Date post: | 26-Jan-2015 |
Category: |
Education |
Upload: | dane-figuracion |
View: | 371 times |
Download: | 6 times |
BRITISH PARLIAMENTARY DEBATE
History
The British Parliamentary debate format differs from many other formats because it involves four teams rather than two.
Debates are presided over by a Speaker, who is often the Chair of the adjudicator panel. The Speaker keeps time and calls debaters to the floor.
Two teams, called the First Proposition and the Second Proposition teams, are charged with the responsibility of supporting the proposition while two other teams, First Opposition and Second Opposition, are charged with opposing it.
The Government supports the motion (the given topic or subject being debated), and the Opposition opposes it.
The teams are also divided into the Opening and Closing halves of the 'House‘
British Parliamentary debate sometimes is referred to as Worlds-style debate or simply four-team debate.
Each team consists of two members with an allotted seven (7) minutes given to each speaker.
Diagram Illustrating the Arrangement of Members in the House and the Sequence in which Speeches are
Delivered
ROLES OF GOVERNMENT/PROPOSITION AND OPPOSITION
Government/PropositionIn supporting the motion, the Government/Proposition carries out the following functions: Defining the motionConstructing a positive case in favor of the
motionProviding substantive materials and
arguments in support of the caseResponding to any challenges made to the
case made by the Opposition.
OppositionIn negating/opposing the motion, the Opposition carries out the following functions:Responding to the Government's definitionConstructing a case in opposition to the
motionProviding substantive material and
arguments in support of the opposition caseResponding to the arguments delivered by
the Government.
Role of the Teams (Overview)
Opening Government:
· Defines the terms of the debate· Opens the case for the Government· Opposes the case of the Opening Opposition when it is presented
Opening Opposition:
· Opposes the case of the Opening Government· Opens the case for the Opposition
Closing Government:
· Extends the Government case· Opposes the cases of the Opening and Closing Opposition teams· Summarizes the debate
Closing Opposition:
· Extends the Opposition case· Opposes the cases of the Opening and Closing Opposition teams· Summarizes the debate
SPEAKER ROLES AND SPEECH SPECIFIC PURPOSES
Prime Minister
The Prime Minister’s responsibilities may include some or all of the following: to offer a reasonable interpretation of
the motionto present a case supporting that
interpretation to employ other strategies deemed
necessary in advancing the Government's stance.
Leader of the Opposition
The Leader of the Opposition’s responsibilities may include some or all of the following:to directly or indirectly refute part or all of
the government's caseto make at least one argument that
demonstrates why the First Opposition team opposes the motion as interpreted by the Prime Minister;
to employ other strategies deemed necessary in advancing the Opposition's stance.
The Leader of the Opposition may also challenge the interpretation of the government's case if it is unreasonable, that is, if it completely misinterprets the motion or severely inhibits meaningful debate.
Deputy Prime Minister
The Deputy Prime Minister’s responsibilities may include some or all of the following:to reestablish the First
Proposition’s case by confronting any refutation presented by the Leader of the Opposition
to refute some or all of the arguments presented by the Leader of the Opposition
to further develop the case presented by the Prime Minister
to employ other strategies deemed necessary in advancing the Government's stance.
Deputy Leader of the Opposition
The Deputy Leader of the Opposition’s responsibilities may include some or all of the following: to continue refutation initiated by
the Leader of the Oppositionto reestablish the Leader of
Opposition’s arguments against the motion
to initiate a new argument against the motion as interpreted by the First Proposition team
to employ other strategies deemed necessary in advancing the Opposition's stance.
Member of the Government The responsibilities of the Member of the Government may include some or all of the following:
to briefly support the case developed by the First Proposition team
to introduce a different argument, sometimes called a “case extension” which is consistent with yet different from the case introduced by the First Proposition team
to employ other strategies deemed necessary in advancing the Government's stance.
Member of the Opposition
The responsibilities of the Member of the Opposition may include some or all of the following:
to briefly support one or more arguments introduced by the First Opposition team
to introduce direct and/or indirect refutation to the case extension presented by the Member of Government
to introduce some new argument, compatible with, but different from that of the First Opposition Team
to employ other strategies deemed necessary in advancing the Opposition's stance.
Government Whip
The responsibilities of the Government Whip may include some or all of the following:
to support any new arguments introduced by the Member of the Government
to reply to any new arguments introduced by the Member of the Opposition
to summarize the debate from the perspective of the Proposition Teams, especially from that of the Second Proposition team
to employ other strategies deemed necessary in advancing the Government's stance.
The Government Whip should not introduce new arguments into the debate.
Opposition Whip
The responsibilities of the Opposition Whip may include some or all of the following: to support any new arguments
introduced by the Member of the Opposition
to reply to any new arguments introduced by the Member of the Government
to summarize the debate from the perspective of the Proposition Teams, especially from that of the Second Opposition team
to employ other strategies deemed necessary in advancing the Opposition's stance.
Points of InformationPOIs shouldn't be given for the sole
purpose of destroying the other team's case. POIs should build your case up as well.
It is always better to get in one or two excellent POIs than four or five mediocre ones.
Speaking StyleThe most important thing is to keep
the audience engaged. Not everyone can be a funny
speaker, and that's okay. Never insult another debater's race,
gender, sexual orientation, or religion. Anything offensive will be penalized.
Definitional Challenges
The only speaker who can object to the OG definition is the LO. If the LO doesn't object, no one else can.
Definitional challenges are exceedingly rare.
The only time you should object to the definition is if it is a truism or tautology.
Knifing
Knifing is when a closing team, or even a partner on the same team,
blatantly disagrees with a fundamental part of the substantive
case that they're supposed to be supporting.
AnalysisTry to introduce facts, case
studies, and philosophical analysis instead of statistics.
Focus on examples.
Stay focused.
Adjudication
The adjudicator has 3 important roles. He or she must:decide the debatemanage the debatejustify the decision
The adjudicator is also not a coach—their primary role is to decide who won and lost the debate in the fairest and most comprehensive manner, and relay that information to the teams.
Adjudicators also have a management role. This includes:inviting speakers to the podiumensuring speakers are provided
with clear time signals
ensuring the ballots are filled in accurately and reach the adjudication team
in extreme situations, adjudicators may need to step in and protect speakers from abuse
Matter and Manner
Matter is the content of your speechMatter Includes:· Substantive arguments for your side· Rebuttal arguments· Case Studies / Facts· POIs
Manner is how you present that content.Manner Includes:· Humor· Appropriate language· Engaging the audience
When judging, matter and manner should be weighted equally.