Date post: | 05-Apr-2018 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | gerry-triaz |
View: | 215 times |
Download: | 0 times |
of 34
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
1/34
Section 7 British Verification Problems
This section includes discussion on the following topics:
British Verification Problem 1
British Verification Problem 2
British Verification Problem 3
British Verification Problem 4
British Verification Problem 5
7.1 British Verification Problem 1
Reference
Reinforced Concrete by T.J.Macgingley & B.S.Choo, Page 333 and Example: 11.1.
Problem
A column 400mm X 400mm carries a dead load of 800 kN and an imposed load of 300 kN. The safe
bearing pressure is 200 kN/m2. Design a square base to resist the loads. The concrete is grade 35 andthe reinforcement is grade 460.
Solution
Figure 7.1
Page 1 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
2/34
Figure 7.2
Figure 7.3
Size of base:
Self-weight of footing = 2.5 x 2.5 x 0.5 x 25 = 78.125 kN.
Therefore, Service load = Dead load + Imposed load + Self weight
= (800 + 300 + 78.125) kN
= 1178.125 kN.
Page 2 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
3/34
Area required = 1178.125 / 200 m2 = 5.890625 m2.
Make the base 2.5 m x 2.5 m.
Moment Steel:
Ultimate load = (1.4 x 800) + (1.6 x 300) = 1600 kN.
Ultimate pressure = 1600 / (2.5 x 2.5) = 256 kNm2
The critical section YY at the column face is shown in Figure 6.1.
MYY= 256 x (2.5 / 2 - 0.4 / 2) x 2.5 x 0.525 = 352.8 kNm.
Try an overall depth of 500 mm with 20 mm bars.
Effective depth = 500 40 20 10 = 430 mm.
Therefore z = 0.95d,
.
= 1976.31 mm2.
Page 3 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
4/34
Minimum area of steel = 0.0015 x B x d = 0.0012 x 2500 x 430 = 1625 mm2 < AS (Hence Safe)
Let us provide 10 nos. 16 mm bars, AS = 2010.62 mm2.
One Way Shear:
The critical section Y1 Y1 at d = 430 mm from the face of the column is shown in Figure 6.2.
Design shear force, VU = 256 x (2.5 /2 0.43 0.4 / 2) x 2.5 = 396.8 kN
Design shear stress, v = =0.369 N/mm2
Now, vC1 = min(0.8 ,5) = 4.7328 N/mm2
> v (Hence Safe)
= 0.395 N / mm2 > v (Hence Safe)
Hence no shear reinforcement is required.
Punching Shear:
Punching shear is checked on a perimeter 1.5d = 625.5 mm from the column face. The critical
Page 4 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
5/34
perimeter is shown in Figure 6.3.
Perimeter = 1690 x 4 = 6760 mm.
Shear = 256 x (2.52 1.692) = 868.8 kN.
v = = 0.3 N / mm2 < VC (Hence Safe).
Hence no shear reinforcement is required.
Spacing:
We provided 10 nos. 16 mm bars, AS = 2010.62 mm2.
Spacing = = 267.11 mm.
Comparison
Table 7.1
7.2 British Verification Problem 2
Reference
Reinforced Concrete by T.J.Macgingley & B.S.Choo, Page 340 and Example: 11.2.
Value Of ReferenceResult
STAAD.foundationResult
Difference inPercent
Effective Depth 430 mm 430 mm None
Governing Moment
352.8 KN-m
352.8 KN-m
None
Area of Steel 1976.31 1976.31 NoneShear Stress (One-
Way) 0.369 N/mm2 0.369 N/mm2 None
Shear Stress (Two-Way) 0.3 N/mm
2 0.3 N/mm2 None
Page 5 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
6/34
Problem
The characteristic loads for an internal column footing in a building are given in the following table.The proposed dimensions for the column and base are shown in Figure 6.4. The safe bearing
pressure of soil is 150 kN / m2. The materials to be used in the foundation are grade 35 concrete andgrade 460 reinforcement.
