Date post: | 22-Mar-2016 |
Category: |
Documents |
Upload: | bishoy-takla |
View: | 232 times |
Download: | 1 times |
12/20/2010
Cairo Sustainable Transportation
Bishoy Tala | Fall 2010 | Bishoy Takla
Professor Achva Benzinberg Stein
Urban Ecologies
Page 2 of20
Table of Contents
1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 3
2. background ............................................................................................................................... 4
3. the problem
3.1. Public transportation ................................................................................................................. 5
3.2. Technology mix and misuse ...................................................................................................... 6
3.3. Traffic signs and enforcement .................................................................................................... 7
3.4. Environmental issues ................................................................................................................. 7
4. the solution
4.1. New cities ................................................................................................................................. 8
4.2. Car-free zones ........................................................................................................................... 9
4.3 New traffic laws ....................................................................................................................... 10
4.5 The bike city ............................................................................................................................ 10
4.6 Successful example of Amsterdam ........................................................................................... 13
5. conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 14
Page 3 of20
Cairo Sustainable Transportation Introduction
“If all the cars in the United States were placed end to end, it would probably be Labor Day
Weekend” Said Doug Larson, but if all the cars in Cairo did so it would be another normal day. Most of
the mega cities in the world have transportation problems.
Egypt is one of the biggest and leading countries in the Middle East, with a population of
80 million1 inhabitants. It is considered the second most populous country in Africa after
Nigeria. Its population is expected to reach 103 million by 20302 , with more than 50% of its
population living in urban areas and cities. Cairo is one of the most densely populated capital
cities in the world; it is the most populous metropolitan area in Africa and ranks 16th
worldwide3. Cairo is faced with many problems in its way to development; the traffic congestion
is a heavy burden with more than 2 million cars on the city’s streets in addition to the air
pollution which causes 15,000 to 25,000 deaths every year.
Nevertheless, Transportation is one of our vital needs as technology and development are
moving forward nowadays. The increasing needs for vehicles results in traffic congestion
especially in big cities. Cairo is considered the biggest megacity in Africa and in the Middle
East, with 7,062,055 people4 living in a total area of 1,881.4 Km2 (464.8 acre)5, giving Cairo a
population density of 40,000 p/km26.
The Greater Cairo Region has been looking for solution to its traffic chaos since the early
1970’s (Figure 1& 2), when the Ministry of Urban Development issued the first development
plan. Then followed a long term development master plan in 1983(Figure 3). in conjunction
with IUERIF institution Paris; the plan divided the existing built-up area into sixteen
homogenous neighborhoods in addition to adding another ten new urban settlements. Eight years
later the department came up with the first update in 1991 followed by a 1997 revision. (Figure
4) . The rapid increase in car traffic, especially in the 1960s, aggravated congestion in the city
centre and effective solutions are still needed. The overcrowded buses, along with a burgeoning
1 http://www.mapsofworld.com/egypt/population.html
2 http://www.almasryalyoum.com/en/news/expert-egypt-population-hit-103-mn-2030
3 http://www.mapsofworld.com/cities/egypt/cairo/population.html
4 www.Cairo.gov.eg
5 http://www.cairo.gov.eg/MainPage/AllProvinceInLines.aspx
6 Tackling the Shelter Challenge of Cities Thinking it Through Together Dr. Hazem El Kouedi
Page 4 of20
fleet of private vehicle, trucks and motorcycle, help to fill the main roads of Cairo with noise and
black diesel fumes and contribute to an increasingly hostile and dangerous world for pedestrians
and bicyclists.7
This research paper is twofold. First, I will examine the government particular planning
approaches to overcome the traffic problem. Secondly, I will respond to the identified strengths
and weaknesses in these approaches. And finally I will introduce the bicycle as the ultimate
solution to Cairo’s traffic congestion problem, as in the example of Amsterdam. To follow its
steps toward more sustainable environment, hopping that one day Cairo might be called ‘the
Middle East’s Amsterdam’
Background
In order to provide the necessary context for understanding the unique nature of Cairo’s
traffic, I will try to explain from my personal experience how critical the traffic problem is in
Cairo, so the reader can have a good picture of the situation. In general, no traffic rules are
observed unless they are enforced with the active presence of the authorities, traffic lights are
ignored and replaced by policemen directing traffic with a whistle and hands. There are no fast
lanes, slow lanes, or passing lanes. Basically the concept of lanes doesn’t exist, cars swarm
across lanes. “Cairo traffic is a microcosm of Egyptian society”8. I don’t believe anyone can
drive in Cairo’s street expect the native Cairenes because dealing with the system and the other
drivers depends deeply on understanding the culture and the sign language, since there are no
physical signs to follow.
