈ���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å¢ÕTÚÈA���Ç¢çKÐÃ4ôÇ�ã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã�À_Å ×áæ�Ç ÈA���Çwç Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ¢ÕHÃ4×bêÚÈ���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å¢ÕHÃ�×áæöÇ�ÈA���Ç¢ç Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ¢ÕTÚ�ÈA� �ÇwçLÐÃ�ôÇã�ä ; À â_ÒyÃ)À_Å�×bêÅqÃ�ÆAÇ ÈA���_Çb:9Ã��m6Ç_À Î ç Î �ÒwÔØÚÈ����ÇyÝñêýýý

Ö�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û ÞgÞqßN¥ oqGeK3>C7C��DF2_>"7�]�T:K3<=DW9�K3<=5�]g2&A�<=5�Z�23T�7J9=GE]g2_KLTW54��X^GhT:?BA�7:KU7:;/2&<rX�T:23]�.\Gh?¿�DF23<_7:;/<4A�Ge>:Á

Page 28: Branch and Bound

�~�e� �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡ß_ß �qÇ Á_ÒÓ÷qè��q���ÇÇ ÈA� �ÇÑæ�Ôd6Ç_À Î ÈA� �ÇyÝ�ÅqÃ�ÆAÇ ÈA���_Çb:9Ã��m6Ç_À Î ç âAÇ�¿9�)ÆAÇ?:RÃ��wÔtÝëêý Ù_ÚëÃ�Å�Ç�ÔLÇ ÈA���Ç�c æÓ�_�qÅ_Å 454Ç ÈA���Çwç Î À â_ÒRÃ)ÀÅ?£AÇ)�RÐÃtÒ_Üàû�Å�Ç�ÀqÐ�Ò5£AÇ)�9ÐÃ4Ò_Üí_� îAÀ âyÝñê

ä� âÖÔtÃt�Ò�Ãàæøéëê=ÃÑû æÑ�_��¿A�qÇ âqã ä?(q�_À â�qÐ:ê"Ã�ú_úRÝ�qÇqÐ4Ò ; Ç â)¿A�ÒAÀ Ò9Ã�����ÕHÃ�×�æÑ�qÇqÐ�Ò ; Ç â)¿q�_ÒAÀ Ò9Ã)�)�qí�� î_À â}ÕLÃ�×bêâAÇ Ò �â��õÅ�Ç_ÀAÐ�Ò5£AÇ��RÐÃ4Ò_ÜAí�� îAÀ�âwêýÖ�¯U· ñ ¯U°�Û Þ^ÞPßf¥ oqGNK&>"7J��Dh2&>C7�]=T:K3<=DW9�K3<=5,]^23A=<=5rZ�2&T�7J9�GH]^2&K3T:54��X^GhT:?BA67WKU7J;\23<,X�TJ2&]�.\Gh?¿ÀDh23<=Dh./A=5�GN5=Á

îAÀ�âaO�-ù��è)Ù�ÚëÃ�Å�ÇS./242&X�Gh¼�KL?H;/<=GN>n7:9�G�»z��<�2656Ge>j2&<�GsKU7YK�7J;\?@G&Or-�7B7:9�GsGh<g5R2LZpGNK&DW9;�7:GhTWKU7:;/2&<�2LZ�7J9�;V>1./242&Xqd_7J9�G�<�Gh¼_7[»z��<�2656G�;V>�>JGh.\GNDF7JGe5s]4csGF¼47:T:K&D½7J;\<�0gd3Z�T:23?Ã7:9�G�?@;\<S9�GNK3X2LZ�./;\k3GH<�2656Ge>hd�KS<�2656GH�p;/7J98.\GNK3>C7 Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò_ÜaO�¹�Zx7:9�;\>j<�2656G�$ > Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò_ÜkUKL.\A�Gj;V>�§�Å Ç_ÀqÐ�Ò5£Ç��9ÐÃ4Ò�ÜAí_� îAÀ�â^dL7:9�Gh<�<=23<�Gj23Zf7J9�GjT:Gh?EK3;/<�;\<�0E.\;/k&Gj<�2656Ge>$DhK3<�./GeK35S7J2]g2_KLTW5SXgGNTJ?YA67:KL7J;\23<=>1�p;/7J9r56GN<=>J;�7"cS./Ge>J>p7J9=K3<�Å�Ç_ÀqÐ�Ò*£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò_ÜAí_� îÀ âBK3<=5I7J9�GYKL.\0323T:;/7J9�?7JGNTJ?H;\<=KU7:GN>NOw19�G ��è�Ù_ÚëÃ�Å�Ç�.\2423XRDF2&<=>J;\56GNT:>�7"��2�DhK&>CGe>�Z�23Tn7:9�G�»{��<�2656G&O�w19�GH�=TW>"7BK3TJ;V>JGN>��p9�GN<ÐÃ4ôÇã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å=� �_��¿q�qÇ�âqã äb(q��À â�yÐ èqé&O -�7I7:9�;\>I7:;/?HG>����¿q�qÇ âAã äb(q�_À�â�yÐ èRés]^2&K3T:5�>

