+ All Categories
Home > Documents > By Jason T. Smith, Kara N. Mitvalsky ( USACE) and K. Douglas...

By Jason T. Smith, Kara N. Mitvalsky ( USACE) and K. Douglas...

Date post: 16-Aug-2020
Category:
Upload: others
View: 0 times
Download: 0 times
Share this document with a friend
1
GOAL OBJECTIVES POTENTIAL FEATURES Restore, to the extent practi- cal, quality, functional, flood- plain habitat and ecological processes in an Illinois River Backwater area. Restore floodplain connec- tivity from the Illinois River to a productive backwater area, which serves as fish spawn- ing grounds and a nutrient recharge to the river. a)Restore the natural hydrograph of the Emiquon Preserve/ Illinois River back- water to approximate pre-settlement conditions. b)Restore native aquatic habitat and ecological processes. c)Increase the presence of a reliable food source and quality habitat for mi- gratory waterfowl, shorebirds, and other breeding birds. d)Improve water quality through proc- essing of nutrients and sediments and reducing sediment resuspension. e)Restore hydrologic river floodplain connectivity. f)Increase IL River connectivity to quality fish spawning and nursery habi- tats g)Export biological productivity to river and maximize sustainability of aquatic habitat h)Provide recreational and educational opportunities Water control structure / Fish passage structure Levee Removal Pump Station Reinforced Levee Spillway Levee Rehabilitation Berms/islands Recreation and Education Tenatively Selected Plan ( T SP ) : The tentatively selected plan was identified through use of the Incremental Cost Analysis Software tool and input from the Product Delivery Team. The TSP is composed of a 7-ft wide Water Control Structure (WCS), a 60,000 GPM Pumping System and 10 Earthen Interior Islands. Real Estate: The Real Estate interests on the Emiquon project presented a unique set of challenges. The project site contains historic easements for the levee and drainage ditches, highway borrow pits, a high pressure natural gas pipeline, Chicago sanitary district flood inundation easement, as well as a USDA-NRCS Wetland Reserve Easement. Corps and TNC staff have worked at great length to determine a path for resolving all of these and other real estate constraints. Many of these issues have been successfully addressed, while others, TNC and Corps partners continue to work on (ex: USDA-NRCS WRP Easement). Collaborative Planning: This project utilized the TNC’s Key Ecological Attributes (KEA) that were defined by the TNC through the Emiquon Scientific Advisory Council. The KEA’s were instrumental in determining objectives and how to measure those objectives to measure success. Corps planners worked collaboratively with TNC preserve staff to develop a 6-year water level management plan to meet the ecological objectives. Developing a 6-year water level management plan allowed the Product Delivery Team to evaluate various alternatives based on how effective they are at meeting the desired water level management plan. This plan was instrumental in identifying what measures are technically feasible due to river levels and which are not. Background and Significance: The Proposed Project is located at one of the largest and most recognized bottomland lakes in the Illinois River Valley. The Illinois River’s significance was recognized by Congress in WRDA 1996 as a “nationally significant ecosystem” as part of the Upper Mississippi River System. The TNC Emiquon property is located within the area Congress authorized for USF&WS acquisition for wetland habitat restoration. Prior to Emiquon’s isolation from the river in 1920 when levee construction was completed, the Project area was a large commercial inland fishery and waterfowl hunting area. Following levee construction, the Project area was drained for agricultural production and served as productive farmland for more than 80 years. In 2000, TNC announced they had purchased the Project area along with additional adjacent lands. The Project area continued to be farmed while a restoration plan was being developed until 2006 when TNC signed into a Wetland Reserve Program (WRP) agreement with the USDA-Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS). In 2007, in cooperation with the WRP agreement, TNC halted pumping and the water levels began to rise, restoring fishery and wetland habitat in this backwater area. However, recent ecosystem restoration efforts at nearby Hennepin and Hopper Lakes were determined to be detrimental to the ecosystem when they ceased to manage water levels. Disturbance to the system occurred due to the high concentration of common and grass carp varieties of fish. The Nature Conservancy has identified that without a more reliable way to manage water levels at Emiquon, the ecosystem may be substantially degraded over time. Design Considerations: Due to varying river levels a managed connection would be necessary that allows for fish passage at selected times of the year while preventing fish passage during other times of the year. For cost savings the pump station outlet pipe delivers flow to the outlet apron of the water control structure. A steel grate structure allows for vehicles to drive over the water control structure opening. Further consideration need to be given to velocity of the incoming water through the structure and the resting area for river fish exiting the preserve. By Jason T. Smith, Kara N. Mitvalsky ( USACE) a nd K. Douglas Blodgett ( T he Nature Conservancy ) 2007 National Agricultural Program Aerial Photograph 2010 National Agricultural Program Aerial Photograph
Transcript
Page 1: By Jason T. Smith, Kara N. Mitvalsky ( USACE) and K. Douglas …conference.ifas.ufl.edu/partnership/posters/SmithJ - TNC... · 2011. 12. 13. · The TNC Emiquon property is located