Mac McCleary once said “Patience is something you admire in the driver behind you and scorn in
the one ahead9” but in Cairo everyone is in need of patience, the usage of horns is continuously and
arbitrarily out of frustration, boredom or impatience, P.J O’Rourke states in his essay “Third
World Driving Hints and Tips” that one should honk the horn “1- when anything blocks the road
7 Sustainable transportation byE Bruun nand J Kenworthy
8 The Cairo House by samia serageldin
9 http://www.quotegarden.com/driving.html
Page 5 of20
2- when anything doesn’t 3- when anything might 4- at red light 5- at green lights 6- at all other
times”10
Cairo’s traffic system jeopardizes the security of the pedestrians in their everyday life,
and the government doesn’t consider their existence in the development plans, and therefore
there are no crossing lines or signs. That makes their presence in the street very risky and
dependent on the drivers’ manners and mercy, since speed limits are ignored; a person can travel
as fast as the surrounding traffic allows him. As a tourist stated this fact “Want to cross the
street? Just step off and keep walking. Drivers will not stop but they will avoid you.”11 The best
way for tourists to cross the street is to find some locals and walk across the street with them.
Even myself, as an Egyptian, in my first visit to Cairo after three years, I was desperate for my
younger brother’s help in crossing the streets. Also, most of the city lacks pedestrian walkways
and its narrow streets need to be more pedestrian-friendly.
The problem
Several factors have contributed to Cairo’s traffic problems.
Public transportation
The increasing number of the private cars as well as Cairenes’ reliance on cars is a
critical issue, and that is the first reason for Cairo’s heavy traffic. The other side of the coin is the
lack of a sufficient public transportation system. Commuters from the suburbs around Cairo
seldom have other options than driving; the system is missing the reliability and the element of
10
Third World Driving Hints and Tips” by Patrick O’Rourke 11
http://www.dintrone.com/egypt/index.html
The sign says pedestrians are not
allowed to use the pedestrian
bridge
Page 6 of20
connectivity which is needed to provide a viable option to the majority of Cairo’s inhabitants.
Thus enhancing public transportation is desirable in order to lower fuel consumption, decrease
traffic congestion and reduce air pollution.12
Technology mix and misuse
Another contributing factor is the mix of old and new
transportation modes sharing the same roads, fast-moving modern
vehicles and slow-moving animal drawn carts, typical of many
street scenes in Cairo .In addition to traffic conflict, safety and
street congestion, there are efficiency issues. Cars are not moving
as efficiently as they could, this misuse of personal vehicles in
slow traffic for short distances has placed a great load of pressure
on traffic flow. For example, an animal drawn cart in Cairo’s street
can delay all the traffic because the right of way is not clearly
given to the motorized vehicle. Studies done on some Indonesian
cities (TDCSA, 1988) recommended guidelines and enforcement to encourage the proper use of
transportation technology.
Traffic signs and enforcement
One of the main causes of congestion is the absence of signs and instruction boards on
Cairo’s roads. Cairo’s Transportation Department should put forth a greater effort to rectify these
common shortcomings in infrastructure. Simply adding street signs would greatly ease traffic
flow. Basic traffic enforcement can be indicated by counting traffic lights and traffic signs; both
are seldom seen in Cairo. We can achieve efficient transportation in Cairo through traffic signs
including the installation and maintenance of traffic lights and the designation of one-way
streets.