Table 7.2
Figure 7.4
Solution
Self-weight of footing = 0.5 x 3.6 x 2.8 x 24 = 120.96 kN.
Total axial load = 770 + 330 + 120.96 = 1220.96 kN.
Total moment = 78 + 34 = 112 kN-m.
Vertical Load (kN) Moment (kN m)
Dead Load 770 78
Imposed Load 330 34
Page 6 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
7/34
Base area = 2.8 x 3.6 = 10.08 m2.
Section modulus = (I / y) = = 6.048 m3.
Maximum pressure = = 139.65 kN / m2 < 150 kN / m2 (Hence Safe).
Factored axial load = (1.4 x 770) + (1.6 x 330) = 1606 kN.
Factored moment = (1.4 x 78) + (1.6 x 34) = 163.6 kN-m.
Maximum pressure = = 186.38 kN / m2.
Minimum pressure = = 132.28 kN / m2.
Calculation of Reinforcement Along Shorter Span (X1-X1):
Average pressure for section X1X1 (as shown in Figure 6.5) = 159.33 kN / m2.
Moment (MY) = (159.33 x 1.175 x 3.6) x (1.175 / 2) = 395.955 kN-m.
Effective depth (d) = 500 40 10 = 450 mm.
Page 7 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
8/34
The minimum area of steel = 0.13 x 3600 x 500 / 100 = 2340 mm2 > calculated area of steel.
Provide minimum steel.
Page 8 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
9/34
Figure 7.5
Calculation of Reinforcement Along Longer Span (Y1-Y1):
Pressure at section Y1 Y1 (as shown in Figure 6.5) = 162.7 kN / m2.
Moment(MX) = (162.7 x 2.8 x 1.575)x(1.575 / 2)+(0.5 x 1.575 x (186.38 162.7) x 2.8)x(2 / 3 x
1.575) = 619.862 kN-m.
Effective depth (d) = 500 40 20 10 = 430 mm.
The minimum area of steel = 0.13 x 2800 x 500 / 100 = 1820 mm2 v (Hence Safe)
Let us consider 1.5 times shear enhancement.
Vce = 1.5 x 429.6 = 644.4 kN/m2 > v (Hence safe)
Hence no shear reinforcement is required.
Page 10 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
11/34
Figure 7.6
Along Section X2-X2:
The critical section X2X2 at d = 450 mm from the face of the column is shown in Figure 6.6.
Average pressure for the required section = 159.33 kN / m2.
Design shear force, VU = 159.33 x 3.6 x 7.25 = 415.85 kN
Design shear stress, v = =256.698 kN / m2
Now, vC1 = min(0.8 ,5) = 4732.8 kN / m2 > v (Hence Safe)
Page 11 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
12/34
= 409.6 kN / m2.
Let us consider 1.5 times shear enhancement.
Vce = 1.5 x 409.6 = 614.4 kN/m2 > v (Hence safe)
Hence no shear reinforcement is required.
Punching Shear:
Page 12 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
13/34
Figure 7.7
The punching shear will be calculated for an area outside the area enclosed by the rectangle at adistance 1.5d from the column face as shown in Figure 6.7.
Total pressure under the base = 2.8 x 3.6 x 132.28 + 0.5 x 3.6 x 2.8 x (186.38 132.28) = 1606.05kN.
Pressure under enclosed rectangle = (1.74)2 x 146.255 + 0.5 x (1.74)2 x (172.4 146.255) = 482.38kN
Punching shear force = 1606.05 482.38 = 1123.67 kN.
Critical perimeter = 1.74 x 4 = 6.96 m.
Punching shear stress = =375.46 kN / m2.