GO

AL

O

BJE

CT

IVE

S

P

OT

EN

TIA

L F

EA

TU

RE

S

Re

sto

re, to

th

e e

xte

nt p

racti-

ca

l, q

ua

lity,

fu

nctio

na

l, flo

od

-p

lain

ha

bita

t a

nd

eco

log

ica

l p

roce

sse

s in

an

Illi

no

is R

ive

r B

ackw

ate

r a

rea

.

Re

sto

re flo

odp

lain

co

nn

ec-

tivity fro

m th

e Illi

no

is R

ive

r to

a

pro

du

ctive

ba

ckw

ate

r are

a,

wh

ich

se

rves a

s fis

h s

paw

n-

ing

gro

un

ds a

nd

a n

utr

ien

t re

ch

arg

e to

th

e r

ive

r.

a)R

esto

re th

e n

atu

ral h

yd

rog

raph

of th

e

Em

iqu

on

Pre

se

rve

/ Illin

ois

Riv

er

back-

wa

ter

to a

pp

roxim

ate

pre

-se

ttle

me

nt

co

nd

itio

ns.

b)R

esto

re n

ative

aq

ua

tic h

ab

ita

t a

nd

e

co

log

ica

l p

rocesses.

c)I

ncre

ase

th

e p

rese

nce

of a

re

liab

le

foo

d s

ou

rce

an

d q

ua

lity h

ab

ita

t fo

r m

i-g

rato

ry w

ate

rfo

wl, s

ho

reb

ird

s, a

nd

o

the

r bre

ed

ing

birds.

d)I

mp

rove

wa

ter

qu

alit

y th

rou

gh

pro

c-

essin

g o

f n

utr

ien

ts a

nd

se

dim

en

ts a

nd

re

ducin

g s

ed

ime

nt re

susp

en

sio

n.

e)R

esto

re h

yd

rolo

gic

riv

er

flo

od

pla

in

co

nn

ectivity.

f)I

ncre

ase

IL R

ive

r co

nne

ctivity t

o

qu

alit

y fis

h s

pa

wn

ing

an

d n

urs

ery

hab

i-ta

ts

g)E

xpo

rt b

iolo

gic

al p

rod

uctivity to

riv

er

an

d m

axim

ize

susta

ina

bili

ty o

f a

qu

atic

ha

bita

t

h)P

rovid

e r

ecre

atio

na

l and

ed

uca

tio

na

l o

pp

ort

un

itie

s

Wa

ter

co

ntr

ol str

uctu

re / F

ish

passa

ge

str

uctu

re

Le

ve

e R

em

ova

l

Pu

mp

Sta

tio

n

Re

info

rce

d L

eve

e S

pill

wa

y

Le

ve

e R

eh

abili

tatio

n

Be

rms/isla

nds

Re

cre

atio

n a

nd

Ed

uca

tio

n

Te

na

tive

ly S

ele

cte

d P

lan

(T

SP

):

The

ten

tati

vel

y s

elec

ted p

lan w

as i

den

tifi

ed t

hro

ugh u

se o

f th

e In

crem

enta

l C

ost

Anal

ysi

s

Soft

war

e to

ol

and i

nput

from

the

Pro

duct

Del

iver

y T

eam

.