Environmental issues
12
First Year Report Captain Drew Fanning, USMC Olmsted Scholar, 2006
Page 7 of20
Cairo’s traffic affects the city in various ways and the most obvious one is the
degradation in air quality. The transport sector is responsible for about 28 % of the final energy
consumption in Egypt, and 25 % of energy related CO2 emissions. Cairo’s transportation emits
15 million tons of CO2/year (table 3). Projections of transport greenhouse gas emission and the
smog over shadowing Cairo are directly related to energy use in transportation system. The
release of greenhouse gases in the combustion of fossil fuels in the vehicles’ engines cause:
1- Acid rain (occurring when water vapor reacts with sulfur and nitrogen dioxides,
producing sulfuric and nitric acid13) Acid precipitation and other toxics can corrode
building materials, in addition, high levels of pollution can cause damage to some of the
ancient structures. Consequently, Cairo will lose its attraction as a tourist destination
because of the traffic congestion and the decay of monuments.
2- Photochemical smog (consisting of ozone and chemical compounds formed under the
influence of sunlight from NOx and volatile organic compounds released in fossil fuel
combustion14) Photochemical smog and pollutants emission such as CO2,CO, NO and,
NO2 directly affect the respiratory system and increase the chances of cardio-vascular
diseases. Statistic shows that 20,000 deaths every year 159 million sick days per year 15
are related to air pollution
Many of the environmental costs of transport are
non-linear in their effects16, and the crucial issue becomes,
not how to measure but how to avoid reaching critical levels
before the environmental cost becomes very expensive.
Even though no one currently is paying the price for
emissions doesn’t mean it is free of cost. According to the
“Ecology of Commerce” Paul Hawkins explains the
difference between the cost and the price “companies aren’t
required to pay for the damage to the environment” 17. However Cairo’s economy suffers
indirectly from the hazard emission and the air pollution. One billion Egyptian pounds18 were
13
http://www.ausetute.com.au/acidrain.html 14
http://www.lenntech.com/faq-air-pollution.htm 15
“average of 2 sick days per person per year” Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency 16
Transport policy and the environment by David Banister 17
Ecology of Commerce, chapter 5
Page 8 of20
spent in the year 2000 because of accidents and other consequences such as hospital costs, lost
working hours and damage to vehicles.
The solution
New cities
Since Cairo has become a less pleasant place to live or work, the need for expanding
Cairo beyond its current borders is a necessary step in solving the transportation problem. In the
late 1970’s the government developed two outside cities, ‘Six of October city’ and ‘Tenth of
Ramadan city’ on the west and east sides respectively. And since that time more and more cities
were developed as a natural response to population increase (Figure 5 ) . ‘Sixth of October city’
already has roughly a million residents and planners expect the population to grow above 3
million by 202019. Some of those cities were successful and some were not, for example the
successful example of Rehab City which took into account the need for close residential
buildings and community facilities, and provided public transport to create an area that is both
self-sustaining, and part of greater Cairo, in contrast to ‘tenth of Ramadan city’ which lacks the
basic transportation network to connect the city together.
Because of the failure to keep up with the rapidly expanding population, more
undeveloped residential neighborhoods were built. The undeveloped narrow streets of ‘Manshiet
Nasser’ are the main reason for the neighborhood congestion; similar congestion could be
avoided by planning and designing a large and rapid master plan to catch up with population
gross.
18
Egypt Almanac , Ch4 19
http://www.planetizen.com/node/45720
Page 9 of20
I think most of these cities were built in the desert around Greater Cairo Region in order
to create new economic poles and to decentralize the population. However, the main necessary
government facilities are still concentrated in downtown Cairo, thus increasing the commuting to
and from the mother city. Since the new cities are based totally on the private-run microbuses
and private cars consequently cause further congestion increase. Which leads to the second
important project of converting downtown Cairo into pedestrian plaza
Downtown Cairo Car-free
A fifteen years plan was announced to relocate
the government concentrated buildings from downtown
Cairo into new cities, to reduce the congestion in
downtown, as part of a bigger plan to create more car-
free zones in Cairo.
New traffic law
The government issued a new and harsher traffic law in 1999, in order to control the
increasing number of accidents and their consequential injures and death. The new law uses the
point system for the first time in Egypt, three traffic offences in a period of six months will result
in suspension of the driver license for one year. But the idea of designating days for specific cars
fell flat when drafting the new law, even though many mega cities have used it successfully.