9=Klk3G�]^GhGh<�X�.VK3DhGN5PdgKL<=5�7J9�GY»{��<�2656Gt;V>17:9�GnX=KLT:Gh<_7p2LZ{K@./GeKUZy2LZy7J9�Gj>J23.\A67J;\23<�>JX=K3DhGt7:TJGNG3Ow19�GsX^GhT:?BA67WKU7:;/2&<�DF23T:T:GN>JXg2&<=56;\<�0S7J2�7:9�;\>B./GeKUZp;V> Î À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ=Os¹�7:>Y56Gh<=>J;/7"c�;V>BDh23?HX�A67:GN5PdKL<=5�Å�Ç_ÀAÐ�Ò5£AÇ��RÐÃ4Ò_ÜAí�� îAÀ âjKL<=5 �qÇqÐ4Ò ; Ç â)¿A�ÒAÀ Ò9Ã����qí_�)îAÀ âjKLT:G�A�X^5=KU7JGe5�;�Zf<�GeDFGN>:>:KLT:c3O¹�< 7J9�G©>CGeDF23<g5�DNK3>JG87J9�G×»{��<�2656GR9=K3>r7"�x2�2&Tr?H23T:G�DW9�;\.\56T:Gh<�O »xK3DW9�DW9�;\.\5öȶ;\>03GN<�GhTWKU7:GN5Pd�KL<=5×7J9=Gr56Gh<=>J;/7"c�È}ç Î À â_Ò9Ã)À_Å?£AÇ��9Ð_Ã4Ò_Ü�2LZ�7J9=GrX=KLTJ7J;VKL.pX^GhT:?BA�7:KU7:;/2&<�¿ Î À�âqèÒ9Ã�ÀÅ¢ÕFé'ELÐÃ�ôÇã�ä ; À â Ò9Ã�ÀÅ�ú9é�×_ÁaDh23T:TJGe>CX^23<g56;/<=0t7:2�7J9�GtDW9�;/.V5H;V>zDF2&?@X=A67JGe5PO{w19�G[DW9�;\.\5�ÈY;\>>JKlk&GN5E;\<I7J9�G�?H;/<���X�T:;\23T:;�7"cs�_A�GNA�G�23<�.\cE;�Z.È}ç Î À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?£AÇ��RÐÃ4Ò_ÜaOöÅ�Ç_ÀAÐ�Ò5£AÇ��RÐÃ4Ò_ÜAí�� îAÀ�â^Oò 237J;VDFGn7:9=KU7$�p9=Gh<�È}ç Î À�â_Ò9Ã)ÀÅ�£AÇ��9ÐÃ�Ò�Ü)§·Å�Ç_ÀqÐ4Ò5£AÇ��9Ð_Ã4Ò_ÜAí_��îAÀ�âad3KL.\.�.\GNKlk&GN>p;\<�;�7W>$>JA�]6�7JT:GhG�9=Klk&Gt56GN<=>C;/7"c0§zÅ Ç_ÀqÐ�Ò5£Ç��9ÐÃ4Ò�ÜAí_� îAÀ)âjK3<=5I5�2@<=2L7pTJGNX�T:GN>JGh<_7x]^2&K3T:5IXgGNTJ?YA67:KL7J;\23<=>]gGh7C7:GhTp7:9=KL<"�qÇqÐ4Ò ; Ç â)¿A�ÒAÀ Ò9Ã����Aí_��îÀ âgO%1�Â%8�z�×�a!�%×!ë�O1¹�<�7:9�GxDh23<_7JGh¼_7q23Z�îzT:2303TWKL?ï}&}6O �=de56GF�=<=Gb�qÇAÐ�Ò�Ù[7:2[]gGz7J9�Gz?EKL¼4;\?BA=?¶23Z_7:9�Gz��Gh;\039_7:>K&>J>J26DF;VKU7JGe5S�p;�7:9�7J9�GjZ�GNK3>J;\]�./GB<�2656GN>$03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5�>C2EZÀK3TNO�0�2656;/Z�c�îzT:2303TWKL? }3}6O �s>J27:9=KU7EK�<�GN� ./;\k3GI<�2656G�;V>YK&5�56Ge587J2�7:9�G�>CA�]g>CGh7B7JT:GhGIKL<=5R?EKL¼89=GNKLXR;/��7J9�GI./;\k3G<�2656G $ >�� Î_Î Ç â�ìAÇyÃ4Ä�ÚÒY;V>p03T:GNKL7JGNT17J9=K3<S2&TpGN�_A=K3.P7J2��qÇqÐ�Ò ÙPO9¨z23A��p;\./.yKL.V>C2H<�GNGN5I7J2K&5�5�DF2656G�7J2E;\<�;/7J;VKL.\;/vNG�K3<=5SA�Xa5�KU7:GE�AÇqÐ�Ò�ÙPO