Comparison
Value Of ReferenceResult
STAAD.foundationResult
Difference inPercent
Effective Depth (X-X) 430 mm 430 mm None
Effective Depth (Y-Y) 450 mm 450 mm None
Governing Moment
(My)395.955 KN-m 395.943 KN-m None
Governing Moment
(Mx)619.862 KN-m 619.909 kN-m None
Area of Steel(Along X-X) 2340.00 2340.00 None
Area of Steel(Along Y-Y) 3472.2334 3472.2334 None
Shear Stress (One-
Way) (Y1-Y1)473.388 kN/m2 473.37 kN/m2 None
Shear Stress (One-
Way) (X1-X1)256.698 kN/m2 256.698 kN/m2 None
Shear Stress (Two-Way) 375.46 kN/m
2 375.44 kN/m2 None
Page 13 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
14/34
Table 7.3
7.3 British Verification Problem 3
Reference
Reinforced Concrete by T.J.Macgingley & B.S.Choo, Page 366 and Example: 11.6
Problem
Design a four pile cap to support a factored axial column load of 3600 kN. The column is 400 mmsquare and the piles are 400 mm in diameter spaced at 1200 mm centers. The materials are grade 35concrete and grade 460 reinforcement.
Figure 7.8
Page 14 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
15/34
Solution
Pile reaction = 3600 / 4 = 900 kN.
Calculation of Bending Moment and Area of Steel:
Figure 7.9
Bending moment at the face of the column = 2 x 900 x 0.4 = 720 kN-m.
Let us assume effective depth as 598 mm.
Page 15 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
16/34
The minimum area of steel = 0.13 x 2200 x 598 / 100 = 1710 mm2 < calculated area of steel.
Calculation of One Way Shear:
Figure 7.10
Shear force at a section aV distance away from the face of the column (as shown in Figure 6.10)
Design shear stress, v = =1368.197 kN / m2
Page 16 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
17/34
Now = 280 mm.
Enhanced shear VCE = = 1368.29 kN/m
2
> v (Hence Safe)
Calculation of Punching Shear:
Figure 7.11
Here, pile spacing
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
18/34
Design shear stress vC = =3762.542 kN/m2.
Allowable shear stress = =4732.874 kN/m2 > vC (Hence safe).
Comparison
Table 7.4
7.4 British Verification Problem 4
Reference
Reinforced Concrete Design by S.N.Sinha, Problem 11-13.
Problem
Design a pile cap with the given data: Load FY = 2000KN, MY = 300 KN-m, Spacing = 900 mm,
Pile in Pile Cap = 75 mm, Bottom Cover = 100 mm, Edge Distance = 275 mm, No. of Pile = 9, fc =
15 MPa, fy = 415 MPa, Column Dimension = 500mm x 500mm, Ultimate Load Factor = 1.5.
Value Of ReferenceResult
STAAD.foundationResult
Difference inPercent
Effective Depth 598 mm 598 mm None
Governing Moment 720 KN-m 720 KN-m None
Area of Steel 2900.188 mm2 2900.188 mm2 None
Shear Stress (One-Way) 1368.197 kN/m2 1368.197 kN/m2 NoneShear Stress (Two-
Way)3762.542
kN/mm2 3762.542 kN/mm2 None
Page 18 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
19/34
Figure 7.12
Solution
Pile reactions are calculated as follow,
P1 = = 416.667 kN,
P2 = = 416.667 kN,
Page 19 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
20/34
P3 = = 416.667 kN,
Calculation of Moment and Reinforcement Along Length (Y1-Y1):
Page 20 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
21/34
Figure 7.13
The critical bending moment will act at the face of the column.
Hence MYY = 3 x 416.667 x 0.65 = 812.5 kN-m.
Let us assume effective depth as 1103 mm.
The minimum area of steel = 0.13 x 2350 x 928 / 100 = 2835.04 mm2 > calculated area of steel.
Provide minimum area of steel.
Calculation of Moment and Reinforcement Along Width (X1-X
1):
The critical bending moment will act at the face of the column.
Hence MYY = (416.667 + 333.333 + 250) x 0.65 = 650 kN-m.
Let us assume effective depth as 1103 mm.
Page 21 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
22/34
The minimum area of steel = 0.13 x 2350 x 928 / 100 = 2835.04 mm2 > Calculated area of steel.