The undeveloped fabric in squatter settlements Manshiet Nasser comparing to Urban fabric in squatter settlements Muhandisin
Page 10 of20
Such harsh laws will not last too long because of the unreasonable penalties such as prison
sentences and very expensive tickets (EGP1000 to EGP300020) for offences like speeding or
driving in the wrong direction 21
The bike City
“Every time I see an adult on a bicycle, I no longer despair for the future of the human
race” said H.G. Wells.
“You would have to have a death wish to cycle in Cairo22” according to
worldtravelguide.net
In light of these two quotes, I suggest the introduction of the bike lane as an ultimate
solution for the overwhelming transportation crisis in Cairo, creating a non-motorized
transportation network which will definitely be considered as a huge step toward sustainable
transportation system. By considering bicycle as mean of transportation and paving the way for it
in Cairo’s main streets will have a positive impact in a various fields; economically,
environmentally and socially. The usage of bikes will also reduce air-pollution related diseases
on the national level and on the individual level will offset the lack of exercise. In addition, it
will enhance the quality of life, attract new economic activity, improve public health and safety,
and create equity for citizens. Moreover bikes will have great benefits on the economic side of
the side of the equation both individually and nationally. Individuals, especially low income
householders, will save a lot of expense spent either on transportation fares or on fuel and
maintenance of their private cars. On the other hand, the government can save the fuel subsidy in
addition to the maintenance for car-related infrastructure such as road, high ways and bridges. In
that sense the introduction of bikes can be seen as solution for poverty reduction as well. Cairo is
not the first to indulge in this domain, China and the Netherlands began the usage of bicycles
several decades ago, and have shown impressive and successful progress towards sustainable
transportation. We see in the America's an effort to catch up in the procession these days. I think
it is time for Cairo to consider bike as one of its modes of transportation.
20
equal to one month wage of a middle class worker 21
http://news.egypt.com/en/200808033391/spot-light/spot-light/the-new-egyptian-traffic-law.html 22
http://www.worldtravelguide.net/egypt/local-transport
Page 11 of20
Cairo had a rich culture of cycling in the first decades of the twentieth century. But this
trend was weakened after the 1952 revelation, when modernization became the foundation of
Egyptian governmental strategies in several fields like urban design, architecture and
transportation. The motor vehicle became the main mode of transportation and the use of bikes
was phased out.
While remaining as a hobby, the bicycle was lost as a mode of transportation because
many cyclists started to use cars instead of bicycles. Bicycles are not counted among the
different transportation modes in Cairo, and the authorities does not consider it in their traffic
planning ,and due to the lack of reliable data it is not so obvious how many trips are made by
bicycle.
This attitude toward bicycles is stereotyped in the public perception as reserved for lower
classes or as a toy for children. However, this picture of bike-free Cairo is misleading; once you
travel inside the smaller streets in a residential area a person can witness many bicycles in the
streets. Young boys racing with their friends, delivery workers or a man ride to the market. All
this proves that bicycle is still accepted and seen as cheap means of moving around. Bikes are
quite ubiquitous in Cairo, but seldom used for commuting. Nearly everyone on a bike is
delivering something or out for recreational reasons.
Cairo has two characteristics that make it fertile ground for bicycles as a means for
getting around in the city. The first statistic shows that walking represents 36% of the total daily
commuting distances23. (Table 1&2) Considering the relatively short walking distances, if we
23
http://www.touregypt.net/cairo/cairostatistics.htm
Page 12 of20
replaced those with bicycles we would have saved a lot of effort and time to devote to the
different activities of life. Second, with the exception of the ‘Moqattam’ neighborhood, Cairo has
a flat surface and is qualified to bicycles’ usage without a lot of effort.
Practical steps to introduce the bike as a mean of transportation
No doubt that bike lanes are one of the first important steps which need to be considered,
however the problem in Cairo is deeper than that. Although developing bicycle routes and
facilities in the central part of Cairo is an important first step, the improvement of the bicycle’s
image in the public’s perception should be changed first. Then the bike lane will come as a result
of people’s needs. Famous Egyptian singers or actors should lead a bike advertisement campaign
to change how people think about bike riders, and introduce the bike as the ideal mean of
transportation to create a sustainable city and communities that encourage carbon-free transport.
When the people are ready to use bikes as mean of navigating, the Government role will begin
by providing bike lanes to protect the cyclists and by subsidized sale of bicycles to encourage
more youth and student to support that project.