�=O1Q�TJ;/7JG�K[?EKU¼4��X�T:2L��7q]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�DF2656GmZ�23T�7J9�Gx./2_K356;\<�0pX�T:23]�.\Gh?�dlA=>J;/<=0[23<�.\cK�?EKL¼_��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"cr�_A�GhA=G3O�w19=KU7B;V>Ndy562�<=2L7B?EKL;\<_7:K3;/<�7J9=GsXg2&TC7:;/2&<82LZ�7J9�G�>J23.\A67:;/2&<

Page 29: Branch and Bound

ô �W :�"õö¢N�s�e�U÷ �EËm�_� Ì�õö ½�F�"õö¢e��Í �,�~�>CX=K&DFG�7:TJGNGn03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5�¿�K3>$;\>[5�23<�Gn;\<rîzT:230&T:K3? }3}6O �_ÁFOx»xK3DW9SX�TJ;\23T:;/7"c��_A�GhA�GB<�2656G�p;/.\.q<�2U��DF23<_7WKL;\<�7:9�GnX=KU7:9�7:2H7J9�G�7:TJGNG�TJ242L7eO

��O1Q�T:;�7:GRKM?EKU¼4��X�T:2L��7S]�T:K3<=DW96��KL<=56��]^23A�<g5 DF2656G�Z�23TS7J9=G8ð_�4~�`_<gKLX=>:K3DW`�X�T:23]�.\Gh?A=>C;\<�0823<=./c©K�?EKL¼_��X�T:;/2&TJ;/7"cR�_A�GhA�G&O w19=KU7s;V>Nd�562R<=2L7E?EKL;\<&7WKL;\<M7:9�GrX^23TJ7J;\23<©2LZ7J9�Gj>J23.\A67J;\23<�>JX=K3DhG$7:TJGNG�0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGe5PO{»mK3DW9IX�T:;/2&TJ;/7"cs�_A�GhA�G�<�2656G��p;\./.�<�2U�ïDF2&<_7:KL;\<7J9�GnX=KL7J9S7J2@7:9�G�7JT:GhGnT:242L7NO

v=Oó¿ÀK&ÁI¹�<EîzT:230&T:K3?Â}3}�O � T:;/0&9&7mDW9=;/.V56T:Gh<H�p;�7:9�� Î�Î Ç âAíyÃ4ôÇtkUKL.\A�G¢§��AÇqÐ�Ò��BKLT:G[K35�5�GN57:287J9�Gr?EKL¼×9�GeKLXqO�Q�;/.\.[7:9�GrX�T:230&T:K3? >C7J;\./.t�x2&TJ`MDh23T:TJGeD½7:./c�;/Zn23<�.\cMT:;\039_7DW9�;\.V56TJGN<I�p;/7J9"� Î_Î Ç�âAíyÃ�ôÇg�·Ð_Ã�ôÇã äb:AÀ ÁåAÅAÃ�3 �qÇ_í���îAÀ)âYKLT:G�K&5�56GN5y��Q�94c�

¿�]gÁ"'t24GN>a7:9�GzX�T:230&T:K3? K35�5�.\GFZu7iDW9�;\.V56TJGN<��p;�7:9E� Î_Î Ç âAíqÃ�ôÇ©§�ÐÃ�ôÇã�ä*:AÀ ÁåÅqÃ�3 �qÇ_èí_� îAÀ�â@7:2H7J9�Gn?EKU¼I9�GNK3Xy�¿ÀDNÁ"0�2656;/Z�cI7J9�GjX=TJ2&03TWKL? >J2E7J9gKU7$2&<�./cS<�2656Ge>p�p;�7:9�� Î_Î Ç âAíyÃ�ô_Ǫ� ÐÃ�ô_Çã ä*:AÀ�ÁqèåAÅqÃ�3��qÇ_í_� îÀ â@KLT:G�K&5�56Ge5s7:2Y7:9�Gn?EKU¼S9�GNK3XSK3<=5s7:2H7J9�Gj>J23.\A67:;/2&<S>JX=K3DhGn>CA�]��7:TJGNG�]^Gh;\<�0sDh23<=>C7JT:A=D½7:GN5PO

� O$|x23<=>J;\5�GhT�7J9=G�>CA=]=>CGh7B>CXgK3DFG@7:TJGNGHZ�23T�7J9=Gs?EKU¼4��Dh./;V�_A�GHX�T:23]�.\Gh?�O b 23TjKL<4cr.\Ghk&Gh.§Ã<�2656G3Á�23Zz7J9�GH>JA�]=>JGF7$7:TJGNG3da.\GF7§¿ñÃ��m£AÇ Ä�âAÇ_Ç?ÔKÁRÝn]^GY7J9�G@?H;/<�;\?BA=?ó2LZz7:9�G@5�Gh03T:GhGe>2LZy7J9�Gnk&GhTJ7J;VDFGN>�;\<=DF.\A=56Ge5�KU7§ÁaO¿ÀK&Á � 9=2U��7J9gKU7z<�2n.\GNKLZ^;\<@7J9�G$>JA�]67:TJGNG1�p;�7:9ETJ242L7bÁBDNKL<HT:GhX�T:GN>JGh<_7zK�DF.\;\�_A�Gp23Za>J;/vNG?H23T:Gp7:9=KL<mÁ}ç � Î_Î Ç âAíyÃ�ô_Ç#�ï?H;/<qÁ(çHÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä_åAÅqÃ|3 �qÇ ð_Ò�÷_È����Ç�úÑ�zèzÃ�ú é9Û¿:Ã��m£Ç Ä_âAÇ_Ç.ÔKÁ9Ý>úÿé&O

¿�]gÁ{«pGN�pTJ;/7JG§¿9À Á ; âA��äRÃ4Òb(5(m:AÀ Á_åAÅqÃ|3��AÇ�A=>J;\<�0@7J9�;V>[56Gh�=<�;/7J;\23<�2LZ.Á(ç � Î_Î Ç�âAíyÃ�ôÇ=O¿ÀDNÁ�|x2&?@XgKLT:Gz7J9=GxT:A�<j7:;/?HGe>{K3>i�xGN./.6K3>i7:9�G1<_A=?B]^GhTf2LZg>J23.\A67:;/2&<B>CXgK3DFGx7JT:GhG�<�2656Ge>0&Gh<�GNT:KL7JGN5�]4cs7J9=G�7"�x2@k3GNT:>J;/2&<=>�2LZd¿9À�Á ; âA��äyÃ4Ò*(5(m:À ÁåÅAÃ�3��qÇ�O

� O1Q�T:;�7:GtKn?EKL¼_��X�T:2L��7x]�T:K3<=DW96��KL<=56��]^23A�<g5@Dh2656G[Z�2&Tz7J9=G$?EKU¼4��DF.\;\�_A�G[X=TJ2&]�./GN?�d&A=>J;\<�023<�.\c�K$?EKU¼4��X=TJ;\23T:;�7"ct�&A=GhA�G&Oiw19=KL7i;V>hdU562[<=2L7i?EK3;/<_7:K3;/<�7:9�GmX^23TJ7J;\23<B2LZ47J9�G�>C2&./A�7J;\23<>CX=K&DFG�7:TJGNGn03Gh<=GhTWKU7JGe5PO1»mK3DW9SX�T:;/2&TJ;/7"c��_A�GNA�Gj<�2656Gj�p;\.\.�<�2U� DF2&<&7WKL;\<S7J9�GjXgKU7J9�7:27J9�G�7:TJGNG�T:242L7eO

