BUILDING THE INVESTMENTMANAGEMENT PROFESSIONPaul Smith, CFAPresident and CEOMay 2017
2
Leads the investment profession globally by promoting the highest standards of ethics,
education, and professional excellence for the ultimate benefit of society.
CFA Institute
GLOBAL INFLUENCE
3
148 member societies
More than 140,000 members in over 150 countries
AMERICAS
Members: 88,900
CFA Program Registrations: 70,300
61%
EUROPE, MIDDLE EAST, AFRICA
Members: 30,900
CFA Program Registrations: 44,900
21%
ASIA PACIFIC
Members: 25,600
CFA Program Registrations: 108,300
18%
Data as of 1 February 2017
CFA Institute
4
SOME HISTORY
70 YEARS OF CHANGE
5
6
A profession by definition “extends a public warranty that it has established and maintains conditions of entry, standards of fair practice, disciplinary procedures, and continuing education for its particular constituency.”~ C. Stewart Sheppard, First Executive Director, Institute of Chartered Financial Analysts (1967)
1965 Graders
CFA Institute
THE PROFESSIONALISM DEBATE
7
“I want you to make all your customers and, for that matter, every investor in your territory realize that this firm has only one ambition—and that is to stand for all that is best in Investment Banking.
The success of this house has been predicated upon the success of our customers—if we take care of them they will take care of us. Our business will continue to grow only as we serve the best interest of the investing public.”
- Charles Merrill, founder, Merrill Lynch (in a 1940s internal memo to employees)
“…the doctor when looking after his patient should think only how he can give the best care to this patient and should not give any thought to the bill which he will send to the patient afterwards.
The primary point seems to be always the quality of the service and the courage to persist in giving well-considered advice, no matter how unpopular that might be sometimes.”
- S. G. Warburg, founder, S.G. Warburg & Co, which ultimately became part of UBS (in the 1950s)
THREE QUESTIONS TODAY
• Our business is changing. How can we demonstrate our value to investors and earn their trust?
• Should increasing professionalism be a priority?
• What inputs can we change to create different outcomes?
8
9
VALUE, TRUST, AND PROFESSIONALISMIN TIMES OF CHANGE
10
Forces of innovationand disruptionspecific to finance
Source: Future State of the Investment Profession, April 2017
Global Trends
CFA Institute
SIX DRIVERS OF HISTORICAL CHANGE
1. Technological innovation
2. The spread of ideas and institutions
3. The tendency of even good political systems to degenerate
4. Demographics
5. Supplies of essential commodities
6. Climate change
Source: Niall Ferguson, Laurence A. Tisch Professor of History, Harvard University
11
INVESTORS LACK TRUST IN US AND DON’T SEE OUR VALUE
12
KEY INDUSTRY INDICATORS:
• All capital raising products saw a decrease in activity in 2015
• Increased market volatility
• Uncertainty about geopolitics and globalization; rise of populism
• Rising interest rates
• Venture capital funding reached highest levels since 2000
Source: PwC Analysis
77%
61%RETAIL
47%
57%INSTITU-TIONAL
51%GENERAL
PUBLIC
TECHNOLOGY
FINANCIALSERVICES
MEDIA
Source: CFA Institute Trust to Loyalty Survey 2016
A TRUST EQUATION
13
=
TRUST & VALUECREDIBILITY PROFESSIONALISM
+ The dependency on aservice provider in a situation of risk over a prolonged period
License to operate
Track record andexperience
Competency
Values
Source: Future State of the Investment Profession, April 2017
WHAT MAKES A PROFESSION?
• Seal of approval and authority recognized by society
• A commitment to use knowledge for the public good, not profit maximization
A common body of knowledge that is widely accepted
Certification that individuals possess such knowledge before practicing
A code of ethics, with compliance monitoring and enforcement
• Continuing professional development
14
Is this a desirable outcome?Will we ever get there?What steps should we be taking?
THE CORE
15
OCCUPATION
INDUSTRY SEGMENT
Portfolio Manager
Research/Investment Analysts
Financial Advisors
Non-Investment Management Roles
Asset Mgmt & Wealth Mgmt
CORE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT
PROFESSIONALS
Asset Owners
Other Firms (Banks, Insurance, Brokerages, Non-FS firms)
INV
ES
TM
EN
T
MA
NA
GE
ME
NT
IN
DU
ST
RY
How is the core changing over time?What limits to growth does the core present?What are the challenges to member societies?
CFA INSTITUTE MARKET PENETRATIONBY REGION
16
Source: Mercer Market Sizing Study
COLOMBUS CINCINNATI CLEVELAND DAYTON CHINA
17
Members 456 467 444 58 4,042
CFA Candidates 398 276 441 103 58,548
18
WHAT INPUTS CAN WE CHANGE TO CREATE DIFFERENT OUTCOMES?
19
“The underlying principles of sound investment should not alter from decade to decade, but the application of these principles must be adapted to significant changes in the financial mechanisms and climate.”
- Benjamin Graham
OUR STRATEGY & OUTCOMES
High standards of entry and professionalism.
Educated, ethical members at the top of their profession.
Regulations that align firms and clients.
Develop Future Professionals
Through relevant and accessible credentialing programs.
Deliver Member Value
That accelerates the professional success of our members.
Build Market Integrity
That benefits investors and our members that serve them.
Business models geared toward achieving investor outcomes.
ST
RA
TE
GY
OU
TC
OM
ES
20 CFA Institute
The investment industry’s
fundamental role is to mobilize
capital for growth and jobs, and
deploy investment services
for wealth creation and
risk management.
EFFECTIVE BUSINESS MODELS
21
Asset Manager Code Global Investment PerformanceStandards (GIPS®)
Pension Trustee Code
Clearly articulated mission, strategy, resources
Transparent product and fee structures oriented towards long-term goals– investors first!
Compensation/incentives that reflectthe value clients receive
Hiring practices that screen for purpose, habits, incentives, diversity
Aligned culture and united values between firms and their stakeholders
CFA Institute
22
Source: Discovering Phi: Motivation as the Hidden Variable in Performance, 2016, CFA Institute and State Street
Ownership: A feeling that you are an integral part of your firm’s future
Cognitive flexibility: Ability to adapt to disruptive forces in the industry
Creativity: Find value inan environment that is increasingly competitive
Citizenship: Doing more than expected for the overall health of the firm
NEW SKILLS
NEEDED FOR
SUCCESS
WHAT DO THESE NEW SKILLS MEAN
FOR THECURRICULUM AND HIRING PRACTICES?
CULTURE CHANGEPHI – PURPOSE, HABITS, INCENTIVES
WOMEN AS A PERCENTAGE OF CFA INSTITUTE MEMBERS
GLOBAL 18%
AMER 17%
APAC 24%
EMEA 17%
23
ADVOCACY – WE NEED YOUR HELP
24
REGULATION ANDPOLICY
FUTURE OF FINANCEINITIATIVE
FUTURE STATE OF THE PROFESSION RESEARCH
Two new Standards & Advocacy Advisory Committees (US and EU)
Close collaboration with societies for greater impact
A long-term effort to shape a trustworthy, forward-thinking investment profession that better serves society. - Putting investors first- Retirement security & affordability- Industry structure, content, and culture
Comprehensive research to suggest the possible future state of the investment profession.
Identification of actions to influence the future state for the best possible outcomes to serve the public interest.
CFA Institute
25
“In all affairs it's a healthy thing now and then to hang a question mark on the things you have long taken for granted.”
- Bertrand Russell, renowned philosopher and Nobel Laureate