The spark has already erupted in the town famous for its choking traffic and high
pollution, a small group of cyclists is trying to guide citizens to alternative means of
transportation which do not cause harm to the environment. Cycle Egypt Club24 aims to promote
cycling and environmental awareness, hoping to make cycling a means of commuting in Cairo.25
Hopefully bikes as a new, alternative and accepted way of commuting will spread from Cairo to
other towns and rural area in Egypt.
24
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=200560479460 25
http://www.al-shorfa.com/cocoon/meii/xhtml/ar/features/meii/features/2008/08/18/feature-02
Page 13 of20
Successful example of Amsterdam
We all know about the importance of cycling for health, but the Dutch believe in that
more than anybody else. Amsterdam has 550,000 bicycles and 800,000 people, making the city
the bike capital of the world26. Around 40% of its commuting trips are made by bicycle, in
addition to a public transportation system consisting of buses, trams and ferries. The city has a
healthier, more active lifestyle for its residents. A rapid infrastructure network of safe and fast
bicycle routes (400 km of bike lanes27) has been developed
Similarity between Amsterdam and Cairo
Amsterdam is a synonymous name for the best bicycle city in the world, but in 1960’s it
was faced by the same problem facing Cairo nowadays, traffic congestion. In the middle of this
century the difference in population between Cairo and Amsterdam was not as significant as it is
now (Figure 6 ). At this time Amsterdam recognized that its roads were too narrow to ensure
efficient traffic flows, therefore businesses were moved to the fringes of the city and into the
greater Amsterdam region, the bicycle use was to be encouraged and car use discouraged. Then a
critical question was asked; should Amsterdam adapt itself to accommodate motorized
transportation, or should it consciously avoid doing so? 28 And this was the beginning for
Amsterdam’s bicycle revolution. I believe the same question need to be asked in Cairo. Can
Cairo handle any more cars? Or is it time to try Amsterdam’s guaranteed solution? Cairo is still
26
http://www.virgin-vacations.com/11-most-bike-friendly-cities.aspx 27
http://www.marcgunther.com/2010/06/01/amsterdam-cycling-to-sustainability/ 28
http://www.velomondial.net/velomondiall2000/PDF/LANGENBE.PDF
Page 14 of20
in the place where Amsterdam was 40 years ago, but if we start now answering this critical
question we could catch up the successful procession of sustainable cities
It seems the similarities between the two cities ended in 1978 when Amsterdam opted to
conserve the historic value of its centre and to encourage
the use of the bicycle and public transport. The
Government eased the way for cyclists by constructing a
'Main Bicycle Network', improving and expanding the
facilities for cyclists, and the removal of physical obstacles
within the cycling infrastructure. And it is not too late for
Cairo, now is the time to turn Cairo’s traffic system into
sustainable and efficient system based on bicycles
Conclusion
Most of the effective solutions started at some point with a dream or idea, and I wish the
expression of my ideas in this research paper could be the starting point to solve Cairo’s traffic
crisis or at least to understand the size of the problem. For Cairo to be a sustainable city, we need
the government to stand up against traffic congestion and consider that the first step towards
progress and prosperity. Greater attention needs to be paid to the decision-making process by
looking at the problem from different angles and studying the consequences in order to convert
Cairo into more livable place.
As a student who has lived and studied in Cairo I conclude this research paper not only
by expressing the problems and concerns but also by hoping for far-sighted solutions and master
development plans to make Cairo a much more sustainable city with environment based on
ecological building principles, prioritizing public transportation, walking and cycling.