u=O�0�2656;�Z�c�îzT:230&T:K3? }3}6O � >C2@7:9=KU7$<=245�GN>p�p;/7J9=ÐÃ�ôÇ_ã ä ; À â�Ò9Ã)ÀÅ?��)�â2�z�qè*/HK3TJGn<�237Gh<_7JGNTJGe5�;\<_7J2H7J9=GnX�TJ;\23T:;/7"c��_A�GhA�G&O�«[KU7:9�GhTed47J9=Gj]gGe>"7[X^GhT:?BA�7:KU7:;/2&<�Z�2&A�<=5�>J2HZÀKLTp;V>>JKlk&GN5�;/<�K3<8K3TJTWKlcr�qÇqÐ4Ò ; Ç â)¿A�ÒAÀ Ò9Ã����qí�� ä_À âaOBw19�GsKL.\032&TJ;/7J9=?Ï7JGNTJ?H;\<=KU7:GN>��p9�GN<7J9�Gn<�Gh¼47$»{��<�2656G�9=K3>&Å���ÙqÇ�âå�qÐ�Òª§·Ï)�qÐ�Òqã ä?(qÇqÐ�Ò5����âAí_�)îAÀ âgO

~eð�O�Q�T:;�7:GnKBk&GhTW>C;\23<s23ZiîzT:230&T:K3?Ã}&}6O � ;\<��p9�;VDW9S�xG�A=>JGtX=K3TJGN<_7�X^23;\<_7JGhTW>m7J2@GF¼6X�.\;\Dh;�7:./cTJGh7:KL;\<�7J9�GsX^23TJ7J;\23<�2LZ�7J9=Gs>C2&./A67:;/2&<�>JX=K&DFG@7JT:GhGHGF¼�K3?@;\<�Ge5�]4c�7:9�GsKL.\032&TJ;/7J9=? ¿ÀK&>;/<SîzT:2303TWKL? }3}6O v&ÁzKL<=5H7:9�G�X�TJ;\23T:;/7"c@�_A�GNA�G$GN<&7:TJ;\GN>xDF2&<&7WKL;\<E7J9=G[�=GN.\5�>�Å���ÙAÇ âå�qÐ4ÒadÏ)�qÐ�Òqã ä ; À â_Ò9Ã�ÀÅ?�A���_â^d¿ñÃ��ð�_�yÃ4Ò9Ã)���AÀÅ å�qÐ4Ò^daKL<=5�ÅqÃ4ÆAÇ�ÈA���Ç8¿�X^23;\<_7JGhTB7J2�DF23T:T:GF�>CX^23<=5�;/<�0H<�2656Gn;\<�>C2&./A�7J;\23<�>CX=K&DFG�7JT:GhGlÁx23<�.\c3O

Page 30: Branch and Bound

�~+,+ �y�4�h�&�"�:���e�����C�N�_ C�H�h�4¡H�i¢e£_�_¡~3~&OxQ�TJ;/7JGrK b ¹ byì ]�TWKL<=DW96��KL<g54��]^23A=<=5MDh245�G�Z�23TH7J9=GS]^2&K3T:56��X^GhT:?BA67WKU7:;/2&<MX�T:23]�.\Gh?�O¨z2&A�TxDh245�G[?BA=>C7x2&A67JX=A67m]^2L7J9s7J9�Gt]gGe>"7m]^2&K3T:5EK3TJTWKL<=03Gh?HGN<&7zK3<=5H;�7W>m56GN<=>J;�7"c&O?�t>CG>JA�;/7:KL]=./G�7:GN>C7$5�KU7WKB7:2@7JGN>C7p7J9=GjDF23T:T:GND½7:<�GN>:>�2LZfc32&A�TpDF2656G3O

~e}�OxQ�TJ;/7JGnK b ¹ bfì ]�TWKL<=DW9���K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5sK3./0&23T:;�7:9�? 7J2j�g<=5IKY]^2&KLTW5sK3TJTWKL<�0&Gh?HGh<_7z7:9=KU7?H;\<�;/?H;\vhGe>17J9�Gn.\Gh<=0L7J9�23Zi7:9�Gn./2&<�03Ge>"71<�Gh7B¿À>JGhGj»{¼6GNT:Dh;\>JGY~ � ;/<r|x9=KLX�7JGhT�}6~eÁFO