Provide minimum area of steel.
Calculation of One Way Shear (for section X1-X1 & X2-X2):
aV
Page 22 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
23/34
Figure 7.14
Shear force at a section aV
distance away from the face of the column (as shown in Figure 6.14)
Now force on the section X1-X1 = 3 x 416.667 = 1250 kN.
And force on the section X2-X2 = 3 x 250 = 750 kN.
Hence design shear stress, v = = 573.18 kN / m2
Page 23 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
24/34
Calculation of One Way Shear (for section Y1-Y1 & Y2-Y2):
Page 24 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
25/34
Figure 7.15
Shear force at a section aV
distance away from the face of the column (as shown in Figure 6.15)
Now force on the section Y1-Y1 = (416.667 + 333.333 + 250) = 1000 kN.
And force on the section Y2-Y2 = (416.667 + 333.333 + 250) = 1000 kN.
Hence design shear stress, v = = 458.547 kN / m2
Page 25 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
26/34
Calculation of Punching Shear:
Figure 7.16
Here, pile spacing > 3 x pile diameter.
Hence, design shear force at the face of the column=(3 x 416.667 + 2 x 333.333 + 3 x 250)=2666.667 kN,
Page 26 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
27/34
Hence we will check for punching shear at the crtical perimeter as shown in Figure 6.16.
(BS 8110:Part1:1997,Clause 3.11.4.5)
Critical perimeter = 4 x (2 x aV +column dimension) = 4 x (2 x 575 + 500) = 6600 mm.
Design shear stress vC = =435.388 kN/m2.
Comparison
Value Of
Reference
Result
STAAD.foundation
Result
Difference in
PercentEffective Depth (X-
X) 928 mm 928 mm None
Effective Depth (Y-Y) 928 mm 928 mm None
Governing Moment
(My)812.503 KN-m 812.5 kN-m m None
Governing Moment
(Mx)650 KN-m 650 KN-m None
Area of Steel(Along X-X) 2835.04 2835.04 None
Area of Steel(Along Y-Y) 2835.04 2835.04 None
Shear Stress (One-Way) (Y1-Y1)
458.547 kN/m2 458.547 kN/m2 None
Shear Stress (One-573.18 kN/m2 573.186 kN/m2 None
Page 27 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
28/34
Table 7.5
7.5 British Verification Problem 5Reference
Reinforced Concrete by T.J.Macgingley & B.S.Choo, Page 351 and Example: 11.4
Problem
Design a rectangular base to support two columns carrying the following loads:
Column 1 Dead load 310 kN, imposed load 160 kN
Column 1 Dead load 310 kN, imposed load 160 kN
The columns are each 350 mm square and are spaced at 2.5 m centers. The width of the base is not to
exceed 2.0 m. the safe bearing pressure on the ground is 180 kN/m2. The materials are grade 35concrete and grade 460 reinforcement.
Figure 7.17
Way) (X1-X1)
Shear Stress (Two-Way) 435.388 kN/m
2 435.388 kN/m2 None
Page 28 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
29/34
Solution
Let us assume the self weight of the base is 130 kN.
Total vertical load = (310 + 160 + 430 + 220 + 130) = 1250 kN.
Area of base = 1250 / 160 = 7.81 m2 (considering safe base pressure as 160 kN/m2).
Length of base = 7.81/2 = 3.91 m
Let the dimension of the mat is as follows,
Width = 2 m,
Length = 4.5 m,
Depth = 0.6 m.
Hence self-weight of mat = 2 x 4.5 x 0.6 x 24 = 129.6 kN.
Hence, total vertical load = (310 + 160 + 430 + 220 + 129.6) = 1249.6 kN.
Actual base pressure = 1249.6 / (2 x 4.5) = 138.84 kN/m2
.
Load Case I (DL & IL on both the column):
The ultimate loads are,
Column 1 load = 1.4 x 310 + 1.6 x 160 = 690 kN,
Column 2 load = 1.4 x 430 + 1.6 x 220 = 954 kN.