The

TS

P i

s co

mpose

d o

f a

7-f

t w

ide

Wat

er C

ontr

ol

Str

uct

ure

(W

CS

), a

60,0

00 G

PM

Pum

pin

g

Syst

em a

nd 1

0 E

arth

en I

nte

rior

Isla

nds.

Re

al E

sta

te:

The

Rea

l E

stat

e in

tere

sts

on t

he

Em

iquon

pro

ject

pre

sente

d a

uniq

ue

set

of

chal

lenges

.

The

pro

ject

sit

e co

nta

ins

his

tori

c ea

sem

ents

for

the

levee

and d

rain

age

dit

ches

, hig

hw

ay

borr

ow

pit

s, a

hig

h p

ress

ure

nat

ura

l gas

pip

elin

e, C

hic

ago s

anit

ary d

istr

ict

flood

inundat

ion

ease

men

t, a

s w

ell

as a

US

DA

-NR

CS

Wet

land R

eser

ve

Eas

emen

t.

Corp

s an

d T

NC

sta

ff h

ave

work

ed a

t gre

at

length

to d

eter

min

e a

pat

h f

or

reso

lvin

g a

ll

of

thes

e an

d o

ther

rea

l es

tate

const

rain

ts.

Man

y o

f th

ese

issu

es h

ave

bee

n

succ

essf

ull

y a

ddre

ssed

, w

hil

e oth

ers,

TN

C

and C

orp

s par

tner

s co

nti

nue

to w

ork

on

(ex:

US

DA

-NR

CS

WR

P E

asem

ent)

.

Co

llab

ora

tive

Pla

nn

ing

:

This

pro

ject

uti

lize

d t

he

TN

C’s

Key

Eco

logic

al A

ttri

bute

s (K

EA

) th

at w

ere

def

ined

by t

he

TN

C t

hro

ugh t

he

Em

iquon S

cien

tifi

c A

dvis

ory

Counci

l.

The

KE

A’s

wer

e in

stru

men

tal

in d

eter

min

ing o

bje

ctiv

es a

nd

how

to m

easu

re t

hose

obje

ctiv

es t

o m

easu

re s

ucc

ess.

Corp

s pla

nner

s w

ork

ed c

oll

abora

tivel

y w

ith T

NC

pre

serv

e st

aff

to d

evel

op a

6-y

ear

wat

er l

evel

man

agem

ent

pla

n t

o m

eet

the

ecolo

gic

al o

bje

ctiv

es.

Dev

elopin

g a

6-y

ear

wat

er l

evel

man

agem

ent

pla

n a

llow

ed t

he

Pro

duct

Del

iver

y T

eam

to e

val

uat

e var

ious

alte

rnat

ives

bas

ed o

n h

ow

eff

ecti

ve

they

are

at

mee

ting t

he

des

ired

wat

er l

evel

man

agem

ent

pla

n.

This

pla

n w

as i

nst

rum

enta

l in

iden

tify

ing

what

mea

sure

s ar

e te

chnic

ally

fea

sible

due

to r

iver

lev

els

and w

hic

h a

re n

ot.

Back

gro

un

d a

nd

Sig

nif

ican

ce:

T

he

Pro

pose

d P

roje

ct i

s lo

cate

d a

t on

e of

the

larg

est

and m

ost

reco

gniz

ed b

ott

om

land l

akes

in t

he

Illi

nois

Riv

er V

alle

y.

The

Illi

no

is R

iver

’s s

ignif

ican

ce w

as r

ecogniz

ed b

y C

ongre

ss i

n

WR

DA

1996 a

s a

“nat

ional

ly s

ignif

ican

t ec

osy

stem

” as

par

t of

the

Upper

Mis

siss

ippi

Riv

er S

yst

em.

The

TN

C E

miq

uon p

roper

ty i

s lo

cate

d w

ithin

the

area

Congre

ss

auth

ori

zed f

or

US

F&

WS

acq

uis

itio

n f

or

wet

land h

abit

at

rest

ora

tio

n.