~Në=O}'t2s»{¼6GhTWDF;V>JGY~l}BAg>C;\<�0EK@./GeK3>C7C��DF2&>C71]�T:K3<=DW9�KL<=5S]^23A�<=5qO~��gOxQ�TJ;/7JGHKI./GeK3>C7C��DF2&>C7$]�TWKL<gDW96��K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�K3./0&23T:;�7:9�? Z�23Tt7J9�G@k3GNTC7:GF¼4��Dh2Uk3GNTpX�TJ2&]�.\Gh?23Zf»z¼4GNT:Dh;\>JG@~ � ;/<,|x9=K3X67JGNT$}6~&O

~���OxQ�TJ;/7JGxKp?EKU¼4��Dh2&>C7P]�T:K3<=DW96��KL<=56��]^23A�<g5tK3./0&23T:;�7:9�?�Z�23T�7J9�Gx>C;\?HX�./G{?EKL¼_��DFA�7qX�TJ2&]�.\Gh?23Zf»z¼4GNT:Dh;\>JG@~tu@;/<,|x9=K3X67JGNT$}6~&O

~tv=OxQ�TJ;/7JG@KE.\GNK3>C7C��DF2_>"7[]=T:K3<=DW96��KL<=54��]^23A�<=5�K3./0&23T:;�7:9�? Z�2&Tp7J9�GY?EK3DW9�;\<�GF��56Ge>C;\03<�X�T:23]6�.\Gh? 2LZ{»{¼6GhTWDF;V>CGn}Lð@;\<�|x9gKLX67:GhT$}6~&O

~ � OxQ�TJ;/7JGHKs.\GNK&>"7J��Dh2&>C7$]�TWKL<=DW9���K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5�KL.\032&TJ;/7J9=? Z�2&T$7:9�GY<=GF7"��23T:`&��56Ge>C;\03<�X�T:23]6�.\Gh? 2LZ{»{¼6GhTWDF;V>CGn}6~�;\<�|x9gKLX67:GhT$}6~&O

~ � OxQ�TJ;/7JGnK b ¹ bfì ]�TWKL<=DW9���K3<=54��]g2&A�<=5sK3./0&23T:;�7:9�?ÂZ�2&T�7J9�G^�a���_A�GNGh<=>C��X�.\K&DFGN?@GN<_7xX�T:23]6�.\Gh? 2LZ{»{¼6GhTWDF;V>CGn}3}Y;\<�|x9gKLX67:GhT$}6~&O

~tu=O}'t2s»{¼6GhTWDF;V>JG�}3ëY;\<,|x9=KLX�7JGhT$}�~$Z�2&T b ¹ byì ]�T:K3<=DW9IK3<=5S]g2&A�<=5PO✭

}Lð=O}'t2s»{¼6GhTWDF;V>JG�})�@;\<,|x9=KLX�7JGhT$}�~$Z�2&T b ¹ byì ]�T:K3<=DW9IK3<=5S]g2&A�<=5PO✭

}6~&O}'t2s»{¼6GhTWDF;V>JG�} �B;\<,|x9=KLX�7JGhT$}�~$Z�2&T b ¹ byì ]�T:K3<=DW9IK3<=5S]g2&A�<=5PO✭

}3}�O}'t2s»{¼6GhTWDF;V>JG�}3ëY;\<,|x9=KLX�7JGhT$}�~$Z�2&Tp./GeK3>C7C��DF2_>"7p]�TWKL<=DW9SKL<=5S]^23A�<g5PO✭

}Lë=O}'t2s»{¼6GhTWDF;V>JG�})�@;\<,|x9=KLX�7JGhT$}�~$Z�2&Tp./GeK3>C7C��DF2_>"7p]�TWKL<=DW9SKL<=5S]^23A�<g5PO✭

}��gO}'t2s»{¼6GhTWDF;V>JG�} �B;\<,|x9=KLX�7JGhT$}�~$Z�2&Tp./GeK3>C7C��DF2_>"7p]�TWKL<=DW9SKL<=5S]^23A�<g5PO✭

}���O}'t2t»z¼4GNT:Dh;\>JGz}���;\<@|x9=K3X67JGNTy}6~fZ�2&T�KLT:]�;/7JTWKLT:c[]�TWKL<=DW9jK3<=5�]^23A�<=5qO b 2&Tq7:9�;\>�GF¼6GhTWDF;V>JG✭ c&23A��p;\./.i<�GhGe5S7J2sX=K&>J>[Z�A�<=DF7J;\23<=>[7J2�K&5�5�./;\k3GB<�2656GN>tKL<=5�>JGh.\GNDF7[7J9�GB<�GF¼47�»z��<=245�G

K&>1X=KLTWKL?HGF7:GhTW>hO


Recommended