Page 15 of20
Pictures
Year Total built-up
area (km2)
1900 42
1950 120
1970 198,2
2000 524,4
Within the last three decades, the total built-up area increased more than 270% Figure 1
First Master Plan in 1970 Target year is 1990 Planning area is 685,000 acres Population is 6.1 million in 1966 Expected 14 million by 1990 Figure 2
Long term development master plan 1983 -Creation of small urban settlements and new satellite cities being connected through development corridors -Dividing the exiting built-up area into 16 homogenous sectors in addition to 10 new urban settlements Figure 3
Updated Plan 1991 -Population is 13 million in 1993 and expected to be 24 million in 2022 -Combining several new urban settlements into one or more new city or new urban community -Combining new settlements No. 1,3,5 to be New Cairo Figure 4
Page 16 of20
1970’s 1980’s
2000’s 1990’s
New Cities
Figure 5
Page 17 of20
Population growth
Figure 6
Page 18 of20
Tables
Transportation modes
Percentage 29
Walking 36% Microbus 18% Bus 12% Metro 11% Car 13% Taxi 4% Other Public Transportation
6%
Table 1
Indicator 2002–2003 2003–2004 Railways Passenger/km
(million) 46,185 76,090
Ton/km (million) 38,444* 4,758 Railway length (km)
9,432 9,467
Roads Passenger/km (million)
113,570 115,845
Ton/km (million) 41,450 43,110 River transport Ton/km (million) 309 2,375 Pipeline transport Million tons 6,489 6,680 Source: State Information Service (2006). Table 2
Table 1 Concentrations of air pollutants in Cairo Pollutant Concentration (µg/m3) U.S. standard (µg/m3) Sulfur dioxide (SO2) Particulates Nitrogen oxides (NOx) Carbon monoxide (CO) Lead Ozone (O3)
40-156 annual mean 349-857 annual mean 90-750 hourly mean 1,000-18,000 hourly mean 0.5-10 annual mean 100-200+ hourly maximum
80 annual mean 75 annual mean 100 annual mean 40,000 1-hour; 10,000 8-hour mean 1.5 quarterly mean 235 hourly maximum
Table 3
29
http://www.touregypt.net/cairo/cairostatistics.htm
Page 19 of20
Works Cited
Rodenbeck, Max. Cairo: the City Victorious. New York: Knopf, 1999. Print.
Dimitriou, Harry T. Urban Transport Planning: a Developmental Approach. London: Routledge,
1992. Print.
Aldridge, James. Cairo. London: Macmillan, 1970. Print.
Ac, By. "Cairo's New Megacities | Planetizen." Planetizen | Urban Planning, Design and
Development Network. Web. 09 Dec. 2010. <http://www.planetizen.com/node/45720>.
Ayoub-Geday, Paul. Egypt Almanac. Wilmington, DE: Egypto-file, 2003. Print.
Banister, David. Transport Policy and the Environment. New York: Routledge, 1998. Print.
"Cairo." Untitled Document. Web. 09 Dec. 2010. <http://www.dintrone.com/egypt/index.html>.
Cairo. Web. 09 Dec. 2010. <http://www.cairo.gov.eg/EnglishPortal/>.
"Cycle Egypt Club | Facebook." Welcome to Facebook. Web. 09 Dec. 2010.
<http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=200560479460>.
"Driving Quotes, Sayings about Automobiles, Cars, Traffic, Carpooling, Etc." The Quote
Garden - Quotes, Sayings, Quotations, Verses. Web. 09 Dec. 2010.
<http://www.quotegarden.com/driving.html>.
"Egypt Local Transport." Travel Guides - World Travel Guide. Web. 09 Dec. 2010.
<http://www.worldtravelguide.net/egypt/local-transport>.
"Egypt Population , Population of Egypt." World Map, Map of the World. Web. 09 Dec. 2010.
<http://www.mapsofworld.com/egypt/population.html>.
Francy, Claire E., Lesley Lababidi, Deborah Cowley, and Aleya Serour. Cairo: the Practical
Guide. Cairo, Egypt: American University in Cairo, 2006. Print.
Page 20 of20
Hawken, Paul. The Ecology of Commerce: a Declaration of Sustainability . New York, NY:
HarperBusiness, 1993. Print.
O’Rourke, Patrick. "Third World Driving Hints and Tips." Print.
Schiller, Preston L., Eric Christian. Bruun, and Jeffrey R. Kenworthy. An Introduction to
Sustainable Transportation: Policy, Planning and Implementation. London: Earthscan,
2010. Print.
Serageldin, Samia. The Cairo House. London: Fourth Estate, 2004. Print.
"Urban Development - Tackling the Shelter Challenge of Cities: Thinking It Through Together."
World Bank Group. Web. 09 Dec. 2010.
<http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/TOPICS/EXTURBANDEVELOPME
NT/0,,contentMDK:21367611~menuPK:2644039~pagePK:64020865~piPK:51164185~t
heSitePK:337178,00.html>.