Page 29 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
30/34
The distance of center of gravity from column 1 is checked for service load case 1:
x = (954 x 2.5)/(690 + 954) = 1.45 m.
The soil pressure is checked for service loads for case 1:
Base area = 4.5 x 2 =9.0 m2,
Base modulus = 2 x 4.52 / 6 = 6.75 m3.
Direct load = 310 + 160 + 430 + 220 + 129.6 = 1249.6 kN.
The moment about the centerline of the base is,
M = (430 + 220) 1.05 (310 + 160) 1.45 = 1.0 kN-m.
Maximum pressure = 1249.6 / 9 + 1 / 6.75 = 138.9 kN / m2 < 180 kN / m2 (Hence safe)
Total uniformly distributed upward load = (690 + 954) / (4.5 x 2 / 2) = 365.33 kN / m.
Load Case II (DL & IL on column 1; DL on column 2):
The ultimate loads are,
Column 1 load = 1.4 x 310 + 1.6 x 160 = 690 kN,
Column 2 load = 1.0 x 430 = 430 kN.
Direct load = 310 + 160 + 430 + 129.6 = 1029.6 kN.
The moment about the centerline of the base is,
M = 430 X 1.54 (310 + 160) 0.96 = 230 kN-m.
Page 30 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
31/34
Maximum pressure = 1029.6 / 9 + 230 / 6.75 = 148.47 kN / m2 < 180 kN / m2 (Hence safe)
Load Case III (DL on column 1; DL & IL on column 2):
The ultimate loads are,
Column 1 load = 1.0 x 310 = 310 kN,
Column 2 load = 1.4 x 430 + 1.6 x 220 = 954 kN.
Direct load = 310 + 430 + 220 + 129.6 = 1089.6 kN.
The moment about the centerline of the base is,
M = (430 + 220) 1.05 310 X 1.45 = 233 kN-m.
Maximum pressure = 1089.6 / 9 + 233 / 6.75 = 155.59 kN / m2 < 180 kN / m2 (Hence safe)
Page 31 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
32/34
Figure 7.18
Design of Longitudinal (Bottom) Steel:
The maximum negative BM from Figure 6.18 is 221.7 kN-m
Assuming 40 mm clear cover and 20 mm bar diameter, effective depth = 600 40 20/2 = 550 mm.
Page 32 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
33/34
The minimum area of steel = 0.13 x 2000 x 600 / 100 = 1560 mm2 > calculated area of steel.
Provide minimum steel.
Provide 16 bars 12 mm in diameter at 125 mm centers to give area of 1808 mm2.
Design of Transverse (Top) Steel:
The maximum positive BM from Figure 6.18 is 99.7 kN-m.
Assuming 40 mm clear cover and 20 mm bar diameter, effective depth = 600 40 20/2 = 550 mm.
Page 33 of 347 British Verification Problems
11/05/2012file://C:\Documents and Settings\albert\Local Settings\Temp\~hhB594.htm
7/31/2019 British Verification Problem
34/34
The minimum area of steel = 0.13 x 2000 x 600 / 100 = 1560 mm2 > calculated area of steel.
Provide minimum steel as above.
Calculation of Vertical Shear:
The maximum vertical shear from case 1 is V = 250.8 kN,
V = = 0.228 N/mm2.
Punching Shear Check:
The critical perimeter for punching shear check is at 1.5 d distance from the face of the column. Here
the perimeter crosses the boundary of the base on two sides. Hence punching shear is less criticalthan the vertical shear in this case.
Comparison
Value Of ReferenceResult
STAAD.foundationResult
Difference inPercent
Max BendingMoment (-) 221.7 kN-m 201.204 kN-m 9.2
Max BendingMoment (+) 99.7 kN-m 108.94 kN-m 9.2
Area of StealRequired 780 mm
2/m 780 mm2/m None
Base Pressure 138.84 kN/m2 136 kN/m2 2
Page 34 of 347 British Verification Problems