Pri

or

to E

miq

uon’s

iso

lati

on f

rom

the

river

in 1

920 w

hen

lev

ee

const

ruct

ion w

as c

om

ple

ted, th

e P

roje

ct a

rea

was

a l

arge

com

mer

cial

inla

nd f

isher

y a

nd w

ater

fow

l hunti

ng a

rea.

Foll

ow

ing l

evee

const

ruct

ion

, th

e P

roje

ct a

rea

was

dra

ined

for

agri

cult

ura

l pro

duct

ion a

nd s

erved

as

pro

duct

ive

farm

land f

or

more

than

80 y

ears

.

In 2

000, T

NC

announce

d t

hey

had

purc

has

ed t

he

Pro

ject

are

a

along w

ith a

ddit

ional

adja

cent

lands.

The

Pro

ject

are

a co

nti

nued

to b

e fa

rmed

whil

e a

rest

ora

tio

n p

lan

was

bei

ng d

evel

oped

unti

l 2006 w

hen

TN

C s

igned

into

a W

etla

nd

Res

erve

Pro

gra

m (

WR

P)

agre

emen

t w

ith t

he

US

DA

-Nat

ura

l

Res

ourc

es C

onse

rvat

ion S

erv

ice

(NR

CS

).

In 2

007,

in c

ooper

atio

n w

ith t

he

WR

P a

gre

emen

t, T

NC

hal

ted

pum

pin

g a

nd t

he

wat

er l

evel

s beg

an t

o r

ise,

res

tori

ng f

isher

y a

nd

wet

land h

abit

at i

n t

his

bac

kw

ater

are

a.

How

ever

, re

cent

ecosy

stem

res

tora

tion

eff

ort

s at

nea

rby H

ennep

in a

nd H

opper

Lak

es w

ere

det

erm

ined

to b

e det

rim

enta

l to

the

ecosy

stem

when

they

cea

sed t

o m

anag

e w

ater

lev

els.

Dis

turb

ance

to t

he

syst

em o

ccurr

ed d

ue

to t

he

hig

h c

once

ntr

atio

n o

f co

mm

on a

nd g

rass

car

p v

arie

ties

of

fish

.

The

Nat

ure

Conse

rvan

cy h

as i

den

tifi

ed t

hat

wit

hout

a m

ore

rel

iab

le w

ay t

o m

anag

e w

ater

lev

els

at E

miq

uon, th

e ec

osy

stem

may

be

subst

anti

ally

deg

raded

over

tim

e.

De

sig

n C

on

sid

era

tio

ns:

Due

to v

aryin

g r

iver

lev

els

a m

anag

ed c

onnec

tio

n w

ould

be

nec

essa

ry t

hat

all

ow

s fo

r fi

sh

pas

sage

at s

elec

ted t

imes

of

the

yea

r w

hil

e pre

ven

ting f

ish p

assa

ge

duri

ng o

ther

tim

es o

f th

e

yea

r.

For

cost

sav

ings

the

pum

p s

tati

on o

utl

et p

ipe

del

iver

s fl

ow

to t

he

outl

et a

pro

n o

f th

e w

ater

contr

ol

stru

cture

.

A s

teel

gra

te s

truct

ure

all

ow

s fo

r veh

icle

s to

dri

ve

over

the

wat

er c

ontr

ol

stru

cture

open

ing.

Furt

her

consi

der

atio

n n

eed t

o b

e giv

en t

o v

eloci

ty o

f th

e in

com

ing w

ater

thro

ugh t

he

stru

cture

and t

he

rest

ing a

rea

for

river

fis

h e

xit

ing t

he

pre

serv

e.

By J

aso

n T

. S

mith

, K

ara

N.

Mitva

lsky

(U

SA

CE

) a

nd

K.

Do

ug

las B

lod

ge

tt

(T

he

Na

ture

Co

nse

rva

ncy

)

20

07 N

ational A

gricultura

l P

rogra

m A

eri

al P

hoto

gra

ph

2

010 N

ational A

gricu

ltu

ral P

rog

ram

Aeri

al P

ho

tog

rap

h

Recommended